{"document":{"slug":"answer-el27-11-exelon-extension","title":"Exelon answers PJM’s request for more time on its capacity-auction complaint","issued":"2026-11-09","accession":"20261109-5139","docket":"EL27-11-000","group":"PJM filings","filer":"Exelon Corporation","kind":"answer","file":"sources/originals/20261109-5139_01.pdf","url":"https://elibrary.ferc.gov/eLibrary/filelist?accession_Number=20261109-5139","sha256":"2032b6a61bc5c65507757cd713fd410f76b44dabe809d2d69f2e48f7c973be29","pages":6,"tokens":1794,"emptyPages":[]},"pages":[{"page":1,"startToken":0,"endToken":268,"text":"UNITED STATES OF AMERICA \nBEFORE THE \nFEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION \nExelon Corporation, \n) \n \n \n) \n \nComplainant \n) \n \n \n) \n \nv. \n) \nDocket No. EL27-11-000 \n \n) \n \nPJM Interconnection, L.L.C., \n) \n \n \n) \n \nRespondent \n) \n \n \n) \n \n \nMOTION FOR LEAVE TO ANSWER AND ANSWER OF  \nEXELON CORPORATION    \nPursuant to Rules 2121 and 2132 of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission’s \n(“Commission”) Rules of Practice and Procedure, Exelon Corporation (“Exelon”) submits this \nmotion for leave to answer and answer (“Answer”) to PJM Interconnection, L.L.C.’s (“PJM”) \nNovember 4, 2026, Preliminary Answer Opposing Fast-Track Processing and Motion for \nExtension of Time to Answer.3   \nI. \nMOTION FOR LEAVE TO ANSWER \nWhile Rule 213(a)(3) permits answers to motions, the PJM Motion is simultaneously styled \nas a “preliminary” answer.  Though this designation clouds the procedural posture of the PJM \nMotion, out of an abundance of caution Exelon respectfully moves pursuant to Rule 212 for leave \n \n1 18 C.F.R. § 385.212. \n2 18 C.F.R. § 385.213(a)(3) (“An answer may be made to any pleading, if not prohibited under paragraph (a)(2) of \nthis section.”).  Exelon submits this answer to the Motion component of PJM’s pleading, and accordingly an answer \nis permitted under Rule 213(a)(3).  To the extent that the Commission deems a motion necessary to process Exelon’s \nresponse to the “preliminary answer” component of PJM’s submission, Exelon respectfully moves for permission to \nrespond, pursuant to Rule 212, as discussed herein. \n3 Exelon Corporation v. PJM Interconnection, L.L.C., Preliminary Answer of PJM Interconnection, L.L.C. Opposing \nFast-Track Processing and Motion for Extension of Time to Answer, Docket No. EL27-11-000 (Nov. 4, 2026) (“PJM \nMotion”)."},{"page":2,"startToken":268,"endToken":719,"text":"2 \nto answer.  While an answer to an answer or protest is not a matter of right under the Commission’s \nregulations,4 the Commission routinely permits such answers when the answer provides useful and \nrelevant information that will assist the Commission in its decision-making process,5 corrects \nfactual inaccuracies and clarifies the issues,6 provides information helpful to the disposition of an \nissue,7 or permits the issues to be narrowed.8  This Answer will assist the Commission in its \ndecision-making process, clarifies the issues, and provides information helpful to the disposition \nof an issue.  Accordingly, Exelon respectfully requests the Commission grant leave and accept this \nAnswer into the record of this proceeding. \nII. \nANSWER \nA. Exelon Supports an Extension of the Comment Period to December 7, 2026. \nThe default comment period for this complaint proceeding is twenty days under Rule \n206(f),9 or until November 23, 2026.  In justifying its extension request through December 21, \n2026, PJM states that “[t]he PJM Board is scheduled to consider these very issues at its November \n17, 2026 meeting, and the PJM Board’s determinations are expected to substantially inform PJM’s \nposition regarding the issues raised in the Complaint.”10  PJM further explains that, “following the \n \n4 18 C.F.R. § 385.213(a)(2).  \n5 See, e.g., Pioneer Transmission, LLC v. N. Ind. Pub. Serv. Co. and Midwest Indep. Transmission Sys. Operator, Inc., \n140 FERC ¶ 61,057, at P 94 (2012); Sw. Power Pool, Inc., 131 FERC ¶ 61,252, at P 19 (2010), reh’g denied, 137 \nFERC ¶ 61,075 (2011) (accepting answers that “provided information that assisted us in our decision-making \nprocess”); Duke Energy Ky., Inc., 122 FERC ¶ 61,182, at P 25 (2008) (accepting answers to a protest that “provided \ninformation that assisted us in our decision-making process”); Tallgrass Transmission, LLC, 125 FERC ¶ 61,248, at \nP 26 (2008), reh’g denied, 150 FERC ¶ 61,224 (2015); PJM Interconnection, L.L.C., 120 FERC ¶ 61,083, at P 23 \n(2007) (answer to protests permitted when it provides information to assist the Commission in its decision-making \nprocess); Entergy Servs. Inc., 126 FERC ¶ 61,227, at P 76 (2009).  \n6 See, e.g., PJM Interconnection, L.L.C., 84 FERC ¶ 61,224, at 62,078 (1998).   \n7 See, e.g., CNG Transmission Corp., 89 FERC ¶ 61,100, at 61,287, n.11 (1999).  \n8 See, e.g., New Energy Ventures, Inc. v. S. Cal. Edison Co., 82 FERC ¶ 61,335, at 62,323, n.1 (1998). \n9 18 C.F.R. § 385.206(f) (“Unless otherwise ordered by the Commission, answers, interventions, and comments to a \ncomplaint must be filed within 20 days after the complaint is filed.”). \n10 PJM Motion at 5."},{"page":3,"startToken":719,"endToken":1064,"text":"3 \nPJM Board’s deliberations, PJM anticipates providing a timeline that outlines the stakeholder \nprocess through which a comprehensive package of capacity market enhancements, along with \nany associated filing(s), will be developed and finalized in PJM’s forthcoming answer.”11  \nExelon understands and appreciates the need for the PJM Board to deliberate and consider \nhow PJM should respond to the instant complaint, and is amenable to providing PJM additional \ntime.  However, the scale of PJM’s proposed extension is excessive for the narrow scope of the \nallegations it must answer.  PJM requests 28 days in addition to the default 20 days.  While PJM’s \napproach to a future “comprehensive package of capacity market enhancements” is certainly of \ninterest, it is simply not what PJM must respond to in this docket.  The only legal question PJM is \nrequired to respond to in its answer is correspondingly the only legal question presented in the \ncomplaint: based on the evidence presented, has the three-year forward period of the Base Residual \nAuction (“BRA”)12 become unjust and unreasonable under the Federal Power Act (“FPA”) and, if \nso, whether a “prompt” auction schedule is a just and reasonable replacement rate.  As the \nestablished market administrator for decades, and during a period of time in which it has for \nmonths (or years) been deeply considering the current market shortcomings and needed remedies, \nit should not take PJM 48 days to express its opinion on this narrow legal question. Nor does PJM \nneed to, in its answer, present a comprehensive road map of future stakeholder meetings and \ntheoretical proposed enhancements to the Reliability Pricing Model (“RPM”).  While Exelon has \n \n11 Id. \n12 Terms not otherwise defined herein shall have the same meaning as set forth in the PJM Open Access Transmission \nTariff (“Tariff”), the Amended and Restated Operating Agreement of PJM Interconnection, L.L.C. (“Operating \nAgreement”), and the Reliability Assurance Agreement Among Load-Serving Entities in the PJM Region (“RAA”).  \nThe Tariff, Operating Agreement, and RAA are currently located under PJM’s “Intra-PJM Tariffs” eTariff title, \navailable here: https://etariff.ferc.gov/TariffBrowser.aspx?tid=1731."},{"page":4,"startToken":1064,"endToken":1414,"text":"4 \nalready acknowledged such reforms will be necessary to “heal all that ails RPM”13 in the coming \nyears, these future reforms are not within the scope of this narrow complaint proceeding, and PJM \nis not required to address them now. \nFurthermore, the PJM Motion provides no explanation as to why the PJM Board could not \nconvene sooner to consider the limited issue raised in the complaint and provide the direction \nnecessary for PJM to submit a timely answer within the comment period prescribed by the \nCommission’s regulations.  Nonetheless, Exelon supports an extension of the comment period \nuntil December 7, 2026, which will provide PJM with a total of 34 days after Exelon filed the \ncomplaint, and nearly three weeks after the PJM Board’s scheduled deliberations conclude on \nNovember 17, 2026.  Exelon submits that this date strikes a reasonable balance between PJM’s \nrequest for additional time and the exigency of Commission action sufficiently in advance of the \nMay 2027 BRA, as discussed below in Section II.B. \nB. Exelon Urges the Commission to Act Sufficiently in Advance of the May 2027 \nBRA. \nExelon takes no position in this Answer regarding PJM’s analysis as to when legal \nconsequence attaches to a Commission-jurisdictional auction process, and in many ways this is \nbeside the point.  Rule 206(h) does not specify a fixed temporal deadline for a Commission \ndecision on the merits of a complaint requesting fast-track processing, and provides the \nCommission with broad discretion in how to act.14  Whatever the action date the Commission \nultimately selects, Exelon respectfully requests the Commission issue its order sufficiently in \n \n13 Exelon Corp. v. PJM Interconnection, L.L.C., Complaint Requesting Fast-Track Processing of Exelon Corporation \nat 6, Docket No. EL27-11-000 (Nov. 3, 2026). \n14 18 C.F.R. § 385.206(h)(1) (“The Commission may resolve complaints using Fast Track procedures if the complaint \nrequires expeditious resolution.  Fast Track procedures may include expedited action on the pleadings by the \nCommission, expedited hearing before an ALJ, or expedited action on requests for stay, extension of time, or other \nrelief by the Commission or an ALJ.”)."},{"page":5,"startToken":1414,"endToken":1723,"text":"5 \nadvance of the May 2027 BRA.  The primary issue presented in this proceeding—the lawfulness \nof the three-year forward period of the BRA—is of critical importance to Market Participants \nacross the PJM Region.  Irrespective of when the consequence of Commission inaction will attach \nlegally, it will certainly attach practically, as parties try to position themselves sufficiently in \nadvance of the uncapped surge in capacity prices coming this May.  Moreover, establishment of a \nrefund effective date is not a substitute for timely Commission action: the relief Exelon seeks is \nprospective, and it can be meaningfully provided only before the auction process moves forward.15  \nAccordingly, Exelon urges the Commission to act expeditiously in this proceeding. \nIII. \nCONCLUSION \nFor these reasons, Exelon requests the Commission establish an extended comment date of \nDecember 7, 2026, and consider expeditiously the instant complaint so the Commission can act \nsufficiently in advance of the May 2027 BRA. \n \n \n \n \n \n \n \nRespectfully submitted, \n \n/s/ Jordan Kwok \n/s/ Thomas S. DeVita \nJordan Kwok \nThomas S. DeVita \nDirector, Federal Regulatory Affairs \nKimberly B. Frank \nAlejandro Bautista \nK&L Gates LLP \nAssistant General Counsel \n1601 K Street, NW \nExelon Corporation  \nWashington, DC  20006 \n(667) 313-0421 \n(919) 831-7012 \njordan.kwok@exeloncorp.com \nthomas.devita@klgates.com \nalejandro.bautista@exeloncorp.com \nkimberly.frank@klgates.com \n \n \n \nCounsel for Exelon Corporation  \nNovember 9, 2026 \n \n15 PJM suggests that establishing a refund effective date preserves any remedy, so expedited action is unnecessary.  \nPJM Motion at 3, 8–10.  As a practical matter, it does not.  PJM acknowledges that the Commission has historically \nbeen reluctant to order refunds related to final market results, and that PJM has opposed such requests.  Id. at 9.  It \nwould presumably do so again.  Any after-the-fact remedy would require unwinding or re-pricing auction results that \nMarket Participants have already relied on, which is the outcome PJM itself says it has resisted."},{"page":6,"startToken":1723,"endToken":1794,"text":"6 \nCERTIFICATE OF SERVICE \nI hereby certify that I have this day served the foregoing document upon each person \ndesignated on the official service list compiled by the Secretary in this proceeding.  \nDated at Washington, D.C., this 9th day of November 2026. \n \n/s/ Thomas S. DeVita \nThomas S. DeVita \nK&L Gates LLP \n1601 K Street, NW \nWashington, DC  20006 \n(919) 831-7012 \nthomas.devita@klgates.com  \n \nCounsel for Exelon Corporation"}],"sections":[{"p":1,"at":0,"title":"Opening text","method":"opening text","endPage":1,"endAt":685,"startToken":0,"endToken":89},{"p":1,"at":685,"title":"I. MOTION FOR LEAVE TO ANSWER","method":"PDF bookmark","endPage":2,"endAt":739,"startToken":89,"endToken":381},{"p":2,"at":739,"title":"II. ANSWER","method":"PDF bookmark","endPage":2,"endAt":752,"startToken":381,"endToken":383},{"p":2,"at":752,"title":"A. Exelon Supports an Extension of the Comment Period to December 7, 2026.","method":"printed heading","endPage":5,"endAt":769,"startToken":383,"endToken":1530},{"p":5,"at":769,"title":"III. Conclusion","method":"PDF bookmark","endPage":5,"endAt":775,"startToken":1530,"endToken":1531},{"p":5,"at":775,"title":"CONCLUSION","method":"printed heading","endPage":6,"endAt":3,"startToken":1531,"endToken":1724},{"p":6,"at":3,"title":"CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE","method":"printed heading","endPage":6,"endAt":435,"startToken":1724,"endToken":1794}]}
