{"meta":{"pdf_sha256":"1970ca7da783cdfa7451a5f83e8a89ec2209aafa753d5bfa074a9ea85bddb3c4","short_title":"Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026","draft_id":"KAT26642","congress":"119th Congress, 2d Session","chamber":"Senate","sponsors":["Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.)","Mike Lee (R-Utah)","Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.)","Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.)"],"released":"2026-09-30","pages":417,"source_pdf":"https://www.epw.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/5/c/5c5f5935-b224-48e7-abea-e60c30e7a4cf/7935BF3C85967B6F56F6F4858FD3221B7E0AEB02D04BE391CAFBD1B884CE3DC5.bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act-text.pdf","mirror_pdfs":["https://www.energy.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/KAT26642FINAL.pdf","https://www.energy.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/Bipartisan-American-Affordability-and-Jobs-Act.pdf"],"total_words":58732,"total_lines":9855,"sections":71,"quotes":94,"paragraphs":2639,"pdf":"bill.pdf","prior_bills":[{"label":"SPEED Act (H.R. 4776), engrossed in House","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm"},{"label":"Energy Permitting Reform Act of 2024 (S. 4753), reported in Senate","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm"}],"site_url":"https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/","repo_url":"https://github.com/pranava0x0/permittingreform","as_of":"2026-11-18"},"topics":{"nepa":"NEPA","ceq":"CEQ","categorical-exclusions":"Exclusions","courts":"Court challenges","permit-certainty":"Issued permits","clean-water-act":"Clean Water Act","esa":"Endangered Species Act","historic-preservation":"Historic preservation","transmission":"Transmission","data-centers":"Data centers","wind-solar":"Wind and solar","offshore":"Offshore","fossil":"Oil, gas and pipelines","mining":"Mining","geothermal":"Geothermal","hydropower":"Hydropower","tribal":"Tribal","congress":"Congress","white-house":"White House"},"sections":[{"n":"1101","h":"Purposes; procedure; savings provision","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle A","suh":"Declaration of Environmental Policy","p1":4,"l1":8,"p2":5,"words":206,"imp":2,"topics":["nepa"],"plain":"Rewrites NEPA's opening section. Adds a statement that NEPA prescribes a procedure for considering and informing the public about the reasonably foreseeable environmental effects of major federal actions. Under that statement, the procedure produces an informational document. Also adds a savings clause that NEPA mandates no particular outcome.","ps":[[{"t":"Rewrites NEPA's opening section.","c":[4,9,4,10]},{"t":"Adds a statement that NEPA prescribes a procedure for considering and informing the public about the reasonably foreseeable environmental effects of major federal actions.","c":[5,11,5,13]},{"t":"Under that statement, the procedure produces an informational document.","c":[5,14,5,16]},{"t":"Also adds a savings clause that NEPA mandates no particular outcome.","c":[5,17,5,19]}]],"points":[{"t":"Codifies NEPA as a procedural statute whose product is an informational document","c":[5,14,5,16]},{"t":"New savings provision: nothing in NEPA mandates a particular outcome","c":[5,17,5,19]}],"quotes":[{"t":"Nothing in this Act mandates a particular outcome as a result of the use of the procedure described in subsection (b).","why":"States in the statute that NEPA is procedural, as the Supreme Court held in Seven County.","c":[5,17,5,19]}],"vs":{"current":"Current NEPA section 2 states purposes only; the procedure and savings language is new.","speed":"The SPEED Act (sec. 2(a)) added a subsection to NEPA section 2 calling the law 'a purely procedural statute' that 'does not mandate particular results'. The Senate text says the same thing in different words.","epra":"EPRA 2024 did not amend NEPA's purposes section."}},{"n":"1102","h":"Definitions","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle A","suh":"Declaration of Environmental Policy","p1":5,"l1":20,"p2":25,"words":2673,"imp":3,"topics":["nepa"],"plain":"Moves NEPA's definitions from section 111 to a new section 3 and expands them. New terms include agency chief environmental review and permitting officers, eNEPA technologies, key permitting agencies, a 20-page record of stakeholder engagement, record of decision, and statement of purpose and need.\n\nThe bill lists 14 kinds of action that are not major federal actions and so fall outside NEPA. A project whose only federal involvement is a loan or loan guarantee is out. So are routine administrative actions under $10 million, and repair or replacement of lifeline infrastructure that adds no more than 20 percent capacity.\n\nThe list also excludes geothermal observation test projects. Transmission upgrades under new Federal Power Act section 216A(b) and covered Natural Gas Act pipeline work are excluded too. Actions another agency already evaluated are excluded, as are Army Corps continuing-authority or environmental-infrastructure projects with a federal share of $50 million or less.","ps":[[{"t":"Moves NEPA's definitions from section 111 to a new section 3 and expands them.","c":[5,22,5,24]},{"t":"New terms include agency chief environmental review and permitting officers, eNEPA technologies, key permitting agencies, a 20-page record of stakeholder engagement, record of decision, and statement of purpose and need.","c":[6,1,6,3]}],[{"t":"The bill lists 14 kinds of action that are not major federal actions and so fall outside NEPA.","c":[16,13,16,14]},{"t":"A project whose only federal involvement is a loan or loan guarantee is out.","c":[17,1,17,3]},{"t":"So are routine administrative actions under $10 million, and repair or replacement of lifeline infrastructure that adds no more than 20 percent capacity.","c":[18,18,18,20]}],[{"t":"The list also excludes geothermal observation test projects.","c":[19,20,19,22]},{"t":"Transmission upgrades under new Federal Power Act section 216A(b) and covered Natural Gas Act pipeline work are excluded too.","c":[20,1,20,6]},{"t":"Actions another agency already evaluated are excluded, as are Army Corps continuing-authority or environmental-infrastructure projects with a federal share of $50 million or less.","c":[20,10,20,15]}]],"points":[{"t":"Loans and loan guarantees alone no longer make a project a major federal action","c":[17,1,17,3]},{"t":"Lifeline infrastructure repair and replacement excluded if capacity grows by 20 percent or less and no new through lanes","c":[19,8,19,10]},{"t":"Corps continuing-authority and environmental infrastructure projects excluded up to a $50 million federal share","c":[21,1,21,3]},{"t":"New 'key permitting agency' list: USDA, Commerce, Interior, Energy, Transportation, Defense, EPA, FERC, NRC, DHS, HUD, the Corps, ACHP","c":[15,7,15,9]},{"t":"Defines a 20-page record of stakeholder engagement documenting pre-application outreach","c":[21,23,21,25]}],"quotes":[{"t":"for which the only Federal involvement is a loan guarantee or loan;","why":"A loan or loan guarantee alone no longer brings a project under NEPA.","c":[17,1,17,3]},{"t":"any proposed agency action associated with a project to repair, reconstruct, restore, retrofit, or replace lifeline infrastructure","why":"Repair and replacement of existing roads, bridges, pipes and lines are excluded.","c":[18,22,18,25]}],"vs":{"current":"NEPA section 111 (added by the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023) lists seven exclusions: non-federal actions with no or minimal federal funding or involvement, general revenue sharing, loans and loan guarantees where the agency lacks sufficient control over their use, SBA loan guarantees, enforcement actions, extraterritorial actions, and non-discretionary actions.\n\nThe bill makes a loan or loan guarantee an exclusion on its own terms when it is the only federal involvement. It covers grants and cost-share awards where the agency lacks predominant control. It adds seven exclusions: routine administrative actions up to $10 million, lifeline infrastructure repair, geothermal test projects, in-corridor transmission work, in-corridor gas pipeline work, actions another agency already reviewed, and Corps projects with a federal share up to $50 million.","speed":"The SPEED Act (sec. 2(f)) added grants and cost-share awards to the financial-assistance exclusion, required 'complete' agency control before funding counts, excluded Farm Service Agency loans and actions already reviewed by another agency, and said federal funding alone cannot make an action major. It also defined 'reasonably foreseeable' effects as those with a close causal relationship to the project. The Senate bill has no such definition in NEPA and no limit on the scope of effects an agency may study; its list of excluded actions is longer.","epra":"EPRA 2024 did not amend NEPA definitions."},"takes":4},{"n":"1103","h":"Implementing procedures","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle A","suh":"Declaration of Environmental Policy","p1":25,"l1":8,"p2":26,"words":174,"imp":1,"topics":["nepa","ceq"],"plain":"Requires every federal agency to update its NEPA regulations, procedures and policies within 180 days of enactment, directs the CEQ Chairman to standardize agency procedures, and lets the Chairman give technical assistance.","ps":[[{"t":"Requires every federal agency to update its NEPA regulations, procedures and policies within 180 days of enactment, directs the CEQ Chairman to standardize agency procedures, and lets the Chairman give technical assistance.","c":[25,19,25,22]}]],"points":[{"t":"180-day deadline for agencies to conform their NEPA procedures","c":[25,17,25,19]},{"t":"CEQ Chairman charged with standardizing procedures across agencies","c":[26,2,26,3]}],"quotes":[{"t":"Not later than 180 days after the date of enactment of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026, each agency of the Federal Government shall make any changes to the existing regulations, procedures, or policies of the agency that are necessary","why":"Agencies get 180 days to conform their procedures.","c":[25,17,25,22]}],"vs":{"current":"NEPA section 103 currently requires agencies to review their authorities for conformity with NEPA; the 180-day implementation mandate and the standardization role are new.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"1104","h":"Cooperation of agencies; reports; availability of information; recommendations; international and national coordination of efforts","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle A","suh":"Declaration of Environmental Policy","p1":26,"l1":9,"p2":27,"words":197,"imp":1,"topics":["nepa"],"plain":"Conforming edits to NEPA section 102(2): agencies must develop methods consistent with data and technology standards for eNEPA technologies, and 'responsible official' becomes 'lead agency'.","ps":[[{"t":"Conforming edits to NEPA section 102(2): agencies must develop methods consistent with data and technology standards for eNEPA technologies, and 'responsible official' becomes 'lead agency'.","c":[27,1,27,4]}]],"points":[{"t":"Ties agency NEPA methods to eNEPA technology standards","c":[27,1,27,4]}],"quotes":[{"t":"are consistent with the requirements for minimum functional requirements and data and technology standards for agency implementation of eNEPA technologies","why":"Agency NEPA methods must meet the new data and technology standards.","c":[27,1,27,4]}],"vs":{"current":"Technical; adds the eNEPA technology reference.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"1105","h":"Procedure for determination of level of review","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle A","suh":"Declaration of Environmental Policy","p1":28,"l1":1,"p2":31,"words":470,"imp":3,"topics":["nepa","categorical-exclusions"],"plain":"Expands when an agency can skip an environmental document. An agency may apply one or a combination of categorical exclusions, but may not stack the same size-based exclusion repeatedly. A categorical exclusion Congress created is also available to the agency. The agency may treat a state or tribal environmental review, or compliance with another federal law, as serving NEPA's function. A project sponsor can ask the lead agency to stop an environmental assessment and go straight to an environmental impact statement. If the lead agency decides no environmental document is needed, no other agency may prepare one.","ps":[[{"t":"Expands when an agency can skip an environmental document.","c":[29,5,29,7]},{"t":"An agency may apply one or a combination of categorical exclusions, but may not stack the same size-based exclusion repeatedly.","c":[28,8,28,14]},{"t":"A categorical exclusion Congress created is also available to the agency.","c":[28,14,28,17]},{"t":"The agency may treat a state or tribal environmental review, or compliance with another federal law, as serving NEPA's function.","c":[28,24,29,3]},{"t":"A project sponsor can ask the lead agency to stop an environmental assessment and go straight to an environmental impact statement.","c":[30,22,31,1]},{"t":"If the lead agency decides no environmental document is needed, no other agency may prepare one.","c":[31,8,31,9]}]],"points":[{"t":"Combination of multiple categorical exclusions allowed","c":[28,8,28,9]},{"t":"State or tribal review that serves a similar function can substitute for federal review","c":[29,1,29,3]},{"t":"Sponsor can demand an EIS instead of an EA","c":[30,22,31,1]},{"t":"Lead agency threshold determination binds all other agencies","c":[31,8,31,9]}],"quotes":[{"t":"If a lead agency determines that an environmental document is not required to be prepared with respect to a proposed agency action under subsection (a), no agency shall prepare an environmental document with respect to the proposed agency action.","why":"The lead agency's decision that no document is needed binds every other agency.","c":[31,5,31,9]},{"t":"the lead agency determines that the review serves a similar function as Federal agency compliance with this Act","why":"A state or tribal review can take the place of a federal one.","c":[29,1,29,3]}],"vs":{"current":"NEPA section 106 (FRA 2023) already lets agencies apply their own or another agency's categorical exclusions; combining exclusions, statutory exclusions, state or tribal substitution and the binding threshold determination are new.","speed":"The SPEED Act (sec. 2(b)) added the same two grounds for skipping a document (another statute or a state or tribal review that serves NEPA's function) and the same rule that a lead agency's threshold call binds other agencies. It also limited agencies to effects proximately caused by the project, which the Senate bill does not. Combining exclusions and the sponsor's right to request an EIS are Senate additions.","epra":"EPRA 2024 did not amend NEPA section 106."},"takes":2},{"n":"1106","h":"Timely and unified Federal reviews","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle A","suh":"Declaration of Environmental Policy","p1":31,"l1":10,"p2":61,"words":4207,"imp":3,"topics":["nepa","ceq","courts"],"plain":"Rewrites NEPA section 107, the core of the review process. Environmental assessments are due in 1 year and environmental impact statements in 2 years, measured from the earlier of the agency's determination or its notice that the application is complete. A record of decision follows a final EIS within 45 days. Agencies in the review must decide all authorizations within 90 days, and agencies outside it within 120 days.\n\nLead agency designation gets a clock, with the CEQ Chairman resolving disputes within 21 days by a final, unreviewable decision. The Chairman can also order a resolution of interagency disputes, and that order counts as full compliance with any interagency consultation obligation under federal law.\n\nThe lead agency must drop any alternative that does not meet the purpose and need or the goals of a non-federal sponsor. Agencies need not consider science published after the notice of intent. Public scoping comment periods run 45 to 60 days, or 75 with the sponsor's consent.\n\nIf an agency defies a Chairman's dispute order and a deadline is missed, then after 30 days its permitting officers and senior executives must spend at least half their workweek on the overdue review. Once any deadline is 60 days overdue, the agency head may not travel more than 25 miles from the duty station until the document or permit issues. The Secretary of Defense is exempt. Project sponsors can sue over missed deadlines. The court must rule within 120 days and can order a decision within 60 days.","ps":[[{"t":"Rewrites NEPA section 107, the core of the review process.","c":[31,11,31,12]},{"t":"Environmental assessments are due in 1 year and environmental impact statements in 2 years, measured from the earlier of the agency's determination or its notice that the application is complete.","c":[46,17,46,18]},{"t":"A record of decision follows a final EIS within 45 days.","c":[49,8,49,13]},{"t":"Agencies in the review must decide all authorizations within 90 days, and agencies outside it within 120 days.","c":[49,21,49,24]}],[{"t":"Lead agency designation gets a clock, with the CEQ Chairman resolving disputes within 21 days by a final, unreviewable decision.","c":[35,19,35,21]},{"t":"The Chairman can also order a resolution of interagency disputes, and that order counts as full compliance with any interagency consultation obligation under federal law.","c":[52,14,52,19]}],[{"t":"The lead agency must drop any alternative that does not meet the purpose and need or the goals of a non-federal sponsor.","c":[38,6,38,8]},{"t":"Agencies need not consider science published after the notice of intent.","c":[43,12,43,16]},{"t":"Public scoping comment periods run 45 to 60 days, or 75 with the sponsor's consent.","c":[44,25,45,1]}],[{"t":"If an agency defies a Chairman's dispute order and a deadline is missed, then after 30 days its permitting officers and senior executives must spend at least half their workweek on the overdue review.","c":[54,5,54,8]},{"t":"Once any deadline is 60 days overdue, the agency head may not travel more than 25 miles from the duty station until the document or permit issues.","c":[54,17,54,20]},{"t":"The Secretary of Defense is exempt.","c":[55,3,55,4]},{"t":"Project sponsors can sue over missed deadlines.","c":[55,18,55,22]},{"t":"The court must rule within 120 days and can order a decision within 60 days.","c":[58,3,58,6]}]],"points":[{"t":"EIS in 2 years, EA in 1 year, with the clock starting at the earlier of the review determination or a complete application","c":[46,17,46,18]},{"t":"ROD within 45 days of the final EIS; all federal permits within 90 days (120 for non-participating agencies)","c":[49,8,49,11]},{"t":"No duty to consider scientific research published after the notice of intent","c":[43,12,43,16]},{"t":"CEQ Chairman's dispute orders are final, unreviewable, and satisfy any interagency consultation requirement","c":[52,11,52,13]},{"t":"Agency head confined to 25 miles of the duty station once a deadline is 60 days overdue; senior staff spend half the week on the review when the agency has defied a CEQ dispute order","c":[53,13,53,17]},{"t":"Sponsors get a cause of action with a 120-day court decision clock","c":[58,3,58,6]},{"t":"Alternatives that do not meet the non-federal sponsor's goals are eliminated","c":[38,11,38,12]}],"quotes":[{"t":"No Federal agency shall be required to consider any scientific or technical research that becomes publicly available after the date of publication of a notice of intent or decision to prepare an environmental document for a proposed agency action.","why":"Research published after the notice of intent need not be considered.","c":[43,12,43,17]},{"t":"the head of the relevant key permitting agency shall not travel more than 25 miles from their official duty station for the purposes of official business until the key permitting agency has published or made public the applicable environmental document and issued all outstanding authorizations","why":"The agency head's travel is restricted once a deadline is 60 days overdue.","c":[54,17,54,23]},{"t":"shall, for purposes of judicial review of the ultimate agency action and all other Federal law, constitute full compliance with and satisfaction of any requirement for interagency consultation, coordination, concurrence, authorization, or other procedural obligation under Federal law that is the subject of the dispute or delay.","why":"A CEQ dispute order satisfies consultation duties under other statutes.","c":[52,14,52,23]},{"t":"eliminate from consideration any alternative (except for a no-action alternative) that does not— “(I) fulfill the purpose and need of the proposed agency action; and “(II) meet the goals of an applicable non-Federal project sponsor.","why":"Alternatives that miss the sponsor's goals are dropped from the analysis.","c":[38,6,38,12]},{"t":"the lead agency shall publish an environmental impact statement, if applicable, not later than the date that is 2 years","why":"The two-year deadline for an environmental impact statement.","c":[48,17,48,20]}],"vs":{"current":"The Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2023 set the 2-year EIS and 1-year EA deadlines, page limits of 150 pages for an EIS and 75 for an EA (both kept), and a sponsor's right to petition a court, which can order the agency to act within 90 days.\n\nNew here: the clock no longer starts at the notice of intent. A record of decision is due 45 days after the EIS and all permits within 90 or 120 days. Agencies need not consider science published after the notice of intent. The CEQ Chairman settles lead-agency and interagency disputes with final, unreviewable orders, and lead-agency disputes take 21 days, down from 40. Alternatives that miss the sponsor's goals are dropped. Missed deadlines can trigger the staff-time and travel sanctions, and courts must rule on deadline suits within 120 days.","speed":"The SPEED Act (sec. 2(c)) kept the 2023 deadlines and added a science cutoff at the earlier of the application or the notice of intent, a requirement that the purpose and need 'meet the goals of the applicant', 21-day clocks for cooperating agencies, and a final agency action within 30 days of the finished document. It had no CEQ dispute orders and no sanctions on agency staff or agency heads.","epra":"EPRA 2024 did not rewrite NEPA section 107; its deadlines were project-specific (energy leasing, rights-of-way)."},"takes":7},{"n":"1107","h":"Programmatic environmental document","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle A","suh":"Declaration of Environmental Policy","p1":61,"l1":22,"p2":62,"words":30,"imp":1,"topics":["nepa"],"plain":"Doubles the shelf life of programmatic environmental documents from 5 years to 10 years before an agency must reevaluate them.","ps":[[{"t":"Doubles the shelf life of programmatic environmental documents from 5 years to 10 years before an agency must reevaluate them.","c":[62,1,62,2]}]],"points":[{"t":"Programmatic documents can be relied on for 10 years, up from 5","c":[62,1,62,2]}],"quotes":[{"t":"by striking “5 years” and inserting “10 years”.","why":"The whole section.","c":[62,1,62,2]}],"vs":{"current":"FRA 2023 set 5 years.","speed":"The SPEED Act (sec. 2(d)) made the same 5-to-10-year change and also let agencies rely on an earlier review for a substantially similar action; the Senate bill handles that through its exclusion for actions another agency already evaluated.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":1},{"n":"1108","h":"Use of categorical exclusions by other agencies","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle A","suh":"Declaration of Environmental Policy","p1":62,"l1":3,"p2":64,"words":342,"imp":1,"topics":["nepa","categorical-exclusions","ceq"],"plain":"Requires every agency to report all its categorical exclusions to CEQ within 30 days and each new one within 7 days; CEQ keeps a public register on its website. An agency may adopt another agency's exclusion after consulting it and documenting the adoption.","ps":[[{"t":"Requires every agency to report all its categorical exclusions to CEQ within 30 days and each new one within 7 days;","c":[62,12,62,15]},{"t":"CEQ keeps a public register on its website.","c":[63,6,63,8]},{"t":"An agency may adopt another agency's exclusion after consulting it and documenting the adoption.","c":[64,9,64,10]}]],"points":[{"t":"Government-wide public register of categorical exclusions at CEQ","c":[63,6,63,8]},{"t":"Agencies may adopt other agencies' listed exclusions","c":[63,16,63,19]}],"quotes":[{"t":"The Council shall maintain, on the website of the Council, an accurate and publicly available record of each categorical exclusion","why":"CEQ must keep a public list of every categorical exclusion.","c":[63,6,63,9]}],"vs":{"current":"FRA 2023 section 109 already allows adoption of another agency's exclusion after consultation and public notice; the CEQ register and notification deadlines are new.","speed":"The SPEED Act (sec. 2(e)) changed one phrase so agencies could adopt exclusions enacted by Congress. The CEQ register and the 30-day and 7-day reporting duties are Senate additions.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"1109","h":"Applications for authorizations","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle A","suh":"Declaration of Environmental Policy","p1":64,"l1":11,"p2":67,"words":407,"imp":2,"topics":["nepa"],"plain":"Sets an application clock: within 60 days, an agency must say whether an application is complete. Within another 60 days, the agency must tell the sponsor whether the action is excluded from NEPA. The agency must also say whether the action needs an environmental assessment or gets a notice of intent for an EIS. Applicants must submit a list of all known permits, a record of stakeholder engagement, and a statement of purpose and need.","ps":[[{"t":"Sets an application clock: within 60 days, an agency must say whether an application is complete.","c":[64,22,64,24]},{"t":"Within another 60 days, the agency must tell the sponsor whether the action is excluded from NEPA.","c":[65,14,65,20]},{"t":"The agency must also say whether the action needs an environmental assessment or gets a notice of intent for an EIS.","c":[66,3,66,8]},{"t":"Applicants must submit a list of all known permits, a record of stakeholder engagement, and a statement of purpose and need.","c":[66,23,66,25]}]],"points":[{"t":"60 days to declare an application complete; 60 more to pick the level of review","c":[65,14,65,16]},{"t":"Applicants file a record of stakeholder engagement with the application","c":[67,1,67,2]}],"quotes":[{"t":"not later than 60 days after the date on which the project sponsor submits the application, the Federal agency shall— “(A) document receipt of the application; and “(B)(i) notify the project sponsor that the application is complete","why":"The 60-day completeness check.","c":[64,22,65,4]}],"vs":{"current":"New. The current section 110 ordered CEQ to study a permitting portal; that study is replaced by the eNEPA mandate in section 1121.","speed":"The SPEED Act (sec. 2(c)(4)) had the same 60-day completeness check and 60-day level-of-review decision. The required list of permits, record of stakeholder engagement and purpose-and-need description are Senate additions.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":1},{"n":"1110","h":"Judicial review","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle A","suh":"Declaration of Environmental Policy","p1":67,"l1":8,"p2":74,"words":1132,"imp":3,"topics":["nepa","courts","tribal"],"plain":"Adds a judicial review section to NEPA. Suits challenging an authorization on NEPA grounds must be filed within 150 days. The party must allege an actual or imminent injury amounting to direct harm. Where a comment period was offered, the party must also have filed a sufficiently detailed comment. The federal court of appeals for the circuit where the project sits gets original and exclusive jurisdiction, with random judge assignment.\n\nIf a court finds a NEPA violation, the only remedy is remand without vacatur or injunction, with a fix deadline of no more than 180 days. The permit stays in effect and the project can proceed during the remand. A preliminary injunction is available only for a likely violation of a law other than NEPA or the National Historic Preservation Act.\n\nCourts must give substantial deference to agencies on the scope and content of environmental documents. No NEPA suit may be brought over an action on tribal trust lands unless the tribe itself sues or effects reach beyond trust lands. No suit may rest on an omission from the list described in section 3(22)(B) of NEPA as amended.","ps":[[{"t":"Adds a judicial review section to NEPA.","c":[67,13,67,13]},{"t":"Suits challenging an authorization on NEPA grounds must be filed within 150 days.","c":[68,1,68,2]},{"t":"The party must allege an actual or imminent injury amounting to direct harm.","c":[68,18,68,20]},{"t":"Where a comment period was offered, the party must also have filed a sufficiently detailed comment.","c":[68,11,68,14]},{"t":"The federal court of appeals for the circuit where the project sits gets original and exclusive jurisdiction, with random judge assignment.","c":[68,23,69,2]}],[{"t":"If a court finds a NEPA violation, the only remedy is remand without vacatur or injunction, with a fix deadline of no more than 180 days.","c":[69,24,70,3]},{"t":"The permit stays in effect and the project can proceed during the remand.","c":[71,15,71,18]},{"t":"A preliminary injunction is available only for a likely violation of a law other than NEPA or the National Historic Preservation Act.","c":[70,17,70,23]}],[{"t":"Courts must give substantial deference to agencies on the scope and content of environmental documents.","c":[73,25,74,2]},{"t":"No NEPA suit may be brought over an action on tribal trust lands unless the tribe itself sues or effects reach beyond trust lands.","c":[73,8,73,11]},{"t":"No suit may rest on an omission from the list described in section 3(22)(B) of NEPA as amended.","c":[74,7,74,8]}]],"points":[{"t":"150-day statute of limitations","c":[68,1,68,2]},{"t":"Only a party with a direct-harm injury can sue, and where a comment period was offered it must have commented","c":[68,10,68,12]},{"t":"Court of appeals has original and exclusive jurisdiction","c":[69,1,69,2]},{"t":"Remand without vacatur is the sole NEPA remedy; the project continues during the remand","c":[69,24,70,1]},{"t":"No preliminary injunction for NEPA or NHPA violations alone","c":[70,17,70,22]},{"t":"Substantial deference to agencies on the scope and contents of the document","c":[73,25,74,2]}],"quotes":[{"t":"the only remedy the court may order to redress that violation is to remand, without vacatur or issuance of an injunction, the applicable authorization to the agency","why":"Remand is the only remedy; a court cannot vacate or enjoin.","c":[69,24,70,3]},{"t":"a claim shall be barred unless the claim— “(1) is filed not later than 150 days","why":"The 150-day filing deadline.","c":[67,24,68,1]},{"t":"In reviewing a claim of whether an authorization complies with the requirements of this Act, a court shall afford substantial deference to the agency relating to the scope and contents of an environmental document.","why":"Courts must defer to the agency on scope and contents.","c":[73,23,74,2]},{"t":"The activity that is the subject of an authorization remanded under paragraph (5)(A) may, notwithstanding that remand, be carried out","why":"The project can proceed during the remand.","c":[71,20,71,23]}],"vs":{"current":"NEPA has no limitations period of its own, so the general 6-year limit on suits against the United States applies, with 2 years for FAST-41 covered projects and 150 days for highway and transit projects. There is no statutory prior-comment rule, cases start in district court, and courts can vacate or enjoin an approval.","speed":"The SPEED Act (sec. 3) had the same core: 150 days, prior comment, direct harm, substantial deference, remand without vacatur or injunction, a 180-day fix deadline, and the tribal trust carve-out. Differences: the House bill barred challenges to the creation of categorical exclusions, required courts to rule within 180 days of receiving the record and appeals within another 180, and applied its remand rule to court orders entered before enactment. The Senate bill drops those three, moves cases to the courts of appeals with random assignment, lets construction continue during a remand in express terms, and allows a preliminary injunction when a different federal law is likely violated.","epra":"EPRA 2024 (sec. 101) set a 150-day limit for energy and mineral project authorizations and a 180-day remand deadline. It did not require prior comment, did not change standing, and left courts their ordinary remedies. That section survives as section 2201 of this bill."},"takes":24},{"n":"1121","h":"Council on Environmental Quality","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle B","suh":"Council on Environmental Quality","p1":74,"l1":18,"p2":96,"words":2543,"imp":2,"topics":["nepa","ceq"],"plain":"Replaces NEPA section 209 with an eNEPA technology mandate. Within 60 days, CEQ must publish data standards for permitting data. CEQ must publish guidance on minimum functional requirements (automated project screening, case management, GIS tools, AI-assisted comment analysis, administrative-record tools) within 120 days. Agencies must begin implementing within 180 days. CEQ and the key permitting agencies build an ePermit unified interagency data system and a public authorization portal hosted by GSA.\n\nA pilot is due within a year and the system by December 1, 2028, 'to the maximum extent practicable'. Congress gets access to the data, fine-tuning procedures and prompt configurations agencies create or adapt for AI tools, but not proprietary or general pre-training materials. CEQ also sets outcome-based performance measures for agencies and staff. Authorizes $5 million a year for NEPA.","ps":[[{"t":"Replaces NEPA section 209 with an eNEPA technology mandate.","c":[74,20,74,21]},{"t":"Within 60 days, CEQ must publish data standards for permitting data.","c":[76,2,76,5]},{"t":"CEQ must publish guidance on minimum functional requirements (automated project screening, case management, GIS tools, AI-assisted comment analysis, administrative-record tools) within 120 days.","c":[77,22,78,2]},{"t":"Agencies must begin implementing within 180 days.","c":[82,22,82,25]},{"t":"CEQ and the key permitting agencies build an ePermit unified interagency data system and a public authorization portal hosted by GSA.","c":[89,20,89,23]}],[{"t":"A pilot is due within a year and the system by December 1, 2028, 'to the maximum extent practicable'.","c":[92,19,92,21]},{"t":"Congress gets access to the data, fine-tuning procedures and prompt configurations agencies create or adapt for AI tools, but not proprietary or general pre-training materials.","c":[90,23,91,4]},{"t":"CEQ also sets outcome-based performance measures for agencies and staff.","c":[92,24,93,2]},{"t":"Authorizes $5 million a year for NEPA.","c":[96,2,96,3]}]],"points":[{"t":"Government-wide permitting data standards within 60 days","c":[76,2,76,5]},{"t":"Public ePermit portal hosted by GSA, targeted for December 1, 2028","c":[92,18,92,21]},{"t":"AI-assisted comment analysis and screening tools named in statute; Congress gets the prompt configurations","c":[90,22,91,1]},{"t":"Agency and personnel performance measures tied to the Permitting Improvement Fund","c":[94,15,94,18]}],"quotes":[{"t":"Automated comment compilation and analysis tools, including services for comment categorization and response that handle the lifecycle of comment submission, analysis, categorization, and response with artificial intelligence support where appropriate.","why":"AI support for comment analysis is written into the statute.","c":[80,1,80,7]},{"t":"not later than December 1, 2028, the Chairman shall develop and implement the ePermit unified interagency data system","why":"The target date for the ePermit system.","c":[92,19,92,21]}],"vs":{"current":"The 2023 law ordered CEQ to study a permitting portal. This section orders one built.","speed":"The House passed a separate ePermit Act alongside the SPEED Act in December 2025 with similar goals; the SPEED Act itself did not include it.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"1131","h":"Definitions","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle C","suh":"Federal Permitting Improvement","p1":96,"l1":10,"p2":97,"words":186,"imp":1,"topics":["nepa","ceq"],"plain":"Definitions for the permitting tracker subtitle. A 'transparency project' is any action that needs an EIS, or an environmental assessment still unfinished 13 months past its deadline.","ps":[[{"t":"Definitions for the permitting tracker subtitle.","c":[96,11,96,11]},{"t":"A 'transparency project' is any action that needs an EIS, or an environmental assessment still unfinished 13 months past its deadline.","c":[97,11,97,14]}]],"points":[{"t":"Every EIS project becomes a tracked transparency project","c":[97,8,97,10]}],"quotes":[{"t":"a proposed agency action requiring the preparation of an environmental impact statement","why":"Every project with an impact statement goes on the tracker.","c":[97,8,97,9]}],"vs":{"current":"New.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"1132","h":"Environmental Review and Permitting Tracker","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle C","suh":"Federal Permitting Improvement","p1":97,"l1":18,"p2":101,"words":529,"imp":2,"topics":["nepa","ceq"],"plain":"Requires CEQ, with GSA, to run a public Environmental Review and Permitting Tracker listing every EIS project within 14 days of its notice of intent. Each entry lists the location, purpose and need, and sponsor and agency contacts. Quarterly schedule-compliance status, which explains every slip and who caused it, and litigation status are also posted.","ps":[[{"t":"Requires CEQ, with GSA, to run a public Environmental Review and Permitting Tracker listing every EIS project within 14 days of its notice of intent.","c":[98,9,98,12]},{"t":"Each entry lists the location, purpose and need, and sponsor and agency contacts.","c":[99,16,99,21]},{"t":"Quarterly schedule-compliance status, which explains every slip and who caused it, and litigation status are also posted.","c":[100,4,100,10]}]],"points":[{"t":"Public tracker for every EIS project","c":[98,2,98,3]},{"t":"Each schedule change must say whether the agency or the sponsor caused it","c":[100,7,100,10]}],"quotes":[{"t":"an explanation of each modification, including whether the modification is due to a delay on the part of an agency or the project sponsor","why":"The tracker must say whether the agency or the sponsor caused each delay.","c":[100,7,100,10]}],"vs":{"current":"The federal Permitting Dashboard tracks FAST-41 covered projects. This tracker covers every project with an impact statement.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"1133","h":"Permitting Improvement Fund","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"NATIONAL ENVIRONMENTAL POLICY ACT OF 1969","su":"Subtitle C","suh":"Federal Permitting Improvement","p1":101,"l1":6,"p2":102,"words":224,"imp":1,"topics":["nepa","ceq"],"plain":"Creates a Permitting Improvement Fund at Treasury that CEQ can transfer to permitting agencies for detailees, training, project managers, standardized processes, and public engagement. Authorizes $20 million a year for fiscal years 2027 through 2033.","ps":[[{"t":"Creates a Permitting Improvement Fund at Treasury that CEQ can transfer to permitting agencies for detailees, training, project managers, standardized processes, and public engagement.","c":[101,22,101,23]},{"t":"Authorizes $20 million a year for fiscal years 2027 through 2033.","c":[102,15,102,16]}]],"points":[{"t":"$20 million a year, FY2027-2033, spent at CEQ's discretion","c":[101,17,101,18]}],"quotes":[{"t":"There is authorized to be appropriated to the Fund $20,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2027 through 2033.","why":"$20 million a year for the fund.","c":[102,14,102,16]}],"vs":{"current":"New.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"1201","h":"Water quality criteria","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"CLEAN WATER ACT","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":102,"l1":18,"p2":103,"words":112,"imp":2,"topics":["clean-water-act","courts"],"plain":"Requires EPA to use notice-and-comment rulemaking when it develops Clean Water Act water quality criteria. Challenges to those criteria and to any definition of 'waters of the United States' go directly to the federal courts of appeals.","ps":[[{"t":"Requires EPA to use notice-and-comment rulemaking when it develops Clean Water Act water quality criteria.","c":[102,23,102,25]},{"t":"Challenges to those criteria and to any definition of 'waters of the United States' go directly to the federal courts of appeals.","c":[103,6,103,9]}]],"points":[{"t":"WOTUS definitions reviewed in courts of appeals, not district courts","c":[103,7,103,9]},{"t":"Water quality criteria become rulemakings","c":[102,23,102,25]}],"quotes":[{"t":"in defining the scope of the term ‘waters of the United States’ for purposes of this Act","why":"Challenges to a 'waters of the United States' definition go to the courts of appeals.","c":[103,7,103,9]}],"vs":{"current":"Criteria are now issued as guidance; WOTUS rules are challenged in district courts after National Association of Manufacturers v. Department of Defense (2018).","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"1202","h":"Clean Water Act permitting and State certification","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"CLEAN WATER ACT","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":103,"l1":10,"p2":122,"words":2661,"imp":3,"topics":["clean-water-act","fossil","transmission"],"plain":"Rewrites Clean Water Act section 401 state certification. Certification is limited to water quality requirements. A state may deny only on clear and convincing evidence that no condition could make the project comply, and may impose only conditions that are necessary, least burdensome, and consistent with the federal permit.\n\nThe process gets a prefiling meeting, a defined complete application, and a 3-day receipt acknowledgment. A 90-day completeness notice and a review period of up to 1 year follow. The period can be extended only if the applicant asks in writing and the certifying authority agrees in writing. Silence is a waiver. Denials must name the specific water quality requirement violated. On judicial review the burden of proof falls on the state by clear and convincing evidence.\n\nFor interstate gas pipelines and bulk-power transmission lines, certification covers only direct point source discharges and must be decided within 9 months.","ps":[[{"t":"Rewrites Clean Water Act section 401 state certification.","c":[103,12,103,13]},{"t":"Certification is limited to water quality requirements.","c":[104,19,104,22]},{"t":"A state may deny only on clear and convincing evidence that no condition could make the project comply, and may impose only conditions that are necessary, least burdensome, and consistent with the federal permit.","c":[105,3,105,7]}],[{"t":"The process gets a prefiling meeting, a defined complete application, and a 3-day receipt acknowledgment.","c":[111,2,111,8]},{"t":"A 90-day completeness notice and a review period of up to 1 year follow.","c":[111,11,111,15]},{"t":"The period can be extended only if the applicant asks in writing and the certifying authority agrees in writing.","c":[115,17,115,23]},{"t":"Silence is a waiver.","c":[115,10,115,11]},{"t":"Denials must name the specific water quality requirement violated.","c":[114,1,114,4]},{"t":"On judicial review the burden of proof falls on the state by clear and convincing evidence.","c":[117,5,117,7]}],[{"t":"For interstate gas pipelines and bulk-power transmission lines, certification covers only direct point source discharges and must be decided within 9 months.","c":[121,15,121,16]}]],"points":[{"t":"Certification scope narrowed to water quality requirements; clear-and-convincing standard for denials","c":[104,19,104,22]},{"t":"One-year cap, extendable only at the applicant's written request and with the certifying authority's written agreement","c":[115,19,115,23]},{"t":"Burden of proof on the state in court","c":[117,5,117,7]},{"t":"Interstate pipelines and transmission lines: point-source discharges only, 9-month clock","c":[121,15,121,16]}],"quotes":[{"t":"no certifying authority may— “(i) deny certification for any reason other than making a determination by clear and convincing evidence that no modification to or reasonable condition on the certification would make it possible to grant the certification without violating water quality requirements","why":"A state can deny only when no condition could make the project comply.","c":[104,24,105,7]},{"t":"a court shall place the burden of proof on the certifying authority to demonstrate, by clear and convincing evidence, that no reasonable modifications to or reasonable conditions on the certification would make it possible to grant the certification","why":"In court, the state carries the burden of proof.","c":[117,5,117,10]}],"vs":{"current":"Section 401 lets states certify that a discharge complies with state water quality standards and 'any other appropriate requirement of State law', with a reasonable period not to exceed 1 year; EPA's 2020 and 2023 rules fought over the scope. The bill codifies a narrow scope similar to the 2020 rule, adds the clear-and-convincing standard and the point-source-only rule for pipelines and transmission.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024; Senate Republicans had sought section 401 limits in earlier bills such as Capito's 2023 RESTART Act."},"takes":6},{"n":"1203","h":"Permit term for NPDES permits","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"CLEAN WATER ACT","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":123,"l1":1,"p2":123,"words":22,"imp":1,"topics":["clean-water-act"],"plain":"Extends the maximum term of state-issued NPDES discharge permits from 5 years to 10 years.","ps":[[{"t":"Extends the maximum term of state-issued NPDES discharge permits from 5 years to 10 years.","c":[123,3,123,4]}]],"points":[{"t":"10-year NPDES permits","c":[123,3,123,4]}],"quotes":[{"t":"by striking “five years” and inserting “10 years”.","why":"The whole section.","c":[123,3,123,4]}],"vs":{"current":"5 years.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":1},{"n":"1204","h":"Permits for dredged or fill material","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"CLEAN WATER ACT","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":123,"l1":5,"p2":128,"words":763,"imp":3,"topics":["clean-water-act","esa","fossil","transmission"],"plain":"Limits EPA's section 404(c) veto to the period between a complete application and permit issuance. Extends nationwide permits from 5 to 10 years and lets the Corps modify them mid-term. Requires the Corps to keep nationwide permits 12, 14, 43, 57 and 58 for projects filling under 2 acres. Filling under 2 acres of navigable waters counts as a minimal adverse effect. Reissuing a nationwide permit needs no Endangered Species Act consultation, only a programmatic environmental assessment under NEPA, and no National Historic Preservation Act consultation, so long as the permit does not loosen preconstruction requirements.","ps":[[{"t":"Limits EPA's section 404(c) veto to the period between a complete application and permit issuance.","c":[124,1,124,5]},{"t":"Extends nationwide permits from 5 to 10 years and lets the Corps modify them mid-term.","c":[125,2,125,6]},{"t":"Requires the Corps to keep nationwide permits 12, 14, 43, 57 and 58 for projects filling under 2 acres.","c":[126,6,126,9]},{"t":"Filling under 2 acres of navigable waters counts as a minimal adverse effect.","c":[125,19,125,22]},{"t":"Reissuing a nationwide permit needs no Endangered Species Act consultation, only a programmatic environmental assessment under NEPA, and no National Historic Preservation Act consultation, so long as the permit does not loosen preconstruction requirements.","c":[128,4,128,6]}]],"points":[{"t":"No section 404(c) veto before an application or after a permit issues","c":[124,4,124,5]},{"t":"Nationwide permits last 10 years","c":[125,2,125,3]},{"t":"Under 2 acres of fill is a minimal effect by statute","c":[125,19,125,22]},{"t":"No ESA or NHPA consultation to reissue a nationwide permit that keeps its preconstruction requirements","c":[128,7,128,10]}],"quotes":[{"t":"shall consider any effects of a discharge of dredged or fill material into less than 2 acres of navigable waters to be a minimal adverse environmental effect.","why":"Fills under 2 acres count as minimal by statute.","c":[125,19,125,22]},{"t":"no consultation with a Federal agency pursuant to section 7(a)(2) of that Act (16 U.S.C. 1536(a)(2)) is required","why":"Reissuing a nationwide permit needs no Endangered Species Act consultation.","c":[127,20,127,22]}],"vs":{"current":"EPA may veto a disposal site at any time, including after a permit issues (Mingo Logan v. EPA, D.C. Circuit, 2013). Nationwide permits run 5 years. A 2020 district court ruling held that reissuing Nationwide Permit 12 required Endangered Species Act consultation.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":6},{"n":"1205","h":"Judicial review timeline clarity","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"CLEAN WATER ACT","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":128,"l1":15,"p2":133,"words":772,"imp":2,"topics":["clean-water-act","courts"],"plain":"Adds a 150-day statute of limitations for challenges to section 404 permits, general permits, verifications and state program approvals. Where a draft was published with at least 30 days for comment, a plaintiff must have commented on the issue. Remedies are limited to remand, with vacatur or injunction available only on a finding of imminent and substantial danger to health or the environment. Remand deadlines are capped at 180 days.","ps":[[{"t":"Adds a 150-day statute of limitations for challenges to section 404 permits, general permits, verifications and state program approvals.","c":[129,10,129,12]},{"t":"Where a draft was published with at least 30 days for comment, a plaintiff must have commented on the issue.","c":[131,12,131,14]},{"t":"Remedies are limited to remand, with vacatur or injunction available only on a finding of imminent and substantial danger to health or the environment.","c":[132,9,132,14]},{"t":"Remand deadlines are capped at 180 days.","c":[133,4,133,5]}]],"points":[{"t":"150-day limit on 404 permit suits","c":[129,21,129,23]},{"t":"Permits stay in force on remand absent imminent and substantial danger","c":[132,9,132,13]}],"quotes":[{"t":"the court may not vacate, revoke, enjoin, or otherwise limit the permit unless the court finds that activities authorized under the permit would present an imminent and substantial danger to human health or the environment","why":"A permit stays in force unless the work poses imminent and substantial danger.","c":[132,9,132,14]}],"vs":{"current":"General 6-year APA limit and ordinary equitable remedies.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"EPRA 2024's 150-day rule applied to energy project authorizations generally, not 404 permits specifically."}},{"n":"1301","h":"Definitions","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE III","tih":"ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT OF 1973","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":133,"l1":11,"p2":134,"words":146,"imp":2,"topics":["esa"],"plain":"Defines 'best scientific and commercial data available' in the Endangered Species Act as all relevant, objective information at the time of the action, including models that account for error and are applied without policy presumptions.","ps":[[{"t":"Defines 'best scientific and commercial data available' in the Endangered Species Act as all relevant, objective information at the time of the action, including models that account for error and are applied without policy presumptions.","c":[133,20,133,22]}]],"points":[{"t":"Defines 'best scientific and commercial data available' in the statute","c":[133,20,133,22]}],"quotes":[{"t":"are impartially gathered and objectively applied without presumptions or policy prescriptions that bias the application.","why":"Part of the new definition of best available data.","c":[134,6,134,8]}],"vs":{"current":"The ESA uses the phrase without defining it.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":7},{"n":"1302","h":"Timeline for Section 7 consultations","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE III","tih":"ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT OF 1973","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":134,"l1":13,"p2":136,"words":327,"imp":3,"topics":["esa"],"plain":"Shortens ESA section 7 formal consultation from 90 to 60 days, and the applicant-consent extension from 150 to 100 days. If consultation stretches past 145 days without the applicant's written consent, the applicant may sue under the APA for agency action unlawfully withheld. Consultation on any project with a NEPA document must finish by the NEPA deadline, unless the Secretary grants an extension for extraordinary circumstances.","ps":[[{"t":"Shortens ESA section 7 formal consultation from 90 to 60 days, and the applicant-consent extension from 150 to 100 days.","c":[134,16,134,17]},{"t":"If consultation stretches past 145 days without the applicant's written consent, the applicant may sue under the APA for agency action unlawfully withheld.","c":[135,23,135,24]},{"t":"Consultation on any project with a NEPA document must finish by the NEPA deadline, unless the Secretary grants an extension for extraordinary circumstances.","c":[136,10,136,13]}]],"points":[{"t":"Formal consultation: 60 days, not 90","c":[134,16,134,17]},{"t":"Consultation must end when the NEPA document is due, absent an extension for extraordinary circumstances","c":[136,10,136,13]},{"t":"APA remedy after 145 days","c":[135,23,135,24]}],"quotes":[{"t":"the consultation process under subsection (a)(2) shall be completed by not later than the date on which the applicable environmental document (as so defined) for the agency action is completed","why":"Consultation must end by the NEPA deadline.","c":[136,4,136,8]}],"vs":{"current":"90 days. With an applicant involved, more than 150 days requires the applicant's consent.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":3},{"n":"1303","h":"Projects in the operational right-of-way","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE III","tih":"ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT OF 1973","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":136,"l1":17,"p2":137,"words":88,"imp":1,"topics":["esa"],"plain":"Exempts highway and transit projects in an existing operational right-of-way that are categorically excluded from NEPA under MAP-21 section 1316 from ESA section 7 consultation and conferencing.","ps":[[{"t":"Exempts highway and transit projects in an existing operational right-of-way that are categorically excluded from NEPA under MAP-21 section 1316 from ESA section 7 consultation and conferencing.","c":[137,2,137,3]}]],"points":[{"t":"No ESA consultation for in-right-of-way transportation projects","c":[137,2,137,3]}],"quotes":[{"t":"shall be exempt from paragraphs (2), (3), and (4) of subsection (a)","why":"The exemption for transportation projects inside an existing right-of-way.","c":[137,2,137,3]}],"vs":{"current":"Such projects still need section 7 consultation today.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"1304","h":"State assumption of consultation responsibilities","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE III","tih":"ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT OF 1973","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":137,"l1":4,"p2":154,"words":2498,"imp":3,"topics":["esa"],"plain":"Creates ESA section 7A letting the Interior Secretary assign section 7 consultation duties to a state, by written agreement, for projects entirely inside the state. Interior must propose a rule within 270 days. States must show legal, financial and staffing capacity, waive sovereign immunity, accept federal court jurisdiction, keep public-records laws comparable to FOIA, and meet the same deadlines as the Secretary. Interior audits annually for 4 years, can terminate after a 120-day cure period, and applicants may still choose federal consultation. Interior's failure to act on an application within 180 days counts as a failure to act under the NEPA sanctions section.","ps":[[{"t":"Creates ESA section 7A letting the Interior Secretary assign section 7 consultation duties to a state, by written agreement, for projects entirely inside the state.","c":[138,7,138,10]},{"t":"Interior must propose a rule within 270 days.","c":[139,1,139,4]},{"t":"States must show legal, financial and staffing capacity, waive sovereign immunity, accept federal court jurisdiction, keep public-records laws comparable to FOIA, and meet the same deadlines as the Secretary.","c":[145,23,145,25]},{"t":"Interior audits annually for 4 years, can terminate after a 120-day cure period, and applicants may still choose federal consultation.","c":[149,1,149,2]},{"t":"Interior's failure to act on an application within 180 days counts as a failure to act under the NEPA sanctions section.","c":[144,20,144,23]}]],"points":[{"t":"States can take over ESA consultation for projects within their boundaries","c":[140,1,140,5]},{"t":"Applicants can opt out and consult with the Interior Department instead","c":[148,7,148,10]},{"t":"Annual audits for 4 years; 10-year renewable agreements","c":[146,22,146,23]}],"quotes":[{"t":"the Secretary may assign, and the State may assume, the consultation responsibilities of the Secretary within the boundary of the State under subsections (a), (b), and (c) of section 7.","why":"The assignment of consultation to a state.","c":[140,1,140,5]}],"vs":{"current":"No mechanism exists; consultation is federal-only (only the Fish and Wildlife Service and NMFS issue biological opinions).","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":6},{"n":"1305","h":"Judicial review","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE III","tih":"ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT OF 1973","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":154,"l1":3,"p2":155,"words":202,"imp":2,"topics":["esa","courts"],"plain":"Lets any person seek review of a biological opinion in the D.C. Circuit within 150 days after it is made public.","ps":[[{"t":"Lets any person seek review of a biological opinion in the D.C. Circuit within 150 days after it is made public.","c":[154,17,154,20]}]],"points":[{"t":"150-day window and D.C. Circuit venue for biological opinion challenges","c":[154,17,154,19]}],"quotes":[{"t":"in the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit by filing in such court not later than 150 days after the date on which the opinion is made public a written petition for review","why":"Biological opinion challenges go to the D.C. Circuit within 150 days.","c":[154,17,154,21]}],"vs":{"current":"Biological opinions are reviewed in district courts under the APA's 6-year limit.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":2},{"n":"1306","h":"Listing determinations","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE III","tih":"ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT OF 1973","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":155,"l1":8,"p2":155,"words":70,"imp":1,"topics":["esa"],"plain":"Requires the Secretary to accept and integrate state-collected data in listing and delisting decisions when it meets the best-available-data standard.","ps":[[{"t":"Requires the Secretary to accept and integrate state-collected data in listing and delisting decisions when it meets the best-available-data standard.","c":[155,14,155,17]}]],"points":[{"t":"State data must be used in listings","c":[155,14,155,15]}],"quotes":[{"t":"the Secretary shall accept and integrate State-collected data, subject to the condition that the State-collected data meets the definition of ‘best scientific and commercial data available’","why":"State-collected data must be used in listing decisions.","c":[155,14,155,17]}],"vs":{"current":"States may submit data but there is no mandate to integrate it.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"1307","h":"Authorization of appropriations","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE III","tih":"ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT OF 1973","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":155,"l1":18,"p2":155,"words":46,"imp":1,"topics":["esa"],"plain":"Authorizes $150 million a year for fiscal years 2027 through 2031 for Endangered Species Act section 7 consultation and for state participation in the program under section 7A.","ps":[[{"t":"Authorizes $150 million a year for fiscal years 2027 through 2031 for Endangered Species Act section 7 consultation and for state participation in the program under section 7A.","c":[155,19,155,20]}]],"points":[{"t":"$150 million a year for consultation capacity","c":[155,19,155,20]}],"quotes":[{"t":"There is authorized to be appropriated $150,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2027 through 2031","why":"$150 million a year for consultation.","c":[155,19,155,20]}],"vs":{"current":"New.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"1308","h":"National Fish and Wildlife Foundation Coastal State Fund","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE III","tih":"ENDANGERED SPECIES ACT OF 1973","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":156,"l1":1,"p2":158,"words":450,"imp":1,"topics":["offshore"],"plain":"Creates a National Fish and Wildlife Foundation Coastal State Fund granting money to coastal states for coastal resource and natural infrastructure programs. The money is allocated 70 percent equally among coastal states and 15 percent by tidal shoreline. Another 15 percent is allocated by coastal population density, and no state gets more than 5 percent. Authorizes $50 million a year for fiscal years 2028 through 2032.","ps":[[{"t":"Creates a National Fish and Wildlife Foundation Coastal State Fund granting money to coastal states for coastal resource and natural infrastructure programs.","c":[157,8,157,11]},{"t":"The money is allocated 70 percent equally among coastal states and 15 percent by tidal shoreline.","c":[157,17,157,21]},{"t":"Another 15 percent is allocated by coastal population density, and no state gets more than 5 percent.","c":[157,24,158,5]},{"t":"Authorizes $50 million a year for fiscal years 2028 through 2032.","c":[158,12,158,13]}]],"points":[{"t":"$50 million a year to coastal states through NFWF","c":[158,12,158,13]}],"quotes":[{"t":"not more than 5 percent of the total amounts allocated under that subsection may be allocated to any single coastal State","why":"No state may receive more than 5 percent.","c":[158,4,158,6]}],"vs":{"current":"New.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"EPRA 2024 had offshore wind revenue-sharing provisions rather than a grant fund."}},{"n":"1401","h":"Maintaining Federal authorizations or permits for projects with non-Federal sponsors","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE IV","tih":"PROJECT CERTAINTY","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":158,"l1":19,"p2":166,"words":1204,"imp":3,"topics":["permit-certainty","wind-solar","offshore","courts"],"plain":"For projects with non-federal sponsors, a federal agency may not revoke, suspend, amend, or otherwise interfere with a federal authorization in effect on or after September 16, 2026.\n\nThere are five exceptions. A court can order the action. The holder can have materially breached the permit or the law, or obtained the permit by fraud. The action can be needed to prevent specific, urgent, substantial and proximate harm to life, property, national security or defense, based on new information not considered in the original review. Or the holder can ask for it.\n\nAgencies must give written notice with the statutory authority and evidence. The sponsor can sue in district court, where the agency carries the burden by clear and convincing evidence and classified information is reviewed in camera. A winning sponsor gets the permit reinstated and an injunction against repeat interference without a court order. The sponsor also gets attorney fees, delay costs, and an additional 25 to 50 percent of all project costs incurred. Awards are paid from the Judgment Fund without appropriation.\n\nWhere a stop-work order issued within the year before enactment was enjoined, the same judge keeps jurisdiction.","ps":[[{"t":"For projects with non-federal sponsors, a federal agency may not revoke, suspend, amend, or otherwise interfere with a federal authorization in effect on or after September 16, 2026.","c":[159,12,159,15]}],[{"t":"There are five exceptions.","c":[159,20,159,21]},{"t":"A court can order the action.","c":[159,20,159,21]},{"t":"The holder can have materially breached the permit or the law, or obtained the permit by fraud.","c":[159,23,160,2]},{"t":"The action can be needed to prevent specific, urgent, substantial and proximate harm to life, property, national security or defense, based on new information not considered in the original review.","c":[160,6,160,9]},{"t":"Or the holder can ask for it.","c":[160,13,160,16]}],[{"t":"Agencies must give written notice with the statutory authority and evidence.","c":[160,24,161,2]},{"t":"The sponsor can sue in district court, where the agency carries the burden by clear and convincing evidence and classified information is reviewed in camera.","c":[162,4,162,7]},{"t":"A winning sponsor gets the permit reinstated and an injunction against repeat interference without a court order.","c":[163,8,163,13]},{"t":"The sponsor also gets attorney fees, delay costs, and an additional 25 to 50 percent of all project costs incurred.","c":[163,23,164,5]},{"t":"Awards are paid from the Judgment Fund without appropriation.","c":[165,18,165,24]}],[{"t":"Where a stop-work order issued within the year before enactment was enjoined, the same judge keeps jurisdiction.","c":[165,13,165,17]}]],"points":[{"t":"No permit revocation absent a court order, breach, fraud, new-information emergency, or the holder's request","c":[159,20,159,21]},{"t":"Burden on the government by clear and convincing evidence","c":[162,4,162,6]},{"t":"Damages of 25 to 50 percent of costs incurred, plus fees and delay costs, from the Judgment Fund","c":[164,3,164,6]},{"t":"Where a stop-work order from the year before enactment was enjoined, the same judge hears any new attempt","c":[165,1,165,3]},{"t":"Cutoff date of September 16, 2026 for permits in effect","c":[159,14,159,15]}],"quotes":[{"t":"a Federal department or agency shall not take any new action that would revoke, rescind, withdraw, terminate, suspend, amend, or alter a Federal authorization or permit in effect on or after September 16, 2026","why":"The bar on revoking or altering an issued permit.","c":[159,11,159,15]},{"t":"costs in an amount equal to not less than 25 percent and not more than 50 percent of the total of all costs incurred by the non-Federal project sponsor or holder of the Federal authorization or permit in connection with the project","why":"A winning sponsor recovers 25 to 50 percent of project costs.","c":[164,3,164,8]},{"t":"If, within 1 year prior to the date of enactment of this Act, a Federal Agency has issued a stop-work order that would interfere with or prevent the construction or operation at full capacity of a project and said order has been enjoined by a court of competent jurisdiction","why":"A stop-work order enjoined in the year before enactment stays with the same judge.","c":[165,1,165,7]}],"vs":{"current":"New. Agencies today can suspend or revoke leases and permits under each statute and the permit's own terms, subject to APA review with the burden on the challenger.","speed":"The SPEED Act (sec. 2(b)) had a shorter version of this rule inside NEPA: the same five exceptions, a clear-and-convincing standard 'as appropriate and where feasible', and APA review in the court of appeals. It had no damages and no cutoff date, and its section 4 exempted any agency action the administration had moved to reconsider since January 20, 2025, which covered the offshore wind approvals then under review. The Senate bill has no such exemption, covers permits in effect on or after September 16, 2026, shifts the burden of proof to the agency, adds money damages, and keeps the same judge on projects whose stop-work orders were already enjoined.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024; this title responds to 2025 and 2026 events."},"takes":21},{"n":"1402","h":"Ensuring fairness for specific types of covered projects","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE IV","tih":"PROJECT CERTAINTY","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":166,"l1":11,"p2":182,"words":2128,"imp":3,"topics":["permit-certainty","wind-solar","offshore","fossil","courts"],"plain":"Creates a cause of action for applicants in 46 named energy project types, plus any similar type a court certifies. The list runs from onshore and offshore wind, solar and storage to coal, gas, oil, nuclear, geothermal, transmission, pipelines, mining, hydrogen, hydropower, LNG and carbon storage.\n\nThe applicant must show a 'pattern of disparate treatment': an intentional, statistically demonstrated rise in denials or delays for that project type, compared with the prior 5 years. The pattern must last 180 days after enactment for permits without a NEPA document, or 280 days for those with one. Executive orders and official statements showing bias count as supporting evidence. The government must produce raw statistics for the year of the suit and the 5 years before it, or face an adverse inference.\n\nPermits for these projects that need no NEPA document must be decided within 1 year of a complete application.\n\nRemedies are an injunction, fees, economic damages, and 50 to 100 percent of the expected construction cost, paid from the Judgment Fund. The applicant must finish the project or repay. Class actions are barred, and suits cannot be filed until 180 or 280 days after enactment.","ps":[[{"t":"Creates a cause of action for applicants in 46 named energy project types, plus any similar type a court certifies.","c":[172,13,172,16]},{"t":"The list runs from onshore and offshore wind, solar and storage to coal, gas, oil, nuclear, geothermal, transmission, pipelines, mining, hydrogen, hydropower, LNG and carbon storage.","c":[169,4,169,5]}],[{"t":"The applicant must show a 'pattern of disparate treatment': an intentional, statistically demonstrated rise in denials or delays for that project type, compared with the prior 5 years.","c":[167,16,167,19]},{"t":"The pattern must last 180 days after enactment for permits without a NEPA document, or 280 days for those with one.","c":[168,11,168,14]},{"t":"Executive orders and official statements showing bias count as supporting evidence.","c":[176,11,176,17]},{"t":"The government must produce raw statistics for the year of the suit and the 5 years before it, or face an adverse inference.","c":[177,15,177,18]}],[{"t":"Permits for these projects that need no NEPA document must be decided within 1 year of a complete application.","c":[173,5,173,8]}],[{"t":"Remedies are an injunction, fees, economic damages, and 50 to 100 percent of the expected construction cost, paid from the Judgment Fund.","c":[179,20,179,23]},{"t":"The applicant must finish the project or repay.","c":[180,23,180,24]},{"t":"Class actions are barred, and suits cannot be filed until 180 or 280 days after enactment.","c":[181,8,181,10]}]],"points":[{"t":"Anti-discrimination rule across 46 named project types, from offshore wind to coal, plus any similar type a court certifies","c":[172,13,172,16]},{"t":"Executive orders and officials' statements admissible as evidence of bias","c":[176,11,176,17]},{"t":"Damages of 50 to 100 percent of expected construction cost","c":[179,20,179,23]},{"t":"One-year deadline for permits that need no NEPA document","c":[173,5,173,8]},{"t":"Claims mature 180 or 280 days after enactment","c":[181,23,181,25]}],"quotes":[{"t":"a pattern of statements made by executive branch officials, Federal department and agency policies, Executive orders, or other official guidance that demonstrates a bias in the permitting regime against the specific type of covered project at issue","why":"Officials' statements and executive orders count as evidence of bias.","c":[176,11,176,19]},{"t":"damages in an amount equal to not less than 50 percent and not more than 100 percent of the total reasonably expected cost of construction of the project","why":"Damages of 50 to 100 percent of expected construction cost.","c":[179,20,179,24]}],"vs":{"current":"New.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":14},{"n":"1403","h":"Avoiding unreasonable delays in permitting","div":"DIVISION A","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENT AND PUBLIC WORKS","ti":"TITLE IV","tih":"PROJECT CERTAINTY","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":182,"l1":7,"p2":185,"words":506,"imp":2,"topics":["permit-certainty","courts"],"plain":"Gives applicants for permits that need no environmental document a right to sue in district court when the 1-year deadline in section 1402(c) is missed. The agency is excused if it proves the delay was caused by a disaster, a national emergency, fraud, withheld information, or a lapse in appropriations of more than 14 days. Courts decide within 120 days and can order a decision within 60 days.","ps":[[{"t":"Gives applicants for permits that need no environmental document a right to sue in district court when the 1-year deadline in section 1402(c) is missed.","c":[183,3,183,6]},{"t":"The agency is excused if it proves the delay was caused by a disaster, a national emergency, fraud, withheld information, or a lapse in appropriations of more than 14 days.","c":[183,15,183,17]},{"t":"Courts decide within 120 days and can order a decision within 60 days.","c":[184,22,184,24]}]],"points":[{"t":"Deadline suits for non-NEPA permits","c":[183,3,183,5]}],"quotes":[{"t":"issue a decision under this section as expeditiously as practicable, but not later than 120 days, after the date on which the petition is filed","why":"The court must rule within 120 days.","c":[184,22,184,24]}],"vs":{"current":"New.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"2101","h":"Transmission permitting","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":185,"l1":10,"p2":200,"words":2415,"imp":3,"topics":["transmission"],"plain":"Overhauls FERC's backstop siting authority under Federal Power Act section 216. FERC must issue a construction or modification permit for an interstate line of 230 kilovolts or more, or an advanced-conductor line at a voltage FERC sets, when it makes the required findings. The line no longer has to sit in a national interest corridor designated by the Energy Department. The state's clock for deciding now starts on the date the application is filed with the state.\n\nFERC must find the line is in the public interest, protects or benefits consumers, and improves reliability. For lines of 345 kilovolts or more the developer may file at FERC at the same time as at the state. FERC must take landowner input, consider the state record, and give a 45-day comment period.\n\nCosts go only to customers who benefit, in line with cost causation, and customers with no or trivial benefit cannot be charged involuntarily. Clean Water Act section 401 certifications and other state approvals under federal law become 'Federal authorizations' coordinated by FERC as lead agency (Interior for offshore), with challenges heard in the courts of appeals. ERCOT is excluded.","ps":[[{"t":"Overhauls FERC's backstop siting authority under Federal Power Act section 216.","c":[185,11,185,12]},{"t":"FERC must issue a construction or modification permit for an interstate line of 230 kilovolts or more, or an advanced-conductor line at a voltage FERC sets, when it makes the required findings.","c":[189,17,189,19]},{"t":"The line no longer has to sit in a national interest corridor designated by the Energy Department.","c":[199,11,199,15]},{"t":"The state's clock for deciding now starts on the date the application is filed with the state.","c":[189,2,189,5]}],[{"t":"FERC must find the line is in the public interest, protects or benefits consumers, and improves reliability.","c":[189,14,189,16]},{"t":"For lines of 345 kilovolts or more the developer may file at FERC at the same time as at the state.","c":[191,20,191,23]},{"t":"FERC must take landowner input, consider the state record, and give a 45-day comment period.","c":[188,11,188,12]}],[{"t":"Costs go only to customers who benefit, in line with cost causation, and customers with no or trivial benefit cannot be charged involuntarily.","c":[194,13,194,14]},{"t":"Clean Water Act section 401 certifications and other state approvals under federal law become 'Federal authorizations' coordinated by FERC as lead agency (Interior for offshore), with challenges heard in the courts of appeals.","c":[195,10,195,13]},{"t":"ERCOT is excluded.","c":[198,17,198,18]}]],"points":[{"t":"No more national interest corridor prerequisite for FERC backstop siting","c":[199,15,199,16]},{"t":"The state's clock starts on the date the application is filed with the state","c":[189,2,189,5]},{"t":"230 kV threshold; simultaneous state and FERC filing at 345 kV and above","c":[189,17,189,19]},{"t":"Cost allocation limited to beneficiaries; no involuntary charges for trivial benefits","c":[194,13,194,14]},{"t":"State 401 certifications for transmission folded into FERC-led federal authorization schedule","c":[195,10,195,12]},{"t":"ERCOT excluded; public power and small co-ops only if they opt in","c":[198,24,199,2]}],"quotes":[{"t":"the Commission shall, after notice and an opportunity for hearing, including a public comment period of at least 45 days, issue one or more permits to individual or joint applicants for the construction or modification of electric transmission facilities necessary in the national interest","why":"FERC 'shall' issue the permit once it makes the findings.","c":[188,10,188,16]},{"t":"Customers that receive no benefit, or benefits that are trivial in relation to the costs sought to be allocated, from electric transmission facilities constructed or modified under this section shall not be involuntarily allocated any of the costs of those transmission facilities","why":"Customers with no or trivial benefit cannot be charged.","c":[194,9,194,14]}],"vs":{"current":"Section 216 (2005, amended 2021) says FERC 'may' site lines, and only inside National Interest Electric Transmission Corridors designated by the Energy Department. FERC can step in where a state lacks siting authority, has not decided within 1 year, has denied the application, or has set conditions that make the line uneconomic. Those grounds stay. The cost allocation and lead-agency changes are new.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act, which amended only NEPA.","epra":"EPRA 2024 (sec. 401) made the same core change: FERC backstop siting without corridor designation, FERC action once a state has had 1 year, beneficiary-pays cost allocation and the trivial-benefit protection.\n\nDifferences: EPRA said FERC 'may' issue a permit after a 60-day comment period and set the floor at 100 kilovolts. This bill says 'shall' after 45 days and sets the floor at 230 kilovolts. It drops EPRA's findings that a line 'significantly reduce transmission congestion' and be 'consistent with sound national energy policy'. It adds simultaneous state and FERC filing at 345 kilovolts, the state record, an opt-in for public power and small co-ops, FERC-led coordination of state water certifications, and review of all related permits in the courts of appeals."},"takes":13},{"n":"2102","h":"Reconductoring and other activities in existing rights-of-way","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":200,"l1":11,"p2":205,"words":637,"imp":3,"topics":["transmission","fossil","categorical-exclusions","historic-preservation"],"plain":"Adds Federal Power Act section 216A: work that maintains or increases grid capacity inside an existing right-of-way is categorically excluded from NEPA. Covered work includes reconductoring, higher operating voltage, added circuits, advanced transmission technologies, added storage at an existing facility, and a parallel circuit. Work under section 216A is also not a major federal action and not an undertaking under the National Historic Preservation Act. The bill also amends Natural Gas Act section 7 for repair, replacement, looping, compression and capacity-enhancement of interstate gas pipelines. That work is not a major federal action or a historic-preservation undertaking when it stays inside an existing right-of-way or previously reviewed footprint.","ps":[[{"t":"Adds Federal Power Act section 216A: work that maintains or increases grid capacity inside an existing right-of-way is categorically excluded from NEPA.","c":[201,23,202,2]},{"t":"Covered work includes reconductoring, higher operating voltage, added circuits, advanced transmission technologies, added storage at an existing facility, and a parallel circuit.","c":[202,16,202,21]},{"t":"Work under section 216A is also not a major federal action and not an undertaking under the National Historic Preservation Act.","c":[202,4,202,8]},{"t":"The bill also amends Natural Gas Act section 7 for repair, replacement, looping, compression and capacity-enhancement of interstate gas pipelines.","c":[203,18,203,21]},{"t":"That work is not a major federal action or a historic-preservation undertaking when it stays inside an existing right-of-way or previously reviewed footprint.","c":[204,14,204,19]}]],"points":[{"t":"Reconductoring and in-corridor grid upgrades exempt from NEPA and NHPA section 106","c":[201,23,202,2]},{"t":"Gas pipeline looping and compression in existing corridors exempt from NEPA and NHPA section 106","c":[204,17,204,21]},{"t":"Clean Water Act and Clean Air Act requirements for pipelines stay in place","c":[205,1,205,3]}],"quotes":[{"t":"Activities to maintain or increase the capacity of the electric grid within a covered area, and any Federal agency action authorizing such activities— “(A) are a category of actions designated as being categorically excluded","why":"Grid upgrades inside an existing right-of-way are excluded from NEPA.","c":[201,19,201,24]},{"t":"The term ‘covered activity’ means any repair, maintenance, replacement, upgrade, rebuilding, modification, optimization, minor relocation, looping, compression, capacity-enhancement project, or addition to a covered facility.","why":"The same exemption for gas pipeline work, including looping and compression.","c":[203,17,203,22]}],"vs":{"current":"DOE and other agencies have administrative categorical exclusions for some reconductoring; there is no statutory exclusion, and pipeline looping and compression get FERC environmental review.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"EPRA 2024 (sec. 209) only told Interior and Agriculture to adopt categorical exclusions for in-corridor grid work, which survives as section 2214. The statutory exemptions here, including the gas pipeline one, are new."}},{"n":"2103","h":"Transmission planning","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":205,"l1":11,"p2":218,"words":1879,"imp":3,"topics":["transmission"],"plain":"Adds Federal Power Act sections 224 and 225. The Energy Department studies transmission constraints and congestion every 3 years and may identify constrained geographic areas. FERC must issue a rule within 180 days requiring every planning region to file a regional planning process and joint interregional processes with its neighbors within 2 years, updated every 4 years. The processes must use common assumptions, a fixed list of six benefits, and selection criteria of improved reliability, consumer benefit and public interest.\n\nCosts are allocated to beneficiaries roughly commensurate with benefits. Compliance with the FERC planning orders published on June 11, 2024, December 6, 2024 and April 28, 2025 (Order 1920 and its two rehearing orders) counts as compliance for regional planning. A project selected in a regional or interregional plan is deemed to meet most of the findings for a FERC backstop permit. Approving a planning process is not a major federal action under NEPA.","ps":[[{"t":"Adds Federal Power Act sections 224 and 225.","c":[205,12,205,13]},{"t":"The Energy Department studies transmission constraints and congestion every 3 years and may identify constrained geographic areas.","c":[205,15,205,17]},{"t":"FERC must issue a rule within 180 days requiring every planning region to file a regional planning process and joint interregional processes with its neighbors within 2 years, updated every 4 years.","c":[211,11,211,13]},{"t":"The processes must use common assumptions, a fixed list of six benefits, and selection criteria of improved reliability, consumer benefit and public interest.","c":[213,1,213,2]}],[{"t":"Costs are allocated to beneficiaries roughly commensurate with benefits.","c":[216,12,216,15]},{"t":"Compliance with the FERC planning orders published on June 11, 2024, December 6, 2024 and April 28, 2025 (Order 1920 and its two rehearing orders) counts as compliance for regional planning.","c":[217,3,217,6]},{"t":"A project selected in a regional or interregional plan is deemed to meet most of the findings for a FERC backstop permit.","c":[217,9,217,12]},{"t":"Approving a planning process is not a major federal action under NEPA.","c":[218,5,218,8]}]],"points":[{"t":"Requires interregional transmission planning by statute","c":[211,19,212,8]},{"t":"FERC rule in 180 days; regional filings in 2 years","c":[211,11,211,13]},{"t":"Compliance with FERC's 2024 and 2025 planning orders (Order 1920) counts for the regional piece","c":[217,1,217,4]},{"t":"Plan-selected projects get a fast path to a FERC siting permit","c":[217,12,217,14]},{"t":"Six enumerated benefits; reliability first","c":[213,19,213,21]}],"quotes":[{"t":"require neighboring transmission planning regions to jointly establish a process for planning interregional transmission facilities in accordance with this section","why":"Neighboring regions must plan interregional lines together.","c":[211,19,211,22]},{"t":"Compliance with a Commission order or rulemaking effective as of the date of enactment of this section, including orders published in the Federal Register on April 28, 2025, December 6, 2024, and June 11, 2024, shall constitute compliance with the regional transmission planning and cost allocation requirements of this section.","why":"Compliance with FERC's existing planning orders counts.","c":[217,1,217,7]}],"vs":{"current":"FERC Orders 1000 and 1920 require regional planning by rule; interregional coordination is weak and there is no statutory requirement. DOE's triennial congestion study exists under section 216(a).","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"EPRA 2024 (sec. 402) created the same sections 224 and 225 but required only interregional plans. This bill also requires regional planning processes, deems FERC Order No. 1920 compliance sufficient for the regional piece, and exempts public power and small co-ops unless they opt in. It drops EPRA's 60-day FERC dispute resolution between regions and FERC's power to impose a plan when regions fail to file one; the only consequence left is a 6-month extension."},"takes":2},{"n":"2104","h":"Improvements relating to local transmission planning and development","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":218,"l1":14,"p2":224,"words":788,"imp":2,"topics":["transmission","data-centers"],"plain":"Adds Federal Power Act section 226. One or more states may refer a utility to FERC for an investigation of its local transmission planning. FERC forms an investigative team with up to 3 state appointees.\n\nThe team may find that the utility's process is not selecting the more efficient or cost-effective local projects, or is crowding out regional planning. FERC may then order process changes or cut the utility's return on equity on local projects. Further remedies are removing the presumption of prudence or fining the utility. A fine, paid to the referring state, can reach $5 million for each local facility developed or energized from 60 days before the referral that FERC finds imprudent and harmful to that state's customers.","ps":[[{"t":"Adds Federal Power Act section 226.","c":[218,16,218,18]},{"t":"One or more states may refer a utility to FERC for an investigation of its local transmission planning.","c":[220,6,220,10]},{"t":"FERC forms an investigative team with up to 3 state appointees.","c":[221,14,221,15]}],[{"t":"The team may find that the utility's process is not selecting the more efficient or cost-effective local projects, or is crowding out regional planning.","c":[222,1,222,4]},{"t":"FERC may then order process changes or cut the utility's return on equity on local projects.","c":[222,22,223,3]},{"t":"Further remedies are removing the presumption of prudence or fining the utility.","c":[223,4,223,8]},{"t":"A fine, paid to the referring state, can reach $5 million for each local facility developed or energized from 60 days before the referral that FERC finds imprudent and harmful to that state's customers.","c":[223,20,223,22]}]],"points":[{"t":"States can trigger FERC investigations of local transmission spending","c":[220,6,220,10]},{"t":"Remedies include lower return on equity and fines up to $5 million per facility","c":[223,7,223,9]}],"quotes":[{"t":"A fine, payable to the referring State, of up to $5,000,000 for each local transmission facility","why":"Fines of up to $5 million per facility, paid to the state.","c":[223,7,223,9]}],"vs":{"current":"Local projects that a utility plans for itself get little federal or state review.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":3},{"n":"2105","h":"Prohibition of right of first refusal","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":224,"l1":4,"p2":224,"words":84,"imp":2,"topics":["transmission"],"plain":"Bans any federal right of first refusal for transmission facilities selected in a regional or interregional plan for cost allocation, overriding any FERC rule or order to the contrary.","ps":[[{"t":"Bans any federal right of first refusal for transmission facilities selected in a regional or interregional plan for cost allocation, overriding any FERC rule or order to the contrary.","c":[224,11,224,14]}]],"points":[{"t":"Incumbent utilities get no federal first claim on regionally planned lines; competitive developers can bid","c":[224,11,224,14]}],"quotes":[{"t":"a Federal right of first refusal is prohibited with respect to a transmission facility selected in a regional or interregional transmission plan for the purposes of cost allocation.","why":"The ban on a federal right of first refusal.","c":[224,11,224,14]}],"vs":{"current":"Order No. 1000 removed federal rights of first refusal; Order No. 1920 restored a conditional one for some upgrades. State right-of-first-refusal laws are untouched.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":3},{"n":"2106","h":"Consolidated planning process","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":224,"l1":15,"p2":226,"words":299,"imp":2,"topics":["transmission"],"plain":"Requires FERC, within 18 months, to make each planning region file a consolidated interconnection and transmission planning process that looks 20 years ahead. The process publishes fuel-neutral planned interconnection locations with a fixed per-megawatt cost. A cluster study in the process has one decision point and nonrefundable security to deter speculative projects. Regions file within 2 years and update every 2 years.","ps":[[{"t":"Requires FERC, within 18 months, to make each planning region file a consolidated interconnection and transmission planning process that looks 20 years ahead.","c":[224,24,225,2]},{"t":"The process publishes fuel-neutral planned interconnection locations with a fixed per-megawatt cost.","c":[225,8,225,12]},{"t":"A cluster study in the process has one decision point and nonrefundable security to deter speculative projects.","c":[225,13,225,17]},{"t":"Regions file within 2 years and update every 2 years.","c":[225,22,225,24]}]],"points":[{"t":"Generation interconnection and transmission planned together","c":[225,3,225,7]},{"t":"Published zonal per-megawatt interconnection prices","c":[225,8,225,12]},{"t":"Nonrefundable deposits and withdrawal penalties for queue entrants","c":[225,13,225,17]}],"quotes":[{"t":"routinely identifies and publishes resource and fuel-neutral planned interconnection locations for generating capacity and an upfront, fixed, zonal, per-megawatt cost for each planned interconnection location","why":"Published interconnection locations with a fixed per-megawatt cost.","c":[225,8,225,12]}],"vs":{"current":"FERC Order No. 2023 set cluster studies; planning and interconnection remain separate processes.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"2107","h":"Ratepayer protection","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":226,"l1":15,"p2":240,"words":1994,"imp":3,"topics":["data-centers","transmission"],"plain":"Congress finds it is not just and reasonable to charge data center, AI and cryptocurrency loads less than the embedded and incremental cost of the transmission they need. FERC must revise its 1994 transmission pricing policy within 270 days, propose a rule 270 days after that, and finish within a further year.\n\nNew Federal Power Act section 228 covers data center loads of 20 megawatts or more. None of the incremental cost of serving them (generation, transmission, distribution) may be recovered from other customers. Recovery continues even if the data center leaves, and utilities must collect financial assurance before building upgrades.\n\nStates may charge these loads more than cost and credit the surplus to other ratepayers. They may run open seasons that award service by ratepayer benefit, whatever the queue order. They may require the load to bring new generation, require curtailable service, and treat data centers less favorably than other industrial customers. The section applies to loads interconnecting after enactment.","ps":[[{"t":"Congress finds it is not just and reasonable to charge data center, AI and cryptocurrency loads less than the embedded and incremental cost of the transmission they need.","c":[226,25,227,4]},{"t":"FERC must revise its 1994 transmission pricing policy within 270 days, propose a rule 270 days after that, and finish within a further year.","c":[229,15,229,18]}],[{"t":"New Federal Power Act section 228 covers data center loads of 20 megawatts or more.","c":[232,9,232,12]},{"t":"None of the incremental cost of serving them (generation, transmission, distribution) may be recovered from other customers.","c":[234,23,235,1]},{"t":"Recovery continues even if the data center leaves, and utilities must collect financial assurance before building upgrades.","c":[235,23,236,1]}],[{"t":"States may charge these loads more than cost and credit the surplus to other ratepayers.","c":[236,14,236,17]},{"t":"They may run open seasons that award service by ratepayer benefit, whatever the queue order.","c":[237,1,237,4]},{"t":"They may require the load to bring new generation, require curtailable service, and treat data centers less favorably than other industrial customers.","c":[237,14,237,17]},{"t":"The section applies to loads interconnecting after enactment.","c":[240,1,240,3]}]],"points":[{"t":"Data centers of 20 MW or more pay the full incremental cost of serving them","c":[234,23,235,1]},{"t":"Costs follow the data center even after it exits","c":[235,14,235,16]},{"t":"Up-front financial assurance before upgrades are built","c":[235,23,236,1]},{"t":"States may auction grid access and require bring-your-own generation","c":[236,23,237,1]},{"t":"Non-firm service gets a lower transmission price","c":[230,9,230,14]},{"t":"Standardized study of cost-reduction options to avoid network upgrades","c":[231,5,231,8]},{"t":"Incremental revenues credited to prevent double recovery from other ratepayers","c":[230,1,230,5]},{"t":"Existing approved arrangements grandfathered","c":[240,5,240,8]}],"quotes":[{"t":"No portion of the incremental cost may be allocated to, or recovered in the rates of, any customer other than a covered load","why":"Other customers cannot be charged the incremental cost of serving a data center.","c":[234,23,235,1]},{"t":"A State may treat covered loads as a separate class of service, and may establish rates, charges, terms, conditions, and interconnection or service priorities for covered loads that differ from, and that are less favorable than, those applicable to other large industrial, manufacturing, or commercial loads.","why":"States may treat data centers less favorably than other large customers.","c":[238,24,239,5]},{"t":"equals or exceeds 20 megawatts or, in the case of data centers or high-density computing facilities developed in phases, is reasonably expected to equal or exceed 20 megawatts at full buildout.","why":"The 20-megawatt threshold.","c":[232,9,232,13]}],"vs":{"current":"Cost allocation for large loads is set in individual state proceedings and FERC tariffs. FERC opened a large-load interconnection rulemaking in 2025. There is no federal floor.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024; data center cost allocation became a central issue in 2025-2026."},"takes":12},{"n":"2108","h":"Dispatchable energy systems market access","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":240,"l1":9,"p2":259,"words":2785,"imp":2,"topics":["transmission","wind-solar"],"plain":"Opens wholesale markets to aggregations of customer-sited batteries, fuel cells and generators that can respond within 15 minutes (5 kilowatts minimum per device, 100 kilowatts per aggregation). After 18 months, grid operator rules that block them are unjust and unreasonable. Grid operators file compliance tariffs within 180 days. Unless state law or the state regulator provides otherwise, distribution utilities in organized markets must interconnect these resources; for public power utilities and other section 201(f) entities the requirement is voluntary. They must also accept wholesale metering data.\n\nA device paid by a state retail program cannot be paid twice for the same service; FERC orders disgorgement and can impose penalties of up to 3 times the amount for each day it was knowingly kept. The Energy Department runs a voluntary streamlined local permitting program for rooftop solar, batteries and vehicle chargers, with $20 million a year authorized for fiscal years 2026 through 2031.","ps":[[{"t":"Opens wholesale markets to aggregations of customer-sited batteries, fuel cells and generators that can respond within 15 minutes (5 kilowatts minimum per device, 100 kilowatts per aggregation).","c":[240,23,240,24]},{"t":"After 18 months, grid operator rules that block them are unjust and unreasonable.","c":[243,13,243,15]},{"t":"Grid operators file compliance tariffs within 180 days.","c":[244,21,244,24]},{"t":"Unless state law or the state regulator provides otherwise, distribution utilities in organized markets must interconnect these resources; for public power utilities and other section 201(f) entities the requirement is voluntary.","c":[252,6,252,10]},{"t":"They must also accept wholesale metering data.","c":[253,7,253,10]}],[{"t":"A device paid by a state retail program cannot be paid twice for the same service;","c":[246,7,246,9]},{"t":"FERC orders disgorgement and can impose penalties of up to 3 times the amount for each day it was knowingly kept.","c":[250,16,250,20]},{"t":"The Energy Department runs a voluntary streamlined local permitting program for rooftop solar, batteries and vehicle chargers, with $20 million a year authorized for fiscal years 2026 through 2031.","c":[259,21,259,23]}]],"points":[{"t":"Virtual power plants get statutory wholesale market access","c":[243,20,243,22]},{"t":"Distribution utilities in organized markets must interconnect behind-the-meter resources","c":[252,9,252,12]},{"t":"Device-level metering allowed; utilities cannot require their own equipment","c":[241,16,241,19]},{"t":"Double-payment ban, with penalties of up to 3 times the amount per day","c":[250,16,250,18]},{"t":"$20 million a year for streamlined local solar and storage permitting","c":[259,22,259,23]}],"quotes":[{"t":"it shall not be just and reasonable within the meaning of sections 205 and 206 for any Transmission Organization to maintain rates, terms, or conditions of service that, by their terms and to the extent that such rates, terms, and conditions directly affect wholesale rates, prevent the participation of any qualifying BTM DES aggregation","why":"Grid operators cannot bar aggregated customer-sited resources from wholesale markets.","c":[243,15,243,20]}],"vs":{"current":"FERC Order No. 2222 (2020) requires aggregation access by rule; implementation has slipped to 2026 and beyond in several regions.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":1},{"n":"2109","h":"Advanced transmission technologies","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":260,"l1":1,"p2":265,"words":745,"imp":2,"topics":["transmission"],"plain":"Requires FERC to make public utilities use advanced transmission technologies, including best-available conductors, dynamic line rating, power flow control and topology optimization, in new and upgraded lines, with a presumption that the cost is prudent. FERC issues a rule within 1 year requiring recurring benefit-cost evaluations; when benefits exceed costs the utility must deploy on FERC's timeline or face a penalty such as a lower return on equity.","ps":[[{"t":"Requires FERC to make public utilities use advanced transmission technologies, including best-available conductors, dynamic line rating, power flow control and topology optimization, in new and upgraded lines, with a presumption that the cost is prudent.","c":[261,13,261,16]},{"t":"FERC issues a rule within 1 year requiring recurring benefit-cost evaluations; when benefits exceed costs the utility must deploy on FERC's timeline or face a penalty such as a lower return on equity.","c":[262,8,262,11]}]],"points":[{"t":"Mandatory use of grid-enhancing technologies when benefits exceed costs","c":[263,16,263,19]},{"t":"Presumption of prudence for their cost","c":[261,23,261,24]},{"t":"Return-on-equity penalty for not deploying","c":[264,19,264,21]}],"quotes":[{"t":"the Commission shall require that public utilities use advanced transmission technologies, including best-available transmission conductors, when carrying out covered projects.","why":"Utilities must use advanced transmission technologies.","c":[261,13,261,16]}],"vs":{"current":"FERC Order No. 1920 requires regions to consider four such technologies; nothing compels deployment.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"EPRA 2024 allowed advanced conductors in backstop projects but had no deployment mandate."},"takes":1},{"n":"2110","h":"Expediting generator interconnection queues","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":265,"l1":11,"p2":266,"words":137,"imp":1,"topics":["transmission"],"plain":"Directs FERC to start a rulemaking within 1 year requiring transmission providers to share and use computing technologies, including AI and automation, to process interconnection requests faster, and to revisit the rule every 4 years.","ps":[[{"t":"Directs FERC to start a rulemaking within 1 year requiring transmission providers to share and use computing technologies, including AI and automation, to process interconnection requests faster, and to revisit the rule every 4 years.","c":[265,13,265,16]}]],"points":[{"t":"AI and automation in interconnection queue studies","c":[265,21,265,23]}],"quotes":[{"t":"to require public utility transmission providers to share and employ, as appropriate, queue management practices with respect to the use of computing technologies, including artificial intelligence, machine learning, and automation","why":"The instruction to automate interconnection studies.","c":[265,18,265,22]}],"vs":{"current":"New.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":1},{"n":"2111","h":"Grid data access","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":266,"l1":7,"p2":272,"words":944,"imp":1,"topics":["transmission"],"plain":"Adds Federal Power Act section 232. Transmission providers must hold the data needed for interconnection and facilities studies and may demand it from any bulk-power system user, owner or operator, who must respond in 15 days in a usable format. Confidentiality rules can shape access but cannot be used to withhold data. Violations are treated as reliability matters. FERC and the Energy Department publish, within 1 year, a reference specification for fully automated interconnection studies.","ps":[[{"t":"Adds Federal Power Act section 232.","c":[266,11,266,11]},{"t":"Transmission providers must hold the data needed for interconnection and facilities studies and may demand it from any bulk-power system user, owner or operator, who must respond in 15 days in a usable format.","c":[268,20,268,23]},{"t":"Confidentiality rules can shape access but cannot be used to withhold data.","c":[270,3,270,5]},{"t":"Violations are treated as reliability matters.","c":[270,12,270,14]},{"t":"FERC and the Energy Department publish, within 1 year, a reference specification for fully automated interconnection studies.","c":[271,23,272,2]}]],"points":[{"t":"15-day deadline to hand over grid study data","c":[268,21,268,23]},{"t":"Reference specification for fully automated interconnection studies","c":[272,1,272,4]}],"quotes":[{"t":"may not be used to withhold grid data if access can be provided consistent with those requirements.","why":"Confidentiality rules cannot be used to withhold grid data.","c":[270,3,270,5]}],"vs":{"current":"New.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"2112","h":"Power marketing administrations","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":272,"l1":15,"p2":278,"words":839,"imp":1,"topics":["transmission"],"plain":"Lets the federal power marketing agencies set pay outside the federal schedule, benchmarked to consumer-owned utilities in their interconnection, to fix hiring and retention problems.","ps":[[{"t":"Lets the federal power marketing agencies set pay outside the federal schedule, benchmarked to consumer-owned utilities in their interconnection, to fix hiring and retention problems.","c":[272,23,273,1]}]],"points":[{"t":"Market-rate pay for power marketing administration staff","c":[274,20,274,25]}],"quotes":[{"t":"shall be comparable to and competitive with similar positions among consumer-owned utilities","why":"The pay benchmark for power marketing administration staff.","c":[274,23,274,25]}],"vs":{"current":"Pay follows the federal General Schedule, with limited exceptions.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Carried over from EPRA 2024 (sec. 802)."}},{"n":"2113","h":"FERC fee assessments","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":278,"l1":3,"p2":278,"words":150,"imp":1,"topics":["transmission"],"plain":"Requires FERC to review every 5 years whether its fees and charges are enough to handle its workload promptly and report to Congress.","ps":[[{"t":"Requires FERC to review every 5 years whether its fees and charges are enough to handle its workload promptly and report to Congress.","c":[278,10,278,12]}]],"points":[{"t":"Five-year FERC fee adequacy review","c":[278,8,278,9]}],"quotes":[{"t":"are sufficient to allow the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to handle its workload in an expedient manner","why":"The test FERC's fees must meet.","c":[278,14,278,16]}],"vs":{"current":"New.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"2114","h":"Collection of data on computational load entities","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":279,"l1":1,"p2":279,"words":156,"imp":2,"topics":["data-centers"],"plain":"Directs the Energy Information Administration to revise Form 861 to collect electricity load from data center entities (AI, cloud, cryptocurrency) at least 90 days before the first April 1 after enactment.","ps":[[{"t":"Directs the Energy Information Administration to revise Form 861 to collect electricity load from data center entities (AI, cloud, cryptocurrency) at least 90 days before the first April 1 after enactment.","c":[279,21,279,24]}]],"points":[{"t":"EIA's Form 861 must report data center load","c":[279,24,279,25]}],"quotes":[{"t":"the Administrator of the Energy Information Administration shall revise Form 861 of the Energy Information Administration to include load from data center entities.","why":"EIA must collect data center load on Form 861.","c":[279,23,279,25]}],"vs":{"current":"EIA does not break out data center load.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":1},{"n":"2115","h":"Conforming amendments; savings provision","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE I","tih":"ELECTRIC TRANSMISSION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":280,"l1":1,"p2":280,"words":138,"imp":1,"topics":["transmission"],"plain":"Conforming cross-references in the Federal Power Act and a savings clause: nothing in the transmission title gives FERC authority over retail electricity sales or local distribution.","ps":[[{"t":"Conforming cross-references in the Federal Power Act and a savings clause: nothing in the transmission title gives FERC authority over retail electricity sales or local distribution.","c":[280,18,280,21]}]],"points":[{"t":"No new FERC authority over retail sales or local distribution","c":[280,18,280,21]}],"quotes":[{"t":"Nothing in this title or an amendment made by this title grants authority to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission under the Federal Power Act (16 U.S.C. 791a et seq.) over sales of electric energy at retail or the local distribution of electricity.","why":"FERC gains no authority over retail sales or local distribution.","c":[280,17,280,21]}],"vs":{"current":"Technical.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"EPRA 2024 had a comparable savings clause."}},{"n":"2201","h":"Accelerating claims","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle A","suh":"Accelerating Claims","p1":280,"l1":24,"p2":286,"words":849,"imp":3,"topics":["courts","fossil","mining"],"plain":"A 150-day statute of limitations applies to any lawsuit challenging a federal agency's grant or denial of an authorization. The limit covers authorizations for an energy, carbon dioxide, mineral or wildfire fuel-reduction project. A shorter limit set by the underlying law applies instead. Covered authorizations include leases, drilling permits, rights-of-way, mining plans, Endangered Species Act statements and permits, and forest restoration approvals. Agencies must publish the decision within 3 days. Courts must expedite the case, and a remand cannot give the agency more than 180 days unless the law requires longer. Agencies must tell the project sponsor about any suit within 30 days.","ps":[[{"t":"A 150-day statute of limitations applies to any lawsuit challenging a federal agency's grant or denial of an authorization.","c":[284,13,284,15]},{"t":"The limit covers authorizations for an energy, carbon dioxide, mineral or wildfire fuel-reduction project.","c":[283,14,283,21]},{"t":"A shorter limit set by the underlying law applies instead.","c":[284,16,284,17]},{"t":"Covered authorizations include leases, drilling permits, rights-of-way, mining plans, Endangered Species Act statements and permits, and forest restoration approvals.","c":[281,13,281,16]},{"t":"Agencies must publish the decision within 3 days.","c":[284,18,284,21]},{"t":"Courts must expedite the case, and a remand cannot give the agency more than 180 days unless the law requires longer.","c":[284,22,284,25]},{"t":"Agencies must tell the project sponsor about any suit within 30 days.","c":[286,1,286,3]}]],"points":[{"t":"150 days to sue over energy and mineral project decisions under any federal law","c":[284,12,284,14]},{"t":"180-day cap on agency action after a court remand","c":[285,8,285,10]},{"t":"Covers oil and gas, mining, offshore, geothermal, rights-of-way and forest fuel-reduction projects","c":[281,13,281,16]},{"t":"A project can still be designated a FAST-41 covered project","c":[286,6,286,8]}],"quotes":[{"t":"a civil action arising under Federal law seeking judicial review of a final agency action granting or denying an authorization shall be barred unless the civil action is filed by the date that is 150 days after the date on which the grant or denial of the authorization is required to be made public","why":"The 150-day limit applies to claims under any federal law.","c":[284,10,284,15]},{"t":"Nothing in this title precludes a project from being designated as a covered project","why":"FAST-41 coordination stays available; the bill adds no new FAST-41 sectors.","c":[286,6,286,8]}],"vs":{"current":"The default limit for suits against the United States is 6 years; some statutes set shorter periods (60 days for Natural Gas Act orders, 2 years for FAST-41 covered projects).","speed":"The SPEED Act's 150-day limit applied to NEPA claims; this section reaches claims under any federal law for energy and mineral projects.","epra":"Carried over from EPRA 2024 (sec. 101) nearly word for word: the 150-day limit, the 180-day remand cap and the 30-day notice to sponsors. This version adds leases, rights-of-way and easements to the definition and starts the clock when the decision is made public, which must happen within 3 days."}},{"n":"2211","h":"Permitting compliance on non-Federal land","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle B","suh":"Federal Onshore Energy Leasing and Permitting","p1":286,"l1":13,"p2":290,"words":719,"imp":2,"topics":["fossil"],"plain":"Removes the federal drilling permit requirement for oil and gas wells on non-federal surface land. The exemption applies where the federal government owns less than half the minerals in the drilling unit. Wells whose wellbore only enters or passes through federal minerals are exempt too. Lessees notify Interior of state permits. Interior cannot require bonds, mitigation or reclamation approval on that non-federal land. Royalties are unchanged; Indian lands are excluded.","ps":[[{"t":"Removes the federal drilling permit requirement for oil and gas wells on non-federal surface land.","c":[286,21,286,23]},{"t":"The exemption applies where the federal government owns less than half the minerals in the drilling unit.","c":[287,1,287,4]},{"t":"Wells whose wellbore only enters or passes through federal minerals are exempt too.","c":[287,5,287,8]},{"t":"Lessees notify Interior of state permits.","c":[287,18,287,21]},{"t":"Interior cannot require bonds, mitigation or reclamation approval on that non-federal land.","c":[289,16,289,17]},{"t":"Royalties are unchanged;","c":[289,1,289,3]},{"t":"Indian lands are excluded.","c":[288,8,288,9]}]],"points":[{"t":"No federal permit to drill for wells on private or state surface with a minority federal mineral interest","c":[287,1,287,4]},{"t":"State permits govern; royalties still owed","c":[289,1,289,3]}],"quotes":[{"t":"the Secretary of the Interior shall not require a permit to drill for an oil and gas lease under the Mineral Leasing Act (30 U.S.C. 181 et seq.) for an action occurring within an oil and gas drilling or spacing unit","why":"No federal drilling permit where the federal mineral share is under half.","c":[286,21,286,24]}],"vs":{"current":"BLM requires an application for permit to drill whenever a well produces from a federal lease, wherever the surface is.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Carried over from EPRA 2024 (sec. 203). EPRA's other onshore oil and gas changes, on lease nominations (sec. 201) and a 4-year drilling permit term (sec. 202), and its coal lease deadlines (sec. 204), are not in this bill."}},{"n":"2212","h":"Rights-of-way across Indian land","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle B","suh":"Federal Onshore Energy Leasing and Permitting","p1":290,"l1":14,"p2":298,"words":1251,"imp":2,"topics":["tribal","transmission"],"plain":"Lets an Indian tribe grant rights-of-way across its own tribal land without Interior Department approval, if the grant follows a tribal regulation that Interior has approved. The tribal regulation must include an environmental review with public comment. Interior has 180 days to approve or disapprove, and its approval is not subject to NEPA, the National Historic Preservation Act or the Endangered Species Act.","ps":[[{"t":"Lets an Indian tribe grant rights-of-way across its own tribal land without Interior Department approval, if the grant follows a tribal regulation that Interior has approved.","c":[291,11,291,13]},{"t":"The tribal regulation must include an environmental review with public comment.","c":[292,21,292,24]},{"t":"Interior has 180 days to approve or disapprove, and its approval is not subject to NEPA, the National Historic Preservation Act or the Endangered Species Act.","c":[293,22,294,1]}]],"points":[{"t":"Tribes can approve their own rights-of-way under an approved tribal regulation","c":[291,8,291,10]},{"t":"Interior has 180 days to approve or disapprove a tribe's regulation","c":[293,22,294,8]}],"quotes":[{"t":"an Indian tribe may grant a right-of-way over and across the Tribal land of the Indian tribe for any purpose.","why":"A tribe may grant a right-of-way across its own land.","c":[291,8,291,10]}],"vs":{"current":"Rights-of-way across tribal land need Interior approval under the 1948 Act and 25 CFR part 169. The HEARTH Act of 2012 already lets tribes approve their own surface leases under approved tribal regulations.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Carried over from EPRA 2024 (sec. 205)."}},{"n":"2213","h":"Accelerating renewable energy permitting","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle B","suh":"Federal Onshore Energy Leasing and Permitting","p1":298,"l1":21,"p2":304,"words":873,"imp":2,"topics":["wind-solar","categorical-exclusions"],"plain":"Interior or the Forest Service must tell an eligible-project applicant within 30 days whether its right-of-way application is complete. If an EIS is needed, the agency has 90 days after finding the application complete to issue a notice of intent. Within 30 days after a complete application is submitted, it must issue any required cost-recovery agreement and grant, deny or defer the application. Deferral requires notice of remaining steps and agency timelines.\n\nWithin 180 days, both departments must develop or adopt categorical exclusions for listed low-disturbance renewable activities, with extraordinary-circumstances exceptions. The list includes previously analyzed disturbances under 5 acres, certain repeat activities, small solar projects, surveys and meteorological towers. BLM must issue standard renewable review standards within 2 years.","ps":[[{"t":"Interior or the Forest Service must tell an eligible-project applicant within 30 days whether its right-of-way application is complete.","c":[299,11,299,14]},{"t":"If an EIS is needed, the agency has 90 days after finding the application complete to issue a notice of intent.","c":[300,6,300,9]},{"t":"Within 30 days after a complete application is submitted, it must issue any required cost-recovery agreement and grant, deny or defer the application.","c":[300,13,300,16]},{"t":"Deferral requires notice of remaining steps and agency timelines.","c":[301,12,301,14]}],[{"t":"Within 180 days, both departments must develop or adopt categorical exclusions for listed low-disturbance renewable activities, with extraordinary-circumstances exceptions.","c":[301,24,302,1]},{"t":"The list includes previously analyzed disturbances under 5 acres, certain repeat activities, small solar projects, surveys and meteorological towers.","c":[302,11,302,13]},{"t":"BLM must issue standard renewable review standards within 2 years.","c":[304,12,304,15]}]],"points":[{"t":"30-day completeness and decision clocks for renewable rights-of-way on public land","c":[299,11,299,14]},{"t":"Categorical exclusions for small solar, met towers and geotechnical work within 180 days","c":[301,22,301,24]},{"t":"Storage added to the definition of an eligible renewable project","c":[303,22,303,22]}],"quotes":[{"t":"The installation, modification, operation, or removal of commercially available solar photovoltaic systems located on— (i) a building or other structure (such as a rooftop, parking lot, or facility, or mounted to signage, lighting, gates, or fences); or (ii) previously disturbed or developed land comprising less than 10 acres.","why":"Small solar installations are to be excluded from NEPA review.","c":[303,4,303,12]}],"vs":{"current":"No statutory deadlines for renewable right-of-way applications; Interior's July 2025 policy sent wind and solar decisions to the Secretary's office for sign-off.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Carried over from EPRA 2024 (secs. 206 and 207): the right-of-way clocks, the low-disturbance exclusions, storage as an eligible project, and the BLM review standards. EPRA's national goal of at least 50 gigawatts of renewable energy authorized on federal land by 2030 is not in this bill."}},{"n":"2214","h":"Electric grid projects","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle B","suh":"Federal Onshore Energy Leasing and Permitting","p1":304,"l1":17,"p2":305,"words":202,"imp":1,"topics":["transmission","categorical-exclusions"],"plain":"Directs Interior and Agriculture to adopt, within 180 days, categorical exclusions for placing power lines in approved corridors. Another exclusion covers upgrades and reconductoring of existing lines in existing rights-of-way or on previously disturbed land. A third exclusion covers battery storage on previously disturbed land.","ps":[[{"t":"Directs Interior and Agriculture to adopt, within 180 days, categorical exclusions for placing power lines in approved corridors.","c":[304,23,305,1]},{"t":"Another exclusion covers upgrades and reconductoring of existing lines in existing rights-of-way or on previously disturbed land.","c":[305,14,305,19]},{"t":"A third exclusion covers battery storage on previously disturbed land.","c":[305,20,305,22]}]],"points":[{"t":"Categorical exclusions for grid work on federal land within 180 days","c":[304,23,305,1]}],"quotes":[{"t":"Construction, operation, upgrade, or decommissioning of a battery or other energy storage technology on previously disturbed or developed land.","why":"Battery storage on disturbed federal land gets a categorical exclusion.","c":[305,20,305,22]}],"vs":{"current":"Agencies have partial administrative exclusions; no statutory mandate.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Carried over from EPRA 2024 (sec. 209, electric grid projects)."}},{"n":"2215","h":"Hardrock mining mill sites","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle B","suh":"Federal Onshore Energy Leasing and Permitting","p1":306,"l1":1,"p2":318,"words":1795,"imp":2,"topics":["mining"],"plain":"Lets a hardrock mine operator locate as many mill sites on public land as are reasonably necessary for waste rock, tailings and other operations. Each mill site covers up to 5 acres and sits under an approved plan of operations. The operator pays a $400 annual fee per site. Mill sites convey no mineral rights and cannot be patented. Hardrock minerals on acquired federal lands become leasable. Mill site fees and those lease receipts go to a new Abandoned Hardrock Mine Fund for cleanup.","ps":[[{"t":"Lets a hardrock mine operator locate as many mill sites on public land as are reasonably necessary for waste rock, tailings and other operations.","c":[308,7,308,10]},{"t":"Each mill site covers up to 5 acres and sits under an approved plan of operations.","c":[308,16,308,18]},{"t":"The operator pays a $400 annual fee per site.","c":[311,9,311,13]},{"t":"Mill sites convey no mineral rights and cannot be patented.","c":[308,14,308,15]},{"t":"Hardrock minerals on acquired federal lands become leasable.","c":[314,17,314,19]},{"t":"Mill site fees and those lease receipts go to a new Abandoned Hardrock Mine Fund for cleanup.","c":[315,9,315,9]}]],"points":[{"t":"A mine operator may locate as many 5-acre mill sites as its plan of operations needs","c":[308,1,308,15]},{"t":"$400 per mill site per year, paid into an abandoned mine cleanup fund","c":[311,12,311,13]}],"quotes":[{"t":"locate and include within the plan of operations as many mill site claims under this subsection as are reasonably necessary for its operations","why":"An operator may locate as many mill sites as its operations need.","c":[308,7,308,10]}],"vs":{"current":"Mill sites are capped at 5 acres each on non-mineral land. The Ninth Circuit held in 2022 (the Rosemont case) that waste rock cannot be stored on claims that lack a valuable mineral deposit.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act; the House passed a separate Mining Regulatory Clarity Act.","epra":"Carried over from EPRA 2024 (sec. 210, hardrock mining mill sites), including the cleanup fund."},"takes":3},{"n":"2221","h":"Geothermal observation test projects","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle C","suh":"Geothermal Leasing and Permitting","p1":318,"l1":12,"p2":325,"words":970,"imp":1,"topics":["geothermal","categorical-exclusions"],"plain":"Requires a categorical exclusion within 1 year for geothermal observation test wells on existing leases that disturb no more than 10 acres, use no permanent roads, and finish within a year. Casual-use activities need only 30 days' notice and are not major federal actions.","ps":[[{"t":"Requires a categorical exclusion within 1 year for geothermal observation test wells on existing leases that disturb no more than 10 acres, use no permanent roads, and finish within a year.","c":[324,17,324,20]},{"t":"Casual-use activities need only 30 days' notice and are not major federal actions.","c":[325,14,325,17]}]],"points":[{"t":"Categorical exclusion for geothermal test wells up to 10 acres","c":[324,17,324,20]}],"quotes":[{"t":"the Secretary concerned shall develop a categorical exclusion for geothermal observation test projects","why":"The exclusion for geothermal test wells.","c":[324,18,324,20]}],"vs":{"current":"BLM adopted administrative geothermal exploration exclusions in 2024 and 2025; no statutory one.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"EPRA 2024 (sec. 208(a)) required a categorical exclusion for geothermal test activity under 10 acres within 180 days. This bill gives 1 year, defines the test projects in detail, and separately excludes them from NEPA as non-major actions (section 1102)."}},{"n":"2222","h":"Geothermal royalties","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle C","suh":"Geothermal Leasing and Permitting","p1":325,"l1":19,"p2":329,"words":490,"imp":1,"topics":["geothermal"],"plain":"Calculates the reduced early-years geothermal royalty per generating facility, starting from each facility's in-service date, so a second plant on an old lease gets its own 10-year lower-royalty period.","ps":[[{"t":"Calculates the reduced early-years geothermal royalty per generating facility, starting from each facility's in-service date, so a second plant on an old lease gets its own 10-year lower-royalty period.","c":[328,22,328,25]}]],"points":[{"t":"Royalty step-up clock runs per power plant, not per lease","c":[328,22,328,25]}],"quotes":[{"t":"each year of the 10-year period following the in-service date of the geothermal electric generating facility","why":"The lower royalty period runs from each plant's in-service date.","c":[328,22,328,25]}],"vs":{"current":"The lower royalty applies to the first 10 years of production under the lease.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024 as reported."}},{"n":"2223","h":"Geothermal leasing reform","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle C","suh":"Geothermal Leasing and Permitting","p1":329,"l1":11,"p2":332,"words":373,"imp":1,"topics":["geothermal"],"plain":"Requires geothermal lease sales every year instead of every 2 years, with a replacement sale in the same year if one is cancelled, and sets 30-day completeness and 30-day decision deadlines for geothermal drilling permits.","ps":[[{"t":"Requires geothermal lease sales every year instead of every 2 years, with a replacement sale in the same year if one is cancelled, and sets 30-day completeness and 30-day decision deadlines for geothermal drilling permits.","c":[329,18,329,21]}]],"points":[{"t":"Annual geothermal lease sales","c":[329,18,329,21]},{"t":"30-day drilling permit clocks","c":[330,3,330,5]}],"quotes":[{"t":"If a lease sale under paragraph (1) for a year is cancelled or delayed, the Secretary shall conduct a replacement sale during the same year.","why":"A cancelled lease sale must be replaced the same year.","c":[329,18,329,21]}],"vs":{"current":"Lease sales at least every 2 years; no permit deadlines.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Carried over from EPRA 2024 (sec. 208(b) and (c)), with the completeness check lengthened from 10 to 30 days and a hard 10-day deadline added for deferred decisions."}},{"n":"2224","h":"Geothermal ombudsman and permitting task force","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle C","suh":"Geothermal Leasing and Permitting","p1":332,"l1":3,"p2":338,"words":834,"imp":1,"topics":["geothermal"],"plain":"Creates a Geothermal Ombudsman and a Geothermal Permitting Task Force inside BLM within 60 days. The Ombudsman resolves disputes between field offices and applicants and may assign staff to help other offices complete geothermal authorizations. The Ombudsman may also pay retention allowances of up to 25 percent of basic pay.","ps":[[{"t":"Creates a Geothermal Ombudsman and a Geothermal Permitting Task Force inside BLM within 60 days.","c":[333,5,333,8]},{"t":"The Ombudsman resolves disputes between field offices and applicants and may assign staff to help other offices complete geothermal authorizations.","c":[334,22,334,24]},{"t":"The Ombudsman may also pay retention allowances of up to 25 percent of basic pay.","c":[336,20,336,22]}]],"points":[{"t":"BLM geothermal ombudsman and strike team","c":[333,5,333,8]}],"quotes":[{"t":"provide dispute resolution services for disputes between the individual field, district, and State offices of the Bureau and applicants for geothermal authorizations","why":"The ombudsman resolves disputes between BLM offices and applicants.","c":[333,18,333,21]}],"vs":{"current":"New.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"EPRA 2024 (sec. 208(g)) created the Geothermal Ombudsman. The task force, staff reassignments and retention allowances are new."}},{"n":"2225","h":"No Federal permit required for geothermal activities on certain land","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle C","suh":"Geothermal Leasing and Permitting","p1":338,"l1":12,"p2":341,"words":415,"imp":1,"topics":["geothermal"],"plain":"No federal drilling permit for geothermal exploration and production on non-federal surface where the United States owns less than 50 percent of the subsurface geothermal estate, if the operator files its state permit with Interior. Indian lands are excluded; royalties are unchanged.","ps":[[{"t":"No federal drilling permit for geothermal exploration and production on non-federal surface where the United States owns less than 50 percent of the subsurface geothermal estate, if the operator files its state permit with Interior.","c":[338,20,338,23]},{"t":"Indian lands are excluded; royalties are unchanged.","c":[340,1,340,2]}]],"points":[{"t":"State permits suffice for geothermal wells with a minority federal interest","c":[338,20,338,23]}],"quotes":[{"t":"The Secretary shall not require an operator to obtain a Federal drilling permit for geothermal exploration and production activities conducted on a non-Federal surface estate","why":"No federal drilling permit on non-federal surface with a minority federal interest.","c":[338,20,338,23]}],"vs":{"current":"A federal permit is required.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Parallel to EPRA 2024's oil and gas provision; the geothermal version is new."}},{"n":"2226","h":"Effect of pending civil actions on processing applications relating to geothermal leasing","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle C","suh":"Geothermal Leasing and Permitting","p1":341,"l1":3,"p2":342,"words":259,"imp":1,"topics":["geothermal","courts"],"plain":"Requires Interior to keep processing geothermal permits, sundry notices and rights-of-way under a valid lease despite pending litigation. Interior must decide within 60 days of completing legal requirements. The duty ends if a court has vacated or enjoined the lease or permit.","ps":[[{"t":"Requires Interior to keep processing geothermal permits, sundry notices and rights-of-way under a valid lease despite pending litigation.","c":[341,22,342,1]},{"t":"Interior must decide within 60 days of completing legal requirements.","c":[342,5,342,8]},{"t":"The duty ends if a court has vacated or enjoined the lease or permit.","c":[342,1,342,5]}]],"points":[{"t":"Litigation alone does not pause geothermal permitting","c":[341,22,341,24]}],"quotes":[{"t":"approve and issue, or deny, each such application not later than 60 days after completing all requirements under applicable Federal laws","why":"Applications are decided within 60 days even while a lawsuit is pending.","c":[342,5,342,8]}],"vs":{"current":"Agencies sometimes pause processing while suits are pending.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"2227","h":"Cost recovery from geothermal leasing, permitting, and inspections","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle C","suh":"Geothermal Leasing and Permitting","p1":342,"l1":19,"p2":346,"words":549,"imp":1,"topics":["geothermal"],"plain":"Lets Interior charge geothermal applicants and lessees for the cost of processing and inspections through September 30, 2033, with hardship reductions, and requires a report within 5 years.","ps":[[{"t":"Lets Interior charge geothermal applicants and lessees for the cost of processing and inspections through September 30, 2033, with hardship reductions, and requires a report within 5 years.","c":[343,1,343,5]}]],"points":[{"t":"Geothermal cost recovery through fiscal year 2033","c":[343,1,343,5]}],"quotes":[{"t":"the Secretary may require an applicant for, or holder of, a geothermal lease to reimburse the United States for all reasonable administrative and other costs","why":"Interior may charge applicants for processing costs.","c":[343,4,343,7]}],"vs":{"current":"New authority.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"EPRA 2024 (sec. 208(d)) told Interior to write cost recovery rules within 180 days. This bill grants the authority directly, with a 2033 sunset."}},{"n":"2228","h":"Publication of Gold Book for geothermal operations on Federal land","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle C","suh":"Geothermal Leasing and Permitting","p1":346,"l1":17,"p2":348,"words":352,"imp":1,"topics":["geothermal"],"plain":"Directs Interior to identify standard geothermal procedures within 1 year and then publish, within 270 days, an updated and renamed 'Gold Book' of surface operating standards that covers geothermal, reviewed every 5 years.","ps":[[{"t":"Directs Interior to identify standard geothermal procedures within 1 year and then publish, within 270 days, an updated and renamed 'Gold Book' of surface operating standards that covers geothermal, reviewed every 5 years.","c":[347,6,347,9]}]],"points":[{"t":"A geothermal edition of BLM's Gold Book","c":[347,6,347,9]}],"quotes":[{"t":"the Secretary of the Interior shall publish an updated version of the Gold Book","why":"Interior must publish an updated Gold Book that covers geothermal.","c":[347,8,347,9]}],"vs":{"current":"The Gold Book (2007) covers oil and gas only.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024 as reported."}},{"n":"2229","h":"NEPA Review","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle C","suh":"Geothermal Leasing and Permitting","p1":349,"l1":1,"p2":351,"words":390,"imp":3,"topics":["fossil","geothermal","nepa","categorical-exclusions"],"plain":"Rewrites section 390 of the Energy Policy Act of 2005. The oil and gas activities listed in section 390(b) of the Energy Policy Act of 2005 are declared not to be major federal actions at all, rather than categorical exclusions. Geothermal is added to two of them, and a new item covers geothermal power lines of up to 20 miles in a corridor approved within the past 10 years. One listed item's look-back goes from 5 to 10 years, and geothermal gets a new item for power lines up to 20 miles in a corridor approved within 10 years. Drilling permits for these activities carry no NEPA requirements.","ps":[[{"t":"Rewrites section 390 of the Energy Policy Act of 2005.","c":[349,2,349,3]},{"t":"The oil and gas activities listed in section 390(b) of the Energy Policy Act of 2005 are declared not to be major federal actions at all, rather than categorical exclusions.","c":[349,9,349,11]},{"t":"Geothermal is added to two of them, and a new item covers geothermal power lines of up to 20 miles in a corridor approved within the past 10 years.","c":[350,7,350,11]},{"t":"One listed item's look-back goes from 5 to 10 years, and geothermal gets a new item for power lines up to 20 miles in a corridor approved within 10 years.","c":[350,1,350,2]},{"t":"Drilling permits for these activities carry no NEPA requirements.","c":[351,6,351,8]}]],"points":[{"t":"Section 390 oil, gas and now geothermal activities are outside NEPA entirely","c":[349,9,349,12]},{"t":"Drilling permits for those activities 'shall not have any requirements' under NEPA","c":[351,6,351,8]}],"quotes":[{"t":"shall not be considered a major Federal action under the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.) if the activity is conducted pursuant to the Mineral Leasing Act (30 U.S.C. 181 et seq.) or the Geothermal Steam Act of 1970 (30 U.S.C. 1001 et seq.) for the purpose of exploration or development of oil, gas, or geothermal resources.","why":"Routine oil, gas and geothermal activities are declared not to be major federal actions.","c":[349,9,349,16]}],"vs":{"current":"Section 390 creates a rebuttable presumption that a categorical exclusion applies to five oil and gas activities; extraordinary circumstances review has been contested.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"EPRA 2024 (sec. 208(f)) extended the section 390 categorical exclusions to geothermal. Declaring the activities not major federal actions, and stripping NEPA from the drilling permits, goes further and applies to oil and gas as well."}},{"n":"2231","h":"Identifying and removing market barriers to hydropower","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle D","suh":"Hydropower","p1":351,"l1":10,"p2":354,"words":338,"imp":1,"topics":["hydropower"],"plain":"FERC, with the Energy Department, reports to Congress within 270 days on market barriers to hydropower and pumped storage. The report also covers how to pay hydropower for the grid services it provides. FERC prepares the report after a technical conference and public comment.","ps":[[{"t":"FERC, with the Energy Department, reports to Congress within 270 days on market barriers to hydropower and pumped storage.","c":[351,17,351,21]},{"t":"The report also covers how to pay hydropower for the grid services it provides.","c":[352,23,353,2]},{"t":"FERC prepares the report after a technical conference and public comment.","c":[354,1,354,4]}]],"points":[{"t":"FERC report on hydropower market barriers","c":[351,17,351,21]}],"quotes":[{"t":"properly compensate conventional, storage, conduit, and emerging hydropower technologies for the full range of services provided to the electric grid","why":"The report must address how hydropower is paid for grid services.","c":[352,23,353,2]}],"vs":{"current":"New.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Carried over from EPRA 2024 (sec. 702). EPRA's hydropower license extensions (sec. 701) and its rule aligning licensing timetables (sec. 703) are not in this bill."}},{"n":"2232","h":"Certain conditions on issuance of licenses","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle D","suh":"Hydropower","p1":354,"l1":5,"p2":354,"words":32,"imp":2,"topics":["hydropower","tribal"],"plain":"Limits the mandatory conditions federal land agencies can attach to a hydropower license under Federal Power Act section 4(e) to those 'reasonably related to the effects of the project'.","ps":[[{"t":"Limits the mandatory conditions federal land agencies can attach to a hydropower license under Federal Power Act section 4(e) to those 'reasonably related to the effects of the project'.","c":[354,8,354,10]}]],"points":[{"t":"Mandatory license conditions must relate to project effects","c":[354,8,354,10]}],"quotes":[{"t":"by inserting “and are reasonably related to the effects of the project” after “of such reservation”.","why":"Mandatory license conditions must relate to the project's effects.","c":[354,8,354,10]}],"vs":{"current":"The department that manages a federal reservation, including Interior for Indian reservations, can impose any condition it deems necessary to protect the reservation and its use.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"2233","h":"Hydropower maintenance and temporary adjustments","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle D","suh":"Hydropower","p1":354,"l1":11,"p2":357,"words":616,"imp":1,"topics":["hydropower"],"plain":"Bars FERC from requiring license amendments for routine hydropower maintenance, repair or replacement, or for temporary operating variances caused by events outside the licensee's control. FERC must propose a rule within 90 days and finish within a further 180 days defining which alterations are substantial enough to need approval. Dam safety authority is preserved.","ps":[[{"t":"Bars FERC from requiring license amendments for routine hydropower maintenance, repair or replacement, or for temporary operating variances caused by events outside the licensee's control.","c":[355,8,355,11]},{"t":"FERC must propose a rule within 90 days and finish within a further 180 days defining which alterations are substantial enough to need approval.","c":[355,14,355,17]},{"t":"Dam safety authority is preserved.","c":[357,3,357,4]}]],"points":[{"t":"No FERC approval needed for routine hydropower maintenance","c":[355,8,355,11]}],"quotes":[{"t":"The Commission shall not require approval or an amendment to a project license for any routine maintenance, repair, or replacement of any portion of a project works","why":"Routine dam maintenance no longer needs FERC sign-off.","c":[355,8,355,11]}],"vs":{"current":"FERC reviews many post-licensing changes individually. It opened an inquiry in November 2025 (Docket RM26-3).","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"2234","h":"Micro hydrokinetic energy projects","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle D","suh":"Hydropower","p1":358,"l1":1,"p2":362,"words":687,"imp":1,"topics":["hydropower"],"plain":"Creates an expedited FERC license of 10 to 20 years for micro hydrokinetic projects of 5 megawatts or less. Qualifying projects are wave, tidal, current and free-flowing river turbines with no impoundment. FERC takes final action within 1 year of the application, with categorical exclusions for low-disturbance activities.","ps":[[{"t":"Creates an expedited FERC license of 10 to 20 years for micro hydrokinetic projects of 5 megawatts or less.","c":[358,21,358,23]},{"t":"Qualifying projects are wave, tidal, current and free-flowing river turbines with no impoundment.","c":[358,15,358,20]},{"t":"FERC takes final action within 1 year of the application, with categorical exclusions for low-disturbance activities.","c":[360,1,360,5]}]],"points":[{"t":"One-year licensing for hydrokinetic projects up to 5 MW","c":[358,21,358,23]}],"quotes":[{"t":"The Commission shall take final action on an application for a license under this section not later than 1 year after the date on which the application is filed","why":"A one-year license decision for small hydrokinetic projects.","c":[360,1,360,4]}],"vs":{"current":"Such projects use the general licensing or pilot project processes.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."}},{"n":"2241","h":"Federal Energy Regulatory Commission staffing","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle E","suh":"Hiring and Retention","p1":362,"l1":4,"p2":362,"words":56,"imp":1,"topics":["transmission"],"plain":"Widens FERC's special pay authority to economic and legal positions and strikes paragraph (6) of the same subsection.","ps":[[{"t":"Widens FERC's special pay authority to economic and legal positions and strikes paragraph (6) of the same subsection.","c":[362,14,362,16]}]],"points":[{"t":"FERC can use special pay rates for economists and lawyers","c":[362,14,362,16]}],"quotes":[{"t":"by striking “or mathematical” and inserting “mathematical, economic, or legal”","why":"Adds economists and lawyers to FERC's special hiring authority.","c":[362,14,362,16]}],"vs":{"current":"The authority covers scientific, technological, engineering and mathematical positions, and the FERC Chairman must consult the Office of Personnel Management when setting pay.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Carried over from EPRA 2024 (sec. 801)."}},{"n":"2242","h":"Northwest Power and Conservation Council","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle E","suh":"Hiring and Retention","p1":362,"l1":17,"p2":362,"words":40,"imp":1,"topics":["hydropower"],"plain":"Amends the cap on Bonneville's funding of the Northwest Power and Conservation Council, section 4(c)(10)(B) of the Northwest Power Act, by adding the words 'since the date of enactment' of this bill.","ps":[[{"t":"Amends the cap on Bonneville's funding of the Northwest Power and Conservation Council, section 4(c)(10)(B) of the Northwest Power Act, by adding the words 'since the date of enactment' of this bill.","c":[362,21,362,23]}]],"points":[{"t":"Technical change to the funding cap for the Northwest Power and Conservation Council","c":[362,21,362,23]}],"quotes":[{"t":"since the date of enactment of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026","why":"The words added to the Council's funding cap.","c":[362,21,362,23]}],"vs":{"current":"Bonneville may fund the Council up to 0.10 mill for each kilowatt-hour of firm power it forecasts selling that year.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Carried over from EPRA 2024 (sec. 803)."}},{"n":"2243","h":"Federal Energy Regulatory Commission personnel safety","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle E","suh":"Hiring and Retention","p1":363,"l1":1,"p2":363,"words":49,"imp":1,"topics":["transmission"],"plain":"Lets FERC authorize its employees to perform law enforcement duties to protect the Chairman and Commissioners.","ps":[[{"t":"Lets FERC authorize its employees to perform law enforcement duties to protect the Chairman and Commissioners.","c":[363,3,363,6]}]],"points":[{"t":"Protective detail authority for FERC commissioners","c":[363,3,363,6]}],"quotes":[{"t":"to perform law enforcement duties as needed to ensure the safety of the Chairman and Commissioners of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission","why":"Security for FERC commissioners.","c":[363,5,363,7]}],"vs":{"current":"New.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Carried over from EPRA 2024 (sec. 804)."}},{"n":"2251","h":"Offshore energy","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle F","suh":"Offshore Energy","p1":363,"l1":11,"p2":364,"words":246,"imp":2,"topics":["offshore","wind-solar"],"plain":"Amends the offshore renewable energy section of the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act. Interior's duty changes from 'prevention of interference with reasonable uses' of the ocean to 'prevention of unreasonable interference with other uses'. Interior, in consultation with the Secretary of Commerce, may grant rights-of-way for electric transmission through national marine sanctuaries, with sanctuary permits lasting as long as the right-of-way. The Inflation Reduction Act's link between offshore wind leasing and oil and gas lease sales is preserved.","ps":[[{"t":"Amends the offshore renewable energy section of the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act.","c":[363,12,363,14]},{"t":"Interior's duty changes from 'prevention of interference with reasonable uses' of the ocean to 'prevention of unreasonable interference with other uses'.","c":[363,15,363,18]},{"t":"Interior, in consultation with the Secretary of Commerce, may grant rights-of-way for electric transmission through national marine sanctuaries, with sanctuary permits lasting as long as the right-of-way.","c":[364,4,364,6]},{"t":"The Inflation Reduction Act's link between offshore wind leasing and oil and gas lease sales is preserved.","c":[364,22,364,24]}]],"points":[{"t":"Offshore wind standard changes to 'unreasonable interference'","c":[363,16,363,18]},{"t":"Transmission cables allowed through marine sanctuaries","c":[364,7,364,10]}],"quotes":[{"t":"by striking “prevention of interference with reasonable uses” and inserting “prevention of unreasonable interference with other uses”","why":"The offshore wind test becomes 'unreasonable interference' with other uses.","c":[363,15,363,18]}],"vs":{"current":"Section 8(p)(4)(I) requires prevention of interference with reasonable uses of the exclusive economic zone, the high seas and the territorial seas.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"The three Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act amendments come from EPRA 2024 (sec. 302(d)), with one change: sanctuary rights-of-way are no longer limited to electricity from renewable energy. EPRA's mandates do not appear here: one offshore oil and gas lease sale and one offshore wind lease sale a year from 2025 to 2029, 400,000 acres of wind leasing a year, and a 30-gigawatt offshore wind goal."}},{"n":"2252","h":"Offshore energy transmission","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE II","tih":"ENERGY PERMITTING","su":"Subtitle F","suh":"Offshore Energy","p1":365,"l1":1,"p2":371,"words":907,"imp":1,"topics":["offshore","transmission"],"plain":"Directs Interior and Energy to identify preferred routes for offshore transmission cables within 2 years and review them every 3 years. Interior is the lead agency for offshore transmission permitting, and a final rule is required within 2 years. Offshore transmission rights-of-way may be issued competitively or noncompetitively by Interior.","ps":[[{"t":"Directs Interior and Energy to identify preferred routes for offshore transmission cables within 2 years and review them every 3 years.","c":[367,15,367,17]},{"t":"Interior is the lead agency for offshore transmission permitting, and a final rule is required within 2 years.","c":[369,8,369,11]},{"t":"Offshore transmission rights-of-way may be issued competitively or noncompetitively by Interior.","c":[370,8,370,10]}]],"points":[{"t":"Planned offshore transmission routes within 2 years","c":[367,15,368,13]},{"t":"Interior is lead agency; rights-of-way can be noncompetitive","c":[369,8,369,10]}],"quotes":[{"t":"shall identify preferred routes on the outer Continental Shelf for transmission cables and sub-seabed infrastructure","why":"Interior and Energy must identify preferred offshore cable routes.","c":[367,22,367,24]}],"vs":{"current":"Each offshore transmission line is permitted on its own.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024, which made offshore lines eligible for FERC backstop siting and cost allocation (kept in section 2101)."}},{"n":"2301","h":"Historic preservation","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE III","tih":"HISTORIC PRESERVATION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":372,"l1":3,"p2":413,"words":5661,"imp":3,"topics":["historic-preservation","tribal","courts"],"plain":"Rewrites section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act. An 'adverse effect' must be reasonably foreseeable and must directly alter a historic property. Temporary alterations are excluded. Visual, atmospheric and audible effects are excluded unless they directly and significantly diminish the property. An 'undertaking' excludes projects whose only federal tie is a loan, guarantee or grant, the non-federal parts of a project, minor repairs, permit renewals and post-approval operations.\n\nThe process gets deadlines: 30 days to decide whether a project is an undertaking and 60 days for the agency's report. A determination or an agreement on the adverse effects follows within 90 days of the report. Advisory Council comments take 45 days, and the final decision takes 30 days. Consultation must be finished by the time the NEPA document is completed, unless the Secretary grants an extension for extraordinary circumstances. State and tribal preservation officers who do not respond in 30 days are passed over, and the agency may decide in its sole discretion that other considerations outweigh preservation.\n\nCourts give substantial deference and may only remand without vacatur or injunction; a preliminary injunction is available only for a likely violation of another law. Claims go to the courts of appeals, within 150 days, from parties who commented and suffered direct harm. A suit over a missed consultation deadline goes to a court where the project is located. Non-signatories cannot challenge programmatic agreements. State and tribal programs are evaluated every 2 years and lose grants if they miss consultation timelines.","ps":[[{"t":"Rewrites section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act.","c":[379,7,379,9]},{"t":"An 'adverse effect' must be reasonably foreseeable and must directly alter a historic property.","c":[380,5,380,9]},{"t":"Temporary alterations are excluded.","c":[380,19,380,21]},{"t":"Visual, atmospheric and audible effects are excluded unless they directly and significantly diminish the property.","c":[380,13,380,17]},{"t":"An 'undertaking' excludes projects whose only federal tie is a loan, guarantee or grant, the non-federal parts of a project, minor repairs, permit renewals and post-approval operations.","c":[383,22,383,24]}],[{"t":"The process gets deadlines: 30 days to decide whether a project is an undertaking and 60 days for the agency's report.","c":[386,8,386,11]},{"t":"A determination or an agreement on the adverse effects follows within 90 days of the report.","c":[392,4,392,6]},{"t":"Advisory Council comments take 45 days, and the final decision takes 30 days.","c":[394,19,394,25]},{"t":"Consultation must be finished by the time the NEPA document is completed, unless the Secretary grants an extension for extraordinary circumstances.","c":[398,3,398,6]},{"t":"State and tribal preservation officers who do not respond in 30 days are passed over, and the agency may decide in its sole discretion that other considerations outweigh preservation.","c":[400,19,400,21]}],[{"t":"Courts give substantial deference and may only remand without vacatur or injunction; a preliminary injunction is available only for a likely violation of another law.","c":[406,25,407,2]},{"t":"Claims go to the courts of appeals, within 150 days, from parties who commented and suffered direct harm.","c":[411,20,411,23]},{"t":"A suit over a missed consultation deadline goes to a court where the project is located.","c":[399,12,399,16]},{"t":"Non-signatories cannot challenge programmatic agreements.","c":[412,24,413,2]},{"t":"State and tribal programs are evaluated every 2 years and lose grants if they miss consultation timelines.","c":[373,18,373,22]}]],"points":[{"t":"Adverse effect limited to direct physical alteration; visual and noise effects mostly excluded","c":[380,5,380,7]},{"t":"Loans and grants alone no longer trigger section 106","c":[383,22,383,24]},{"t":"End-to-end deadlines; silence from a preservation officer after 30 days lets the agency proceed","c":[400,19,400,21]},{"t":"Agency may find other considerations outweigh preservation 'in the sole discretion' of the official","c":[391,13,391,17]},{"t":"150-day limit, court of appeals jurisdiction, remand without vacatur","c":[408,23,408,25]},{"t":"Later National Register listings do not reopen a review","c":[413,14,413,17]}],"quotes":[{"t":"any visual, atmospheric, or audible element, unless the visual, atmospheric, or audible element would have a direct impact on a historic property that would significantly diminish the eligible characteristics of the historic property","why":"Visual, atmospheric and audible effects mostly no longer count as adverse.","c":[380,13,380,18]},{"t":"in the sole discretion of the Federal official and as otherwise allowed by law, other considerations outweigh the consideration of historic preservation as to any or all adverse effects of the undertaking","why":"The agency may decide that other considerations outweigh preservation.","c":[393,4,393,9]},{"t":"the only remedy the court may order is to remand, without vacatur or issuance of an injunction, the applicable agency action to the Federal agency","why":"Remand is the only remedy, as in the NEPA title.","c":[406,25,407,3]}],"vs":{"current":"Section 106 is one sentence requiring agencies to 'take into account' effects on historic properties; the process lives in Advisory Council regulations (36 CFR part 800) with no statutory deadlines, a broad definition of adverse effect that includes visual and audible intrusions, and ordinary APA review.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024. This is the first major permitting bill to rewrite section 106."},"takes":36},{"n":"2302","h":"Funding for the Historic Preservation Fund; use and availability; grants for Tribal Historic Preservation officers; additional funding","div":"DIVISION B","divh":"COMMITTEE ON ENERGY AND NATURAL RESOURCES","ti":"TITLE III","tih":"HISTORIC PRESERVATION","su":null,"suh":null,"p1":414,"l1":1,"p2":417,"words":474,"imp":2,"topics":["historic-preservation","tribal"],"plain":"Authorizes $200 million a year for deposit in the Historic Preservation Fund for fiscal years 2027 through 2036. Deposits become available the next fiscal year without a further appropriation. Creates a $20 million-a-year grant program (fiscal years 2027 through 2030) for tribal historic preservation officers. The grants build online databases of records and of properties of traditional religious or cultural importance. Protections against disclosing sensitive site locations are included.","ps":[[{"t":"Authorizes $200 million a year for deposit in the Historic Preservation Fund for fiscal years 2027 through 2036.","c":[414,10,414,11]},{"t":"Deposits become available the next fiscal year without a further appropriation.","c":[414,17,414,19]},{"t":"Creates a $20 million-a-year grant program (fiscal years 2027 through 2030) for tribal historic preservation officers.","c":[417,1,417,2]},{"t":"The grants build online databases of records and of properties of traditional religious or cultural importance.","c":[415,8,415,11]},{"t":"Protections against disclosing sensitive site locations are included.","c":[416,3,416,6]}]],"points":[{"t":"$200 million a year for the Historic Preservation Fund through 2036","c":[414,10,414,11]},{"t":"$20 million a year for tribal preservation databases","c":[417,1,417,2]}],"quotes":[{"t":"There is authorized to be appropriated for deposit in the Historic Preservation Fund $200,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2027 through 2036.","why":"$200 million a year for the Historic Preservation Fund.","c":[414,9,414,11]}],"vs":{"current":"The fund was authorized at $150 million a year through fiscal year 2023 and has been awaiting reauthorization.","speed":"Not in the SPEED Act.","epra":"Not in EPRA 2024."},"takes":8}],"overview":{"summary":{"text":"This bipartisan Senate bill would change federal permitting for energy and infrastructure projects and set what data centers pay for transmission service.","source":{"label":"Senate EPW Committee","url":"https://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2026/9/capito-lee-whitehouse-and-heinrich-introduce-bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act-of-2026"}},"status":{"points":[{"text":"On November 16 the Senate agreed, 70 to 27, to end debate on the sponsors' substitute, SA 6883. Sixty votes were needed. Adopting the substitute and passing the bill are later votes.","source":{"label":"Senate roll call vote 264","url":"https://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_votes/vote1192/vote_119_2_00264.htm"}},{"text":"On November 17 the four sponsors filed a managers' amendment to the substitute, SA 7022. It adds landowner protections for transmission permits, makes federal permits public and raises the Historic Preservation Fund to $300 million a year. Senators had filed 172 amendments to the substitute or the bill by then.","source":{"label":"Congressional Record, November 17","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CREC-2026-11-17/html/CREC-2026-11-17-pt1-PgS5725-4.htm"}},{"text":"The Senate agreed on November 9, 73 to 25, to end debate on taking up H.R. 2347, the vehicle for the permitting bill. Voting no were 23 Democrats, Republican Mike Rounds and independent Bernie Sanders.","source":{"label":"Senate roll call vote 257","url":"https://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_votes/vote1192/vote_119_2_00257.htm"}},{"text":"On November 10 the Senate agreed to take up the bill, 62 to 21, with 17 senators not voting. Neither vote was on passage.","source":{"label":"Senate roll call vote 258","url":"https://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_votes/vote1192/vote_119_2_00258.htm"}},{"text":"Majority Leader John Thune then offered the sponsors' substitute as amendment SA 6883. On November 11 he filed motions to end debate on it and on H.R. 2347.","source":{"label":"U.S. Senate Press Gallery, Nov. 11","url":"https://www.dailypress.senate.gov/wednesday-november-11-2026/"}},{"text":"The White House's Statement of Administration Policy, dated November 9, says the administration strongly supports passage of S. 5653.","source":{"label":"Office of Management and Budget","url":"https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/SAP-S5653.pdf"}},{"text":"Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer voted on November 9 to end debate and said he will seek changes to parts of the bill through amendments.","source":{"label":"Senate Democrats","url":"https://www.democrats.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/leader-schumer-statement-after-permitting-reform-bill-advances-in-the-senate"}},{"text":"The four sponsors released their substitute on November 7. It edits 43 sections of the September 30 text, adds 13 and drops one.","source":{"label":"Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee","url":"https://www.energy.senate.gov/press/rep/lee-capito-heinrich-and-whitehouse-release-substitute-amendment-to-bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act-of-2026/"}},{"text":"A spokesman for House Democratic Leader Hakeem Jeffries said November 5 that he will not rubber-stamp the Senate bill without more involvement from his caucus.","source":{"label":"Punchbowl News","url":"https://punchbowl.news/article/energy/trump-jeffries-senate-on-permitting/"}},{"text":"A White House official said November 6 that the Defense Department was advancing nine more wind projects held at the Pentagon.","source":{"label":"Punchbowl News","url":"https://punchbowl.news/article/energy/trump-jeffries-senate-on-permitting/"}},{"text":"Heatmap reported that President Trump urged all senators on November 8 to vote for the bill.","source":{"label":"Heatmap","url":"https://heatmap.news/am/baaja-senate-vote"}},{"text":"Sponsors: Shelley Moore Capito (R-W.Va.) and Sheldon Whitehouse (D-R.I.) of Environment and Public Works; Mike Lee (R-Utah) and Martin Heinrich (D-N.M.) of Energy and Natural Resources.","source":{"label":"Senate EPW Committee","url":"https://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2026/9/capito-lee-whitehouse-and-heinrich-introduce-bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act-of-2026"}},{"text":"On October 27, Duckworth, Wyden, Merkley and Markey asked for canceled clean energy grants to be restored before the Senate decides whether to end debate on taking up the permitting bill. The four did not say which way they would vote on that motion.","source":{"label":"Letter to the four bill sponsors","url":"https://www.duckworth.senate.gov/news/press-releases/duckworth-colleagues-to-committee-leadership-trump-must-begin-restoring-illegally-cancelled-energy-projects-before-critical-vote-on-bipartisan-permitting-reform-bill"}},{"text":"Capito told WV MetroNews on October 11 that the White House has made concessions on wind and solar projects. She said Senate leaders promised to take up permitting reform first after the election.","source":{"label":"WV MetroNews","url":"https://wvmetronews.com/2026/10/11/capito-says-permitting-bill-would-blast-away-delays-and-protect-approved-projects/"}},{"text":"The Senate EPW majority's October 7 roundup lists statements of support from the U.S. Chamber, Business Roundtable, American Clean Power, API, LIUNA and the National Governors Association.","source":{"label":"Senate EPW Committee","url":"https://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2026/10/what-they-re-saying-bipartisan-permitting-reform-will-deliver-cheaper-energy-more-jobs-responsible-growth"}},{"text":"A coalition of 185 community, labor, climate and environmental justice groups asked congressional leaders on October 13 to oppose the bill.","source":{"label":"Center for Biological Diversity","url":"https://biologicaldiversity.org/w/news/press-releases/185-groups-slam-permitting-bills-sweetheart-deal-for-data-centers-2026-10-13/"}},{"text":"NPR reported on October 15 that Tribal groups sent Senate leaders a letter the week before. Preservation advocates quoted in the report call the bill's Section 106 changes the most serious threat to the law in its 60-year history.","source":{"label":"NPR","url":"https://www.npr.org/2026/10/15/nx-s1-6001504/section-106-historic-preservation-act-threats-anniversary"}},{"text":"The Defense Department advanced two onshore wind projects on October 22, which a White House official tied to the bill's passage; Whitehouse called it a start and asked for more on wind and solar.","source":{"label":"Joshua Siegel, Punchbowl News (X)","url":"https://x.com/SiegelScribe/status/2113279782419128579"}},{"text":"House Speaker Mike Johnson said on October 23 that he supports the Senate bill.","source":{"label":"Joshua Siegel, Punchbowl News (X)","url":"https://x.com/SiegelScribe/status/2113682338181779731"}},{"text":"More opponents declared in the week of October 20: the All Pueblo Council of Governors, 13 preservation groups and nine Democratic attorneys general. More than 100 public lands groups, the People's Environmental Justice Caucus and Rep. Leger Fernández joined them.","source":{"label":"POLITICO (X)","url":"https://x.com/NicoPortuondo/status/2112571938484957230"}},{"text":"Support letters the same week came from 19 former economic and national security officials, the five main clean energy trade groups, and API with 137 other organizations.","source":{"label":"Institute for Progress","url":"https://ifp.org/wp-content/uploads/econ-policy-national-security-officials-endorse-baaja.pdf"}},{"text":"Senate Majority Leader Thune filed cloture on November 11 on both the substitute, SA 6883, and the bill, H.R. 2347.","source":{"label":"Senate floor log, November 11","url":"https://www.dailypress.senate.gov/wednesday-november-11-2026/"}},{"text":"Under Senate rules, cloture allows up to 30 more hours on the substitute before the vote to adopt it; the cloture motion on the bill is then pending, and invoking it would lead to a vote on passage.","source":{"label":"Congressional Research Service, Filibusters and Cloture in the Senate","url":"https://www.everycrsreport.com/reports/RL30360.html"}}]},"next":{"date":"2026-11-18","text":"Votes from 11:45 a.m. on adopting the substitute and on ending debate on the bill. Neither is the vote on passage.","source":{"label":"Senate floor schedule","url":"https://www.dailypress.senate.gov/tuesday-november-17-2026/"}},"headlines":[{"id":"deadlines","title":"Review deadlines","text":"Sets 2-year EIS and 1-year assessment deadlines, followed by deadlines for agency decisions. Extensions and enforcement conditions apply; the travel sanction limits official trips beyond 25 miles after a qualifying deadline is 60 days overdue.","sections":["1106","1109"],"ts":[{"t":"Sets 2-year EIS and 1-year assessment deadlines, followed by deadlines for agency decisions.","c":[46,15,46,18],"n":"1106"},{"t":"Extensions and enforcement conditions apply; the travel sanction limits official trips beyond 25 miles after a qualifying deadline is 60 days overdue.","c":[54,17,54,20],"n":"1106"}]},{"id":"lawsuits","title":"Court challenges","reviewed_as":"Lawsuit limits","text":"Generally allows 150 days for NEPA challenges in a court of appeals, with direct-harm and conditional comment requirements. Limits remedies to remand, with a fix due within 180 days; preliminary injunctions remain available under specified conditions involving other law.","sections":["1110","2201"],"ts":[{"t":"Generally allows 150 days for NEPA challenges in a court of appeals, with direct-harm and conditional comment requirements.","c":[67,24,68,2],"n":"1110"},{"t":"Limits remedies to remand, with a fix due within 180 days; preliminary injunctions remain available under specified conditions involving other law.","c":[69,24,70,1],"n":"1110"}]},{"id":"certainty","title":"Issued permits","reviewed_as":"Permit certainty","text":"Restricts interference with permits in effect on or after September 16, 2026, subject to listed exceptions including the holder’s request. If the agency fails to meet its burden in court, the sponsor is entitled to specified relief, including a court-determined 25 to 50 percent of incurred project costs not otherwise recovered.","sections":["1401","1402"],"ts":[{"t":"Restricts interference with permits in effect on or after September 16, 2026, subject to listed exceptions including the holder’s request.","c":[159,12,159,15],"n":"1401"},{"t":"If the agency fails to meet its burden in court, the sponsor is entitled to specified relief, including a court-determined 25 to 50 percent of incurred project costs not otherwise recovered.","c":[164,3,164,6],"n":"1401"}]},{"id":"datacenters","title":"Data center costs","text":"Newly connected data-center loads of 20 megawatts or more must cover their incremental electricity costs. Previously approved service arrangements remain in effect. The bill recognizes state authority to require new generation.","sections":["2107","2114"],"ts":[{"t":"Newly connected data-center loads of 20 megawatts or more must cover their incremental electricity costs.","c":[235,12,235,13],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Previously approved service arrangements remain in effect.","c":[240,5,240,8],"n":"2107"},{"t":"The bill recognizes state authority to require new generation.","c":[237,14,237,17],"n":"2107"}]},{"id":"transmission","title":"Transmission siting","text":"FERC can permit interstate lines of 230 kilovolts and up that states have not approved, after making required findings, and planning regions must plan lines with their neighbors.","sections":["2101","2103"],"ts":[{"t":"FERC can permit interstate lines of 230 kilovolts and up that states have not approved, after making required findings, and planning regions must plan lines with their neighbors.","c":[189,17,189,19],"n":"2101"}]},{"id":"exemptions","title":"Actions outside NEPA","text":"Excludes specified loan-only actions, qualifying work in existing grid and pipeline corridors, and listed oil, gas and geothermal activities from NEPA. Each exclusion has its own scope and conditions.","sections":["1102","2102","2229"],"ts":[{"t":"Excludes specified loan-only actions, qualifying work in existing grid and pipeline corridors, and listed oil, gas and geothermal activities from NEPA.","c":[204,17,204,21],"n":"2102"},{"t":"Each exclusion has its own scope and conditions.","c":[204,19,204,21],"n":"2102"}]},{"id":"water","title":"Clean Water Act","text":"Narrows state water-quality certification review and generally limits it to one year; extensions require written agreement. Extends nationwide permits to 10 years.","sections":["1202","1204"],"ts":[{"t":"Narrows state water-quality certification review and generally limits it to one year; extensions require written agreement.","c":[114,20,114,22],"n":"1202"},{"t":"Extends nationwide permits to 10 years.","c":[125,2,125,3],"n":"1204"}]},{"id":"species","title":"Endangered Species Act","text":"Cuts the standard formal consultation period from 90 days to 60, with extension rules. Lets approved state programs assume specified consultation responsibilities; applicants can opt for federal consultation.","sections":["1302","1304"],"ts":[{"t":"Cuts the standard formal consultation period from 90 days to 60, with extension rules.","c":[134,16,134,17],"n":"1302"},{"t":"Lets approved state programs assume specified consultation responsibilities; applicants can opt for federal consultation.","c":[148,7,148,10],"n":"1304"}]},{"id":"historic","title":"Historic preservation and tribal consultation","reviewed_as":"Historic preservation","text":"Narrows the effects covered by historic-preservation review and sets deadlines. Adds a 150-day challenge window and limits remedies, with separate rules for missed deadlines.","sections":["2301","2302"],"ts":[{"t":"Narrows the effects covered by historic-preservation review and sets deadlines.","c":[380,13,380,16],"n":"2301"},{"t":"Adds a 150-day challenge window and limits remedies, with separate rules for missed deadlines.","c":[408,23,408,25],"n":"2301"}]},{"id":"digital","title":"Digital permitting","text":"Requires a public tracker of defined transparency projects, and targets December 1, 2028 for an interagency ePermit system, to the maximum extent practicable.","sections":["1121","1132"],"ts":[{"t":"Requires a public tracker of defined transparency projects, and targets December 1, 2028 for an interagency ePermit system, to the maximum extent practicable.","c":[98,1,98,3],"n":"1132"}]}],"clocks":[{"clock":"2 years","what":"Environmental impact statement","section":"1106","quote":"not later than the date that is 2 years after the earlier of","c":[48,19,48,20]},{"clock":"1 year","what":"Environmental assessment","section":"1106","quote":"is 1 year after the earlier of","c":[46,18,46,18]},{"clock":"60 + 60 days","what":"Application judged complete, then level of review chosen","section":"1109","quote":"not later than 60 days after the date on which the project sponsor submits the application","c":[64,22,64,23]},{"clock":"45 days","what":"Record of decision after the impact statement","section":"1106","quote":"later than 45 days after the date on which the lead agency publishes an environmental impact statement","c":[49,9,49,11]},{"clock":"90 days","what":"Decisions on outstanding federal authorizations after the EIS or assessment; extensions may apply","section":"1106","quote":"later than 90 days after the date on which the lead agency publishes an environmental impact statement","c":[49,17,49,20]},{"clock":"150 days","what":"Window to file a NEPA lawsuit","section":"1110","quote":"is filed not later than 150 days after the date on which","c":[68,1,68,2]},{"clock":"180 days","what":"Agency fix after a court remand","section":"1110","quote":"which shall not exceed 180 days after the date on which the order of the court was entered","c":[70,8,70,10]},{"clock":"60 days","what":"Endangered Species Act formal consultation","section":"1302","quote":"by striking “90-day” and inserting “60-day”","c":[134,16,134,17]},{"clock":"1 year","what":"State water quality certification (9 months for interstate pipelines and power lines)","section":"1202","quote":"not to exceed 1 year from the date of receipt of the certification application","c":[114,21,114,22]},{"clock":"1 year","what":"Energy permits that need no environmental document","section":"1402","quote":"not later than 1 year after the date on which the latest of the covered applications is determined to be complete","c":[173,6,173,8]},{"clock":"180 days","what":"Agencies rewrite their NEPA procedures","section":"1103","quote":"Not later than 180 days after the date of enactment of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026, each agency of the Federal Government shall make any changes","c":[25,17,25,20]},{"clock":"December 1, 2028","what":"ePermit interagency data system, to the maximum extent practicable","section":"1121","quote":"not later than December 1, 2028, the Chairman shall develop and implement the ePermit unified interagency data system","c":[92,19,92,21]}],"money":[{"amount":"$200 million a year","what":"Historic Preservation Fund","years":"2027 to 2036","section":"2302","quote":"$200,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2027 through 2036","c":[414,10,414,11]},{"amount":"$150 million a year","what":"Endangered Species Act consultation and state programs","years":"2027 to 2031","section":"1307","quote":"There is authorized to be appropriated $150,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2027 through 2031","c":[155,19,155,20]},{"amount":"$50 million a year","what":"Coastal State Fund at the National Fish and Wildlife Foundation","years":"2028 to 2032","section":"1308","quote":"There is authorized to be appropriated to carry out the program $50,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2028 through 2032","c":[158,11,158,13]},{"amount":"$20 million a year","what":"Permitting Improvement Fund for agency staff","years":"2027 to 2033","section":"1133","quote":"There is authorized to be appropriated to the Fund $20,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2027 through 2033","c":[102,14,102,16]},{"amount":"$20 million a year","what":"Tribal historic preservation databases","years":"2027 to 2030","section":"2302","quote":"$20,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2027 through 2030","c":[417,1,417,2]},{"amount":"$20 million a year","what":"Local permitting for rooftop solar, batteries and chargers","years":"2026 to 2031","section":"2108","quote":"$20,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2026 through 2031","c":[259,22,259,23]},{"amount":"$5 million a year","what":"CEQ's NEPA work","years":"every year","section":"1121","quote":"There is authorized to be appropriated to carry out this Act $5,000,000 for each fiscal year","c":[96,2,96,3]}],"money_note":"These are authorizations. Congress would still have to appropriate the money."},"compare":{"generated":"2026-10-01","versions":[{"key":"current","label":"Current law","sub":"Baseline as of October 1, 2026."},{"key":"epra","label":"EPRA 2024","sub":"S. 4753 (Manchin, Barrasso). Reported July 31, 2024. The full Senate never voted on passage.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm"},{"key":"speed","label":"SPEED Act","sub":"H.R. 4776 (Westerman, Golden). Passed the House 221-196 on December 18, 2025.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm"},{"key":"senate","label":"BAAJA","sub":"Released September 30, 2026.","url":"https://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2026/9/capito-lee-whitehouse-and-heinrich-introduce-bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act-of-2026"}],"groups":[{"id":"nepa","label":"Environmental review","rows":[{"id":"purpose","topic":"Purpose statement","current":{"text":"States purposes only.","cite":"42 U.S.C. 4321","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4321"},"epra":{"text":"No change."},"speed":{"text":"Adds that NEPA is 'a purely procedural statute' that 'does not mandate particular results'.","cite":"Sec. 2(a)","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},"senate":{"text":"Adds that NEPA prescribes a procedure that ends in an informational document, and that nothing in it mandates a particular outcome.","sections":["1101"],"ts":[{"t":"Adds that NEPA prescribes a procedure that ends in an informational document, and that nothing in it mandates a particular outcome.","c":[5,14,5,16],"n":"1101"}]}},{"id":"mfa","topic":"Actions outside NEPA","current":{"text":"Seven exclusions since 2023, including projects with minimal federal funding and loans where the agency lacks sufficient control.","cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336e(10)","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336e"},"epra":{"text":"No general change. FERC approval of a joint interregional transmission plan, and its orders resolving planning disputes, are declared not to be major federal actions; a FERC permit for a project selected in such a plan still is one.","cite":"Sec. 402","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20402.%20TRANSMISSION%20PLANNING"},"speed":{"text":"Adds grants and cost-share awards, Farm Service Agency loans, and actions another agency already reviewed. Federal money alone cannot make an action major.","cite":"Sec. 2(f)","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},"senate":{"text":"Fourteen exclusions. Adds loan-only projects, routine actions up to $10 million, lifeline infrastructure repair, geothermal test wells, in-corridor grid and gas pipeline work, previously reviewed actions, and Corps projects up to a $50 million federal share.","sections":["1102","2102"],"ts":[{"t":"Fourteen exclusions.","c":[20,13,20,14],"n":"1102"},{"t":"Adds loan-only projects, routine actions up to $10 million, lifeline infrastructure repair, geothermal test wells, in-corridor grid and gas pipeline work, previously reviewed actions, and Corps projects up to a $50 million federal share.","c":[21,1,21,3],"n":"1102"}]}},{"id":"scope","topic":"Effects an agency must study","current":{"text":"'Reasonably foreseeable' effects. The Supreme Court held in 2025 that agencies need not study separate upstream or downstream projects.","cite":"42 U.S.C. 4332(2)(C); Seven County v. Eagle County","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4332"},"epra":{"text":"No change."},"speed":{"text":"Only effects proximately caused by the project itself. Speculative effects and effects of separate projects are excluded.","cite":"Sec. 2(b), 2(f)","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},"senate":{"text":"No statutory limit on scope. Courts must give agencies substantial deference on the scope and contents of the document.","sections":["1110"],"ts":[{"t":"No statutory limit on scope.","absent":true},{"t":"Courts must give agencies substantial deference on the scope and contents of the document.","c":[73,25,74,2],"n":"1110"}]}},{"id":"skip","topic":"Reviews short of a full statement","reviewed_as":"Ways to skip a full review","current":{"text":"An agency's own categorical exclusions, or another agency's after consultation and public notice.","cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336(a), 4336c","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336"},"epra":{"text":"Orders new categorical exclusions for renewable, geothermal and grid work on federal land.","cite":"Secs. 206, 208, 209","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20206.%20ACCELERATING%20RENEWABLE%20ENERGY%20PERMITTING"},"speed":{"text":"Adds exclusions enacted by Congress. Another statute or a state or tribal review can stand in for NEPA. A lead agency's finding that no document is needed binds other agencies.","cite":"Sec. 2(b), 2(e)","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},"senate":{"text":"Same substitutes and the same binding rule, plus combining several exclusions on one project and a public CEQ register of every exclusion.","sections":["1105","1108"],"ts":[{"t":"Same substitutes and the same binding rule, plus combining several exclusions on one project and a public CEQ register of every exclusion.","c":[63,6,63,9],"n":"1108"}]}},{"id":"deadlines","topic":"Review deadlines","current":{"text":"EIS in 2 years and EA in 1 year, counted from the earliest of the agency's determination, a complete application, or the notice of intent. Page limits of 150 and 75.","cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336a(e), (g)","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336a"},"epra":{"text":"No change."},"speed":{"text":"Keeps the 2023 deadlines. Adds 60 days to judge an application complete and 60 days to pick the level of review.","cite":"Sec. 2(c)","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},"senate":{"text":"Same 2-year and 1-year deadlines, counted from the earlier of the agency's determination or a complete application. Same two 60-day front-end clocks.","sections":["1106","1109"],"ts":[{"t":"Same 2-year and 1-year deadlines, counted from the earlier of the agency's determination or a complete application.","c":[48,17,48,21],"n":"1106"},{"t":"Same two 60-day front-end clocks.","c":[64,22,64,24],"n":"1109"}]}},{"id":"after","topic":"Decisions after the review","current":{"text":"No general deadline for the record of decision or for other agencies' permits."},"epra":{"text":"Project-specific clocks, such as 30 days to decide a renewable right-of-way once reviews are done.","cite":"Sec. 206","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20206.%20ACCELERATING%20RENEWABLE%20ENERGY%20PERMITTING"},"speed":{"text":"Final agency action within 30 days of the finished EIS or EA.","cite":"Sec. 2(c)","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},"senate":{"text":"Finding of no significant impact within 7 days of an EA. Record of decision within 45 days of an EIS. All federal permits within 90 days, or 120 days for agencies outside the review.","sections":["1106"],"ts":[{"t":"Finding of no significant impact within 7 days of an EA.","c":[47,8,47,12],"n":"1106"},{"t":"Record of decision within 45 days of an EIS.","c":[49,8,49,13],"n":"1106"},{"t":"All federal permits within 90 days, or 120 days for agencies outside the review.","c":[47,23,48,3],"n":"1106"}]}},{"id":"science","topic":"New science during a review","current":{"text":"Agencies need not do new research unless it is essential and the cost and time are reasonable.","cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336(b)(3)","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336"},"epra":{"text":"No change."},"speed":{"text":"No new research after an application arrives. No duty to consider research published after the earlier of the application or the notice of intent.","cite":"Sec. 2(b), 2(c)","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},"senate":{"text":"No duty to consider research published after the notice of intent, and no delay to wait for it.","sections":["1106"],"ts":[{"t":"No duty to consider research published after the notice of intent, and no delay to wait for it.","c":[43,12,43,16],"n":"1106"}]}},{"id":"alternatives","topic":"Alternatives","current":{"text":"A reasonable range of alternatives that are feasible and meet the purpose and need.","cite":"42 U.S.C. 4332(2)(C)(iii)","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4332"},"epra":{"text":"No change."},"speed":{"text":"The statement of purpose and need must meet the applicant's goals.","cite":"Sec. 2(c)","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},"senate":{"text":"The lead agency must drop any alternative that misses the purpose and need or the non-federal sponsor's goals. The no-action alternative stays.","sections":["1106"],"ts":[{"t":"The lead agency must drop any alternative that misses the purpose and need or the non-federal sponsor's goals.","c":[38,6,38,8],"n":"1106"},{"t":"The no-action alternative stays.","c":[38,7,38,7],"n":"1106"}]}},{"id":"missed","topic":"Missed deadlines","current":{"text":"A sponsor may petition a court, which can order the agency to act within 90 days.","cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336a(g)(3)","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336a"},"epra":{"text":"No change."},"speed":{"text":"Extensions only with the applicant's approval. A sponsor that approved one cannot petition a court unless the agency misses the new deadline or delays for reasons other than finishing its review.","cite":"Sec. 2(c)","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},"senate":{"text":"Once a deadline is 60 days overdue the agency head may not travel more than 25 miles from the duty station. Senior staff must spend half the workweek on the review when the agency has defied a CEQ dispute order. Courts must rule on a sponsor's petition within 120 days and can order a decision in 60.","sections":["1106"],"ts":[{"t":"Once a deadline is 60 days overdue the agency head may not travel more than 25 miles from the duty station.","c":[54,17,54,20],"n":"1106"},{"t":"Senior staff must spend half the workweek on the review when the agency has defied a CEQ dispute order.","c":[54,5,54,8],"n":"1106"},{"t":"Courts must rule on a sponsor's petition within 120 days and can order a decision in 60.","c":[58,3,58,6],"n":"1106"}]}},{"id":"ceq","topic":"CEQ's role","current":{"text":"Designates a lead agency within 40 days when agencies disagree. CEQ removed its own NEPA regulations in 2025 and 2026.","cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336a(a)(5)","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336a"},"epra":{"text":"No change."},"speed":{"text":"No structural change."},"senate":{"text":"The Chairman names lead agencies in 21 days and settles interagency disputes by final orders no court can review. CEQ runs a public permitting tracker, an ePermit portal targeted for December 1, 2028, and a $20 million-a-year improvement fund.","sections":["1106","1121","1132","1133"],"ts":[{"t":"The Chairman names lead agencies in 21 days and settles interagency disputes by final orders no court can review.","c":[36,3,36,4],"n":"1106"},{"t":"CEQ runs a public permitting tracker, an ePermit portal targeted for December 1, 2028, and a $20 million-a-year improvement fund.","c":[102,15,102,16],"n":"1133"}]}},{"id":"programmatic","topic":"Programmatic reviews","current":{"text":"Reliable for 5 years without reevaluation.","cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336b","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336b"},"epra":{"text":"No change."},"speed":{"text":"10 years. Agencies may also reuse an earlier review of a substantially similar action.","cite":"Sec. 2(d)","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},"senate":{"text":"10 years.","sections":["1107"],"ts":[{"t":"10 years.","c":[62,1,62,2],"n":"1107"}]}}]},{"id":"courts","label":"Lawsuits","rows":[{"id":"sol","topic":"Time limit for a NEPA suit","current":{"text":"6 years by default, 2 years for FAST-41 projects, 150 days for highways and transit.","cite":"28 U.S.C. 2401(a); 42 U.S.C. 4370m-6; 23 U.S.C. 139(l)","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/2401"},"epra":{"text":"150 days for energy and mineral project decisions.","cite":"Sec. 101","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20101.%20ACCELERATING%20CLAIMS"},"speed":{"text":"150 days.","cite":"Sec. 3","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%203.%20JUDICIAL%20REVIEW"},"senate":{"text":"150 days.","sections":["1110"],"ts":[{"t":"150 days.","c":[68,1,68,2],"n":"1110"}]}},{"id":"standing","topic":"Who can sue","current":{"text":"Any party with standing that is adversely affected. No statutory comment requirement outside FAST-41."},"epra":{"text":"No change."},"speed":{"text":"Only a party that filed a substantive and unique comment and suffers direct harm. No challenges to the creation of a categorical exclusion.","cite":"Sec. 3","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%203.%20JUDICIAL%20REVIEW"},"senate":{"text":"Only a party alleging an actual or imminent injury amounting to direct harm. Where a comment period was offered, it must also have filed a detailed substantive comment.","sections":["1110"],"ts":[{"t":"Only a party alleging an actual or imminent injury amounting to direct harm.","c":[68,18,68,20],"n":"1110"},{"t":"Where a comment period was offered, it must also have filed a detailed substantive comment.","c":[68,11,68,14],"n":"1110"}]}},{"id":"venue","topic":"Which court","current":{"text":"District court, unless another statute sends the case to a court of appeals."},"epra":{"text":"No change."},"speed":{"text":"No change."},"senate":{"text":"The court of appeals for the circuit where the project sits, with randomly assigned judges.","sections":["1110"],"ts":[{"t":"The court of appeals for the circuit where the project sits, with randomly assigned judges.","c":[68,22,69,2],"n":"1110"}]}},{"id":"remedy","topic":"Remedy for a flawed review","current":{"text":"Courts may vacate the approval or enjoin the project."},"epra":{"text":"Ordinary remedies. An agency gets no more than 180 days on remand, unless applicable law needs longer.","cite":"Sec. 101","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20101.%20ACCELERATING%20CLAIMS"},"speed":{"text":"Remand only, without vacatur or injunction, with a fix due in 180 days. Applies to earlier court orders too.","cite":"Sec. 3","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%203.%20JUDICIAL%20REVIEW"},"senate":{"text":"Remand only, without vacatur or injunction, with a fix due in 180 days. Work may continue during the remand. A preliminary injunction is possible when a law other than NEPA or the National Historic Preservation Act is likely violated.","sections":["1110"],"ts":[{"t":"Remand only, without vacatur or injunction, with a fix due in 180 days.","c":[69,24,70,1],"n":"1110"},{"t":"Work may continue during the remand.","c":[71,20,71,23],"n":"1110"},{"t":"A preliminary injunction is possible when a law other than NEPA or the National Historic Preservation Act is likely violated.","c":[70,17,70,23],"n":"1110"}]}},{"id":"court-clock","topic":"Court timetable","current":{"text":"None."},"epra":{"text":"Expedited consideration.","cite":"Sec. 101","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20101.%20ACCELERATING%20CLAIMS"},"speed":{"text":"Judgment within 180 days of the agency record. Appeals decided in 180 days.","cite":"Sec. 3","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%203.%20JUDICIAL%20REVIEW"},"senate":{"text":"Final judgment 'as expeditiously as possible'. No fixed deadline.","sections":["1110"],"ts":[{"t":"Final judgment 'as expeditiously as possible'.","c":[69,16,69,18],"n":"1110"},{"t":"No fixed deadline.","c":[69,16,69,18],"n":"1110"}]}},{"id":"energy-sol","topic":"Suits over energy and mineral permits under any law","current":{"text":"6 years by default."},"epra":{"text":"150 days, unless another law sets a shorter limit. Remand capped at 180 days unless applicable law needs longer.","cite":"Sec. 101","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20101.%20ACCELERATING%20CLAIMS"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"150 days. Remand capped at 180 days unless applicable law needs longer.","sections":["2201"],"ts":[{"t":"150 days.","c":[284,12,284,15],"n":"2201"},{"t":"Remand capped at 180 days unless applicable law needs longer.","c":[285,8,285,11],"n":"2201"}]}},{"id":"other-sol","topic":"Suits under water, wildlife and historic preservation laws","current":{"text":"6 years, in district court, with ordinary remedies."},"epra":{"text":"Its 150-day limit for energy and mineral projects reaches Endangered Species Act section 7 and 10 statements and permits. Water and historic preservation suits are not addressed.","cite":"Sec. 101","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20101.%20ACCELERATING%20CLAIMS"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"150 days for section 404 permits, biological opinions and section 106 decisions. Biological opinions go to the D.C. Circuit. Remand without vacatur for section 404 and section 106.","sections":["1205","1305","2301"],"ts":[{"t":"150 days for section 404 permits, biological opinions and section 106 decisions.","c":[154,19,154,20],"n":"1305"},{"t":"Biological opinions go to the D.C. Circuit.","c":[154,17,154,19],"n":"1305"},{"t":"Remand without vacatur for section 404 and section 106.","c":[406,25,407,3],"n":"2301"}]}}]},{"id":"certainty","label":"Issued permits","rows":[{"id":"revoke","topic":"Revoking an issued permit","current":{"text":"Allowed under each statute and permit, subject to ordinary court review."},"epra":{"text":"Not addressed."},"speed":{"text":"Barred except for a court order, breach, fraud, a specific, immediate, substantial and proximate harm, or the holder's request. Review in the court of appeals. The bill sets out no money damages.","cite":"Sec. 2(b)","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},"senate":{"text":"Barred, with the same five exceptions, for permits in effect on or after September 16, 2026. The agency carries the burden by clear and convincing evidence. A winning sponsor recovers fees, delay costs and 25 to 50 percent of project costs.","sections":["1401"],"ts":[{"t":"Barred, with the same five exceptions, for permits in effect on or after September 16, 2026.","c":[159,12,159,15],"n":"1401"},{"t":"The agency carries the burden by clear and convincing evidence.","c":[162,4,162,6],"n":"1401"},{"t":"A winning sponsor recovers fees, delay costs and 25 to 50 percent of project costs.","c":[164,3,164,6],"n":"1401"}]}},{"id":"reopened","topic":"Approvals reopened since January 2025","current":{"text":"Agencies may ask a court to send their own approvals back."},"epra":{"text":"Not addressed."},"speed":{"text":"Exempt. The bill does not apply to any action an agency moved to reconsider after January 20, 2025.","cite":"Sec. 4","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%204.%20PRESERVATION%20OF%20ONGOING%20ADMINISTRATIVE%20CORRECTIONS"},"senate":{"text":"No exemption. Where a stop-work order from the year before enactment was enjoined, the same judge hears any new attempt.","sections":["1401"],"ts":[{"t":"No exemption.","c":[159,11,159,14],"n":"1401"},{"t":"Where a stop-work order from the year before enactment was enjoined, the same judge hears any new attempt.","c":[165,13,165,17],"n":"1401"}]}},{"id":"disparate","topic":"Treatment of energy types","reviewed_as":"Unequal treatment of energy types","current":{"text":"No cause of action."},"epra":{"text":"Not addressed."},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Applicants in 46 named project types, plus any similar type a court certifies, can sue over an intentional pattern of delays or denials aimed at their project type. Damages run from 50 to 100 percent of expected construction cost.","sections":["1402"],"ts":[{"t":"Applicants in 46 named project types, plus any similar type a court certifies, can sue over an intentional pattern of delays or denials aimed at their project type.","c":[173,13,173,17],"n":"1402"},{"t":"Damages run from 50 to 100 percent of expected construction cost.","c":[179,20,179,24],"n":"1402"}]}},{"id":"non-nepa","topic":"Permits that need no environmental document","current":{"text":"No general deadline."},"epra":{"text":"No general deadline. Clocks for particular permits only, such as wind, solar and geothermal applications.","cite":"Secs. 206, 208","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20206.%20ACCELERATING%20RENEWABLE%20ENERGY%20PERMITTING"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Decision within 1 year of a complete application for the listed project types, enforceable in court.","sections":["1402","1403"],"ts":[{"t":"Decision within 1 year of a complete application for the listed project types, enforceable in court.","c":[173,5,173,8],"n":"1402"}]}}]},{"id":"statutes","label":"Water, wildlife and historic sites","rows":[{"id":"401","topic":"State water quality certification","current":{"text":"States certify compliance with water quality standards and other appropriate state law within a reasonable period of up to 1 year.","cite":"33 U.S.C. 1341","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/33/1341"},"epra":{"text":"Not addressed."},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Scope limited to water quality requirements. Denials and conditions need clear and convincing evidence. One-year cap, extendable only if the applicant and the state both agree in writing. Interstate pipelines and transmission lines get 9 months and are reviewed only for direct point-source discharges.","sections":["1202"],"ts":[{"t":"Scope limited to water quality requirements.","c":[104,19,104,22],"n":"1202"},{"t":"Denials and conditions need clear and convincing evidence.","c":[105,1,105,5],"n":"1202"},{"t":"One-year cap, extendable only if the applicant and the state both agree in writing.","c":[115,20,115,23],"n":"1202"},{"t":"Interstate pipelines and transmission lines get 9 months and are reviewed only for direct point-source discharges.","c":[121,14,121,17],"n":"1202"}]}},{"id":"404","topic":"Clean Water Act permits","current":{"text":"EPA may veto a fill site at any time. Nationwide permits and state discharge permits last 5 years. A 2020 court ruling required wildlife consultation to reissue a nationwide permit.","cite":"33 U.S.C. 1342, 1344","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/33/1342"},"epra":{"text":"Not addressed."},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"EPA veto limited to the period between a complete application and the permit. Nationwide and discharge permits last 10 years. Nationwide permits that keep their preconstruction requirements are reissued without consultation, and fills under 2 acres count as minimal.","sections":["1203","1204"],"ts":[{"t":"EPA veto limited to the period between a complete application and the permit.","c":[124,4,124,5],"n":"1204"},{"t":"Nationwide and discharge permits last 10 years.","c":[123,4,123,4],"n":"1203"},{"t":"Nationwide permits that keep their preconstruction requirements are reissued without consultation, and fills under 2 acres count as minimal.","c":[127,16,127,19],"n":"1204"}]}},{"id":"esa","topic":"Endangered species consultation","current":{"text":"Formal consultation in 90 days, extendable. Only the federal wildlife agencies issue biological opinions.","cite":"16 U.S.C. 1536","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/16/1536"},"epra":{"text":"No change to consultation. Interior's approval of tribal right-of-way rules is exempt from the Act.","cite":"Sec. 205","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20205.%20RIGHTS-OF-WAY%20ACROSS%20INDIAN%20LAND"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"60 days, and no later than the NEPA deadline absent extraordinary circumstances. States may take over consultation under an agreement with Interior. $150 million a year authorized.","sections":["1302","1304","1307"],"ts":[{"t":"60 days, and no later than the NEPA deadline absent extraordinary circumstances.","c":[134,16,134,17],"n":"1302"},{"t":"States may take over consultation under an agreement with Interior. $150 million a year authorized.","c":[155,19,155,20],"n":"1307"}]}},{"id":"106","topic":"Historic preservation review","current":{"text":"Agencies 'take into account' effects on historic properties under Advisory Council rules. No statutory deadlines. Visual and audible effects count.","cite":"54 U.S.C. 306108; 36 CFR part 800","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/54/306108"},"epra":{"text":"No change to the review. Interior's approval of tribal right-of-way rules is exempt from it.","cite":"Sec. 205","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20205.%20RIGHTS-OF-WAY%20ACROSS%20INDIAN%20LAND"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Statutory deadlines from start to finish. Adverse effects limited to direct alteration. Loans and grants alone do not trigger review, unless they are for historic preservation. An agency may proceed when a preservation officer is silent for 30 days.","sections":["2301"],"ts":[{"t":"Statutory deadlines from start to finish.","c":[386,8,386,10],"n":"2301"},{"t":"Adverse effects limited to direct alteration.","c":[380,4,380,7],"n":"2301"},{"t":"Loans and grants alone do not trigger review, unless they are for historic preservation.","c":[383,25,384,3],"n":"2301"},{"t":"An agency may proceed when a preservation officer is silent for 30 days.","c":[400,19,400,21],"n":"2301"}]}}]},{"id":"grid","label":"Transmission and the grid","rows":[{"id":"backstop","topic":"Federal siting of interstate lines","current":{"text":"FERC can site a line only inside a corridor the Energy Department has designated, and only where a state lacks authority, has held an application for more than 1 year, or has set uneconomic conditions.","cite":"16 U.S.C. 824p","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/16/824p"},"epra":{"text":"FERC may permit lines of 100 kilovolts and up without a corridor.","cite":"Sec. 401","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20401.%20TRANSMISSION%20PERMITTING"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"FERC may permit lines of 230 kilovolts and up without a corridor, once it makes the required findings. The state's clock starts on the day the application is filed with the state. Developers of lines of 345 kilovolts and up may file at FERC and the state together.","sections":["2101"],"ts":[{"t":"FERC may permit lines of 230 kilovolts and up without a corridor, once it makes the required findings.","c":[189,17,189,19],"n":"2101"},{"t":"The state's clock starts on the day the application is filed with the state.","c":[189,2,189,5],"n":"2101"},{"t":"Developers of lines of 345 kilovolts and up may file at FERC and the state together.","c":[191,20,191,23],"n":"2101"}]}},{"id":"planning","topic":"Regional and interregional planning","current":{"text":"Regional planning required by FERC Orders 1000 and 1920. Interregional work is coordination only."},"epra":{"text":"Joint interregional plans required within 2 years. FERC resolves disputes and can impose a plan.","cite":"Sec. 402","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20402.%20TRANSMISSION%20PLANNING"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Regional and interregional planning processes required within 2 years. Compliance filings already made by the dates the bill lists count for the regional part. FERC can extend a late filing by 6 months.","sections":["2103"],"ts":[{"t":"Regional and interregional planning processes required within 2 years.","c":[214,21,214,22],"n":"2103"},{"t":"Compliance filings already made by the dates the bill lists count for the regional part.","c":[217,3,217,6],"n":"2103"},{"t":"FERC can extend a late filing by 6 months.","c":[217,22,217,24],"n":"2103"}]}},{"id":"cost","topic":"Who pays for new lines","current":{"text":"Beneficiaries pay, roughly in proportion to benefits, under FERC and court precedent."},"epra":{"text":"Beneficiaries pay under the cost-causation principle. No involuntary charges for trivial benefits.","cite":"Secs. 401, 402","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20401.%20TRANSMISSION%20PERMITTING"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Same rule, with costs 'at least roughly commensurate' with six listed benefits.","sections":["2101","2103"],"ts":[{"t":"Same rule, with costs 'at least roughly commensurate' with six listed benefits.","c":[193,20,193,22],"n":"2101"}]}},{"id":"corridor","topic":"Upgrades in existing corridors","current":{"text":"Covered by agency categorical exclusions in some cases."},"epra":{"text":"Interior and Agriculture adopt categorical exclusions within 180 days.","cite":"Sec. 209","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20209.%20ELECTRIC%20GRID%20PROJECTS"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Reconductoring, voltage increases and added circuits in existing rights-of-way are outside NEPA and section 106 by statute. So are gas pipeline looping and compression in existing corridors.","sections":["2102","2214"],"ts":[{"t":"Reconductoring, voltage increases and added circuits in existing rights-of-way are outside NEPA and section 106 by statute.","c":[201,23,202,1],"n":"2102"},{"t":"So are gas pipeline looping and compression in existing corridors.","c":[204,17,204,21],"n":"2102"}]}},{"id":"datacenters","topic":"Data centers and other large loads","current":{"text":"No federal floor. Retail costs are set in state rate cases and utility tariffs. FERC's 1994 transmission pricing policy lets a utility charge a new transmission customer the higher of embedded cost or incremental expansion cost, not the sum of the two. It may price separate lines on different bases.","cite":"FERC pricing policy statement, 59 FR 55031 (1994)","url":"https://archives.federalregister.gov/issue_slice/1994/11/3/55026-55045.pdf"},"epra":{"text":"Not addressed."},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"New Federal Power Act section 228 covers data center and high-density computing loads of 20 megawatts or more, counting phased buildouts and commonly controlled sites. Those that connect after enactment pay the full incremental cost of serving them, even after they leave; arrangements approved earlier stay in effect. States may auction access, require new generation, and require curtailable service. Separately, and with no size threshold, FERC must charge computing loads both the embedded and the incremental cost of transmission service. The Energy Information Administration must collect data center load.","sections":["2107","2114"],"ts":[{"t":"New Federal Power Act section 228 covers data center and high-density computing loads of 20 megawatts or more, counting phased buildouts and commonly controlled sites.","c":[232,5,232,8],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Those that connect after enactment pay the full incremental cost of serving them, even after they leave; arrangements approved earlier stay in effect.","c":[235,12,235,13],"n":"2107"},{"t":"States may auction access, require new generation, and require curtailable service.","c":[236,23,237,1],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Separately, and with no size threshold, FERC must charge computing loads both the embedded and the incremental cost of transmission service.","c":[229,19,229,24],"n":"2107"},{"t":"The Energy Information Administration must collect data center load.","c":[279,23,279,25],"n":"2114"}]},"note":{"label":"Earlier bill","text":"H.R. 9340 asks states to consider charging data centers of 100 megawatts or more for all added upgrade costs, even after departure, with financial assurance before construction. States could decline. The House passed it 417-3 on September 16. On September 30 the Senate fell short of ending debate on taking it up: 57 for, 43 against, 60 needed. BAAJA section 228 uses similar terms but makes them binding at 20 megawatts, and section 2107(a) adds an embedded-cost charge for transmission. Harvard's Ari Peskoe called the House bill's consider standard 'largely symbolic', since Congress cannot force state regulators to act, and called BAAJA's data center rules 'an improvement on the status quo'.","sources":[{"cite":"H.R. 9340, as passed by the House","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr9340eh/html/BILLS-119hr9340eh.htm"},{"cite":"CBS News on the 417-3 House vote","url":"https://www.cbsnews.com/news/house-bill-data-center-energy-costs/"},{"cite":"Senate roll call vote 254","url":"https://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_votes/vote1192/vote_119_2_00254.htm"},{"cite":"Heatmap on the Ratepayer Protection Act","url":"https://heatmap.news/politics/ratepayer-protection-act-explained"},{"cite":"Heatmap on the Senate bill's data center rules","url":"https://heatmap.news/daily/data-center-permitting-deal"}]}},{"id":"queue","topic":"Interconnection queues","current":{"text":"Cluster studies under FERC Order No. 2023."},"epra":{"text":"Not addressed."},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Interconnection planned with transmission over 20 years, with published per-megawatt prices and nonrefundable deposits. Providers must share and use automation in queue studies, as appropriate. Grid data due in 15 days.","sections":["2106","2110","2111"],"ts":[{"t":"Interconnection planned with transmission over 20 years, with published per-megawatt prices and nonrefundable deposits.","c":[225,10,225,12],"n":"2106"},{"t":"Providers must share and use automation in queue studies, as appropriate.","c":[265,18,265,21],"n":"2110"},{"t":"Grid data due in 15 days.","c":[268,21,268,23],"n":"2111"}]}},{"id":"gets","topic":"Advanced transmission technologies","current":{"text":"Planners must consider them under Order No. 1920."},"epra":{"text":"Advanced conductors eligible for backstop permits.","cite":"Sec. 401","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20401.%20TRANSMISSION%20PERMITTING"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Utilities must deploy them when benefits exceed costs, or face a lower return on equity.","sections":["2109"],"ts":[{"t":"Utilities must deploy them when benefits exceed costs, or face a lower return on equity.","c":[264,15,264,18],"n":"2109"}]}},{"id":"rofr","topic":"Right of first refusal","current":{"text":"FERC removed the federal right in 2011 and allowed it again for some replacement lines in Order No. 1920."},"epra":{"text":"Not addressed."},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Banned for regionally or interregionally planned lines.","sections":["2105"],"ts":[{"t":"Banned for regionally or interregionally planned lines.","c":[224,11,224,13],"n":"2105"}]}},{"id":"local","topic":"Local transmission spending","current":{"text":"Little federal review of projects a utility plans for itself."},"epra":{"text":"Not addressed."},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"States can refer a utility to FERC. Remedies include a lower return and fines up to $5 million per facility.","sections":["2104"],"ts":[{"t":"States can refer a utility to FERC.","c":[220,6,220,8],"n":"2104"},{"t":"Remedies include a lower return and fines up to $5 million per facility.","c":[223,7,223,9],"n":"2104"}]}},{"id":"der","topic":"Customer-sited batteries and generators","current":{"text":"Wholesale market access by rule under FERC Order No. 2222."},"epra":{"text":"Not addressed."},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Statutory wholesale market access for aggregations of 100 kilowatts and up, with a ban on double payment.","sections":["2108"],"ts":[{"t":"Statutory wholesale market access for aggregations of 100 kilowatts and up, with a ban on double payment.","c":[242,3,242,4],"n":"2108"}]}}]},{"id":"resources","label":"Energy on federal land and water","rows":[{"id":"oilgas","topic":"Oil and gas","current":{"text":"A federal drilling permit is required whenever a well taps federal minerals. Five routine activities get a rebuttable categorical exclusion.","cite":"30 U.S.C. 226; 42 U.S.C. 15942","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/30/226"},"epra":{"text":"No federal permit where the federal mineral share is under 50 percent on non-federal land. Lease nominations offered as submitted. Drilling permits last 4 years.","cite":"Secs. 201 to 203","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20201.%20ONSHORE%20OIL%20AND%20GAS%20LEASING"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"No federal permit where the federal mineral share is under 50 percent on non-federal land. The routine oil and gas activities already listed in law, plus geothermal power lines of up to 20 miles in approved corridors, are outside NEPA entirely.","sections":["2211","2229"],"ts":[{"t":"No federal permit where the federal mineral share is under 50 percent on non-federal land.","c":[287,1,287,4],"n":"2211"},{"t":"The routine oil and gas activities already listed in law, plus geothermal power lines of up to 20 miles in approved corridors, are outside NEPA entirely.","c":[351,6,351,8],"n":"2229"}]}},{"id":"coal","topic":"Coal","current":{"text":"Leasing at Interior's discretion, with no decision deadlines."},"epra":{"text":"Deadlines for coal lease reviews and decisions.","cite":"Sec. 204","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20204.%20COAL%20LEASES%20ON%20FEDERAL%20LAND"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"No leasing provisions. Coal appears only in the list of project types protected from unequal treatment.","sections":["1402"],"ts":[{"t":"No leasing provisions.","absent":true},{"t":"Coal appears only in the list of project types protected from unequal treatment.","c":[169,11,169,12],"n":"1402"}]}},{"id":"renewables","topic":"Wind, solar and storage on public land","current":{"text":"No application deadlines. A 2020 goal of 25 gigawatts by 2025.","cite":"43 U.S.C. 3004","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/43/3004"},"epra":{"text":"30-day clocks, small-project exclusions, and a goal of 50 gigawatts by 2030.","cite":"Secs. 206, 207","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20206.%20ACCELERATING%20RENEWABLE%20ENERGY%20PERMITTING"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"The same 30-day clocks and small-project exclusions. No gigawatt goal.","sections":["2213"],"ts":[{"t":"The same 30-day clocks and small-project exclusions.","c":[299,11,299,14],"n":"2213"},{"t":"No gigawatt goal.","absent":true}]}},{"id":"offshore","topic":"Offshore leasing","current":{"text":"Offshore wind leasing is tied to oil and gas lease sales by the Inflation Reduction Act.","cite":"43 U.S.C. 3006(b)(2)","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/43/3006"},"epra":{"text":"One oil and gas sale and one wind sale every year through 2029, 400,000 acres of wind a year, and a 30-gigawatt wind goal.","cite":"Secs. 301, 302","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20301.%20OFFSHORE%20OIL%20AND%20GAS%20LEASING"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"No lease sale mandates. Changes Interior's offshore wind test to 'unreasonable interference' with other uses and orders planned offshore transmission routes.","sections":["2251","2252"],"ts":[{"t":"No lease sale mandates.","absent":true},{"t":"Changes Interior's offshore wind test to 'unreasonable interference' with other uses and orders planned offshore transmission routes.","c":[363,17,363,18],"n":"2251"}]}},{"id":"lng","topic":"LNG exports","current":{"text":"Energy Department public-interest review with no deadline.","cite":"15 U.S.C. 717b","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/15/717b"},"epra":{"text":"Decision within 90 days of the environmental review, or the application is deemed granted.","cite":"Secs. 601, 602","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20601.%20ACTION%20ON%20APPLICATIONS"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"No export provisions. LNG projects appear in the list of project types protected from unequal treatment.","sections":["1402"],"ts":[{"t":"No export provisions.","absent":true},{"t":"LNG projects appear in the list of project types protected from unequal treatment.","c":[171,13,171,14],"n":"1402"}]}},{"id":"geothermal","topic":"Geothermal","current":{"text":"Lease sales at least every 2 years.","cite":"30 U.S.C. 1003","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/30/1003"},"epra":{"text":"Annual lease sales, 30-day permit decisions, an ombudsman, and exclusions for test wells.","cite":"Sec. 208","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20208.%20GEOTHERMAL%20LEASING%20AND%20PERMITTING%20IMPROVEMENTS"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"All of that, plus a per-plant royalty clock, no federal permit on minority-interest land, processing during lawsuits, and a NEPA exemption for routine drilling.","sections":["2221","2222","2223","2224","2225","2226","2229"],"ts":[{"t":"All of that, plus a per-plant royalty clock, no federal permit on minority-interest land, processing during lawsuits, and a NEPA exemption for routine drilling.","c":[341,22,342,1],"n":"2226"}]}},{"id":"hydro","topic":"Hydropower","current":{"text":"Federal land agencies set mandatory license conditions.","cite":"16 U.S.C. 797(e)","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/16/797"},"epra":{"text":"License extensions, a market barriers report, and aligned timetables.","cite":"Secs. 701 to 703","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20701.%20HYDROPOWER%20LICENSE%20EXTENSIONS"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"The market barriers report, a limit on mandatory conditions, no approval for routine maintenance, and a 1-year deadline for FERC to decide small hydrokinetic licenses.","sections":["2231","2232","2233","2234"],"ts":[{"t":"The market barriers report, a limit on mandatory conditions, no approval for routine maintenance, and a 1-year deadline for FERC to decide small hydrokinetic licenses.","c":[360,1,360,4],"n":"2234"}]}},{"id":"mining","topic":"Hardrock mining","current":{"text":"Mill sites are capped at 5 acres each. A 2022 appeals court ruling barred waste storage on claims without valuable minerals.","cite":"30 U.S.C. 42","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/30/42"},"epra":{"text":"As many mill sites as reasonably necessary, with fees paid into a cleanup fund.","cite":"Sec. 210","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20210.%20HARDROCK%20MINING%20MILL%20SITES"},"speed":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Additional mill sites on public land as reasonably necessary for waste rock, tailings and related operations, with a $400 yearly fee per site and a new Abandoned Hardrock Mine Fund.","sections":["2215"],"ts":[{"t":"Additional mill sites on public land as reasonably necessary for waste rock, tailings and related operations, with a $400 yearly fee per site and a new Abandoned Hardrock Mine Fund.","c":[311,12,311,13],"n":"2215"}]}},{"id":"tribal","topic":"Tribal lands","current":{"text":"Interior must approve rights-of-way across tribal land.","cite":"25 U.S.C. 323 to 328","url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/25/323"},"epra":{"text":"Tribes may grant their own rights-of-way under approved tribal rules.","cite":"Sec. 205","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20205.%20RIGHTS-OF-WAY%20ACROSS%20INDIAN%20LAND"},"speed":{"text":"No NEPA suits over tribal trust resource projects except by the tribe or over effects outside the trust lands. The no-action alternative is presumed harmful for tribe-initiated projects.","cite":"Secs. 2(b), 3","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},"senate":{"text":"Both: tribal rights-of-way, the limit on NEPA suits, and the no-action presumption.","sections":["2212","1110","1106"],"ts":[{"t":"Both: tribal rights-of-way, the limit on NEPA suits, and the no-action presumption.","c":[37,23,38,1],"n":"1106"}]}}]}],"added":[{"text":"Money damages when an agency unlawfully pulls a permit, and a cause of action for unequal treatment of 46 named project types.","sections":["1401","1402"],"ts":[{"t":"Money damages when an agency unlawfully pulls a permit, and a cause of action for unequal treatment of 46 named project types.","c":[179,20,179,23],"n":"1402"}]},{"text":"Cost rules for data centers of 20 megawatts and up, and federal data on their electricity use.","sections":["2107","2114"],"ts":[{"t":"Cost rules for data centers of 20 megawatts and up, and federal data on their electricity use.","c":[279,23,279,25],"n":"2114"}]},{"text":"Clean Water Act changes: state certification, EPA's veto, permit terms, nationwide permits.","sections":["1201","1202","1203","1204","1205"],"ts":[{"t":"Clean Water Act changes: state certification, EPA's veto, permit terms, nationwide permits.","c":[123,19,123,22],"n":"1204"}]},{"text":"Endangered Species Act changes: shorter consultation, state assumption, a definition of best available data.","sections":["1301","1302","1304"],"ts":[{"t":"Endangered Species Act changes: shorter consultation, state assumption, a definition of best available data.","c":[134,16,134,17],"n":"1302"}]},{"text":"A rewrite of historic preservation review under section 106.","sections":["2301"],"ts":[{"t":"A rewrite of historic preservation review under section 106.","c":[379,8,379,9],"n":"2301"}]},{"text":"CEQ dispute orders, sanctions for missed deadlines, a public tracker and the ePermit portal.","sections":["1106","1121","1132"],"ts":[{"t":"CEQ dispute orders, sanctions for missed deadlines, a public tracker and the ePermit portal.","c":[51,24,52,1],"n":"1106"}]},{"text":"NEPA exemptions for gas pipeline work in existing corridors and for routine oil, gas and geothermal drilling.","sections":["2102","2229"],"ts":[{"t":"NEPA exemptions for gas pipeline work in existing corridors and for routine oil, gas and geothermal drilling.","c":[349,9,349,13],"n":"2229"}]},{"text":"Grid rules: local transmission oversight, the right-of-first-refusal ban, joint interconnection planning, mandatory advanced technologies, grid data access.","sections":["2104","2105","2106","2109","2111"],"ts":[{"t":"Grid rules: local transmission oversight, the right-of-first-refusal ban, joint interconnection planning, mandatory advanced technologies, grid data access.","c":[224,11,224,13],"n":"2105"}]},{"text":"Wholesale market access for aggregated customer-sited storage and generation.","sections":["2108"],"ts":[{"t":"Wholesale market access for aggregated customer-sited storage and generation.","c":[242,23,242,24],"n":"2108"}]}],"dropped":[{"from":"speed","text":"The limit on effects an agency may study to those proximately caused by the project.","cite":"Sec. 2(b), 2(f)","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},{"from":"speed","text":"The exemption for approvals an agency moved to reconsider after January 20, 2025.","cite":"Sec. 4","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%204.%20PRESERVATION%20OF%20ONGOING%20ADMINISTRATIVE%20CORRECTIONS"},{"from":"speed","text":"The bar on suits challenging the creation of a categorical exclusion.","cite":"Sec. 3","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%203.%20JUDICIAL%20REVIEW"},{"from":"speed","text":"Fixed 180-day deadlines for court judgments and appeals.","cite":"Sec. 3","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%203.%20JUDICIAL%20REVIEW"},{"from":"speed","text":"Applying the remand-only rule to court orders issued before enactment.","cite":"Sec. 3","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%203.%20JUDICIAL%20REVIEW"},{"from":"speed","text":"The ban on withdrawing a finished environmental document, and on seeking a voluntary remand without the sponsor's consent.","cite":"Sec. 2(b)","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm#:~:text=SEC.%202.%20NEPA%20REFORM"},{"from":"epra","text":"Annual offshore oil and gas and offshore wind lease sales through 2029, and the 30-gigawatt offshore wind goal.","cite":"Secs. 301, 302","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20301.%20OFFSHORE%20OIL%20AND%20GAS%20LEASING"},{"from":"epra","text":"The 90-day deadline for LNG export decisions.","cite":"Secs. 601, 602","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20601.%20ACTION%20ON%20APPLICATIONS"},{"from":"epra","text":"The goal of 50 gigawatts of renewable energy on federal land by 2030.","cite":"Sec. 207","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20207.%20IMPROVING%20RENEWABLE%20ENERGY%20COORDINATION%20ON%20FEDERAL%20LAND"},{"from":"epra","text":"Onshore oil and gas lease nomination changes and 4-year drilling permits.","cite":"Secs. 201, 202","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20201.%20ONSHORE%20OIL%20AND%20GAS%20LEASING"},{"from":"epra","text":"Deadlines for coal lease decisions.","cite":"Sec. 204","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20204.%20COAL%20LEASES%20ON%20FEDERAL%20LAND"},{"from":"epra","text":"Reliability assessments of other agencies' proposed rules.","cite":"Sec. 501","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20501.%20RELIABILITY%20ASSESSMENTS"},{"from":"epra","text":"FERC's power to settle disputes between planning regions and impose an interregional plan.","cite":"Sec. 402","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20402.%20TRANSMISSION%20PLANNING"},{"from":"epra","text":"Hydropower license extensions and aligned licensing timetables.","cite":"Secs. 701, 703","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm#:~:text=SEC.%20701.%20HYDROPOWER%20LICENSE%20EXTENSIONS"}],"bills":{"id":"data-center-bills","label":"Data center bills","intro":"BAAJA's data center and load-growth rules beside the federal bills that would regulate large computing loads, transmission pricing, and interconnection speed. EPRA 2024 and the SPEED Act did not address data center ratepayer rules or non-firm transmission service. Each cell links to the text it summarizes.","versions":[{"key":"policy","label":"Current policy","sub":"The White House Ratepayer Protection Pledge (March 2026) and FERC's June 18, 2026 show cause orders. FERC set no large-load rule.","url":"https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2026/03/ratepayer-protection-pledge/"},{"key":"senate","label":"BAAJA","sub":"Released September 30, 2026. Sections 2107 and 2114.","url":"https://www.epw.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/2026/9/capito-lee-whitehouse-and-heinrich-introduce-bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act-of-2026"},{"key":"rpa","label":"Ratepayer Protection Act (H.R. 9340)","sub":"Evans (R-Colo.) and Castor (D-Fla.). House-passed text, September 16, 2026. On September 30 the Senate fell short of ending debate on whether to take it up.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr9340eh/html/BILLS-119hr9340eh.htm"},{"key":"grid_savings","label":"GRID Savings Act (S. 5199)","sub":"Heinrich (D-N.M.), August 2026. In committee; a unanimous-consent request failed September 17.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm"},{"key":"pftp","label":"Power for the People Act (S. 3682)","sub":"Van Hollen (D-Md.), January 2026; House companion H.R. 8241 (Tonko). In committee.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm"},{"key":"grid_act","label":"GRID Act (S. 3852)","sub":"Hawley (R-Mo.) and Blumenthal (D-Conn.), February 11, 2026. In committee.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3852is/html/BILLS-119s3852is.htm"}],"rows":[{"id":"scope","topic":"Who is covered","policy":{"text":"The Pledge: seven hyperscalers and AI companies, later joined by governors, developers and power providers. FERC's June 2026 orders: the six regional grid operators.","url":"https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2026/03/ratepayer-protection-pledge/","cite":"White House, Ratepayer Protection Pledge","quote":"President Trump is calling on the leading United States hyperscalers and AI companies to build, bring, or buy all of the energy needed for building and operating data centers"},"rpa":{"text":"Data centers with 100 MW or more of peak demand at one site or campus, contracting after enactment. The introduced bill covered any 100 MW load; committee narrowed it.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr9340eh/html/BILLS-119hr9340eh.htm","cite":"H.R. 9340, House-passed text","quote":"require electric energy primarily to operate information technology infrastructure and related systems pertaining to data storage and computational applications and services"},"grid_savings":{"text":"Any new or expanded non-residential load of 150 MW or more at one interconnection, counting affiliated sites and phases. Not limited to data centers.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text","quote":"has an aggregate requested or projected peak electric demand of not less than 150 megawatts behind a single point of interconnection"},"pftp":{"text":"Data centers drawing more than 50 MW, counting same-owner facilities in one utility area. Crypto mines are defined separately.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text","quote":"has an energy demand greater than 50 megawatts"},"grid_act":{"text":"Private data centers of 20 MW or more, existing or planned within 5 years. Federal data centers excluded.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3852is/html/BILLS-119s3852is.htm","cite":"S. 3852 text","quote":"with a power demand of 20 megawatts or more that is not owned, operated, or maintained"},"senate":{"text":"Section 228: data centers and high-density computing, including crypto mining, of 20 MW or more at one site or at commonly controlled sites, counting phased buildouts. Section 2107(a) pricing: any computational load on the bulk-power system, no size threshold. Ancillary computing at other commercial or industrial facilities is excluded from section 228.","sections":["2107"],"ts":[{"t":"Section 228: data centers and high-density computing, including crypto mining, of 20 MW or more at one site or at commonly controlled sites, counting phased buildouts.","c":[232,9,232,11],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Section 2107(a) pricing: any computational load on the bulk-power system, no size threshold.","c":[229,1,229,3],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Ancillary computing at other commercial or industrial facilities is excluded from section 228.","c":[233,7,233,11],"n":"2107"}]}},{"id":"binding","topic":"Binding or optional","policy":{"text":"Mostly voluntary. The Pledge creates no legal duty. FERC's June 18 orders find grid operators' tariffs may be unjust and make them justify or rewrite them. No final FERC rule.","url":"https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2026/03/ratepayer-protection-pledge-proclamation","cite":"Proclamation, 91 FR 11439","quote":"The Ratepayer Protection Pledge and the commitments embodied therein effectuate the national policy of the United States."},"rpa":{"text":"Optional. A PURPA standard each state must consider within 1 year and decide within 2. States need not adopt it.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr9340eh/html/BILLS-119hr9340eh.htm","cite":"H.R. 9340, House-passed text","quote":"shall commence consideration under section 111, or set a hearing date for consideration"},"grid_savings":{"text":"Binding. New Federal Power Act section 224 gives FERC jurisdiction over large-load interconnection; final rule within 1 year.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text","quote":"the Commission shall issue a final rule, applicable to each transmitting utility, establishing standards and procedures for the interconnection of covered large loads"},"pftp":{"text":"Mixed. FERC must order transmission cost tariffs (120 days) and a data center queue rule (180 days). The rate class is a PURPA standard states must consider.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text","quote":"the Commission shall issue a rule requiring all covered interconnection entities to create, for the purpose of addressing reliability and affordability concerns from new data center loads"},"grid_act":{"text":"Binding prohibition enforced by DOE, with penalties of at least $1 million a day.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3852is/html/BILLS-119s3852is.htm","cite":"S. 3852 text","quote":"a covered entity may not build, own, operate, or maintain a data center unless the data center derives all of its energy"},"senate":{"text":"Binding. Section 228 is a federal floor in the Federal Power Act. Section 2107(a) orders FERC to revise its 1994 pricing policy in 270 days, propose a rule 270 days later and finish within a year.","sections":["2107"],"ts":[{"t":"Binding.","c":[234,23,235,1],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Section 228 is a federal floor in the Federal Power Act.","c":[234,22,234,24],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Section 2107(a) orders FERC to revise its 1994 pricing policy in 270 days, propose a rule 270 days later and finish within a year.","c":[229,15,229,18],"n":"2107"}]}},{"id":"incremental","topic":"Cost of serving the load","policy":{"text":"Pledge signers say they will pay for the new generation and grid upgrades their data centers need. Retail costs otherwise follow state rate cases.","url":"https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2026/03/ratepayer-protection-pledge/","cite":"White House, Ratepayer Protection Pledge","quote":"Companies will pay for all new power delivery infrastructure upgrades required to service their data centers"},"rpa":{"text":"Rates recover from the data center the full incremental cost of generation, transmission or distribution upgrades needed to serve it.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr9340eh/html/BILLS-119hr9340eh.htm","cite":"H.R. 9340, House-passed text","quote":"shall be designed to recover from the large-load customer the full, incremental cost of any generation, transmission, or distribution upgrade necessary to serve the load of such large-load customer"},"grid_savings":{"text":"The load pays all interconnection and direct-assignment costs. Network upgrades are charged to it and credited back against its transmission bills, as for generators. Generation and distribution are not covered.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text","quote":"directly assigned to, and fully borne by, the applicable covered large-load customer"},"pftp":{"text":"Data centers pay local transmission upgrades that exist only because of them. States must consider a rate class that recovers the full cost of upgrades.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text","quote":"allocate to each interconnecting data center local transmission upgrade costs that, but for the existence of the data center, would not be needed"},"grid_act":{"text":"No cost allocation rule. New data centers must be off the grid; existing ones must show they do not raise rates or pay credits.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3852is/html/BILLS-119s3852is.htm","cite":"S. 3852 text","quote":"will not increase the electrical rates paid by ratepayers"},"senate":{"text":"No incremental cost of serving a covered load (generation, storage, transmission, distribution) may be recovered from other customers.","sections":["2107"],"ts":[{"t":"No incremental cost of serving a covered load (generation, storage, transmission, distribution) may be recovered from other customers.","c":[234,23,235,1],"n":"2107"}]}},{"id":"transmission","topic":"Transmission pricing","policy":{"text":"FERC's 1994 transmission pricing policy allows the higher of embedded cost or incremental expansion cost for a service, rather than their sum. Separate lines may be priced on different bases.","url":"https://archives.federalregister.gov/issue_slice/1994/11/3/55026-55045.pdf","cite":"FERC pricing policy statement, 59 FR 55031 (1994)"},"rpa":{"text":"Transmission upgrades fall under the state standard. No FERC role and no embedded-cost charge.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr9340eh/html/BILLS-119hr9340eh.htm","cite":"H.R. 9340, House-passed text","quote":"any generation, transmission, or distribution upgrade necessary to serve the load of such large-load customer"},"grid_savings":{"text":"FERC classifies and allocates facilities under interconnection rules adapted for loads. A load may fund regional lines in exchange for transmission rights.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text","quote":"to voluntarily fund all or a portion of a transmission facility selected in a regional or interregional transmission plan"},"pftp":{"text":"Two parts: direct assignment of local upgrades, plus rates reflecting the embedded cost of the grid.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text","quote":"require data centers to pay transmission rates applicable to their rate class that reflect the embedded cost of the integrated grid"},"grid_act":{"text":"No transmission pricing rule and no FERC role.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3852is/html/BILLS-119s3852is.htm","cite":"S. 3852 text","quote":"how interconnection costs and other infrastructure costs needed to supply the data center with power from the electric grid are allocated"},"senate":{"text":"Computational loads pay both the embedded and the incremental cost of transmission. Incremental payments are credited to the utility's revenue requirement so other customers are not charged twice.","sections":["2107"],"ts":[{"t":"Computational loads pay both the embedded and the incremental cost of transmission.","c":[229,20,229,25],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Incremental payments are credited to the utility's revenue requirement so other customers are not charged twice.","c":[230,1,230,4],"n":"2107"}]}},{"id":"exit","topic":"If the data center leaves","policy":{"text":"Pledge signers say they will pay negotiated rates whether or not they use the power.","url":"https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2026/03/ratepayer-protection-pledge/","cite":"White House, Ratepayer Protection Pledge","quote":"Importantly, they will pay these rates for the power and related infrastructure that are brought online to service their data centers, whether they use the electricity or not"},"rpa":{"text":"Recovery continues if the customer ends its contract or stops buying power.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr9340eh/html/BILLS-119hr9340eh.htm","cite":"H.R. 9340, House-passed text","quote":"including in the event of such large-load customer terminating a contract or other agreement with the electric utility"},"grid_savings":{"text":"Financial security must protect other customers if the load fails to proceed or perform.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text","quote":"financial security designed to protect any customer from unrecovered costs if a covered large load fails to proceed or perform"},"pftp":{"text":"States must consider longer minimum contracts and minimum demand charges.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text","quote":"an extension of minimum utility contract lengths for data center customers to ensure that data center load does not leave utilities and ratepayers with stranded costs"},"grid_act":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Recovery continues if the data center ends its contract or stops buying power before the incremental cost is paid off.","sections":["2107"],"ts":[{"t":"Recovery continues if the data center ends its contract or stops buying power before the incremental cost is paid off.","c":[235,14,235,15],"n":"2107"}]}},{"id":"assurance","topic":"Up-front collateral","policy":{"text":"FERC's June orders call for rising readiness requirements to deter speculative requests.","url":"https://www.utilitydive.com/news/ferc-doe-data-center-interconnection/823360/","cite":"Utility Dive on FERC's June 2026 orders","quote":"We target speculative projects by establishing escalating readiness requirements for distinct phases of the study process to deter duplicative or speculative requests for transmission service,"},"rpa":{"text":"The utility must require assurances or contributions before building an upgrade.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr9340eh/html/BILLS-119hr9340eh.htm","cite":"H.R. 9340, House-passed text","quote":"an electric utility shall require the large-load customer provide to the electric utility financial assurances or contributions to cover the cost of such upgrade"},"grid_savings":{"text":"FERC's rule sets payment and security requirements.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text","quote":"financial security designed to protect any customer from unrecovered costs if a covered large load fails to proceed or perform"},"pftp":{"text":"States must consider higher study fees, deposits or collateral, and up-front construction contributions.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text","quote":"an increase in up-front interconnection study costs, deposit amounts, or collateral requirements for data center projects"},"grid_act":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Before building or upgrading generation, transmission or distribution for the load, the utility must collect assurances or contributions covering the cost.","sections":["2107"],"ts":[{"t":"Before building or upgrading generation, transmission or distribution for the load, the utility must collect assurances or contributions covering the cost.","c":[235,23,236,1],"n":"2107"}]}},{"id":"rate-class","topic":"Separate rate class","policy":{"text":"Pledge signers say they will negotiate separate rate structures with utilities and states.","url":"https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2026/03/ratepayer-protection-pledge/","cite":"White House, Ratepayer Protection Pledge","quote":"Companies will voluntarily negotiate new, separate rate structures with their utilities and relevant State governments wherever they build data centers."},"rpa":{"text":"Not addressed."},"grid_savings":{"text":"Not addressed."},"pftp":{"text":"States must consider a data center rate class. DOE grants help them.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text","quote":"establishing a rate class specific to data centers to ensure that data center owners and operators are covering the full cost of the generation, transmission, and distribution upgrades necessary to serve data centers"},"grid_act":{"text":"DOE must put residential customers' rates ahead of every other class.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3852is/html/BILLS-119s3852is.htm","cite":"S. 3852 text","quote":"the Secretary shall prioritize the electrical rates paid by residential ratepayers over all other ratepayer classes"},"senate":{"text":"States may make data centers a separate class with rates, terms and interconnection priorities less favorable than other large industrial loads.","sections":["2107"],"ts":[{"t":"States may make data centers a separate class with rates, terms and interconnection priorities less favorable than other large industrial loads.","c":[239,1,239,4],"n":"2107"}]}},{"id":"queue","topic":"Who connects first","policy":{"text":"FERC wants standard large-load applications and studies in each region.","url":"https://rmi.org/resources/understanding-fercs-large-load-orders/","cite":"RMI on FERC's June 2026 orders","quote":"Develop standardized transmission service applications and study processes for large loads"},"rpa":{"text":"Not addressed."},"grid_savings":{"text":"Study timelines and readiness requirements against speculative requests. No open seasons.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text","quote":"protect other customers from the costs of speculative or duplicative requests"},"pftp":{"text":"Grid operators run a data center queue that favors those offsetting their demand, and may delay or deny connections that hurt reliability or affordability.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text","quote":"a data center that is not already interconnected with the electric grid may not interconnect with the electric grid unless the data center has fully advanced through the applicable data center load queue system"},"grid_act":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"States may run open seasons that award service by greatest benefit to other ratepayers, whatever the order of requests.","sections":["2107"],"ts":[{"t":"States may run open seasons that award service by greatest benefit to other ratepayers, whatever the order of requests.","c":[237,1,237,5],"n":"2107"}]}},{"id":"own-power","topic":"Bring your own power","policy":{"text":"Pledge signers say they will build, bring or buy new generation. FERC told grid operators to address co-location.","url":"https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2026/03/ratepayer-protection-pledge/","cite":"White House, Ratepayer Protection Pledge","quote":"Companies will build, bring, or buy the new generation resources and electricity needed to satisfy their new energy demands"},"rpa":{"text":"Not addressed."},"grid_savings":{"text":"Optional. A load may be studied with its own generation, storage or flexibility.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text","quote":"the study and interconnection, separately or together, of a covered large load and any associated generation, energy storage, or verifiable load flexibility"},"pftp":{"text":"Queue priority for data centers that bring new low- or no-carbon supply they pay for. Not required.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text","quote":"are designated for the service of, and paid for by, the data center owner or operator, including through a power purchase agreement or another bilateral contract"},"grid_act":{"text":"Starting 180 days after enactment, new data centers must take all power, including backup, from sources separate from the grid. Existing grid-connected centers have a 10-year transition under DOE certificates.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3852is/html/BILLS-119s3852is.htm","cite":"S. 3852 text","quote":"derives all of its energy, including back-up energy, from a captive power plant, on-site power generation, or some other source or combination of sources separate from, and not deriving power from, the electric grid"},"senate":{"text":"States may require the data center to procure, build or contract for new generation sufficient to serve it.","sections":["2107"],"ts":[{"t":"States may require the data center to procure, build or contract for new generation sufficient to serve it.","c":[237,14,237,17],"n":"2107"}]}},{"id":"flexibility","topic":"Curtailable service","policy":{"text":"FERC asked grid operators for new transmission services for flexible large loads.","url":"https://www.utilitydive.com/news/ferc-doe-data-center-interconnection/823360/","cite":"Utility Dive on FERC's June 2026 orders","quote":"new transmission services for flexible large loads"},"rpa":{"text":"Not addressed."},"grid_savings":{"text":"Flexible and phased interconnection service at the customer's election.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text","quote":"flexible interconnection service, subject to enforceable operating limits"},"pftp":{"text":"Flexibility agreements let the operator curtail data centers before other users and can count toward the supply they must bring.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text","quote":"data centers may be interrupted by the covered interconnection entity"},"grid_act":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"States may require service that limits how much or when the load draws power. FERC must price non-firm transmission service lower.","sections":["2107"],"ts":[{"t":"States may require service that limits how much or when the load draws power.","c":[237,20,237,23],"n":"2107"},{"t":"FERC must price non-firm transmission service lower.","c":[230,9,230,14],"n":"2107"}]}},{"id":"credits","topic":"Surplus returned to other customers","policy":{"text":"Not addressed."},"rpa":{"text":"Not addressed."},"grid_savings":{"text":"Upgrade payments are credited back to the paying load, not to other customers.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text","quote":"those costs shall be credited back against transmission service charges"},"pftp":{"text":"Not addressed."},"grid_act":{"text":"Grid-connected data centers can pay Rate Effect Credits to offset their effect on rates.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3852is/html/BILLS-119s3852is.htm","cite":"S. 3852 text","quote":"a credit paid by a covered entity to an appropriate party, as determined by the Secretary, that offsets the effect that a data center would otherwise have on the electrical rates paid by ratepayers"},"senate":{"text":"States may charge more than cost and credit the surplus to other customers.","sections":["2107"],"ts":[{"t":"States may charge more than cost and credit the surplus to other customers.","c":[236,14,236,17],"n":"2107"}]}},{"id":"existing","topic":"Existing data centers","policy":{"text":"The Pledge covers new demand only.","url":"https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2026/03/ratepayer-protection-pledge/","cite":"White House, Ratepayer Protection Pledge","quote":"satisfy their new energy demands"},"rpa":{"text":"Applies to customers that request service or contract after enactment. States that already acted on a comparable standard are exempt.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr9340eh/html/BILLS-119hr9340eh.htm","cite":"H.R. 9340, House-passed text","quote":"on or after the date of the enactment of this paragraph, requests to enter into, or enters into, a contract or other agreement"},"grid_savings":{"text":"New or expanded loads only.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text","quote":"a new or expanded nonresidential electric load"},"pftp":{"text":"The queue covers data centers not yet connected. The text does not say how the tariff or rate class treats existing sites.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text","quote":"a data center that is not already interconnected with the electric grid may not interconnect"},"grid_act":{"text":"Existing data centers get 10 years to leave the grid, operating meanwhile under one-year DOE certificates.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3852is/html/BILLS-119s3852is.htm","cite":"S. 3852 text","quote":"Until the date that is 10 years after the date of enactment of this Act, a covered entity that owns, operates, or maintains an existing data center that derives any of its energy from the electric grid"},"senate":{"text":"Section 228(b) cost protection and (c) state open-season authority apply to covered loads interconnecting on or after enactment. Previously approved service arrangements remain in effect. Section 2107(a) transmission pricing has no express existing-load exemption; its scope is separate.","sections":["2107"],"ts":[{"t":"Section 228(b) cost protection and (c) state open-season authority apply to covered loads interconnecting on or after enactment.","c":[240,1,240,3],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Previously approved service arrangements remain in effect.","c":[240,5,240,8],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Section 2107(a) transmission pricing has no express existing-load exemption; its scope is separate.","absent":true}]}},{"id":"data","topic":"Reporting","policy":{"text":"FERC found grid operators' upgrade costs are not transparent. No EIA change.","url":"https://www.utilitydive.com/news/ferc-doe-data-center-interconnection/823360/","cite":"Utility Dive on FERC's June 2026 orders","quote":"lack of transparency in how RTOs and ISOs determine how network upgrades are assigned and paid for"},"rpa":{"text":"Not addressed."},"grid_savings":{"text":"Each load, state commission and FERC get the classification, costs and alternatives studied.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text","quote":"Disclosure to the applicable covered large-load customer, each applicable State commission, and the Commission of"},"pftp":{"text":"FERC sets disclosure rules for interconnection requests. DOE helps with load forecasts.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text","quote":"the Commission shall establish transparency and disclosure requirements for data center load interconnection requests"},"grid_act":{"text":"DOE sets public disclosure of usage, property deals and utility agreements.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3852is/html/BILLS-119s3852is.htm","cite":"S. 3852 text","quote":"the Secretary shall establish a national requirement for covered entities to provide to the public"},"senate":{"text":"EIA must add data center load to Form 861, with no 20 MW threshold in section 2114. Revision is due at least 90 days before the first April 1 after enactment.","sections":["2114"],"ts":[{"t":"EIA must add data center load to Form 861, with no 20 MW threshold in section 2114.","c":[279,5,279,8],"n":"2114"},{"t":"Revision is due at least 90 days before the first April 1 after enactment.","c":[279,21,279,24],"n":"2114"}]}},{"id":"non-firm","topic":"Non-firm rate discount","policy":{"text":"FERC's 1994 pricing policy allows discounted or negotiated rates, but sets no mandatory transmission rate discount for flexible or non-firm computing loads.","url":"https://archives.federalregister.gov/issue_slice/1994/11/3/55026-55045.pdf","cite":"FERC pricing policy statement, 59 FR 55031 (1994)"},"rpa":{"text":"Not addressed."},"grid_savings":{"text":"Directs FERC to provide flexible interconnection service, but establishes no statutory rate discount for non-firm service.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text"},"pftp":{"text":"Allows curtailable service agreements to satisfy clean energy requirements, but specifies no discounted transmission rate.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text"},"grid_act":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"FERC must revise its transmission pricing policy within 270 days to provide a lower transmission price for computational loads electing non-firm service. Studies must include a standardized analysis of upgrades and cost-reduction options.","sections":["2107"],"ts":[{"t":"FERC must revise its transmission pricing policy within 270 days to provide a lower transmission price for computational loads electing non-firm service.","c":[230,9,230,14],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Studies must include a standardized analysis of upgrades and cost-reduction options.","c":[231,5,231,8],"n":"2107"}]}},{"id":"queue-speed","topic":"Queue speed and study automation","policy":{"text":"Order 2023 set cluster studies and study deadlines; FERC's June 2026 show cause orders asked grid operators for large-load study timelines, but set no automation requirements.","url":"https://rmi.org/resources/understanding-fercs-large-load-orders/","cite":"RMI on FERC's June 2026 orders"},"rpa":{"text":"Not addressed."},"grid_savings":{"text":"Sets study schedules and readiness requirements to curb speculative requests, but mandates no AI or automation in study software.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5199is/html/BILLS-119s5199is.htm","cite":"S. 5199 text"},"pftp":{"text":"Creates a dedicated data center queue; grid operators may delay or deny studies for loads that threaten reliability.","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3682is/html/BILLS-119s3682is.htm","cite":"S. 3682 text"},"grid_act":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Directs FERC within 1 year to require AI and automation in interconnection study evaluations. Mandates 15-day grid data turnaround (backed by section 316A reliability penalties for public utilities and FERC compliance orders for other entities), and requires a joint FERC/DOE reference spec for fully automated studies within 1 year.","sections":["2110","2111"],"ts":[{"t":"Directs FERC within 1 year to require AI and automation in interconnection study evaluations.","c":[265,14,265,17],"n":"2110"},{"t":"Mandates 15-day grid data turnaround (backed by section 316A reliability penalties for public utilities and FERC compliance orders for other entities), and requires a joint FERC/DOE reference spec for fully automated studies within 1 year.","c":[268,20,268,23],"n":"2111"}]}},{"id":"att-reconductoring","topic":"Grid-enhancing tech and reconductoring","policy":{"text":"FERC Order No. 1920 requires transmission planners to evaluate dynamic line ratings, advanced power flow control, and advanced conductors, but deployment is voluntary.","url":"https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/06/11/2024-10609/building-for-the-future-through-electric-regional-transmission-planning-and-cost-allocation","cite":"FERC Order No. 1920, 89 FR 49704 (2024)"},"rpa":{"text":"Not addressed."},"grid_savings":{"text":"Not addressed."},"pftp":{"text":"Not addressed."},"grid_act":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Utilities must deploy advanced transmission technologies whenever benefits exceed costs, backed by ROE reduction penalties. In-corridor reconductoring and grid capacity expansions are categorically excluded from NEPA and NHPA reviews.","sections":["2102","2109"],"ts":[{"t":"Utilities must deploy advanced transmission technologies whenever benefits exceed costs, backed by ROE reduction penalties.","c":[263,16,263,19],"n":"2109"},{"t":"In-corridor reconductoring and grid capacity expansions are categorically excluded from NEPA and NHPA reviews.","c":[201,23,202,2],"n":"2102"}]}},{"id":"btm-power","topic":"Behind-the-meter generation and storage","policy":{"text":"FERC Order No. 2222 directed grid operators to accommodate distributed energy resource aggregations by administrative rule, but establishes no direct statutory right in the Federal Power Act.","url":"https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/10/06/2020-20596/participation-of-distributed-energy-resource-aggregations-in-markets-operated-by-regional","cite":"FERC Order No. 2222, 85 FR 67094 (2020)"},"rpa":{"text":"Not addressed."},"grid_savings":{"text":"Not addressed."},"pftp":{"text":"Not addressed."},"grid_act":{"text":"Not addressed."},"senate":{"text":"Effective 18 months after enactment, bars grid operators from blocking qualifying behind-the-meter aggregations from wholesale markets. Unless state law or the state regulator provides otherwise, distribution utilities in organized markets must interconnect them; voluntary for public power utilities. Device-level inverter telemetry allowed.","sections":["2108"],"ts":[{"t":"Effective 18 months after enactment, bars grid operators from blocking qualifying behind-the-meter aggregations from wholesale markets.","c":[243,13,243,16],"n":"2108"},{"t":"Unless state law or the state regulator provides otherwise, distribution utilities in organized markets must interconnect them; voluntary for public power utilities.","c":[252,9,252,12],"n":"2108"},{"t":"Device-level inverter telemetry allowed.","c":[241,16,241,19],"n":"2108"}]}}],"others_label":"Other data center bills","others":[{"text":"Data Center Transparency Act (H.R. 6984; Menendez, Casar): EIA would collect each data center's energy use every six months; EPA would report on water use and emissions. No cost rules.","cite":"H.R. 6984 text","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr6984ih/html/BILLS-119hr6984ih.htm"},{"text":"Protecting Ratepayers Act (H.R. 9777; Donalds): data centers of 5 MW or more, existing ones included, would have to take all power and water from sources separate from the public grid and water system within 180 days, and the Pledge proclamation would gain the force of law.","cite":"H.R. 9777 text","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr9777ih/html/BILLS-119hr9777ih.htm"},{"text":"Clean Cloud Act (S. 1475; Whitehouse, Fetterman): an EPA emissions standard and fee for data centers and crypto mines over 100 kW, with annual EIA reporting. A utility may not pass the fee to other customers.","cite":"S. 1475 text","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s1475is/html/BILLS-119s1475is.htm"}]},"focused":[{"id":"data-center-disclosure","label":"Data center disclosure","question":"What would communities learn about a data center’s power and water use?","section":"2114","baseline":"BAAJA would have the Energy Information Administration revise Form 861 to collect electricity load attributable to data centers.","entries":[{"label":"Data Center Transparency Act of 2026 (S. 5640)","cite":"Senate introduced text, §2 · September 30, 2026","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5640is/html/BILLS-119s5640is.htm","text":"For data centers consuming at least 50 megawatts each day, EPA would report at least quarterly on water use and emissions. EIA would publish state electricity totals and changes in household bills at least twice a year."},{"label":"Data Center Water and Energy Transparency Act of 2026 (S. 4213)","cite":"Senate introduced text, §3 · March 25, 2026","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s4213is/html/BILLS-119s4213is.htm","text":"Operators of facilities with at least 25 megawatts of peak demand would report energy and water use to the state, or to federal agencies if the state has no program. Proposed facilities and expansions meeting the bill’s threshold would also report five-year projections."},{"label":"Data Center Community Empowerment Act of 2026 (S. 5645)","cite":"Senate introduced text, §2 · September 30, 2026","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5645is/html/BILLS-119s5645is.htm","text":"State, local and Tribal governments could request Energy Department help estimating power, water and infrastructure impacts. The department could not recommend whether to approve or reject an individual project."}],"ts":[{"t":"BAAJA would have the Energy Information Administration revise Form 861 to collect electricity load attributable to data centers.","c":[279,23,279,25],"n":"2114"}]},{"id":"data-center-siting","label":"Data center siting","question":"Who decides where a data center can be built, and when is environmental review required?","section":"1102","baseline":"BAAJA would exclude a proposed agency action on a non-federal project from the definition of major federal action if the only federal involvement is a loan or loan guarantee.","entries":[{"label":"Protecting Local Control of Data Centers Act (H.R. 10119)","cite":"House introduced text, §2 · August 20, 2026","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr10119ih/html/BILLS-119hr10119ih.htm","text":"For data centers on non-federal land, federal agencies could neither override state or local siting and permitting authority nor condition federal funding on its surrender."},{"label":"Public Lands Accountability Act (H.R. 10465)","cite":"House introduced text, §2 · September 16, 2026","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr10465ih/html/BILLS-119hr10465ih.htm","text":"A Bureau of Land Management authorization for a hyperscale data center on public lands would require an environmental impact statement. The bill would rule out categorical exclusions and require at least 45 days for written comments and a hearing in the affected community."},{"label":"Data center construction on federal land (S. 5658)","cite":"Senate introduced text, §1 · September 30, 2026","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s5658is/html/BILLS-119s5658is.htm","text":"The bill would prohibit construction on National Forest System and Interior-managed lands, with specified Tribal lands excluded. Newly conveyed land would revert to the United States if used for a data center unless Congress specifically authorized that use."}],"ts":[{"t":"BAAJA would exclude a proposed agency action on a non-federal project from the definition of major federal action if the only federal involvement is a loan or loan guarantee.","c":[17,1,17,3],"n":"1102"}]},{"id":"digital-permitting","label":"Digital permitting","question":"Would agencies study a permitting portal or have to build one?","section":"1121","baseline":"BAAJA would direct CEQ to implement the ePermit interagency system by December 1, 2028, to the maximum extent practicable.","entries":[{"label":"E-NEPA (current law)","cite":"42 U.S.C. §4336d · NEPA §110","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2024-title42/html/USCODE-2024-title42-chap55-subchapI-sec4336d.htm","text":"Congress directed the Council on Environmental Quality (CEQ) to study digital environmental review tools and report to Congress. A permit portal was a subject of that study; the statute did not direct CEQ to build it."},{"label":"ePermit Act (H.R. 4503)","cite":"House-passed text, §§3, 5, 7 and 8 · December 9, 2025","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4503eh/html/BILLS-119hr4503eh.htm","text":"CEQ would publish data standards within 60 days and implementation guidance within 120 days. The target for the shared system is December 1, 2027, to the maximum extent practicable: one year earlier than BAAJA. Section 8 expressly conditions CEQ contracting authority on available appropriations."},{"label":"ePermit Act (S. 3800)","cite":"Senate introduced text, §§3, 5, 7 and 8 · February 5, 2026","url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119s3800is/html/BILLS-119s3800is.htm","text":"The Senate text sets the same 60-day and 120-day deadlines and the same qualified December 1, 2027 system target as the House text. Its contracting clause omits the House version’s express appropriations condition."}],"ts":[{"t":"BAAJA would direct CEQ to implement the ePermit interagency system by December 1, 2028, to the maximum extent practicable.","c":[92,18,92,21],"n":"1121"}]}]},"communities":{"_about":"Curated from data/research/communities.json (a Sonnet reading of the bill text, 2026-10-02). The build checks each quote against the cited section.","intro":"How the bill changes who can comment, be consulted, take part in planning or go to court.","who":{"public":"The public","tribes":"Tribes","states":"States","local":"Local governments","landowners":"Landowners","consulting":"Consulting parties"},"pages":[{"id":"tribes","label":"Section 106 and tribes","note":"Historic preservation review, tribal land and the lawsuits that follow from them."},{"id":"water","label":"Species and water","note":"Endangered Species Act consultation and Clean Water Act permits and certifications, with their court rules."},{"id":"siting","label":"Siting and transmission","note":"Federal siting of transmission lines, landowners, payments to places a line crosses and where challenges go."},{"id":"courts","label":"Court rules and public comment","note":"Environmental review: comment periods, who can sue, how long they have and which court hears them."}],"groups":[{"id":"comment","label":"Comment and notice"},{"id":"consult","label":"Consultation"},{"id":"plan","label":"Planning and siting"},{"id":"challenge","label":"Challenges in court"}],"rows":[{"id":"eis-comment-period","group":"comment","topic":"Comment period on a notice of intent for an EIS","who":["public","tribes","states","local","landowners"],"effect":"changes","now":"Each notice of intent to prepare an environmental impact statement must request public comment on alternatives, impacts and relevant studies. The statute sets no minimum or maximum comment period.","now_cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336a(c)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336a","baaja":"Each notice of intent would be published in the Federal Register with a request for comment. The lead agency would set a comment period of 45 to 60 days after publication, or up to 75 days if the lead agency and the project sponsor agree.","sections":["1106"],"quote":"The lead agency shall establish a comment period of not less than 45 days and not more than 60 days after the date on which the notice to prepare an environmental impact statement is published in the Federal Register","page":"courts","c":[44,24,45,4],"ts":[{"t":"Each notice of intent would be published in the Federal Register with a request for comment.","c":[44,9,44,11],"n":"1106"},{"t":"The lead agency would set a comment period of 45 to 60 days after publication, or up to 75 days if the lead agency and the project sponsor agree.","c":[44,24,45,2],"n":"1106"}]},{"id":"ce-combine","group":"comment","topic":"Combining categorical exclusions","reviewed_as":"Combining categorical exclusions to skip a review","who":["public","tribes","states","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"An agency need not prepare an environmental document if the action fits one of its own categorical exclusions, another agency's exclusion adopted under section 109, or another provision of law.","now_cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336(a)(2)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336","baaja":"A lead agency could rely on one exclusion or a combination of several. Repeated use of the same or similar exclusions based on size, acreage or dollar thresholds would not count as a combination. An exclusion established by Congress would also qualify. The text adds no notice or comment step for relying on an exclusion.","sections":["1105"],"quote":"1 or a combination of multiple categorical exclusions (excluding multiple applications of the same or similar categorical exclusions that are based on size, acreage, or dollar amount thresholds) of the agency","page":"courts","c":[28,8,28,13],"ts":[{"t":"A lead agency could rely on one exclusion or a combination of several.","c":[28,8,28,9],"n":"1105"},{"t":"Repeated use of the same or similar exclusions based on size, acreage or dollar thresholds would not count as a combination.","c":[28,10,28,13],"n":"1105"},{"t":"An exclusion established by Congress would also qualify.","c":[28,14,28,16],"n":"1105"},{"t":"The text adds no notice or comment step for relying on an exclusion.","absent":true}]},{"id":"not-major-action","group":"comment","topic":"Actions defined as not a major Federal action","who":["public","tribes","states","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"NEPA excludes seven kinds of action from 'major Federal action', including projects with no or minimal federal funding or involvement and non-discretionary actions.","now_cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336e(10)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336e","baaja":"The list would grow to fourteen. New entries include projects whose only federal involvement is a loan or loan guarantee, and routine agency actions costing up to $10,000,000. Others cover lifeline infrastructure repair that adds no more than 20 percent capacity, geothermal observation tests, transmission activities described in a new section 216A(b) of the Federal Power Act and covered activities under Natural Gas Act section 7(i)(1). Actions another agency already evaluated under NEPA, and some Corps projects with a federal share of up to $50,000,000, also qualify. These actions fall outside the Act's review requirements.","sections":["1102"],"quote":"a proposed agency action, the effects of which were previously evaluated by another agency in compliance with this Act","page":"courts","c":[20,9,20,12],"ts":[{"t":"The list would grow to fourteen.","c":[20,13,20,14],"n":"1102"},{"t":"New entries include projects whose only federal involvement is a loan or loan guarantee, and routine agency actions costing up to $10,000,000.","c":[18,18,18,20],"n":"1102"},{"t":"Others cover lifeline infrastructure repair that adds no more than 20 percent capacity, geothermal observation tests, transmission activities described in a new section 216A(b) of the Federal Power Act and covered activities under Natural Gas Act section 7(i)(1).","c":[19,8,19,10],"n":"1102"},{"t":"Actions another agency already evaluated under NEPA, and some Corps projects with a federal share of up to $50,000,000, also qualify.","c":[20,9,20,12],"n":"1102"},{"t":"These actions fall outside the Act's review requirements.","c":[16,13,16,14],"n":"1102"}]},{"id":"state-tribal-substitute","group":"comment","topic":"State or tribal review standing in for NEPA","who":["public","tribes","states","local"],"effect":"changes","now":"An agency need not prepare an environmental document when the action is excluded under a categorical exclusion or 'another provision of law'. The threshold test does not refer to state or tribal reviews.","now_cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336(a)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336","baaja":"An agency would not need an environmental document if the action was reviewed under a state or tribal environmental review law or policy and the lead agency finds the review serves a similar function. The same applies where another federal law serves a similar function. On a sponsor's request the lead agency must also consider, and as appropriate adopt, state or tribal analysis. The text does not say what notice or comment the earlier review must have had.","sections":["1105","1106"],"quote":"the proposed agency action relates to a project or action that has been reviewed pursuant to a State environmental review statute or a Tribal environmental review statute, ordinance, resolution, regulation, or formally adopted policy","quote_section":"1105","page":"courts","c":[28,23,29,1],"ts":[{"t":"An agency would not need an environmental document if the action was reviewed under a state or tribal environmental review law or policy and the lead agency finds the review serves a similar function.","c":[28,23,28,26],"n":"1105"},{"t":"The same applies where another federal law serves a similar function.","c":[29,5,29,8],"n":"1105"},{"t":"On a sponsor's request the lead agency must also consider, and as appropriate adopt, state or tribal analysis.","c":[45,19,45,23],"n":"1106"},{"t":"The text does not say what notice or comment the earlier review must have had.","absent":true}]},{"id":"research-cutoff","group":"comment","topic":"New science that arrives after a notice of intent","who":["public","tribes","states","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"Agencies may use any reliable data source and need not do new research unless it is essential to a reasoned choice among alternatives and the cost and time are not unreasonable. The statute sets no cutoff date for outside information.","now_cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336(b)(3)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336","baaja":"No federal agency would have to consider research that becomes public after the notice of intent or the decision to prepare an environmental document, and an agency could not delay past a deadline to wait for it. A savings clause leaves in place Administrative Procedure Act review of information in comments received during a comment period.","sections":["1106"],"quote":"No Federal agency shall be required to consider any scientific or technical research that becomes publicly available after the date of publication of a notice of intent or decision to prepare an environmental document","page":"courts","c":[43,12,43,17],"ts":[{"t":"No federal agency would have to consider research that becomes public after the notice of intent or the decision to prepare an environmental document, and an agency could not delay past a deadline to wait for it.","c":[43,12,43,16],"n":"1106"},{"t":"A savings clause leaves in place Administrative Procedure Act review of information in comments received during a comment period.","c":[44,2,44,5],"n":"1106"}]},{"id":"alternatives-scope","group":"comment","topic":"Alternatives the public can ask an agency to study","who":["public","tribes","states","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"An environmental impact statement studies a reasonable range of alternatives that are technically and economically feasible and meet the purpose and need.","now_cite":"42 U.S.C. 4332(2)(C)(iii)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4332","baaja":"The lead agency must eliminate any alternative, except no-action, that does not fulfill the purpose and need or meet the goals of an applicable non-federal sponsor. Cooperating agencies must consider only the alternatives the lead agency found reasonable. The statement of purpose and need would include the sponsor's goals.","sections":["1106","1102"],"quote":"a cooperating agency shall be bound by the purpose and need of the proposed agency action and consider only those alternatives to the proposed agency action that the lead agency has, consistent with paragraph (1)(C), determined are reasonable","quote_section":"1106","page":"courts","c":[41,22,42,3],"ts":[{"t":"The lead agency must eliminate any alternative, except no-action, that does not fulfill the purpose and need or meet the goals of an applicable non-federal sponsor.","c":[38,6,38,8],"n":"1106"},{"t":"Cooperating agencies must consider only the alternatives the lead agency found reasonable.","c":[41,22,42,1],"n":"1106"},{"t":"The statement of purpose and need would include the sponsor's goals.","c":[23,18,23,19],"n":"1102"}]},{"id":"tracker-portal","group":"comment","topic":"Public tracker and portal for large reviews","who":["public","local","landowners","tribes"],"effect":"expands","now":"The 2023 NEPA amendments called for a study of an online permitting portal, not for a portal or a project tracker.","now_cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336d","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336d","baaja":"CEQ would keep a public tracker with an entry for every project needing an EIS, and for any EA still open 13 months after its deadline. Entries show location, purpose and need, contacts for the sponsor and lead agency, schedule changes and litigation status. A common authorization portal, targeted for December 1, 2028, must include a way to tell local communities about notices of intent, public meetings and project status.","sections":["1132","1121"],"quote":"include a mechanism for the dissemination of relevant information (such as a notice of intent for public comment, public meetings, project statuses, or a notice of intent to begin an environmental review) to local communities, as applicable","quote_section":"1121","page":"courts","c":[86,21,87,2],"ts":[{"t":"CEQ would keep a public tracker with an entry for every project needing an EIS, and for any EA still open 13 months after its deadline.","c":[98,9,98,12],"n":"1132"},{"t":"Entries show location, purpose and need, contacts for the sponsor and lead agency, schedule changes and litigation status.","c":[99,10,99,13],"n":"1132"},{"t":"A common authorization portal, targeted for December 1, 2028, must include a way to tell local communities about notices of intent, public meetings and project status.","c":[86,24,87,2],"n":"1121"}]},{"id":"stakeholder-record","group":"comment","topic":"Record of the sponsor's outreach before applying","who":["local","tribes","public","states"],"effect":"changes","now":"The NEPA statute does not require a sponsor to file a record of its community outreach with an application.","baaja":"A sponsor would file, with its application, a record of stakeholder engagement of up to 20 pages. It lists pre-application contacts with state, local and tribal officials and community entities, the meeting dates, a brief summary of feedback and how feedback shaped the proposal. The bill requires the record, not any particular outreach.","sections":["1109","1102"],"quote":"a record of stakeholder engagement for the proposed agency action as of the date of the application","quote_section":"1109","page":"courts","c":[67,1,67,2],"ts":[{"t":"A sponsor would file, with its application, a record of stakeholder engagement of up to 20 pages.","c":[21,23,21,25],"n":"1102"},{"t":"It lists pre-application contacts with state, local and tribal officials and community entities, the meeting dates, a brief summary of feedback and how feedback shaped the proposal.","c":[22,14,22,18],"n":"1102"},{"t":"The bill requires the record, not any particular outreach.","c":[67,1,67,2],"n":"1109"}]},{"id":"statutory-exemptions","group":"comment","topic":"Corridor work and routine drilling placed outside NEPA","who":["public","tribes","landowners","consulting","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"Agencies can use categorical exclusions for some of this work. Five routine oil and gas activities on public land have a categorical exclusion that can be set aside in extraordinary circumstances.","now_cite":"42 U.S.C. 15942","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/15942","baaja":"Grid capacity work in or next to an existing right-of-way, and interstate gas pipeline repair, looping and compression in covered areas, would be outside NEPA and would not be a section 106 undertaking. Routine oil, gas and geothermal drilling activities on public and national forest land would not be a major Federal action and would carry no NEPA requirements. Clean Water Act and Clean Air Act duties remain for pipelines.","sections":["2102","2229"],"quote":"shall not be considered an undertaking for purposes of section 306108 of title 54, United States Code, if the covered activity remains within a covered area","quote_section":"2102","page":"courts","c":[204,22,204,25],"ts":[{"t":"Grid capacity work in or next to an existing right-of-way, and interstate gas pipeline repair, looping and compression in covered areas, would be outside NEPA and would not be a section 106 undertaking.","c":[204,22,204,25],"n":"2102"},{"t":"Routine oil, gas and geothermal drilling activities on public and national forest land would not be a major Federal action and would carry no NEPA requirements.","c":[351,2,351,8],"n":"2229"},{"t":"Clean Water Act and Clean Air Act duties remain for pipelines.","c":[205,4,205,8],"n":"2102"}]},{"id":"water-criteria-rulemaking","group":"comment","topic":"Public comment on federal water quality criteria","who":["public","states","tribes"],"effect":"expands","now":"EPA develops and publishes water quality criteria after consulting federal and state agencies and other interested persons. The statute does not require notice-and-comment rulemaking.","now_cite":"33 U.S.C. 1314(a)(1)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/33/1314","baaja":"EPA would have to use rulemaking under 5 U.S.C. 553 when it develops any section 304(a) criterion. Final criteria, and a definition of waters of the United States, would be added to the actions reviewed first in the courts of appeals under section 509(b)(1).","sections":["1201"],"quote":"In developing any criterion under this subsection, the Administrator shall carry out a rulemaking under section 553 of title 5, United States Code.","page":"water","c":[102,22,102,25],"ts":[{"t":"EPA would have to use rulemaking under 5 U.S.C. 553 when it develops any section 304(a) criterion.","c":[102,22,102,25],"n":"1201"},{"t":"Final criteria, and a definition of waters of the United States, would be added to the actions reviewed first in the courts of appeals under section 509(b)(1).","c":[103,6,103,9],"n":"1201"}]},{"id":"tribal-row-review","group":"comment","topic":"Environmental review of tribal rights-of-way","who":["tribes","public","landowners"],"effect":"changes","now":"The Secretary of the Interior grants rights-of-way across Indian land under the 1948 Act, as a federal decision.","now_cite":"25 U.S.C. 323","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/25/323","baaja":"A tribe could grant rights-of-way over its own land without Interior's approval if it follows a tribal regulation Interior has approved. The regulation must provide an environmental review that informs the public, gives a reasonable opportunity to comment and requires the tribe to answer each relevant and substantive comment before approval. Interior's approval of a tribal regulation is not subject to NEPA, section 106 or the Endangered Species Act.","sections":["2212"],"quote":"the Indian tribe provides a response to each relevant and substantive public comment on the significant environmental impacts identified by the Indian tribe under subclause (I) before the Indian tribe approves the right-of-way","page":"tribes","c":[293,3,293,10],"ts":[{"t":"A tribe could grant rights-of-way over its own land without Interior's approval if it follows a tribal regulation Interior has approved.","c":[291,12,291,14],"n":"2212"},{"t":"The regulation must provide an environmental review that informs the public, gives a reasonable opportunity to comment and requires the tribe to answer each relevant and substantive comment before approval.","c":[293,4,293,10],"n":"2212"},{"t":"Interior's approval of a tribal regulation is not subject to NEPA, section 106 or the Endangered Species Act.","c":[293,15,293,16],"n":"2212"}]},{"id":"cooperating-agencies","group":"consult","topic":"State, tribal and local governments as cooperating agencies","who":["states","tribes","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"A lead agency may designate any federal, state, tribal or local agency with jurisdiction by law or special expertise over an environmental impact as a cooperating agency. It may comment by the date in the schedule.","now_cite":"42 U.S.C. 4336a(a)(3)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4336a","baaja":"The designation test names jurisdiction by law over an environmental effect. It does not mention special expertise. The lead agency must identify and invite likely agencies within 30 days of the notice of intent or EA decision, and each has 7 days to accept or decline. A cooperating agency's comments are limited to matters within its jurisdiction by law, and designation gives it no authority over the action.","sections":["1106"],"quote":"Comments submitted by a cooperating agency under clause (i) shall be limited to matters relating to the jurisdiction by law of the cooperating agency","page":"courts","c":[41,6,41,10],"ts":[{"t":"The designation test names jurisdiction by law over an environmental effect.","c":[38,20,38,23],"n":"1106"},{"t":"It does not mention special expertise.","absent":true},{"t":"The lead agency must identify and invite likely agencies within 30 days of the notice of intent or EA decision, and each has 7 days to accept or decline.","c":[38,24,39,5],"n":"1106"},{"t":"A cooperating agency's comments are limited to matters within its jurisdiction by law, and designation gives it no authority over the action.","c":[41,8,41,10],"n":"1106"}]},{"id":"s106-who","group":"consult","topic":"Who is consulted under section 106","who":["consulting","tribes","states","local","public"],"effect":"narrows","now":"The statute says only that agencies must take into account effects on historic properties and give the Advisory Council a chance to comment. The Advisory Council's rules let individuals and organizations with a demonstrated interest join as consulting parties and require the agency to seek public input.","now_cite":"54 U.S.C. 306108; 36 CFR 800.2(c)(5), (d)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/54/306108","baaja":"The new consultation steps name state and tribal historic preservation officers, Indian tribes, Native Hawaiian organizations, local governments and the applicant. They do not name other consulting parties or the public. The agency 'may' consult the named parties on the area of effects and on historic properties, and must seek and, as applicable, incorporate their information if received within 30 days of a request. The agency's duty is limited to the area of potential effects it identifies.","sections":["2301"],"quote":"may consult with any applicable State Historic Preservation Officers, Tribal Historic Preservation Officers, Indian tribes, or Native Hawaiian organizations, local governments, and project, activity, or program applicants","page":"tribes","c":[387,11,387,16],"ts":[{"t":"The new consultation steps name state and tribal historic preservation officers, Indian tribes, Native Hawaiian organizations, local governments and the applicant.","c":[387,10,387,16],"n":"2301"},{"t":"They do not name other consulting parties or the public.","absent":true},{"t":"The agency 'may' consult the named parties on the area of effects and on historic properties, and must seek and, as applicable, incorporate their information if received within 30 days of a request.","c":[387,10,387,15],"n":"2301"},{"t":"The agency's duty is limited to the area of potential effects it identifies.","c":[386,3,386,6],"n":"2301"}]},{"id":"s106-scope","group":"consult","topic":"What counts as an effect or an undertaking under section 106","who":["consulting","tribes","states","local","public"],"effect":"narrows","now":"Review covers federal or federally assisted undertakings and federally licensed ones. Under the Advisory Council's rules, visual, atmospheric and audible effects can count.","now_cite":"54 U.S.C. 306108; 36 CFR part 800","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/54/306108","baaja":"An adverse effect must be reasonably foreseeable and directly alter a property's characteristics. Visual, atmospheric or audible elements count only if they directly and significantly diminish the property's eligible characteristics. An undertaking would exclude work where the only federal involvement is a loan, loan guarantee or grant not made for historic preservation, and the area of potential effects would exclude areas affected only by a non-federal part of a project.","sections":["2301"],"quote":"any visual, atmospheric, or audible element, unless the visual, atmospheric, or audible element would have a direct impact on a historic property that would significantly diminish the eligible characteristics of the historic property","page":"tribes","c":[380,13,380,18],"ts":[{"t":"An adverse effect must be reasonably foreseeable and directly alter a property's characteristics.","c":[380,4,380,7],"n":"2301"},{"t":"Visual, atmospheric or audible elements count only if they directly and significantly diminish the property's eligible characteristics.","c":[380,13,380,17],"n":"2301"},{"t":"An undertaking would exclude work where the only federal involvement is a loan, loan guarantee or grant not made for historic preservation, and the area of potential effects would exclude areas affected only by a non-federal part of a project.","c":[381,11,381,14],"n":"2301"}]},{"id":"s106-clocks","group":"consult","topic":"Deadlines in section 106 consultation","who":["consulting","tribes","states","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"The statute sets no deadlines for consultation.","now_cite":"54 U.S.C. 306108","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/54/306108","baaja":"The agency has 30 days to decide whether a proposal is an undertaking and 60 days after that to send a report when there are adverse effects. It then has 90 days to find the effects acceptable or reach an agreement, followed by 60 days of consultation, 45 days for formal Advisory Council comments and 30 days for a final determination. Consultation must end by the date the environmental document is due, unless the Secretary approves an extension for extraordinary circumstances.","sections":["2301"],"quote":"The consultation process initiated under subparagraph (A) shall be completed not later than the date on which the applicable environmental document under section 107(g) of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969","page":"tribes","c":[398,1,398,6],"ts":[{"t":"The agency has 30 days to decide whether a proposal is an undertaking and 60 days after that to send a report when there are adverse effects.","c":[386,8,386,10],"n":"2301"},{"t":"It then has 90 days to find the effects acceptable or reach an agreement, followed by 60 days of consultation, 45 days for formal Advisory Council comments and 30 days for a final determination.","c":[392,4,392,5],"n":"2301"},{"t":"Consultation must end by the date the environmental document is due, unless the Secretary approves an extension for extraordinary circumstances.","c":[398,3,398,6],"n":"2301"}]},{"id":"s106-objections","group":"consult","topic":"Silence and objections in section 106 consultation","who":["consulting","tribes","states","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"The statute requires the agency to take effects into account and give the Council a chance to comment. It does not address silence or objections.","now_cite":"54 U.S.C. 306108","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/54/306108","baaja":"If a preservation officer, tribe, Native Hawaiian organization or local government does not respond within 30 days of a request to review a report or finding, the agency proceeds. If a party raises substantive objections within 30 days, the agency has 30 days to explain how it considered them, and its duty to consult on that report is then fulfilled. The agency may decide, in its sole discretion, that other considerations outweigh historic preservation.","sections":["2301"],"quote":"shall provide a response explaining how the Federal agency has considered the substantive objections in the report","page":"tribes","c":[402,18,402,21],"ts":[{"t":"If a preservation officer, tribe, Native Hawaiian organization or local government does not respond within 30 days of a request to review a report or finding, the agency proceeds.","c":[400,16,400,19],"n":"2301"},{"t":"If a party raises substantive objections within 30 days, the agency has 30 days to explain how it considered them, and its duty to consult on that report is then fulfilled.","c":[402,18,402,21],"n":"2301"},{"t":"The agency may decide, in its sole discretion, that other considerations outweigh historic preservation.","c":[393,4,393,9],"n":"2301"}]},{"id":"s106-offices","group":"consult","topic":"Funding and oversight of state and tribal preservation offices","who":["states","tribes"],"effect":"changes","now":"Money in the Historic Preservation Fund is available for expenditure only when Congress appropriates it.","now_cite":"54 U.S.C. 303103","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/54/303103","baaja":"The bill authorizes $200,000,000 a year for the Fund for fiscal years 2027 to 2036 and makes deposits available from fiscal year 2028 without further appropriation. It adds $20,000,000 a year for fiscal years 2027 to 2030 in competitive grants for tribal preservation officers' online databases. Programs would be evaluated at least every 2 years, and a program that does not regularly meet consultation timelines is not consistent, which can lead to suspended grants and the Secretary taking over the officer's functions.","sections":["2302","2301"],"quote":"shall be made available for expenditure for fiscal year 2028 and each fiscal year thereafter, without further appropriation or fiscal year limitation","quote_section":"2302","page":"tribes","c":[414,17,414,19],"ts":[{"t":"The bill authorizes $200,000,000 a year for the Fund for fiscal years 2027 to 2036 and makes deposits available from fiscal year 2028 without further appropriation.","c":[414,15,414,18],"n":"2302"},{"t":"It adds $20,000,000 a year for fiscal years 2027 to 2030 in competitive grants for tribal preservation officers' online databases.","c":[416,24,417,2],"n":"2302"},{"t":"Programs would be evaluated at least every 2 years, and a program that does not regularly meet consultation timelines is not consistent, which can lead to suspended grants and the Secretary taking over the officer's functions.","c":[373,18,373,22],"n":"2301"}]},{"id":"esa-clock","group":"consult","topic":"Time for Endangered Species Act section 7 consultation","who":["states","tribes","public"],"effect":"narrows","now":"Formal consultation concludes within 90 days, and an extension to 150 days or more needs the applicant's consent. Consultation is between the wildlife agency, the federal agency and the permit applicant.","now_cite":"16 U.S.C. 1536(b)(1)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/16/1536","baaja":"The 90-day period becomes 60 days and the 150-day mark becomes 100 days. An applicant becomes eligible for relief under 5 U.S.C. 706(1) if an extended consultation passes 145 days without the required statement or consent. When an environmental document is required, consultation must finish by the date that document is due, unless the Secretary approves an extension for extraordinary circumstances.","sections":["1302"],"quote":"the consultation process under subsection (a)(2) shall be completed by not later than the date on which the applicable environmental document (as so defined) for the agency action is completed","page":"water","c":[136,4,136,8],"ts":[{"t":"The 90-day period becomes 60 days and the 150-day mark becomes 100 days.","c":[134,16,134,17],"n":"1302"},{"t":"An applicant becomes eligible for relief under 5 U.S.C. 706(1) if an extended consultation passes 145 days without the required statement or consent.","c":[135,18,135,21],"n":"1302"},{"t":"When an environmental document is required, consultation must finish by the date that document is due, unless the Secretary approves an extension for extraordinary circumstances.","c":[136,4,136,7],"n":"1302"}]},{"id":"esa-state-assumption","group":"consult","topic":"State-run Endangered Species Act consultation","reviewed_as":"State takeover of Endangered Species Act consultation","who":["states","public"],"effect":"expands","now":"Only the federal wildlife agencies consult under section 7. States cannot take over that role.","now_cite":"16 U.S.C. 1536(a)(2), (b)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/16/1536","baaja":"Interior could assign its consultation duties to a state by written agreement of up to 10 years, for projects within that state. The state must publish its complete application at least 60 days before filing, take public comment for at least 30 days and respond to comments. Audits for the first 4 years go out for public comment and Interior must respond within 60 days. District courts would hear suits against a state that fails to carry out its duties, under the same standards as against Interior. A permit applicant may still choose to consult Interior.","sections":["1304"],"quote":"a State shall be required to respond to public comments received under subparagraph (A)(ii)","page":"water","c":[143,22,143,24],"ts":[{"t":"Interior could assign its consultation duties to a state by written agreement of up to 10 years, for projects within that state.","c":[146,22,146,23],"n":"1304"},{"t":"The state must publish its complete application at least 60 days before filing, take public comment for at least 30 days and respond to comments.","c":[143,11,143,13],"n":"1304"},{"t":"Audits for the first 4 years go out for public comment and Interior must respond within 60 days.","c":[149,11,149,13],"n":"1304"},{"t":"District courts would hear suits against a state that fails to carry out its duties, under the same standards as against Interior.","c":[147,6,147,8],"n":"1304"},{"t":"A permit applicant may still choose to consult Interior.","c":[148,7,148,9],"n":"1304"}]},{"id":"s401-scope","group":"consult","topic":"What a state can deny or condition under Clean Water Act section 401","who":["states","tribes","local","public"],"effect":"narrows","now":"A state certifies that a federally permitted project meets water quality standards and other appropriate state law. Conditions it sets become conditions of the federal permit.","now_cite":"33 U.S.C. 1341(a), (d)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/33/1341","baaja":"Scope would be limited to 'water quality requirements', meaning sections 301, 302, 303, 306 and 307 and the federal, state and tribal laws implementing them. A certifying authority could deny only on clear and convincing evidence that no modification or reasonable condition would allow certification. Each condition needs clear and convincing evidence that it is necessary, the least burdensome and consistent with the federal permit.","sections":["1202"],"quote":"deny certification for any reason other than making a determination by clear and convincing evidence that no modification to or reasonable condition on the certification would make it possible to grant the certification without violating water quality requirements","page":"water","c":[105,1,105,7],"ts":[{"t":"Scope would be limited to 'water quality requirements', meaning sections 301, 302, 303, 306 and 307 and the federal, state and tribal laws implementing them.","c":[122,15,122,18],"n":"1202"},{"t":"A certifying authority could deny only on clear and convincing evidence that no modification or reasonable condition would allow certification.","c":[105,1,105,5],"n":"1202"},{"t":"Each condition needs clear and convincing evidence that it is necessary, the least burdensome and consistent with the federal permit.","c":[105,8,105,11],"n":"1202"}]},{"id":"s401-time","group":"consult","topic":"Time for a state to act on a section 401 certification","who":["states","tribes","public","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"A state must act within a reasonable period, not over one year, or the certification requirement is waived. States must set procedures for public notice of all applications and for public hearings to the extent they deem appropriate.","now_cite":"33 U.S.C. 1341(a)(1)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/33/1341","baaja":"The federal agency sets a reasonable period of up to 1 year that must account for time needed under state or tribal law for public notice and comment. An extension needs the applicant's written request and the state's written concurrence. Certifying authorities must keep procedures for public notice of all applications and, as they see fit, hearings. For interstate gas pipelines and interstate transmission lines the period is up to 9 months and certification covers only direct point-source discharges.","sections":["1202"],"quote":"a licensing or permitting agency shall, categorically or on a case-by-case basis for each certification application, establish a reasonable period of time (not to exceed 9 months from the date of receipt of the certification application)","page":"water","c":[121,12,121,16],"ts":[{"t":"The federal agency sets a reasonable period of up to 1 year that must account for time needed under state or tribal law for public notice and comment.","c":[114,18,114,21],"n":"1202"},{"t":"An extension needs the applicant's written request and the state's written concurrence.","c":[115,20,115,23],"n":"1202"},{"t":"Certifying authorities must keep procedures for public notice of all applications and, as they see fit, hearings.","c":[106,9,106,14],"n":"1202"},{"t":"For interstate gas pipelines and interstate transmission lines the period is up to 9 months and certification covers only direct point-source discharges.","c":[118,23,119,2],"n":"1202"}]},{"id":"nwp-reissue","group":"consult","topic":"Reissuing nationwide Clean Water Act permits","who":["states","tribes","public","consulting"],"effect":"narrows","now":"Nationwide permits and state discharge permits last 5 years. A 2020 court ruling required wildlife consultation to reissue a nationwide permit.","now_cite":"33 U.S.C. 1344(e)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/33/1344","baaja":"Reissuing a nationwide permit would need no state consultation under ESA section 6(a), no federal consultation under ESA section 7(a)(2) and no section 106 consultation, and NEPA would be met by a programmatic assessment, if the permit does not narrow or raise the threshold for preconstruction requirements. The Corps would consider only effects on water quality requirements and treat a discharge into less than 2 acres as minimal. General permits would last 10 years.","sections":["1204","1203"],"quote":"no consultation with a Federal agency pursuant to section 7(a)(2) of that Act (16 U.S.C. 1536(a)(2)) is required","quote_section":"1204","page":"water","c":[127,20,127,22],"ts":[{"t":"Reissuing a nationwide permit would need no state consultation under ESA section 6(a), no federal consultation under ESA section 7(a)(2) and no section 106 consultation, and NEPA would be met by a programmatic assessment, if the permit does not narrow or raise the threshold for preconstruction requirements.","c":[127,16,127,19],"n":"1204"},{"t":"The Corps would consider only effects on water quality requirements and treat a discharge into less than 2 acres as minimal.","c":[125,19,125,22],"n":"1204"},{"t":"General permits would last 10 years.","c":[125,2,125,3],"n":"1204"}]},{"id":"tribal-consent","group":"plan","topic":"Tribal consent to rights-of-way across tribal land","who":["tribes"],"effect":"expands","now":"A right-of-way across land of a tribe organized under the 1934 and 1936 Acts needs the consent of the proper tribal officials.","now_cite":"25 U.S.C. 324","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/25/324","baaja":"The bill strikes the references to the 1934 and 1936 Acts from that sentence, which as amended reads as covering lands of any tribe. A tribe could also grant rights-of-way itself under an approved regulation and set compensation and terms by negotiation or regulation. An approved regulation does not stop a tribe from consenting to a grant by Interior.","sections":["2212"],"quote":"organized under the Act of June 18, 1934 (48 Stat. 984), as amended; the Act of May 1, 1936 (49 Stat. 1250); or the Act of June 26, 1936 (49 Stat. 1967),","page":"tribes","c":[290,25,291,3],"ts":[{"t":"The bill strikes the references to the 1934 and 1936 Acts from that sentence, which as amended reads as covering lands of any tribe.","c":[290,25,291,3],"n":"2212"},{"t":"A tribe could also grant rights-of-way itself under an approved regulation and set compensation and terms by negotiation or regulation.","c":[298,9,298,11],"n":"2212"},{"t":"An approved regulation does not stop a tribe from consenting to a grant by Interior.","c":[298,5,298,8],"n":"2212"}]},{"id":"ferc-backstop","group":"plan","topic":"FERC siting of a line over a state's objection","who":["states","local","landowners","tribes","public"],"effect":"narrows","now":"FERC can permit a line only in a national interest corridor the Energy Department has designated, and only if the state lacks authority, has not decided within 1 year, has set conditions that make the line uneconomic, or has denied the application.","now_cite":"16 U.S.C. 824p(b)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/16/824p","baaja":"The corridor requirement is dropped. FERC 'shall' issue a permit for lines of 230 kilovolts or more that meet the findings, including one of the state-related triggers. The state's clock would start when the application is filed with the state. Developers of lines of 345 kilovolts or more could file at FERC at the same time as at the state, but FERC may not issue a permit until it makes one of the state-related findings.","sections":["2101"],"quote":"the electric transmission facilities are capable of transmitting electric energy at a voltage of not less than 230 kilovolts","page":"siting","c":[189,17,189,19],"ts":[{"t":"The corridor requirement is dropped.","c":[199,11,199,16],"n":"2101"},{"t":"FERC 'shall' issue a permit for lines of 230 kilovolts or more that meet the findings, including one of the state-related triggers.","c":[188,10,188,13],"n":"2101"},{"t":"The state's clock would start when the application is filed with the state.","c":[189,3,189,5],"n":"2101"},{"t":"Developers of lines of 345 kilovolts or more could file at FERC at the same time as at the state, but FERC may not issue a permit until it makes one of the state-related findings.","c":[192,5,192,8],"n":"2101"}]},{"id":"ferc-voices","group":"plan","topic":"Views before FERC in a siting case","who":["public","states","tribes","landowners","local"],"effect":"expands","now":"FERC must give each state, affected federal agency and tribe, private property owners and other interested persons a reasonable opportunity to present views on need and impact. The statute sets no minimum comment period.","now_cite":"16 U.S.C. 824p(d)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/16/824p","baaja":"FERC must hold a public comment period of at least 45 days and must take landowner input into account. Affected landowners include owners of land crossed, used as a facility site or abutting the right-of-way, owners of a residence within 500 feet of the right-of-way, and federal, state and local governments. A state may file any part of its state record, and FERC must consider it.","sections":["2101"],"quote":"In authorizing the construction or modification of an electric transmission facility under subsection (b), the Commission shall take into account landowner input.","page":"siting","c":[190,23,191,2],"ts":[{"t":"FERC must hold a public comment period of at least 45 days and must take landowner input into account.","c":[188,12,188,12],"n":"2101"},{"t":"Affected landowners include owners of land crossed, used as a facility site or abutting the right-of-way, owners of a residence within 500 feet of the right-of-way, and federal, state and local governments.","c":[187,8,187,10],"n":"2101"},{"t":"A state may file any part of its state record, and FERC must consider it.","c":[191,6,191,8],"n":"2101"}]},{"id":"eminent-domain","group":"plan","topic":"Eminent domain and compensation for a FERC-permitted line","who":["landowners","local"],"effect":"changes","now":"A permit holder that cannot agree on compensation, and that FERC finds made good-faith efforts to engage landowners early, may use eminent domain in federal or state court. Federal procedure follows state practice as nearly as practicable. Just compensation is fair market value including severance damages.","now_cite":"16 U.S.C. 824p(e), (f)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/16/824p","baaja":"Federal court procedure would follow Rule 71.1 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Section 2101(e) also strikes subsection (f) of section 216 and replaces it with a cost allocation subsection. As written, the statutory fair market value language would no longer appear in section 216. The text does not change the Fifth Amendment's just-compensation requirement.","sections":["2101"],"quote":"shall be in accordance with rule 71.1 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure","page":"siting","c":[192,13,192,14],"ts":[{"t":"Federal court procedure would follow Rule 71.1 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.","c":[192,13,192,14],"n":"2101"},{"t":"Section 2101(e) also strikes subsection (f) of section 216 and replaces it with a cost allocation subsection.","c":[192,17,192,19],"n":"2101"},{"t":"As written, the statutory fair market value language would no longer appear in section 216.","absent":true},{"t":"The text does not change the Fifth Amendment's just-compensation requirement.","absent":true}]},{"id":"jurisdiction-payments","group":"plan","topic":"Payments to places a transmission line crosses","who":["local","states"],"effect":"expands","now":"Section 219(b)(4) lists categories of costs FERC may allow utilities to recover as transmission rate incentives.","now_cite":"16 U.S.C. 824s(b)(4)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/16/824s","baaja":"The list would add all prudently incurred costs of payments to jurisdictions impacted by lines developed under section 216 or 225. The text does not require any payment or set an amount.","sections":["2101"],"quote":"all prudently incurred costs associated with payments to jurisdictions impacted by electric transmission facilities developed pursuant to section 216 or 225","page":"siting","c":[198,9,198,12],"ts":[{"t":"The list would add all prudently incurred costs of payments to jurisdictions impacted by lines developed under section 216 or 225.","c":[198,9,198,12],"n":"2101"},{"t":"The text does not require any payment or set an amount.","absent":true}]},{"id":"state-referral","group":"plan","topic":"States referring a utility's local transmission planning to FERC","who":["states","public","local"],"effect":"expands","now":"There is little federal review of transmission a utility plans for itself within its service territory.","baaja":"Within 1 year FERC must set procedures for states to refer a public utility for investigation of its local transmission planning. FERC must notice the investigation for public comment and certify a team that includes up to 3 state-appointed members, then notice the team's report for comment. Remedies include changed processes, a lower return on equity, loss of the prudence presumption and a fine of up to $5,000,000 per facility paid to the referring state.","sections":["2104"],"quote":"the Commission shall, by rule, establish procedures by which 1 or more States may refer a public utility to the Commission for an investigation into the processes used by the public utility for planning and developing local transmission facilities","page":"siting","c":[220,5,220,10],"ts":[{"t":"Within 1 year FERC must set procedures for states to refer a public utility for investigation of its local transmission planning.","c":[220,4,220,6],"n":"2104"},{"t":"FERC must notice the investigation for public comment and certify a team that includes up to 3 state-appointed members, then notice the team's report for comment.","c":[221,14,221,15],"n":"2104"},{"t":"Remedies include changed processes, a lower return on equity, loss of the prudence presumption and a fine of up to $5,000,000 per facility paid to the referring state.","c":[223,7,223,9],"n":"2104"}]},{"id":"selected-projects-deemed","group":"plan","topic":"Selected regional projects and FERC siting findings","who":["states","local","landowners","public"],"effect":"narrows","now":"For each permit, FERC must find that a line is in the public interest, protects or benefits consumers and meets the other findings before issuing a siting permit.","now_cite":"16 U.S.C. 824p(b)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/16/824p","baaja":"A project selected in a regional or joint interregional plan would be considered to satisfy the findings in paragraphs (2) through (5) and, if applicable, (6) of section 216(b). The planning section lists required process elements, and none addresses state or public participation. Approval of a planning process is not a major Federal action under NEPA.","sections":["2103"],"quote":"a project that is selected by 1 or more transmission planning regions pursuant to a regional or joint interregional transmission plan in accordance with this section shall be considered to satisfy paragraphs (2) through (5)","page":"siting","c":[217,9,217,13],"ts":[{"t":"A project selected in a regional or joint interregional plan would be considered to satisfy the findings in paragraphs (2) through (5) and, if applicable, (6) of section 216(b).","c":[217,12,217,14],"n":"2103"},{"t":"The planning section lists required process elements, and none addresses state or public participation.","c":[214,9,214,12],"n":"2103"},{"t":"Approval of a planning process is not a major Federal action under NEPA.","c":[218,5,218,8],"n":"2103"}]},{"id":"nepa-sol","group":"challenge","topic":"Time to sue over a NEPA decision","who":["public","tribes","states","local","landowners"],"effect":"narrows","now":"A suit against a federal agency generally must be filed within 6 years. Projects covered by FAST-41 have a 2-year limit.","now_cite":"28 U.S.C. 2401(a); 42 U.S.C. 4370m-6","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/2401","baaja":"A claim that an environmental review was not properly conducted under NEPA would be barred unless filed within 150 days after the authorization is published in the Federal Register (where an EIS was prepared) or made public (any other case), unless a shorter deadline applies. A supplemental document required by court order starts a new 150-day clock, and the claim is limited to information not in the earlier document.","sections":["1110"],"quote":"is filed not later than 150 days after the date on which, unless a shorter deadline is specified under Federal law","page":"courts","c":[68,1,68,3],"ts":[{"t":"A claim that an environmental review was not properly conducted under NEPA would be barred unless filed within 150 days after the authorization is published in the Federal Register (where an EIS was prepared) or made public (any other case), unless a shorter deadline applies.","c":[68,1,68,3],"n":"1110"},{"t":"A supplemental document required by court order starts a new 150-day clock, and the claim is limited to information not in the earlier document.","c":[72,10,72,13],"n":"1110"}]},{"id":"nepa-who-can-sue","group":"challenge","topic":"Who can bring a NEPA claim","who":["public","tribes","local","landowners"],"effect":"narrows","now":"Any party with standing who is adversely affected may sue. The comment-first requirement applies to FAST-41 covered projects, not to NEPA claims generally.","now_cite":"42 U.S.C. 4370m-6","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/42/4370m-6","baaja":"Where an opportunity for comment was provided, the plaintiff must have submitted a substantive comment, detailed enough to put the agency on notice of the issue, during a public comment period. The plaintiff, or one of its members, must allege an actual or imminent injury in fact amounting to a direct harm. The section says it does not create a cause of action.","sections":["1110"],"quote":"in the case of an authorization for which an opportunity for comment was provided, the claim is filed by a party that submitted a substantive comment during a public comment period associated with that authorization","page":"courts","c":[68,10,68,14],"ts":[{"t":"Where an opportunity for comment was provided, the plaintiff must have submitted a substantive comment, detailed enough to put the agency on notice of the issue, during a public comment period.","c":[68,11,68,14],"n":"1110"},{"t":"The plaintiff, or one of its members, must allege an actual or imminent injury in fact amounting to a direct harm.","c":[68,18,68,20],"n":"1110"},{"t":"The section says it does not create a cause of action.","c":[74,9,74,11],"n":"1110"}]},{"id":"nepa-court","group":"challenge","topic":"Which court hears a NEPA claim","who":["public","tribes","states","local","landowners"],"effect":"changes","now":"Claims go to a federal district court unless another statute sends them to a court of appeals.","baaja":"The court of appeals for the circuit where the project will be built or operated would have original and exclusive jurisdiction, with supplemental jurisdiction over related claims on the authorization's validity. Judges are to be randomly assigned to the maximum extent practicable. Courts must give substantial deference to the agency on the scope and contents of the document and must rule 'as expeditiously as possible', with no fixed deadline.","sections":["1110"],"quote":"The court of appeals of the United States for the circuit in which a project subject to an authorization will be constructed, expanded, or operated shall have original and exclusive jurisdiction over a claim.","page":"courts","c":[68,22,69,2],"ts":[{"t":"The court of appeals for the circuit where the project will be built or operated would have original and exclusive jurisdiction, with supplemental jurisdiction over related claims on the authorization's validity.","c":[68,22,69,2],"n":"1110"},{"t":"Judges are to be randomly assigned to the maximum extent practicable.","c":[69,9,69,12],"n":"1110"},{"t":"Courts must give substantial deference to the agency on the scope and contents of the document and must rule 'as expeditiously as possible', with no fixed deadline.","c":[73,25,74,2],"n":"1110"}]},{"id":"nepa-remedy","group":"challenge","topic":"Remedy when a court finds a NEPA violation","who":["public","tribes","states","local","landowners"],"effect":"narrows","now":"Courts may vacate the approval or enjoin the project.","baaja":"The only remedy would be a remand without vacatur or injunction, with instructions and a deadline of no more than 180 days. The authorization stays in effect and the project may proceed during the remand. A preliminary injunction is allowed only if the authorization is likely to violate a federal law other than NEPA and the National Historic Preservation Act, and the usual harm, equity and public interest tests are met.","sections":["1110"],"quote":"the only remedy the court may order to redress that violation is to remand, without vacatur or issuance of an injunction","page":"courts","c":[69,24,70,1],"ts":[{"t":"The only remedy would be a remand without vacatur or injunction, with instructions and a deadline of no more than 180 days.","c":[69,24,70,1],"n":"1110"},{"t":"The authorization stays in effect and the project may proceed during the remand.","c":[71,15,71,18],"n":"1110"},{"t":"A preliminary injunction is allowed only if the authorization is likely to violate a federal law other than NEPA and the National Historic Preservation Act, and the usual harm, equity and public interest tests are met.","c":[70,18,70,23],"n":"1110"}]},{"id":"nepa-tribal-trust","group":"challenge","topic":"NEPA challenges to actions on tribal trust land","who":["tribes","public","states","local"],"effect":"changes","now":"There is no separate rule for actions on tribal trust land. The general NEPA rules apply.","baaja":"For an action authorizing use of land, minerals or other resources held in trust for a tribe, there would be no administrative or judicial review based on a failure to comply with NEPA. The exceptions are a claim by the tribe whose trust resources are used and a claim about reasonably foreseeable effects outside those resources. For tribe-initiated actions, the lead agency must presume the no-action alternative has negative effects.","sections":["1110","1106"],"quote":"there shall be no administrative or judicial review of such final agency action based on a claim of failure to comply with the requirements of this Act","quote_section":"1110","page":"tribes","c":[73,8,73,11],"ts":[{"t":"For an action authorizing use of land, minerals or other resources held in trust for a tribe, there would be no administrative or judicial review based on a failure to comply with NEPA.","c":[73,8,73,11],"n":"1110"},{"t":"The exceptions are a claim by the tribe whose trust resources are used and a claim about reasonably foreseeable effects outside those resources.","c":[73,15,73,17],"n":"1110"},{"t":"For tribe-initiated actions, the lead agency must presume the no-action alternative has negative effects.","c":[37,24,38,3],"n":"1106"}]},{"id":"nepa-outreach-record","group":"challenge","topic":"Claims over gaps in the sponsor's outreach record","who":["public","local","tribes"],"effect":"narrows","now":"No such record is required today, so no claim arises over it.","baaja":"There would be no claim or judicial review of whether a final agency action complies with NEPA for any omission from the list described in section 3(22)(B). In the bill's definitions that list is the sponsor's pre-application engagement with state, local and tribal officials and community entities.","sections":["1110","1102"],"quote":"there shall not be a claim or judicial review of whether a final agency action complies with the requirements of this Act for any omission from the list described in section 3(22)(B)","quote_section":"1110","page":"courts","c":[74,5,74,8],"ts":[{"t":"There would be no claim or judicial review of whether a final agency action complies with NEPA for any omission from the list described in section 3(22)(B).","c":[74,5,74,8],"n":"1110"},{"t":"In the bill's definitions that list is the sponsor's pre-application engagement with state, local and tribal officials and community entities.","c":[22,10,22,14],"n":"1102"}]},{"id":"energy-sol","group":"challenge","topic":"Time to sue over energy and mineral permits under any federal law","who":["public","tribes","states","local","landowners"],"effect":"narrows","now":"A suit against a federal agency generally must be filed within 6 years.","now_cite":"28 U.S.C. 2401(a)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/2401","baaja":"A civil action under federal law seeking review of a final agency action granting or denying an authorization for an energy, carbon capture or mineral project would be barred unless filed within 150 days after the action is made public, which must happen within 3 days of the action. Courts must expedite, and a remand deadline is up to 180 days unless a longer time is needed to comply with law.","sections":["2201"],"quote":"a civil action arising under Federal law seeking judicial review of a final agency action granting or denying an authorization shall be barred unless the civil action is filed by the date that is 150 days after","page":"courts","c":[284,10,284,14],"ts":[{"t":"A civil action under federal law seeking review of a final agency action granting or denying an authorization for an energy, carbon capture or mineral project would be barred unless filed within 150 days after the action is made public, which must happen within 3 days of the action.","c":[284,12,284,15],"n":"2201"},{"t":"Courts must expedite, and a remand deadline is up to 180 days unless a longer time is needed to comply with law.","c":[284,22,284,25],"n":"2201"}]},{"id":"s404-courts","group":"challenge","topic":"Challenges to Clean Water Act section 404 permits","who":["public","tribes","states","local","landowners"],"effect":"narrows","now":"A suit generally has a 6-year limit, is heard in district court, and the ordinary remedies apply.","now_cite":"28 U.S.C. 2401(a)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/2401","baaja":"Suits over individual and general permits, verifications under a general permit, and EPA approval of a state permit program would be barred unless filed within 150 days. Where a draft was published in the Federal Register with at least 30 days of comment, the plaintiff must have filed a detailed comment and the claim must relate to it. A court must remand and may not vacate or enjoin a permit unless activities would present an imminent and substantial danger to human health or the environment for which no other equitable remedy is available.","sections":["1205"],"quote":"of an individual permit or general permit issued under this section shall be filed not later than the date that is 150 days after the date on which the permit was issued","page":"water","c":[129,19,129,23],"ts":[{"t":"Suits over individual and general permits, verifications under a general permit, and EPA approval of a state permit program would be barred unless filed within 150 days.","c":[129,21,129,23],"n":"1205"},{"t":"Where a draft was published in the Federal Register with at least 30 days of comment, the plaintiff must have filed a detailed comment and the claim must relate to it.","c":[131,1,131,5],"n":"1205"},{"t":"A court must remand and may not vacate or enjoin a permit unless activities would present an imminent and substantial danger to human health or the environment for which no other equitable remedy is available.","c":[132,9,132,13],"n":"1205"}]},{"id":"esa-biop-suit","group":"challenge","topic":"Time and court for challenges to biological opinions","who":["public","states","tribes","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"Challenges to a biological opinion are brought under general law with a 6-year default limit.","now_cite":"28 U.S.C. 2401(a)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/2401","baaja":"Any person could seek review of a biological opinion only in the D.C. Circuit, by a petition filed within 150 days after the opinion is made public on the agency's website.","sections":["1305"],"quote":"in the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit by filing in such court not later than 150 days after the date on which the opinion is made public a written petition for review","page":"water","c":[154,17,154,21],"ts":[{"t":"Any person could seek review of a biological opinion only in the D.C. Circuit, by a petition filed within 150 days after the opinion is made public on the agency's website.","c":[154,18,154,20],"n":"1305"}]},{"id":"s106-suit","group":"challenge","topic":"Time, comment and court rules for section 106 claims","who":["consulting","public","tribes","states","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"A section 106 decision is challenged under the Administrative Procedure Act with a 6-year default limit. The statute has no comment-first rule.","now_cite":"28 U.S.C. 2401(a)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/28/2401","baaja":"A claim would be barred unless filed within 150 days after the later of the final agency action being made public and the preservation officer being notified. The plaintiff must have suffered or imminently will suffer direct harm and, where there was a comment period, filed a substantive and unique comment by the noticed deadline on the same subject. Claims go to the courts of appeals, with substantial deference to the agency.","sections":["2301"],"quote":"the claim is filed not later than 150 days after the later of","page":"tribes","c":[408,23,408,25],"ts":[{"t":"A claim would be barred unless filed within 150 days after the later of the final agency action being made public and the preservation officer being notified.","c":[408,23,409,2],"n":"2301"},{"t":"The plaintiff must have suffered or imminently will suffer direct harm and, where there was a comment period, filed a substantive and unique comment by the noticed deadline on the same subject.","c":[409,9,409,12],"n":"2301"},{"t":"Claims go to the courts of appeals, with substantial deference to the agency.","c":[406,14,406,17],"n":"2301"}]},{"id":"s106-gov-exemption","group":"challenge","topic":"Governments that raise issues in consultation keep their right to sue","who":["tribes","states","local","consulting"],"effect":"changes","now":"No comment-first rule applies today to section 106 claims.","baaja":"The direct-harm and comment requirements would not apply where a state or tribal preservation officer, tribe, Native Hawaiian organization or local government gave detailed written notice during consultation that identified the issues. The exemption does not name other consulting parties or the public.","sections":["2301"],"quote":"a claim in which a State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, or local government has provided detailed notice in writing during the consultation process","page":"tribes","c":[410,9,410,15],"ts":[{"t":"The direct-harm and comment requirements would not apply where a state or tribal preservation officer, tribe, Native Hawaiian organization or local government gave detailed written notice during consultation that identified the issues.","c":[410,13,410,17],"n":"2301"},{"t":"The exemption does not name other consulting parties or the public.","absent":true}]},{"id":"s106-remedy","group":"challenge","topic":"Remedy when a court finds a section 106 violation","who":["consulting","public","tribes","states","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"Courts may vacate or enjoin under ordinary remedies.","baaja":"The only remedy would be a remand without vacatur or injunction, with a deadline of no more than 180 days. A preliminary injunction is allowed only if the action likely violates a federal law other than the historic preservation division of title 54 or NEPA, and the usual tests are met.","sections":["2301"],"quote":"the only remedy the court may order is to remand, without vacatur or issuance of an injunction, the applicable agency action to the Federal agency","page":"tribes","c":[406,25,407,3],"ts":[{"t":"The only remedy would be a remand without vacatur or injunction, with a deadline of no more than 180 days.","c":[406,25,407,3],"n":"2301"},{"t":"A preliminary injunction is allowed only if the action likely violates a federal law other than the historic preservation division of title 54 or NEPA, and the usual tests are met.","c":[407,18,407,22],"n":"2301"}]},{"id":"s106-programmatic","group":"challenge","topic":"Challenges to section 106 programmatic agreements","who":["consulting","tribes","public","states","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"The statute says nothing about programmatic agreements. The Advisory Council's rules allow them.","baaja":"Only signatories could sue over how a programmatic agreement is implemented; no court would have jurisdiction over a suit by anyone else. Federal agencies must develop programmatic agreements for routine and repetitive categories, and a state or tribal officer's agreement for the same category would apply.","sections":["2301"],"quote":"A party that is not a signatory to a programmatic agreement entered into for purposes of this subsection may not bring a civil action to challenge the implementation of the programmatic agreement.","page":"tribes","c":[412,24,413,3],"ts":[{"t":"Only signatories could sue over how a programmatic agreement is implemented; no court would have jurisdiction over a suit by anyone else.","c":[412,24,413,2],"n":"2301"},{"t":"Federal agencies must develop programmatic agreements for routine and repetitive categories, and a state or tribal officer's agreement for the same category would apply.","c":[404,12,404,16],"n":"2301"}]},{"id":"s401-courts","group":"challenge","topic":"Court review of state certification decisions","who":["states","tribes","public","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"Section 401 sets no burden of proof for review of a denial or condition.","now_cite":"33 U.S.C. 1341","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/33/1341","baaja":"A court reviewing a denial must put the burden on the certifying authority to show by clear and convincing evidence that no reasonable modification or condition would allow certification. For a challenged condition, the authority must show by clear and convincing evidence that it is necessary, least burdensome and consistent with the federal permit. A waiver of certification would not be subject to judicial review.","sections":["1202"],"quote":"a court shall place the burden of proof on the certifying authority to demonstrate, by clear and convincing evidence, that no reasonable modifications to or reasonable conditions on the certification would make it possible to grant the certification","page":"water","c":[117,5,117,10],"ts":[{"t":"A court reviewing a denial must put the burden on the certifying authority to show by clear and convincing evidence that no reasonable modification or condition would allow certification.","c":[117,5,117,9],"n":"1202"},{"t":"For a challenged condition, the authority must show by clear and convincing evidence that it is necessary, least burdensome and consistent with the federal permit.","c":[117,14,117,17],"n":"1202"},{"t":"A waiver of certification would not be subject to judicial review.","c":[116,8,116,10],"n":"1202"}]},{"id":"permit-revocation","group":"challenge","topic":"Asking an agency to revoke or change an issued permit","who":["public","tribes","states","local"],"effect":"narrows","now":"Agencies may revoke, suspend or amend authorizations under their own statutes and permit terms, subject to court review.","baaja":"For projects with non-federal sponsors, a federal agency could not take new action to revoke, suspend, amend or alter an authorization in effect on or after September 16, 2026, except in five cases. These include a court order, a material breach or violation of law, fraud, a need to prevent specific, urgent, substantial and proximate harm based on new information, or a request from the holder. The agency carries the burden by clear and convincing evidence.","sections":["1401"],"quote":"a Federal department or agency shall not take any new action that would revoke, rescind, withdraw, terminate, suspend, amend, or alter a Federal authorization or permit in effect on or after September 16, 2026","page":"courts","c":[159,11,159,15],"ts":[{"t":"For projects with non-federal sponsors, a federal agency could not take new action to revoke, suspend, amend or alter an authorization in effect on or after September 16, 2026, except in five cases.","c":[159,12,159,15],"n":"1401"},{"t":"These include a court order, a material breach or violation of law, fraud, a need to prevent specific, urgent, substantial and proximate harm based on new information, or a request from the holder.","c":[160,6,160,9],"n":"1401"},{"t":"The agency carries the burden by clear and convincing evidence.","c":[162,4,162,6],"n":"1401"}]},{"id":"tribal-row-petition","group":"challenge","topic":"Objecting to a tribe's handling of a right-of-way","who":["public","landowners","local","tribes"],"effect":"expands","now":"The Secretary of the Interior grants rights-of-way across Indian land.","now_cite":"25 U.S.C. 323","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/25/323","baaja":"An interested party that has exhausted tribal remedies could petition Interior to review a tribe's compliance with its approved regulation. If Interior finds a violation it may act, including rescinding approval of the regulation, after the tribe gets a formal hearing and a chance to cure.","sections":["2212"],"quote":"An interested party, after exhaustion of any applicable Tribal remedies, may submit a petition to the Secretary of the Interior","page":"tribes","c":[296,10,296,12],"ts":[{"t":"An interested party that has exhausted tribal remedies could petition Interior to review a tribe's compliance with its approved regulation.","c":[296,10,296,12],"n":"2212"},{"t":"If Interior finds a violation it may act, including rescinding approval of the regulation, after the tribe gets a formal hearing and a chance to cure.","c":[296,20,296,24],"n":"2212"}]},{"id":"transmission-courts","group":"challenge","topic":"Courts for challenges to transmission authorizations","who":["states","public","local","landowners","tribes"],"effect":"changes","now":"Section 216(h) has no judicial review provision. Review follows each underlying law.","now_cite":"16 U.S.C. 824p(h)","now_url":"https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/16/824p","baaja":"Any order of a federal agency, or of a state agency acting under federal law, to issue, condition or deny a federal authorization for a transmission facility would be reviewed in the courts that review FERC orders under Federal Power Act section 313. 'Federal authorization' would include a Clean Water Act section 401 certification and other state approvals required under federal law, except under the Coastal Zone Management Act.","sections":["2101"],"quote":"shall be subject to judicial review in the same courts in which an order of the Commission is subject to judicial review under section 313","page":"siting","c":[197,5,197,7],"ts":[{"t":"Any order of a federal agency, or of a state agency acting under federal law, to issue, condition or deny a federal authorization for a transmission facility would be reviewed in the courts that review FERC orders under Federal Power Act section 313.","c":[197,5,197,7],"n":"2101"},{"t":"'Federal authorization' would include a Clean Water Act section 401 certification and other state approvals required under federal law, except under the Coastal Zone Management Act.","c":[195,11,195,13],"n":"2101"}]}]},"datacenters":{"_about":"What BAAJA does for data centers, high-density computing loads and grid speed. The build checks each quote against the cited section.","intro":"What the bill would change for data centers, AI computing facilities and grid interconnection: study automation, transmission rates, grid-enhancing technologies, behind-the-meter resources and cost allocation.","who":{"hyperscalers":"Hyperscalers & AI","data_centers":"Data center operators","btm_power":"Behind-the-meter power & VPPs","grid_operators":"Grid operators & utilities","ratepayers":"Ratepayers & states"},"groups":[{"id":"speed","label":"Interconnection speed and study automation"},{"id":"pricing","label":"Transmission rates and non-firm service"},{"id":"grid-tech","label":"Advanced grid technologies and reconductoring"},{"id":"btm","label":"Behind-the-meter generation and virtual power plants"},{"id":"protection","label":"Cost allocation and financial assurance"}],"rows":[{"id":"study-automation","group":"speed","topic":"Interconnection study automation and AI evaluation","who":["hyperscalers","data_centers","grid_operators"],"effect":"changes","now":"Transmission providers evaluate interconnection requests using manual engineering studies and cluster studies under FERC Order No. 2023, with no federal automation mandate.","now_cite":"FERC Order No. 2023, 88 FR 61014 (2023)","now_url":"https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/09/06/2023-16597/improvements-to-generator-interconnection-procedures-and-agreements","baaja":"Directs FERC to initiate a rulemaking within 1 year requiring public utility transmission providers to share and employ queue management practices using artificial intelligence, machine learning, and automation to evaluate and process interconnection requests faster, revisited every 4 years.","sections":["2110"],"quote":"to require public utility transmission providers to share and employ, as appropriate, queue management practices with respect to the use of computing technologies, including artificial intelligence, machine learning, and automation","c":[265,18,265,22],"ts":[{"t":"Directs FERC to initiate a rulemaking within 1 year requiring public utility transmission providers to share and employ queue management practices using artificial intelligence, machine learning, and automation to evaluate and process interconnection requests faster, revisited every 4 years.","c":[265,14,265,17],"n":"2110"}]},{"id":"grid-data-deadlines","group":"speed","topic":"15-day default deadline for grid study data","who":["hyperscalers","data_centers","grid_operators"],"effect":"expands","now":"Interconnection studies are frequently delayed by months while transmission providers wait for neighboring utilities or bulk-power system users to furnish network models and engineering data.","now_cite":"FERC Order No. 2023, 88 FR 61014 (2023)","now_url":"https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/09/06/2023-16597/improvements-to-generator-interconnection-procedures-and-agreements","baaja":"Adds Federal Power Act section 232. Bulk-power system users, owners, and operators must provide requested grid data within 15 days (unless FERC sets an alternative timeline for a data category) in a format the requester can use or convert. Confidentiality rules cannot be used to withhold data; violations by public utilities are subject to FPA section 316A reliability enforcement penalties, with other entities subject to FERC compliance orders.","sections":["2111"],"quote":"shall provide requested grid data not later than 15 days after receiving the request.","c":[268,21,268,23],"ts":[{"t":"Adds Federal Power Act section 232.","c":[266,8,266,10],"n":"2111"},{"t":"Bulk-power system users, owners, and operators must provide requested grid data within 15 days (unless FERC sets an alternative timeline for a data category) in a format the requester can use or convert.","c":[268,20,268,23],"n":"2111"},{"t":"Confidentiality rules cannot be used to withhold data; violations by public utilities are subject to FPA section 316A reliability enforcement penalties, with other entities subject to FERC compliance orders.","c":[270,15,270,16],"n":"2111"}]},{"id":"automated-spec","group":"speed","topic":"Standardized reference spec for fully automated studies","who":["hyperscalers","data_centers","grid_operators"],"effect":"changes","now":"Each regional grid operator and utility maintains its own engineering criteria and software workflows.","now_cite":"RMI on FERC's June 2026 orders","now_url":"https://rmi.org/resources/understanding-fercs-large-load-orders/","baaja":"Requires FERC and the Department of Energy to publish, within 1 year, a joint reference specification for fully automated interconnection studies, including system impact studies, without supplemental data requests during the study process.","sections":["2111"],"quote":"to enable full automation of interconnection studies, including system impact studies, without supplemental data requests during the study.","c":[272,1,272,4],"ts":[{"t":"Requires FERC and the Department of Energy to publish, within 1 year, a joint reference specification for fully automated interconnection studies, including system impact studies, without supplemental data requests during the study process.","c":[271,23,272,3],"n":"2111"}]},{"id":"cost-reduction-options","group":"speed","topic":"Standardized cost-reduction options in upgrade studies","who":["hyperscalers","data_centers","grid_operators"],"effect":"changes","now":"Grid operators currently lack standardized large-load study processes and cost-reduction options, prompting FERC in June 2026 to direct RTOs to develop standardized study rules and flexible service.","now_cite":"RMI on FERC's June 2026 orders","now_url":"https://rmi.org/resources/understanding-fercs-large-load-orders/","baaja":"Requires FERC rules for a standardized analysis to identify upgrades for computational load sites and cost-reduction options.","sections":["2107"],"quote":"to require standardized analysis to identify upgrades for a computational load site and cost reduction options, as the Commission may require by rule.","c":[231,5,231,8],"ts":[{"t":"Requires FERC rules for a standardized analysis to identify upgrades for computational load sites and cost-reduction options.","c":[231,5,231,8],"n":"2107"}]},{"id":"non-firm-discount","group":"pricing","topic":"Mandatory transmission rate discount for non-firm computational load","who":["hyperscalers","data_centers","grid_operators"],"effect":"expands","now":"FERC's 1994 pricing policy allows flexible or negotiated transmission rates, but establishes no statutory requirement for discounted rates when computational loads accept non-firm service.","now_cite":"FERC pricing policy statement, 59 FR 55031 (1994)","now_url":"https://archives.federalregister.gov/issue_slice/1994/11/3/55026-55045.pdf","baaja":"Directs FERC to revise its 1994 pricing policy statement within 270 days to provide a lower cost of transmission service for computational loads that elect non-firm transmission service, followed by a proposed rule within 270 days and a final rule within 1 year.","sections":["2107"],"quote":"provide for a lower cost of transmission service for eligible customers seeking transmission service on behalf of computational load owners and computational load operators that elect non-firm transmission service.","c":[230,9,230,14],"ts":[{"t":"Directs FERC to revise its 1994 pricing policy statement within 270 days to provide a lower cost of transmission service for computational loads that elect non-firm transmission service, followed by a proposed rule within 270 days and a final rule within 1 year.","c":[231,9,231,12],"n":"2107"}]},{"id":"firm-pricing-baseline","group":"pricing","topic":"Standard firm transmission pricing baseline ('and' pricing)","who":["hyperscalers","data_centers","ratepayers"],"effect":"narrows","now":"Under FERC's 1994 policy statement, utilities charge the higher of embedded costs or incremental expansion costs ('or' pricing) rather than their sum, though separate facilities may be priced on different bases.","now_cite":"FERC pricing policy statement, 59 FR 55031 (1994)","now_url":"https://archives.federalregister.gov/issue_slice/1994/11/3/55026-55045.pdf","baaja":"Declares it unjust and unreasonable under FPA sections 205 and 206 to charge computational loads less than embedded costs plus incremental expansion costs ('and' pricing). Directs that incremental revenues be credited to the utility's annual transmission revenue requirement to prevent double recovery from other customers.","sections":["2107"],"quote":"charge less than the embedded costs and incremental expansion costs to eligible customers seeking transmission service from computational load owners and computational load operators","c":[226,25,227,4],"ts":[{"t":"Declares it unjust and unreasonable under FPA sections 205 and 206 to charge computational loads less than embedded costs plus incremental expansion costs ('and' pricing).","c":[226,25,227,4],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Directs that incremental revenues be credited to the utility's annual transmission revenue requirement to prevent double recovery from other customers.","c":[230,1,230,5],"n":"2107"}]},{"id":"flexible-tariffs-codified","group":"pricing","topic":"Codification of flexible and interim transmission service","who":["hyperscalers","data_centers","grid_operators"],"effect":"expands","now":"Flexible interconnection tariffs vary by utility and RTO, with no statutory federal definition of non-firm or contract demand transmission service for large computing loads.","now_cite":"Utility Dive on FERC large load orders","now_url":"https://www.utilitydive.com/news/ferc-doe-data-center-interconnection/823360/","baaja":"Statutorily defines transmission service categories under FPA section 228, explicitly including network integration, point-to-point, and any interim, non-firm, or contract demand service that limits the quantity of energy withdrawn or operating conditions.","sections":["2107"],"quote":"any interim, non-firm, contract demand, or other service that limits","c":[234,15,234,16],"ts":[{"t":"Statutorily defines transmission service categories under FPA section 228, explicitly including network integration, point-to-point, and any interim, non-firm, or contract demand service that limits the quantity of energy withdrawn or operating conditions.","c":[234,15,234,16],"n":"2107"}]},{"id":"att-mandate","group":"grid-tech","topic":"Mandatory deployment of advanced transmission technologies","who":["hyperscalers","data_centers","grid_operators"],"effect":"expands","now":"FERC Order No. 1920 requires transmission providers to consider advanced technologies (dynamic line ratings, power flow control, topology optimization) in regional planning, but does not compel utilities to build them.","now_cite":"FERC Order No. 1920, 89 FR 49704 (2024)","now_url":"https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2024/06/11/2024-10609/building-for-the-future-through-electric-regional-transmission-planning-and-cost-allocation","baaja":"Requires public utilities to use advanced transmission technologies in covered projects whenever benefits exceed costs, backed by a presumption of prudence and return-on-equity reduction penalties for non-compliance.","sections":["2109"],"quote":"the Commission shall require that public utilities use advanced transmission technologies, including best-available transmission conductors, when carrying out covered projects.","c":[261,13,261,16],"ts":[{"t":"Requires public utilities to use advanced transmission technologies in covered projects whenever benefits exceed costs, backed by a presumption of prudence and return-on-equity reduction penalties for non-compliance.","c":[261,13,261,16],"n":"2109"}]},{"id":"reconductoring-ce","group":"grid-tech","topic":"NEPA and historic preservation categorical exclusion for reconductoring","who":["hyperscalers","grid_operators"],"effect":"expands","now":"Agencies like DOE maintain administrative categorical exclusions for some reconductoring, but there is no statutory cross-agency exclusion, and projects across federal lands lack statutory exemption from NHPA section 106 consultation.","now_cite":"10 CFR Part 1021, Subpart D, App. B (B4.6)","now_url":"https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-10/chapter-X/part-1021/subpart-D/appendix-Appendix%20B%20to%20Subpart%20D%20of%20Part%201021","baaja":"Adds Federal Power Act section 216A: work that maintains or increases grid capacity in an existing right-of-way or necessary adjacent area (reconductoring, higher voltage, advanced conductors, added circuits) is designated as categorically excluded from NEPA and exempt from NHPA section 106 undertakings.","sections":["2102"],"quote":"Activities to maintain or increase the capacity of the electric grid within a covered area, and any Federal agency action authorizing such activities— “(A) are a category of actions designated as being categorically excluded","c":[201,19,201,24],"ts":[{"t":"Adds Federal Power Act section 216A: work that maintains or increases grid capacity in an existing right-of-way or necessary adjacent area (reconductoring, higher voltage, advanced conductors, added circuits) is designated as categorically excluded from NEPA and exempt from NHPA section 106 undertakings.","c":[201,23,202,1],"n":"2102"}]},{"id":"btm-wholesale-access","group":"btm","topic":"Statutory wholesale market access for behind-the-meter power","who":["hyperscalers","data_centers","btm_power"],"effect":"expands","now":"FERC Order No. 2222 directed RTOs to accommodate distributed energy resource aggregations by administrative rule, but established no statutory access right or deadline in the Federal Power Act.","now_cite":"FERC Order No. 2222, 85 FR 67094 (2020)","now_url":"https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/10/06/2020-20596/participation-of-distributed-energy-resource-aggregations-in-markets-operated-by-regional","baaja":"Effective 18 months after enactment, declares it unjust and unreasonable under FPA sections 205 and 206 for any grid operator to prevent participation of qualifying behind-the-meter aggregations (100 kW minimum aggregation, 5 kW per unit, 15-minute response) in wholesale energy, capacity, or ancillary service markets.","sections":["2108"],"quote":"prevent the participation of any qualifying BTM DES aggregation in wholesale energy, capacity, or ancillary services markets administered by the Transmission Organization.","c":[243,20,243,22],"ts":[{"t":"Effective 18 months after enactment, declares it unjust and unreasonable under FPA sections 205 and 206 for any grid operator to prevent participation of qualifying behind-the-meter aggregations (100 kW minimum aggregation, 5 kW per unit, 15-minute response) in wholesale energy, capacity, or ancillary service markets.","c":[243,13,243,16],"n":"2108"}]},{"id":"btm-metering","group":"btm","topic":"Device-level metering and inverter telemetry","who":["hyperscalers","data_centers","btm_power"],"effect":"expands","now":"FERC Order No. 2222 left metering and telemetry rules to individual RTO compliance filings and distribution utilities, without a statutory rule guaranteeing use of device-level or inverter equipment.","now_cite":"FERC Order No. 2222, 85 FR 67094 (2020)","now_url":"https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/10/06/2020-20596/participation-of-distributed-energy-resource-aggregations-in-markets-operated-by-regional","baaja":"Rules cannot require equipment owned or installed by the distribution utility; wholesale market participation may use device-level equipment and smart inverters for metering and telemetry.","sections":["2108"],"quote":"are not required to include equipment owned or installed by the distribution utility (as so defined), and may include the use of device-level equipment, including inverters.","c":[241,16,241,19],"ts":[{"t":"Rules cannot require equipment owned or installed by the distribution utility; wholesale market participation may use device-level equipment and smart inverters for metering and telemetry.","c":[241,16,241,19],"n":"2108"}]},{"id":"ratepayer-shield","group":"protection","topic":"No allocation of incremental cost to other customers","who":["data_centers","ratepayers"],"effect":"narrows","now":"Cost allocation for large loads is decided in utility rate cases before state commissions or FERC.","now_cite":"White House, Ratepayer Protection Pledge","now_url":"https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2026/03/ratepayer-protection-pledge/","baaja":"Adds Federal Power Act section 228. For data centers and high-density computing loads of 20 MW or more that interconnect on or after enactment, no portion of the incremental generation, storage, transmission, or distribution cost may be allocated to or recovered in rates of any other customer. Existing approved arrangements remain grandfathered.","sections":["2107"],"quote":"No portion of the incremental cost may be allocated to, or recovered in the rates of, any customer other than a covered load","c":[234,23,235,1],"ts":[{"t":"Adds Federal Power Act section 228.","c":[231,23,231,24],"n":"2107"},{"t":"For data centers and high-density computing loads of 20 MW or more that interconnect on or after enactment, no portion of the incremental generation, storage, transmission, or distribution cost may be allocated to or recovered in rates of any other customer.","c":[234,23,235,1],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Existing approved arrangements remain grandfathered.","c":[240,5,240,8],"n":"2107"}]},{"id":"exit-liability-assurance","group":"protection","topic":"Exit liability and up-front financial assurance","who":["data_centers","ratepayers","grid_operators"],"effect":"narrows","now":"The House-passed Ratepayer Protection Act proposed an optional PURPA standard directing states to consider requiring up-front financial assurance and continuing cost recovery on exit, leaving adoption optional without a binding federal statutory mandate.","now_cite":"H.R. 9340, House-passed text","now_url":"https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr9340eh/html/BILLS-119hr9340eh.htm","baaja":"For loads connecting on or after enactment, utilities must collect financial assurance or upfront contributions before constructing facilities or upgrades. Cost recovery continues even if the data center terminates its contract or ceases electric purchases; existing arrangements are grandfathered.","sections":["2107"],"quote":"an electric utility shall require the covered load to provide financial assurances or contributions sufficient to cover the cost of the facility or upgrade","c":[235,23,236,1],"ts":[{"t":"For loads connecting on or after enactment, utilities must collect financial assurance or upfront contributions before constructing facilities or upgrades.","c":[235,23,236,1],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Cost recovery continues even if the data center terminates its contract or ceases electric purchases; existing arrangements are grandfathered.","c":[235,14,235,16],"n":"2107"}]},{"id":"state-open-seasons","group":"protection","topic":"State authority to auction grid access and require new generation","who":["ratepayers","data_centers"],"effect":"changes","now":"State utility regulation typically treats large customers under standard industrial tariff classes, without statutory frameworks for statewide competitive open seasons or auctions.","now_cite":"Heatmap on data center regulation","now_url":"https://heatmap.news/daily/data-center-permitting-deal","baaja":"For loads connecting on or after enactment, States may hold competitive solicitations or open seasons to allocate retail service among covered loads, charge more than incremental cost to rebate other customers, require bring-your-own new generation, and prioritize non-firm loads. Pre-enactment approved arrangements remain in effect.","sections":["2107"],"quote":"use an open season or competitive solicitation to allocate among covered loads the opportunity to obtain and contract for retail electric service","c":[236,23,237,1],"ts":[{"t":"For loads connecting on or after enactment, States may hold competitive solicitations or open seasons to allocate retail service among covered loads, charge more than incremental cost to rebate other customers, require bring-your-own new generation, and prioritize non-firm loads.","c":[236,23,237,1],"n":"2107"},{"t":"Pre-enactment approved arrangements remain in effect.","c":[240,5,240,8],"n":"2107"}]},{"id":"eia-reporting","group":"protection","topic":"Mandatory EIA reporting on data center electricity load","who":["hyperscalers","data_centers","ratepayers"],"effect":"expands","now":"EIA Form 861 collects utility sales by broad commercial and industrial sectors, without separate reporting on data center or computing power demand.","now_cite":"EIA Form 861 instructions","now_url":"https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/eia861/","baaja":"Directs the Energy Information Administration to revise Form 861 to include electricity load from data center entities (AI, cloud, cryptocurrency) no later than 90 days before the first April 1 after enactment.","sections":["2114"],"quote":"the Administrator of the Energy Information Administration shall revise Form 861 of the Energy Information Administration to include load from data center entities.","c":[279,23,279,25],"ts":[{"t":"Directs the Energy Information Administration to revise Form 861 to include electricity load from data center entities (AI, cloud, cryptocurrency) no later than 90 days before the first April 1 after enactment.","c":[279,21,279,24],"n":"2114"}]}]},"speed":{"intro":"Studies of how long energy projects take and why, grouped by cause, with the bill text on each cause and named analysts' readings of it. Disagreements between studies are noted on the cause they concern.","blockers":[{"id":"nepa-eis-duration","title":"Environmental impact statement timelines","headline":"Median EIS took 2.2 years in 2024, down from 3.1","sections":["1105","1106","1107","1108","1109","1132"],"evidence":[{"org":"Council on Environmental Quality","title":"New data shows Biden-Harris Administration improved speed of federal permitting and environmental reviews (news release on CEQ EIS timelines report)","url":"https://bidenwhitehouse.archives.gov/ceq/news-updates/2025/01/13/new-data-shows-biden-harris-administration-improved-speed-of-federal-permitting-and-environmental-reviews","date":"2025-01-13","period":"final EISs 2010-2024","finding":"CEQ reported a median of 2.2 years from notice of intent to final EIS for EISs finished in 2024; the 2017-2020 median was 3.1 years and 2021-2024 was 2.4 years.","quote":"For final EISs issued in 2024, the median time from NOI to final EIS was 2.2 years and approximately 41 percent of final EISs issued in 2024 were completed in 2 years or less.","kind":"government report"},{"org":"Center for Growth and Opportunity (Utah State University)","title":"NEPA Timelines for Clean Energy Projects: Understanding Delays in Clean Energy Development","url":"https://www.thecgo.org/research/nepa-timelines-for-clean-energy-projects-understanding-delays-in-clean-energy-development/","date":"2023-06-13","period":"89 clean energy EISs with notices of intent 2009-2022","finding":"CGO found clean-energy EISs averaged about three years from notice of intent to record of decision, with solar fastest (just under two years to final EIS) and hydroelectric slowest (5.1 years).","quote":"The average timeline across all energy types is approximately three years, excluding projects that have yet to be completed.","kind":"dataset"},{"org":"Resources for the Future","title":"Most Renewable Projects Overcome Lawsuits and Move Through Federal Review Faster on Average than Other Infrastructure Projects (press release on RFF NEPA papers)","url":"https://www.rff.org/news/press-releases/most-renewable-projects-overcome-lawsuits-and-move-through-federal-review-faster-on-average-than-other-infrastructure-projects/","date":"2025-08-05","period":"wind, solar and geothermal projects with EISs, 2010-2023","finding":"RFF found solar and wind EISs averaged 26 and 43 months against 54 months across all project types, and most wind, solar and geothermal projects took over five years to become operational.","quote":"solar and wind projects respectively take 26 and 43 months to get through NEPA","kind":"study"},{"org":"Columbia University Center on Global Energy Policy","title":"Project timeline savings under BAAJA (assumptions tab quoting CEQ data)","url":"https://www.energypolicy.columbia.edu/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/baaja-timelines-v6.html","date":"2026-10-21","period":"CEQ EIS data 2010-2024; agency reports June 2023-June 2025","finding":"CGEP, citing CEQ, put the 2019-2024 median EIS at 2.8 years, and noted agencies reported two EISs and 153 assessments missing the 2023 statutory deadlines between June 2023 and June 2025.","quote":"Between June 2023 and June 2025, agencies reported two EISs and 153 assessments that missed deadlines","kind":"dataset"}],"disagreement":"The studies measure different spans. CEQ counts from the notice of intent to the final statement (2.2 to 2.8 years, depending on the years covered); CGO and RFF count to the record of decision or to operation, so their figures run longer and do not compare directly. CEQ's report PDF would not load, so its figures come from CEQ's news release.","passages":[{"section":"1106","text":"the lead agency shall publish an environmental impact statement, if applicable, not later than the date that is 2 years after the earlier of","c":[48,17,48,20]}],"readings":["2026-10-21-cgep-timelines-1","2026-10-21-cgep-timelines-3","2026-10-02-king-spalding-3","2026-10-02-womble-bond-dickinson-1"]},{"id":"nepa-litigation","title":"Lawsuits under NEPA","headline":"1 in 450 NEPA decisions is sued, but 28% of projects with an EIS","sections":["1110","1205","1305"],"evidence":[{"org":"University of Utah Wallace Stegner Center","title":"Measuring the NEPA Litigation Burden: A Review of 1,499 Federal Court Cases","url":"https://dc.law.utah.edu/stegner_pubs/6","date":"2020","period":"federal court NEPA cases over a thirteen-year period","finding":"Ruple and Race found about one in 450 NEPA decisions (all decisions, including categorical exclusions) was litigated, and the challenge rate fell over the study period.","quote":"We found that only one in 450 NEPA decisions were litigated and that the rate of NEPA challenges declined during the thirteen-year study period.","kind":"study"},{"org":"Stanford University","title":"NEPA Litigation Over Large Energy and Transport Infrastructure Projects","url":"https://fsi.stanford.edu/node/35265","date":"2023-10-02","period":"355 major projects completing federal environmental study 2010-2018","finding":"Bennon and Wilson found 28% of projects requiring an EIS saw pre-development litigation, with the highest rates for solar (nearly two-thirds), pipelines (50%), wind (38%) and transmission (31%).","quote":"The highest litigation rate is in solar energy projects, nearly two-thirds of which are litigated. Other high-litigation sectors include pipelines (50%), transmission lines (31%), and wind energy projects (38%).","kind":"study"},{"org":"Resources for the Future","title":"Taking Green Energy Projects to Court: NEPA Review and Court Challenges to Renewable Energy","url":"https://www.rff.org/publications/reports/taking-green-energy-projects-to-court-nepa-review-and-court-challenges-to-renewable-energy/","date":"2025-08-04","period":"utility-scale wind and solar projects completing EIS review","finding":"RFF found nearly a third of solar and half of wind projects that completed EISs were sued, and agencies mostly won.","quote":"Nearly a third of solar projects and half of wind projects completing NEPA environmental impact statement reviews faced court challenges.","kind":"study"},{"org":"Breakthrough Institute","title":"Understanding NEPA Litigation: A Systematic Review of Recent NEPA-Related Appellate Court Cases","url":"https://thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/understanding-nepa-litigation","date":"2024-07-11","period":"appellate NEPA cases 2013-2022","finding":"Breakthrough found NEPA appeals averaged 4.2 years from the EIS or EA to the end of the appeal, with agencies winning about 80%.","quote":"On average, 4.2 years elapsed between publication of an environmental impact statement or environmental assessment and conclusion of the corresponding legal challenge at the appellate level.","kind":"study"}],"disagreement":"The two headline rates use different bases. Ruple and Race count all NEPA decisions, nearly all of them categorical exclusions; Bennon and Wilson count only projects that needed a full impact statement. For wind, Stanford finds 38% sued and RFF about half; for solar, Stanford finds nearly two-thirds and RFF about a third.","passages":[{"section":"1110","text":"a claim shall be barred unless the claim","c":[67,24,67,25]}],"readings":["2026-10-23-revelator-1","2026-10-04-stanford-law-school-1","2026-10-02-bpc-2","2026-10-02-womble-bond-dickinson-2","2026-10-04-stanford-law-school-3"]},{"id":"interconnection","title":"Interconnection queues","headline":"Request to operation now takes over 4 years; 13% of requested capacity was built","sections":["2110","2114","2107"],"evidence":[{"org":"Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory","title":"Queued Up: 2025 Edition (data as of end of 2024)","url":"https://eta-publications.lbl.gov/publications/queued-2025-edition-characteristics","date":"2025-12","period":"queues through end of 2024; projects built 2000-2024","finding":"LBNL found the median time from interconnection request to commercial operation doubled from under 2 years (built 2000-2007) to over 4 years (built 2018-2024).","quote":"the median duration from IR to COD has doubled from <2 years for projects built in 2000-2007 to over 4 years for those built in 2018-2024.","kind":"dataset"},{"org":"Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory","title":"Queued Up: 2025 Edition (completion rates)","url":"https://eta-publications.lbl.gov/publications/queued-2025-edition-characteristics","date":"2025-12","period":"requests submitted 2000-2019, outcome by end of 2024","finding":"LBNL found 13% of capacity requested 2000-2019 reached operation, 77% was withdrawn and 10% was still active.","quote":"Only 13% of capacity that submitted interconnection requests from 2000-2019 had reached commercial operations by the end of 2024; 77% of that capacity had been withdrawn and 10% was still active.","kind":"dataset"},{"org":"American Public Power Association (reporting LBNL's next Queued Up edition)","title":"Backlog of Power Plants Seeking Transmission Grid Connection Eased Somewhat in 2025: LBNL","url":"https://www.publicpower.org/periodical/article/backlog-power-plants-seeking-transmission-grid-connection-eased-somewhat-2025-lbnl","date":"2026-07-01","period":"queues through end of 2025","finding":"Reporting LBNL's July 2026 update, APPA says request-to-agreement took well over 3 years in 2025 and request-to-operation exceeded 5 years in regions with data. LBNL's own page was not fetchable.","quote":"the median duration from submitting a request to signing an IA was well over 3 years in 2025, while the timeline to reach commercial operations exceeds 5 years","kind":"review"},{"org":"The Climate Brink","title":"Off-grid data centers have 60-80% higher emissions","url":"https://www.theclimatebrink.com/p/off-grid-data-centers-have-60-80","date":"2026-10-26","period":"2026 commentary","finding":"Hausfather finds data centers that skip the grid for on-site gas generators have 60 to 80% higher emissions. He gives no figure for queue times.","quote":"A rush to power is leading data centers to install the least efficient and leakiest types of fossil gas generators rather than connecting to the grid","kind":"review"}],"passages":[{"section":"2110","text":"queue management practices with respect to the use of computing technologies","c":[265,20,265,21]}],"readings":[]},{"id":"transmission-build","title":"High-voltage transmission construction","headline":"322 miles of 345 kV+ line finished in 2024, against nearly 4,000 in 2013","sections":["2101","2102","2103","2104","2105","2106","2109"],"evidence":[{"org":"Grid Strategies and Americans for a Clean Energy Grid","title":"Fewer New Miles (July 2025)","url":"https://gridstrategiesllc.com/wp-content/uploads/ACEG_Grid-Strategies_Fewer-New-Miles-2025_vF.pdf","date":"2025-07","period":"lines completed 2010-2024","finding":"Grid Strategies found only 322 miles of 345 kV+ lines were completed in 2024, versus nearly 4,000 in 2013.","quote":"In 2024, only 322 miles of new high-voltage transmission lines were completed, the third slowest year of new construction for 345 kV and above transmission over the past 15 years.","kind":"dataset"},{"org":"Grid Strategies and Americans for a Clean Energy Grid","title":"Fewer New Miles (gas pipeline comparison)","url":"https://gridstrategiesllc.com/wp-content/uploads/ACEG_Grid-Strategies_Fewer-New-Miles-2025_vF.pdf","date":"2025-07","period":"2020-2024","finding":"Gas pipelines averaged 534 miles a year over five years against 345 miles for high-voltage lines; the report links the gap to FERC's siting authority over pipelines.","quote":"Over the past five years, natural gas pipelines have averaged 534 miles per year, outpacing the 345-mile annual average for high-voltage transmission by more than 50%.","kind":"dataset"},{"org":"Grid Strategies and Americans for a Clean Energy Grid","title":"Fewer New Miles (DOE needs benchmark)","url":"https://gridstrategiesllc.com/wp-content/uploads/ACEG_Grid-Strategies_Fewer-New-Miles-2025_vF.pdf","date":"2025-07","period":"DOE 2024 National Transmission Planning Study, through 2050","finding":"The report cites DOE's study as calling for doubling regional and quadrupling interregional capacity by 2050, about 5,000 miles a year of regional lines.","quote":"calls for at least a doubling of the current regional transmission capacity and quadrupling of interregional transmission capacity by 2050.","kind":"dataset"}],"passages":[{"section":"2101","text":"issue one or more permits to individual or joint applicants for the construction or modification of electric transmission facilities necessary in the national interest","c":[188,13,188,16]},{"section":"2105","text":"a Federal right of first refusal is prohibited","c":[224,11,224,12]}],"readings":["2026-10-21-cgep-timelines-2","2026-10-05-abundant-future-1","2026-10-01-grid-strategies-1","2026-10-02-niskanen-center-1","2026-10-20-epi-oge-rofr-1","2026-09-30-bommarito-consulting-3"]},{"id":"local-state-siting","title":"Local and state siting","headline":"At least 459 local governments restrict wind or solar; studies disagree on how much federal review adds","sections":[],"evidence":[{"org":"Columbia University Sabin Center for Climate Change Law","title":"Opposition to Renewable Energy Facilities in the United States: June 2025 Edition","url":"https://climate.law.columbia.edu/content/opposition-renewable-energy-facilities-united-states-june-2025-edition","date":"2025-06","period":"restrictions through end of 2024","finding":"Sabin counted at least 459 counties and municipalities in 44 states with severe local restrictions on renewables, up 16% in a year.","quote":"By the end of 2024, at least 459 counties and municipalities across 44 states had adopted severe local restrictions on siting renewables.","kind":"dataset"},{"org":"Columbia University Sabin Center (reported by pv magazine USA)","title":"The U.S. saw a 14 percent increase in contested renewable projects, 9.8 GW in cancellations in 2025","url":"https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2026/09/08/the-u-s-saw-a-14-percent-increase-in-contested-renewable-projects-9-8-gw-in-cancellations-in-2025/","date":"2026-09-08","period":"contested projects 2004-2025","finding":"The sixth Sabin report counts 567 contested projects since 2004, with about 40% cancelled; it says cancellations cannot all be attributed to local opposition.","quote":"Of the 567 total contested projects since 2004, at least 227 (approximately 40%) have been canceled.","kind":"review"},{"org":"Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (reported by Latitude Media)","title":"Local opposition is now a 'leading cause' of canceled clean energy projects","url":"https://latitudemedia.com/news/local-opposition-is-now-a-leading-cause-of-canceled-clean-energy-projects","date":"2024-08-29","period":"survey of 123 developer staff at 62 companies, 2023 (primary report published 2024-01)","finding":"LBNL's developer survey ranked community opposition and local ordinances alongside grid interconnection as leading causes of delay and cancellation.","quote":"community opposition and ordinances limiting renewable development are the \"leading causes of project delays and cancellations,\" on par with grid interconnection issues","kind":"survey"},{"org":"Third Way (survey by ERM)","title":"Full Research Findings: Pathways to Accelerating Clean Energy (PACE) Report","url":"https://www.thirdway.org/report/full-research-findings-pathways-to-accelerating-clean-energy-pace-report","date":"2025-11-06","period":"survey of 200+ industry practitioners","finding":"Third Way's survey found organized resistance affects a minority of projects, federal reviews caused the longest delays, and state and local permitting also slowed projects.","quote":"Only a minority of projects face concerted resistance capable of altering or halting development. Federal permitting reviews caused the longest delays for new projects, but state and local permitting also slowed deployment significantly.","kind":"survey"},{"org":"Environmental Law Reporter","title":"Dispelling the Myths of Permitting Reform and Identifying Effective Pathways Forward (55 ELR 10038)","url":"https://www.eli.org/sites/default/files/files-pdf/55.DispellingTheMyths.pdf","date":"2025-01","period":"review of empirical literature, past 14 years","finding":"Adelman and co-authors conclude the empirical record shows environmental review and permitting rarely delay or block utility-scale renewables, citing the LBNL survey result that environmental regulations caused under 15% of delays or cancellations.","quote":"The available empirical record shows that environmental reviews and permitting rarely delay or block utility-scale renewable energy projects","kind":"review"},{"org":"Crux","title":"Federal permitting and clean energy: 2026 survey","url":"https://www.cruxclimate.com/insights/federal-permitting-clean-energy-projects","date":"2026","period":"survey of 50 developers and permitting professionals","finding":"A Crux survey of 50 developers says federal permitting contributed to delays or cancellations in 94% of surveyed projects.","quote":"Federal permitting contributed to delays or cancellations in 94% of clean energy projects surveyed and raised costs for every developer.","kind":"survey"}],"disagreement":"No study found here splits cancellations into local and federal shares. Sabin and LBNL rank local opposition among the top causes. Adelman and co-authors find environmental review rarely delays or blocks utility-scale renewables. Third Way and Crux put federal permitting first, for length of delay or how often it is a factor. Crux counts federal permitting as a factor, not as the main cause.","passages":[],"readings":[]},{"id":"federal-reversals","title":"Federal action on approved projects","headline":"Agencies halted large solar and offshore wind projects in 2025; judges let the offshore ones resume","sections":["1401","1402","1403","2251","2252"],"evidence":[{"org":"pv magazine USA (reporting Sabin Center)","title":"The U.S. saw a 14 percent increase in contested renewable projects, 9.8 GW in cancellations in 2025","url":"https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2026/09/08/the-u-s-saw-a-14-percent-increase-in-contested-renewable-projects-9-8-gw-in-cancellations-in-2025/","date":"2026-09-08","period":"2025","finding":"The largest 2025 cancellation in Sabin's data, 6.2 GW Esmeralda 7 in Nevada, was cancelled by BLM.","quote":"The largest of these projects was the 6.2 GW Esmeralda 7 Solar Project in Nevada, which was canceled by the Bureau of Land Management in October 2025.","kind":"review"},{"org":"Associated Press via PBS NewsHour","title":"Senate reaches bipartisan deal on permitting bill to speed approvals of new energy projects","url":"https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/senate-reaches-bipartisan-deal-on-permitting-bill-to-speed-approvals-of-new-energy-projects","date":"2026-09-30","period":"December 2025 suspensions","finding":"AP reports the administration suspended five offshore wind projects in December and they later moved forward after federal judges intervened.","quote":"The administration suspended five offshore wind projects in December, citing unspecified national security concerns. The projects later moved forward after federal judges intervened.","kind":"review"}],"passages":[{"section":"1401","text":"a Federal department or agency shall not take any new action that would revoke, rescind, withdraw, terminate, suspend, amend, or alter a Federal authorization or permit","c":[159,11,159,14]},{"section":"1402","text":"an empirically demonstrated statistical pattern that","c":[167,14,167,15]}],"readings":["2026-10-21-flegal-x-1402","2026-10-08-grist-1","2026-10-02-king-spalding-4","2026-10-03-foundation-for-american-inno-1","2026-10-05-heatmap-1","2026-10-01-sierra-club-1"]},{"id":"nhpa-section-106","title":"Historic preservation review (Section 106)","headline":"Over 120,000 reviews a year; no study measures how long they take","sections":["2301","2302"],"evidence":[{"org":"Advisory Council on Historic Preservation","title":"About the ACHP fact sheet","url":"https://www.achp.gov/sites/default/files/2025-07/2025_AboutTheACHPFactSheet_072225v2.pdf","date":"2025-07-22","period":"annual","finding":"ACHP says over 120,000 undertakings go through Section 106 each year and over 95% resolve without ACHP involvement.","quote":"While more than 95 percent of these cases are resolved without the ACHP","kind":"government report"},{"org":"Institute for Progress","title":"Reforming Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act","url":"https://ifp.org/?p=9257","date":"2026-06-30","period":"current practice","finding":"IFP says few undertakings are found to adversely affect historic properties, but those that do are disproportionately large energy and infrastructure projects.","quote":"But those that do are disproportionately the large energy and infrastructure projects the country most needs.","kind":"review"},{"org":"Environmental Law Reporter","title":"Dispelling the Myths of Permitting Reform (55 ELR 10038)","url":"https://www.eli.org/sites/default/files/files-pdf/55.DispellingTheMyths.pdf","date":"2025-01","period":"literature review","finding":"Adelman and co-authors note that there are almost no data or studies on how long Section 106 consultation takes.","quote":"The NHPA, and particularly the §106 consultation process, can impact project timelines as well, but there are virtually no data","kind":"review"}],"disagreement":"No study measuring Section 106 delay was found. The Advisory Council's figures count reviews and how they end, not how long they take; the Institute for Progress argues that a small number of large projects carry most of the cost.","passages":[{"section":"2301","text":"Not later than 30 days after the date of receipt of a request for review of a proposed project, activity, or program under this section","c":[386,8,386,11]},{"section":"2302","text":"$200,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2027 through 2036","c":[414,10,414,11]}],"readings":["2026-10-02-vinson-elkins-nhpa-1","2026-10-19-mackenzie-x-1","2026-10-09-tribal-orgs-letter-2","2026-10-02-ncshpo-1"]},{"id":"esa-section-7","title":"Endangered species consultations","headline":"Median formal consultation took 62 days; 20% ran past 135","sections":["1302","1304","1305"],"evidence":[{"org":"Defenders of Wildlife","title":"Testimony on 'ESA Consultation Impediments to Economic and Infrastructure Development'","url":"https://naturalresources.house.gov/UploadedFiles/Testimony_Li.pdf","date":"2017-03-28","period":"FWS consultations over seven years (about 88,000 projects)","finding":"Li reported median consultation times of 13 days (informal) and 62 days (formal) from when FWS had enough information to start.","quote":"the median duration of informal consultations was 13 days and formal consultations was 62 days","kind":"study"},{"org":"Defenders of Wildlife","title":"Testimony (share over deadline)","url":"https://naturalresources.house.gov/UploadedFiles/Testimony_Li.pdf","date":"2017-03-28","period":"same FWS data","finding":"Li reported 1,381 formal consultations, 20%, exceeded the 135-day limit, many with agreed extensions.","quote":"Only 1,381 formal consultations (20 percent) exceeded the 135-day limit prescribed in Services regulations, and many of those had agreed upon extensions.","kind":"study"}],"disagreement":"The figures come from Defenders of Wildlife testimony describing a peer-reviewed study; the study itself and a 2004 GAO report would not load. The clock starts when the agency has a complete submission, so time spent before that is not counted.","passages":[{"section":"1302","text":"the consultation process under subsection (a)(2) shall be completed by not later than the date on which the applicable environmental document","c":[136,4,136,7]}],"readings":["2026-10-02-bpc-5","2026-10-02-womble-bond-dickinson-3","2026-10-01-rep-jared-huffman-1"]},{"id":"cwa-401-404","title":"Clean Water Act permits and state certification","headline":"No current national data on how long these permits take","sections":["1202","1204","1205"],"evidence":[{"org":"EPA Office of Inspector General","title":"Report 12-P-0083 at a glance (Corps/EPA review of Appalachian surface coal mining permits)","url":"https://19january2021snapshot.epa.gov/sites/static/files/2015-10/documents/20111121-12-p-0083_glance.pdf","date":"2011-11-21","period":"Appalachian surface coal mining permits, about 2008-2011","finding":"EPA's inspector general found more than a third of the Corps individual permits in its sample took a year or longer. The sample is from 2011 and covers coal mining only.","quote":"More than one-third of issued permits took a year or longer to process.","kind":"government report"}],"disagreement":"No national data from the 2020s on how long Section 404 permits or Section 401 certifications take was found. The only measurement is a 2011 sample of coal-mining permits.","passages":[{"section":"1202","text":"respond to the request not later than 30 days after the date on which the request is received","c":[107,9,107,11]}],"readings":[]},{"id":"agency-capacity","title":"Agency staffing","headline":"No government-wide count of permitting staff was found","sections":["1133","1132","2241","2302"],"evidence":[{"org":"Nextgov/FCW (quoting Eric Beightel, former Federal Permitting Council director)","title":"Trump administration debuts permitting modernization plan, even as staff cuts could jeopardize it","url":"https://www.nextgov.com/modernization/2025/06/trump-administration-debuts-permitting-modernization-plan-even-staff-cuts-could-jeopardize-it/405848/","date":"2025-06","period":"2025","finding":"A former Permitting Council director warned staff losses and expected funding cuts could undermine the federal permitting modernization plan. No headcount is given.","quote":"I’m concerned, however, that the loss of staff and the funding reductions expected for agencies will hinder the ability of the agencies to fulfill the ambitious goals of this effort","kind":"review"},{"org":"Institute for Progress","title":"Reforming Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (SHPO capacity)","url":"https://ifp.org/?p=9257","date":"2026-06-30","period":"state offices","finding":"IFP reports Utah's digital SHPO finishes about 98% of reviews within seven days.","quote":"Utah’s fully digital SHPO completes about 98% of reviews within seven days, while offices without modern data systems lag badly.","kind":"review"},{"org":"Environmental Law Reporter","title":"Dispelling the Myths of Permitting Reform (55 ELR 10038)","url":"https://www.eli.org/sites/default/files/files-pdf/55.DispellingTheMyths.pdf","date":"2025-01","period":"literature review","finding":"Adelman and co-authors argue that agency funding, staffing and training speed permitting for every kind of project.","quote":"Increasing agency capacity through adequate funding, staffing, and training improves the permitting process for everyone.","kind":"review"}],"disagreement":"No government-wide count of permitting staff was found. A 20 to 30% staff decline that appears in search results could not be traced to a source.","passages":[{"section":"1133","text":"The purpose of the Fund is to improve the performance of key permitting agencies with respect to timely environmental reviews and authorizations","c":[101,11,101,13]}],"readings":["2026-10-02-king-spalding-3"]},{"id":"clean-vs-fossil-review","title":"Clean energy and fossil projects in federal review","headline":"Solar and wind reviews ran shorter than average; no study compares clean and fossil shares","sections":["2213","2214","1402","2221","2222","2223","2224","2225","2226","2227","2228","2229","2251","2252"],"evidence":[{"org":"Resources for the Future","title":"Most Renewable Projects Overcome Lawsuits and Move Through Federal Review Faster on Average than Other Infrastructure Projects","url":"https://www.rff.org/news/press-releases/most-renewable-projects-overcome-lawsuits-and-move-through-federal-review-faster-on-average-than-other-infrastructure-projects/","date":"2025-08-05","period":"2010-2023","finding":"RFF found solar, wind and geothermal reviews were historically shorter than other infrastructure, though other steps may take as long.","quote":"solar, wind, and geothermal projects have historically seen shorter review times on average than other infrastructure projects, although other process steps may be just as time-consuming.","kind":"study"}],"disagreement":"No source found here gives the clean energy and fossil fuel shares of NEPA reviews.","passages":[{"section":"2213","text":"shall issue a notice of intent not later than 90 days after the date on which the applicable Secretary determines that an application is complete","c":[300,6,300,9]}],"readings":["2026-10-02-third-way-1"]}]},"positions":{"issues":[{"id":"deadlines","title":"Review deadlines","headline":"deadlines","topics":["nepa","ceq","categorical-exclusions"]},{"id":"lawsuits","title":"Court challenges","headline":"lawsuits","topics":["courts"]},{"id":"certainty","title":"Issued permits, wind and solar","headline":"certainty","topics":["permit-certainty","wind-solar","offshore"],"disputes":[{"id":"unlawful","question":"Can a later administration revoke a permit it says was issued unlawfully?","passages":[{"section":"1401","text":"the Federal agency is required to take such action by order of a court of competent jurisdiction","c":[159,20,159,21]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-26-earthjustice-1","2026-10-15-wilderness-society-1","2026-10-22-weiss-1","2026-10-23-cwp-1"]}},{"id":"pattern","question":"When can a developer sue over how agencies treat a project type?","passages":[{"section":"1402","text":"an empirically demonstrated statistical pattern that","c":[167,14,167,15]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-09-30-rep-jared-huffman-2","2026-10-26-oilchange-1"],"for":["2026-10-21-flegal-x-1402","2026-10-03-senate-enr-committee-chair-l-1"]}}]},{"id":"datacenters","title":"Data center costs","headline":"datacenters","topics":["data-centers"],"disputes":[{"id":"costs","question":"Must data centers pay the embedded and incremental cost of transmission service?","passages":[{"section":"2107","text":"to require public utilities and transmitting utilities to charge eligible customers seeking transmission service on behalf of computational load owners and computational load operators the embedded cost and the incremental cost of transmission service","c":[229,19,229,25]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-18-bisnow-dc-costs"],"for":["2026-10-12-ifp-deal-3","2026-10-02-bpc-6"]}}]},{"id":"transmission","title":"Transmission siting","headline":"transmission","topics":["transmission"]},{"id":"exemptions","title":"Oil, gas, mining and exclusions","headline":"exemptions","topics":["fossil","mining","geothermal","clean-water-act"]},{"id":"tribal","title":"Tribal consultation and historic preservation","topics":["tribal","historic-preservation"],"sections":["2301","2302","2212"],"link":"#/communities/tribes","disputes":[{"id":"consult","question":"Must an agency still consult Tribes?","passages":[{"section":"2301","text":"may consult with any applicable State Historic Preservation Officers, Tribal Historic Preservation Officers, Indian tribes","c":[387,11,387,14]},{"section":"2301","text":"shall seek, discuss, as appropriate, and incorporate, as applicable, information from each applicable State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe","c":[387,23,388,2]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-16-tribal-claim-fact-1","2026-10-09-tribal-orgs-letter-1","2026-10-20-nathpo-x-1","2026-10-19-nrdc-1"],"for":["2026-10-13-ifp-tribal-1","2026-10-19-hochman-x-1","2026-10-07-searchlight-1"]}},{"id":"undertaking","question":"Which projects still get a 106 review?","passages":[{"section":"2301","text":"substantial Federal control and responsibility","c":[383,14,383,15]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-20-preservation-coalition-1"],"for":["2026-10-12-ifp-deal-1"]}},{"id":"effects","question":"What counts as harm to a historic place?","passages":[{"section":"2301","text":"directly alters the characteristics of a historic property","c":[380,5,380,6]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-20-preservation-coalition-2"],"for":["2026-10-12-ifp-deal-2"]}},{"id":"sacred","question":"Which sacred places count?","passages":[{"section":"2301","text":"means an identifiable geographic location or feature at which an event of continuing religious or cultural significance to a living community occurred","c":[372,15,372,18]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-16-tribal-claim-fact-2"],"for":["2026-10-13-ifp-tribal-2","2026-10-19-hochman-x-2"]}},{"id":"deadline","question":"What if a Tribe misses the 30 days?","passages":[{"section":"2301","text":"fails to respond within 30 days of receipt of a request for review of any report or finding by the applicable Federal official, the applicable Federal official shall proceed","c":[400,16,400,20]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-09-tribal-orgs-letter-2","2026-10-16-tribal-claim-fact-3","2026-10-01-national-trust-1","2026-10-02-ncshpo-1","2026-10-20-preservation-coalition-3"],"for":[]}},{"id":"thpo","question":"Can Interior take over a THPO?","passages":[{"section":"2301","text":"the Secretary shall assume all or part of the functions of the Tribal Historic Preservation Officer","c":[377,10,377,11]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-09-tribal-orgs-letter-3","2026-10-16-tribal-claim-fact-7","2026-10-20-preservation-coalition-4"],"for":["2026-10-08-ifp-tribal-report-thpo"]}},{"id":"override","question":"Can an agency set aside harm to a sacred place?","passages":[{"section":"2301","text":"in the sole discretion of the Federal official and as otherwise allowed by law, other considerations outweigh","c":[393,4,393,7]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-09-tribal-orgs-letter-4","2026-10-01-national-trust-2"],"for":["2026-10-19-mackenzie-x-1"]}},{"id":"courts","question":"Can a court stop a project that skipped the review?","passages":[{"section":"2301","text":"the only remedy the court may order is to remand, without vacatur or issuance of an injunction","c":[406,25,407,2]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-16-tribal-claim-fact-5","2026-10-09-tribal-orgs-letter-5","2026-10-20-preservation-coalition-5"],"for":["2026-10-07-searchlight-3"]}},{"id":"funding","question":"Is the Tribal funding authorized or appropriated?","passages":[{"section":"2302","text":"There is authorized to be appropriated to the Secretary to carry out this subsection $20,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2027 through 2030","c":[416,24,417,2]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-16-tribal-claim-fact-4"],"for":["2026-10-19-hochman-x-3","2026-10-07-searchlight-2"]}},{"id":"without","question":"How does the bill compare with the administration's draft rule for Tribes?","passages":[],"note":"No single passage: this is about what happens if the bill fails and the Advisory Council finishes its draft rule.","readings":{"against":["2026-10-16-tribal-claim-fact-6"],"for":["2026-10-13-ifp-tribal-3"]}},{"id":"standing","question":"Can a Tribe still sue?","passages":[{"section":"2301","text":"the claim is filed by a party that has suffered or imminently will suffer direct harm from the agency action","c":[409,9,409,12]},{"section":"2301","text":"has provided detailed notice in writing during the consultation process","c":[410,13,410,15]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-09-tribal-orgs-letter-6"],"for":["2026-09-30-ifp-deal-tribal-1"]}}]},{"id":"esa","title":"Endangered species","topics":["esa"],"sections":["1301","1302","1304","1305"],"disputes":[{"id":"science","question":"What happens to the best-available-science rule?","passages":[{"section":"1301","text":"impartially gathered and objectively applied without presumptions or policy prescriptions that bias the application","c":[134,6,134,8]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-06-cbd-esa-letter-1"],"for":["2026-09-30-ifp-deal-esa-1"]}},{"id":"states","question":"Can a state run consultations?","passages":[{"section":"1304","text":"the Secretary may assign, and the State may assume, the consultation responsibilities of the Secretary within the boundary of the State","c":[140,1,140,4]},{"section":"1304","text":"authorize the State to take the actions necessary to carry out the responsibilities being assumed","c":[145,20,145,22]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-06-cbd-esa-letter-2","2026-10-20-earthjustice-esa-2"],"for":["2026-09-30-ifp-deal-esa-2"]}},{"id":"courts","question":"Where can a consultation be challenged?","passages":[{"section":"1305","text":"of any opinion issued by the Secretary under subsection (b) in the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit","c":[154,16,154,18]},{"section":"1304","text":"The district courts of the United States shall have exclusive jurisdiction over any civil action against a State","c":[147,6,147,8]}],"readings":{"against":["2026-10-06-cbd-esa-letter-3","2026-10-20-earthjustice-esa-1"],"for":[]}}]}]},"checks":{"inference":{"cached_only":true,"checked":"2026-10-06","flagged":0,"input_sha256":"a64a604d95e0b7b4a95876f8e139e29e3b46b3e6763f8d36779befa87d3402c4","model":"claude-sonnet-5","supported":794,"total":812,"unchecked":18,"stale":true},"links":{"blocked":52,"browser":46,"checked":"2026-11-18","dead":0,"error":1,"ok":772,"total":825},"quotes":{"bill_total":174,"bill_verified":174,"browser":90,"checked":"2026-11-18","missing":0,"near":0,"total":1090,"unreachable":0,"unverifiable":0,"verified":1000},"points":{"total":163,"cited":163},"takes":{"total":158,"sections":27},"cites":{"summary":{"total":289,"cited":289,"absent":0},"rows":{"total":310,"cited":296,"absent":14},"gaps":[]}},"amend_index":{"date":"2026-11-07","counts":{"edited":43,"new":13,"dropped":1,"moved":2,"unchanged":25,"substantive":50,"technical":9},"sections":{"1101":{"id":"1101","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"1101"},"1102":{"id":"1102","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1102"},"1103":{"id":"1103","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1103"},"1104":{"id":"1104","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"1104"},"1105":{"id":"1105","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"1105"},"1106":{"id":"1106","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1106"},"1107":{"id":"1107","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"1107"},"1108":{"id":"1108","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"1108"},"1109":{"id":"1109","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1109"},"1110":{"id":"1110","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1110"},"1121":{"id":"1121","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1121"},"1131":{"id":"1131","status":"edited","kind":"technical","n":"1131"},"1132":{"id":"1132","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1132"},"1133":{"id":"1133","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"1133"},"1201":{"id":"1201","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"1201"},"1202":{"id":"1202","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1202"},"1203":{"id":"1203","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"1203"},"1204":{"id":"1204","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1204"},"1205":{"id":"1205","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1205"},"1301":{"id":"1301","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"1301"},"1302":{"id":"1302","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"1302"},"1303":{"id":"1303","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"1303"},"1304":{"id":"1304","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1304"},"1305":{"id":"1305","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1305"},"1306":{"id":"1306","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"1306"},"1307":{"id":"1307","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"1307"},"1308":{"id":"1308","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1308"},"1401":{"id":"1401","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1401"},"1402":{"id":"1402","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1402"},"1403":{"id":"1403","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"1403"},"2101":{"id":"2101","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2101"},"2102":{"id":"2102","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2102"},"2103":{"id":"2103","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2103"},"2104":{"id":"2104","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2104"},"2105":{"id":"2105","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2105"},"2106":{"id":"2106","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2106"},"2107":{"id":"2107","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2107"},"2108":{"id":"2108","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2108"},"2109":{"id":"2109","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2109"},"2110":{"id":"2110","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2110"},"2111":{"id":"2111","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2111"},"2112":{"id":"2112","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2112"},"2113":{"id":"2113","status":"edited","kind":"technical","n":"2113"},"2114":{"id":"2114","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2114"},"2115":{"id":"2118","status":"moved","kind":"technical","n":"2118"},"2201":{"id":"2201","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2201"},"2211":{"id":"2211","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"2211"},"2212":{"id":"2212","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2212"},"2213":{"id":"2213","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"2213"},"2214":{"id":"2214","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"2214"},"2215":{"id":"2215","status":"edited","kind":"technical","n":"2215"},"2221":{"id":"2221","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2221"},"2222":{"id":"2222","status":"edited","kind":"technical","n":"2222"},"2223":{"id":"2223","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"2223"},"2224":{"id":"2224","status":"edited","kind":"technical","n":"2224"},"2225":{"id":"2225","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2225"},"2226":{"id":"2226","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"2226"},"2227":{"id":"2227","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"2227"},"2228":{"id":"2228","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"2228"},"2229":{"id":"2229","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2229"},"2231":{"id":"2231","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"2231"},"2232":{"id":"2232","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"2232"},"2233":{"id":"2233","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"2233"},"2234":{"id":"2234","status":"edited","kind":"technical","n":"2234"},"2241":{"id":"2241","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"2241"},"2242":{"id":"2242-dropped","status":"dropped","kind":"substantive","n":"2242"},"2243":{"id":"2242","status":"moved","kind":"technical","n":"2242"},"2251":{"id":"2251","status":"unchanged","kind":null,"n":"2251"},"2252":{"id":"2252","status":"edited","kind":"technical","n":"2252"},"2301":{"id":"2301","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2301"},"2302":{"id":"2302","status":"edited","kind":"substantive","n":"2302"}},"floor":6,"pages":494,"reactions":{"supports":4,"opposes":7,"mixed":2,"undecided":1,"comments":3}},"recent":{"media":[{"url":"https://www.kosu.org/news/2026-11-18/senate-expected-to-vote-on-permitting-bill-tribal-leaders-in-oklahoma-beyond-oppose","title":"Senate expected to vote on permitting bill tribal leaders in Oklahoma, beyond oppose","outlet":"KOSU","date":"2026-11-18"},{"url":"https://x.com/SiegelScribe/status/2122744229516485116","title":"Update: Sen. Schiff is still “pushing for consideration of his amendment via a floor vote prior to final passage of the bill” to strip NHPA section of BAAJA, a spokesman told me “The amendment is strictly germane…and has the support of two-thirds of the Democratic Caucus”","outlet":"X / @SiegelScribe","date":"2026-11-17"},{"url":"https://x.com/SiegelScribe/status/2122775557670572148","title":"Senate EPW top Dem Sheldon Whitehouse tells me coming out of Dem lunch that negotiators are “finishing up the hotline on amendments and hoping to get agreement there”","outlet":"X / @SiegelScribe","date":"2026-11-17"},{"url":"https://x.com/SiegelScribe/status/2122801049446580509","title":"SCOOP: Senate permitting reform negotiators have finalized changes to BAAJA ahead of the final vote expected this week.","outlet":"X / @SiegelScribe","date":"2026-11-17"},{"url":"https://x.com/SiegelScribe/status/2122667684777402860","title":"Scoop in @PunchbowlNews AM: Senate negotiators near deal on changes to NHPA section of BAAJA to shore up votes amid tribal pushback.","outlet":"X / @SiegelScribe","date":"2026-11-17"},{"url":"https://x.com/SiegelScribe/status/2122776169334620360","title":"On the second round of managers amendment changes to the bill that are expected, Sen. Whitehouse told me it would be a mix of “technical things that are actually technical improvements and bipartisan things that can move smoothly.”","outlet":"X / @SiegelScribe","date":"2026-11-17"}],"milestones":[{"id":"2026-11-16-senate-cloture-substitute","date":"2026-11-16","title":"Senate votes 70 to 27 to end debate on the sponsors' substitute, SA 6883"},{"id":"2026-11-10-senate-motion-to-proceed","date":"2026-11-10","title":"Senate votes 62 to 21 to take up H.R. 2347"},{"id":"2026-11-10-substitute-sa-6883-proposed","date":"2026-11-10","title":"Thune offers the sponsors' substitute as SA 6883, with amendments SA 6884 to SA 6890"},{"id":"2026-11-09-senate-cloture-motion-to-proceed","date":"2026-11-09","title":"Senate votes 73 to 25 to end debate on taking up H.R. 2347"},{"id":"2026-11-07-substitute-amendment","date":"2026-11-07","title":"Sponsors release a 494-page substitute amendment"},{"id":"2026-10-27-duckworth-doe-awards","date":"2026-10-27","title":"Four senators seek restored grants ahead of Senate motion to take up permitting reform"}],"counts":{"timeline":143,"people":91,"media":544},"positions":{"supports":40,"opposes":19,"mixed":7,"letters":15},"votes":[{"number":257,"date":"2026-11-09","question":"Ending debate on the motion to proceed to H.R. 2347","yeas":73,"nays":25,"not_voting":2},{"number":258,"date":"2026-11-10","question":"The motion to proceed to H.R. 2347","yeas":62,"nays":21,"not_voting":17},{"number":264,"date":"2026-11-16","question":"Ending debate on the substitute, SA 6883","yeas":70,"nays":27,"not_voting":3}],"estimates":{"count":18,"publishers":8}}}
