# Sec. 1110. Judicial review

BAAJA draft released September 30, 2026. AI-assisted analysis; proposed changes.

Saved AI review: 794 supported, 0 flagged, 18 unchecked of 812 statements; checked 2026-10-06; stale: true. Coverage excludes current-law comparison cells and some research paraphrases. Read data/core.json checks for link and quote results and their dates. A stale review does not verify the current wording.

[Official PDF](https://www.epw.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/5/c/5c5f5935-b224-48e7-abea-e60c30e7a4cf/7935BF3C85967B6F56F6F4858FD3221B7E0AEB02D04BE391CAFBD1B884CE3DC5.bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act-text.pdf) · [Browser section](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/#/bill/sec/1110)

## Summary

Adds a judicial review section to NEPA. ([p. 67, line 13 to p. 67, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=67)) Suits challenging an authorization on NEPA grounds must be filed within 150 days. ([p. 68, line 1 to p. 68, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68)) The party must allege an actual or imminent injury amounting to direct harm. ([p. 68, line 18 to p. 68, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68)) Where a comment period was offered, the party must also have filed a sufficiently detailed comment. ([p. 68, line 11 to p. 68, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68)) The federal court of appeals for the circuit where the project sits gets original and exclusive jurisdiction, with random judge assignment. ([p. 68, line 23 to p. 69, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68))

If a court finds a NEPA violation, the only remedy is remand without vacatur or injunction, with a fix deadline of no more than 180 days. ([p. 69, line 24 to p. 70, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69)) The permit stays in effect and the project can proceed during the remand. ([p. 71, line 15 to p. 71, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=71)) A preliminary injunction is available only for a likely violation of a law other than NEPA or the National Historic Preservation Act. ([p. 70, line 17 to p. 70, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=70))

Courts must give substantial deference to agencies on the scope and content of environmental documents. ([p. 73, line 25 to p. 74, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=73)) No NEPA suit may be brought over an action on tribal trust lands unless the tribe itself sues or effects reach beyond trust lands. ([p. 73, line 8 to p. 73, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=73)) No suit may rest on an omission from the list described in section 3(22)(B) of NEPA as amended. ([p. 74, line 7 to p. 74, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=74))

## Key points

- 150-day statute of limitations ([p. 68, line 1 to p. 68, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68))
- Only a party with a direct-harm injury can sue, and where a comment period was offered it must have commented ([p. 68, line 10 to p. 68, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68))
- Court of appeals has original and exclusive jurisdiction ([p. 69, line 1 to p. 69, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69))
- Remand without vacatur is the sole NEPA remedy; the project continues during the remand ([p. 69, line 24 to p. 70, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69))
- No preliminary injunction for NEPA or NHPA violations alone ([p. 70, line 17 to p. 70, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=70))
- Substantial deference to agencies on the scope and contents of the document ([p. 73, line 25 to p. 74, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=73))

## What others say it would do

Outside readings, quoted from their sources. These are claims about effects, not findings of this tracker.

- **King & Spalding** (Lawyers and legal scholars; explains): Agencies would be freed from considering science published after a review starts, and courts would defer to technical determinations.
  > They would not need to consider research published after review begins, and courts would defer substantially to their technical determinations.
  [King & Spalding, 2026-10-02](https://www.kslaw.com/Insights/Articles/The-Senate-Permitting-Deal-What-It-Would-Change-and-What-to-Do-Now). On the bill text at [p. 43, line 12 to p. 43, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=43).
- **American Petroleum Institute** (Industry; supports): Short limitation periods and durable final decisions are an essential part of reform for oil and gas developers.
  > Judicial review reforms that provide for timely resolution of legal challenges and greater durability for final agency decisions are an essential component of meaningful permitting reform.
  [API letter to Thune and Schumer, 2026-09-30](https://www.api.org/-/media/Files/news/letters-comments/2026/2026-09-30-API-Senate-Leadership-Permitting-Reform-Letter-of-Support.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 1 to p. 68, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).
- **Food & Water Watch** (Environmental groups; opposes): The litigation provisions close off legal options communities have used against polluting projects.
  > It would shut the door to critical legal options communities have relied on to challenge harmful, polluting projects.
  [Food & Water Watch, 2026-09-30](https://www.foodandwaterwatch.org/2026/09/30/bipartisan-permitting-reform-plan-is-danger-to-public-health-enviro-protection-states-rights/). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 1 to p. 68, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).
- **Southern Environmental Law Center** (Environmental groups; opposes): Faster reviews and approvals come at the expense of communities' ability to protect themselves.
  > It makes it easier to speed through environmental reviews and get permits by making it harder for communities to protect themselves from harm.
  [pv magazine USA, 2026-10-01](http://pv-magazine-usa.com/2026/10/01/senate-introduces-landmark-permitting-bill-as-industry-data-and-environmental-groups-clash-over-reforms/). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 10 to p. 68, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).
- **The Hill** (Reporting; mixed): Supporters expect fewer late lawsuits; opponents say 150 days could stifle legitimate complaints.
  > supporters saying they will cut down on lawsuits that can interrupt a project years after it is approved, while opponents say the short window could stymie legitimate complaints.
  [The Hill, 2026-10-01](https://thehill.com/policy/energy-environment/6124792-bipartisan-permitting-reform-data-centers-energy-projects/). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 1 to p. 68, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).
- **Beveridge & Diamond** (Lawyers and legal scholars; explains): Direct-to-circuit review would effectively end NEPA/NHPA district-court litigation and most ESA district-court litigation, and ensure three-judge panels.
  > This would effectively end all NEPA and NHPA litigation and much ESA litigation in district courts where such cases have largely been brought.
  [Mondaq (Beveridge & Diamond), 2026-10-02](https://www.mondaq.com/unitedstates/environmental-law/1850440/senate-permitting-bill-would-reshape-environmental-permitting-and-reviews). On the bill text at [p. 69, line 1 to p. 69, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69).
- **Beveridge & Diamond** (Lawyers and legal scholars; explains): The 'direct harm' comment requirement could tighten Article III standing for procedural-injury claims.
  > arguably tightening typical Article III standing requirements to bring such claims based on claimed procedural injuries.
  [Mondaq (Beveridge & Diamond), 2026-10-02](https://www.mondaq.com/unitedstates/environmental-law/1850440/senate-permitting-bill-would-reshape-environmental-permitting-and-reviews). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 19 to p. 68, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).
- **Beveridge & Diamond** (Lawyers and legal scholars; explains): For NEPA/NHPA violations courts would be nearly limited to remand without vacatur with a 180-day cure, and injunctions require a likely violation of some other statute.
  > Where a court finds a NEPA or NHPA violation, the bill would largely eliminate relief other than remand without vacatur, with the agency having no more than 180 days to cure the deficiency.
  [Mondaq (Beveridge & Diamond), 2026-10-02](https://www.mondaq.com/unitedstates/environmental-law/1850440/senate-permitting-bill-would-reshape-environmental-permitting-and-reviews). On the bill text at [p. 69, line 24 to p. 70, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69).
- **Bipartisan Policy Center** (Think tanks; supports): The comment and direct-harm requirements would produce fewer, earlier lawsuits, with objections raised while the agency can still fix them.
  > The result of these changes would be fewer and earlier challenges, with objections reaching the agency while it can still fix them, rather than after the environmental review has concluded.
  [Bipartisan Policy Center, 2026-10-02](https://bipartisanpolicy.org/explainer/explaining-the-senate-permitting-bill-the-bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 10 to p. 68, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).
- **Bipartisan Policy Center** (Think tanks; explains): A NEPA defect alone could no longer halt a project; an arbitrary-and-capricious claim under the APA would keep its full remedies.
  > Under BAAJA, a NEPA violation alone would no longer stop a project.
  [Bipartisan Policy Center, 2026-10-02](https://bipartisanpolicy.org/explainer/explaining-the-senate-permitting-bill-the-bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act). On the bill text at [p. 69, line 24 to p. 70, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69).
- **Eno Center for Transportation** (Think tanks; mixed): Exclusive court-of-appeals jurisdiction may standardize review but weaken the local connection to projects.
  > That may help to produce a more standard review of cases, but also may somewhat reduce the local connection to projects.
  [Eno Center for Transportation, 2026-10-02](https://enotrans.org/article/senate-proposes-major-changes-to-permit-and-review-processes/). On the bill text at [p. 69, line 1 to p. 69, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69).
- **Eno Center for Transportation** (Think tanks; concerns): One theme of the bill is shifting litigation power from public litigants to permit applicants.
  > rebalancing power away from public litigants and toward permit applicants
  [Eno Center for Transportation, 2026-10-02](https://enotrans.org/article/senate-proposes-major-changes-to-permit-and-review-processes/). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 10 to p. 68, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).
- **King & Spalding** (Lawyers and legal scholars; mixed): Litigation risk falls but does not disappear: opponents would likely redirect challenges to substantive statutes such as the Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act.
  > Courts could still halt a project for violations of substantive statutes such as the Clean Air Act or the CWA, so opponents may try to shift the focus of their challenges toward those statutes
  [King & Spalding, 2026-10-02](https://www.kslaw.com/Insights/Articles/The-Senate-Permitting-Deal-What-It-Would-Change-and-What-to-Do-Now). On the bill text at [p. 70, line 17 to p. 70, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=70).
- **King & Spalding** (Lawyers and legal scholars; explains): Because only commenters with direct harm can sue, the comment period becomes the litigation battleground and opponents will file detailed comments.
  > Only commenters could sue, so expect opponents to file detailed comments.
  [King & Spalding, 2026-10-02](https://www.kslaw.com/Insights/Articles/The-Senate-Permitting-Deal-What-It-Would-Change-and-What-to-Do-Now). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 10 to p. 68, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).
- **Womble Bond Dickinson** (Lawyers and legal scholars; mixed): The 150-day, remand-only regime reduces the chance a NEPA claim alone stops construction while leaving substantive-law claims intact.
  > These changes could reduce the ability of a NEPA challenge alone to interrupt construction, while leaving projects subject to independently applicable substantive requirements.
  [Womble Bond Dickinson, 2026-10-02](https://www.womblebonddickinson.com/us/node/21451). On the bill text at [p. 69, line 24 to p. 70, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69).
- **Sen. Kevin Cramer** (Officials; supports): Cramer calls the expedited judicial review the most important part and argues a smaller plaintiff pool prevents delay-by-litigation.
  > Lawfare works best with more litigants, and if everybody’s allowed to be a plaintiff, guess what? You don’t even have to come close to being successful to screw the whole thing up
  [Daily Caller News Foundation, 2026-10-03](https://dailycaller.com/2026/10/03/kevin-cramer-senate-permitting-bill-class-energy-projects-fines-capito-lee-heinrich-whitehouse). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 19 to p. 68, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).
- **Stanford Law School** (Lawyers and legal scholars; concerns): The 150-day limit and court-of-appeals venue change little, since most NEPA suits are already filed within months and decided on summary judgment.
  > So here, they feel more like window dressing than anything else.
  [Stanford Law School (blog), 2026-10-04](https://law.stanford.edu/2026/10/04/permitting-reform-legislation-would-take-a-meat-axe-to-environmental-law-when-what-we-need-is-a-surgical-scalpel/). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 1 to p. 68, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).
- **Stanford Law School** (Lawyers and legal scholars; opposes): The 'direct harm' requirement could bar suits over indirect or cumulative impacts, such as added emissions in an already polluted area.
  > What does the real work in this clause is the “direct harm” language, which potentially eliminates claims over indirect or cumulative impacts
  [Stanford Law School (blog), 2026-10-04](https://law.stanford.edu/2026/10/04/permitting-reform-legislation-would-take-a-meat-axe-to-environmental-law-when-what-we-need-is-a-surgical-scalpel/). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 19 to p. 68, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).
- **Stanford Law School** (Lawyers and legal scholars; opposes): Letting a project proceed during a remand means it can be built before its impacts are properly considered, which defeats NEPA's purpose.
  > This language, if enacted, effectively guts the core purpose and effect of NEPA.
  [Stanford Law School (blog), 2026-10-04](https://law.stanford.edu/2026/10/04/permitting-reform-legislation-would-take-a-meat-axe-to-environmental-law-when-what-we-need-is-a-surgical-scalpel/). On the bill text at [p. 69, line 24 to p. 70, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69).
- **Ben Schifman** (Think tanks; supports): Section 1110 would limit third-party suits that try to stop a Tribe from managing its own resources.
  > there's an important benefit for federally recognized Tribes in §1110 of BAAJA: limiting the ability of third parties to sue to stop the Tribe from managing its own resources as it wants to.
  [X, 2026-10-16](https://x.com/BenSchifman/status/2110931358696563164). On the bill text at [p. 73, line 8 to p. 73, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=73).
- **Southern Environmental Law Center** (Environmental groups; opposes): SELC says the bill's statute of limitations and limits on state, tribal and local water authority would reduce communities' ability to challenge energy projects such as gas pipelines.
  > Restricts the ability of states, tribes, and local communities to protect local waterways and drinking water supplies threatened by large energy projects, like gas pipelines.
  [SELC press release, 2026-09-30](https://www.selc.org/?p=44520). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 1 to p. 68, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).
- **Heatmap News** (Reporting; explains): The bill could reduce legal risk for future interstate gas pipelines that might serve a large data center, which Holzman says reads as an easier path to more gas generation in the region.
  > It would reduce legal risks associated with future interstate gas pipelines under development expected to potentially branch out to Project Jupiter
  [Heatmap News (The Fight), 2026-10-16](https://heatmap.news/plus/the-fight/spotlight/project-jupiter-permitting). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 1 to p. 68, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).
- **Aaron Weiss** (Environmental groups; opposes): Weiss says that when a court sends an environmental review back, construction continues and Section 1401 bars the agency from changing the permit, and challengers get 150 days to sue.
  > Challengers also get just 150 days to sue.
  [Common Dreams, 2026-10-22](https://www.commondreams.org/news/senate-permitting-bill). On the bill text at [p. 159, line 12 to p. 159, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=159).
- **The Revelator** (Lawyers and legal scholars; opposes): Camacho and Glicksman say BAAJA hollows out NEPA, including courts' ability to enforce it.
  > the bill is an out-and-out assault on the National Environmental Policy Act, the bedrock environmental law that has for more than 50 years required the federal government to look before it leaps.
  [The Revelator, 2026-10-23](https://therevelator.org/baaja). On the bill text at [p. 68, line 1 to p. 68, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68).

## Selected statutory quotes

> the only remedy the court may order to redress that violation is to remand, without vacatur or issuance of an injunction, the applicable authorization to the agency

[p. 69, line 24 to p. 70, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69)

Remand is the only remedy; a court cannot vacate or enjoin.

> a claim shall be barred unless the claim— “(1) is filed not later than 150 days

[p. 67, line 24 to p. 68, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=67)

The 150-day filing deadline.

> In reviewing a claim of whether an authorization complies with the requirements of this Act, a court shall afford substantial deference to the agency relating to the scope and contents of an environmental document.

[p. 73, line 23 to p. 74, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=73)

Courts must defer to the agency on scope and contents.

> The activity that is the subject of an authorization remanded under paragraph (5)(A) may, notwithstanding that remand, be carried out

[p. 71, line 20 to p. 71, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=71)

The project can proceed during the remand.

## Comparison notes

- [SPEED Act (H.R. 4776), engrossed in House](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm)
- [Energy Permitting Reform Act of 2024 (S. 4753), reported in Senate](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm)

### Current law

NEPA has no limitations period of its own, so the general 6-year limit on suits against the United States applies, with 2 years for FAST-41 covered projects and 150 days for highway and transit projects. There is no statutory prior-comment rule, cases start in district court, and courts can vacate or enjoin an approval.

### EPRA 2024 (reported S. 4753)

EPRA 2024 (sec. 101) set a 150-day limit for energy and mineral project authorizations and a 180-day remand deadline. It did not require prior comment, did not change standing, and left courts their ordinary remedies. That section survives as section 2201 of this bill.

### SPEED Act (House-passed H.R. 4776)

The SPEED Act (sec. 3) had the same core: 150 days, prior comment, direct harm, substantial deference, remand without vacatur or injunction, a 180-day fix deadline, and the tribal trust carve-out. Differences: the House bill barred challenges to the creation of categorical exclusions, required courts to rule within 180 days of receiving the record and appeals within another 180, and applied its remand rule to court orders entered before enactment. The Senate bill drops those three, moves cases to the courts of appeals with random assignment, lets construction continue during a remand in express terms, and allows a preliminary injunction when a different federal law is likely violated.

## Full statutory text

Extracted from the official PDF; line cites mark paragraph starts. Consult the PDF for exact layout.

[p. 67, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=67) (indent level 0)

Title I of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (as amended by section 1102(b)(1)) is amended by inserting after section 110 (42 U.S.C. 4336d) the following:

[p. 67, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=67) (indent level 0)

“SEC. 111. JUDICIAL REVIEW.

[p. 67, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=67) (indent level 1)

“(a) DEFINITION OF CLAIM.—In this section, the term ‘claim’ means a claim that—

[p. 67, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=67) (indent level 2)

“(1) is filed on or after the date of enactment of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026; and

[p. 67, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=67) (indent level 2)

“(2) seeks judicial review under any provision of Federal law of an authorization based on a claim that an environmental review failed to be properly conducted pursuant to the requirements of this Act.

[p. 67, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=67) (indent level 1)

“(b) LIMITATIONS ON CLAIMS.—Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a claim shall be barred unless the claim—

[p. 68, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68) (indent level 2)

“(1) is filed not later than 150 days after the date on which, unless a shorter deadline is specified under Federal law—

[p. 68, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68) (indent level 3)

“(A) in the case of a claim in which an environmental impact statement was prepared, the applicable authorization was published in the Federal Register; and

[p. 68, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68) (indent level 3)

“(B) in the case of any other claim, the authorization was made public;

[p. 68, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68) (indent level 2)

“(2) in the case of an authorization for which an opportunity for comment was provided, the claim is filed by a party that submitted a substantive comment during a public comment period associated with that authorization, with such comment being sufficiently detailed to put the applicable Federal agency on notice of the particular issue on which the party seeks judicial review; and

[p. 68, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68) (indent level 2)

“(3) is filed by a party alleging (or has an individual member alleging) an actual or imminent injury in fact amounting to a direct harm.

[p. 68, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68) (indent level 1)

“(c) PROCEDURAL MATTERS FOR CLAIMS.—

[p. 68, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=68) (indent level 2)

“(1) ORIGINAL JURISDICTION.—The court of appeals of the United States for the circuit in which a project subject to an authorization will be constructed, expanded, or operated shall have original and exclusive jurisdiction over a claim.

[p. 69, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69) (indent level 2)

“(2) SUPPLEMENTAL JURISDICTION.—The courts of appeals of the United States shall have supplemental jurisdiction over other claims related to the validity of the authorization at issue in the claim within the original jurisdiction of the court of appeals.

[p. 69, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69) (indent level 2)

“(3) RANDOM ASSIGNMENT OF CASES.—To the maximum extent practicable, a court of appeals of the United States shall randomly assign judges appointed, designated, or assigned to sit as judges of the court to hear claims in a manner to avoid the appearance of favoritism or bias.

[p. 69, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69) (indent level 2)

“(4) DEADLINES FOR RESOLUTION.—A court of appeals of the United States shall render a final judgment with respect to a claim as expeditiously as possible.

[p. 69, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69) (indent level 2)

“(5) REMEDY.—

[p. 69, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=69) (indent level 3)

“(A) IN GENERAL.—Except as provided in subparagraph (B) and notwithstanding any other provision of law, if a court determines that an authorization does not comply with the requirements of this Act, the only remedy the court may order to redress that violation is to remand, without vacatur or issuance of an injunction, the applicable authorization to the agency with—

[p. 70, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=70) (indent level 4)

“(i) specific instructions to correct errors or deficiencies found by the court; and

[p. 70, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=70) (indent level 4)

“(ii) a reasonable schedule and deadline for the agency to act on remand, which shall not exceed 180 days after the date on which the order of the court was entered.

[p. 70, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=70) (indent level 3)

“(B) PRELIMINARY INJUNCTIONS.—

[p. 70, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=70) (indent level 4)

“(i) IN GENERAL.—Notwithstanding subparagraph (A) and subject to clause (ii), a court may issue a preliminary injunction for the applicable authorization when—

[p. 70, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=70) (indent level 5)

“(I) there is a substantial likelihood the authorization violates a Federal law other than—

[p. 70, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=70) (indent level 6)

“(aa) this Act; or

[p. 70, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=70) (indent level 6)

“(bb) division A of subtitle III of title 54, United States Code;

[p. 70, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=70) (indent level 5)

“(II) necessary to prevent irreparable harm to the plaintiff;

[p. 71, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=71) (indent level 5)

“(III) the balance of equities favors the plaintiff; and

[p. 71, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=71) (indent level 5)

“(IV) a preliminary injunction is in the public interest.

[p. 71, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=71) (indent level 4)

“(ii) REQUIREMENTS.—A preliminary injunction issued by a court under clause (i) shall last no longer than the time the court finds is reasonably necessary—

[p. 71, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=71) (indent level 5)

“(I) for the correction of the violation described in clause (i)(I); and

[p. 71, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=71) (indent level 5)

“(II) to prevent the irreparable harm described in clause (i)(II).

[p. 71, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=71) (indent level 2)

“(6) REMANDED ACTIONS.—

[p. 71, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=71) (indent level 3)

“(A) CONTINUED EFFECT OF AUTHORIZATION.— An authorization remanded under paragraph (5)(A) shall remain in effect while the Federal agency corrects any errors or deficiencies found by the reviewing court.

[p. 71, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=71) (indent level 3)

“(B) FEDERAL ACTION DURING REMAND.— The activity that is the subject of an authorization remanded under paragraph (5)(A) may, notwithstanding that remand, be carried out, including during the time prescribed by the applicable court to correct the applicable errors or deficiencies.

[p. 72, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=72) (indent level 2)

“(7) TREATMENT OF SUPPLEMENTAL OR REVISED ENVIRONMENTAL DOCUMENTS.—

[p. 72, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=72) (indent level 3)

“(A) IN GENERAL.—For purposes of a claim—

[p. 72, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=72) (indent level 4)

“(i) a supplemental or revised environmental document for an authorization, when required by court order, shall be considered to be a separate environmental document; and

[p. 72, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=72) (indent level 4)

“(ii) the deadline for filing a claim for judicial review of an authorization described in clause (i) shall be the date that is 150 days after the date on which the authorization for which the supplemental environmental document is prepared is made public by the agency, unless a shorter time is specified in the Federal law pursuant to which judicial review is authorized.

[p. 72, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=72) (indent level 3)

“(B) LIMITATION.—A claim for review of an authorization described in subparagraph (A)(i) shall be limited to information contained in the final supplemental environmental documents that was not contained in a previous environmental document for the authorization.

[p. 73, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=73) (indent level 2)

“(8) ACTIONS FOR USE OF TRIBAL TRUST RESOURCES.—

[p. 73, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=73) (indent level 3)

“(A) IN GENERAL.—Except as provided in subparagraph (B), for any action that authorizes the use of lands, minerals, or other resources held in trust at the time of a final agency action by the United States for the benefit of an Indian Tribe, there shall be no administrative or judicial review of such final agency action based on a claim of failure to comply with the requirements of this Act.

[p. 73, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=73) (indent level 3)

“(B) EXCEPTIONS.—Subparagraph (A) shall not apply to an action for administrative or judicial review—

[p. 73, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=73) (indent level 4)

“(i) brought by the Indian Tribe for which the United States holds the lands, minerals, or other resources in trust; or

[p. 73, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=73) (indent level 4)

“(ii) that involves reasonably foreseeable effects of the final agency action that occur outside the lands, minerals, or other resources held in trust by the United States for the benefit of an Indian Tribe.

[p. 73, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=73) (indent level 1)

“(d) ROLE OF COURT.—In reviewing a claim of whether an authorization complies with the requirements of this Act, a court shall afford substantial deference to the agency relating to the scope and contents of an environmental document.

[p. 74, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=74) (indent level 1)

“(e) PROHIBITION ON CERTAIN CLAIMS AND JUDICIAL REVIEW.—Notwithstanding any other provision of law, there shall not be a claim or judicial review of whether a final agency action complies with the requirements of this Act for any omission from the list described in section 3(22)(B).

[p. 74, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=74) (indent level 1)

“(f) EFFECT.—Nothing in this section—

[p. 74, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=74) (indent level 2)

“(1) establishes a cause of action or a right to judicial review;

[p. 74, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=74) (indent level 2)

“(2) places any limit on filing a claim that a person has violated the terms of an authorization; or

[p. 74, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=74) (indent level 2)

“(3) affects the right to obtain review under section 107(g)(4).”.

