# Sec. 1402. Ensuring fairness for specific types of covered projects

BAAJA draft released September 30, 2026. AI-assisted analysis; proposed changes.

Saved AI review: 794 supported, 0 flagged, 18 unchecked of 812 statements; checked 2026-10-06; stale: true. Coverage excludes current-law comparison cells and some research paraphrases. Read data/core.json checks for link and quote results and their dates. A stale review does not verify the current wording.

[Official PDF](https://www.epw.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/5/c/5c5f5935-b224-48e7-abea-e60c30e7a4cf/7935BF3C85967B6F56F6F4858FD3221B7E0AEB02D04BE391CAFBD1B884CE3DC5.bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act-text.pdf) · [Browser section](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/#/bill/sec/1402)

## Summary

Creates a cause of action for applicants in 46 named energy project types, plus any similar type a court certifies. ([p. 172, line 13 to p. 172, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=172)) The list runs from onshore and offshore wind, solar and storage to coal, gas, oil, nuclear, geothermal, transmission, pipelines, mining, hydrogen, hydropower, LNG and carbon storage. ([p. 169, line 4 to p. 169, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169))

The applicant must show a 'pattern of disparate treatment': an intentional, statistically demonstrated rise in denials or delays for that project type, compared with the prior 5 years. ([p. 167, line 16 to p. 167, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=167)) The pattern must last 180 days after enactment for permits without a NEPA document, or 280 days for those with one. ([p. 168, line 11 to p. 168, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=168)) Executive orders and official statements showing bias count as supporting evidence. ([p. 176, line 11 to p. 176, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=176)) The government must produce raw statistics for the year of the suit and the 5 years before it, or face an adverse inference. ([p. 177, line 15 to p. 177, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=177))

Permits for these projects that need no NEPA document must be decided within 1 year of a complete application. ([p. 173, line 5 to p. 173, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=173))

Remedies are an injunction, fees, economic damages, and 50 to 100 percent of the expected construction cost, paid from the Judgment Fund. ([p. 179, line 20 to p. 179, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=179)) The applicant must finish the project or repay. ([p. 180, line 23 to p. 180, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=180)) Class actions are barred, and suits cannot be filed until 180 or 280 days after enactment. ([p. 181, line 8 to p. 181, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=181))

## Key points

- Anti-discrimination rule across 46 named project types, from offshore wind to coal, plus any similar type a court certifies ([p. 172, line 13 to p. 172, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=172))
- Executive orders and officials' statements admissible as evidence of bias ([p. 176, line 11 to p. 176, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=176))
- Damages of 50 to 100 percent of expected construction cost ([p. 179, line 20 to p. 179, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=179))
- One-year deadline for permits that need no NEPA document ([p. 173, line 5 to p. 173, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=173))
- Claims mature 180 or 280 days after enactment ([p. 181, line 23 to p. 181, line 25](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=181))

## What others say it would do

Outside readings, quoted from their sources. These are claims about effects, not findings of this tracker.

- **E2** (Clean energy industry; mixed): Permitting reform must end the administration's clean-energy permit blocks to matter for supply and prices.
  > That also must include ending the administration's clean energy permit blocks, which are keeping gigawatts of the cheapest power off the grid as prices rise for everyone.
  [PV Tech, 2026-10-01](https://www.pv-tech.org/us-planning-reform-bill-gets-mixed-response-from-clean-energy-groups/).
- **Sierra Club** (Environmental groups; concerns): Without enforceable protection against the administration's blocks, the bill cannot guarantee wind and solar get built.
  > this bill cannot guarantee that more wind and solar projects will actually get built as long as the Trump administration continues to block them at every turn.
  [PV Tech, 2026-10-01](https://www.pv-tech.org/us-planning-reform-bill-gets-mixed-response-from-clean-energy-groups/).
- **Foundation for American Innovation** (Think tanks; mixed): The certainty provisions are novel and depend on how courts enforce them, but together make mass targeting of disfavored projects much harder.
  > These provisions would not guarantee that every project gets approved, but they would make politically motivated obstruction much harder to sustain
  [Daily Caller News Foundation, 2026-10-03](https://dailycaller.com/2026/10/03/kevin-cramer-senate-permitting-bill-class-energy-projects-fines-capito-lee-heinrich-whitehouse).
- **TC Energy** (Industry; supports): The framework improves permitting certainty for gas pipelines as well as renewables.
  > improves permitting certainty for all forms of energy, from renewables to natural gas.
  [Daily Caller News Foundation, 2026-10-03](https://dailycaller.com/2026/10/03/kevin-cramer-senate-permitting-bill-class-energy-projects-fines-capito-lee-heinrich-whitehouse).
- **Rep. Jared Huffman** (Officials; concerns): The fair-treatment provisions for wind, solar and storage are untested, will not end the administration's hostility, and would draw Freedom Caucus opposition in the House.
  > the provisions that seek to guarantee fair treatment for wind, solar, and battery storage are novel, untested, and don't really end the war on clean energy
  [House Natural Resources Democrats, 2026-09-30](https://huffman.house.gov/media-center/press-releases/ranking-member-huffman-statement-on-senate-permitting-deal). On the bill text at [p. 167, line 14 to p. 167, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=167).
- **McGuireWoods** (Lawyers and legal scholars; explains): Developers could sue over a demonstrated pattern of agencies treating a technology class differently, with damages up to full expected construction cost.
  > Damages could range from 50% to 100% of the project's expected construction cost.
  [McGuireWoods, 2026-10-02](https://www.mcguirewoods.com/client-resources/alerts/2026/10/bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act-of-2026-proposes-sweeping-reform-for-energy-and-infrastructure-projects/). On the bill text at [p. 179, line 20 to p. 179, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=179).
- **Third Way** (Think tanks; supports): The certainty provisions apply across technologies and administrations, not only to wind and solar.
  > Though a favorite target of President Trump, renewables are not the only projects assured fair treatment under BAAJA.
  [Third Way, 2026-10-02](https://www.thirdway.org/blog/one-baaja-blast-please).
- **Senate ENR Committee (Chair Lee's office)** (Officials; supports): Section 1402 is presented as recourse if a future administration repeats attacks on oil and gas, with explicit protection for gas pipelines.
  > Section 1402 provides recourse if a future administration tries to use the same playbook
  [Daily Caller News Foundation, 2026-10-03](https://dailycaller.com/2026/10/03/kevin-cramer-senate-permitting-bill-class-energy-projects-fines-capito-lee-heinrich-whitehouse). On the bill text at [p. 167, line 14 to p. 167, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=167).
- **Heatmap** (Reporting; mixed): The 'pattern of disparate treatment' cause of action is untested law, so it is unclear how courts would apply it to wind permitting delays.
  > At the same time, the discrimination language is a new area of law, Schifman told me, so there's some uncertainty as to how it would apply.
  [Heatmap, 2026-10-05](https://heatmap.news/politics/baaja-executive-actions). On the bill text at [p. 167, line 14 to p. 167, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=167).
- **Foley Hoag** (Lawyers and legal scholars; explains): The permit-certainty section would bar agencies from revoking or suspending authorizations in effect on or after Sept. 16, 2026, including offshore wind construction and operations plans, subject to listed exceptions and a clear-and-convincing burden on the agency.
  > The protection would not be absolute. Agencies could still act under a court order; for a material breach or violation of law; for fraud or misrepresentation; at the holder's request
  [Foley Hoag Energy & Climate Counsel, 2026-10-23](https://foleyhoag.com/news-and-insights/blogs/energy-and-climate-counsel/2026/october/baaja-blast-a-second-wind-certainty-cables-and-cost-allocation-for-offshore-wind-under-the-senat/). On the bill text at [p. 159, line 12 to p. 159, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=159).
- **Heatmap News** (Reporting; mixed): The permit-certainty ban exempts actions required by court order, so it is unresolved whether a court granting a remand motion would trigger the exception or give developers a damages claim.
  > The restriction exempts cases where "the agency is required to take such action by order of a court."
  [Heatmap News (The Fight), 2026-10-16](https://heatmap.news/plus/the-fight/hotspots/the-trump-administration-is-still-messing-with-offshore-wind-farms). On the bill text at [p. 159, line 20 to p. 159, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=159).
- **Oil Change International** (Environmental groups; opposes): The group reads the permit certainty sections as letting corporations sue agencies over actions that would reduce the use of federally permitted projects, covering existing permits as well as new ones.
  > This doesn’t just apply to projects permitted after the bill passes, but all projects with any kind of federal permit.
  [Oil Change International, 2026-10-26](https://oilchange.org/blogs/the-proposed-u-s-infrastructure-permitting-reform-bill-would-be-a-disaster-for-communities-and-for-climate-action/). On the bill text at [p. 167, line 14 to p. 167, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=167).
- **Theodore Roosevelt Conservation Partnership** (Environmental groups; concerns): TRCP says the permit certainty language as drafted locks in place nearly any permit a federal agency issues, which limits adaptive management for fish and wildlife.
  > as drafted the language effectively locks in place nearly any permit issued by a federal agency.
  [Theodore Roosevelt Conservation Partnership, 2026-10-23](https://www.trcp.org/2026/10/23/what-the-senates-permitting-bill-could-mean-for-hunters-and-anglers/). On the bill text at [p. 159, line 12 to p. 159, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=159).
- **Jane Flegal** (Think tanks; supports): A developer suing under Section 1402 must show missed deadlines or improper denials, a sharp rise over past rates and intent to target a project type, so past approval rates are evidence and not a quota.
  > The old approval rate is *not a quota,* but can be used as evidence of targeting.
  [X, 2026-10-21](https://x.com/JaneAFlegal/status/2112881718592180646). On the bill text at [p. 167, line 14 to p. 167, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=167).

## Selected statutory quotes

> a pattern of statements made by executive branch officials, Federal department and agency policies, Executive orders, or other official guidance that demonstrates a bias in the permitting regime against the specific type of covered project at issue

[p. 176, line 11 to p. 176, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=176)

Officials' statements and executive orders count as evidence of bias.

> damages in an amount equal to not less than 50 percent and not more than 100 percent of the total reasonably expected cost of construction of the project

[p. 179, line 20 to p. 179, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=179)

Damages of 50 to 100 percent of expected construction cost.

## Comparison notes

- [SPEED Act (H.R. 4776), engrossed in House](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm)
- [Energy Permitting Reform Act of 2024 (S. 4753), reported in Senate](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm)

### Current law

New.

### EPRA 2024 (reported S. 4753)

Not in EPRA 2024.

### SPEED Act (House-passed H.R. 4776)

Not in the SPEED Act.

## Full statutory text

Extracted from the official PDF; line cites mark paragraph starts. Consult the PDF for exact layout.

[p. 166, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=166) (indent level 1)

(a) SENSE OF CONGRESS.—It is the sense of Congress that—

[p. 166, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=166) (indent level 2)

(1) all Federal agencies shall treat all applications for Federal authorizations or permits fairly and efficiently; and

[p. 166, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=166) (indent level 2)

(2) this section shall serve as a guarantee that fair and efficient decisionmaking shall occur after the date of enactment of this Act.

[p. 166, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=166) (indent level 1)

(b) DEFINITIONS.—In this section:

[p. 166, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=166) (indent level 2)

(1) COVERED APPLICATION.—The term “covered application” means a complete application for 1 or more Federal authorizations or permits.

[p. 167, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=167) (indent level 2)

(2) FEDERAL AUTHORIZATION OR PERMIT.— The term “Federal authorization or permit” means an authorization, permit, record of decision, right-of-way, finding of no significant impact, verification, extension, construction and operations plan, biological opinion, incidental take statement, concurrence, or any other approval or order that is necessary, including any determination by a Federal department or agency that additional authorizations or permits are not necessary, for the construction or operation at full capacity of a specific type of covered project.

[p. 167, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=167) (indent level 2)

(3) PATTERN OF DISPARATE TREATMENT.— The term “pattern of disparate treatment” means, with respect to 1 specific type of covered project, an empirically demonstrated statistical pattern that—

[p. 167, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=167) (indent level 3)

(A) shows a substantial increase, compared against the 5 most recent calendar years of empirical data on Federal authorization or permit decisions and delays for that specific type of covered project, in—

[p. 167, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=167) (indent level 4)

(i) the percentage of Federal authorizations or permits for that 1 specific type of covered project that are unreasonably delayed beyond the applicable timeline as described in subsection (d)(1)(A)(ii); or

[p. 168, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=168) (indent level 4)

(ii) the percentage of Federal authorizations or permits for that 1 specific type of covered project that are improperly denied;

[p. 168, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=168) (indent level 3)

(B) persists—

[p. 168, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=168) (indent level 4)

(i) for a Federal authorization or permit for which an environmental impact statement or environmental assessment (as those terms are defined in section 3 of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969) are not required, over a minimum period of 180 days, at least 180 days of which occurred after the date of enactment of this Act; or

[p. 168, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=168) (indent level 4)

(ii) for a Federal authorization or permit for which an environmental impact statement or environmental assessment (as so defined) are required, over a minimum period of 280 days, at least 280 days of which occurred after the date of enactment of this Act; and

[p. 168, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=168) (indent level 3)

(C) is the result of an intentional course of action undertaken by the Federal Government to create such a pattern.

[p. 169, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169) (indent level 2)

(4) SPECIFIC TYPE OF COVERED PROJECT.— The term “specific type of covered project” means 1 of the following types of projects:

[p. 169, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169) (indent level 3)

(A) A project to produce electricity from onshore wind.

[p. 169, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169) (indent level 3)

(B) A project to produce electricity from offshore wind.

[p. 169, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169) (indent level 3)

(C) A project to produce electricity from solar.

[p. 169, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169) (indent level 3)

(D) An energy storage project.

[p. 169, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169) (indent level 3)

(E) A project to produce electricity from coal.

[p. 169, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169) (indent level 3)

(F) A project to produce electricity from natural gas.

[p. 169, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169) (indent level 3)

(G) A project to produce electricity from oil.

[p. 169, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169) (indent level 3)

(H) A project to produce electricity from a nuclear fission reactor.

[p. 169, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169) (indent level 3)

(I) A project to produce electricity from geothermal.

[p. 169, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169) (indent level 3)

(J) An onshore electricity transmission project.

[p. 169, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169) (indent level 3)

(K) An offshore electricity transmission project.

[p. 169, line 25](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=169) (indent level 3)

(L) A natural gas pipeline project.

[p. 170, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(M) An oil pipeline project.

[p. 170, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(N) A hydrogen pipeline project.

[p. 170, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(O) A carbon dioxide pipeline project.

[p. 170, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(P) A natural gas liquids pipeline project.

[p. 170, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(Q) A project to produce coal.

[p. 170, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(R) A project to produce onshore natural gas.

[p. 170, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(S) A project to produce offshore natural gas.

[p. 170, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(T) A project to produce onshore oil.

[p. 170, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(U) A project to produce offshore oil.

[p. 170, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(V) A hardrock mining project to produce minerals, with hardrock mining projects that produce the same mineral to be considered the same specific type of covered project for purposes of this paragraph.

[p. 170, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(W) A hardrock mineral processing project to produce or expand production of hardrock minerals.

[p. 170, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(X) A project to produce electricity from hydrogen.

[p. 170, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(Y) A project to produce electricity from biomass.

[p. 170, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=170) (indent level 3)

(Z) A project to refine or process petroleum products.

[p. 171, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=171) (indent level 3)

(AA) A project to produce biomass.

[p. 171, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=171) (indent level 3)

(BB) A hydropower project.

[p. 171, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=171) (indent level 3)

(CC) A pumped storage hydropower project.

[p. 171, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=171) (indent level 3)

(DD) A project to produce electricity from a fusion machine.

[p. 171, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=171) (indent level 3)

(EE) A project to produce uranium.

[p. 171, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=171) (indent level 3)

(FF) A project to enrich, convert, fabricate, reprocess, or store source material or special nuclear material (as those terms are defined in section 11 of the Atomic Energy Act of 1954 (42 U.S.C. 2014)).

[p. 171, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=171) (indent level 3)

(GG) A project to export or import liquefied natural gas.

[p. 171, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=171) (indent level 3)

(HH) A project to liquefy natural gas or to regasify liquefied natural gas.

[p. 171, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=171) (indent level 3)

(II) A project to export or import crude oil.

[p. 171, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=171) (indent level 3)

(JJ) A project to export or import refined petroleum products.

[p. 171, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=171) (indent level 3)

(KK) A project to export or import coal.

[p. 171, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=171) (indent level 3)

(LL) A geologic carbon dioxide sequestration or storage project, including an injection well;

[p. 172, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=172) (indent level 3)

(MM) An enhanced oil or natural gas recovery project, including a project using carbon dioxide, water, or other injectants.

[p. 172, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=172) (indent level 3)

(NN) Long-duration battery storage.

[p. 172, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=172) (indent level 3)

(OO) A project to refine or process crude oil.

[p. 172, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=172) (indent level 3)

(PP) A project to refine natural gas or natural gas liquids.

[p. 172, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=172) (indent level 3)

(QQ) An ammonia pipeline project.

[p. 172, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=172) (indent level 3)

(RR) A produced water pipeline project.

[p. 172, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=172) (indent level 3)

(SS) A helium pipeline project.

[p. 172, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=172) (indent level 3)

(TT) A coal gasification project.

[p. 172, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=172) (indent level 3)

(UU) Any other specific type of energy related project not described in subparagraphs (A) through (TT) that a United States district court of competent jurisdiction certifies shares common industrial characteristics, taking into account the specificity of the covered project types described in subparagraphs (A) through (TT).

[p. 172, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=172) (indent level 1)

(c) TIMELINE FOR ISSUANCE OF CERTAIN AUTHORIZATIONS OR PERMITS NOT SUBJECT TO ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEWS.—For any specific type of covered project for which 1 or more Federal authorizations or permits are required, but for which Federal authorizations or permits are not agency actions for which an environmental impact statement or environmental assessment (as those terms are defined in section 3 of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969) is required, all Federal departments and agencies shall render decisions on all applicable covered applications not later than 1 year after the date on which the latest of the covered applications is determined to be complete.

[p. 173, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=173) (indent level 1)

(d) JUDICIAL REVIEW.—

[p. 173, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=173) (indent level 2)

(1) CAUSE OF ACTION.—

[p. 173, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=173) (indent level 3)

(A) IN GENERAL.—The applicant seeking a Federal authorization or permit for a specific type of covered project may bring an action in a United States district court in which the project is at least partially located alleging, subject to subparagraph (B), that after the date of enactment of this Act 1 or more Federal authorizations or permits for that specific type of covered project were—

[p. 173, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=173) (indent level 4)

(i) improperly denied due to a pattern of disparate treatment by the Federal Government against the specific type of covered project at issue; or

[p. 173, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=173) (indent level 4)

(ii) unreasonably delayed due to a pattern of disparate treatment by the Federal Government against the specific type of covered project at issue by more than 60 days beyond the applicable deadline described in—

[p. 174, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=174) (indent level 5)

(I) section 107(g)(1)(A) of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4336a(g)(1)(A));

[p. 174, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=174) (indent level 5)

(II) section 107(g)(1)(B) of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4336a(g)(1)(B)); or

[p. 174, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=174) (indent level 5)

(III) subsection (c).

[p. 174, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=174) (indent level 3)

(B) REQUIREMENT.—

[p. 174, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=174) (indent level 4)

(i) IN GENERAL.—In a cause of action brought under subparagraph (A), the applicant shall have the burden of proof of showing that—

[p. 174, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=174) (indent level 5)

(I) the relevant application satisfies all applicable Federal law;

[p. 174, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=174) (indent level 5)

(II) the applicable Federal authorizations or permits would not, if granted, be subject to cancellation—

[p. 174, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=174) (indent level 6)

(aa) for a violation of application Federal law; or

[p. 174, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=174) (indent level 6)

(bb) because the Federal authorization or permit would have been obtained through fraud, intentional concealment, or material misrepresentation; and

[p. 175, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=175) (indent level 5)

(III) the Federal authorizations or permits were improperly denied or unreasonably delayed due to a pattern of disparate treatment by the Federal Government against the specific type of covered project at issue that occurred after the date of enactment of this Act.

[p. 175, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=175) (indent level 4)

(ii) PRIMA FACIE EVIDENCE.—

[p. 175, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=175) (indent level 5)

(I) EVIDENCE.—The following shall be considered by a court as prima facie evidence of a pattern of disparate treatment under clause (i)(III):

[p. 175, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=175) (indent level 6)

(aa) EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE.— Empirical evidence demonstrating a pattern of improper denial or unreasonable delay with respect to the specific type of covered project at issue compared to the previous rate at which other Federal authorizations or permits were delivered for that same specific type of covered project prior to the commencement of the alleged pattern of delayed or denied Federal authorizations or permits.

[p. 176, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=176) (indent level 6)

(bb) SUPPORTING EVIDENCE.— In support of the empirical evidence described in item (aa), an applicant may provide supporting evidence, including a pattern of statements made by executive branch officials, Federal department and agency policies, Executive orders, or other official guidance that demonstrates a bias in the permitting regime against the specific type of covered project at issue, except as provided in subclause (II).

[p. 176, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=176) (indent level 5)

(II) EXCLUSION.—Statements, policies, Executive orders, or other guidance that expresses a preference for, or opposition to, 1 or more specific types of covered projects, but is unrelated to the permitting of such projects, shall not be considered by a court as supporting evidence of a pattern of disparate treatment under subclause (I)(bb).

[p. 177, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=177) (indent level 4)

(iii) BURDEN OF EVIDENTIARY PRODUCTION.—

[p. 177, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=177) (indent level 5)

(I) IN GENERAL.—In a cause of action brought under this paragraph, if the applicant produces prima facie evidence of a pattern of disparate treatment under clause (i), the Federal Government shall have the burden to provide to the applicant and the court raw statistical data for the calendar year in which the action is brought and the preceding 5 calendar years showing, with respect to the specific type of covered project at issue—

[p. 177, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=177) (indent level 6)

(aa) the number and percentage of projects that received all necessary Federal authorizations or permits;

[p. 178, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=178) (indent level 6)

(bb) the number and percentage of projects that were denied 1 or more Federal authorizations or permits; and

[p. 178, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=178) (indent level 6)

(cc) the number and percentage of projects for which 1 or more covered applications were pending for more than 60 days beyond the applicable deadline described in subsection (c).

[p. 178, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=178) (indent level 5)

(II) FAILURE TO PRODUCE.—A failure of the Federal Government to produce the data described in subclause (I) shall result in an adverse inference against the 1 or more Federal agencies named in the cause of action.

[p. 178, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=178) (indent level 3)

(C) RECORD FOR REVIEW.—The court shall hear a cause of action brought under this paragraph solely on—

[p. 178, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=178) (indent level 4)

(i) the evidence produced by the applicant;

[p. 178, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=178) (indent level 4)

(ii) the administrative record before the agency; and

[p. 179, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=179) (indent level 4)

(iii) any raw statistical data required to be provided under subparagraph (B)(iii).

[p. 179, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=179) (indent level 2)

(2) REMEDY.—

[p. 179, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=179) (indent level 3)

(A) IN GENERAL.—If the applicant for a specific type of covered project successfully proves that the applicable Federal authorizations or permits were improperly denied or unreasonably delayed under paragraph (1), the applicant shall be entitled to—

[p. 179, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=179) (indent level 4)

(i) injunctive relief, as provided by applicable Federal law;

[p. 179, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=179) (indent level 4)

(ii) reasonable attorney fees and costs of litigation, as the court determines appropriate;

[p. 179, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=179) (indent level 4)

(iii) economic damages, including any costs associated with the applicable denial or delay, as the court determines appropriate; and

[p. 179, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=179) (indent level 4)

(iv) damages in an amount equal to not less than 50 percent and not more than 100 percent of the total reasonably expected cost of construction of the project, which amount shall be determined by the court taking into consideration—

[p. 180, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=180) (indent level 5)

(I) the degree to which the Federal interference in the applicable specific type of covered project occurred due to bad faith;

[p. 180, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=180) (indent level 5)

(II) the degree to which there exists a pattern of similar Federal interference in specific types of covered projects; and

[p. 180, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=180) (indent level 5)

(III) the actual degree of economic harm to the project sponsor or operator.

[p. 180, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=180) (indent level 3)

(B) REQUIREMENT.—To receive a remedy under subparagraph (A), the applicant shall demonstrate the technical and financial ability to construct the applicable specific type of covered project.

[p. 180, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=180) (indent level 2)

(3) PROJECT COMPLETION.—An applicant that receives a remedy under paragraph (2) shall, after obtaining all necessary Federal authorizations or permits and absent force majeure—

[p. 180, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=180) (indent level 3)

(A) complete the applicable specific type of covered project; or

[p. 180, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=180) (indent level 3)

(B) repay all remedies received under paragraph (2).

[p. 181, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=181) (indent level 2)

(4) SOURCE OF FUNDS.—Amounts awarded under paragraph (2)—

[p. 181, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=181) (indent level 3)

(A) shall be paid from the fund described in section 1304 of title 31, United States Code; and

[p. 181, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=181) (indent level 3)

(B) shall not be subject to the availability of appropriations.

[p. 181, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=181) (indent level 2)

(5) PROHIBITION ON CLASS ACTIONS.—Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure shall not apply to any action brought under this section, and no party with a claim under this section or any other person may sue as a representative party on behalf of any member of a specific type of covered project subject to Rule 23 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

[p. 181, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=181) (indent level 2)

(6) LIMITATION ON BRINGING CLAIMS.—With respect to a claim filed under this section after the date of enactment of this Act—

[p. 181, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=181) (indent level 3)

(A) no claim related to a Federal authorization or permit for which an environmental impact statement or environmental assessment (as those terms are defined in section 3 of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969) is required may be filed until the date that is 280 days after that date of enactment; and

[p. 182, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=182) (indent level 3)

(B) no claim related to a Federal authorization or permit for which an environmental impact statement or environmental assessment (as so defined) is not required may be filed until the date that is 180 days after that date of enactment.

