# Sec. 2301. Historic preservation

BAAJA draft released September 30, 2026. AI-assisted analysis; proposed changes.

Saved AI review: 794 supported, 0 flagged, 18 unchecked of 812 statements; checked 2026-10-06; stale: true. Coverage excludes current-law comparison cells and some research paraphrases. Read data/core.json checks for link and quote results and their dates. A stale review does not verify the current wording.

[Official PDF](https://www.epw.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/5/c/5c5f5935-b224-48e7-abea-e60c30e7a4cf/7935BF3C85967B6F56F6F4858FD3221B7E0AEB02D04BE391CAFBD1B884CE3DC5.bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act-text.pdf) · [Browser section](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/#/bill/sec/2301)

## Summary

Rewrites section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act. ([p. 379, line 7 to p. 379, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=379)) An 'adverse effect' must be reasonably foreseeable and must directly alter a historic property. ([p. 380, line 5 to p. 380, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380)) Temporary alterations are excluded. ([p. 380, line 19 to p. 380, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380)) Visual, atmospheric and audible effects are excluded unless they directly and significantly diminish the property. ([p. 380, line 13 to p. 380, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380)) An 'undertaking' excludes projects whose only federal tie is a loan, guarantee or grant, the non-federal parts of a project, minor repairs, permit renewals and post-approval operations. ([p. 383, line 22 to p. 383, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=383))

The process gets deadlines: 30 days to decide whether a project is an undertaking and 60 days for the agency's report. ([p. 386, line 8 to p. 386, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=386)) A determination or an agreement on the adverse effects follows within 90 days of the report. ([p. 392, line 4 to p. 392, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=392)) Advisory Council comments take 45 days, and the final decision takes 30 days. ([p. 394, line 19 to p. 394, line 25](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=394)) Consultation must be finished by the time the NEPA document is completed, unless the Secretary grants an extension for extraordinary circumstances. ([p. 398, line 3 to p. 398, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=398)) State and tribal preservation officers who do not respond in 30 days are passed over, and the agency may decide in its sole discretion that other considerations outweigh preservation. ([p. 400, line 19 to p. 400, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=400))

Courts give substantial deference and may only remand without vacatur or injunction; a preliminary injunction is available only for a likely violation of another law. ([p. 406, line 25 to p. 407, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=406)) Claims go to the courts of appeals, within 150 days, from parties who commented and suffered direct harm. ([p. 411, line 20 to p. 411, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=411)) A suit over a missed consultation deadline goes to a court where the project is located. ([p. 399, line 12 to p. 399, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=399)) Non-signatories cannot challenge programmatic agreements. ([p. 412, line 24 to p. 413, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=412)) State and tribal programs are evaluated every 2 years and lose grants if they miss consultation timelines. ([p. 373, line 18 to p. 373, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=373))

## Key points

- Adverse effect limited to direct physical alteration; visual and noise effects mostly excluded ([p. 380, line 5 to p. 380, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380))
- Loans and grants alone no longer trigger section 106 ([p. 383, line 22 to p. 383, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=383))
- End-to-end deadlines; silence from a preservation officer after 30 days lets the agency proceed ([p. 400, line 19 to p. 400, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=400))
- Agency may find other considerations outweigh preservation 'in the sole discretion' of the official ([p. 391, line 13 to p. 391, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=391))
- 150-day limit, court of appeals jurisdiction, remand without vacatur ([p. 408, line 23 to p. 408, line 25](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=408))
- Later National Register listings do not reopen a review ([p. 413, line 14 to p. 413, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=413))

## What others say it would do

Outside readings, quoted from their sources. These are claims about effects, not findings of this tracker.

- **Beveridge & Diamond** (Lawyers and legal scholars; explains): Section 106 consultation could end without an agreement on resolving adverse effects, with narrowed scope that omits indirect effects.
  > with greater emphasis on an action agency's ability to conclude Section 106 consultation without an agreement on resolving adverse effects to historic properties.
  [Mondaq (Beveridge & Diamond), 2026-10-02](https://www.mondaq.com/unitedstates/environmental-law/1850440/senate-permitting-bill-would-reshape-environmental-permitting-and-reviews). On the bill text at [p. 379, line 15 to p. 379, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=379).
- **NCAI, NARF, NATHPO and six other Tribal organizations** (Tribal Nations and groups; opposes): Tribes would not be consulted while the agency draws the review area, finds historic properties and assesses effects, only after its report.
  > Tribal Nations need not be consulted as federal agencies designate an area of potential effect, identify historic properties, and assess potential effects
  [Joint letter (via HillHeat), 2026-10-09](https://hillheat.com/files/517/Joint-Tribal-Org-Letter-Opposing-BAAJA-NHPA-Title-FINAL-with-Logos-10_9_26.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 387, line 11 to p. 387, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=387).
- **NCAI, NARF, NATHPO and six other Tribal organizations** (Tribal Nations and groups; opposes): A Tribe would have only 30 days to object to an agency's Section 106 report.
  > forces a Tribal Nation to assert substantive objections to a federal agency’s Section 106 report within a mere 30 days of receipt
  [Joint letter (via HillHeat), 2026-10-09](https://hillheat.com/files/517/Joint-Tribal-Org-Letter-Opposing-BAAJA-NHPA-Title-FINAL-with-Logos-10_9_26.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 401, line 22 to p. 401, line 25](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=401).
- **NCAI, NARF, NATHPO and six other Tribal organizations** (Tribal Nations and groups; opposes): Missed deadlines would cost a Tribe its THPO status and funding, and Interior would take over the office's work.
  > missed review deadlines will result in the loss of THPO status and funding, as well as the deeply paternalistic assumption of THPO functions by the Department of the Interior
  [Joint letter (via HillHeat), 2026-10-09](https://hillheat.com/files/517/Joint-Tribal-Org-Letter-Opposing-BAAJA-NHPA-Title-FINAL-with-Logos-10_9_26.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 377, line 10 to p. 377, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=377).
- **NCAI, NARF, NATHPO and six other Tribal organizations** (Tribal Nations and groups; opposes): Agencies could decide that other considerations outweigh harm to sacred places.
  > the bill would give federal agencies the authority to determine that “other considerations” outweigh adverse effects on our sacred places
  [Joint letter (via HillHeat), 2026-10-09](https://hillheat.com/files/517/Joint-Tribal-Org-Letter-Opposing-BAAJA-NHPA-Title-FINAL-with-Logos-10_9_26.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 393, line 4 to p. 393, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=393).
- **NCAI, NARF, NATHPO and six other Tribal organizations** (Tribal Nations and groups; opposes): Remand without vacatur as the default remedy would let a project proceed while a flawed review is redone.
  > nearly eliminates any real remedies available to Tribal Nations by stipulating remand without vacatur as a baseline
  [Joint letter (via HillHeat), 2026-10-09](https://hillheat.com/files/517/Joint-Tribal-Org-Letter-Opposing-BAAJA-NHPA-Title-FINAL-with-Logos-10_9_26.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 406, line 25 to p. 407, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=406).
- **NATHPO, NCAI, NARF, AAIA and Cultural Heritage Partners** (Tribal Nations and groups; opposes): The existing duty to consult would become optional when the agency identifies historic properties.
  > BAAJA turns that mandate into a “may”: an agency “may consult” Tribes when it identifies historic properties.
  [Cultural Heritage Partners (posted by NATHPO), 2026-10-16](https://edge.growthzonecms.com/sites/2385/2026/10/20261017_BAAJA_Tribes_Claim_vs_Fact_FINAL.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 387, line 11 to p. 387, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=387).
- **NATHPO, NCAI, NARF, AAIA and Cultural Heritage Partners** (Tribal Nations and groups; opposes): The new definition's examples are built things and artifacts, which leaves mountains, springs and rivers uncertain.
  > the definition’s own examples are a “district, site, building, structure, or object” and “artifacts or material remains,” not a mountain, spring, or river
  [Cultural Heritage Partners (posted by NATHPO), 2026-10-16](https://edge.growthzonecms.com/sites/2385/2026/10/20261017_BAAJA_Tribes_Claim_vs_Fact_FINAL.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 372, line 15 to p. 372, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=372).
- **NATHPO, NCAI, NARF, AAIA and Cultural Heritage Partners** (Tribal Nations and groups; opposes): The bill gives Tribes 30 days to respond, half the 60 days supporters criticize in the administration's draft rule.
  > BAAJA halves the time, with the same consequence.
  [Cultural Heritage Partners (posted by NATHPO), 2026-10-16](https://edge.growthzonecms.com/sites/2385/2026/10/20261017_BAAJA_Tribes_Claim_vs_Fact_FINAL.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 400, line 16 to p. 400, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=400).
- **NATHPO, NCAI, NARF, AAIA and Cultural Heritage Partners** (Tribal Nations and groups; opposes): A court that finds a Section 106 violation could only send the review back while construction continues.
  > Courts cannot stop a project that violates Section 106; the only remedy is to reinitiate the review while construction continues.
  [Cultural Heritage Partners (posted by NATHPO), 2026-10-16](https://edge.growthzonecms.com/sites/2385/2026/10/20261017_BAAJA_Tribes_Claim_vs_Fact_FINAL.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 406, line 25 to p. 407, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=406).
- **NATHPO, NCAI, NARF, AAIA and Cultural Heritage Partners** (Tribal Nations and groups; opposes): The administration's draft rule can be fought or reversed, while the bill's limits would be permanent.
  > Trading a reversible bad rule for an irreversible bad statute is not protection.
  [Cultural Heritage Partners (posted by NATHPO), 2026-10-16](https://edge.growthzonecms.com/sites/2385/2026/10/20261017_BAAJA_Tribes_Claim_vs_Fact_FINAL.pdf).
- **NATHPO** (Tribal Nations and groups; opposes): Agencies already must consult Tribes, and the bill would make that optional.
  > Agencies are already legally required to consult Tribes. BAAJA makes that optional.
  [X, 2026-10-20](https://x.com/NATHPO_org/status/2112359143525003621). On the bill text at [p. 387, line 11 to p. 387, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=387).
- **National Trust for Historic Preservation** (Historic preservationists; opposes): Consultation could end when a party misses a deadline, and the agency could proceed without revisiting earlier findings.
  > Consultation could effectively end when a consulting party does not respond within prescribed deadlines
  [National Trust for Historic Preservation, 2026-10-01](https://savingplaces.org/press-center/media-resources/national-trust-rejects-key-provisions-of-permitting-reform-bill). On the bill text at [p. 400, line 16 to p. 400, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=400).
- **National Trust for Historic Preservation** (Historic preservationists; opposes): An agency could end review on its own finding that other considerations outweigh historic preservation.
  > the proposal would give federal agencies significant authority to end the Section 106 process based on their own unilateral determination that other considerations outweigh historic preservation
  [National Trust for Historic Preservation, 2026-10-01](https://savingplaces.org/press-center/media-resources/national-trust-rejects-key-provisions-of-permitting-reform-bill). On the bill text at [p. 393, line 4 to p. 393, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=393).
- **National Conference of State Historic Preservation Officers** (States and counties; opposes): If a SHPO, THPO or Tribe does not answer on an agreement, the agency could sign it with the Advisory Council instead.
  > If a SHPO, THPO, Tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, or local government fails to respond to an agreement, the Federal official could enter into the agreement with ACHP instead.
  [NCSHPO, 2026-10-02](https://ncshpo.org/2026/10/02/senate-proposal-does-more-than-streamline-section-106/). On the bill text at [p. 401, line 9 to p. 401, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=401).
- **NRDC** (Environmental groups; concerns): The bill limits when Tribes take part in decisions and which Tribal interests count.
  > The bill limits Tribal participation in decisions concerning federally connected projects and what Tribal interests are protected
  [NRDC, 2026-10-19](https://www.nrdc.org/media/nrdc-assessment-baaja-2026-permitting-transmission-bill). On the bill text at [p. 387, line 11 to p. 387, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=387).
- **Institute for Progress** (Think tanks; supports): The existing statutory duty to consult Tribes, and THPO authority, stay as they are.
  > NHPA’s Tribal consultation requirement, THPO authority, or other sources of duties to Tribes (treaties, the trust responsibility, NAGPRA, and the consultation executive orders) are unchanged in BAAJA.
  [Institute for Progress, 2026-10-13](https://ifp.org/wp-content/uploads/BAAJA-protects-Tribal-consultation-from-ACHPs-regulatory-rollback.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 387, line 23 to p. 388, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=387).
- **Institute for Progress** (Think tanks; supports): The new definition would keep natural features eligible, which the administration's draft rule would exclude.
  > would ensure natural features important to Tribes can be treated as historic properties under NHPA
  [Institute for Progress, 2026-10-13](https://ifp.org/wp-content/uploads/BAAJA-protects-Tribal-consultation-from-ACHPs-regulatory-rollback.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 372, line 15 to p. 372, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=372).
- **Institute for Progress** (Think tanks; supports): Without the bill, Tribes face the administration's narrower draft rule, which a later rulemaking would struggle to undo.
  > Without BAAJA, Tribes face the narrowed ACHP rule now — ACHP has already voted in favor of it — then years of litigation and a new administration’s rulemaking process to attempt to reverse it.
  [Institute for Progress, 2026-10-13](https://ifp.org/wp-content/uploads/BAAJA-protects-Tribal-consultation-from-ACHPs-regulatory-rollback.pdf).
- **Thomas Hochman** (Commentators; supports): The existing shall-consult duty stays, and the bill adds Tribal consultation steps to Section 106 itself.
  > BAAJA keeps Sec. 101’s "shall consult" language *and* adds explicit Tribal consultation requirements to Section 106.
  [X, 2026-10-19](https://x.com/ThomasHochman/status/2112264088671998226). On the bill text at [p. 387, line 23 to p. 388, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=387).
- **Thomas Hochman** (Commentators; supports): The bill writes a definition of Tribal sacred places into the statute.
  > It also codifies definitions for Tribal sacred places
  [X, 2026-10-19](https://x.com/ThomasHochman/status/2112264088671998226). On the bill text at [p. 372, line 15 to p. 372, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=372).
- **Searchlight Institute** (Think tanks; supports): The bill writes the Tribal role in historic preservation review into law, from the start of consultation on.
  > It writes tribes' role in historic preservation reviews into law, guaranteeing them a seat from the start of consultation through every major decision.
  [Searchlight Institute, 2026-10-07](https://www.searchlightinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/MEMO-The-Bipartisan-American-Affordability-and-Jobs-Act-BAAJA-is-a-Good-Deal.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 397, line 22 to p. 397, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=397).
- **Searchlight Institute** (Think tanks; supports): A procedural error alone would no longer stop a project, while courts could still halt one on the merits.
  > What changes is that a paperwork mistake in a procedural review can't kill a project on its own.
  [Searchlight Institute, 2026-10-07](https://www.searchlightinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/MEMO-The-Bipartisan-American-Affordability-and-Jobs-Act-BAAJA-is-a-Good-Deal.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 406, line 25 to p. 407, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=406).
- **Aidan Mackenzie** (Think tanks; supports): Section 106 gathers information and consults; it never gave a veto, and the bill does not change that.
  > NHPA 106 is an information gathering and consultation process. That's true now and BAAJA doesn't change it
  [X, 2026-10-19](https://x.com/AidanRMackenzie/status/2112277233327051221). On the bill text at [p. 393, line 4 to p. 393, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=393).
- **Vinson & Elkins** (Lawyers and legal scholars; supports): The bill ties historic preservation deadlines to the NEPA schedule, with enforceable penalties if the historic preservation process runs longer.
  > the bill ties NHPA deadlines to the NEPA process, with enforceable penalties if the NHPA process exceeds NEPA reviews.
  [Vinson & Elkins, 2026-10-02](https://www.velaw.com/insights/to-the-finish-line-ten-ways-the-new-senate-permitting-bill-is-a-boon-for-energy-infrastructure/). On the bill text at [p. 398, line 3 to p. 398, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=398).
- **Institute for Progress** (Think tanks; supports): THPOs already work under federal approval and review, with disapproval and suspension possible today; the bill shortens the review cycle and adds the takeover step, which the report says matters for Tribal self-government.
  > THPO programs already operate within a federal approval and oversight framework.
  [Institute for Progress, 2026-10-08](https://ifp.org/wp-content/uploads/Tribal-consultation-under-the-Bipartisan-American-Affordability-and-Jobs-Act.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 377, line 10 to p. 377, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=377).
- **NATHPO, NCAI, NARF, AAIA and Cultural Heritage Partners** (Tribal Nations and groups; opposes): A Tribe that misses the new deadlines can lose its preservation funding and see Interior take over its office, which the paper calls an affront to sovereignty.
  > Far from protecting Tribes or leaving their preservation offices “unchanged,” BAAJA penalizes Tribes that miss its deadlines
  [Cultural Heritage Partners (posted by NATHPO), 2026-10-16](https://edge.growthzonecms.com/sites/2385/2026/10/20261017_BAAJA_Tribes_Claim_vs_Fact_FINAL.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 377, line 10 to p. 377, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=377).
- **Institute for Progress** (Think tanks; supports): A Tribe that raised its concern in writing during consultation can still sue after the decision, without meeting the new tests on who may sue.
  > Section 2301(c) exempts Tribes from the new standing requirements, ensuring that Tribes who raised a concern in writing during consultation can bring a lawsuit after the decision.
  [Institute for Progress, 2026-09-30](https://ifp.org/how-the-permitting-deal-works/). On the bill text at [p. 410, line 13 to p. 410, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=410).
- **NCAI, NARF, NATHPO and six other Tribal organizations** (Tribal Nations and groups; opposes): The bill would set a 150-day limit to sue and narrow who may bring a case.
  > This bill also institutes a 150-day statute of limitations, attempts to limit standing
  [Joint letter (via HillHeat), 2026-10-09](https://hillheat.com/files/517/Joint-Tribal-Org-Letter-Opposing-BAAJA-NHPA-Title-FINAL-with-Logos-10_9_26.pdf). On the bill text at [p. 409, line 9 to p. 409, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=409).
- **Preservation coalition (13 groups)** (Historic preservationists; opposes): Redefining 'undertaking' to require a federal permit or approval plus substantial federal control would pull most federally funded projects out of Section 106 review.
  > Projects funded by federal grants or loans would mostly fall outside the Section 106 process unless the funding is for historic preservation itself.
  [Coalition letter hosted by National Trust, 2026-10-20](https://savingplaces.org/permitting-reform-coalition-letter-october-20). On the bill text at [p. 383, line 14 to p. 383, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=383).
- **Preservation coalition (13 groups)** (Historic preservationists; opposes): The new statutory definition of 'adverse effect' would exclude most visual, atmospheric, audible and temporary effects, and the area of potential effects would be capped.
  > A new statutory definition of "adverse effect" would exclude most visual, atmospheric, and audible effects, temporary effects, and effects on parts of a property beyond its character-defining features.
  [Coalition letter hosted by National Trust, 2026-10-20](https://savingplaces.org/permitting-reform-coalition-letter-october-20). On the bill text at [p. 380, line 5 to p. 380, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380).
- **Preservation coalition (13 groups)** (Historic preservationists; opposes): A 30-day consulting-party clock lets an agency proceed without a SHPO, THPO, Tribe or local government, or reach agreement with the ACHP instead.
  > Consulting parties would generally have 30 days to provide information or object, after which the agency may proceed without them.
  [Coalition letter hosted by National Trust, 2026-10-20](https://savingplaces.org/permitting-reform-coalition-letter-october-20). On the bill text at [p. 388, line 6 to p. 388, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=388).
- **Preservation coalition (13 groups)** (Historic preservationists; opposes): The Interior Secretary could assume a THPO's functions and suspend its funding if timelines are missed, which the signers say violates the government-to-government relationship.
  > For the first time, the Secretary of the Interior could assume a THPO's functions and suspend its funding.
  [Coalition letter hosted by National Trust, 2026-10-20](https://savingplaces.org/permitting-reform-coalition-letter-october-20). On the bill text at [p. 377, line 10 to p. 377, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=377).
- **Preservation coalition (13 groups)** (Historic preservationists; opposes): Claims would have to be filed within 150 days, with deference to the agency and remand without vacatur as the usual remedy, so projects could proceed while violations are corrected.
  > Claims would have to be filed within 150 days, courts would owe agencies substantial deference, and the usual remedy would be remand without vacatur or injunction.
  [Coalition letter hosted by National Trust, 2026-10-20](https://savingplaces.org/permitting-reform-coalition-letter-october-20). On the bill text at [p. 408, line 23 to p. 408, line 25](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=408).
- **Institute for Progress** (Think tanks; supports): Section 2301 writes much of the ACHP's existing Section 106 consultation process into statute while setting deadlines and narrowing which actions and effects are reviewed.
  > Section 2301 comprehensively reforms NHPA § 106, codifying much of ACHP's existing regulatory process to protect consultation rights while also streamlining review
  [Institute for Progress, 2026-10-12](https://ifp.org/how-the-permit). On the bill text at [p. 383, line 14 to p. 383, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=383).
- **Institute for Progress** (Think tanks; supports): The new 'adverse effect' definition requires an effect that is reasonably foreseeable and directly alters what makes a property historic, which raises the bar for showing harm.
  > This new definition raises the bar for demonstrating that an effect harms a historic property, requiring parties to identify how the effect directly alters a core element that made the property eligible for the Register.
  [Institute for Progress, 2026-10-12](https://ifp.org/how-the-permit). On the bill text at [p. 380, line 5 to p. 380, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380).

## Selected statutory quotes

> any visual, atmospheric, or audible element, unless the visual, atmospheric, or audible element would have a direct impact on a historic property that would significantly diminish the eligible characteristics of the historic property

[p. 380, line 13 to p. 380, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380)

Visual, atmospheric and audible effects mostly no longer count as adverse.

> in the sole discretion of the Federal official and as otherwise allowed by law, other considerations outweigh the consideration of historic preservation as to any or all adverse effects of the undertaking

[p. 393, line 4 to p. 393, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=393)

The agency may decide that other considerations outweigh preservation.

> the only remedy the court may order is to remand, without vacatur or issuance of an injunction, the applicable agency action to the Federal agency

[p. 406, line 25 to p. 407, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=406)

Remand is the only remedy, as in the NEPA title.

## Comparison notes

- [SPEED Act (H.R. 4776), engrossed in House](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-119hr4776eh/html/BILLS-119hr4776eh.htm)
- [Energy Permitting Reform Act of 2024 (S. 4753), reported in Senate](https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/BILLS-118s4753rs/html/BILLS-118s4753rs.htm)

### Current law

Section 106 is one sentence requiring agencies to 'take into account' effects on historic properties; the process lives in Advisory Council regulations (36 CFR part 800) with no statutory deadlines, a broad definition of adverse effect that includes visual and audible intrusions, and ordinary APA review.

### EPRA 2024 (reported S. 4753)

Not in EPRA 2024. This is the first major permitting bill to rewrite section 106.

### SPEED Act (House-passed H.R. 4776)

Not in the SPEED Act.

## Full statutory text

Extracted from the official PDF; line cites mark paragraph starts. Consult the PDF for exact layout.

[p. 372, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=372) (indent level 1)

(a) ELIGIBILITY FOR INCLUSION ON NATIONAL REGISTER.— Section 302706 of title 54, United States Code, is amended—

[p. 372, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=372) (indent level 2)

(1) in subsection (a), by striking the subsection designation and all that follows through “Property of traditional religious and” and inserting the following:

[p. 372, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=372) (indent level 1)

“(a) ELIGIBILITY.—

[p. 372, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=372) (indent level 2)

“(1) DEFINITION OF PROPERTY OF TRADITIONAL RELIGIOUS OR CULTURAL IMPORTANCE.—In this subsection, the term ‘property of traditional religious or cultural importance’ means an identifiable geographic location or feature at which an event of continuing religious or cultural significance to a living community occurred, including any prehistoric or historic district, site, building, structure, or object, and any existing artifacts or material remains at that district, site, building, structure, or object.

[p. 372, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=372) (indent level 2)

“(2) DETERMINATION.—Property of traditional religious or”; and

[p. 372, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=372) (indent level 2)

(2) in subsection (b), by striking “subsection (a)” and inserting “subsection (a)(2)”.

[p. 373, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=373) (indent level 1)

(b) PROGRAM EVALUATION.—

[p. 373, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=373) (indent level 2)

(1) STATE PROGRAMS.—Section 302302 of title 54, United States Code, is amended—

[p. 373, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=373) (indent level 3)

(A) in subsection (a)—

[p. 373, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=373) (indent level 4)

(i) in the subsection heading, by striking “Occcur” and inserting “Occur”; and

[p. 373, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=373) (indent level 4)

(ii) by striking “4” and inserting “2”;

[p. 373, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=373) (indent level 3)

(B) in subsection (b)—

[p. 373, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=373) (indent level 4)

(i) by striking “If” and inserting the following:

[p. 373, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=373) (indent level 2)

“(1) IN GENERAL.—If”;

[p. 373, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=373) (indent level 4)

(ii) in paragraph (1) (as so designated), by striking “within a reasonable period of time” and inserting “within 2 years of the date of the disapproval”; and

[p. 373, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=373) (indent level 4)

(iii) by adding at the end the following:

[p. 373, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=373) (indent level 2)

“(2) COMPLIANCE WITH TIMELINES.—A State program shall not be considered consistent with this division under paragraph (1) if the applicable State Historic Preservation Officer does not regularly comply with timelines for consultation, complete consultation expeditiously, or meet required metrics under this division.

[p. 374, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=374) (indent level 2)

“(3) DISAPPROVAL.—If the Secretary disapproves of a State program or a major aspect of a State program under paragraph (1), the Secretary shall require the suspension in whole or in part of—

[p. 374, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=374) (indent level 3)

“(A) any contracts and cooperative agreements among the Secretary and the applicable State and State Historic Preservation Officer; and

[p. 374, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=374) (indent level 3)

“(B) any grants distributed through the Historic Preservation Fund to the applicable State and State Historic Preservation Officer.

[p. 374, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=374) (indent level 2)

“(4) REVIEW.—If the Secretary determines under paragraph (1) that a State program remains not consistent, or has not made acceptable progress towards becoming consistent, with this division within the 2-year timeline described in that paragraph, the Secretary shall assume all or part of the functions of the State Historic Preservation Officer until the date on which the State Historic Preservation Officer demonstrates that the State program is consistent under paragraph (1).”; and

[p. 374, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=374) (indent level 3)

(C) in subsection (d)(2)—

[p. 374, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=374) (indent level 4)

(i) in the matter preceding subparagraph (A), by inserting “shall” after “Secretary”;

[p. 375, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=375) (indent level 4)

(ii) in subparagraph (A)—

[p. 375, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=375) (indent level 5)

(I) by striking “may conduct periodic fiscal audits” and inserting “not less frequently than every 4 years, conduct fiscal audits”; and

[p. 375, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=375) (indent level 5)

(II) by striking “as needed”; and

[p. 375, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=375) (indent level 4)

(iii) in subparagraph (B), by striking “shall”.

[p. 375, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=375) (indent level 2)

(2) TRIBAL PROGRAMS.—

[p. 375, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=375) (indent level 3)

(A) IN GENERAL.—Chapter 3027 of title 54, United States Code, is amended by adding at the end the following:

[p. 375, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=375) (indent level 0)

“§ 302707. Program evaluation

[p. 375, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=375) (indent level 1)

“(a) WHEN EVALUATION SHOULD OCCUR.—Periodically, but not less frequently than every 2 years after the date on which a tribal program has been approved to assume functions and responsibilities under section 302702, the Secretary, in consultation with the Council under applicable provisions of this division, and in cooperation with the Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, shall evaluate the tribal program to determine whether the tribal program is consistent with this division.

[p. 375, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=375) (indent level 1)

“(b) DISAPPROVAL OF PROGRAM.—

[p. 375, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=375) (indent level 2)

“(1) IN GENERAL.—If, at any time, the Secretary determines that a major aspect of a tribal program is not consistent with this division, the Secretary shall disapprove the tribal program and suspend in whole or in part any contracts or cooperative agreements with the Indian tribe and the Tribal Historic Preservation Officer under this division, until the program is consistent with this division, unless the Secretary determines that the tribal program will be made consistent with this division within 2 years of the date of the disapproval.

[p. 376, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=376) (indent level 2)

“(2) COMPLIANCE WITH TIMELINES.—A tribal program shall not be considered consistent with this division under paragraph (1) if the applicable Tribal Historic Preservation Officer does not regularly comply with timelines for consultation, complete consultation expeditiously, or meet required metrics under this division.

[p. 376, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=376) (indent level 2)

“(3) DISAPPROVAL.—If the Secretary disapproves of a tribal program or a major aspect of a tribal program under paragraph (1), the Secretary shall require the suspension in whole or in part of—

[p. 376, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=376) (indent level 3)

“(A) any contracts or cooperative agreements among the Secretary and the applicable Indian tribe and Tribal Historic Preservation Officer; and

[p. 377, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=377) (indent level 3)

“(B) any grants distributed through the Historic Preservation Fund to the applicable Indian tribe and Tribal Historic Preservation Officer.

[p. 377, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=377) (indent level 2)

“(4) REVIEW.—If the Secretary determines under paragraph (1) that a tribal program remains not consistent, or has not made acceptable progress towards becoming consistent, with this division within the 2-year timeline described in that paragraph, the Secretary shall assume all or part of the functions of the Tribal Historic Preservation Officer until the date on which the Tribal Historic Preservation Officer demonstrates that the State program is consistent under paragraph (1).

[p. 377, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=377) (indent level 1)

“(c) OVERSIGHT.—The Secretary, in consultation with Tribal Historic Preservation Officers, shall establish oversight methods to ensure tribal program consistency and quality without imposing undue review burdens on Tribal Historic Preservation Officers.

[p. 377, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=377) (indent level 1)

“(d) FISCAL AUDIT AND MANAGEMENT SYSTEM.—

[p. 377, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=377) (indent level 2)

“(1) SUBSTITUTION FOR COMPARABLE FEDERAL SYSTEMS.—At the discretion of the Secretary, a system of fiscal audit and management of the Indian tribe may be substituted for comparable Federal systems, subject to the conditions that the system of the Indian tribe—

[p. 378, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=378) (indent level 3)

“(A) establishes and maintains substantially similar accountability standards; and

[p. 378, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=378) (indent level 3)

“(B) provides for independent professional peer review.

[p. 378, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=378) (indent level 2)

“(2) FISCAL AUDITS AND REVIEW BY SECRETARY.— The Secretary shall—

[p. 378, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=378) (indent level 3)

“(A) not less frequently than every 4 years, conduct periodic fiscal audits of tribal programs approved under this chapter; and

[p. 378, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=378) (indent level 3)

“(B) ensure that the tribal programs meet applicable accountability standards.

[p. 378, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=378) (indent level 2)

“(3) ISDEAA AUDIT SUBSTITUTION.—An audit conducted to meet the requirements of section 5 of the Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act (25 U.S.C. 5305) of a tribal program shall meet the requirements of this subsection, subject to the requirement that the audit shall be submitted to each of the Director, the Director of the Bureau of Indian Affairs, and the Council.”.

[p. 378, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=378) (indent level 2)

(3) CONFORMING AMENDMENT.—Section 302702 of title 54, United States Code, is amended, in the matter preceding paragraph (1), by striking “302302 and 302303” and inserting “302303 and 302707”.

[p. 379, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=379) (indent level 2)

(4) CLERICAL AMENDMENT.—The table of sections for chapter 3027 of title 54, United States Code, is amended by adding at the end the following:

[p. 379, line None](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=379) (indent level 2)

“302707. Program evaluation.”.

[p. 379, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=379) (indent level 1)

(c) EFFECT OF UNDERTAKING ON HISTORIC PROPERTY.— Section 306108 of title 54, United States Code, is amended—

[p. 379, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=379) (indent level 2)

(1) in the second sentence, by striking “The head of the Federal agency” and inserting the following:

[p. 379, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=379) (indent level 2)

“(2) OPPORTUNITY TO COMMENT.—The head of any Federal agency described in paragraph (1)”;

[p. 379, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=379) (indent level 2)

(2) in the first sentence, by striking “The head of any Federal agency having direct or indirect” and inserting the following:

[p. 379, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=379) (indent level 1)

“(b) ADVERSE EFFECT OF THE UNDERTAKING.—

[p. 379, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=379) (indent level 2)

“(1) IN GENERAL.—The head of any Federal agency having direct”;

[p. 379, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=379) (indent level 2)

(3) by inserting before subsection (b) (as so designated) the following:

[p. 379, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=379) (indent level 1)

“(a) DEFINITIONS.—In this section:

[p. 379, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=379) (indent level 2)

“(1) ADVERSE EFFECT OF THE UNDERTAKING.—

[p. 380, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380) (indent level 3)

“(A) IN GENERAL.—The term ‘adverse effect of the undertaking’ means a consequence of an undertaking that—

[p. 380, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380) (indent level 4)

“(i) is reasonably foreseeable; and

[p. 380, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380) (indent level 4)

“(ii) directly alters the characteristics of a historic property in a manner that would diminish the integrity of the location, design, setting, materials, workmanship, or association of the historic property.

[p. 380, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380) (indent level 3)

“(B) EXCLUSIONS.—The term ‘adverse effect of the undertaking’ does not include—

[p. 380, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380) (indent level 4)

“(i) any visual, atmospheric, or audible element, unless the visual, atmospheric, or audible element would have a direct impact on a historic property that would significantly diminish the eligible characteristics of the historic property;

[p. 380, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380) (indent level 4)

“(ii) any temporary alteration to a historic property that is limited to the time it takes to complete an undertaking; or

[p. 380, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=380) (indent level 4)

“(iii) any effect on a portion of the historic property other than an adverse effect to the character-defining features, such as contributing elements, cultural-use locations, or access points, that significantly contribute to the qualification of the property for inclusion on the National Register.

[p. 381, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=381) (indent level 2)

“(2) AREA OF POTENTIAL EFFECTS.—

[p. 381, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=381) (indent level 3)

“(A) IN GENERAL.—The term ‘area of potential effects’ means the area within which an undertaking may cause an effect described in paragraph (1)(A).

[p. 381, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=381) (indent level 3)

“(B) EXCLUSION.—The term ‘area of potential effects’ does not include any geographic area affected solely by a portion of a project, activity, or program that is not subject to Federal control or responsibility.

[p. 381, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=381) (indent level 2)

“(3) MADE PUBLIC.—The term ‘made public’, with respect to a final agency action, means that the final agency action is published in a single location on the primary website of the applicable Federal agency with—

[p. 381, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=381) (indent level 3)

“(A) hyperlinks to the final agency action prominently displayed on the website; and

[p. 381, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=381) (indent level 3)

“(B) the date of initial publication of the final agency action displayed and maintained on the website.

[p. 381, line 25](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=381) (indent level 2)

“(4) REASONABLY FORESEEABLE.—

[p. 382, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=382) (indent level 3)

“(A) IN GENERAL.—The term ‘reasonably foreseeable’, with respect to an adverse effect of the undertaking, means an effect of the undertaking that shares a reasonably close causal relationship to, and is proximately caused by, the undertaking being considered.

[p. 382, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=382) (indent level 3)

“(B) EXCLUSIONS.—The term ‘reasonably foreseeable’, with respect to an adverse effect of the undertaking, does not include—

[p. 382, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=382) (indent level 4)

“(i) any adverse effect of the undertaking that is speculative or attenuated from the undertaking; or

[p. 382, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=382) (indent level 4)

“(ii) any adverse effect of the undertaking relating to an unrelated prior, separate existing, or potential future undertaking.

[p. 382, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=382) (indent level 2)

“(5) STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER.— The term ‘State Historic Preservation Officer’ means—

[p. 382, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=382) (indent level 3)

“(A) the official designated and appointed pursuant to section 302301(1) to administer the State Historic Preservation Program; or

[p. 382, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=382) (indent level 3)

“(B) a representative designated to act for the official described in subparagraph (A).

[p. 383, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=383) (indent level 2)

“(6) TRIBAL HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER.— The term ‘Tribal Historic Preservation Officer’ means the Tribal official designated pursuant to section 302702(2) who has assumed the duties of the State Historic Preservation Officer for purposes of compliance with subsection (b) within the boundaries of the applicable tribal land.

[p. 383, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=383) (indent level 2)

“(7) UNDERTAKING.—

[p. 383, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=383) (indent level 3)

“(A) IN GENERAL.—The term ‘undertaking’ means a project, activity, or program that—

[p. 383, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=383) (indent level 4)

“(i) requires a Federal permit, license, or approval; and

[p. 383, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=383) (indent level 4)

“(ii) is subject to substantial Federal control and responsibility.

[p. 383, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=383) (indent level 3)

“(B) EXCLUSION.—The term ‘undertaking’ does not include—

[p. 383, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=383) (indent level 4)

“(i) any portion of a project, activity, or program over which a Federal agency does not exercise substantial control or responsibility over the outcome;

[p. 383, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=383) (indent level 4)

“(ii) a project, activity, or program for which the only Federal involvement is a loan, loan guarantee, grant (including a capitalization grant), cost-share award, or other form of financial assistance that is not for the primary purpose of historic preservation;

[p. 384, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=384) (indent level 4)

“(iii) a project, activity, or program that consists of minor restoration, rehabilitation, repair, maintenance, stabilization, hazardous material remediation, structure hardening, provision of handicapped access, or other similar minor projects that do not diminish the integrity of a historic property;

[p. 384, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=384) (indent level 4)

“(iv) a project, activity, or program that is a survey or work completed to conduct consultations;

[p. 384, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=384) (indent level 4)

“(v) a project, activity, or program that—

[p. 384, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=384) (indent level 5)

“(I) is any alteration to a historic property that is necessary for public safety; and

[p. 384, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=384) (indent level 5)

“(II) does not diminish the integrity of the historic property;

[p. 384, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=384) (indent level 4)

“(vi) an activity or decision that is non-discretionary and made in accordance with the statutory authority of the Federal agency;

[p. 385, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=385) (indent level 4)

“(vii) any—

[p. 385, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=385) (indent level 5)

“(I) renewal of a special use permit on the expiration of the special use permit if no substantive changes are made from the original special use permit; or

[p. 385, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=385) (indent level 5)

“(II) transfer of ownership of a special use permit;

[p. 385, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=385) (indent level 4)

“(viii) the implementation of, or any act or omission under, a memorandum of agreement, programmatic agreement, or other instrument executed in connection with compliance with this section, after the date on which a determination has been made under subsection (c); or

[p. 385, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=385) (indent level 4)

“(ix) the continuation, operation, maintenance, or post-approval implementation of a project, activity, or program after the determination has been made under subsection (c), except that a subsequent discrete decision of a Federal agency to amend or materially modify a determination made under subsection (c) is itself an undertaking, to the extent provided in this section.”; and

[p. 386, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=386) (indent level 2)

(4) by adding at the end the following:

[p. 386, line 2](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=386) (indent level 1)

“(c) CONSULTATION.—

[p. 386, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=386) (indent level 2)

“(1) IN GENERAL.—The responsibilities of a Federal agency under this section shall be limited to historic properties within the area of potential effects identified by the Federal agency.

[p. 386, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=386) (indent level 2)

“(2) INITIATION AND REPORT.—

[p. 386, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=386) (indent level 3)

“(A) IN GENERAL.—Not later than 30 days after the date of receipt of a request for review of a proposed project, activity, or program under this section, the applicable Federal official shall determine whether the proposed project, activity, or program is an undertaking subject to the requirements of this section.

[p. 386, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=386) (indent level 3)

“(B) ESTABLISHMENT OF AREA OF POTENTIAL EFFECTS AND IDENTIFICATION AND DETERMINATION OF HISTORIC PROPERTIES.—

[p. 386, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=386) (indent level 4)

“(i) IN GENERAL.—If the applicable Federal official determines under subparagraph (A) that the proposed project, activity, or program is an undertaking, the applicable Federal official shall establish the area of potential effects for the undertaking.

[p. 387, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=387) (indent level 4)

“(ii) IDENTIFICATION OF HISTORIC PROPERTIES.—The applicable Federal official shall identify and determine any historic properties within the area of potential effects.

[p. 387, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=387) (indent level 4)

“(iii) CONSULTATION.—For purposes of establishing the area of potential effects for the undertaking and identifying and determining any historic properties under clauses (i) and (ii), respectively, the applicable Federal official may consult with any applicable State Historic Preservation Officers, Tribal Historic Preservation Officers, Indian tribes, or Native Hawaiian organizations, local governments, and project, activity, or program applicants.

[p. 387, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=387) (indent level 4)

“(iv) INCORPORATION OF INFORMATION.— Upon a determination made under subparagraph (A), before establishing the area of potential effects under clause (i) or identifying and determining historic properties under clause (ii), the applicable Federal official shall seek, discuss, as appropriate, and incorporate, as applicable, information from each applicable State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, or Native Hawaiian organization, local government, and project, activity, or program applicant, if the information is communicated to the applicable Federal official not later than 30 days after the date on which the Federal official submits a request for such information.

[p. 388, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=388) (indent level 3)

“(C) PROGRAM ALTERNATIVE.—If the applicable Federal official determines under subparagraph (A) that the proposed project, activity, or program is an undertaking that is governed by a program alternative authorized under section 800.14 of title 36, Code of Federal Regulations (or successor regulations), including an alternate procedure, programmatic agreement, exempted category, standard treatment, or program comment, the applicable Federal official may follow the applicable program alternative with respect to the undertaking.

[p. 388, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=388) (indent level 3)

“(D) DETERMINATION OF EFFECTS.—

[p. 388, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=388) (indent level 4)

“(i) IN GENERAL.—If the applicable Federal official determines that a proposed project, activity, or program is an undertaking under subparagraph (A), the applicable Federal official shall determine whether there are any adverse effects of the undertaking within the area of potential effects.

[p. 389, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=389) (indent level 4)

“(ii) NO ADVERSE EFFECTS.—The applicable Federal official shall have no further obligations under this section if the applicable Federal official determines under clause (i) that—

[p. 389, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=389) (indent level 5)

“(I) the proposed project, activity, or program is an undertaking for which there are no adverse effects of the undertaking;

[p. 389, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=389) (indent level 5)

“(II) the undertaking does not have the potential to cause adverse effects of the undertaking; or

[p. 389, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=389) (indent level 5)

“(III) historic properties are not present.

[p. 389, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=389) (indent level 4)

“(iii) REPORT.—If the applicable Federal official determines under subparagraph (A) that the proposed project, activity, or program is an undertaking, for which there will be adverse effects of the undertaking, as determined under clause (i), not later than 60 days after the date of the determination under subparagraph (A), the applicable Federal official shall complete and submit for review to the applicable State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, local government, and project, activity, or program applicant under this division a report that—

[p. 390, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=390) (indent level 5)

“(I) identifies whether historic properties are present within the area of potential effects; and

[p. 390, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=390) (indent level 5)

“(II) if historic properties are present within the area of potential effects—

[p. 390, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=390) (indent level 6)

“(aa) identifies the area of potential effects for the undertaking;

[p. 390, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=390) (indent level 6)

“(bb) identifies the historic properties within the area of potential effects;

[p. 390, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=390) (indent level 6)

“(cc) considers only the portion of the property within the area of potential effects;

[p. 391, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=391) (indent level 6)

“(dd) documents the adverse effects of the undertaking;

[p. 391, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=391) (indent level 6)

“(ee) identifies prudent and feasible measures within the area of potential effects to avoid, minimize, or mitigate the adverse effects of the undertaking;

[p. 391, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=391) (indent level 6)

“(ff) identifies and explains any case in which, as applicable, the applicable Federal official has decided not to require such prudent and feasible measures because, in the sole discretion of the applicable Federal official and as otherwise allowed by law, other considerations outweigh the consideration of historic preservation as to any or all adverse effects of the undertaking; and

[p. 391, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=391) (indent level 6)

“(gg) does not identify measures described in item (ee) that are not prudent or would occur outside the area of potential effects, unless the project, activity, or program applicant has submitted a written request for alternative mitigation measures.

[p. 392, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=392) (indent level 2)

“(3) DETERMINATION.—

[p. 392, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=392) (indent level 3)

“(A) IN GENERAL.—Not later than 90 days after the date of submission of a report under paragraph (2)(D)(iii), unless a shorter timeline is agreed to by the State Historic Preservation Officer or Tribal Historic Preservation Officer and each applicable Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, and local government, the applicable Federal official, in consultation with the applicable State Historic Preservation Officer and Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, and local government under this division, shall—

[p. 392, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=392) (indent level 4)

“(i) determine, based on the report, that—

[p. 392, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=392) (indent level 5)

“(I)(aa) the adverse effects of the undertaking would not so diminish the integrity of the historic property to the extent that the historic property would be made ineligible for listing on the National Register; and

[p. 393, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=393) (indent level 6)

“(bb) the obligations of the Federal official under this section shall be satisfied; or

[p. 393, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=393) (indent level 5)

“(II)(aa) in the sole discretion of the Federal official and as otherwise allowed by law, other considerations outweigh the consideration of historic preservation as to any or all adverse effects of the undertaking; and

[p. 393, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=393) (indent level 6)

“(bb) the obligations of the Federal official under this section shall be satisfied; or

[p. 393, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=393) (indent level 4)

“(ii) reach an agreement with the applicable State Historic Preservation Officer and Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, local government, and project, activity, or program applicant that describes how the adverse effects of the undertaking would be avoided, minimized, or mitigated.

[p. 393, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=393) (indent level 3)

“(B) NO AGREEMENT.—

[p. 393, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=393) (indent level 4)

“(i) CONSULTATION PERIOD.—If an agreement is not reached under clause (ii) of subparagraph (A) within the 90-day period described in that subparagraph, during the 60-day period beginning immediately after the end of that 90-day period, there shall be a period of consultation among the applicable Federal official, State Historic Preservation Officer and Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, and local government.

[p. 394, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=394) (indent level 4)

“(ii) FORMAL ADVISORY COMMENTS.—

[p. 394, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=394) (indent level 5)

“(I) REQUEST.—If an agreement is not reached under clause (i) within the 60-day period described in that clause, the head of the Federal agency shall request formal advisory comments from the Council with respect to the applicable undertaking.

[p. 394, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=394) (indent level 5)

“(II) RESPONSE.—Not later than 45 days after the date on which the Council receives a request under subclause (I), the Council shall submit to the head of the Federal agency the formal advisory comments requested.

[p. 394, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=394) (indent level 5)

“(III) FINAL DETERMINATION.— Not later than 30 days after the date on which the head of the Federal agency receives the formal advisory comments from the Council under subclause (II), the head of the Federal agency (or an agency official delegated by the head of the Federal agency) shall make a final determination on the undertaking that demonstrates how the formal advisory comments were considered.

[p. 395, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=395) (indent level 5)

“(IV) SATISFACTION OF OBLIGATIONS.— Effective on the date on which a final determination is made under subclause (III), the obligations of the applicable Federal agency under this section shall be satisfied.

[p. 395, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=395) (indent level 3)

“(C) MULTIPLE DETERMINATIONS.—If an undertaking involves multiple corridors or large land areas, the applicable Federal official may issue multiple determinations under subparagraph (A) in a phased process.

[p. 395, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=395) (indent level 2)

“(4) LEAD FEDERAL AGENCY.—

[p. 395, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=395) (indent level 3)

“(A) IN GENERAL.—If more than 1 Federal agency has jurisdiction over a project, activity, or program that is determined to be an undertaking, the 1 or more applicable Federal agencies shall designate a lead Federal agency to comply with the requirements of this subsection.

[p. 396, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=396) (indent level 3)

“(B) PRESUMPTION.—If a lead Federal agency has been designated for purposes of complying with the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.), the lead Federal agency designated for purposes of complying with that Act shall serve as the lead Federal agency for purposes of this subsection unless the applicable Federal agencies jointly determine that another Federal agency is better suited to carry out the responsibilities of the lead Federal agency under this subsection.

[p. 396, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=396) (indent level 3)

“(C) WRITTEN REQUEST; DESIGNATION BY SECRETARY.—If the 1 or more applicable Federal agencies do not designate a lead Federal agency under subparagraph (A) by the date that is 15 days after the date on which the applicable Federal agencies receive notice of a proposed undertaking—

[p. 396, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=396) (indent level 4)

“(i) in the case of an undertaking initiated by an applicant, the applicant may submit to the Secretary a written request for the Secretary to designate a lead Federal agency; or

[p. 397, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=397) (indent level 4)

“(ii) in the case of an undertaking initiated by the Federal Government, the Secretary shall designate a lead Federal agency.

[p. 397, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=397) (indent level 3)

“(D) FAILURE TO SIGN PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENT.—The failure of the head of a Federal agency that is not the lead Federal agency to be a signatory to a programmatic agreement under this subsection shall not affect the conduct of the project, activity, or program subject to the programmatic agreement.

[p. 397, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=397) (indent level 2)

“(5) TIMELINES FOR CONSULTATION.—

[p. 397, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=397) (indent level 3)

“(A) INITIATION.—If a project, activity, or program requires the preparation of an environmental document under the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.), any consultation with respect to the project, activity, or program required for purposes of this subsection shall initiate not later than the date of initiation of the environmental review.

[p. 397, line 25](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=397) (indent level 3)

“(B) COMPLETION.—

[p. 398, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=398) (indent level 4)

“(i) IN GENERAL.—The consultation process initiated under subparagraph (A) shall be completed not later than the date on which the applicable environmental document under section 107(g) of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4336a(g)) is completed with respect to the undertaking, unless the Secretary approves an extension of the deadline due to extraordinary circumstances beyond the control, and not due to any actions, of the consulting parties.

[p. 398, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=398) (indent level 4)

“(ii) FAILURE TO COMPLETE BY DEADLINE.—If the consultation process initiated under subparagraph (A) is not complete by the later of the deadline established under clause (i) or the date extended under that clause, the consultation requirement for purposes of this subsection, each State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, and employee within Senior Executive Service (as defined in section 2101a of title 5) that has supervisory authority over personnel in a relevant agency that has a substantive role or responsibility in the consultation, shall spend not less than 50 percent of the workweek, as determined pursuant to title 5 or other applicable law, to remedy the failure.

[p. 399, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=399) (indent level 4)

“(iii) CAUSES OF ACTION.—

[p. 399, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=399) (indent level 5)

“(I) RIGHT TO PETITION.—A project, activity, or program applicant may obtain judicial review of the compliance by a Federal agency with the deadline established under clause (i) by filing a complaint with a court of competent jurisdiction in which a substantial part of the applicable proposed project, activity, or program is situated.

[p. 399, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=399) (indent level 5)

“(II) REMEDY.—If a court of competent jurisdiction under this clause finds that a Federal agency has failed to act in accordance with this subsection, the court shall provide injunctive relief, as appropriate, to give effect to this subsection and retain jurisdiction to ensure compliance with any such relief.

[p. 400, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=400) (indent level 5)

“(III) EXPEDITED PROCEDURES; TIME TO DECIDE.—The reviewing court under this clause shall—

[p. 400, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=400) (indent level 6)

“(aa) establish an expedited schedule for briefing and disposition; and

[p. 400, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=400) (indent level 6)

“(bb) issue a decision as expeditiously as practicable.

[p. 400, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=400) (indent level 3)

“(C) PARTICIPATION OF STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER OR TRIBAL HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICER.—

[p. 400, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=400) (indent level 4)

“(i) IN GENERAL.—If the State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, or local government fails to respond within 30 days of receipt of a request for review of any report or finding by the applicable Federal official, the applicable Federal official shall proceed to the determination under paragraph (3)(A).

[p. 400, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=400) (indent level 4)

“(ii) SUBSEQUENT INVOLVEMENT.—If a State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, or local government that fails to respond by the deadline described in clause (i) re-enters the consultation process required for purposes of this subsection, the applicable Federal official—

[p. 401, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=401) (indent level 5)

“(I) shall not be required to reconsider any previous report or finding; and

[p. 401, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=401) (indent level 5)

“(II) may consult with the Council in lieu of the State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, or local government.

[p. 401, line 15](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=401) (indent level 4)

“(iii) NO SUBSTANTIVE OBJECTIONS.— If the State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, local government, or Council, as applicable, has entered the consultation process required for purposes of this subsection, but does not provide any substantive objections by the date that is 30 days after the date of receipt of a report or finding, the applicable Federal official shall proceed to the determination under paragraph (3)(A).

[p. 402, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=402) (indent level 4)

“(iv) SUBSTANTIVE OBJECTIONS.—If the State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, local government, or Council, as applicable, has entered the consultation process required for purposes of this subsection and provides substantive objections with respect to any of the matters included in the applicable report under items (aa) through (ff) of paragraph (2)(D)(iii)(II) by the date that is 30 days after the date of receipt of the report, not later than 30 days after the date of receipt of the objections, the applicable Federal official—

[p. 402, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=402) (indent level 5)

“(I) shall provide a response explaining how the Federal agency has considered the substantive objections in the report; and

[p. 402, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=402) (indent level 5)

“(II) may provide a supplemental report.

[p. 402, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=402) (indent level 4)

“(v) FULFILLMENT OF CONSULTING OBLIGATIONS.—On the provision of a response under clause (iv)(I), the obligation of the applicable Federal official to consult for purposes of this subsection shall be considered to be fulfilled with respect to the report.

[p. 403, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=403) (indent level 4)

“(vi) AGREEMENT.—If a State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, or local government fails to respond to an agreement under this subparagraph, the applicable Federal official may enter into the agreement with the Council in lieu of the State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, or local government.

[p. 403, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=403) (indent level 2)

“(6) COORDINATION WITH NEPA.—For any undertaking subject to the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.), the applicable Federal official may use the preparation of a draft environmental document that the Federal agency prepares under that Act to comply with the report required under paragraph (2)(D)(iii) if the applicable Federal official—

[p. 404, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=404) (indent level 3)

“(A) has notified each applicable State Historic Preservation Officer or Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, local government, and the Council of the intent to use the environmental document for that purpose; and

[p. 404, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=404) (indent level 3)

“(B) determines that the draft environmental document includes each of the components required to be in the report under paragraph (2)(D)(iii).

[p. 404, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=404) (indent level 2)

“(7) PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENTS.—

[p. 404, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=404) (indent level 3)

“(A) BY FEDERAL AGENCY.—The head of any Federal agency shall, in consultation with the Council, develop and implement programmatic agreements to govern categories of undertakings that are—

[p. 404, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=404) (indent level 4)

“(i) determined to normally have no adverse effects of the undertaking;

[p. 404, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=404) (indent level 4)

“(ii) similar and repetitive in nature; or

[p. 404, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=404) (indent level 4)

“(iii) routine management activities undertaken at Federal installations, facilities, or other land management units.

[p. 404, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=404) (indent level 3)

“(B) BY STATE AND TRIBAL HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICERS.—

[p. 405, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=405) (indent level 4)

“(i) IN GENERAL.—A State Historic Preservation Officer or a Tribal Historic Preservation Officer may develop and implement programmatic agreements within their applicable jurisdiction to govern categories of undertakings that are—

[p. 405, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=405) (indent level 5)

“(I) determined to normally have no adverse effects of the undertaking; or

[p. 405, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=405) (indent level 5)

“(II) similar and repetitive in nature.

[p. 405, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=405) (indent level 4)

“(ii) MULTIPLE PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENTS.—If a Federal agency and a State Historic Preservation Officer or Tribal Historic Preservation Officer each have programmatic agreements governing the same category of undertakings, the programmatic agreement of the State Historic Preservation Officer or Tribal Historic Preservation Officer shall be applied to the applicable category of undertakings.

[p. 405, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=405) (indent level 2)

“(8) QUALIFIED HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICERS.— The Secretary shall collaborate with Tribal Historic Preservation Officers, tribal leaders, and relevant nonprofit organizations to develop standard requirements for Tribal Historic Preservation Officers that reflects the traditional knowledge, expertise, and access to traditional cultural leaders required for a successful tribal historic preservation program.

[p. 406, line 6](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=406) (indent level 2)

“(9) JUDICIAL REVIEW.—

[p. 406, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=406) (indent level 3)

“(A) DEFINITION OF AGENCY ACTION.—In this paragraph, the term ‘agency action’ has the meaning given the term in section 551 of title 5.

[p. 406, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=406) (indent level 3)

“(B) ROLE OF THE COURT.—In reviewing a claim of whether an undertaking complies with the requirements of this division, a court—

[p. 406, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=406) (indent level 4)

“(i) shall afford substantial deference to the agency; and

[p. 406, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=406) (indent level 4)

“(ii) may not substitute the judgment of the court for the judgment of the agency.

[p. 406, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=406) (indent level 3)

“(C) REMEDY.—

[p. 406, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=406) (indent level 4)

“(i) IN GENERAL.—Except as provided in clause (ii) and notwithstanding any other provision of law, if a court determines that an agency action does not comply with the requirements of this division, the only remedy the court may order is to remand, without vacatur or issuance of an injunction, the applicable agency action to the Federal agency with—

[p. 407, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=407) (indent level 5)

“(I) specific instructions to correct errors or deficiencies found by the court; and

[p. 407, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=407) (indent level 5)

“(II) a reasonable schedule and deadline for the agency to act on remand, which shall not exceed 180 days after the date on which the order of the court was entered.

[p. 407, line 12](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=407) (indent level 4)

“(ii) PRELIMINARY INJUNCTIONS.—

[p. 407, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=407) (indent level 5)

“(I) IN GENERAL.—Notwithstanding clause (i) and subject to subclause (II), a court may issue a preliminary injunction for the applicable agency action when—

[p. 407, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=407) (indent level 6)

“(aa) there is a substantial likelihood the agency action violates a Federal law (other than this division or the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4321 et seq.));

[p. 407, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=407) (indent level 6)

“(bb) necessary to prevent irreparable harm to the plaintiff;

[p. 408, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=408) (indent level 6)

“(cc) the balance of equities favors the plaintiff; and

[p. 408, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=408) (indent level 6)

“(dd) a preliminary injunction is in the public interest.

[p. 408, line 5](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=408) (indent level 5)

“(II) REQUIREMENTS.—The effective period of a preliminary injunction issued by a court under subclause (I) shall be not longer than the time the court finds is reasonably necessary—

[p. 408, line 11](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=408) (indent level 6)

“(aa) for the correction of the violation described in subclause (I)(aa); and

[p. 408, line 14](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=408) (indent level 6)

“(bb) to prevent the irreparable harm described in subclause (I)(bb).

[p. 408, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=408) (indent level 3)

“(D) LIMITATIONS ON CLAIMS.—

[p. 408, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=408) (indent level 4)

“(i) IN GENERAL.—Notwithstanding chapter 7 of title 5, a claim described in subparagraph (B) shall be barred unless—

[p. 408, line 21](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=408) (indent level 5)

“(I) except in a case in which a shorter deadline is specified under Federal law, the claim is filed not later than 150 days after the later of—

[p. 409, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=409) (indent level 6)

“(aa) the date on which the final agency action is made public; and

[p. 409, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=409) (indent level 6)

“(bb) the applicable State Historic Preservation Officer or Tribal Historic Preservation Officer is notified of the final agency action;

[p. 409, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=409) (indent level 5)

“(II) the claim is filed by a party that has suffered or imminently will suffer direct harm from the agency action; and

[p. 409, line 13](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=409) (indent level 5)

“(III) in the case of an agency action for which there was a public comment period with respect to the agency action, the claim—

[p. 409, line 17](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=409) (indent level 6)

“(aa) is filed by a party that submitted a substantive and unique comment—

[p. 409, line 20](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=409) (indent level 7)

“(AA) during the public comment period by the noticed comment deadline; and

[p. 409, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=409) (indent level 7)

“(BB) that was sufficiently detailed to put the applicable Federal agency on notice of the issue for which the party seeks review; and

[p. 410, line 3](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=410) (indent level 6)

“(bb) concerns the same subject matter raised in the comment submitted during the public comment period.

[p. 410, line 7](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=410) (indent level 4)

“(ii) APPLICATION.—The requirements of subclauses (II) and (III) of clause (i) shall not apply with respect to a claim in which a State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, or local government has provided detailed notice in writing during the consultation process that—

[p. 410, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=410) (indent level 5)

“(I) puts the applicable Federal agency on notice of the agency action; and

[p. 410, line 19](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=410) (indent level 5)

“(II) sufficiently identifies any issues relating to that agency action for which the party seeks review under this paragraph.

[p. 410, line 23](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=410) (indent level 4)

“(iii) SUPPLEMENTAL FINDINGS DOCUMENTS.—

[p. 411, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=411) (indent level 5)

“(I) IN GENERAL.—If an agency issues a supplemental findings document in response to a court order remanding an agency action, the deadline described in clause (i)(I) shall be the date on which the agency makes public the supplemental findings document.

[p. 411, line 9](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=411) (indent level 5)

“(II) LIMITATION.—A claim for review of an agency action described in subparagraph (B) shall be limited to information contained in the final supplemental findings document that was not contained in a previous findings document.

[p. 411, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=411) (indent level 3)

“(E) PROCEDURAL MATTERS FOR CLAIMS.—

[p. 411, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=411) (indent level 4)

“(i) ORIGINAL JURISDICTION.—Except with respect to a claim brought under paragraph (5)(B)(iii), the courts of appeals of the United States shall have original and exclusive jurisdiction over a claim for review of an agency action described in subparagraph (B).

[p. 412, line 1](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=412) (indent level 4)

“(ii) SUPPLEMENTAL JURISDICTION.— The courts of appeals of the United States shall have supplemental jurisdiction over other claims related to the validity of the final agency action at issue in the claim within the original jurisdiction of the court of appeals.

[p. 412, line 8](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=412) (indent level 4)

“(iii) RANDOM ASSIGNMENT OF CASES.—To the maximum extent practicable, a court of appeals of the United States shall randomly assign judges appointed, designated, or assigned to sit as judges of the court to hear claims in a manner to avoid the appearance of favoritism or bias.

[p. 412, line 16](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=412) (indent level 4)

“(iv) DEADLINE FOR RESOLUTION.— A court of appeals of the United States shall render a final judgment with respect to a claim for review of an agency action described in subparagraph (B) as expeditiously as possible.

[p. 412, line 22](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=412) (indent level 2)

“(10) CHALLENGES TO PROGRAMMATIC AGREEMENTS.—

[p. 412, line 24](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=412) (indent level 3)

“(A) IN GENERAL.—A party that is not a signatory to a programmatic agreement entered into for purposes of this subsection may not bring a civil action to challenge the implementation of the programmatic agreement.

[p. 413, line 4](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=413) (indent level 3)

“(B) JUDICIAL REVIEW.—No court shall have jurisdiction to hear or consider any action pertaining to the implementation of a programmatic agreement entered into for purposes of this subsection that is brought by a party described in subparagraph (A).

[p. 413, line 10](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=413) (indent level 1)

“(d) NO POST-DEADLINE REQUIREMENT FOR REINITIATION.— The identification of a property for, nomination of a property to, or listing of a property on the National Register after the date on which the head of the Federal agency initiates a review under this section shall not require the head of the Federal agency to delay, reopen, supplement, or otherwise modify the review or consultation process under this section.”.

[p. 413, line 18](https://pranava0x0.github.io/permittingreform/bill.pdf#page=413) (indent level 1)

(d) CONFORMING AMENDMENT.—Section 306114 of title 54, United States Code, is amended by striking the second sentence.

