EL26-67-000 · 2026-07-09 · Individual No Affiliation

Second Supplemental Technical Comment of L.M. Marlowe on the Frequency-Response Absorption Standard and Coupling-Discrimination Protocol

An individual intervenor filing as L.M. Marlowe submits a second supplemental technical comment urging FERC to judge show cause responses against physical stability, observability and cost causation, and describing a frequency-response absorption standard evaluated at minimum system inertia.

Asks FERC to: Hold every framework, tariff and methodology before the Commission to the full requirements of the show cause orders, including physical stability and observability, and consider the described absorption standard.

Answers the order. Comment filed in the show cause dockets proposing a stability test for large-load interconnection studies, bearing on the operational requirements the June orders ask RTOs to address.

E-7 PJM: Show cause or propose tariff changes in 60 days (p. 7) E-7 PJM: Application / study process (P 6(a), p. 7)

Key points

  1. Marlowe says a response fixing only commercial access without addressing physical stability and observability does not meet the show cause orders.
    A submission that resolves the commercial or market-access dimension of large-load integration without demonstrably addressing the physical stability and observability questions that gave rise to these proceedings PDF p. 1
  2. She argues a correlated block of dispersed computational loads could become the largest credible contingency, replacing the largest generator.
    Where the coordinated-drop magnitude of the block exceeds the loss-of-largest- unit value, the largest credible contingency is no longer a generator PDF p. 2
  3. She proposes testing any behaviorally coupled load block at a credible minimum-inertia condition.
    the absorption of any behaviorally-coupled load block must be evaluated at a credible minimum-inertia condition PDF p. 2
  4. She says detecting unaccounted-for load and reassigning its cost happen in one settlement calculation.
    the quantity that identifies unaccounted-for load and the quantity that reassigns its cost are the same quantity. PDF p. 3

Read topic-matched comments in EL26-67

Topics in the text: Cost allocation

Source sections

Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.

Opening text

opening text · Topic match: Cost allocation

It provides additional technical detail responsive to the reliability and observability questions raised in these proceedings, and asks that all submissions be evaluated against the full requirements of the Commission’s Show Cause Orders.
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

I. The Standard of Evaluation Respectfully Urged

printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation

Commenter asks that each submission — including Commenter’s own — be measured against that complete standard, so that the resolution the Commission adopts rests on frameworks that fulfill the whole of what reliability and consumer protection require, not a part.
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

II. The Binding Contingency Has Shifted

printed heading

The Binding Contingency Has Shifted Reserve adequacy and frequency-response planning have historically been sized against an enumerated largest credible contingency — typically the loss of the single largest generating unit — treated as physical and independent.
Read this passage

III. The Frequency-Response Absorption Standard (Minimum-Inertia Condition)

printed heading

Stability requires two conditions simultaneously: the initial RoCoF must remain below the protection threshold at which relays trip generation, and the frequency excursion before PFR arrests it must remain within the trip band.
Read this passage

IV. The Coupling-Discrimination Protocol

printed heading

The Coupling-Discrimination Protocol A rigorous standard must distinguish the true common-mode risk from legitimate distributed flexibility, because both produce correlated load movement.
Read this passage

V. Remediation Is Intrinsic to the Measurement, Not Appended to It

printed heading

Remediation Is Intrinsic to the Measurement, Not Appended to It This section states an engineering property of the architecture, not a policy position.
Read this passage

VI. Relationship to the Record and Reservation

printed heading

Relationship to the Record and Reservation This Comment supplements and does not supersede Commenter’s prior filings.
Read this passage

VII. Conclusion

printed heading

Conclusion Commenter respectfully requests that the Commission consider these technical considerations, and that it hold each framework, methodology, and tariff before it — including Commenter’s own — to the full rigor of what the Show Cause Orders require.
Read this passage