EL26-67-001 · 2026-07-17 · Maryland Office of People's CounselOHIO CONSUMERS' COUNSELDELAWARE DIVISION OF THE PUBLIC ADVOCATE ,OFFICE OF THE ILLINOIS ATTORNEY GENERAL ,

The Maryland Office of People's Counsel, et al. submit Request for Rehearing of the 06/18/2026 Order

The Maryland Office of People's Counsel, Ohio Consumers' Counsel, Delaware Division of the Public Advocate and Illinois Attorney General request rehearing and clarification of the E-7 order's cost shifting findings, arguing only FERC can fix tariff-imposed cost shifts between transmission customers.

Asks FERC to: Grant rehearing on FERC's duty to remedy actual cost shifts, and clarify that cost recovery agreements must require payment of the full Network Upgrade cost and that revenue be credited immediately to other transmission customers.

Answers the order. Rehearing and clarification request on the E-7 cost-shifting findings; it presses the standard for the pro forma cost recovery agreement and the crediting of its revenue.

E-7 PJM: Cost-recovery agreement (P 77, p. 28) E-7 PJM: Cost transparency (P 71, p. 51)

Key points

  1. The Joint Consumer Advocates say the cost shifts come from the PJM Tariff, which only FERC can reform, not from retail rates.
    the cost shifts identified by the Order do not originate at the retail level, and the responsibility to cure them cannot lie with state regulators. PDF p. 2
  2. They challenge FERC's reliance on state sub-allocation, since a state cannot move costs between transmission customers under the tariff.
    The PJM Tariff fixes the charges each transmission customer pays, and a state cannot move costs from one transmission customer to another. PDF p. 3
  3. They ask FERC to set the standard that a cost recovery agreement is just and reasonable only if the Eligible Customer pays the full Network Upgrade cost.
    An agreement is just and reasonable only if it requires the Eligible Customer to pay the full cost of the Network Upgrades needed to accommodate the large load. PDF p. 4
  4. Their hypothetical shows a NITS-based agreement paying $21 million in year one against a $36 million revenue requirement increase, a $15 million shortfall.
    That falls $15 million short of the $36 million increase in the annual zonal revenue requirement caused by the Network Upgrades the transmission owner identified PDF p. 26
  5. They ask that transmission owners immediately credit cost recovery agreement revenue to other customers in the zone.
    transmission owners must immediately credit all revenue received under cost-recovery agreements to transmission customers in the relevant zone. PDF p. 28

Read topic-matched comments in EL26-67

Topics in the text: Cost allocation · Filing procedure · Retail and wholesale authority

Source sections

Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.

Opening text

opening text · Topic match: Cost allocation

We respectfully request rehearing on the Commission’s finding that it “must act to address the risk of cost shifting among transmission customers” but not actual cost shifts among transmission customers that are guaranteed by the PJM Tariff.3 We agree with the Commission that, if implemented…
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

I. Statement of Issues and Specifications of Error

printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation

To the extent the Order’s findings regarding state authority over retail cost allocation constitute final determinations, the Commission erred by finding that transparency will enable state regulators to sub-allocate Network Upgrade costs to retail customers “as they see fit,” without considering…
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

II. Illustration: The PJM transmission tariff spreads Network Upgrade

printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation

Because our requests for rehearing are about the PJM Tariff, we illustrate how the tariff operates with a hypothetical about Network Upgrade costs.
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

III. Requests for Rehearing

printed heading · Topic match: Filing procedure

Requests for Rehearing
Read this passage

A. By failing to remedy a transmission tariff that facilitates systemic and

printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation

FERC, 756 F.3d 556, 561, 565 (7th Cir. 2014). 29 Order at P 68 (“The Commission has a duty to address the risk of cost shifting among transmission customers that may result in unjust and unreasonable transmission rates.”); id. (“To fulfill its responsibility to ensure that transmission rates are…
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

B. The Commission failed to rationally connect Network Upgrade cost

printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation

Pennsylvania EDCs and their affiliated transmission companies cannot implement cost allocation methodologies that conflict with FERC-approved tariffs and orders.”) (EAP’s members include several PJM Transmission Owners). 23 Under the second model, a transmission owner recovers transmission charges…
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

IV. Requests for Clarification

printed heading

Requests for Clarification
Read this passage

A. The Commission should clarify that a just and reasonable

printed heading

The Commission should clarify that a just and reasonable cost-recovery agreement requires the Eligible Customer to pay the full incremental cost of Network Upgrades needed to accommodate the large load.
Read this passage

B. The Commission should clarify that transmission owners must

printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation

The Commission should clarify that transmission owners must immediately credit revenue received under cost-recovery agreements to the other transmission customers in the zone.
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

CONCLUSION

printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation

CONCLUSION The Order correctly finds that the PJM Tariff shifts the costs of Network Upgrades for large loads to transmission customers that neither caused nor benefit from them.
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

Certificate of Service

printed heading

Sussler Philip L.
Read this passage