Comments of the Illinois Commerce Commission in support of PJM Interconnection, L.L.C.’s 07/31/2026 filing
The Illinois Commerce Commission comments in support of PJM's July 31 Reliability Backstop Procurement filing, while raising concerns about forecast error, new state allocation duties for retail access states, and state access to registry data.
Asks FERC to: Accept PJM's backstop proposal with mitigation of cost shifts to existing ratepayers, no new obligations on states, PJM clarifications, and state access to RBP data.
Parallel proceeding. Comments in the separate PJM backstop docket ER26-3380. ICC cites the E-7 order's expectation that cost transparency will let states sub-allocate costs, and says it doubts that assumption for retail access states.
E-7 PJM: Cost transparency (P 71, p. 51)
Key points
- ICC generally supports PJM's one-time supplemental capacity procurement for large-load shortfalls.
The ICC generally supports PJM's proposal to implement a one-time, supplemental procurement of new capacity to address the identified resource adequacy shortfall PDF p. 1
- ICC praises the bilateral phase because it assigns costs to the new load that contributed to the shortfall.
Bilateral contracts provide new load with an opportunity to purchase capacity and address the shortfall to which they directly contributed. PDF p. 2
- ICC says the proposal has no mechanism to moderate load forecast error, and 15-year contracts could compound it.
The PJM proposal does not include any mechanism to moderate any potential error, such as cost reconciliation. PDF p. 4
- ICC questions how retail access states can assign wholesale capacity costs to retail load through the new RBP Obligation.
it is unclear how states, particularly retail access states like Illinois, would be able to assign wholesale capacity costs to retail load in the manner PJM proposes PDF p. 5
- ICC doubts that states are best placed to identify cost causers, which the E-7 order expects cost transparency to enable.
expecting the states to make such determinations for PJM and the Commission may be unreasonable. PDF p. 6
- ICC asks that registry data reach all states and that PJM's non-disclosure form be flexible.
the ICC, for instance, would not be in a position to sign the pro forma non-disclosure agreements to access confidential data from PJM as it reads at this time. PDF p. 7
Read topic-matched comments in ER26-3380
Topics in the text: Cost allocation · Registry access · Reliability and curtailment
Source sections
Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.
Opening text
opening text · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
The ICC recommends that the Commission require sufficient mitigation efforts to protect against cost shifts to or any negative impacts on existing ratepayers, impose no new obligations upon the states, and require PJM to provide the clarifications, transparency, and access to data as discussed…Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
I. COMMENTS
printed heading
I.Read this passage
A. The Core Elements of PJM’s Reliability Backstop Procurement Proposal are
printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation
PJM proposes to “empower” states by imposing on them an obligation to “submit RBP RBOs, which PJM would then apply to the allocation of RBP Charges” to load serving entities (“LSEs”).5 Given the timing and the lack of implementation details, particularly for retail access states like Illinois,…Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
B. PJM’s Proposal Requires Active Collaboration Between PJM and States
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
PJM’s territory covers vastly different market structures and PJM’s proposals must work for all of them.Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
II. CONCLUSION
printed heading
The ICC further requests any and all other appropriate relief.Read this passage
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
printed heading
Dated at Chicago, Illinois, this 19th day of August, 2026. /s/ Christine F.Read this passage