Protest, Motion to Reject, and Alternative Request for the Imposition of Conditions of Delaware Division of the Public Advocate et al
Six state consumer advocates jointly protest PJM's Reliability Backstop Procurement in ER26-3380, ask FERC to reject it as unjust and unreasonable, offer two alternatives, and list conditions if FERC accepts it.
Asks FERC to: Reject the RBP; direct PJM to refile a subscription-based procurement or advance the effective date of its IRAS proposal; if RBP is accepted, impose conditions such as a five-year procurement period.
Parallel proceeding. Protest in PJM's separate backstop procurement docket ER26-3380, which the advocates link to the EL26-67 show cause order they say already found PJM's tariff appears unjust and unreasonable.
E-7 PJM: 30-day report on serving large loads with adequate generation (p. 8)
Key points
- The advocates say RBP cost allocation to large loads depends on state action, and where states do not act, zonal charges fall on the general ratepayer body.
where a state does not act—or acts late—zonal RBP charges are allocated onto the general ratepayer body within the PDF p. 4
- They say RBP's design contradicts its stated 6.8 GW reliability need through opt-outs, 15-year terms and no market mitigation.
PJM says that reliability demands that nearly 7 gigawatts of new supply be procured in the near-term, yet permits an untold number of megawatts (or possibly gigawatts) to opt-out of the auction PDF p. 9
- They say the $555/MW-day price ceiling comes from a one-year capacity design and does not fit a commitment of up to 15 years.
A cap set on that basis is irrelevant to the determination of what should be paid PDF p. 6
- They put 15 years of RBP charges on a 6,831 MW total at about $20.8 billion.
$555/MW-day x 365 days x 15 years would be $20,756,847,375. PDF p. 30
- Option One: refile as a subscription model in which load-serving entities set the procurement quantity and bear credit obligations.
PJM should be directed to refile the RBP as a "subscription" model PDF p. 30
- Option Two: advance IRAS so large loads from 2028/2029 either bring their own resources or are treated as first-off in emergencies.
the Commission should, in lieu of approving the RBP, advance the effective date of IRAS PDF p. 33
- As a fallback, they ask that any approval limit the procurement period to five years.
The Commission should limit the RBP procurement period to five years PDF p. 34
Read topic-matched comments in ER26-3380
Topics in the text: Cost allocation · Reliability and curtailment · Registry access
Source sections
Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.
Opening text
opening text · Topic match: Registry access
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA BEFORE THE FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION PJM Interconnection, L.L.C.Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
SUMMARY
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation
This allocation to be developed by state commission or RERRA is given a name by PJM, the “RBP Obligation” (RBO).15 In the “unexpected event”16 that “RBOs are ultimately not reported to PJM,” PJM proposes that the costs for up to 15 years of capacity payments to zones/areas to which RBP cost…Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
I. Protest
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation
RBP will saddle ratepayers with fifteen years of payments, even as PJM admits that the proposed commitment period is as much as a decade longer than the five-year bilateral procurements that will meet PJM’s reliability needs.Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
A. RBP’s design is contrary to PJM’s assertion that the proposal is needed to address a reliability risk associated with a 6.8 GW capacity shortfall.
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation
Proposed Tariff Attachment DD, section 18.1(d) provides in part:35 The Initial RBP Target shall be further decremented, if requested by an Electric Distributor, by up to the associated MW quantity of load that participates in a peak shaving adjustment program where such Electric Distributor’s…Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
B. PJM fails to demonstrate that 15-year resource commitments are needed to meet the capacity shortfall.
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation
Cir. 2023). 58 Id. 59 Id. at 857. - 17 - Although the foregoing demonstrates that the fifteen-year period is unjust and unreasonable, we note that it is also unduly discriminatory to require some ratepayers to pay for fifteen-year procurements when other ratepayers are insulated from RBP charges…Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
C. The RBP fosters the exercise of seller-side market power and is unlikely to secure the least-cost combination of resources.
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Registry access
It must be emphasized that Joint Consumer Advocates do not concede that the Reliability Pricing Model (RPM) is at present competitive or just and reasonable.Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
D. The proposed $555/MW-Day cap price is excessive.
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation
But as used in the RBP, the $555/MW-day price is a soft price cap, meaning that ratepayers are subject to paying a selected resource’s “as bid” offer price—and are not protected by a fixed, $555/MW-day cap.Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
E. The absence of locational criteria for RBP resource procurements poses unjustified cost risks for ratepayers.
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation
The absence of locational criteria for RBP resource procurements poses unjustified cost risks for ratepayers.Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
II. Request for issuance of directive to pjm to implement one of two just and reasonable alternatives
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation
PJM proposes no counterpart provision to adjust the target forecast for known reductions in projected new large loads even as those forecasts have been rapidly and continuously plummeting. 107 Id. ¶ 8. 108 “The initial allocation of RBP UCAP MW to each Electric Distributor zone/area will be based…Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
III. If the Commission declines to reject RBP, it should condition acceptance to address evident and substantial concerns.
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation
PJM’s assertions demonstrate that it is unjust and unreasonable to require ratepayers to bear procurement costs over a fifteen-year period.Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
CONCLUSION
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation
It is self-contradictory, deeply flawed, and likely to result in significant and excessive costs to ratepayers that are “all pain and no gain.” As the stakeholder process made clear, the purported capacity shortfall and whatever reliability concerns it engenders can be addressed through far less…Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
printed heading
Dated on this 21st day of August, 2026. /s/ Lauren L.Read this passage