ER26-3380-000 · 2026-08-21 · Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel

The Ohio Consumers' Counsel submits Protest and Request for Rejection of Filing or in the Alternative for Evidentiary Hearings and/or Settlement Proceedings re PJM Interconnection, L.L.C.’s Reliability Backstop Procurement filing

The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel protests PJM's Reliability Backstop Procurement in ER26-3380, saying it shifts data center capacity risk and cost to existing consumers. OCC asks FERC to reject it or set it for hearing or settlement using the Market Monitor's proposal as a starting point.

Asks FERC to: Reject PJM's Reliability Backstop Procurement filing or, in the alternative, accept it subject to refund and set it for evidentiary hearing or settlement proceedings starting from the IMM proposal.

Parallel proceeding. A protest in PJM's separate backstop docket ER26-3380 on who bears capacity risk for large loads, the same cost-shift concern behind E-7's cost-recovery directive and its resource adequacy report.

E-7 PJM: Cost-recovery agreement (P 77, p. 28) E-7 PJM: 30-day report on serving large loads with adequate generation (p. 8)

Key points

  1. OCC says the backstop shifts the cost and risk of capacity for data center load to existing Ohio consumers.
    It will unreasonably shift the risks and costs associated with acquiring that new capacity from the data center loads to existing consumers in Ohio and elsewhere in PJM. PDF p. 2
  2. OCC objects that PJM relies on state allocation, and Ohio has no statute governing large-load capacity cost allocation.
    Ohio has no statutes governing allocation of large load-related generation capacity costs among retail customers. PDF p. 7
  3. OCC says nothing constrains suppliers from bidding the $555/MW-day cap, set against a 6,800 MW scarcity.
    The $555/MW-day (unforced capacity) offer cap is based on scarcity conditions and is significantly higher than the clearing price in the 2028/2029 auction of $325/MW-day PDF p. 9
  4. OCC notes the IMM calculated data center demand raised other customers' capacity costs by about $23.1 billion over three auctions.
    data center demand increased capacity costs to other PJM customers by approximately $23.1 billion across the 2025/2026, 2026/2027, 2027/2028 Base Residual Auctions. PDF p. 12
  5. OCC calls the 20 percent supplier shortage penalty too low and objects to passing penalties to load.
    PJM's proposal to limit the shortage penalty to 20% of the offer price for the capacity is also unjust, unreasonable and unduly discriminatory and preferential in favor of suppliers. PDF p. 15
  6. OCC backs the IMM approach of 15-year bilateral contracts for data center load with all risks on the counterparties.
    the IMM proposes that LSEs serving the new AI and large data center loads enter into 15-year bilateral contracts in which the risks and costs of the new generation to be acquired to serve those loads are allocated only to the parties to those contracts. PDF p. 17
  7. Alternatively OCC wants acceptance subject to refund and settlement or hearing built on the IMM proposal.
    if FERC accepts the filing, it should do so subject to refund and set the filing for hearing and/or settlement proceedings with directives that the parties use the IMM RBP proposal as a starting point. PDF p. 20

Read topic-matched comments in ER26-3380

Topics in the text: Reliability and curtailment · Cost allocation · Registry access

Source sections

Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.

Opening text

opening text

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA BEFORE THE FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION PJM Interconnection, L.L.C. ) Docket No.
Read this passage

I. BACKGROUND

printed heading

I.
Read this passage

BACKGROUND

printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation

It also asserts that the shortfall in capacity cleared to meet the resource adequacy needs of the region has grown for each of the past three RPM auction Delivery Years, which includes the 2028/2029 Delivery Year auction, run in July of this year.8 PJM proposes to implement a one-time auction along…
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

II. PROTEST

printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation

While there are additional matters pending or contemplated to implement specific data center load tariffs for American Transmission Systems, Inc., Dayton Power and Light Company and Duke Energy Ohio, to date the PUCO has not adopted orders establishing programs for these utilities. 7 generating…
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

A. PJM’s RBP proposal will not ensure just, reasonable rates for consumers;

printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation

Additionally, PJM argues that its proposed “maximum willingness-to-pay cap” will provide “a direct limit on procurement costs even in the absence of offer mitigation.”28 PJM proposes to set the cap at the maximum price for the existing RPM auctions of $555/MW/day, arguing that this mitigates market…
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

B. The RBP proposal will unjustly and unreasonably leave existing consumers

printed heading · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment

Allowing those costs to be transferred to load essentially just shifts the risk that a generating resource will be commercially operational to the parties with no control over those operations, i.e., the loads that must bear the costs of the power to be generated.
Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment

C. The IMM proposed approach to resource adequacy in PJM will ensure

printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation

This in turn better comports with the Seventh Circuit’s cost allocation mandate that costs must be allocated in a manner roughly commensurate with cost causation and beneficiaries of the proposed new infrastructure.52 Unlike the PJM RBP proposal, the IMM RBP proposal provides no loopholes for new…
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

III. CONCLUSION

printed heading

III.
Read this passage

CONCLUSION

printed heading · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment

CONCLUSION FERC may accept or reject a utility filing under section 205 of the Federal Power Act, 16 U.S.C. 824d, depending on whether the utility has demonstrated that its proposal is just, reasonable, and not unduly discriminatory or preferential.59 However, as PJM notes in its RBP Application,…
Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

printed heading

Dated in Columbus, Ohio this 21st day of August, 2026. /s/ Denise C.
Read this passage