Comments of the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission to the Proposal of PJM Interconnection, L.L.C. to establish Interim Resource Adequacy Service and Large Load Registry to address System Reliability
The Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission comments on PJM's Interim Resource Adequacy Service and Large Load Registry filing. It supports the registry but objects to the proposed curtailment compensation tariff section as an intrusion on state retail ratemaking.
Asks FERC to: Sever and deny the proposed compensation rate section or adopt the PA PUC's alternative language, modify the registry to give states curtailment data, and otherwise accept the filing.
Parallel proceeding. Comments in PJM's interim resource adequacy docket ER26-3515. Its split between wholesale curtailment compensation and state retail authority, and its registry data request, relate to E-7 adequacy and cost transparency.
E-7 PJM: 30-day report on serving large loads with adequate generation (p. 8) E-7 PJM: Cost transparency (P 71, p. 51)
Key points
- The PA PUC supports a New Large Load registry but objects to the compensation language in Appendix A.
PA PUC supports the creation and maintenance of a New Large Load (NLL) Registry and suggests improvements to the Registry. PDF p. 2
- The tariff lets a large load accept less than 50% of the Non-Performance Charge Rate in retail rates, which the PA PUC says abdicates retail authority.
retail ratemaking authority would be inappropriately and unlawfully abdicated to NLLs. PDF p. 3
- PJM's compensation ranges from 50% of the Non-Performance Charge Rate down to zero.
PJM’s proposal also allows eligible NLLs to agree upon a retail rate between 50% of the Non- Performance Charge Rate and zero dollars PDF p. 4
- The PA PUC says the large load would effectively set its own curtailment compensation, with no validation of actual curtailment.
Under this scheme, the NLL functions as a retail rate regulator that sets its own curtailment compensation rates up to a maximum threshold of 50% of the Non-Performance Charge Rate. PDF p. 5
- It cites Pennsylvania Executive Order 2026-05 limiting data center costs on other customers.
Governor Josh Shapiro signed Executive Order 2026-05 on August 18, 2026. PDF p. 6
- Alternative language sets compensation at 0% unless a state regulator permits up to 50%.
The rate for the provision of Interim Resource Adequacy Service shall be 0% of the Non-Performance Charge Rate PDF p. 7
- State commissions should have access to the registry and to curtailment data.
state utility commissions should have access to the Registry and curtailment data should be provided in the Registry. PDF p. 8
Read topic-matched comments in ER26-3515
Topics in the text: Reliability and curtailment · Registry access · Retail and wholesale authority
Source sections
Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.
Opening text
opening text · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
ER26-3515-000 COMMENTS OF THE PENNSYLVANIA PUBLIC UTILITY COMMISSION The Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission (PA PUC) submits these comments to the Proposal of PJM Interconnection, L.L.C.’s (PJM) to Establish Interim Resource Adequacy Service and Large Load Registry to Address System Reliability…Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
I. Compensation for Load Reduction Under IRAS
printed heading · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
Compensation for Load Reduction Under IRAS PJM proposes a compensation mechanism for NLLs that provide a load reduction service, i.e. curtailment, which creates new obligations for Electric Distributors.Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
X. COMPENSATION FOR PROVIDING INTERIM RESOURCE
printed heading · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
COMPENSATION FOR PROVIDING INTERIM RESOURCE ADEQUACY SERVICE (a) The rate for the provision of Interim Resource Adequacy Service shall be 0% of the Non-Performance Charge Rate specified in Tariff, Attachment DD, section 10A(e), unless any State Utility Regulator elects to permit in its…Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
II. Large Load Registry
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
Large Load Registry PA PUC supports PJM’s proposed Large Load Registry and requests that it be improved to enable authorized users to compute compensation.Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
III. Conclusion
printed heading
III.Read this passage
Conclusion
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
Additionally, we request a modification of the proposed New Large Load Registry.Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
printed heading
Barnes Deputy Chief Counsel Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission 400 North St., 3rd Floor Harrisburg, PA 17120 Tel: (717) 787-5000 Dated: September 3, 2026Read this passage