Protest of Community Collaboration on Climate Change, et al. re the Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Inc.’s filing proposing revisions to establish the Zero Injection Generator Interconnection Agreement
Community Organizations and Clean Energy Advocates (Sierra Club, NRDC, Clean Grid Alliance and others) protest MISO's ZGIA filing, accepting the zero-injection design but objecting to missing penalties, transparency, scope limits and cost-shift safeguards.
Asks FERC to: Direct MISO to cure the listed deficiencies, through a deficiency letter or compliance in the show cause proceeding, before FERC accepts the ZGIA filing.
Parallel proceeding. Protests MISO's ZGIA filing in ER26-3552, MISO's co-location response to the E-8 order, and argues it falls short of the order's cost transparency and cost-shift protections.
E-8 MISO: Services for flexible / co-located loads (P 6(d), p. 7) E-8 MISO: Cost-recovery agreement (P 6(b), p. 6) E-8 MISO: Show cause or propose tariff changes in 60 days (p. 5)
Key points
- The protesters accept the ZGIA design and object to the missing tariff mechanics.
Our organizations do not oppose the intended design of MISO’s ZGIA Proposal PDF p. 2
- They ask FERC to send MISO a deficiency letter or order further compliance in the show cause docket.
we urge the Commission to direct MISO to address these tariff and procedural defects through either a deficiency letter or direct further compliance via the show cause proceeding. PDF p. 2
- They want operational penalties for unauthorized injections, citing the E-8 order's concern about control and protection requirements.
The Commission should require MISO to modify its ZGIA proposal to include robust operational penalties for ZGIA Generating Facilities that make unauthorized injections PDF p. 4
- They say MISO has not justified the 20-second Transient Tolerance Window.
MISO has not justified why a maximum period of 20 seconds is either operationally attainable by a generator PDF p. 12
- They say MISO falls short of the E-8 order's cost transparency requirements.
MISO has fallen well short of the Order’s clear requirements on transparency. PDF p. 14
- They ask for a cap on the ZGIA program's size or duration, citing the ERAS and SPP HILLGA precedents.
To achieve the narrow tailoring required by the Commission’s open access precedents, a program that bypasses the traditional interconnection queue must have some limitation on how large it could get. PDF p. 17
- They say deferred upgrade costs could reach other customers if supporting generation fails.
the Proposal does not require adequate financial security, cost-recovery agreements, or true-ups for the cost of deferred transmission upgrades if the ZG Generating Facility fails to materialize, retires early, or becomes permanently unavailable. PDF p. 21
- They call the five-year commitment an intent, not a firm term, and unsupported by evidence.
Beyond this bald statement, MISO provides no evidentiary basis for choosing this inadequate formulation and therefore is arbitrary. PDF p. 22
- They conclude that MISO has the structure for a reasonable co-location program and should cure defects before acceptance.
Since MISO has the structure for a reasonable co-location program, we urge the Commission to direct MISO to cure the deficiencies with filing before accepting it. PDF p. 30
Read topic-matched comments in ER26-3552
Topics in the text: Connecting load and generation · Cost allocation · Reliability and curtailment
Source sections
Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.
Opening text
opening text
1 UNITED STATES OF AMERICA BEFORE THE FEDERAL ENERGY REGULATORY COMMISSION Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Inc.Read this passage
I. INTRODUCTION
printed heading
I.Read this passage
INTRODUCTION
printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation
Without proper tariff provisions, this process could have the opposite of MISO’s intended effect by instead operationalizing ongoing cost shifts that will be difficult, if not impossible, for states to untangle, triggering otherwise preventable reliability shortalls, and allowing generators with…Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
TABLE OF CONTENTS
printed heading
TABLE OF CONTENTS I.Read this passage
D. The Proposal Fails to Adequately Mitigate the Risk that Network Upgrades Will Be Paid
printed heading
D.Read this passage
II. ARGUMENT
printed heading
II.Read this passage
A. The Proposal Fails to Actually Ensure Zero Injection by ZG Generators.
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
A third infirmity in ensuring that zero means zero is how MISO proposes to set the “Transient Tolerance Window,” which is “the period of time after a reduction or loss of load by the ZG Associated Load by the end of which window the [ZG] Generating Facility must have” ceased injections to the…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
B. The Proposal Lacks Required Transparency.
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
The Commission found in the Show Cause Order that MISO must provide “cost transparency measures […] to provide stakeholders with sufficient information and visibility regarding the Network Upgrades, and their associated costs, needed to provide transmission service to Eligible Customers on behalf…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
C. The ZGIA Program’s Scope Should Have a Defined Limitation.
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
While acknowledging stakeholders’ “[r]equests to ensure ZGIA is a transitional construct and does not replace the standard GIA process,” MISO wholly ignored the point in its response to related comments: 63 To achieve the narrow tailoring required by the Commission’s open access precedents, a…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
D. The Proposal Fails to Adequately Mitigate the Risk that Network Upgrades Will
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
X, Generator Interconnection Procedures, Section 3.2.5.1(2); see also id. at 3.2.5.2.1 (“For ZG Interconnection Service to be granted, these analyses must determine that no Network Upgrades are needed to maintain system reliability other than Network Upgrades at the same substation as the Point of…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
E. The Proposal Requires Greater Clarity on the Treatment of Hybrid Resources.
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
Additionally, a ZG Generating Facility shall be metered “separate from any metering used for the ZG Associated Load,”93 but the Proposal should clarify whether a constituent storage unit within a ZGIA Hybrid Resource must be separately metered from the constituent generator and whether its charging…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
F. Drafting Errors
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
X, App’x 19 § 9.7.4.7 (requiring a ZG Generating Facility to reduce injections to match the ZG Associated Load’s Demand). 28 To support a ZG Generating Facility’s requirement to avoid grid injections and produce only the power its ZG Associated Load demands, MISO proposes to require that, after a…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
III. CONCLUSION
printed heading
III.Read this passage
CONCLUSION
printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation
CONCLUSION To effectuate MISO’s zero injection concept without raising the risk of adverse reliability events and cost shifts, Community Organizations and Clean Energy Advocates respectfully ask the Commission to use its authority to help MISO course correct.Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
printed heading
Wacker Dr., 14th Floor Chicago, IL 60606 sdoshi@earthjustice.orgRead this passage