Answer and Motion for Leave to Answer of the Independent Market Monitor for PJM Interconnection, L.L.C. to the Answer of PJM Interconnection, L.L.C. filed on 09/10/2026
The PJM Independent Market Monitor answers PJM's September 10 answer in the backstop procurement docket and asks for leave to answer. It argues the proposal leaves data center costs with other customers and repeats its recommendation that FERC reject the filing.
Asks FERC to: Accept the answer, reject PJM's Reliability Backstop Procurement, and direct PJM under FPA Section 206 to file within two weeks a solution requiring data centers to bear their own costs.
Parallel proceeding. Filed in PJM's backstop docket ER26-3380, and it also criticizes PJM's interim resource adequacy filing in ER26-3515. Its argument that data centers should bear capacity costs bears on E-7 adequacy and cost-shift questions.
E-7 PJM: 30-day report on serving large loads with adequate generation (p. 8) E-7 PJM: Cost-recovery agreement (P 77, p. 28)
Key points
- The Market Monitor says the shortfall comes entirely from data center load and PJM's approach keeps imposing those costs on other customers.
The shortfall identified in the RBP Filing is a result solely of data center demand. PDF p. 2
- It cites $29.4 billion of capacity market costs and 20,539.7 MW of data center load left in the 2029/2030 auction.
add to the $29.4 billion of capacity market costs that have resulted from the inclusion of data centers PDF p. 3
- PJM pushes allocation to states and distribution companies instead of assigning data center costs to data centers.
PJM is attempting to evade its responsibility to directly ensure that data centers pay their own costs by shifting that responsibility to the states and the EDCs. PDF p. 5
- The Monitor recommends rejection and a two-week Section 206 directive, including removing unbuilt data center load from auctions.
The Market Monitor continues to recommend that the Commission reject the RBP Filing and direct PJM, under the Commission’s FPA Section 206 authority, to file, within two weeks, a solution PDF p. 6
- New data center loads would need 15-year bilateral contracts with new generation that allow no cost or risk shifting.
PJM should establish criteria to be included in the RAA defining the obligations of LSEs to require that new data center loads have 15 year bilateral contracts with new generation PDF p. 6
- The Monitor says the backstop and the interim service use inconsistent definitions of qualifying capacity, with bilateral terms as short as five years.
The RBP Filing includes inconsistent definitions of capacity that will result in unintended consequences for reliability and capacity market prices in the future. PDF p. 30
Read topic-matched comments in ER26-3380
Topics in the text: Credit and exit · Cost allocation · Reliability and curtailment
Source sections
Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.
Opening text
opening text · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
PJM states (September 10th Answer at 64): “It is fallacious to suggest that a just and reasonable cost allocation approach must either identify specific loads (which are not FPA- jurisdictional actors) and not the LSEs serving those loads or be limited to one type of load when the resource adequacy…Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
I. ANSWER
PDF bookmark
I.Read this passage
A. PJM’s Reliance on “Cooperative Federalism” Is Misguided and Has Resulted in a Flawed and Incomplete Proposal.
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation
The September 10th Answer defends (at 56–65) what it alleges is a “cost allocation approach” in the RBP Filing with references to “cooperative federalism.” The RBP Filing does not propose a cost allocation approach, it proposes to procure the 6,831.3 MW shortfall of capacity through a flawed…Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
B. The September 10th Answer Fails to Address the Issues Raised by the Market Monitor and Others.
PDF bookmark
The September 10th Answer Fails to Address the Issues Raised by the Market Monitor and Others.Read this passage
1. The Shortfall is Entirely the Result of Data Center Load.
PDF bookmark
The Shortfall is Entirely the Result of Data Center Load.Read this passage
2. The Shortfall MW Value Is Not Correct and PJM Refuses to Correct It.
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation
The argument that PJM seeks to evade is that PJM must support its 6,831.3 MW target, inherently a precise number, based on accurate and contemporaneous information.Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
3. PJM Incorrectly Allocates Data Center Costs to EDCs/LSEs and Their Customers.
PDF bookmark
PJM Incorrectly Allocates Data Center Costs to EDCs/LSEs and Their Customers.Read this passage
4. PJM Allocates Financial Risks Created by Data Centers to EDCs and Their Customers.
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Credit and exit
PJM proposes that RBP sellers provide collateral equal to 20 percent of the first three years of their RBP sell offers.50 Under assumptions consistent with the buyer side obligation derivation, namely that 1 MW is offered at $555 per MW-day, the RBP seller’s credit requirement is $121,545 per MW (3…Read this passage Filed comments: Credit and exit
5. PJM Ignores Fundamental Locational Market Requirements.
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
However, this type of interconnection study cannot and does not 65 RBP Filing, Attachment A (Marked Tariff), Proposed OATT Attachment DD § 18.9(a). 66 See IMM Protest at 11; EKPC Protest at 31–33; JCA Protest at 28–29; AEP Protest at 29. 67 See PJM Answer at 60 n.179. - 27 - replace a local…Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
6. PJM’s Procurement Process is Flawed.
PDF bookmark
The September 10th Answer asserts that because some commenters would like a higher number and some would like a lower number, that PJM must be correct.Read this passage
7. PJM’s Definitions of Capacity That Can Satisfy the Requirements to Meet Data Center Load are Inconsistent.
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
The problem is that PJM proposes to treat RBP offset capacity as equivalent to RBP supply for 71 OATT Attachment DD § 16.4(e)(ii). - 30 - purposes of reducing the regional reliability requirement, even though the two have materially different contractual protections and performance obligations.Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
II. MOTION FOR LEAVE TO ANSWER
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Filing procedure
MOTION FOR LEAVE TO ANSWER The Commission’s Rules of Practice and Procedure, 18 CFR § 385.213(a)(2), do not permit answers to protests, answers, or requests for rehearing unless otherwise ordered by the decisional authority.Read this passage Filed comments: Filing procedure
III. CONCLUSION
PDF bookmark
CONCLUSION The Market Monitor respectfully requests that the Commission afford due consideration to this answer as the Commission resolves the issues raised in this proceeding.Read this passage
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
printed heading
Dated at Eagleville, Pennsylvania, this 25th day of September, 2026.Read this passage