PJM states request clarification or separate consideration of the interim service proposal
The Organization of PJM States comments on PJM's Interim Resource Adequacy Service filing. Eleven member commissions support the registry, curtailment priority and demand curve exclusion, ask PJM to clarify the compensation rate, and alternatively ask FERC to sever it.
Asks FERC to: Require PJM to clarify the IRAS compensation rate and who sets it; if the issues persist, sever and reject Attachment DD-4 section X and accept the rest of the filing.
Parallel proceeding. State regulators' comments in PJM's separate IRAS docket ER26-3515. Curtailing large loads without their own capacity before other customers parallels the E-7 flexible-load service directive, with the retail-wholesale boundary at issue.
E-7 PJM: Service for flexible loads (P 85, p. 56) E-7 PJM: 30-day report on serving large loads with adequate generation (p. 8)
Key points
- OPSI supports the registry and a wholesale curtailment signal before pre-emergency procedures, but not the compensation mechanism without clarification.
the Commission should not accept PJM’s proposed compensation mechanism, without further clarification. PDF p. 1
- OPSI supports calling IRAS before pre-emergency load management so existing customers and demand response do not bear the first consequences of a shortfall.
Calling on IRAS first appropriately places the initial operational consequences of a capacity shortfall on the amount of demand associated with NLLs that entered the system without sufficient new capacity PDF p. 4
- OPSI says differential treatment of new large loads should include less firm service.
This differential treatment should reasonably include less firm service. PDF p. 5
- OPSI supports removing new large loads without their own capacity from the demand curve starting with the 2029/2030 auction.
NLLs entering the system without sufficient new capacity should not be permitted to increase capacity-market demand and rely on PJM’s existing capacity supply to satisfy that incremental requirement. PDF p. 6
- States need meaningful registry access to design retail curtailment and cost allocation.
states must have meaningful access to the Registry so they can determine how curtailment should be implemented at the retail level PDF p. 7
- OPSI asks PJM to clarify whether retail regulators can set the IRAS rate or only decide eligibility for compensation.
PJM should clarify whether retail regulators can set the IRAS rate itself at retail or if they simply have the ability to determine whether specific retail loads are entitled to compensation PDF p. 8
- OPSI says the 50% rate is unsupported because PJM calls a zero rate just and reasonable.
The Commission should sever and reject proposed Attachment DD-4 § X and accept the remainder of PJM’s filing without the unsupported 50% compensation mechanism PDF p. 10
Read topic-matched comments in ER26-3515
Topics in the text: Reliability and curtailment · Registry access · Cost allocation
Source sections
Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.
Opening text
opening text · Topic match: Registry access
The Organization of PJM States, Inc. (“OPSI”) files these comments and request for clarification in response to PJM’s August 13, 2026, filing proposing revisions to the Open Access Transmission Tariff (“Tariff”) and the Reliability Assurance Agreement Among Load Serving Entities (“RAA”) to…Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
I. Comments
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation
COMMENTS Recognizing the 2027/2028 Base Residual Auction (“BRA”) cleared short of the PJM Region Reliability Requirement, PJM now proposes several measures intended to improve regional resource adequacy, including the creation and maintenance of an NLL Registry, establishment of IRAS, requiring new…Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
a. OPSI Supports the BYONC Incentive, but PJM Should Further explain whether it is expected to exacerbate volatility of supply
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation
One of the very purposes of IRAS is “for New Large Loads to bring new capacity to address their capacity needs instead of relying on PJM’s capacity market” and eliminate resource adequacy shortfalls.8 OPSI is supportive of the primary objectives of this proposal.Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
b. OPSI Supports Curtailing New Large Loads Without Sufficient Capacity Before Pre-Emergency Load Management
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
More importantly, the proposal functionally eliminates the incentive for NLL to bring new capacity.”11 PJM now proposes to implement an IRAS Action before calling on Pre-Emergency Load Management when available economic real-time supply may be insufficient to maintain required reserves or…Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
c. OPSI Supports Excluding New Large Loads Without BYONC from the VRR Curve Until They Bring Their Own Capacity
PDF bookmark
OPSI SUPPORTS EXCLUDING NEW LARGE LOADS WITHOUT BYONC FROM THE VRR CURVE UNTIL THEY BRING THEIR OWN CAPACITY Beginning with the 2029/2030 BRA, PJM proposes to exclude NLLs without sufficient BYONC or Allocated RBP Unforced Capacity (“UCAP”) MW from the Variable Resource Requirement (“VRR”) Curve.14…Read this passage
d. OPSI Supports the Large Load Registry to Inform Retail Curtailment and Cost Allocation
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Registry access
The Registry will include information such as location, in- service date, peak load, backup generation, peak-shaving adjustments, BYONC, and other relevant characteristics, and PJM will use that information to identify and allocate IRAS obligations by zone/area.21 PJM also recognizes that this…Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
II. PJM should clarify the proposed IRAS compensation rate and the mechanism used to determine it
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Registry access
PJM describes the IRAS framework as squarely within the Commission’s established transmission jurisdiction and proposes that “[t]he rate for the provision of Interim Resource Adequacy Service shall be 50% of the Non-Performance Charge Rate” unless an Eligible NLL elects to accept less in its retail…Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
III. If the Commission reaches the merits on the existing record, it should sever the compensation provisions and find them to be unjust and unreasonable
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
By PJM’s own account, rapid large-load growth has outpaced new supply, tightened the capacity market, and produced resource-adequacy shortfalls.28 PJM attributes the current shortfall particularly to the “unprecedented surge in data center load” occurring faster than new supply can come online,…Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
IV. Conclusion
PDF bookmark
IV.Read this passage
CONCLUSION
printed heading · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
CONCLUSION The rapid influx of NLLs appearing in the PJM region presents a real threat to regional resource adequacy and reliability, and the status quo is not an option.Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
printed heading
Dated at Newark, Delaware this September 3, 2026.Read this passage