Order Accepting Proposed Tariff Revisions (Duke Energy Carolinas pro forma NITSA, ER26-2691-000 and -001)
FERC accepts Duke Energy Carolinas' revised pro forma network service agreement, effective August 1, 2026. It approves a shortfall payment for loads of 100 MW or more, rolled-in upgrade pricing and security terms, while encouraging more cost-shift protection and saying the order does not prejudge the show cause orders.
Parallel proceeding. A section 205 acceptance in a separate docket that approves a minimum-payment and security mechanism of the kind the show cause orders ask RTOs to consider, while FERC states it does not prejudge those orders.
E-7 PJM: Cost-recovery agreement (P 77, p. 28) E-8 MISO: Minimum cost recovery / security (P 119, p. 74) E-9 SPP: Cost-recovery + crediting (Ordering (B)(1)(b), p. 21)
Key points
- DEC's revisions respond to load growth of about 800 MW since 2012, including nine large new Network Load requests from 102 MW to 945 MW.
customer-served load has increased by approximately 800 MW since 2012, which includes nine customer requests to serve new large Network Load Source text
- FERC accepts the change-in-service and restudy rules because they avoid overbuilt upgrades that shift costs.
without resulting in DEC building more extensive Network Upgrades than necessary to provide that service, which could shift costs to DEC's other transmission customers. Source text
- FERC upholds default rolled-in treatment of Network Upgrade costs over SACE's protest.
we find that DEC's proposal to codify in the pro forma NITSA that the cost of Network Upgrades will be rolled into its transmission rates as the default comports with longstanding Commission policy. Source text
- FERC says non-conforming agreements with incremental rates remain available.
the Commission will consider non-conforming NITSAs that include an alternative cost-recovery mechanism such as an incremental rate. Source text
- FERC approves a shortfall payment if actual service falls below 75 percent of scheduled MW for 15 years, for loads of 100 MW or more.
to pay a Shortfall Payment if actual NITS falls below 75% of the MW value of service in the load schedule for each month and year during the 15-year period following the in-service date of its Network Upgrades Source text
- FERC finds the shortfall payment does not double recover because it is credited to a revenue account.
Shortfall Payments serve to reduce, rather than add to, DEC's revenue collection through its transmission revenue requirement. Source text
- FERC encourages DEC and others to add further cost-shift protections, including alternative transmission technologies.
Other measures may include greater deployment of alternative transmission technologies and grid enhancing technologies Source text
- FERC says the order does not prejudge the June 2026 show cause orders or the RM26-4 ANOPR.
our approval today in no way prejudges the outcomes of the June 2026 Large Load Show Cause Order proceedings under FPA section 206 Source text
Topics in the text: Cost allocation · Credit and exit · Registry access
What the document says
Unpaginated filing
FERC accepts a shortfall payment for network loads of 100 MW or more.
The purpose of the Shortfall Payment mechanism is to reduce the potential cost impacts of large load service requests on other DEC transmission customers if the Network Load does not materialize or otherwise takes less service than anticipated. Source text
Unpaginated filing
The 100 MW large-load threshold is just and reasonable.
Based on the record before us, we also find that the 100 MW threshold is just and reasonable. Source text
Unpaginated filing
Shortfall payments reduce, not add to, Duke's transmission revenue requirement.
Shortfall Payments serve to reduce, rather than add to, DEC’s revenue collection through its transmission revenue requirement. Source text
Unpaginated filing
Network Upgrade costs roll into transmission rates by default, large-load upgrades included.
Network Upgrades that are part of an integrated system benefit all system users. Source text
Unpaginated filing
Network Upgrade costs roll into transmission rates by default, large-load upgrades included.
That policy does not change based on the size or scope of Network Upgrades constructed to fulfill a transmission customer’s request for network service. Source text
Unpaginated filing
Duke may still file a non-conforming agreement with incremental rates.
the Commission will consider non-conforming NITSAs that include an alternative cost-recovery mechanism such as an incremental rate. Source text
Unpaginated filing
FERC rejects ElectriCities' comparability objection to the 100 MW terms as outside its retail jurisdiction.
The Commission lacks jurisdiction over retail customers, and we therefore dismiss ElectriCities’ argument. Source text
Unpaginated filing
Retail cost-shift worries from load additions are beyond FERC's jurisdiction.
we note that SACE’s concerns regarding retail cost allocation and rates pertaining to load additions are beyond the Commission’s jurisdiction. Source text
Elsewhere in the record
Other parties on the same questions, in their own documents.
- Chang dissented over the lack of dedicated security Commissioner Judy Chang
- See accepts 75% but calls it a low-end safeguard Commissioner Lindsay See
- Rosner calls the tariff an improvement, with risk left over Commissioner David Rosner
Source sections
Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.
Opening text
opening text
ER26-2691-000 ER26-2691-001 ORDER ACCEPTING PROPOSED TARIFF REVISIONS (Issued October 9, 2026) On May 29, 2026, pursuant to section 205 of the Federal Power Act (FPA)[fn:2] and Part 35 of the Commission’s regulations,[fn:3] Duke Energy Carolinas, LLC (DEC) filed revisions to its pro forma Network…Read this passage
Background
printed heading
All of DEC’s network customers have existing individual NITSAs on file with the Commission, most of which predate the 2012 filing of DEC’s pro forma NITSA.[fn:6] Proposed Tariff Revisions DEC proposes revisions to the body of its pro forma NITSA and existing attachments, as well as to add a new…Read this passage
Discussion
printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation
DEC argues that, accordingly, DEC proposed section I.1 to apply to all NITS requests because it will ensure that Direct Assignment Facilities and Network Upgrades are truly needed and sized correctly to reliably serve the amount of load requested and to avoid potential cost shifts to other…Read this passage
Attachment A – (Specifications for Network Integration Transmission Service)
printed heading
DEC argues that this change is necessary because listing the customer’s owned generation and contracts in individual NITSAs should not be considered non-conforming.[fn:127] In section 6.7 (Request for Change in Service), DEC proposes to clarify that customers remain responsible for the costs of…Read this passage
Attachment B – (Delivery Points)
printed heading
Attachment B – (Delivery Points) DEC proposes to add bracketed placeholders for delivery point number and names and to remove the Delivery Point Data Sheet from its pro forma NITSA, in favor of posting it on the publicly available portion of its OASIS website.[fn:132] DEC states that this will…Read this passage
Attachment C – (Transmission and Distribution Rates)
printed heading
Attachment C – (Transmission and Distribution Rates) DEC proposes to revise the title of the attachment to add “Transmission” to reflect the reality that certain delivery points may be served by transmission or distribution facilities.[fn:133] DEC also proposes to duplicate the distribution rates…Read this passage
Attachment D – (Network Operating Agreement)
printed heading
Attachment D – (Network Operating Agreement) DEC proposes to delete the existing Attachment D (Power Factor Penalty) and replace it with a section titled “Network Operating Agreement.”[fn:135] DEC explains that it has proposed to delete Attachment D because: (1) the power factor requirements…Read this passage
Attachment E – (Other Charges/Credits)
printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation
We note, however, that although we find DEC’s proposed revisions to its pro forma NITSA are just and reasonable and not unduly discriminatory or preferential based on the record in this proceeding, DEC may still (and we encourage it to) at any time either execute non-conforming NITSAs that provide…Read this passage
Background
printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation
DEC’s Committed Revenue Contribution Proposal Does Not Include Sufficient Security Requirements to Protect Customers Against the Risk of Cost Shifts As discussed below, DEC proposes to require long-term financial commitments from LSEs that serve large loads.Read this passage
Conclusion
printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation
We should, as the Commission has done,[fn:179] encourage utilities to voluntarily submit filings that bolster customer protections while rigorously scrutinizing those filings to ensure they actually protect customers against the risk of unjustified cost shifts resulting from the addition of large…Read this passage
Footnotes
Word notes · Topic match: Cost allocation
Off. of the President, Ratepayer Protection Pledge (Mar. 4, 2026), https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/2026/03/ratepayer-protection-pledge/ (“Companies will pay for all new power delivery infrastructure upgrades required to service their data centers, including adequate network upgrade costs to…Read this passage