PJM answers comments and protests about interim resource adequacy service
PJM moves for leave to answer and answers the comments and protests on its Interim Resource Adequacy Service and Large Load Registry filing. It defends the 50 MW definition, the federal-state split and the demand curve exclusion, and offers corrections on compliance.
Asks FERC to: Accept the Tariff and RAA revisions effective October 12, 2026; if FERC rejects any element, direct prescriptive changes on compliance or give guidance.
Parallel proceeding. PJM's answer in its separate ER26-3515 docket. It ties its 50 MW definition to the June 2026 show cause order and presents IRAS curtailment as a flexible-load service, the topic of the E-7 directive.
E-7 PJM: Service for flexible loads (P 85, p. 56) E-7 PJM: Application / study process (P 6(a), p. 7)
Key points
- PJM says the 2027/2028 auction fell short of the reliability requirement and calls IRAS and the registry the needed tools.
The Base Residual Auction for the 2027/2028 Delivery Year procured insufficient capacity to meet the PJM Region Reliability Requirement. PDF p. 1
- Absent new capacity, PJM says new large loads must be flexible and reduce demand during emergencies.
Absent such new capacity, New Large Loads must be flexible and, pursuant to PJM’s operational needs, reduce their energy demands when called upon during system emergencies. PDF p. 3
- PJM says it offered severable elements and urges timely approval of the registry, definition and bring-new-capacity obligation.
PJM highlights the importance of timely Commission approval of the following discrete elements: the Large Load Registry, PDF p. 6
- PJM cites a July 22 event in which nearly 4,000 MW of data center load tripped offline in Virginia.
a July 22 event saw nearly 4,000 MW of data center load trip offline unexpectedly in Virginia. It was the largest such event in PJM history. PDF p. 7
- PJM defends the 50 MW threshold as consistent with the June 2026 show cause order and rejects a baseline for existing loads.
No information presented by any of these parties renders PJM’s proposed threshold unjust and unreasonable. PDF p. 15
- PJM argues IRAS directs only a MW quantity to distributors and leaves retail curtailment choices to states.
it neither targets nor directs specific retail customers to be subject to curtailment, nor compels or restricts the authority of the retail authority to prioritize among the retail customers PDF p. 18
- PJM asks FERC to prescribe changes or give guidance if it rejects any element.
the Commission either direct prescriptive changes to be implemented on compliance or provide guidance to aid PJM and stakeholders to develop a just and reasonable approach. PDF p. 8
- PJM agrees to clarifying edits on compliance to the bring-your-own-capacity language for demand resources.
PJM agrees that the “not” included in this section should be removed PDF p. 64
Read topic-matched comments in ER26-3515
Topics in the text: Registry access · Reliability and curtailment · Cost allocation
Source sections
Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.
Opening text
opening text · Topic match: Cost allocation
Except for in reference to the “NEDC/PJM Governors’ Principles,” reference herein to the PJM states shall include the 13 state signatories and the District of Columbia. 4 Ratepayer Protection Pledge, The White House (Mar. 4, 2026), https://www.whitehouse.gov/releases/…Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
I. ANSWER
printed heading
I.Read this passage
A. There Is Overwhelming Support for PJM’s Proposed Large Load
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
Regardless, PJM disputes EKPC’s characterization as there was indeed broad support for a registry as evidenced in the August 13 Filing. 28 PA PUC Comments at 7; OPSI Comments and Request for Clarification or to Sever at 7. 29 August 13 Filing, Transmittal Letter at 28 (citing proposed RAA, Schedule…Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
B. PJM’s Proposed Definition of Large Load Is Consistent with Commission
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
Given the reliability and operational purposes of the Large Load Registry, PJM must have visibility into all Large Loads for registry purposes to ensure reliability and facilitate proper planning for the region, and existing Large Loads should be treated no differently. 50 IMM Comments at 29-31. 51…Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
C. There Is Widespread Support to Establish a Policy that New Large Loads
printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation
See August 13 Filing, Affidavit of Christopher Pilong on Behalf of PJM Interconnection, L.L.C. (Attachment C) ¶ 12 (“Pilong Aff.”). 59 See August 13 Filing, Transmittal Letter at 4-5. 60 Ratepayer Protection Pledge. 61 See Ratepayer Protection Pledge Announcement; July 2026 Ratepayer Protection…Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
D. IRAS Divides Authority over Responses to an Interim Resource Adequacy
printed heading · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
PJM will not direct reductions to specific New Large Loads pursuant to IRAS.”92 However, it is worth noting that, following PJM’s August 13 Filing, the Commission, in Tri-State Generation and Transmission Association, Inc. (“Tri-State”), shed to areas with concentrations of non-capacity backed new…Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
E. Calling for IRAS Load Reductions Before Pre-Emergency Load
printed heading · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
OPSI, NJ BPU, the Pennsylvania Governor’s Office, Ohio FEA, and Ohio ELC each express strong support for PJM’s proposed placement of IRAS within the sequence of PJM’s operational tools for addressing emergency conditions.122 These entities recognize that PJM’s proposal: • “appropriately places the…Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
F. PJM’s BYONC Rules Appropriately Incent the Development of New
printed heading · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
Electric Power Supply Association (“EPSA”) and others representing the interests of existing generators contend that the rule that New Large Loads must contract with new capacity to address their resource adequacy needs is unduly discriminatory against existing Capacity Resources.163 In other…Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
G. Excluding New Large Loads from the VRR Curve Until They Bring New
printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation
The DCC claims that PJM “cannot expect new supply resources to appear if the price signals sent by the market do not reflect—as will be the case under PJM’s IRAS proposal--the actual load that must be served in the region.”182 The DCC completely ignores that the New Large Loads (many of which may…Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
H. The IRAS Compensation Mechanism Benefits Ratepayers, Adheres to
printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation
The IRAS Compensation Mechanism Benefits Ratepayers, Adheres to Cost Causation Principles, and Reflects a Division of Labor that Respects States’ Jurisdictional Authority over Retail Customers and Rates.Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
I. IRAS Does Not Unduly Discriminate Against New Large Loads.
printed heading · Topic match: Reliability and curtailment
By definition, FRR Entities must bring new capacity for all new loads within their territory.226 If an FRR Entity does not include sufficient capacity in its FRR Capacity Plan, the FRR Entity is subject to “an FRR Commitment Insufficiency Charge, in an amount equal to two times the Cost of New…Read this passage Filed comments: Reliability and curtailment
II. CONCLUSION
printed heading
II.Read this passage
CONCLUSION
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
CONCLUSION PJM asks that the Commission consider this answer and accept the Tariff and RAA revisions proposed in this proceeding, effective October 12, 2026, as requested.Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
printed heading
Dated at Washington, D.C., this 23rd day of September 2026. /s/ Ryan J.Read this passage