Protest of Clean Energy Advocates and Community Organizations
Sierra Club, NRDC, Sustainable FERC Project, regional clean energy groups and two community organizations protest MISO's LARS filing as a permanent parallel process that shifts costs to other customers and DPP generators, discriminates, and departs from the show cause order's proximity test.
Asks FERC to: Reject all of LARS and direct MISO to work with stakeholders on a different proposal; alternatively issue a deficiency letter, or at least delay effectiveness until MISO files its promised cost provisions.
Answers the order. Protests MISO's LARS filing against the E-8 show cause order's cost-shifting concern and its definition of electrically proximate large load, and notes the cost recovery agreement is deferred.
E-8 MISO: Show cause or propose tariff changes in 60 days (p. 5) E-8 MISO: Cost-recovery agreement (P 6(b), p. 6)
Key points
- The groups say LARS is a new permanent parallel process that shifts costs, creates reliability concerns and allows discrimination.
MISO's LARS proposal is a new, permanent parallel interconnection study process that will shift costs from large loads to other existing and future transmission customers and resource owners PDF p. 3
- They note MISO's own account that LARS adopts no cost allocation methodology and defers cost shifting to later filings.
LARS adopts no cost allocation methodology PDF p. 13
- Load-study and common violations go to Baseline Reliability or Other projects paid by all loads in the pricing zone, while DPP generators fund their own upgrades.
LARS, therefore, takes a category of costs usually assigned to generators and assigns them to existing load. PDF p. 14
- They argue the standing injection persists after the paired load leaves, and zonal customers bear the cost.
LARS creates a standing injection that was studied only on the assumption of a matched withdrawal PDF p. 22
- They say LARS would give a limited number of projects preferential access each year, with vertically integrated utilities deciding which.
LARS sets up a generation and load study process that would offer a limited number of projects preferential access to the transmission system each year, year after year. PDF p. 22
- They say MISO invented an expansive definition of proximate instead of following the order's substation test.
MISO invents a new expansive definition of "proximate" in an attempt to demonstrate that its proposal is responsive to the Commission's Order. PDF p. 37
- They argue siloed parallel processes raise upgrade costs and bias risk and favor integrated planning such as GALIP.
meeting every new need with a new, siloed interconnection process (as MISO has done with ERAS, the ZGIA, now LARS, and soon the LLPR) significantly increases network upgrade costs PDF p. 45
Read topic-matched comments in ER27-25
Topics in the text: Connecting load and generation · Cost allocation · Reliability and curtailment
What the document says
PDF p. 14
LARS puts upgrade costs of load-caused violations on zonal ratepayers instead of the pair.
LARS, therefore, takes a category of costs usually assigned to generators and assigns them to existing load. PDF p. 14Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 18
FERC cannot find LARS just and reasonable without MISO's unfiled cost-shifting agreement.
A process that assigns upgrade costs to zonal load now, on the strength of an agreement whose terms are not before the Commission, has not been shown to be just and reasonable. PDF p. 18
PDF p. 18
LARS and the queue use different assumptions, so both can claim the same headroom.
These differing approaches risk MISO allocating transmission headroom twice. PDF p. 18
PDF p. 18
Queued generators say overallocation raises their upgrade costs and curtails their output.
Failing to coordinate DPP and LARS shifts costs onto DPP customers. PDF p. 18Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 30
Utility gatekeeping of LARS applications is undue discrimination against independent generators.
In other words, the LSE is the gatekeeper for participation in LARS, because without it PDF p. 30Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 32
LARS is a permanent, uncapped fast lane untethered to any identified resource adequacy need.
LARS is not time-limited, as MISO's most recent queue-jumping proposal ERAS was. PDF p. 32Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 33
Same-LRZ pairing is not the two-substation test the Show Cause Order described.
Instead, LARS generators and load are merely required to be in the same general Local Resource Zone. PDF p. 33Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 24
LARS generators get full capacity-market access years before other queue generators.
MISO's proposal is unduly discriminatory because it grants generators associated with qualifying large loads an accelerated pathway to obtain access to MISO's Planning Resource Auction market PDF p. 24
PDF p. 21
After 15 years the generator keeps full NRIS even if its load is gone.
After fifteen years, the generator keeps full NRIS of up to 150 percent of the departed load's peak demand with no further study and no cost at all. PDF p. 21
PDF p. 39
Clean energy groups say LARS adds a fifth path onto the grid and breaks planning.
LARS would be at least the fifth separate path onto the MISO transmission system PDF p. 39Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 40
Clean energy groups say LARS adds a fifth path onto the grid and breaks planning.
By excluding the DPP, LARS does the opposite of NERC's procedures. PDF p. 40Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 45
Protesters ask FERC to reject LARS outright; Clean Energy Advocates offer a deficiency letter instead.
the Commission should reject all portions of MISO's LARS proposal and direct MISO to engage with stakeholders to advance a different proposal. PDF p. 45Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
Elsewhere in the record
Other parties on the same questions, in their own documents.
- MISO would proceed before the rest of the cost protections are approved Midcontinent Independent System Operator
Source sections
Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.
Opening text
opening text · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
ER27-25-000 PROTEST OF CLEAN ENERGY ADVOCATES AND COMMUNITY ORGANIZATIONS Pursuant to Rule 211 of the Rules of Practice and Procedure of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (“FERC” or “Commission”)1, Clean Energy Advocates2 and Community Organizations3 respectfully submit this protest in…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
TABLE OF CONTENTS
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
TABLE OF CONTENTS I.Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
C. LARS is an unjustified departure from the Commission’s pro forma interconnection
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
C.Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
D. MISO’s LARS proposal is not responsive to Commission direction regarding
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
D.Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
I. Introduction
printed heading
I.Read this passage
Introduction
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
The Commission should reject LARS because it is not just and reasonable and is unduly discriminatory or, in the alternative, issue a deficiency letter requiring MISO to demonstrate how LARS can be made just and reasonable.Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
II. Background
printed heading
II.Read this passage
Background
printed heading
BackgroundRead this passage
A. Large Load Growth and Interconnection
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
MISO acknowledges that “large loads have overtaken the EPR process.”7 The 89 EPR requests approved in MTEP26 accounted for roughly 54 percent of the approximately $14.7 billion of transmission investment approved in that cycle.8 A generator may be treated as an alternative to a transmission…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
B. The Show Cause Order
printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation
These include: (1) A definition of large load. (2) A rolling application process with non-refundable fees, escalating readiness requirements, and disclosure of duplicative requests. (3) Study procedures that account for large-load behavior and flexibility. (4) Evaluations of alternative…Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
C. The LARS Proposal
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
MISO retained this structure over stakeholder objections, citing “mixed feedback.” MISO Large Load Working Group, MISO Response to Feedback, at 7 (Sept. 28, 2026), available at 9 Second, the Interconnection Customer develops a generating facility, demonstrates that it will provide energy to the…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
D. The Stakeholder Process
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
The Stakeholder Process MISO developed LARS in eleven weeks.Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
III. Arguments
printed heading
III.Read this passage
A. LARS creates a cost shift from large loads and their generation to other
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
ER25-1674-000 (Apr. 7, 2025), Accession No. 20250407-5242 (explaining that excluding late-stage DPP projects from an expedited interconnection study produces reliability gaps, and that resolving the resulting overallocation of transmission headroom through the annual MTEP process does not cure them…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
B. LARS violates open access principles and enables undue discrimination
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
This is particularly true for the types of large loads that MISO anticipates connecting, which have disproportionately high load factors and therefore should not have the excess capacity to bid into the PRA. 102 Id. at 15. 103 Transmittal Letter at 2. 104 See id. at 9 (“The agreement must…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
C. LARS is an unjustified departure from the Commission’s pro forma
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
While LARS might fast track a limited set of privileged interconnection requests, the creation of a new interconnection queue will put competing pressures on MISO’s staff and compute time to process standard DPP requests.Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
D. MISO’s LARS proposal is not responsive to Commission direction regarding
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
Additionally, MISO justifies this choice by arguing that tying LARS Associated Load to Local Resource Zones “avoids price separation between the paired generation and LARS Associated Load.”148 However, Local Resource Zones do not always align with transmission pricing zones and cost allocation…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
E. LARS threatens reliability and efficient planning
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
Due to the permanent nature of MISO’s LARS proposal, there is a risk that non-LARS transmission customers could be permanently disadvantaged by the process and bear the costs of transmission investments needed to resolve issues caused, at least in part, by a LARS request, or series of…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
IV. Conclusion
printed heading
IV.Read this passage
Conclusion
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
Conclusion For the foregoing reasons, the Commission should reject all portions of MISO’s LARS proposal and direct MISO to engage with stakeholders to advance a different proposal.Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
printed heading
Dated: October 23, 2026. /s/ Justin Vickers Justin Vickers Senior Attorney, Sierra Club 2101 Webster St., 13th Floor Oakland, CA 94612 (224) 420-0614 justin.vickers@sierraclub.org Counsel for Sierra ClubRead this passage