Joint Protest of the Iowa Office of the Consumer Advocate, the Citizens Utility Boards of Michigan, Illinois, Wisconsin and Minnesota, Citizens Action Coalition of Indiana, the Michigan and Illinois Attorneys General, and the Minnesota Department of Commerce
The Iowa Office of the Consumer Advocate and eight other consumer advocates and state offices jointly protest MISO's LARS filing, objecting to grandfathering about 30 GW, zonal cost allocation, LRZ-wide proximity and queue jumping.
Asks FERC to: Reject the grandfathering exemptions, GIP Section 3.12.4 cost assignment, the LRZ definition of electrically proximate and queue-jumping provisions; require MISO to address cost shifting in its section 205 filings and in the section 206 docket.
Answers the order. Protests MISO's LARS filing as an incomplete answer to the E-8 show cause order on cost shifting and electrically proximate loads, and asks that cost issues be heard in the EL26-70 docket.
E-8 MISO: Show cause or propose tariff changes in 60 days (p. 5) E-8 MISO: Cost-recovery agreement (P 6(b), p. 6) E-8 MISO: Minimum cost recovery / security (P 119, p. 74)
Key points
- The protesters oppose exempting or partly exempting about 30 GW of existing load from MISO's large load reliability requirements.
MISO is proposing to fully or partially exempt approximately 30 gigawatts of existing load from the Large Load Interconnection Reliability Requirements. PDF p. 3
- They say LARS does not address the show cause order's cost-shifting concerns, which MISO defers to filings due by November 16.
MISO's LARS Process does not address the Commission's concerns regarding cost-shifting expressed in the Show Cause Order. PDF p. 4
- Violations seen in the load study or in both studies go to Baseline Reliability or Other projects, which are allocated zonally.
The LARS Process does not assign the cost of all network upgrades to the cost-causer. PDF p. 6
- They say a same-Local-Resource-Zone test departs from the order's two-substation example of electrically proximate.
MISO's LRZ proposal does not meaningfully engage with the Show Cause Order. PDF p. 9
- They argue LARS studies generators before DPP projects that have waited through multiple phases.
In effect, any LARS project will be studied before the DPP projects that have waited through multiple phases of study. PDF p. 11
- They ask FERC to let them address cost impacts across all MISO section 205 filings in the section 206 show cause docket.
The Joint Protestors should be permitted to address the cost-shifting impacts, transparency issues, and other consumer protection issues raised in MISO's Section 205 filings as a whole PDF p. 4
Read topic-matched comments in ER27-25
Topics in the text: Connecting load and generation · Registry access · Cost allocation
What the document says
PDF p. 9
Generation must connect in the load's Local Resource Zone, which can span several states.
Neither MISO Witness Drake nor the Transmittal Letter explain how the LARS proposal mitigates the electrical impact of LARS Associated Load and generation facilities being spaced potentially hundreds of miles apart PDF p. 9Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 6
Upgrades for violations seen in the load study, or in both studies, go to zonal load.
Unlike the violations observed only in the generation study, the LARS Process assigns the cost of network upgrades to address violations observed in the transmission studies and observed in both the transmission study and the generation study to Baseline Reliability PDF p. 6Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 6
LARS puts upgrade costs of load-caused violations on zonal ratepayers instead of the pair.
The LARS proposal does not adequately assign costs to the cost causers, and MISO has not yet fully developed a cost allocation proposal for LARS load and PDF p. 6Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 4
FERC cannot find LARS just and reasonable without MISO's unfiled cost-shifting agreement.
The Commission should require MISO to address cost-shifting in all of its Section 205 filings and in all of its direct responses to the Section 206 Show Cause Order. PDF p. 4
PDF p. 10
LARS is a permanent, uncapped fast lane untethered to any identified resource adequacy need.
The Joint Protestors are concerned that LARS, similar to ERAS, will enable queue jumping. PDF p. 10Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 9
Same-LRZ pairing is not the two-substation test the Show Cause Order described.
The Joint Protestors respectfully urge the Commission to require MISO to establish a reasonable distance of "electrically proximate" PDF p. 9
PDF p. 3
Consumer advocates object to exempting about 30 GW of existing large load from reliability rules.
In total, MISO is proposing to fully or partially exempt approximately 30 gigawatts of existing load from the Large Load Interconnection Reliability Requirements. PDF p. 3
Elsewhere in the record
Other parties on the same questions, in their own documents.
- MISO would proceed before the rest of the cost protections are approved Midcontinent Independent System Operator
Source sections
Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.
Opening text
opening text · Topic match: Registry access
JOINT PROTEST The Joint Protestors submit this Joint Protest regarding the proposed tariff revisions filed by the Midcontinent Independent System Operator, Inc. (“MISO”) regarding the Large Load 2 Additional Resource Study Process (“LARS Process”) with the Commission in the above- captioned…Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
II. Cost-Shifting Should be Addressed Across MISO’s Section 205 Filings and in the
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
In a future submission, Joint Protestors may ask FERC to take action under Section 206 to address that need by (i) finding that the lack of funding provisions for consumer advocate offices renders MISO’s Tariff unjust and unreasonable and unduly discriminatory, and (ii) establishing a mechanism in…Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
III. The LARS Process Lacks Transparency on Costs and Allows Cost-Shifting of
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
The LARS Process Lacks Transparency on Costs and Allows Cost-Shifting of Network Upgrades MISO proposes to add a new GIP Section 3.12.4 to describe the studies that will take place for LARS generation projects.11 With respect to mitigations or network upgrades to address violations observed during…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
A. The generator will be responsible for any constraints unique to the
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
If a GIP defers or displaces a BRP, then the costs of the GIP up to the costs of the deferred or displaced BRP shall be allocated consistent with the cost allocation for the BRP.14 The LARS Process does not assign the cost of all network upgrades to the cost-causer.Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
IV. The LARS Process Fails to Address the Commission’s Show Cause Order’s
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
The LARS Process Fails to Address the Commission’s Show Cause Order’s Requirement to be “Electrically Proximate” MISO proposes LARS as load and generation pairs, interconnecting within the same Local Resource Zone (LRZ).16 MISO LRZ’s are physically large, with LRZ 1 spanning from Montana to…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
A. MISO’s LARS proposal provides the Tariff structure necessary to enable
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
MISO’s LARS proposal provides the Tariff structure necessary to enable an Interconnection Customer to serve an electrically proximate load as the LARS Associated Load must be located within the same LRZ.Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
V. MISO Fails to Explain How LARS is Not a Queue-Jumping Proposal
printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
The Show Cause Order explicitly asks MISO to show, in their FPA Section 205 filing, how they will “avoid disrupting existing commercial arrangements.”29 MISO has not shown how the LARS filing will avoid such disruptions to the existing DPP queue, and will avoid being unjust and unreasonable, or…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
CONCLUSION
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
Easler Attorney Iowa Attorney General Office of the Consumer Advocate 1375 East Court Avenue Des Moines, IA 50319 jennifer.easler@oca.iowa.gov For the Iowa Office of the Consumer Advocate /s/ Sydnie Lieb Sydnie Lieb Assistant Commissioner of Regulatory Affairs, Energy Resources Division Minnesota…Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
Easler Attorney Office of Consumer Advocate of Iowa 1375 East Court Avenue Des Moines, IA 50319-0063 (515) 725-7224 jennifer.easler@oca.iowa.govRead this passage Filed comments: Registry access