Limited Protest of Google LLC
Google files a limited protest of MISO's LARS filing. It supports studying large loads with paired generation but says LARS lacks cost-shifting protections and gives load-serving entities gatekeeper control, and asks FERC to reject it or accept and suspend it.
Asks FERC to: Reject LARS with guidance to refile alongside cost-shift protections, or accept and suspend it to review with MISO's pro forma cost shifting agreement; add direct access for independent generators.
Answers the order. Protests MISO's LARS response to E-8 because the cost shifting protections the order seeks, including a pro forma cost recovery agreement, were not filed with it.
E-8 MISO: Show cause or propose tariff changes in 60 days (p. 5) E-8 MISO: Cost-recovery agreement (P 6(b), p. 6)
Key points
- Google supports the LARS concept but protests that MISO filed it without protections against cost shifting.
MISO has filed LARS without accompanying and necessary protections against cost shifting, which prevents the Commission from finding that LARS is just and reasonable. PDF p. 2
- Upgrades for load-caused violations are classed as Baseline Reliability or Other projects, whose costs are recovered from all network customers in the pricing zone.
the costs of those project types are recovered from all network customers in a Transmission Pricing Zone. PDF p. 2
- Overallocated headroom would be fixed through a future MTEP project, and residential customers could bear that cost.
residential and other commercial customers could be left holding the bag for transmission projects needed to interconnect LARS generators PDF p. 6
- Google suggests more conservative study assumptions, such as counting DPP requests at Decision Point II, to avoid overallocation.
LARS could be modified to use more conservative assumptions PDF p. 7
- MISO plans to file the pro forma cost shifting agreement by November 16, 2026, so the record lacks it today.
the cost shifting agreement will be submitted in a separate section 205 filing by November 16, 2026 PDF p. 8
- Google offers two options: reject with direction to refile with protections, or accept, suspend and consolidate with the MISO show cause proceeding.
the Commission could accept and suspend the proposal and consolidate it with the MISO Large Load Show Cause proceeding PDF p. 8
- Google says routing applications through load-serving entities risks undue discrimination against independent generators.
LARS opens the door to undue discrimination and could undermine core open access principles by making load-serving entities ("LSEs") the gatekeepers of the LARS process. PDF p. 9
Read topic-matched comments in ER27-25
Topics in the text: Connecting load and generation · Cost allocation · Reliability and curtailment
What the document says
PDF p. 2
LARS puts upgrade costs of load-caused violations on zonal ratepayers instead of the pair.
Under current rules, the costs of those project types are recovered from all network customers in a Transmission Pricing Zone. PDF p. 2
PDF p. 8
FERC cannot find LARS just and reasonable without MISO's unfiled cost-shifting agreement.
the Commission cannot determine that LARS is just and reasonable because the record lacks such a key piece of the puzzle. PDF p. 8Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 3
Google: reject LARS with guidance, or accept and suspend it until the cost agreement arrives.
the Commission should either reject LARS with guidance indicating that it needs to be filed concurrently with procedures to prevent cross-subsidization or, in the alternative, accept and suspend the proposal PDF p. 3Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 2
Google: reject LARS with guidance, or accept and suspend it until the cost agreement arrives.
Google supports the intent and conceptual direction of LARS. PDF p. 2Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 6
LARS and the queue use different assumptions, so both can claim the same headroom.
each process is based on an incomplete snapshot of the transmission system and how it will operate in practice, which increases the likelihood that the LARS and DPP processes will produce incompatible results. PDF p. 6Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 7
Google would model advanced-stage queue projects in LARS so large loads absorb study error.
LARS could be modified to use more conservative assumptions PDF p. 7Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 9
Utility gatekeeping of LARS applications is undue discrimination against independent generators.
making load-serving entities ("LSEs") the gatekeepers of the LARS process PDF p. 9Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
PDF p. 9
Google wants independent generators to have direct access, with FERC resolving disputes with the utility.
protections providing that all forms of generation, including independent generation, have nondiscriminatory, direct access to the expedited generation interconnection study process under LARS. PDF p. 9Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
Elsewhere in the record
Other parties on the same questions, in their own documents.
- MISO says independent generators can negotiate before applying Midcontinent Independent System Operator
Source sections
Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.
Opening text
opening text · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
In addition, MISO must also continue to refine and improve its principal interconnection process, the Definitive Planning Phase (“DPP”), so that all generation resources in MISO—not 8 Id. at 14. -4- just those paired with large loads—can interconnect on a reasonable timeline.Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
A. The LARS Proposal Opens the Door to Shifting the Costs of Serving LARS Pairs onto Other Customers and Future MTEP Cycles
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
That is particularly so given that LARS’s design creates the very real risk of overallocation because ongoing DPP cycles do not include LARS requests and the LARS studies do not include DPP projects before they have signed Generator Interconnection Agreements.19 As a result, each process is based…Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
B. Without the Pro Forma Cost Shifting Agreement, the Commission Cannot Find LARS Just and Reasonable
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
It could reject the LARS proposal outright with direction to MISO that if it refiles LARS it must contain adequate protections against cost shifting, including any pro forma agreement.Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
C. LARS Opens the Door to Undue Discrimination
PDF bookmark · Topic match: Connecting load and generation
Under MISO’s proposal, LARS applications must be submitted through a designated LARS Associated Transmission Customer, which MISO indicates is typically the LSE.Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
printed heading
Dated: October 23, 2026 Washington, D.C. /s/ Bryan Shpall Bryan Shpall Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati 1700 K Street NW Fifth Floor Washington, DC 20006Read this passage