ER26-3380-001 · 2026-10-29 · Indicated PJM Transmission Owners

Request for Rehearing of the Indicated PJM Transmission Owners of the September 29, 2026 backstop order (TO exit amendment)

Indicated PJM Transmission Owners (the FirstEnergy Transmission Companies and Duquesne Light) request rehearing of FERC's September 29, 2026 order on PJM's Reliability Backstop Procurement. They challenge the order for leaving PJM's transmission owner Exit Amendment open instead of rejecting it.

Asks FERC to: Grant rehearing and definitively reject PJM's proposed Exit Amendment on cost-causation grounds and because PJM lacked unilateral Section 205 filing authority.

Parallel proceeding. Rehearing in PJM's backstop docket ER26-3380. The exit-fee and cost-causation dispute over who pays for procured capacity runs alongside the E-7 adequacy and cost-recovery directives.

E-7 PJM: 30-day report on serving large loads with adequate generation (p. 8) E-7 PJM: Cost-recovery agreement (P 77, p. 28)

Key points

  1. The Owners seek rehearing out of caution and hope PJM files a revised Section 205 proposal that moots it.
    submit this rehearing request out of an abundance of caution to preserve their rights in this fast-moving and dynamic proceeding. PDF p. 2
  2. FERC accepted the proposal, suspended it five months to February 28, 2027, and set a paper hearing on cost allocation, exit rules and collateral.
    suspended for five months, effective February 28, 2027, subject to refund and the outcome of the further procedures ordered in this proceeding. PDF p. 3
  3. The Order found PJM did not explain why transmission owners should bear backstop charges, but did not reject the exit fee outright.
    fails to explain why Transmission Owners—who are not the buyers for which PJM procures capacity under the RBP—should be responsible for RBP Charges PDF p. 3
  4. The Owners say the cost-causation finding should be final: transmission owners are not the beneficiaries of the backstop.
    should have been stated finally and definitively, instead of being left open for decision after a paper hearing. PDF p. 5
  5. PJM lacked filing authority because the Exit Amendment changes the Consolidated Transmission Owners Agreement, which needs a transmission owner vote.
    PJM cannot avoid the CTOA’s amendment procedures by casting a change to the core terms of the CTOA as an amendment to the OATT, rather than to the CTOA. PDF p. 7
  6. PJM also skipped the 45 days' notice owed to transmission owners and should have used Section 206.
    PJM therefore was required to provide the TOs with 45 days’ notice before filing the Exit Amendment. PDF p. 8

Read topic-matched comments in ER26-3380

Topics in the text: Filing procedure · Cost allocation · Credit and exit

What the document says

PDF p. 5

FERC should have finally rejected the TO Exit Amendment on cost-causation grounds.

The Order’s preliminary conclusion that the Exit Amendment may violate cost-causation principles should have been stated finally and definitively, instead of being left open for decision after a paper hearing. PDF p. 5

PDF p. 6

FERC should have finally rejected the TO Exit Amendment on cost-causation grounds.

the Commission has found it just and reasonable to impose generation capacity costs on LSEs located within an exiting TO’s zone, not on the TO as such. PDF p. 6

PDF p. 7

PJM lacked section 205 authority to file the Exit Amendment over the TOs' CTOA rights.

PJM cannot avoid the CTOA’s amendment procedures by casting a change to the core terms of the CTOA as an amendment to the OATT, rather than to the CTOA. PDF p. 7

PDF p. 8

PJM lacked section 205 authority to file the Exit Amendment over the TOs' CTOA rights.

Because PJM failed to fulfill any of these procedural prerequisites, PJM exceeded its authority in unilaterally submitting the Exit Amendment as a section 205 filing. PDF p. 8

PDF p. 2

TOs and FirstEnergy seek rehearing mainly to preserve issues while PJM prepares a replacement filing.

The Indicated PJM Transmission Owners submit this rehearing request out of an abundance of caution to preserve their rights in this fast-moving and dynamic proceeding. PDF p. 2
Filed comments: Filing procedure

Source sections

Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.

Opening text

opening text · Topic match: Filing procedure

The FirstEnergy Transmission Companies are separately filing a rehearing request raising other issues. 5 See PJM Interconnection, L.L.C., 196 FERC ¶ 61,245 (2026) (“Order”). 2 The Indicated PJM Transmission Owners are hopeful that PJM6 will submit a revised section 205 filing that supersedes its…
Read this passage Filed comments: Filing procedure

I. Background

PDF bookmark

I.
Read this passage

BACKGROUND

printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation

On September 29, 2026, the Commission issued its Order, accepting PJM’s RBP proposal for filing, “suspended for five months, effective February 28, 2027, subject to refund and the outcome of the further procedures ordered in this proceeding.”7 The Commission identified three aspects of PJM’s…
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

II. Request for rehearing

PDF bookmark · Topic match: Filing procedure

REQUEST FOR REHEARING
Read this passage Filed comments: Filing procedure

A. Statement of Issues and Specification of Errors

PDF bookmark

Statement of Issues and Specification of Errors The Indicated PJM Transmission Owners submit the following Statement of Issues and Specification of Errors pursuant to Rule 713(c)(1)-(2) of the Commission’s Rules of Practice and Procedure.14 • The Order is erroneous, arbitrary and capricious, fails…
Read this passage

B. Argument

PDF bookmark

B.
Read this passage

1. The Exit Amendment Violates Cost-Causation Principles

PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation

Under cost-causation principles, rates must “reflect to some degree the costs actually caused by the customer who must pay for them,” and costs must be 6 allocated in a manner at least roughly commensurate with benefits.15 As the Order recognized, PJM proposes to procure RBP capacity “on behalf of…
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

2. PJM Lacked Authority To File The Exit Amendment

PDF bookmark · Topic match: Filing procedure

The Order did not adopt that modification; rather, it accepted the Exit Amendment as filed, anticipated that modifications may be directed after the paper hearing, and encouraged PJM to submit a new filing.29 The Commission should grant rehearing and hold that PJM lacked authority under section 205…
Read this passage Filed comments: Filing procedure

III. CONCLUSION

PDF bookmark

III.
Read this passage

CONCLUSION

printed heading · Topic match: Filing procedure

CONCLUSION For the foregoing reasons, the Indicated PJM Transmission Owners respectfully request that the Commission grant rehearing of the Order and definitively reject PJM’s proposed Exit Amendment.
Read this passage Filed comments: Filing procedure

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

printed heading

Dated at New York, N.Y., this 29th day of October, 2026. /s/ Sanford I.
Read this passage