Request for Rehearing to Promote Transparency for Ohio Consumers
The Office of the Ohio Consumers' Counsel requests rehearing of FERC's October 9, 2026 order accepting PJM's Large Load Registry. It objects that state consumer advocate offices are excluded from the registry's confidential data and says this conflicts with the show cause orders.
Asks FERC to: Reject the registry proposal with directions to refile it so that state consumer advocate offices can access the confidential registry information, subject to confidentiality obligations.
Parallel proceeding. Rehearing in ER26-3515 that invokes the June 2026 PJM show cause order. It argues the order's cost data transparency findings for state regulators support giving consumer advocates access to the Large Load Registry, tied to the E-7 cost transparency directive.
E-7 PJM: Cost transparency (P 71, p. 51)
Key points
- The Counsel says the order lets PJM exclude state consumer advocate offices from the registry's confidential information.
that order allows PJM to exclude state consumer advocate offices from the list of entities entitled to access confidential information to be collected and maintained in the Large Load Registry. PDF p. 3
- It says advocates need data on large load magnitude, location and growth to test cost shifting to consumers.
Responsibility for advocating for consumer interests cannot be meaningfully discharged without access to information concerning the magnitude, location, and anticipated growth of large load. PDF p. 4
- It argues confidentiality can be handled by protective measures rather than categorical exclusion.
Legitimate confidentiality and security concerns can be addressed through protective measures rather than categorical exclusion. PDF p. 4
- The Counsel cites the Market Monitor's figure of $29 billion in added capacity costs over four auctions.
data center growth has driven $29 billion in additional capacity costs over the last four Base Residual Auctions PDF p. 7
- It lists three errors: no reasoned decision, undue discrimination versus state commissions, and inconsistency with the show cause rulings.
Whether FERC’s ruling excluding state consumer advocate offices from the confidential information in the Large Load Registry is inconsistent with its rulings in the Show Cause proceedings PDF p. 10
- The June PJM show cause order found cost information lacking for state regulators, which the Counsel says supports advocate access.
makes it difficult for interested parties, including transmission customers and state regulators, to accurately assess which transmission costs are driven by requests for transmission service PDF p. 17
- The Counsel asks FERC to direct PJM to extend registry access to consumer advocates.
FERC should reverse its ruling on this issue, and direct PJM to extend access to the Large Load Registry confidential information to state consumer advocate offices, subject to confidentiality obligations. PDF p. 19
Read topic-matched comments in ER26-3515
Topics in the text: Registry access · Filing procedure · Cost allocation
What the document says
PDF p. 19
Ohio asks FERC to give state consumer advocates confidential registry access.
extend access to the Large Load Registry confidential information to state consumer advocate offices, subject to confidentiality obligations. PDF p. 19Filed comments: Registry access
Source sections
Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.
Opening text
opening text · Topic match: Filing procedure
ER26-3515-000 REQUEST FOR REHEARING TO PROMOTE TRANSPARENCY FOR OHIO CONSUMERS BY OFFICE OF THE OHIO CONSUMERS’ COUNSEL Maureen Willis Consumers’ Counsel Angela O/Brien Deputy Consumers’ Counsel Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel 65 East State Street, Suite 700 Columbus, Ohio 43215 Telephone:…Read this passage Filed comments: Filing procedure
TABLE OF CONTENTS
printed heading · Topic match: Filing procedure
TABLE OF CONTENTS I.Read this passage Filed comments: Filing procedure
A. FERC’s failure to allow state consumer advocate offices access to the
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
FERC’s failure to allow state consumer advocate offices access to the Large Load Registry confidential information fails the test for reasoned decision-making because FERC never addressed OCC’s concerns. .......................8Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
B. FERC’s exclusion of state consumer advocate offices from the
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
FERC’s exclusion of state consumer advocate offices from the confidential information in the Large Load Registry unduly discriminates against these statutorily mandated consumer representatives. ...............................13Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
C. FERC’s ruling is an unlawful unexplained departure from its rulings in the
printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation
ER26-3515-000 REQUEST FOR REHEARING TO PROMOTE TRANSPARENCY FOR OHIO CONSUMERS BY OFFICE OF THE OHIO CONSUMERS’ COUNSELRead this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation
I. INTRODUCTION
printed heading
I.Read this passage
INTRODUCTION
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
Under Section 313 of the Federal Power Act (“FPA”), 16 U.S.C. § 825l, and Rule 713 of the FERC’s Rules of Practice and Procedure, 18 C.F.R. § 385.713, the Office of the Ohio Consumers’ Counsel (“OCC”) requests rehearing of the October 9 Order.Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
II. BACKGROUND
printed heading
II.Read this passage
BACKGROUND
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
The October 9 Order accepts PJM’s Large Load Registry proposal, including the definition of Large Loads and the provision that excludes state consumer advocate offices from access to the confidential information collected and maintained in the Registry.18 The October 9 Order rejected all other…Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
III. SPECIFICATIONS OF ERRORS ON REHEARING
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
FERC erred by acting in an arbitrary and capricious manner in approving PJM’s Large Load Registry proposal without ensuring that state consumer advocate offices have access to the confidential information that will be collected and maintained in that Registry.Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
IV. ISSUES ON REHEARING
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
Whether FERC’s ruling excluding state consumer advocate offices from the confidential information in the Large Load Registry unduly discriminates against state consumer advocate offices as compared to other entities entitled to access that information, contrary to the statutory requirements in…Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
V. REQUEST FOR REHEARING
printed heading · Topic match: Filing procedure
REQUEST FOR REHEARINGRead this passage Filed comments: Filing procedure
A. FERC’s failure to allow state consumer advocate offices access to the Large
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
The October 9 Order recounts PJM’s argument that the confidential information in the Registry must be available only to “‘as small a universe of entities as possible,’ while still making sure it is available to those who require access to implement their responsibilities, as well 20October 9 Order…Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
B. FERC’s exclusion of state consumer advocate offices from the confidential
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
FERC’s exclusion of state consumer advocate offices from the confidential information in the Large Load Registry unduly discriminates against these statutorily mandated consumer representatives.Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
C. FERC’s ruling is an unlawful unexplained departure from its rulings in the
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
The same is true of the state consumer advocate offices need to access the confidential information in the Large Load Registry.Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
VI. CONCLUSION AND PRAYER FOR RELIEF
printed heading · Topic match: Registry access
CONCLUSION AND PRAYER FOR RELIEF WHEREFORE, OCC respectfully requests that FERC reconsider its ruling in the October 9 Order.Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
printed heading
Dated in Washington, D.C., on this 9th day of November, 2026. /s/ Denise C.Read this passage