ER27-517-000 · 2026-11-16 · New York Independent System Operator, Inc.
NYISO files large-load integration procedures and market rules under section 205
Back to sections and commentaryPDF page 1
10 Krey Boulevard, Rensselaer, NY 12144
Ph: 518.356.6000 | Fax: 518.356.8899
Website: www.nyiso.com | LinkedIn: NYISO | Twitter: @NewYorkISO
November 16, 2026
Submitted Electronically
Honorable Debbie-Anne A. Reese, Esq.
Secretary
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
888 First Street N.E.
Washington, D.C. 20426
Re: New York Independent System Operator, Inc., Proposed Tariff Revisions to
Establish New Large Load Integration Procedures and Related Market
Participation Provisions, Request to Hold Show Cause Proceedings in Continued
Abeyance, and Request for One-Week Extension of the Comment Period, Docket
No. ER27-___-000
Dear Secretary Reese,
In accordance with Section 205 of the Federal Power Act (“FPA”)1 and Part 35 of the
Commission’s regulations,2 the New York Independent System Operator, Inc. (“NYISO”)
submits proposed revisions to its Open-Access Transmission Tariff (“OATT”) and Market
Administration and Control Area Services Tariff (“Services Tariff”).3 The proposed revisions
establish new Large Load Integration Procedures (“LLIP”) and related market participation
provisions. They are intended to fully satisfy the concerns raised by the Commission in its
Order Instituting Proceeding Under Section 206 of the Federal Power Act (“Show Cause
Order”)4 to the extent that they involve issues that are within the scope of the NYISO’s tariff
filing authority.5
The proposals in this filing are designed to account for issues and conditions in the
NYISO region. They build on the NYISO’s recently adopted Standard Interconnection
Procedures and on various NYISO-specific independent entity variations that are foundational to
the interconnection process in New York and that bring many benefits. They also: (i) address the
unprecedented near-term resource adequacy challenges, driven in large part by an expected
influx of large loads, that the NYISO now faces; (ii) leverage the NYISO’s existing “financial”
transmission reservation service model to maximize the benefits to flexible large loads and other
customers; and (iii) contain various mechanisms to protect customers.
The NYISO’s proposals recognize that NYISO is a single-state entity whose operational
boundaries coincide with the retail rate and resource adequacy jurisdiction of the New York State
1 16 U.S.C. § 824d.
2 18 C.F.R. § 35.
3 Capitalized terms that are not otherwise defined in this filing or in the proposed tariff revisions shall have
the meaning specified in the NYISO’s OATT or its Services Tariff.
4 N.Y. Indep. Sys. Operator, Inc., 195 FERC ¶ 61,216, at PP 3, 38 (2026) (“Show Cause Order”).
5 Consistent with Paragraph 41 of the Show Cause Order, this transmittal letter explains how the NYISO’s
specific proposals in this filing are responsive to the Show Cause Order’s various preliminary findings and
directives.
PDF page 2
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 2
Public Service Commission (“NYPSC”). The NYPSC has separately launched a proceeding to
address state-jurisdictional interconnection reforms that are likely to influence the evolution of
Commission-jurisdictional large load rules in New York.6
The NYISO’s proposal incorporates a compromise approach to resource adequacy
requirements, the State Exempt Load Project exception, that is intended to reconcile the
NYISO’s reliability responsibilities with the NYPSC’s resource adequacy authority in a manner
that is consistent with cooperative federalism principles.7 More generally, the NYISO has
carefully considered and sought to adhere to the Commission’s guidance on large load
jurisdictional issues and to respect both federal and state authority while still producing a
proposal that effectively meets the NYISO region’s needs.
Parts II and III of this transmittal letter describe the NYISO’s proposed new LLIP and
explain its benefits. Among other things, Parts II and III: (i) describe the NYISO’s proposed
definition of “Large Load,” which reflects minor changes to the Show Cause Order’s noted
version to reflect NYISO’s circumstances; (ii) incorporate clear and detailed large load
interconnection rules into the NYISO OATT; (iii) introduce transition rules that balance the
timely implementation of the new procedures while avoiding disruptions to existing commercial
arrangements that have achieved reasonable progress; (iv) promote timely Large Load
interconnections; (v) provide for new types of Commission-jurisdictional transmission services,
i.e, “Firm Withdrawal Service” and “Non-Firm Withdrawal Service”, that reflect the unique
characteristics of both the NYISO’s transmission model and of co-located Large Loads, Large
Load with behind the meter generation, and flexible Large Loads that are able to limit their use
of the system; (vi) delineate the division of responsibilities between the NYISO and
transmission-owning utilities under the LLIP; (vii) include detailed application and readiness
requirements to deter speculative projects that could unduly shift costs onto existing customers;
(viii) establish a Large Load Integration Study Process; (ix) address the identification and cost
allocation of upgrades; and (x) describe how alternative transmission technologies will be
considered.
Part IV of this transmittal letter describes the various new market participation provisions
that the NYISO is proposing to account for the proliferation of Large Loads and to support its
Large Load reforms. These proposals include revised and new market rules to govern: (i) Large
Loads eligible to be served via Firm Withdrawal Service, (ii) Large Loads or portions thereof
and an “Associated Resource(s)” that enter into a “Co-Located Arrangement” or “Partner
Resource Arrangement” so that the Large Load may be served via some amount of Firm
Withdrawal Service; (iii) Large Loads or portions thereof served via Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service and/or are designated Zero Withdrawal Service Loads; (iv) the co-location of Large
Loads with Supply.
6 See Proceeding on Motion of the Commission to Address Interconnection Reforms for Large Load, Order
Instituting Proceeding and Soliciting Comments, NYPSC Case No. 26-E-0045 (Feb. 12, 2026).
7 See Part II.G.ii.
PDF page 3
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 3
Within this framework, the NYISO would, among other things: (i) establish a rule under
which Non-Firm Withdrawal Service would be curtailed when the applicable nodal Locational-
Based Marginal Price (“LBMP”) for a Large Load reaches $200 MW/h; (ii) explain how
different categories of Large Loads will interact with the NYISO’s capacity market Demand Side
Resource rules; (iii) subject all Large Loads to fees and charges on a gross load basis; (iv) adopt
a System Reliability Benefit Fee applicable to Large Loads served by some amount of Non-Firm
Withdrawal Service to allocate costs to them that are roughly commensurate with the benefits
they receive from ICAP Resources and the value of the reliability services that they provide; (v)
apply certain data reporting requirements to all Large Loads; (vi) introduce a new Co-Located
and Limited Load Configuration market participation model; (vii) use Associated Resource rules
tied to NYISO Capacity Regions in lieu of the Show Cause Order’s “electrically proximate
resource;” (viii) address the extent to which Demand Side Resources and Aggregations may
become Associated Resources; (ix) enhance the NYISO’s DER and Aggregation participation
model rules; (x) sunset the NYISO’s existing BTM:NG Resource program; and (xi) update the
existing “buyer-side” capacity market power mitigation measures to reflect new issues presented
by Large Loads and emerging resource adequacy challenges in New York.
Part V explains why the NYISO is not proposing to adopt the three new transmission
services that the Commission established in the PJM Co-Location Order8 and provides additional
information regarding the benefits of the NYISO’s established financial transmission reservation
model and new Withdrawal Services.
New York’s Commission-jurisdictional transmission-owning utilities are concurrently
making separate FPA Section 205 filings to address Show Cause Order matters that fall under
their reserved filing rights. As discussed in Part VI of this transmittal letter, the traditional New
York Transmission Owners (“NYTOs”)9 are making a contemporaneous FPA Section 205 filing
that will propose various tariff revisions to the NYISO OATT, principally to Rate Schedule 5,
and add several new pro forma agreements to the NYISO OATT. Among other things the
NYTOs will submit a new two-party pro forma cost recovery agreement to address the cost-
shifting issues discussed in the Show Cause Order. The non-incumbent transmission owners
(“NTOs”)10 that were subject to the Show Cause Order will be making concurrent Section 205
filings to address matters that implicate their reserved filing rights and that reflect the structural
differences between them and the NYTOs. The NYISO believes that its Section 205 filing, in
combination with the NYTO’s and NTOs’, will address all of the issues raised by the Show
Cause Order.11
8 PJM Interconnection, L.L.C., 193 FERC ¶ 61,217 (2025).
9 The NYTOs include Central Hudson Gas & Electric Corporation; Consolidated Edison Company of New
York, Inc.; New York State Electric & Gas Corporation; Niagara Mohawk Power Corp.; Orange and Rockland
Utilities, Inc.; and Rochester Gas and Electric Corporation.
10 The NTOs include LS Power Grid New York Corporation I (“LS Power NY”) and New York Transco
LLC.
11 See Show Cause Order at P 38 (requiring the NYISO, NYTOs, and NTOs to collectively address issues
concerning, “(a) the application process, study procedures, and ongoing operational requirements that apply to
Eligible Customers seeking transmission service on behalf of large loads; (b) additional transparency concerning the
Network Upgrade costs to provide transmission service to Eligible Customers on behalf of large loads, a pro forma
PDF page 4
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 4
Part VII explains that the Commission should determine that this filing is just,
reasonable, and not unduly discriminatory and issue an order accepting it under the FPA Section
205 standard of review without requiring any modifications or additional procedures. At the
same time, the NYISO consents to the Commission’s exercise of its authority to modify or sever
any element of the NYISO’s proposed tariff revisions to the maximum extent permitted by law.
As noted below in Part VIII, the NYISO’s proposal has evolved substantially in response
to extensive stakeholder feedback. The NYISO’s proposed tariff revisions received the super-
majority stakeholder approval required under the NYISO’s shared governance model to
authorize its submission under FPA Section 205.
Part IX below explains that the NYISO is requesting a February 1, 2027 effective date for
the LLIP-related tariff provisions described in Parts II and III, June 1, 2028 for the Large Load
market participation provisions set forth in Part IV, and May 1, 2029 for the sunsetting of the
existing BTM:NG Resource program which is described in Part IV.I.
Consistent with the August 14, 2026 letter order (“Abeyance Order”)12 in the Show
Cause Order proceeding, the NYISO respectfully requests in Part X below that the Commission
hold the Section 206 proceedings initiated by the Show Cause Order in continued abeyance
pending action on this filing. If the Commission accepts this filing it should also issue an order
terminating the Show Cause Order proceeding with respect to the NYISO.13
Finally, the NYISO asks that the Commission briefly extend the comment period on this
filing from the standard twenty-one days to twenty-eight days. As noted in Part XI a modest
extension would provide interested parties with additional time to address the numerous,
complex, and consequential issues implicated by the NYISO’s proposals and by the Show Cause
Order. A one-week extension would also accommodate the Thanksgiving holiday and should
not hinder the Commission’s review because the NYISO’s earliest requested effective date is
more than two weeks after the end of the standard sixty-day notice period.
cost recovery agreement between NYISO, the relevant transmission owner and Eligible Customer taking
transmission service on behalf of the large load to mitigate the risk of cost shifting among transmission customers,
and a mechanism to ensure such payments are appropriately credited towards transmission owners’ transmission
revenue requirements consistent with the Commission’s cost-of-service regulations; (c) the rates, terms, and
conditions of service that apply to co-location arrangements; (d) transmission services that reflect Eligible
Customers taking transmission service on behalf of co-located loads, load with behind the meter generation, and
flexible large loads that are willing and able to limit their use of the transmission system under certain conditions;
and (e) the rates, terms, and conditions of service applicable to interconnection customers serving electrically
proximate large load or co-located load.”).
12 N.Y. Indep. Sys. Operator, Inc.,196 FERC ¶ 61,130 (2026) (“Abeyance Order”).
13 See Abeyance Order at P 12.
PDF page 5
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 5
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I.
DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED.............................................................................................. 9
II. The NYISO’s Proposed Tariff Revisions to Establish and Implement Large Load
Integration Procedures ............................................................................................................... 10
A.
Large Load ........................................................................................................................ 10
B.
Proposed New Transmission Services for Large Loads ................................................... 11
C.
Large Load Integration Procedures ................................................................................... 13
i.
Key Elements of the Large Load Integration Procedures ............................................. 13
ii.
Overview of Large Load Integration Procedures .......................................................... 18
D.
Scope and Effective Date of Large Load Integration Procedures ..................................... 21
i.
Application of Large Load Integration Procedures ...................................................... 21
ii.
Effective Date of Large Load Integration Procedures and Transition Requirements ... 22
iii.
Pre-Application Reports............................................................................................ 25
E.
Large Load Integration Study Process Start Date and Timeframe ................................... 26
i.
Large Load Integration Study Process Start Date ......................................................... 26
ii.
Large Load Integration Study Process Timeframe and Process Overlap ..................... 27
F.
Large Load Integration Request ........................................................................................ 28
i.
Application Process and Timeframe Requirements for Submission of Large Load
Integration Request ............................................................................................................... 29
ii.
Submission Requirements for Large Load Integration Requests ................................. 30
iii.
Review and Validation of Large Load Integration Requests .................................... 33
iv.
Study Agreement ...................................................................................................... 35
v.
Queue Position .............................................................................................................. 35
vi.
Modifications ............................................................................................................ 36
vii.
Withdrawal ................................................................................................................ 39
G.
Assessment of Reliability Impacts and Determination of Withdrawal Service ................ 40
i.
Determination of Withdrawal Service .......................................................................... 40
ii.
Resource Adequacy Impact Standard ........................................................................... 43
iii.
Transmission Security Standard ............................................................................... 48
H.
Initial Study Phase ............................................................................................................ 49
i.
Overview of New Study Process .................................................................................. 50
ii.
Initial Study Phase Overview ........................................................................................ 52
iii.
Resource Adequacy and Modeling Period ................................................................ 52
PDF page 6
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 6
iv.
RAMP Part 1 Process................................................................................................ 53
v.
SIS Entry Decision Period ............................................................................................ 56
vi.
RAMP Part 2 Process................................................................................................ 56
vii.
System Impact Study ................................................................................................ 57
viii.
ALI Entry Decision Period ....................................................................................... 59
I.
Assessment of Load Integration (“ALI”) and Facilities Study ......................................... 61
i.
Assessment of Load Integration.................................................................................... 61
ii.
Facilities Study.............................................................................................................. 63
iii.
Conclusion of Large Load Integration Study Process .............................................. 67
J.
Affected Systems .............................................................................................................. 67
i.
Coordination with Affected Systems within the New York Control Area ................... 67
ii.
Coordination with External Affected Systems ............................................................. 68
iii.
Study of Impacts to New York State Transmission System of an Affected System
Eligible Customer’s Proposed Interconnection to Another Region’s Transmission System 69
III. Post-Study Requirements ................................................................................................... 72
i.
Post-Study Agreements ................................................................................................. 72
ii.
Transmission Service Agreement for Firm and Non-Firm Withdrawal Service for
Large Loads .......................................................................................................................... 73
iii.
Large Load Performance, Protection and Control, and Monitoring Requirements .. 75
iv.
Status of Large Load Project and Associated Network Upgrades ............................ 77
B.
Additional Requirements .................................................................................................. 78
i.
Study Cost Allocation, Invoicing, and Deposit Requirements ..................................... 78
ii.
Confidentiality Requirements ....................................................................................... 80
iii.
Dispute Resolution Requirements............................................................................. 81
iv.
Third Party Conducting Studies ................................................................................ 81
v.
Additional Requirements .............................................................................................. 81
IV. The NYISO’s Proposed Tariff Revisions to Establish New Market Participation
Provisions Applicable to Large Loads ...................................................................................... 82
A.
Overview of Key Market Design Elements ...................................................................... 82
B.
Market Rules Applicable to Full Withdrawal Service and Limited Withdrawal Service
Loads ......................................................................................................................................... 85
i.
Firm Withdrawal Service Loads ................................................................................... 86
ii.
Limited Withdrawal Service Loads .............................................................................. 86
C.
Proposed Large Load Operating Requirements ................................................................ 98
PDF page 7
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 7
D.
Additional CLLC Rules .................................................................................................... 99
i.
Overview and Eligibility ............................................................................................... 99
ii.
CLLC-Specific Definitions ........................................................................................... 99
iii.
CLLC-Specific Metering and Telemetry Requirements ......................................... 101
iv.
CLLC-Specific Energy Market Rules ..................................................................... 101
v.
CLLC-Specific Capacity Market Rules ...................................................................... 103
vi.
CLLC-Specific Settlement Rules ............................................................................ 104
E.
Deviation Charges for CLLCs that Fail to Follow NYISO’s Dispatch Instructions ...... 105
i.
Overwithdrawal MW x Max (MPRCDAM, MPRCRT) x Length of Interval in seconds
3600 seconds ....................................................................................................................... 105
ii.
Underwithdrawal MW x Max (MPRCDAM, MPRCRT) x Length of Interval in seconds
3600 seconds ....................................................................................................................... 105
F.
The Associated Resource Arrangements and the Capacity Region Construct ............... 106
G.
DSR/Aggregation Rules.................................................................................................. 109
H.
DER Modeling Improvements and Baseline Enhancements .......................................... 111
I.
Sunsetting the NYISO’s BTM:NG Resource Program .................................................. 112
J.
Proposed Revisions to the NYISO’s Market Power Mitigation Measures ..................... 113
i.
Revisions to the “Buyer-Side” Capacity Market Power Mitigation Measures ........... 113
ii.
Additional Market Power Mitigation Measures Changes for CLLCs ........................ 116
V.
The NYISO's Proposals Build on the NYISO's Established Transmission Model and
Market Structures and Do Not Need to Incorporate the PJM Co-Location Order's
Tranmission Services ................................................................................................................ 116
A.
The NYISO’s Financial Transmission Service Model Enables the NYISO to Maximize
the Use of the Transmission System Efficiently and to Support Flexible Service for Large
Loads ....................................................................................................................................... 117
B.
The NYISO’s Financial Reservation Model Promotes Economic Efficiency in the Use of
the Transmission System and Resources ................................................................................ 119
C.
There Is No Need for the NYISO to Adopt the Transmission Services Established by the
PJM Co-Location Order .......................................................................................................... 121
VI. The NYTOs and the NTOs Are addressing certain show cause order issues in
Separate FPA Section 205 Filings ............................................................................................ 124
VII. The FPA Section 205 Standard of Review and Severability ......................................... 125
VIII.
Stakeholder Approval ........................................................................................... 126
IX. Requested Effective Dates ................................................................................................ 127
X.
Request to Continue Abeyance of Show Cause Proceedings ........................................ 127
PDF page 8
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 8
XI. Request for Extended Comment Period ......................................................................... 128
XII. Communications and Correspondence ........................................................................... 129
XIII.
Service .................................................................................................................... 129
XIV.
Conclusion ............................................................................................................. 130
PDF page 9
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 9
I.
DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED
The NYISO submits the following with this filing letter:
1. Affidavit of Thinh T. Nguyen (“Nguyen Affidavit”) (Attachment I);
2. Affidavit of Zachary T. Smith (“Smith Affidavit”) (Attachment II);
3. Affidavit of James Ross Altman (“Altman Affidavit”) (Attachment III);
4. Affidavit of Jonathan Newton (“Newton Affidavit”) (Attachment IV);
5. Affidavit of Dr. Scott M. Harvey (“Harvey Affidavit”) (Attachment V);
6. NYISO Large Load Integration Study Process (“LLISP”) Overview Figure
(Attachment VI);
7. Large Load Integration Study Process Cycle Figure (Attachment VII);
8. A clean version of the NYISO OATT Attachment LL sections containing the
proposed tariff revisions with an effective date of February 1, 2027 (Attachment
VIII);
9. A blacklined version of the NYISO OATT Attachment LL sections containing the
proposed tariff revisions with an effective date of February 1, 2027 (Attachment IX);
10. A clean version of the NYISO Services Tariff sections containing the proposed tariff
revisions with an effective date of February 1, 2027 (Attachment X);
11. A blacklined version of the NYISO Services Tariff containing the proposed tariff
revisions with an effective date of February 1, 2027 (Attachment XI);
12. A clean version of the remainder of the NYISO OATT sections containing the
proposed tariff revisions with an effective date of February 1, 2027 (Attachment XII);
13. A blacklined version of the remainder of the NYISO OATT sections containing the
proposed tariff revisions with an effective date of February 1, 2027 (Attachment
XIII);
14. A clean version of the NYISO Services Tariff sections containing the proposed tariff
revisions with an effective date of June 1, 2028 (Attachment XIV);
15. A blacklined version of the NYISO Services Tariff sections containing the proposed
tariff revisions with an effective date of June 1, 2028 (Attachment XV);
16. A clean version of the remainder of the NYISO OATT sections containing the
proposed tariff revisions with an effective date of June 1, 2028 (Attachment XVI);
PDF page 10
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 10
17. A blacklined version of the remainder of the NYISO OATT sections containing the
proposed tariff revisions with an effective date of June 1, 2028 (Attachment XVII).
II.
THE NYISO’S PROPOSED TARIFF REVISIONS TO ESTABLISH AND
IMPLEMENT LARGE LOAD INTEGRATION PROCEDURES
A.
Large Load
In the Show Cause Order, the Commission found that it would be reasonable to define a
large load as “a new commercial or industrial customer, located at a single site behind one or
more points of interconnection, and that has a peak load of 50 MW or greater and interconnects
to the transmission system at a voltage level of greater than 69 kV, and is not part of a co-
location arrangement.”14 The Commission stated that an “appropriate definition, including a
load size and interconnection voltage threshold, should be based on the characteristics of
NYISO’s transmission system.”15
The NYISO proposes to adopt the Commission’s definition of Large Load with certain
variations described below. In particular, the NYISO proposes to define Large Load for its
OATT and Services Tariff as follows:
Large Load shall mean a commercial or industrial Load located at a single site or
in close proximity, behind one or more Points of Interconnection, that has a peak
Load of 50 MW or greater connected to the New York State Transmission
System, which is subject to and has completed the applicable requirements of the
Large Load Integration Procedures in Attachment LL of the ISO OATT. For
purposes of this definition, Load shall be considered to be located “in close
proximity” if it: (i) is located within 2 miles and 2 electrical buses and (ii) is
electrically located in the same Capacity Region.16
First, the NYISO proposes to provide that the Load may be located either at a single site
or in close proximity. As indicated in the definition, the NYISO proposes to define “in close
proximity” to mean that the Load is both: (i) located within 2 miles and 2 electrical buses and (ii)
is electrically located in the same Capacity Region. Load projects could be spread across a
geographic area that necessitate more than one Point of Interconnection (e.g., data center
campus) and should be addressed as a single project in assessing their system impacts. The
requirement for both 2 miles and 2 buses constitutes a reasonable basis for defining close
proximity based on the different topography across the New York State Transmission System,
as: (i) there are parts of the system in which 2 buses are located many miles away from each
other (e.g. upstate New York), and (ii) additionally, there are parts of the system in which
numerous buses can be located within 2 miles (e.g. New York City). In addition, it is necessary
that a single Large Load be located within a single Capacity Region for purposes of the
14 Show Cause Order at P 64.
15 Id.
16 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.1 (definition of Large Load), 44.3.1.1; Services Tariff § 2.12 (definition
of Large Load)
PDF page 11
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 11
assessment of the reliability impacts of the Large Load, including accounting for any Associated
Resources.
Second, the NYISO proposes not to exclude load that is part of a co-location arrangement
as in the Commission’s definition. The NYISO proposes to establish specific requirements
concerning Co-Located Arrangements as described in Part IV.D.
Finally, for purposes of the transition requirements for load projects currently
participating in the NYISO’s existing load interconnection process, the NYISO proposes to
clarify that the requirements applicable to Large Loads in its tariffs apply to those load projects
that were subject to and completed the requirements in the Large Load Integration Procedures.
B.
Proposed New Transmission Services for Large Loads
The NYISO’s proposed rules for the participation of Large Loads in the ISO
Administered Markets vary depending on a Large Load’s Withdrawal Service(s)17
classification(s) as determined in the LLIP.18 Depending on the results of the LLIP, a Large
Load may be eligible to receive Firm Withdrawal Service19 and/or Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service20 and/or to be a Zero Withdrawal Service Load.21
The new Firm and Non-Firm Withdrawal Services are described in new Section 3A of the
NYISO OATT. They are new forms of Commission-jurisdictional Transmission Service with
terms and conditions that reflect the unique operational and reliability challenges that providing
transmission service to Large Loads presents to the NYISO system. These challenges are
described in the Altman Affidavit. In addition, as described in Part V below and in the Harvey
Affidavit the design of new Firm and Non-Firm Withdrawal Services is consistent with the
NYISO’s existing financial reservation transmission service model. The creation of the new
Withdrawal Services is responsive to the Show Cause Order’s preliminary finding that the
NYISO’s tariff appears to be unjust and unreasonable because it does not include transmission
services for Eligible Customers taking transmission service on behalf of Eligible Load, or on
17 See proposed Services Tariff § 2.23.
18 All Large Loads that are subject to the Large Load Integration Procedures as described in Part II.D.i must
complete the procedures set forth in Attachment LL of the OATT and meet the requirements, as applicable, to
receive Transmission Service under the OATT. See proposed Services Tariff § 4.1.6.
19 “Firm Withdrawal Service” shall be defined as “Transmission Service offered to a Large Load, or a
portion thereof, that does not cause adverse impacts to resource adequacy and/or transmission security.” See
proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.1 (definition of Firm Withdrawal Service).
20 “Non-Firm Withdrawal Service” shall be defined as “Transmission Service subject to dispatch
procedures offered to a dispatchable Large Load, or a portion thereof, that causes adverse impacts to resource
adequacy and/or transmission security.” See proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.1 (definition of Non-Firm
Withdrawal Service). The NYISO would also revise the definition of “Transmission Service” in existing OATT
§1.20 to account for and to reference the creation of the new “Withdrawal Services.”
21 A “Zero Withdrawal Service Load” shall be defined as “[a] Large Load or portion thereof that is not
authorized under the ISO OATT to withdraw Energy from the NYS Transmission System.” See proposed Services
Tariff § 2.26.
PDF page 12
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 12
behalf of flexible large loads that are willing and able to limit their use of the transmission
system under certain conditions.22
For convenience, this transmittal letter sometimes refers informally to the NYISO
providing Firm or Non-Firm Withdrawal Service “to” Large Loads or to Large Loads “taking” or
“receiving” them. Such references are meant to encompass instances where a Transmission
Customer is taking the services on a Large Load’s behalf in which a Large Load is acting as its
own Load-Serving Entity. They should not be construed as indicating that Firm or Non-Firm
Withdrawal Services are not Commission-jurisdictional forms of transmission service.
Firm Withdrawal Service would be available to Large Loads that are determined, through
the LLIP, not to cause adverse impacts or violations to resource adequacy or transmission
security or which adverse impacts or violations are mitigated as described in Part II.G.i.23
A Large Load, or any portion thereof, taking Firm Withdrawal Service will be able to use
the transmission system to serve its load in a price-agnostic manner and will be treated in the
same manner as other customers taking firm Transmission Service, including with respect to
curtailment priority. Firm Withdrawal Service will be subject to NYISO emergency operating
procedures, and Large Loads taking such service may be required to curtail for reliability needs
consistent with the priority treatment that load resources receive today.24 All requests for Firm
Withdrawal Service will have the same reservation priority, and Firm Withdrawal Service will
have the same priority as Firm Point-to-Point Transmission Service. Firm Withdrawal Service
will have priority over Non-Firm Withdrawal Service.25
Non-Firm Withdrawal Service would be made available to dispatchable Large Loads that
are deemed to cause violations or adverse impacts to resource adequacy and/or transmission
security, which violations or adverse impacts are not mitigated as described in Part II.G.i.26
Large Loads taking Non-Firm Withdrawal Service will be eligible to withdraw Energy from the
transmission system, subject to a bid cap and other necessary requirements.27 As described in
Part IV.B.ii.b, the NYISO proposes to use a mandatory bid cap of $200/MWh as the mechanism
to curtail Non-Firm Large Loads to avoid adverse impacts to the system. Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service will be subject to NYISO dispatch and emergency operating procedures.28
Zero Withdrawal Service Loads will be either (a) a Limited Withdrawal Service Load in
a Co-Located and Limited Load Configuration (“CLLC”), or (b) a Co-Located Located Load in a
Co-Located Local Generator Configuration (“CLGC”). Zero Withdrawal Service Loads will be
Large Loads that have not requested Withdrawal Service rights and will not be authorized to
withdraw Energy from the NYS Transmission System. As described in Part IV.B.ii.e, a Zero
22 Show Cause Order at PP 109, 112.
23 Proposed OATT § 1.6.
24 Id. § 3A.1.1.
25 Id. § 3A.3.
26 Id. § 1.14.
27 Id. § 3A.1.2.
28 Id. § 3A.1.2.
PDF page 13
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 13
Withdrawal Service Load will not participate in the markets but will still be subject to certain
requirements if participating under the CLLC model.
C.
Large Load Integration Procedures
In the Show Cause Order, the Commission found that, notwithstanding the NYISO’s
existing load interconnection requirements, the NYISO’s existing OATT appears to be unjust
and unreasonable because it does not include provisions that address with sufficient clarity and
consistency the study process for the provision of transmission service to Eligible Customers on
behalf of large loads, including the unique operational characteristics of large loads.29
The NYISO proposes to establish new Large Load Integration Procedures, which will be
located in Attachment LL to the OATT.30 The procedures include clear and detailed
requirements pursuant to which: (i) an Eligible Customer may submit a Large Load Integration
Request for the evaluation of the proposed interconnection of a Large Load Project to the New
York State Transmission System and (ii) the NYISO and Transmission Owners, as applicable,
will evaluate the proposed interconnection, identify any Attachment Facilities and Network
Upgrades required for the reliable interconnection of such project and their estimated costs and
schedule, and determine the project’s Firm Withdrawal Service or Non-Firm Withdrawal Service
amounts or, if requested, its eligibility to proceed as a Zero Withdrawal Service Load.
The NYISO highlights in Part II.C.i key elements of its proposed Large Load Integration
Procedures. The NYISO then provides a high-level overview of the new procedures in Part
II.C.ii and in the figure in Attachment VI. Finally, the NYISO describes the new procedures in
detail in Parts II.D through III, including demonstrating that the procedures are just and
reasonable and address the findings of the Show Cause Order in light of the NYISO’s distinct
planning framework and market structure, its role as a single-state independent system operator
(“ISO”), and other New York-specific conditions. The proposed procedures are supported by the
affidavit of Thinh T. Nguyen, NYISO Senior Manager of Interconnection Projects (“Nguyen
Affidavit”).
i.
Key Elements of the Large Load Integration Procedures
a)
Clear and Detailed Procedures
The NYISO proposes in this filing to establish new Large Load Integration Procedures as
described in detail in Parts II.D through III that set forth clear and detailed tariff requirements
concerning the application for and the study of the proposed interconnection of Large Load
Projects. The NYISO proposes that these new procedures replace its existing load
interconnection requirements set forth in Sections 3.9 and 4.5 of the OATT, subject to certain
transition requirements.
b)
Effective Date and Transition Process
29 Show Cause Order at PP 3, 46.
30 See proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.1 (definition of Large Load Integration Procedures).
PDF page 14
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 14
The NYISO proposes that the Large Load Integration Procedures have an effective date
of February 1, 2027, as described in Parts II.D.ii and IX. The NYISO also proposes to establish
transition rules that balance timely implementing the new requirements adopted in response to
Show Cause Order with minimizing disruptions to those projects that have already completed or
progressed to certain defined milestones in the NYISO’s existing load interconnection process.
As described in Part II.D.ii, the NYISO proposes to establish two transition groups – Transition
Group A and Transition Group B – for projects that meet the definition of Large Load and satisfy
certain tariff-prescribed milestones and requirements. Projects in Transition Group A must have
advanced at least as far as the facilities study stage under the existing rules by a tariff-prescribed
deadline and can elect to complete the load interconnection process under the NYISO’s existing
rules. Projects in Transition Group B must have advanced at least as far as the completion of the
system impact study by a tariff-prescribed deadline and can elect to enter the first Large Load
Integration Study Process under the new Attachment LL rules, which transition process will not
require the performance of a System Impact Study. Finally, the NYISO proposes additional
transition rules to facilitate the completion of certain ongoing system impact studies for
information purposes as described in Part II.D.ii.
The NYISO’s proposed transition framework—under which it seeks to balance parties’
expectations based on their relative progress against the proposal’s benefits and the need for
administrable deadlines—is supported by ample precedent. Market participants do not have a
reasonable expectation that market rules will remain unchanged.31 To the contrary, the
Commission has stated that “there is always risk that tariffs and regulations can change, which is
a risk that market participants take in a competitive market.”32 Consequently, where, as here,
revisions in a Section 205 proposal are filed prospectively, such revisions do not implicate the
filed rate doctrine or rule against retroactive ratemaking.33 Rather, the Commission balances any
settled expectations against the benefits of the proposal, and has accepted the revisions where the
benefits outweigh such expectations.34 As discussed in greater detail below, the NYISO’s
proposal reasonably accounts for parties’ expectations by establishing transition rules based on
each project’s relative stage of development, demonstrated commercial readiness, and size.35
This is consistent with the Commission’s directive to reasonably consider existing commercial
arrangements while drawing clear, administrable lines for the proposal’s effectiveness.
c)
Timeframe of Large Load Integration Procedures
The NYISO proposes a timeframe for the performance of the Large Load Integration
Study Process of between one year and six months and two years, including a 90-day period for
the performance of the System Impact Study, as described in Part II.E.ii The overall duration
depends on when a Large Load Project satisfies the application requirements for entry into the
31 See ISO New England Inc., 190 FERC ¶ 61,063 at P 35 (2025).
32 PJM Interconnection, LLC, 189 FERC ¶ 61,095 at P 72 (2024); see also PJM Interconnection, LLC, 190
FERC ¶ 61,084 at P 191 (2025) (“[I]interconnection customers are not entitled to any particular rules or processes as
of the date they submit an interconnection request. Neither the interconnection process, specifically, nor the tariff,
generally, is fixed in time at the point that a customer submits an interconnection request.”).
33 See PJM Interconnection, LLC, 190 FERC ¶ 61,084 at PP 189-93.
34 See ISO New England, LLC, 190 FERC ¶ 61,063 at P 34.
35 See Part II.D.ii.
PDF page 15
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 15
study. The timeframe constitutes a just and reasonable period of time for the NYISO,
Transmission Owners, and Eligible Customers to perform their respective responsibilities under
the proposed Large Load Integration Study Process as described in Part II.E.ii. These
responsibilities include performing preliminary analyses and assessing the feasibility of proposed
interconnections, studying the proposed interconnection of the Group of projects participating in
the study, including their impacts on the resource adequacy and transmission security of the
transmission system, identifying any Attachment Facilities and Network Upgrades required for
the reliable interconnection of such project, including determining and allocating the cost
estimates for such facilities, and determining the project’s Firm Withdrawal Service or Non-Firm
Withdrawal Service amounts or, if requested, its eligibility to proceed as a Zero Withdrawal
Service Load.
d)
Role of Transmission Owners
The NYISO proposes to allocate the scope of responsibilities in the Large Load
Integration Procedures between itself and the Transmission Owners as detailed in this filing
letter. The proposed allocation is similar to the allocation of responsibilities in the NYISO’s
existing load interconnection procedures. It accounts for the NYISO’s and Transmission
Owners’ respective planning responsibilities, system knowledge, and access to underlying
criteria and data. The parallel division of work will also allow the NYISO and the Transmission
Owners, working in parallel, to meet the proposed study timeframes and minimize inefficient
and duplicative analyses.
e)
Assessment of Reliability Impacts and Determinations of
Withdrawal Service
The NYISO proposes that the interconnection of Large Loads must not adversely impact
resource adequacy or transmission security. To assess the impacts of Large Loads on the
reliability of the New York State Transmission System, the NYISO proposes to establish a
Resource Adequacy Impact Standard as described in Part II.G.ii and a Transmission Security
Standard as described in Part II.G.iii. The NYISO and Transmission Owners, as applicable, will
apply these standards in evaluating the impacts of the proposed interconnection of Large Load
Projects.
The NYISO proposes to perform these evaluations for purposes of calculating a Large
Load Project’s amount of Firm Withdrawal Service and Non-Firm Withdrawal Service and, if
requested, its eligibility to be classified as a Zero Withdrawal Service Load. In making this
determination, the NYISO will account for available actions to mitigate any adverse reliability
impacts as described in Part II.G.i. In particular, a Large Load Project may mitigate its adverse
impacts to resource adequacy by associating with new supply – an Associated Resource – or by
taking sufficient Non-Firm Withdrawal Service. Further, a Large Load Project may mitigate its
adverse impacts on transmission security by agreeing to proceed with Network Upgrades that
address the violation or by taking sufficient Non-Firm Withdrawal Service. For certain
transmission security violations that can only be resolved with Network Upgrades, the Large
Load Project will be required to proceed with Network Upgrades.
PDF page 16
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 16
f)
State Exempt Large Load Projects
After considering comments expressed by the New York State Department of Public
Service (“NYDPS”) staff during the stakeholder process, the NYISO is proposing tariff language
under which it would not include Large Load Projects identified by the NYDPS in the standard
application of the NYISO’s Resource Adequacy Impact Standard.36 Such “State Exempt Large
Load Projects” would instead be eligible to receive Firm Withdrawal Service so long as their
collective impact did not cause a resource adequacy violation.37 This topic is discussed further in
Part II.G.ii below and in the Altman Affidavit.
g)
Application Process and Readiness Requirements
The NYISO proposes to establish in Attachment LL detailed application requirements for
a Large Load Project to participate in and advance through the Large Load Integration Study
Process. This includes requirements for the Eligible Customer to submit a Large Load
Integration Request, a non-refundable Application Fee, a Study Deposit, and additional
information and requirements as described in Part II.F.ii The NYISO must review and confirm
the customer’s satisfaction of these requirements for the Large Load Project to proceed in the
process. In addition, the NYISO proposes to establish readiness requirements for Large Load
Projects. This includes Site Control requirements that must be satisfied with the Large Load
Integration Request as described in Part II.F.ii.d and a Readiness Deposit that must be provided
for the project to enter the Assessment of Load Integration as described in Part II.H.viii. The
inclusion of Study Deposits, Site Control requirements, and Readiness Deposits will assist in
deterring speculative or duplicative submissions as contemplated by the Show Cause Order.38
h)
Study Process
The NYISO proposes to establish a Large Load Study Integration Process in the Large
Load Integration Procedures that establishes clear and consistent requirements for the evaluation
of proposed interconnections of Large Load Projects to the New York State Transmission
System. The NYISO proposes that this process include an Initial Study Phase as described in
Part II.H. This phase includes a Resource Adequacy and Modeling Period and a System Impact
Study, in which the NYISO and Transmission Owners, as applicable, will perform an initial
assessment of the proposed interconnection of a Group of Large Load Projects. This will include
applying the Resource Adequacy Impact Standard and Transmission Security Standard to assess
the impacts of the Large Load Projects on the New York State Transmission System and
evaluating whether the proposed interconnection of each Large Load Project is Physically
Infeasible. This study phase will provide Eligible Customers with an initial determination of
Attachment Facilities and Network Upgrades with preliminary estimates of the costs and
schedule for constructing these facilities, along with a preliminary determination of each Large
36 The NYISO’s stakeholders voted to approve the addition of these new provisions at the October 28th
Management Committee meeting.
37 The exclusion of State Exempt Large Load Projects only applies to the standard application of the
Resource Adequacy Impact Standard. Identified State Exempt Large Load Projects are still subject to the
Transmission Security Standard discussed further in Part II.G.iii below.
38 Show Cause Order at P 62.
PDF page 17
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 17
Load Project’s amount of Firm Withdrawal Service and Non-Firm Withdrawal Service and, if
requested, its eligibility to be classified as a Zero Withdrawal Service Load.
For Large Load Projects that elect to proceed in the study based on the results of the
Initial Study Phase, the NYISO proposes to perform an Assessment of Load Integration as
described in Part II.I.i that will evaluate the remaining projects applying the Resource Adequacy
Impact Standard and Transmission Security Standard. The NYISO will identify any violations
or adverse impacts on the Bulk Electric System and, if more than one project in the Group
contributes to a violation, then the NYISO will provide the Transmission Owner with the
projects’ respective contributions to the identified violation.
In parallel with this analysis, the applicable Transmission Owners will perform Facilities
Studies for the remaining Large Load Projects as described in Part II.I.ii to: (i) identify any
violations or adverse impacts on the non-Bulk Electric System and the Large Load Projects’
respective contributions to such violations and adverse impacts, (ii) develop Network Upgrades
to mitigate identified violations, (iii) develop the estimated cost and schedule to construct the
Network Upgrades, (iv) allocate the cost responsibility of Network Upgrades among Large Load
Projects in the Group based on their respective contributions to the violation or adverse impact,
(v) identify the Attachment Facilities required to reliably interconnect the Large Load Projects,
and (vi) develop the estimated costs and schedule to construct the facilities. Following the
performance of these analyses, the NYISO will post on its website a summary of each Large
Load Project’s required Network Upgrades, including their estimated costs, and each Large Load
Project’s final amount of Firm Withdrawal Service and Non-Firm Withdrawal Service and, if
requested, its eligibility to be classified as a Zero Withdrawal Service Load.
Finally, as described in Part II.J, the NYISO proposes to establish study requirements: (i)
to address the impact of Large Load Projects in New York on Affected Systems in New York
and on neighboring planning regions, and (ii) to address the impacts in New York of load
projects connecting to neighboring regions.
i)
Identification and Cost Allocation of Upgrades
The NYISO proposes that each Large Load Project participating in the Large Load
Integration Study Process will be responsible for the costs of the Attachment Facilities and
Network Upgrades identified for the safe and reliable interconnection of the project, which costs
will be allocated by the Transmission Owner in the Facilities Study. As described in Part II.I.ii,
at the conclusion of the Facilities Study, an Eligible Customer that intends for its project to
proceed must accept the cost allocation for its Large Load Project’s required Attachment
Facilities and Network Upgrades and provide the applicable Transmission Owner(s) with
security to cover its allocated costs. The Transmission Owners will address in their separate
Section 205 filing(s) the projects’ cost responsibility for the required facilities as set forth in the
appropriate agreements (e.g., cost recovery agreement, interconnection agreement, security
agreement).
PDF page 18
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 18
j)
Alternative Transmission Technologies
As described in Part II.I.ii.b, the NYISO proposes that the Transmission Owner, in
identifying Network Upgrades in the Facilities Study, consider whether an alternative
transmission technology could reasonably be implemented to address the identified violation or
constraint and determine whether the above technologies should be used consistent with Good
Utility Practice, Applicable Reliability Requirements, and Applicable Laws and Regulations,
including providing an explanation of the results for each technology. The alternative
transmission technologies include static synchronous compensators, static VAR compensators,
advanced power flow control devices, transmission switching, synchronous condensers, voltage
source converters, advanced conductors, and tower lifting.
k)
Transmission Services Agreement
As described in Part III.ii, the NYISO proposes to establish requirements for the Eligible
Customer and the Large Load Project (if the Large Load Project is not its own Eligible Customer
or Load Serving Entity) to enter into a Transmission Service Agreement with the NYISO for the
Large Load Project and proposes a pro forma Transmission Service Agreement.39
l)
Operational Requirements
As described in Part III.iii, the NYISO proposes to establish performance, protection and
control, and operating requirements for Large Load Projects. Further, the NYISO proposes to
establish a process as described in Part III.iii by which a project may request an exemption from
certain of these requirements.
m)
Adoption of Requirements from Standard Interconnection
Procedures
The NYISO proposes to include in the new Large Load Integration Procedures certain
process steps and requirements currently used in its Standard Interconnection Procedures for
generating facilities. For example, as described in Part II.H.iv, the NYISO proposes to provide
for the Transmission Owner to assess in the Initial Study Phase whether a project may not
interconnect due to physical infeasibility, so that such projects can withdraw without incurring or
causing significant costs, time, and resources. In addition, the NYISO proposes to use the same
or similar requirements as those included in its Standard Interconnection Procedures or
elsewhere in its tariffs for study cost allocation, invoicing and payment requirements,
confidentiality, dispute resolution, and other standard administrative provisions, which
requirements have previously been accepted by the Commission as just and reasonable.
ii.
Overview of Large Load Integration Procedures
39 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.14.2.
PDF page 19
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 19
The Large Load Integration Procedures are summarized as follows, which requirements
are described in detail in Parts II.D through III below, and are illustrated in the overview figure
provided in Attachment VI.
The procedures establish that an entity may request at any time information concerning
the proposed interconnection of a Large Load by requesting a Pre-Application Report as
described in Part II.D.iii below.
The procedures further establish the requirements for the recurring Large Load
Integration Study Process as described in Parts II.E through II.J below. To enter a particular
study process cycle, an Eligible Customer may submit a Large Load Integration Request for its
Large Load Project at any time, including an Application Fee, the Study Deposit 1, information
regarding any Associated Resources, a demonstration of Site Control, and all other required
information and materials as described in Part II.F.ii. The Eligible Customer must timely cure
any deficiencies identified by the NYISO, Connecting Transmission Owner, or Affected
Transmission Owner. If the Eligible Customer submits a valid Large Load Integration Request
and executes a Large Load Integration Study Agreement, the Large Load Project will be
included in the next available Group for participation in the study cycle.
The Large Load Integration Study Process will commence with the Initial Study Phase,
which will be performed in two successive rounds – Initial Study Round 1 and Initial Study
Round 2 – as described in Part II.H.ii. The Initial Study Round 1 will evaluate Large Load
Projects that satisfied the requirements to enter the study cycle prior to the deadline to enter
Group 1, and the Initial Study Round 2 will evaluate Large Load Projects that satisfied the
requirements to enter the study cycle after the deadline to enter Group 1, but prior to the deadline
to enter Group 2.
Each round of the Initial Study Phase will include both the Resource Adequacy and
Modeling Period (“RAMP”) and the System Impact Study (“SIS”). The RAMP, as described in
Part II.H.iii will include the following components: (i) the RAMP Part 1 Process, (ii) the SIS
Entry Decision Period, and (iii) the RAMP Part 2 Process. For the RAMP Part 1 Process, the
NYISO will preliminarily develop the base case for the System Impact Study, and the
Connecting Transmission Owners will prepare preliminary one-line diagrams that identify the
Attachment Facilities for the Large Load Projects. The Connecting Transmission Owner will
also conduct a Physical Infeasibility Screening of the proposed interconnections of the Large
Load Projects. Finally, the NYISO will perform a Resource Adequacy Evaluation to assess the
Large Load Projects using the Resource Adequacy Impact Standard. At the conclusion of the
RAMP Part 1 Process, the NYISO will commence the SIS Entry Decision Period in which an
Eligible Customer will elect for its Large Load Project either to proceed to the System Impact
Study or to withdraw from the Load Queue. The NYISO will then conduct the RAMP Part 2
Process to update the base case for the System Impact Study, to develop the scope of the System
Impact Study, and to conduct a Scoping Meeting with the Eligible Customers with Large Load
Projects in the Group that elected to proceed to the System Impact Study.
The NYISO will then perform the System Impact Study in coordination with the
Connecting Transmission Owners and Affected Transmission Owners as described in Part
PDF page 20
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 20
II.H.vii. The System Impact Study will assess the Large Load Projects using the Transmission
Security Standard. The Connecting Transmission Owner and Affected Transmission Owner will
preliminarily determine the Attachment Facilities and the Network Upgrades required for the
Large Load Project, along with non-binding cost estimates for such facilities, including such
facilities necessary for the Large Load Project to be eligible as a Zero Withdrawal Service Load,
if requested. The NYISO will preliminarily determine the amount of Firm Withdrawal Service
or Non-Firm Withdrawal Service for the Large Load Projects and, if requested, whether the
Large Load Project is eligible to be a Zero Withdrawal Service Load. The System Impact Study
results will be subject to stakeholder review and comment and must be approved by the
stakeholder Operating Committee. Following the completion of the draft System Impact Study
Report for Group 1 for the Initial Study Round 1, the NYISO will commence the Initial Study
Round 2 for Group 2, which will be performed in accordance with the same requirements as for
Group 1.
After the completion of the Initial Study Round 2 for Group 2, the NYISO will
commence the ALI Entry Decision Period as described in Part II.H.viii. For this decision period,
an Eligible Customer for a Large Load Project that participated in either the Initial Study Round
1 or the Initial Study Round 2 of the Initial Study Phase will either: (i) elect for its Large Load
Project to proceed to the Assessment of Load Integration and submit to the NYISO its Study
Deposit 2 and Readiness Deposit or (ii) withdraw its Large Load Project from the Load Queue.
The NYISO will then commence the Assessment of Load Integration (“ALI”) as
described in Part II.I.i for the Group of Large Load Projects that elected to proceed, while the
Connecting Transmission Owners and any Affected Transmission Owners will commence in
parallel the Facilities Studies for the Large Load Project(s) as described in Part II.I.ii. For the
ALI Part 1 Study, the NYISO will (i) evaluate the impact on the Bulk Electric System of the
proposed interconnection of the Large Load Projects using the Resource Adequacy Impact
Standard and the Transmission Security Standard, (ii) identify any violations or adverse impacts
caused by one or more of the Large Load Projects, (iii) if more than one project contributes to a
violation or adverse impact, identify and provide to the Transmission Owners the projects’
respective contributions to the identified violation, and (iv) update the amounts of Firm
Withdrawal Service and Non-Firm Withdrawal Service for each Large Load Project. During the
Facilities Study, each Connecting Transmission Owner and Affected Transmission Owner will
determine and cost allocate the Attachment Facilities and Local Network Upgrades and Non-
Local Network Upgrades to mitigate violations identified by the Connecting Transmission
Owner or Affected Transmission Owner on the non-Bulk Electric System, including facilities
necessary for the Large Load Project to be eligible as a Zero Withdrawal Service Load, if
requested. Where more than one Large Load Project contributes to a violation on the non-Bulk
Electric System, the Transmission Owner will determine the projects’ respective contributions.
Following the ALI Part 1 Study and the NYISO’s identification of any violations on the
Bulk Electric System and projects’ respective contributions to the violations, each Connecting
Transmission Owner and Affected Transmission Owner will determine the Non-Local Network
Upgrades to mitigate violations identified by the NYISO on the Bulk Electric System and the
cost allocation of each shared upgrade based on the projects’ respective contribution to the
violations provided by the NYISO for the Bulk Electric System or identified to the Transmission
PDF page 21
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 21
Owner for the non-Bulk Electric System. The NYISO will then confirm in the ALI Part 2 Study
the Non-Local Network Upgrades identified by the Transmission Owner, will designate the final
amounts of Firm Withdrawal Service and Non-Firm Withdrawal Service for each Large Load
Project, and will confirm eligibility to be classified as a Zero Withdrawal Service Load, if
requested. To proceed with its Large Load Project, the Eligible Customer must accept its cost
allocation for Attachment Facilities and Network Upgrades required for its project and post
related security to the applicable Transmission Owner(s). Following the NYISO’s completion of
the Assessment of Load Integration and the Transmission Owners’ provision of the final results
of the Facilities Study, the NYISO will post on its website a summary of: (i) the Network
Upgrades identified for each Large Load Project and their estimated costs and (ii) each Large
Load Project’s final amount of Firm Withdrawal Service and Non-Firm Withdrawal Service and
its eligibility to be classified as Zero Withdrawal Service Load.
Following the completion of the Large Load Integration Study Process cycle, the Eligible
Customer of a Large Load Project must enter into a security agreement, cost recovery agreement,
interconnection agreement and any construction agreements with, as applicable, the Connecting
Transmission Owner and any Affected Transmission Owners and Affected System Operators as
described in Part III.i. In addition, the Eligible Customer must enter into a Transmission Service
Agreement with the NYISO and the Large Load (if the Large Load is not its own Transmission
Customer or Load Serving Entity) concerning its amounts of Firm Withdrawal Service and Non-
Firm Withdrawal Service as described in Part III.ii.
D.
Scope and Effective Date of Large Load Integration Procedures
i.
Application of Large Load Integration Procedures
The NYISO proposes that the Large Load Integration Procedures apply: (i) to proposed
interconnections of a Large Load Project to the New York State Transmission System and (ii) to
proposals to make a Material Modification to an existing load or a Large Load Project
interconnected or seeking to interconnect to the New York State Transmission System.40 The
NYISO proposes to define a Large Load Project consistent with its definition of Large Load, as
described in Part II.A.41
The NYISO proposes to carve out of the Large Load Integration Procedures load projects
that are public safety facilities and providers of essential services (e.g., emergency medical
services, first responder facilities, or public water supply and treatment facilities), station service,
and Critical Electric System Infrastructure Loads.42 These facilities provide essential public-
safety or basic public-health services for which delays or service limitations could create
significant public welfare consequences. These projects will still be subject to the applicable
Transmission Owner’s load interconnection procedures, including any requirements concerning
safe and reliable service. In addition, the NYISO proposes that the procedures not apply to a
40 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.1 (definition of Large Load Integration Procedures), 44.3.1.1. The
requirements for modifications are described in Part II.F.vi.
41 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.1 (definition of Large Load Project), 44.3.1.1. Large Load Projects
include Computational Large Loads and Non-Computational Large Loads.
42 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.3.1.2.
PDF page 22
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 22
commercial or industrial Load proposing to connect or connecting to the Long Island
Transmission District system at a voltage of 69 kV and below.43 This exclusion accounts for the
Long Island Power Authority’s responsibilities concerning the Long Island Transmission District
and is consistent with the Commission’s proposal that large loads include load interconnecting to
the transmission system at a voltage level of greater than 69 kV.
A load project that is not subject to the Large Load Integration Procedures will be subject
to the load interconnection procedures of the Transmission Owner to which system it is seeking
to interconnect.44 In addition, the new procedures will not apply to the evaluation of the
interconnection of Associated Resources.45 Such resources will instead be assessed in the
applicable generation interconnection procedures or, for non-generation projects, the applicable
requirements for registering the resource.
ii.
Effective Date of Large Load Integration Procedures and Transition
Requirements
In the Show Cause Order, the Commission recognized that different large loads are
currently at different stages of existing interconnection processes and that large loads and
Eligible Customers taking transmission service on behalf of large loads are negotiating, entering
into, and/or have executed various agreements related to interconnecting to the transmission
system and/or the provision of transmission service.46 Accordingly, the Commission indicated
that any tariff revisions should “(a) propose a reasonable implementation period to ensure
minimal disruption to such existing commercial arrangements, and (b) allow a reasonable
amount of time to finalize ongoing agreements that are nearing completion as of the date such
Tariff provisions are filed with the Commission.”47 Further, the Commission indicated that
“[s]uch proposed Tariff revisions should include a reasonable effective date that accommodates
such considerations regarding these existing commercial arrangements.”48
The NYISO proposes that the Large Load Integration Procedures become effective on
February 1, 2027 as described in Part IX.49 Upon this effective date, the NYISO’s existing load
interconnection rules in Sections 3.9 and 4.5 of the NYISO OATT will no longer apply and the
existing load projects in the NYISO’s Queue will be withdrawn, except as otherwise provided in
the transition rules described below.50
As described below and in the Nguyen Affidavit, the NYISO proposes to establish
transition rules for existing load projects in its Queue that reasonably balance the timely
implementation of the new requirements adopted in response to Show Cause Order with
43 Id. § 44.3.1.3.
44 Id. § 44.3.1.4.
45 Id. § 44.3.1.4.
46 Show Cause Order at P 5.
47 Id.
48 Id.
49 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.2.1.
50 Proposed OATT §§ 3.9, 4.5.8, Attach. LL §§ 44.2.1, 44.4. The projects that remain in the Queue will be
subject to requirements in the new Attachment LL, except as otherwise indicated in the transition rules. Id. §
44.4.1.6.
PDF page 23
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 23
minimizing disruptions to existing projects that have already completed or progressed to certain
defined milestones in the NYISO’s existing load interconnection process.51
First, the NYISO proposes to retain the Queue Position of a load project in its Queue that,
as of the effective date of the new procedures, has completed the study process required by
Section 3.9 of the OATT, but has not yet entered service.52 These load projects have or are in the
process of entering into the applicable interconnection agreements and commercial
arrangements.
Second, the NYISO proposes to establish a transition group – Transition Group A – for
load projects that currently have a Queue Position, satisfy the definition of a Large Load Project,
and have met certain milestones and requirements that demonstrate substantial progress in the
existing interconnection process in Section 3.9 of the OATT.53 These projects have already
progressed to at least the facilities study stage of the existing process and have provided evidence
of their readiness to proceed. Moreover, as described in the Affidavit of James Ross Altman,
Senior Manager, Reliability Planning for the NYISO (“Altman Affidavit”), the resource
adequacy impacts for these projects have already been studied in the NYISO’s biennial
reliability assessment, which is pending approval with the NYISO’s Board of Directors, and such
impacts will be managed through the Reliability Planning Process.54 Accordingly, the NYISO
proposes that these projects may elect to complete the facilities study and proceed in accordance
with the existing requirements in Section 3.9 of the OATT.55
In particular, to proceed in Transition Group A, an existing load project that satisfies the
definition of a Large Load Project must satisfy or have satisfied all of the following
requirements: (i) has submitted an interconnection request before June 18, 2026, (ii) has received
Operating Committee approval of the scope of its system impact study before June 18, 2026, (iii)
has received Operating Committee approval of the report of its system impact study before
March 1, 2027, (iv) has one or more qualifying agreements before November 16, 2026,56 (v) has
an ongoing or completed facilities study with a Connecting Transmission Owner and any
Affected Transmission Owner before November 16, 2026, or a facilities study is not required for
its load project, and (vi) has posted security or made a milestone payment to the Connecting
Transmission Owner and any Affected Transmission Owner by March 1, 2027.57 A load project
that elects to proceed in Transition Group A to complete its evaluation in accordance with the
51 Nguyen Affidavit at PP 28-32.
52 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.4.1.1. There are not currently any existing load projects participating in
the OATT Section 4.5 load interconnection process.
53 Id. § 44.1 (definition of Transition Group A).
54 See Altman Affidavit at P 19.
55 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.4.1.2.
56 A qualifying agreement includes one of the following: (i) a study work agreement (not including the
study agreement for the system impact study), (ii) a support services agreement, (iii) a transaction form, (iv) a
master services agreement, (v) a cost reimbursement agreement, (vi) a facility study agreement, (vii) an
interconnection agreement, (viii) a development agreement, (ix) an engineering, procurement and construction
agreement, or (x) a security agreement. Id. § 44.4.1.2.1.
57 Id. § 44.4.1.2. To proceed in Transition Group A, the load project must have satisfied requirements (i),
(ii), (iv), and (v) at the time of the effective date of the new procedures and requirements (iii) and (vi) by March 1,
2027. Id.
PDF page 24
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 24
existing requirements in Section 3.9 of the OATT will be responsible for mitigating any
transmission security violations.58 That is, such load project that is assessed under the existing
tariff rules will be eligible for transmission service consistent with the NYISO’s existing tariff
requirements and will not be eligible to obtain Non-Firm Withdrawal Service or to be classified
as a Zero Withdrawal Service Load. The project may elect to instead enter Transition Group B if
it wants to obtain such alternative Withdrawal Service under the new tariff rules.
Third, the NYISO proposes to establish a transition group – Transition Group B – for
load projects that currently have a Queue Position, satisfy the definition of a Large Load Project,
and have met certain milestones in the existing interconnection process in Section 3.9 of the
OATT, but are not as far advanced in the existing process as projects eligible to participate in
Transition Group A.59 These projects have already progressed to at least the conclusion of their
system impact study in the existing tariff process and have provided evidence of their readiness
to proceed. The Transition Group B projects would be eligible to participate in the first Large
Load Integration Study Process – i.e., the Transition Large Load Integration Study Process.60
In particular, to proceed in Transition Group B, an existing load project that satisfies the
definition of a Large Load Project must satisfy or have satisfied all of the following
requirements: (i) has submitted an interconnection request before June 18, 2026, (ii) has received
Operating Committee approval of the scope of its system impact study before November 16,
2026, (iii) has received Operating Committee approval of the report of its system impact study
before June 1, 2027, (iv) has one or more fully executed qualifying agreements before June 1,
2027,61 and (v) does not satisfy the requirements to enter Transition Group A or has satisfied
these requirement but provides notice to the NYISO of its election to enter Transition Group B
instead to be eligible to obtain Non-Firm Withdrawal Service or, if requested, be eligible to be
classified as Zero Withdrawal Service Load.62
A load project that elects to proceed in Transition Group B may participate in the
Transition Large Load Integration Study Process. To do so, it must submit a Large Load
Integration Request as part of the transition process and will receive a new Load Queue Position.
The transition process will be largely consistent with the NYISO’s proposed standard Large
Load Integration Study Process, except that the transition process will not include a System
Impact Study (or the related requirements for developing such study) as the Transition Group B
projects would have already been subject to a system impact study under the Section 3.9
requirements.63
58 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.4.1.2.
59 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Transition Group B), 44.4.1.3.
60 Id. § 44.4.1.3.
61 See footnote 56 above.
62 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.4.1.3. To proceed in Transition Group B, the load project must have
satisfied requirements (i) and (ii) at the time of the effective date of the new procedures and requirements (iii), (iv),
and (v) by June 1, 2027. Id.
63 Id. § 44.4.1.3.1. As the Transition Group B projects were previously assessed in a system impact study,
an Eligible Customer for such project may not make certain modifications when it submits a Large Load Integration
Request for the project to participate in the transition process. In particular, the Eligible Customer may not make: (i)
any increase in the peak, gross load amount (i.e., MW or MVAR), or (ii) a change to the Point of Interconnection
PDF page 25
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 25
Finally, the NYISO proposes that it will proceed to complete a system impact study
under Section 3.9 of the OATT for information purposes for a load project if, prior to the
effective date of the Large Load Integration Procedures: (i) an Eligible Customer has submitted
an interconnection request for a load project that is smaller than 50 MW and (ii) the NYISO has
commenced the system impact study for the project.64 The NYISO would retain the load project
in the Queue for the duration of the system impact study and would withdraw the project from
the Queue upon the delivery of the study report to the Eligible Customer or termination of the
study. As the projects are smaller than 50 MW, they will not be eligible to proceed in the
NYISO’s new process, but the Eligible Customer may complete the system impact study to
obtain additional information concerning the proposed interconnection, which may benefit the
assessment of the load project in the applicable Transmission Owner’s load interconnection
procedures.
If an existing load project in the NYISO’s Queue does not satisfy one of the above
transition requirements, the NYISO will withdraw it from the Queue following the effective date
of the new Large Load Integration Procedures.65 If the withdrawn project satisfies the
requirements to participate in the new procedures, the Eligible Customer may reapply to
participate in the new Large Load Integration Study Process by submitting a Large Load
Integration Request in accordance with the rules described below.66 If the withdrawn project
does not satisfy the new requirements for participation in the Large Load Integration Study
Process, it must be evaluated in accordance with the applicable Transmission Owner’s load
interconnection procedures.67
iii.
Pre-Application Reports
The NYISO proposes to establish a process in the Large Load Integration Procedures by
which an entity may request a Pre-Application Report for information regarding the proposed
interconnection of a load project consistent with the definition of Large Load at a particular point
on the New York State Transmission System.68 The proposed process is based on and consistent
with the Pre-Application Report process in the NYISO’s Standard Interconnection Procedures in
Attachment HH of the OATT.69 It creates a mechanism by which a prospective Eligible
Customer may obtain information based on readily available data concerning potential Points of
Interconnection to enhance its ability to develop a Large Load Integration Request for a Large
Load Project. Based on the NYISO’s experience in its Standard Interconnection Procedures as
that has not been agreed upon by the Connecting Transmission Owner prior to submission of the Large Load
Integration Request. Id. § 44.4.1.3.2. An Eligible Customer seeking to make such changes may submit the project
anew for a subsequent Large Load Integration Study Process.
64 Id. § 44.4.1.4.
65 Id. § 44.4.1.5.
66 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.4.1.5.
67 Id.
68 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.1 (definitions of Pre-Application Report and Pre-Application Request
Form), 44.5.
69 OATT Attach. HH § 40.4.2. The Attachment HH process was based on the pre-application report
process that the Commission incorporated into the pro forma Small Generator Interconnection Process in its Order
No. 792. See Small Generator Interconnection Agreements and Procedures, Order No. 792, 145 FERC ¶ 61,159, at
PP 28-82 (2013), clarified, Order No. 792-A, 146 FERC ¶ 61,214 (2014).
PDF page 26
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 26
described in the Nguyen Affidavit, the Pre-Application Report process has improved the
applications submitted by Interconnection Customers, reducing deficiencies in the initial
submissions and identifying early in the process potential issues with Points of Interconnection
and whether the interconnection is subject to the NYISO’s procedures.70
The NYISO proposes that an entity be able to request at any time a Pre-Application
Report by submitting: (i) a Pre-Application Request Form in the form set forth in Appendix 2 to
Attachment LL to request information for a single Point of Interconnection and (ii) a non-
refundable pre-application fee of $5,000.71 Upon the NYISO’s receipt of the completed form
and application fee, the NYISO will provide the information to the applicable Transmission
Owner within 5 Business Days.72 Once the Transmission Owner confirms within 5 Business
Days that it is the appropriate Connecting Transmission Owner for the Point of Interconnection
and identifies any Affected Transmission Owners to the extent known at that time, it will
coordinate with the requesting entity and any Affected Transmission Owner for a pre-application
scoping meeting.73 Within 25 Business Days of this scoping meeting, the Connecting
Transmission Owner will complete, in coordination with any Affected Transmission Owner(s),
and return the Pre-Application Report.74
The Pre-Application Report will be in the form set forth in Appendix 2 to Attachment LL
as completed using readily available data to the extent available.75 This pre-application process
is not a mandatory step for an Eligible Customer to proceed into the Large Load Integration
Process and is solely for information purposes and is non-binding.76 The Eligible Customer will
be informed if the proposed interconnection is not subject to the Large Load Integration
Procedures, and the information report will be completed to the extent possible.77
E.
Large Load Integration Study Process Start Date and Timeframe
i.
Large Load Integration Study Process Start Date
The NYISO proposes to commence the Transition Large Load Integration Study Process,
which is applicable to participants in Transition Group B, on June 1, 2027.78 The NYISO
proposes to then commence the first regular Large Load Integration Study Process on July 1,
70 Nguyen Affidavit at P 18.
71 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.5.1.1. The entity may submit additional request forms and fees to
request information about additional Points of Interconnection. Id. The application fee will be divided 25% to the
NYISO and 75% to the Connecting Transmission Owner. Id. § 44.5.1.2.
72 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.5.1.2. If the Transmission Owner is not the appropriate Connecting
Transmission Owner, the NYISO will provide the form to the appropriate Connecting Transmission Owner within 5
Business Days. Id. § 44.5.1.3.
73 Id. The requesting entity will be required to execute any confidentiality or non-disclosure agreement
required by the applicable Transmission Owner for the disclosure of information concerning its system. Id.
74 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.5.1.3.
75 Id. § 44.5.1.4.
76 Id. §§ 44.5.1.4 and 44.5.1.5.
77 Id. § 44.5.1.4.
78 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Transition Large Load Integration Study Process Start Date), 44.6.1.1.
PDF page 27
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 27
2027.79 The NYISO will commence each subsequent Large Load Integration Study Process on
the latter of: (i) one year after the start date of the previous Large Load Integration Study
Process, or (ii) the first Calendar Day of the next month following the completion of the most
recent ongoing or completed Assessment of Load Integration and Facilities Study.80 The
proposed mechanism for establishing the start date will allow for an end-to-end process whereby
the Assessment of Load Integration must be completed for the Group of Large Load Projects
participating in each study cycle, including the determination of their cost allocation and
provision of security, prior to the commencement of the next Assessment of Load Integration.
This will ensure greater certainty concerning process results and reduce potential issues that can
arise from the overlapping study work.
ii.
Large Load Integration Study Process Timeframe and Process Overlap
The NYISO proposes a timeframe of between approximately one year and six months
and two years for the performance of the Large Load Integration Study Process cycle, which
includes a 90-day time period to perform the System Impact Study. The overall process
timeframe for a particular Large Load Project will depend on when the Eligible Customer has
satisfied the application requirements for its project to enter the study cycle. The time period
includes the two rounds of the Initial Study Phase for the study cycle, which require
approximately six months each, and then the performance of the Assessment of Load Integration
and Facilities Study, which are performed in parallel and require approximately one year.81 The
proposed timeframe is illustrated in the figure provided in Attachment VII.
The NYISO acknowledges that the proposed timeframe is longer than the process
duration contemplated by the Show Cause Order.82 However, the timeframe constitutes a just
and reasonable period of time in light of the scope of the Large Load Integration Study Process
and ensures that the NYISO, Transmission Owners, and Eligible Customers are able to perform
their respective responsibilities under this process. As detailed in the Nguyen Affidavit, the
79 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Large Load Integration Study Process Start Date), 44.6.1.2. The duration of the
Initial Study Phase for the Transition Large Load Integration Study Process will be shorter than for a subsequent
process because there will not be a System Impact Study for the transition process. Accordingly, the NYISO is able
to commence the first regular Large Load Integration Study Process a month following the start of the transition
process. The NYISO will complete the Assessment of Load Integration for the Transition Large Load Integration
Study Process prior to the commencement of the Assessment of Load Integration for the subsequent Large Load
Integration Study Process.
80 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.6.1.2.
81 If a Large Load Project enters in the second round of the Initial Study Phase (i.e., Initial Study Round 2),
the overall process duration for its project would be approximately one year and six months.
82 The Show Cause Order proposes a process duration of 60 to 90 calendar days, resulting in a study that
includes any Direct Assignment Facilities and Network Upgrades necessary to accommodate the transmission
service request as well as a non-binding good-faith estimate of the cost and the time to construct such facilities.
Show Cause Order at P 69. However, the Commission did not detail in the Show Cause Order the scope of the
study work that permitted that duration. The Commission did reference Southwest Power Pool’s (“SPP”) 90-day
timeframe for its High Impact Large Load (“HILL”) process as an example of the 90-day duration. However, the
SPP study is an individual study with non-binding results. SPP has noted that cluster studies may be needed if the
volume of large loads becomes large and that such cluster studies will take longer than 90 days, including to address
the impacts of customers withdrawing. Comments of Southwest Power Pool, Inc., Interconnection of Large Loads to
the Interstate Transmission System, FERC Docket No. RM26-4-000 at 18 (Nov. 21, 2025) (“SPP Comments”).
PDF page 28
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 28
NYISO developed the timeframes for the different study elements, in coordination with the
Transmission Owners, based on their extensive experience in performing similar administrative
and study work in the existing load interconnection procedures, their performance of comparable
study work and process steps in the NYISO’s Standard Interconnection Procedures for generator
interconnections, and reasonable estimates of the time required to address new process elements
required to account for the analyses contemplated by the Show Cause Order and process
enhancements detailed in this filing.83
The timeframes also account for sufficient time for Eligible Customers to participate in a
scoping meeting, to review and comment on study results in the different study phases, and to
make informed business decisions on whether to proceed with their projects to subsequent study
phases. In addition, this timeframe will provide opportunities for stakeholder review and input in
the process. Finally, while the grouping of Large Load Projects into consolidated studies will
provide for a more efficient overall process that improves the identification of upgrades across
the interconnecting projects than through the performance of overlapping individual studies,
assessing projects on a group basis increases the complexity in preparing the studies and the
technical analyses with a resulting increase on the time required to perform the studies. This
includes the time required to account for the impacts of projects withdrawing from a Group
during the study process or at one of the decision points.
The NYISO also proposes that the performance of a given Large Load Integration Study
Process overlap with the performance of elements of the prior Transition Large Load Integration
Study Process or Large Load Integration Study Process.84 In particular, the NYISO proposes to
perform the two rounds of the Initial Study Phase of a given Large Load Integration Study
Process cycle in parallel with the performance of the Assessment of Load Integration and
Facilities Study stages of the prior study cycle. This will enable the NYISO to commence the
assessment of additional load projects approximately every six months while completing the
study work for the prior study cycle.
The NYISO proposes to establish in Attachment LL certain tariff-prescribed timeframes
for elements of the Large Load Integration Study Process as described throughout this filing. If
the NYISO, Connecting Transmission Owner, Affected Transmission Owner, or Affected
System Operator is unable to complete an individual component of the process in accordance
with that component’s timeframe established in Attachment LL, the NYISO proposes that the
entity responsible for performing that component will complete it as soon as practicable, and the
NYISO will notify Eligible Customers of any anticipated resulting delay in the overall timeframe
of the study process.85
F.
Large Load Integration Request
In the Show Cause Order, the Commission highlighted the absence of certain process
elements in the existing load interconnection process in the NYISO’s OATT. In particular, the
Commission indicated the absence of: “(i) an application process that accepts Eligible
83 Nguyen Affidavit at P 11-17.
84 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.6.1.2.
85 Id. § 44.6.1.3.
PDF page 29
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 29
Customers’ applications for transmission service on behalf of large loads on a rolling basis, (2) a
non-refundable application fee, and sufficient readiness requirements that escalate at distinct
phases of the study process to deter duplicative or speculative requests for transmission service
(e.g. meaningful milestones and/or financial commitments); and (3) information and data
requirements that Eligible Customers must submit to NYISO and/or the Transmission Owners
regarding the characteristics of the large load on behalf of which the Eligible Customer is taking
transmission service, including disclosure to NYISO of any substantially similar pending
transmission service requests on behalf of the same large load customer.” 86
The NYISO proposes to establish an application process, along with fees, deposits, and
information and data requirements for its Large Load Integration Process that address the
Commission’s findings concerning the existing tariff rules.
i.
Application Process and Timeframe Requirements for Submission of Large
Load Integration Request
The NYISO proposes to require that an Eligible Customer submit a Large Load
Integration Request and satisfy additional entry requirements for a Large Load Project to enter a
Large Load Integration Study Process.87 For purposes of the Transition Large Load Integration
Study Process, the NYISO proposes to establish an application window that commences on
March 1, 2027, and concludes on May 31, 2027, during which a project in Transition Group B
may satisfy the requirements to enter the study process.88 The NYISO proposes to separately
begin accepting Large Load Integration Requests on April 1, 2027, for Large Load Projects that
intend to enter the first regular Large Load Integration Study Process or subsequent processes.89
Beginning on that date, an Eligible Customer may submit a Large Load Integration Request at
any time.90
Starting with its first Large Load Integration Study Process after the transition process,
the NYISO proposes to include a Large Load Project with a validated Large Load Integration
Request and an executed Large Load Integration Study Agreement into the next available Group
of projects (i.e., Group 1 or Group 2) that will be evaluated in a Large Load Integration Study
Process.91 In particular, the NYISO will include a Large Load Project in Group 1 for the Initial
Study Round 1 of a given study process if the project has not yet been included in a Group
evaluated in a previous Large Load Integration Study Process cycle and has satisfied the
requirements to enter a Group prior to the deadline for entering Group 1.92 The NYISO will
include a Large Load Project in Group 2 for the Initial Study Round 2 if the project has satisfied
86 Show Cause Order at P 65.
87 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.6.2.1.
88 Id. § 44.4.1.3.1.
89 Id. §§ 44.6.1.2, 44.6.2.1.
90 Id. § 44.6.2.1.
91 Id. § 44.6.2.2.
92 Id. § 44.6.2.2.
PDF page 30
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 30
the requirements for entering a Group after the deadline to enter Group 1, but prior to the
deadline to enter Group 2.93
ii.
Submission Requirements for Large Load Integration Requests
The NYISO proposes that an Eligible Customer be required to submit the following
information and data, fees, and deposits for purposes of entering the Large Load Integration
Study Process.
a)
Request Form
The Eligible Customer must submit a completed Large Load Integration Request in
accordance with the form established in Appendix 1 to Attachment LL.94 The standard form
provides for the Eligible Customer to submit information required for the evaluation of the Large
Load Project in the Large Load Integration Study Process, including information regarding the
project’s size, its proposed Point of Interconnection, its association with any Associated
Resources, the expected nature of the load project, modeling and operational data, and evidence
of its satisfaction of the additional project entry requirements (e.g., Application Fee, Study
Deposit, Site Control).95 In addition, consistent with the requirements in the NYISO’s
Interconnection Request form for its Standard Interconnection Procedures,96 the Large Load
Integration Request includes an attestation form affirming the accuracy of the submitted
information and Eligible Customer’s responsibility for study costs, including costs incurred prior
to the full execution of the Large Load Integration Study Agreement.
The Show Cause Order identified the lack of requirements in the NYISO’s existing tariffs
for an Eligible Customer’s disclosure to the NYISO of any substantially similar pending
transmission service requests on behalf of the same large load customer.97 The NYISO proposes
to clarify as part of the Large Load Integration Request requirements that an Eligible Customer,
or an Eligible Customer and one of its Affiliates, cannot submit a request for a mutually
exclusive Large Load Project with a Large Load Project in the Load Queue or with a project for
which a Large Load Integration Request has been submitted and the NYISO is evaluating for
purposes of validation.98 This is necessary to deter speculative Large Load Integration Requests,
including Eligible Customers proposing multiple variations of proposed interconnections.99 In
addition, this is required to enable the identification of physically infeasible projects. The
NYISO’s proposed approach is consistent with its restriction of the submission of mutually
exclusive Interconnection Requests in its Standard Interconnection Procedures.
b)
Application Fee
93 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.1 (definition of Large Load Integration Request), 44.6.2.2.
94 Id. § 44.6.3.1.
95 Id. § 44.16.1.
96 Id. § 40.25.1.
97 Show Cause Order at P 65.
98 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.6.3.1.
99 Eligible Customers can use the NYISO’s proposed Pre-Application Report process to obtain information
concerning alternative Points of Interconnection prior to submitting a Large Load Integration Request.
PDF page 31
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 31
The Eligible Customer must submit a non-refundable Application Fee in cash in the
amount of $10,000 to account for expenses incurred in assessing the Large Load Integration
Request.100 As described in the Nguyen Affidavit, the proposed Application Fee aligns with the
expense of assessing applications and is consistent with the Application Fee used in the NYISO’s
Standard Interconnection Procedures.101
c)
Study Deposit
The Eligible Customer must submit certain Study Deposits for the Large Load Integration
Study Process. As described in Part III.B.i.c, the NYISO proposes to hold the Study Deposit for
the duration of the Eligible Customer’s participation in the study process until the settlement of
the final invoice and will only draw on such deposit if the Eligible Customer fails to timely pay
its invoice for study costs.102
As part of its submission of its Large Load Integration Request, an Eligible Customer
must submit the first study deposit – Study Deposit 1 – in the following amounts based on the
size of its load project and whether the project is participating in the Transition Large Load
Integration Study Process or a subsequent Large Load Integration Study Process.103
Load Project Size
Deposit for Large Load
Integration Study Process
Deposit for Transition
Large Load Integration
Study Process
Less than 200 MW
$100,000
$200,000
Less than 500 MW and
greater than or equal to 200
MW
$150,000
$250,000
Greater than or equal to 500
MW
$200,000
$300,000
The deposit amount is higher for participants in the Transition Large Load Integration Study
Process as such projects are not subject to a System Impact Study, and instead proceed to the
more extensive Assessment of Load Integration following the completion of the Resource
Adequacy and Modeling Period. A participant in the Large Load Integration Study Process other
than the transition process will be required to submit an additional study deposit – Study Deposit
2 – to increase its study deposit amount to the higher deposit amount if it elects for its project to
proceed to the Assessment of Load Integration as described in Part II.H.viii.
As described in the Nguyen Affidavit, the NYISO developed the study deposit amounts
based on its experience in conducting its current load interconnection process and similar study
work in its Standard Interconnection Procedures. Under its existing rules, a load project must
100 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.1 (definition of Application Fee), 44.6.3.2. The $10,000 amount will
be allocated 75% to the NYISO and 25% to the Connecting Transmission Owner. Id.
101 Nguyen Affidavit at P 19; see also OATT Attach. HH § 40.5.5.1.3.
102 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.1 (definition of Study Deposit 1), 44.6.3.3., 44.15.4.3.3.
103 Id. § 44.6.3.3.
PDF page 32
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 32
provide a study deposit of $150,000.104 While this reasonably covers the costs of the study work
for a system impact study under the current process, the NYISO anticipates that there will be
increased study costs going forward due to more complex studies resulting from more MWs
being introduced into the system model. As described in the Nguyen Affidavit, with system
models more constrained, the study work is more complex requiring more engineering work to
complete and, as a result, additional study costs.105 Consistent with its Study Deposit
requirements in its Standard Interconnection Procedures, the NYISO proposes to assess different
study deposit amounts based on project size to account for the more significant impacts of higher
MW projects.106
These study deposits will not apply to the Facilities Study, which will be addressed
through separate requirements between the Eligible Customer and the applicable Transmission
Owner(s).
d)
Readiness Requirements/ Site Control
In the Show Cause Order, the Commission indicated that clear and consistent study
procedures could include readiness requirements (i.e. meaningful milestones and/or financial
commitments) to help ensure that Eligible Customers’ requests for transmission service on behalf
of large loads are more viable and more likely to materialize as planned, given that they must
meet specific milestones and/or pay costs to proceed.”107
The NYISO proposes two mechanisms for the Eligible Customer to demonstrate the
readiness of its project – (i) a demonstration of full Site Control for the Large Load with the
Large Load Integration Request108 and (ii) a Readiness Deposit during the ALI Entry Decision
Period, which is described in Part II.H.viii. As described in the Nguyen Affidavit, an Eligible
Customer’s satisfaction of these requirements provides reasonable evidence of meaningful
progress and financial commitment in the development of the Large Load Project.109
For purposes of the Site Control requirements, the NYISO proposes to define Site
Control consistent with its definition in its Standard Interconnection Procedures adopted in
response to Order No. 2023.110 To satisfy the Site Control requirement, the Eligible Customer
104 Nguyen Affidavit at P 21. In the NYISO’s Standard Interconnection Procedures, the Study Deposit
amount is based on the facility size and ranges from $100,000 for a Facility smaller than 80 MW, to $150,000 for a
Facility greater than or equal to 80 MW and smaller than 200 MW, to $250,000 for a Facility greater than or equal
to 200 MW. See OATT Attach. HH § 40.5.5.1.4.
105 Nguyen Affidavit at P 22.
106 Notwithstanding the Study Deposit amounts, the NYISO will allocate study costs to the particular Large
Load Project responsible for such costs in accordance with cost causation principles as described in Part III.B.i.a).
See Nguyen Affidavit at P 23.
107 Show Cause Order at P 62.
108 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.6.3.4.
109 Nguyen Affidavit at P 25.
110 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.1 (definition of Site Control). In particular, Site Control
“shall mean the necessary land right sufficient to develop, construct, operate, and maintain the Large Load
Project over a term of at least ten (10) years from the date of the submission of the Large Load Integration
Request. Site Control may be demonstrated by documentation establishing: (1) ownership of, a leasehold
interest in, or a right to develop a site of sufficient size to construct and operate the Large Load Project; (2)
PDF page 33
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 33
must submit: (i) the materials demonstrating Site Control permitted by the NYISO’s procedures,
(ii) an attestation in a form to be set forth in the NYISO’s procedures from an officer of the
company indicating the amount of acreage required for the Large Load Project and that such
acreage amount is covered by the submitted Site Control materials, and (iii) a licensed
professional engineer (electrical or civil) signed and stamped site plan that depicts that the Site
Control provided by the Eligible Customer can support the proposed arrangement of the Large
Load Project.111
e)
Additional Submission Requirements
The Eligible Customer must indicate whether it will be using an Associated Resource as
further described in Part II.G.i.a.112 If so, the Eligible Customer must submit to the NYISO an
Associated Resource Attestation Form in the form set forth in Appendix 7 to this Attachment
LL.113 The form must be executed by both representatives of the Large Load Project and the
Associated Resource and indicate their intent to enter into, as applicable, a Partner Resource
Arrangement or a Co-Located Arrangement.114
In addition, as described in Part III.iii, an Eligible Customer for a Non-Computational
Large Load may request an exemption from certain performance or protection and control
requirements and provide the necessary information for such exemption.115 The Eligible
Customer must request such exemption through either its Large Load Integration Request or a
subsequent modification request.116
Finally, an Eligible Customer must indicate whether it is eligible to be a State Exempt
Large Load Project as described in Part II.G.ii.b, in which case it must submit a State Exempt
Large Load Project Verification through either its Large Load Integration Request or in the ALI
Entry Decision Period.117
iii.
Review and Validation of Large Load Integration Requests
The NYISO proposes to establish requirements for the review and validation of Large
Load Integration Requests. These requirements reflect the NYISO’s experience in reviewing
and validating Interconnection Requests for its Standard Interconnection Procedures.
an option to purchase or acquire a leasehold site of sufficient size to construct and operate the Large Load
Project; or (3) any other documentation that clearly demonstrates the right of Eligible Customer to occupy a
site of sufficient size to construct and operate the Large Load Project. The term “necessary land right”
restricts the use of the site for mutually exclusive projects, but does not restrict multi-use applications of the
site in addition to its use for the Large Load Project, such as agriculture, ranching, etc.”
111 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.6.3.4.
112 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Associated Resource), 44.6.3.5.
113 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Associated Resource Attestation Form), 44.6.3.5.
114 Id. § 44.6.3.5.
115 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Non-Computational Large Load), 44.6.3.6, 44.14.3.4.
116 Id. § 44.14.3.4.
117 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.6.3.7, 44.10.4.1.
PDF page 34
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 34
A Large Load Integration Request will not be considered to be a valid request until the
NYISO has confirmed all of the tariff required items.118 Within 5 Business Days of its receipt of
a Large Load Integration Request submission that includes all of the required items, the NYISO
will (i) acknowledge receipt of the request, (ii) confirm receipt of the Application Fee and Study
Deposit 1, (iii) identify the Connecting Transmission Owner(s) with which the Large Load is
proposing to connect and any Affected Transmission Owner(s) and Affected Systems that the
NYISO is aware of, and (iv) make available the information submitted with the Large Load
Integration Request and its acknowledgement to the Connecting Transmission Owner(s) and any
identified Affected Transmission Owner(s) and Affected Systems.119 Within this same time
period, the Connecting Transmission Owner identified by the NYISO must confirm it is the
appropriate Connecting Transmission Owner and confirm the appropriate Affected Transmission
Owner(s) and Affected Systems.120
Within 15 Business Days of the conclusion of the initial 5 Business Day period, the
NYISO will confirm whether all of the elements of the Large Load Integration Request comply
with the tariff requirements and review the provided modeling data and models.121 Within this
period, the NYISO will notify the Eligible Customer whether its Large Load Integration Request
is valid or includes any deficiencies.122 The Eligible Customer must provide the NYISO with
information required to address a deficiency within 10 Business Days after receipt of such
notice.123 Within 10 Business Days of this submission, the NYISO will review and, if it
determines the identified deficiency has not been addressed, will notify the Eligible Customer of
the remaining deficiency, which the Eligible Customer must address pursuant to the same
process as the initially identified deficiencies.124 If the NYISO determines that Eligible
Customer’s Large Load Integration Request is valid or that the Eligible Customer has addressed
any deficiencies within the required timeframe, the NYISO will notify the Eligible Customer that
the Large Load Integration Request is valid, and such request will proceed as part of the Load
Queue.125
The NYISO will maintain on its OASIS or publicly accessible portion of its website a list
of all valid Large Load Integration Requests, including whether a Large Load Project is a State
Exempt Large Load Project.126 If the Eligible Customer fails to submit additional information
118 Id. § 44.6.6.1.
119 Id. § 44.6.5.1.
120 Id. § 44.6.5.1.
121 Id. § 44.6.5.2.
122 Id. §§ 44.6.5.3, 44.6.6.1. If the Eligible Customer seeks an exemption from a performance or protection
and control requirement, the NYISO will notify the Eligible Customer if additional time to evaluate the requested
exemption is required; provide a timeline for completion of any study conducted by the NYISO and applicable
Transmission Owner; and notify the Eligible Customer of the determination prior to notifying whether the Large
Load Integration Request is valid or includes any deficiencies. Id.
123 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.6.6.2. The Eligible Customer’s submission will be limited to
addressing the identified deficiency(ies) and must address all deficiencies identified by the NYISO when submitting
its attempted cure. Id.
124 Id. The NYISO will promptly forward such additional information provided by the Eligible Customer
to the Connecting Transmission Owner and Affected Transmission Owner. Id.
125 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.6.6.3.
126 Id. § 44.6.9.
PDF page 35
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 35
required by the NYISO within the required timeframe or does not satisfy the requirements for a
validated Large Load Integration Request within 90 Calendar Days of the Eligible Customer’s
submission of the Large Load Integration Request, the NYISO will deem the Large Load
Integration Request withdrawn without an opportunity to cure.127
The NYISO also proposes to establish requirements to obtain information subsequent to
the validation of the Large Load Integration Request. In particular, if the NYISO, Connecting
Transmission Owner, or Affected Transmission Owner finds: (i) that the technical data provided
by Eligible Customer is incomplete or contains errors or (ii) that it requires additional
information from the Eligible Customer to perform its responsibilities required under Attachment
LL, then such entity will request that Eligible Customer provide such information.128 The
Eligible Customer must then submit such information within five Business Days of the request.
If Eligible Customer fails to do so, its Large Load Integration Request will be deemed withdrawn
without an opportunity to cure.129
iv.
Study Agreement
The NYISO proposes to require the Eligible Customer to enter into a study agreement –
the Large Load Integration Study Agreement – for the Large Load Integration Study Process
with the NYISO, the Connecting Transmission Owner, and any identified Affected Transmission
Owner(s) or Affected System Owner(s).130 The NYISO proposes to establish a pro forma study
agreement form in Appendix 6 to Attachment LL. The form agreement is based on the study
agreement used for the Cluster Study Process in the NYISO’s Standard Interconnection
Procedures as modified to address the specific terms and requirements for the Large Load
Integration Study Process.
The NYISO proposes to tender an executable version of the study agreement as soon as
practicable after its verification that the Eligible Customer’s Large Load Integration Request is
valid.131 Within 10 Calendar Days of the tendering of the agreement, the Eligible Customer,
Connecting Transmission Owner(s), and any Affected Transmission Owner(s) or Affected
System Operator(s) must execute the study agreement.132
v.
Queue Position
127 Id. § 44.6.6.3.
128 Id. § 44.6.8.
129 Id. § 44.6.8.
130 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Large Load Integration Study Agreement), 44.6.7.1. A Large Load Project
must separately enter into a Facilities Study agreement with the applicable Transmission Owner(s) if it proceeds to a
Facilities Study.
131 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.6.7.1.
132 Id. § 44.6.7.2. If the NYISO subsequently identifies additional or other Connecting Transmission
Owner(s), Affected Transmission Owner(s), or Affected System Operator(s) for the Large Load Integration Request,
the NYISO will tender as soon as practicable an amended version of the Large Load Integration Study Agreement,
which the parties must execute within 10 Calendar Days. Id. § 44.6.7.3.
PDF page 36
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 36
The NYISO proposes to establish a Load Queue for projects participating in the Large
Load Integration Study Process.133 The NYISO will assign a Load Queue Position for a Large
Load Integration Request based upon the date and time of the NYISO’s receipt of the Eligible
Customer’s complete submission of the request.134 If the NYISO validates the Large Load
Integration Request, then the request will retain its assigned Load Queue Position based on the
date and time the submission was originally filed.135 This is consistent with the NYISO’s Queue
requirements in its Standard Interconnection Procedures.136
All Large Load Integration Requests that are a part of a single Group for the Large Load
Integration Study Process will be considered equally queued as between the Large Load
Integration Requests within the same Group.137 However, a Large Load Integration Request’s
individual Load Queue Position will be used to determine priority as between Large Load
Integration Requests in the same Group in the event of a Physical Infeasibility determination as
described in Part II.H.iv.a.138 Large Load Integration Requests that are part of a particular Large
Load Integration Study Process will be considered to have a higher Load Queue Position than
requests that are part of a subsequent study process.139
vi.
Modifications
The NYISO proposes to establish requirements in the Large Load Integration Procedures
for an Eligible Customer to request that the NYISO evaluate whether the Eligible Customer’s
proposed modification to its existing load interconnected to or proposing to interconnect to the
New York State Transmission System or to its Large Load Project is permitted or is a Material
Modification.140 If the NYISO determines pursuant to this process that a proposed modification
is a Material Modification, the Eligible Customer may either withdraw the proposed
modification request or submit a new Large Load Integration Request in a subsequent Large
Load Integration Study Process to be studied for such modification.141
a)
Modification Review Process
The NYISO proposes modification procedures based on the modification requirements in
its Standard Interconnection Procedures. To request a modification, an Eligible Customer must
submit to the NYISO: (i) a Load Modification Request in the form of Appendix 3 to this
133 Id. § 44.1 (definition of Load Queue).
134 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Load Queue Position), 44.7.1.1.
135 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.7.1.1. An Eligible Customer may transfer its Load Queue Position for
its Large Load Integration Request to another entity only if: (i) the acquiring entity acquires the specific Large Load
Project identified in the Large Load Integration Request, (ii) the Point of Interconnection does not change, (iii) the
acquiring entity demonstrates Site Control for the Large Load Project, (iv) the transferring Eligible Customer is up-
to-date on payments to the NYISO, and (v) the acquiring entity submits any deposits required for its Large Load
Integration Request under Attachment LL. Id. § 44.7.1.3.
136 OATT Attach. HH § 40.6.1.1.
137 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.7.1.2.
138 Id. § 44.7.1.2.
139 Id. § 44.7.1.2.
140 Id. § 44.7.2.1.
141 Id. § 44.7.2.1.
PDF page 37
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 37
Attachment LL, (ii) a study deposit in cash in the amount of $10,000, and (iii) any required
supporting information or documentation.142 Upon its receipt of the request, the NYISO will
commence and perform any necessary additional studies as soon as practicable, but in no event
will the NYISO commence such studies later than 30 Calendar Days after receiving the complete
request.143 For purposes of these studies, the NYISO may assess the modified load or Large
Load Project using the Resource Adequacy Impact Standard and the Transmission Security
Standard described in Part II.G.144 In response to Eligible Customer’s request, the NYISO will
evaluate, with input from, as applicable, the Connecting Transmission Owner, Affected
Transmission Owner, and Affected System Owner, the proposed modification, including
performing any studies to determine whether it deems the requested modification material based
on the nature of the modification.145 For purposes of this determination, the NYISO may
consider, as further detailed in its procedures, whether the proposed modification would result in
a material difference in the defining electrical characteristics of the existing load or the Large
Load Project in a manner that is adverse to system reliability or that will have a material impact
on the cost or timing of any Large Load Integration Request with an equal or lower Load Queue
Position.146
The NYISO will inform the Eligible Customer in writing of whether the requested
modification would constitute a Material Modification and whether the modification would
result in a change to the load project’s Firm Withdrawal Service or Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service.147 The Eligible Customer will retain its Load Queue Position if its requested
modification is determined not to be a Material Modification.148
b)
Modifications During Large Load Integration Study Process
With limited exceptions described below, the NYISO proposes that an Eligible Customer
not be permitted to request a modification to the information provided in its validated Large
Load Integration Request for its Large Load Project until the completion of, as applicable, the
Transition Large Load Integration Study Process or Large Load Integration Study Process and
the Facilities Study in which the Large Load Project is participating, which modification would
constitute a Material Modification.149 As described in the Nguyen Affidavit, this is because such
modifications would require updated models which may require updates to base cases and
auxiliary study files and therefore would delay the performance of the study adversely impacting
all study participants.150 Once the study is completed, an Eligible Customer may again request
142 Id. § 44.7.2.2. The proposed modification must be accompanied by any resulting updates to the models
included in such requests to the extent required in the Load Modification Request. Id.
143 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.7.2.3. Any additional studies resulting from such modification will be
done at Eligible Customer’s cost. Id.
144 Id. § 44.7.2.3.
145 Id. § 44.7.2.4.
146 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Material Modification), 44.7.2.4.
147 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.7.2.4.
148 Id. § 44.7.2.2.
149 Id. § 44.7.2.2. This is consistent with the NYISO’s Standard Interconnection Procedure which prohibit
modifications during the study process with limited exceptions. OATT Attach. HH § 40.6.3.
150 Nguyen Affidavit at P 37.
PDF page 38
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 38
the NYISO’s review of proposed modifications to determine whether they are permitted under
the Large Load Integration Procedures and are not material.
The NYISO proposes the following limited exceptions to this restriction on modifications
during the Large Load Integration Study Process. The Eligible Customer may request a
modification for its Large Load Project: (i) to reduce the project size in the SIS Entry Decision
Period or the ALI Entry Decision Period, provided that the project with the reduced size
continues to satisfy the definition of Large Load Project, (ii) to modify the Point of
Interconnection for the project to address Physical Infeasibility in the SIS Entry Decision Period
or in the ALI Entry Decision Period, provided that the modification is agreed upon with the
Connecting Transmission Owner and does not modify the electrical characteristics of the project,
or (iii) to include or change the Associated Resource(s) that satisfy the Associated Resource
requirements in the ALI Entry Decision Period.151 This set of modifications will provide
Eligible Customers with a limited opportunity to modify their projects in response to preliminary
input in the Initial Study Phase. The permitted modifications will generally reduce or lessen the
severity of the reliability issues identified for the project, which minimizes the potential impact
of such modifications on other projects participating in the study.
c)
Material Modifications
Notwithstanding the modification review process, the NYISO proposes that the following
modifications will be considered a Material Modification and require the submission of a Large
Load Integration Request under the Large Load Integration Procedures.152
First, the NYISO proposes to establish certain requirements concerning modifications to
existing loads that are already integrated into the transmission system. Large existing loads in
New York are primarily traditional manufacturing load that have been managed for years with a
good understanding of their potential reliability impacts. Accordingly, the NYISO proposes to
only evaluate modifications to existing load in the Large Load Integration Procedures if a
modification has the potential for significant impacts to the Bulk Electric System. For an
existing load that is in service prior to June 18, 2026, the NYISO proposes that an increase in the
peak, gross load amount by 50 MW or greater compared to the baseline MW value (as reported
by the Connecting Transmission Owner) will be a Material Modification and require study in the
Large Load Integration Study Process. If, however, such existing load proposes to change its
load type and thus its operational characteristics (e.g., changing from a manufacturer to a data
center), the NYISO proposes that a smaller increase in the peak, gross load amount by 10 MW or
greater compared to the baseline MW value (as reported by the Connecting Transmission
Owner) would constitute a Material Modification so that the NYISO can assess the reliability
impacts of this change.
Second, for load projects participating in Transition Group A and for subsequent Large
Load Projects participating in the Transition Large Load Integration Study Process or a Large
Load Integration Study Process, the NYISO proposes that an increase in the peak, gross load
151 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.7.2.2.1.
152 Id. § 44.7.2.1.1.
PDF page 39
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 39
amount by 10 MW or greater compared to the baseline MW value will constitute a Material
Modification.153 The Large Load Project is permitted to increase its size less than 10 MW
without such modification being a Material Modification. However, this 10 MW amount is
determined on a cumulative basis. For example, if a 100 MW load seeks to increase its size by 5
MW, such modification will not be a Material Modification. If, however, the Large Load seeks a
second 5 MW increase that brings its cumulative increase from the initial 100 MW to 110 MW,
this second increase would constitute a Material Modification.
Finally, the NYISO proposes that any change to the Point of Interconnection for an
existing load or a Large Load Project is a Material Modification, except as permitted during the
SIS Entry Decision Period or ALI Entry Decision Period as described above.
vii.
Withdrawal
The NYISO proposes to establish withdrawal requirements for the Large Load
Integration Procedures.154 In particular, an Eligible Customer may withdraw its Large Load
Integration Request at any time by submitting written notice of such withdrawal to the
NYISO.155 Further, if an Eligible Customer fails to adhere to all requirements of these Large
Load Integration Procedures, the NYISO will deem the Large Load Integration Request to be
withdrawn and shall provide written notice to the Eligible Customer of the withdrawal and an
explanation of the reasons for such withdrawal.156
The NYISO proposes that the Eligible Customer have a cure period of 15 Business Days
in which to either respond with information or actions that cures the deficiency or to notify the
NYISO of its intent to pursue Dispute Resolution.157 The NYISO, however, proposes that
certain time-critical deadlines will not be eligible for a cure period.158 This will reduce the
potential for study delays that adversely impact all Large Load Projects participating in the
study. This is consistent with the withdrawal requirements in the NYISO’s Standard
Interconnection Procedures.159
The withdrawal of a Large Load Project will result in the loss of the Eligible Customer’s
Load Queue Position.160 An Eligible Customer that withdraws or is deemed to have withdrawn
153 The “baseline MW value” will be determined as set forth in the NYISO’s procedures.
154 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.7.3.
155 Id. § 44.7.3.1.
156 Id. § 44.7.3.1.
157 Id. § 44.7.3.1.
158 The time critical deadlines include (i) the deadline for an Eligible Customer to cure a deficiency in its
Large Load Integration Request identified by the NYISO; (ii) the deadline for an Eligible Customer to cure a
deficiency in its submission of information; (iii) the deadline for the SIS Entry Decision Period; (iv) the deadline for
the ALI Entry Decision Period; and (v) the deadline for the Eligible Customer to satisfy a milestone demonstrating
that it accepts its cost responsibility for Network Upgrades and Attachment Facilities in accordance with the
requirements established by the applicable Transmission Owner.
159 OATT Attach. HH § 40.6.4.1.
160 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.7.3.2, 44.7.3.3. If the Eligible Customer disputes the withdrawal and
loss of its Load Queue Position, then during Dispute Resolution, the Eligible Customer’s Large Load Integration
Request is eliminated from the Load Queue until such time that the outcome of Dispute Resolution would restore its
Load Queue Position. Id.
PDF page 40
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 40
its Large Load Integration Request is responsible for paying the NYISO, Connecting
Transmission Owner, and Affected Transmission Owner all costs that they prudently incurred
with respect to that Large Load Integration Request prior to the receipt of the notice described
above.161 The NYISO will conduct a final reconciliation of Eligible Customer’s costs and for
returning or cancelling deposits.162 In the event of a withdrawal, the NYISO, Connecting
Transmission Owner, and Affected Transmission Owner, as applicable, subject to non-disclosure
arrangements, will provide, at Eligible Customer’s request, supporting documentation,
workpapers, and databases or data that the NYISO and Connecting Transmission Owner
developed in the preparation of the applicable study conducted up to the date of withdrawal of
the Large Load Integration Request.163
G.
Assessment of Reliability Impacts and Determination of Withdrawal Service
i.
Determination of Withdrawal Service
The NYISO proposes to determine the amounts of Firm Withdrawal Service and Non-
Firm Withdrawal Service for each Large Load Project and, if requested, to determine eligibility
to be classified as Zero Withdrawal Service Load, based on both the resource adequacy and
transmission security impacts of the project and available actions to mitigate any adverse
reliability impacts.164 This approach ensures the reliability of the New York State Transmission
system and that Large Loads will be responsible for the costs associated with mitigating any
adverse impacts to system reliability resulting from their interconnection.
For purposes of assessing the reliability impacts of the proposed interconnection of a
Large Load Project, the NYISO proposes to establish a Resource Adequacy Impact Standard (as
described in Part II.G.ii) and a Transmission Security Standard (as described in Part
II.G.iii). The NYISO proposes that the analyses be applied to ensure that New York State
Transmission System facilities are sufficient to reliably serve existing load and meet load growth
and changes in load patterns in compliance with Applicable Reliability Requirements.165 These
requirements include New York State Reliability Council (“NYSRC”) Reliability Rules,
Northeast Power Coordinating Council (“NPCC”) Basic Design and Operating Criteria, North
American Electric Reliability Corporation (“NERC”) Planning Standards, NYISO rules,
practices and procedures, and the applicable Transmission Owner criteria included in FERC
Form No. 715.166 These Applicable Reliability Requirements are consistent with the NYISO’s
requirements for its Standard Interconnection Procedures.167 The NYISO and Transmission
Owners, as applicable, will apply the Resource Adequacy Impact Standard and Transmission
161 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.7.3.2.
162 Id. § 44.7.3.3.
163 Id. § 44.7.3.4. The Eligible Customer must pay all monies due to the NYISO, Connecting Transmission
Owner, and Affected Transmission Owner before it is allowed to obtain any Large Load Integration Study Process
data or results. Id. § 44.7.3.2.
164 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.8, 44.8.3.1.
165 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.8.
166 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Applicable Reliability Requirements), 44.8.
167 OATT Attach. HH § 40.12.1.2.
PDF page 41
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 41
Security Standard in line with these Applicable Reliability Requirements in the appropriate
studies in the Large Load Integration Study Process as described below.
If there are no adverse impacts or violations, as applicable, identified in accordance with
the Resource Adequacy Impact Standard or Transmission Security Standard as described below,
the Large Load Project may proceed with Firm Withdrawal Service.
a)
Addressing Adverse Impacts Under Resource Adequacy Impact
Standard
If an adverse impact is identified under the Resource Adequacy Impact Standard, a Large
Load Project may mitigate the adverse impacts through its association with an Associated
Resource and remain eligible for Firm Withdrawal Service.168 In such case, the Large Load
Project will obtain Non-Firm Withdrawal Service until a Large Load Bilateral Transaction with
an Associated Resource, as part of a Co-Located Resource Arrangement or Partner Resource
Arrangement, is initially certified.169 Alternatively, the Large Load Project may elect to proceed
with Non-Firm Withdrawal Service (in full or part) without proposing an association with an
Associated Resource.
These Withdrawal Service alternatives are illustrated in the following figure:
Adverse Impact Under
Resource Adequacy Impact
Standard
Eligible Withdrawal Service
No
Firm
Yes (with an Associated Resource
that fully mitigates adverse
impact)
Firm*
Yes (with an Associated Resource
that partially mitigates adverse
impact)
Partial Firm* and partial Non-Firm
Yes (without an Associated
Resource)
Non-Firm
* Non-Firm until Large Load Bilateral Transaction with an Associated
Resource is initially certified
A Large Load may enter into an arrangement with an Associated Resource for the Large
Load to obtain an amount of Firm Withdrawal Service – including a Partner Resource
Arrangement with a Partner Resource and a Co-Located Arrangement with a Co-Located
Resource. For a Resource to be eligible to be an Associated Resource, the Resource: (i) must
complete the interconnection study process and obtain sufficient Capacity Resource
Interconnection Service rights, except if the Partner Resource is a Demand Side Resource, (ii)
must be a proposed project that does not yet meet the inclusion rules for the Reliability Planning
168 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.8.3.3.
169 Id. § 44.8.3.3.
PDF page 42
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 42
Process at the time the Large Load Integration Request is validated, (iii) is a new Installed
Capacity Supplier, and (iv) is not another Large Load participating in the ISO-Administered
Wholesale Markets as a Demand Side Resource that has obtained Firm Withdrawal Service
through a Partner Resource Arrangement or Co-Located Arrangement.170 In addition, for a Co-
Located Arrangement, the Resource must be co-located behind the same Point of Interconnection
as the given Large Load.171 Further, for a Partner Resource Arrangement, the Resource must be
located in the same Capacity Region as the given Large Load.172
For all arrangements between a Large Load and an Associated Resource, the
arrangements must satisfy all applicable requirements for a term of 15 years and have a Large
Load Bilateral Transaction in place for the full term.173 If the Associated Resource exits the
NYISO administered markets or the arrangement otherwise fails to comply with applicable
requirements prior to the end of the 15-year term, then the Large Load ceases to be eligible for
the amount of Firm Withdrawal Service that depends on the arrangement with the Associated
Resource, as further detailed under the proposed provisions in the Services Tariff and the
OATT.174 The Associated Resource eligibility and ongoing requirements are further discussed
below in Part IV.F.
b)
Addressing Violations Under Transmission Security Standard
If a violation is identified under the Transmission Security Standard, a Large Load
Project may either take Non-Firm Withdrawal Service or may proceed with Network Upgrades
that mitigate the violation.175 In such case, the Large Load Project will obtain Non-Firm
Withdrawal Service until the Network Upgrades are complete and in service, after which the
Large Load Project will obtain Firm Withdrawal Service.176 Notwithstanding the impact on
Withdrawal Service, certain transmission security violations cannot be mitigated by the project
taking Non-Firm Withdrawal Service and require Network Upgrades (as described in Part II.G.iii
below). For these upgrades that are necessary for the project to obtain Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service or, if requested, to be eligible to be classified as a Zero Withdrawal Service Load, the
Large Load Project may not enter service until such Network Upgrades are complete and in
service or the NYISO and applicable Transmission Owner determine that such reliability impacts
can be managed through normal operating procedures until the Network Upgrades are
complete.177 These Withdrawal Service alternatives are illustrated in the following figure:
Violation Under Transmission
Security Standard
Eligible Withdrawal Service
No
Firm
170 Id. § 44.6.4.1, 44.6.4.2.
171 Id. § 44.6.4.1.
172 Id. § 44.6.4.2.
173 Id. § 44.6.4.3.
174 See, e.g., id. § 44.6.4.3; Services Tariff § 4.1.12 & 5.18.
175 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.8.3.3.
176 Id. § 44.8.3.3.
177 Id. § 44.8.3.3.
PDF page 43
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 43
Yes (without proceeding with
Network Upgrades required for Firm
Service)*
Non-Firm
Yes (with Network Upgrades
required for Firm Service)*
Firm (once Network Upgrades enter
service)
* The Large Load Project must proceed with the construction of those
Network Upgrades that are necessary, notwithstanding Non-Firm
Withdrawal Service, to resolve certain transmission security issues.
c)
Withdrawal Service Based on Results Under Both Resource
Adequacy Impact Standard and Transmission Security Standard
The NYISO’s final determination concerning Withdrawal Service will be based on both
the results of the analyses using the Resource Adequacy Impact Standard and the Transmission
Security Standard and any mitigation actions concerning adverse impacts or violations identified
based on either of these standards. For example, a Large Load Project for which there are no
adverse impacts on resource adequacy may still be limited to Non-Firm Withdrawal Service if
there are transmission security violations that are not mitigated in the manner described above.
d)
LIPA Exception Regarding Non-Firm Withdrawal Service
The NYISO proposes to include in its Withdrawal Service requirements, to the extent
accepted by the Commission, the following exception requested by the Long Island Power
Authority concerning the application of Non-Firm Withdrawal Service for projects
interconnecting in the Long Island Transmission District. In particular, Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service and the procedures for studying Non-Firm Withdrawal Service under the Large Load
Integration Procedures for the Long Island Transmission District will only apply if dispatch
procedures applicable to serving a Large Load on a non-firm basis have been adopted by the
Board of Trustees for the Long Island Power Authority in accordance with Article 5, Title 1-A of
the New York Public Authorities Law.178 The Long Island Power Authority requested this
exception based on its status as a non-jurisdictional utility under the Federal Power Act and will
provide its more detailed justification for this proposed exception in a separate filing.
ii.
Resource Adequacy Impact Standard
The NYISO proposes to establish a Resource Adequacy Impact Standard to evaluate the
impact of each Large Load Project on the resource adequacy of the New York Control Area
using probabilistic evaluations consistent with the Applicable Reliability Requirements,
including the NYSRC Reliability Rules.179 This analysis will enable the NYISO to determine
whether the Large Load Project proposing to interconnect to the New York State Transmission
System: (i) is eligible to obtain Firm Withdrawal Service or (ii) due to the resource adequacy
impacts, may either proceed with such service with an Associated Resource or is only eligible to
178 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.8.3.1.1.
179 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Resource Adequacy Impact Standard), 44.8.1.1.
PDF page 44
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 44
obtain Non-Firm Withdrawal Service. This places responsibility for the Large Load Project’s
impacts to the transmission system with the Large Load.
The NYISO proposes to apply this Resource Adequacy Impact Standard in the Resource
Adequacy Evaluation performed during the RAMP Part 1 Process as described in Part
II.H.iv.b.180 The NYISO will then perform this assessment anew in the Assessment of Load
Integration as described in Part II.I.i and at any point thereafter as part of a review of a Large
Load Project’s requested modification as described in Part II.F.vi, in each case if the Large Load
Project modifies its load or includes or modifies any Associated Resources.181
For purposes of this assessment, the NYISO proposes to use the most recent resource
adequacy model from the Reliability Planning Process, as updated in accordance with the
NYISO’s procedures.182 The NYISO will test a Large Load together with any Associated
Resource(s), with the assumption that the Associated Resource(s) will obtain Capacity Resource
Interconnection Service.183 The NYISO will consider the operating characteristics of the Large
Load Project and any Associated Resource(s) as part of this evaluation.184
The amounts of Firm Withdrawal Service and Non-Firm Withdrawal Service determined
using the Resource Adequacy Impact Standard will be subject to change based on: (i) the
determinations using the Transmission Security Standard as described below and (ii) available
actions to mitigate any adverse reliability impacts as described above.185
a)
Resource Adequacy Impact Standard Except for State Exempt Large
Load Projects
The NYISO proposes to apply the Resource Adequacy Impact Standard differently
depending on whether or not a Large Load Project is identified by the NYDPS as a State Exempt
Large Load Project as described below. The NYISO proposes to apply the Resource Adequacy
Impact Standard in the manner described: (i) in this Part II.G.ii.a for Large Load Projects that are
not identified as State Exempt Large Load Projects and (ii) in Part II.G.ii.b for State Exempt
Large Load Projects.
The NYISO proposes to apply the Resource Adequacy Impact Standard in the following
manner to determine the amount of Non-Firm Withdrawal Service and Firm Withdrawal Service
that the Large Load Project is eligible for based on resource adequacy impacts to the New York
Control Area.186 The NYISO will evaluate a Large Load Project for years 1 through 10 of the
study to determine the extent that the project degrades resource adequacy in consideration of any
offset by an Associated Resource.187 If the Large Load Project degrades resource adequacy by
180 Id. § 44.8.1.2.
181 Id. § 44.8.1.2.
182 Id. § 44.8.1.3.
183 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.8.1.3.
184 Id. § 44.8.1.3.
185 Id. § 44.8.1.6.
186 Id. §§ 44.8.1.1, 44.8.1.4.
187 Id. § 44.8.1.4.1.
PDF page 45
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 45
25 MW or less, the Large Load Project will be eligible for Firm Withdrawal Service in its full
requested amount, provided that it completes any identified Network Upgrades to address any
violations of the Transmission Security Standard.188 If the Large Load Project degrades resource
adequacy by greater than 25 MW, the Large Load Project will be eligible for a partial amount of
Firm Withdrawal Service.189 The NYISO will determine the partial amount based on how much
of the Withdrawal Service must be Non-Firm Withdrawal Service to bring the Loss of Load
Expectation to the pre-project level.190
As described in the Altman Affidavit, the Resource Adequacy Impact Standard is just and
reasonable because it provides a clear requirement for the integration of Large Load Projects to
not adversely impact NYCA resource adequacy and, thus, reliability.191 The use of the Resource
Adequacy Impact Standard is particularly important when the NYISO faces statewide resource
deficiencies, which it has recently identified beginning in 2033 in its current longer-term
reliability planning assessment.192 In applying the 25 MW impact threshold, the NYISO will
employ a probabilistic evaluation comparable to those used in evaluating resource adequacy
under the rules established by NYSRC and calculate the Large Load Project’s MW impact.193
The proposed methodology that the NYISO will use to calculate the 25 MW impact threshold is
also reasonable and consistent with the NYISO’s longstanding consideration of similar impacts
when studying proposed interconnections to the New York State Transmission System.194 Using
a threshold, as opposed to a precise calculation, provides a reasonable tolerance commensurate
with the degree of precision in the models and avoids potentially subjecting Large Load Projects
to adverse findings based on the modeling that are immaterial to a project’s impact to
reliability.195
b)
Resource Adequacy Impact Standard for State Exempt Large Load
Projects
The NYISO proposes to establish a category of Large Load Projects – State Exempt
Large Load Projects – that will be subject to an alternative Resource Adequacy Impact Standard.
The NYISO proposes that the NYDPS may identify a Large Load Project as a State Exempt
Large Load Project through an exemption process adopted by the NYPSC in its ongoing large
load interconnection proceedings.196 The Eligible Customer must provide this verification as
part of either the project’s submission of its Large Load Integration Request or during the ALI
Entry Decision Period.197
188 Id. § 44.8.1.4.1.1.
189 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.8.1.4.1.2.
190 Id. § 44.8.1.4.1.2.
191 Altman Affidavit at P 21.
192 Id. at PP 10-18.
193 Id. at P 24.
194 Id. at P 25.
195 Id. at P 26.
196 See Proceeding on Motion of the Commission to Address Interconnection Reforms for Large Load,
Order Instituting Proceeding and Soliciting Comments, NYPSC Case No. 26-E-0045 (Feb. 12, 2026).
197 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.6.3.7, 44.10.4.2.
PDF page 46
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 46
For State Exempt Large Load Projects, the NYISO will apply the Resource Adequacy
Impact Standard to evaluate the collective impact of the State Exempt Large Load Projects
within a Group to determine their eligibility for Firm Withdrawal Service.198
The NYISO will perform this evaluation as follows. If the collective impact of the State
Exempt Large Load Projects within a Group does not violate the resource adequacy criterion
contained in the NYSRC Reliability Rules for years 1 through 5 of the study, then those projects
will be eligible for Firm Withdrawal Service in their full requested amounts.199 The NYISO
proposes to use the resource adequacy criterion contained in NYSRC Reliability Rules as it
captures the applicable standard for New York for ensuring that there are adequate resources to
maintain system reliability.200
For purposes of the preliminary Resource Adequacy Evaluation performed during the
Initial Study Phase, the NYISO will report the results of the evaluation for informational
purposes if the collective impact of the State Exempt Large Load Projects within a Group
violates the resource adequacy criterion contained in the NYSRC Reliability Rules for years 1
through 5 of the study.201
For purposes of the NYISO’s subsequent analyses applying the Resource Adequacy
Impact Standard in the Assessment of Load Integration, the NYISO proposes to perform the
following more detailed assessment. If, during the evaluation, the collective impact of the State
Exempt Large Load Projects within a Group violates the resource adequacy criterion contained
in the NYSRC Reliability Rules for years 1 through 5 of the study, the NYISO will notify the
Eligible Customers, NYDPS, and applicable Transmission Owners of the results.202 Within 60
Calendar Days of the NYISO providing this notice to NYDPS, an authorized representative of
NYDPS may inform the NYISO that it is revoking the State Exempt Large Load Project
Verification(s) for one or more of the Large Load Projects in the Group. If the State Exempt
Large Load Project Verification(s) remain valid, such Large Load Project(s) will continue as
State Exempt Large Load Project(s). In such case, the NYISO will re-evaluate whether the
remaining State Exempt Large Load Projects violate the resource adequacy criterion contained in
the NYSRC Reliability Rules for years 1 through 5 of the study. If the collective impact of the
remaining State Exempt Large Load Projects does not violate the resource adequacy criterion
contained in the NYSRC Reliability Rules, then those projects will be eligible for Firm
Withdrawal Service in their full requested MW amounts. If, however: (i) NYDPS revokes any of
the State Exempt Large Load Project Verifications for the Large Load Projects in the Group or
(ii) the collective impact of the remaining State Exempt Large Load Projects violates the
resource adequacy criterion contained in the NYSRC Reliability Rules, then those projects will
198 Id. § 44.8.1.5; see Altman Affidavit at P 32.
199 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.8.1.5.1. The Resource Adequacy Impact Standard uses the acceptable
reliability level in the NYCA as set forth in the NYSRC’s Resource Adequacy Reliability Rules, which is based on
the evaluation “that the loss of load expectation (LOLE) of disconnecting firm load due to resources deficiencies
shall be, on average, no more than 0.1 loss of load Event-Days per year.” Altman Affidavit at PP 8-9, 35.
200 See Altman Affidavit at PP 8-9, 35, 38.
201 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.8.1.5.2.
202 Id. § 44.8.1.5.3.
PDF page 47
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 47
no longer be eligible to be State Exempt Large Load Projects and must be evaluated in the
manner described in Part II.G.ii.a above.”
c)
The State Exempt Large Load Projects Proposal Is Consistent with
Cooperative Federalism
The NYPSC stated in the Show Cause Order proceeding that the FPA gives it the
primary role in ensuring the adequacy of generation resources in New York, and that it intends to
exercise its authority with respect to large load resource adequacy.203 Meanwhile, the
Commission has jurisdiction over resource adequacy issues to the extent that they affect
wholesale electricity market, interstate transmission, or bulk power system reliability matters.204
The Commission’s interest in these types of resource adequacy issues is reflected in the Show
Cause Order, including its informational report directive and its suggestion that the NYISO take
other steps to address resource adequacy challenges.205 And the NYISO itself has resource
adequacy responsibilities under applicable NERC, NPCC, and NYSRC requirements and its
Commission-jurisdictional tariffs.
Thus, resource adequacy implicates both federal and state jurisdiction. Consistent with
the Show Cause Order,206 the NYISO has designed the State Exempt Large Load Projects
proposal to respect cooperative federalism. As the Altman Affidavit explains,207 the NYISO
needs to consider the resource adequacy implications of Firm Withdrawal Service awards in
order to fulfill its reliability obligations. The NYISO is not seeking to displace New York State’s
resource adequacy authority or “targeting” state-jurisdictional activity.208 The NYISO is simply
accounting for resource adequacy implications when deciding whether to make Commission-
jurisdictional transmission service available to Commission-jurisdictional Transmission
Customers. At the same time, the NYISO’s proposal would preserve state authority by enabling
the NYDPS to determine that certain Large Loads should be allowed to receive firm service even
if they would otherwise individually exceed the NYISO’s Resource Adequacy Impact Standard.
Making this treatment unavailable to the extent that State Exempt Large Load Projects would
collectively cause a resource adequacy violation is not an impermissible intrusion into state
jurisdiction. It is a reasonable safeguard to ensure that federal reliability requirements are
maintained.
203 See Notice of Intervention and Preliminary Comment of the New York State Public Service
Commission, Docket No. EL26-69-000 (July 9, 2026) (“NYPSC Preliminary Comments”) at 3-5.
204 See, e.g., Conn. Dept. of Pub. Util. Control v. FERC, 569 F.3d 477, 485 (D.C. Cir. 2009) (distinguishing
between “direct regulation of generation facilities” — which is beyond the Commission’s reach — and
determination of the installed capacity requirement, which directly “affects rates within the Commission’s
jurisdiction.”)
205 See Show Cause Order at P 128.
206 See id. at P 76 (“Indeed, the Commission’s objective in this proceeding is to respect the cooperative
federalism approach established under the FPA”); NYPSC Preliminary Comments at 4-5 (acknowledging this
statement and the Commission’s commitment to cooperative federalism.)
207 Altman Affidavit at PP 8-10, 37-38.
208 In FERC v. Elec. Power Supply Ass’n, 577 U.S. 260, 264 (2016) (“EPSA”) and ONEOK, Inc. v. Learjet,
Inc., 575 U.S. 373, 385 (2015), the Supreme Court was clear that whether a particular rule “targeted” federal or state
matters was a key factor in determining whether the rule was within the Commission’s jurisdiction.
PDF page 48
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 48
The NYISO’s balanced approach is permissible under the FPA. The Supreme Court has
clearly established that “the wholesale and retail markets in electricity…are not hermetically
sealed from each other.”209 There is room for reasonable compromise210 in areas where federal
and state jurisdiction overlap. In this case, the proposed Resource Adequacy Impact Standard is
critical to the NYISO’s ability to serve Large Loads. The State Exempt Large Load Project
proposal, therefore, represents a program of cooperative federalism and recognizes New York
State’s role regarding resource adequacy without encroaching upon federal jurisdiction over
wholesale electricity rates and transmission service.
iii.
Transmission Security Standard
The NYISO proposes to establish a Transmission Security Standard to evaluate the
impact of each Large Load Project on the transmission security of the New York Control Area as
described below and in the Nguyen Affidavit.211 The NYISO proposes that the Transmission
Security Standard be applied to assess the reliability impacts of the proposed interconnection of
the proposed Large Load Project and determine the amount of Firm Withdrawal Service and
Non-Firm Withdrawal Service that the Large Load Project is eligible for and, if requested,
whether the Large Load Project, or any portion, is eligible to be classified as a Zero Withdrawal
Service Load based on transmission security impacts.212 The amounts of Firm Withdrawal
Service and Non-Firm Withdrawal Service determined using the Transmission Security Standard
will be subject to modification based on: (i) the determinations using the Resource Adequacy
Impact Standard and (ii) available actions to mitigate any adverse reliability impacts, as
described above.213
The NYISO proposes that this assessment be used in the System Impact Study.214 In
addition, the NYISO proposes that this assessment then be performed: (i) anew in the
Assessment of Load Integration and (ii) at any point thereafter as part of a review of a Large
Load Project’s requested modification if the Large Load Project modifies its load or includes or
modifies a Co-Located Resource(s).215 For purposes of this assessment, the NYISO proposes
that the year 5 cases of the most recent quarterly Short-Term Assessment of Reliability
(“STAR”) base case in the Short-Term Reliability Process be used to evaluate the impact of each
Large Load Project on the transmission security of the New York Control Area.216 The Large
Load will be tested together with any Associated Resource, as applicable, and the operating
209 EPSA, 577 U.S. at 281.
210 The NYDPS staff reviewed the NYISO’s proposal and stated that it did not object to it prior to the
October 28, 2026, vote of the NYISO’s stakeholder Management Committee to approve this filing. The NYISO
acknowledges that NYDPS staff reserved its right to raise issues in this proceeding. See Adam Evans (DPS)
Statement at October 28 NYISO Management Committee; available at: https://www.nyiso.com/documents/20142/
59483202/Adam%20Evans%20DPS%20Statement.pdf.
211 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.1 (definition of Transmission Security Standard), 44.8.2.1; Nguyen
Affidavit at PP 33-36.
212 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.8.2.4.
213 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.8.2.5.
214 Id. § 44.8.2.2.
215 Id. § 44.8.2.2.
216 Id. § 44.8.2.3.
PDF page 49
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 49
characteristics of the Large Load Project and any Associated Resources will be considered as
part of the evaluation.217
The NYISO proposes to perform short-circuit/fault duty, steady state (thermal and
voltage) and stability analyses to evaluate the transmission security impacts for the Group of
Large Load Projects on the Bulk Electric System and to identify any violations in Applicable
Reliability Requirements.218 The NYISO will also determine if the Group of Large Load
Projects degrades interface transfer capability by greater than 25 MW.219 If the NYISO
identifies a violation or a degradation of greater than 25 MW, the impacted Transmission Owner
will be responsible for identifying a Network Upgrade to mitigate that violation or
degradation.220 In addition, consistent with the Show Cause Order, the NYISO proposes to
perform, as applicable, electromagnetic transient screening of the proposed Large Load
Project.221
The NYISO proposes that the applicable Transmission Owner perform the steady state
(thermal and voltage) and short-circuit/fault duty analyses of the non-Bulk Electric System and
its distribution system and identify any violations.222 The applicable Transmission Owner may
perform bus flow analysis of the Bulk Electric System and non-Bulk Electric System.223 If a
Transmission Owner identifies a violation, the impacted Transmission Owner will be responsible
for identifying a Network Upgrade to mitigate the violation.224
The NYISO or Transmission Owner, as applicable, will calculate each Large Load
Project’s impact on the observed transmission security violation as set forth in the NYISO’s
procedures or the Transmission Owner’s procedures.225 For each identified violation, the
NYISO or the Transmission Owner, as applicable, will identify if the violation can be resolved
by the Large Load Project receiving Non-Firm Withdrawal Service for some or all of the
project’s size as described in the NYISO’s procedures.226 If a violation cannot be resolved by
receiving Non-Firm Withdrawal Service or the Large Load Project is seeking to be eligible to be
classified as a Zero Withdrawal Service Load, the violation must be addressed by one or more
Network Upgrades. Violations that cannot be resolved through receiving Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service include any potential adverse reliability impact that degrades system reliability or results
in noncompliance with the NERC, NPCC, or NYSRC reliability standards and that cannot be
managed through the normal operating procedures of the NYISO and/or Transmission Owner.227
H.
Initial Study Phase
217 Id. § 44.8.2.3.
218 Id. § 44.8.2.4.1.
219 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.8.2.4.1.
220 Id. § 44.8.2.4.1.
221 Show Cause Order at P 66; proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.8.2.4.2.
222 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.8.2.4.3.
223 Id. § 44.8.2.4.3.
224 Id. § 44.8.2.4.3.
225 Id. § 44.8.2.4.4.
226 Id. § 44.8.2.4.5.
227 Id. § 44.8.2.4.5.
PDF page 50
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 50
i.
Overview of New Study Process
In the Show Cause Order, the Commission indicated that the NYISO’s tariff appears to
lack sufficiently clear and consistent provisions establishing a study process for evaluating the
provision of transmission service to Eligible Customers on behalf of large loads that considers
the unique characteristics and impacts of large loads on the transmission system, including
identifying the Direct Assignment Facilities and Network Upgrades necessary to provide such
service reliably and providing a non-binding good-faith estimate of the cost and the time to
construct such facilities.228 The Commission further indicated that the NYISO’s tariff may not
clearly and consistently require the NYISO or the Transmission Owners to conduct studies that
evaluate the transmission system’s ability to withstand risks observed from analyzed large load
behavior created by the large load at the point of interconnection, or any other necessary
supplemental studies to evaluate the impact of providing transmission service to Eligible
Customers on behalf of large loads.229
The NYISO’s existing load interconnection procedures in Sections 3.9 and 4.5 of the
OATT provide for it, in cooperation with the applicable Transmission Owner, to perform
technical studies to determine whether the proposed interconnection may degrade system
reliability or adversely affect the operation of the NYS Power System.230 The NYISO proposes
to establish in place of these requirements a new Large Load Integration Study Process in
Attachment LL of the OATT. This process will include detailed, clear and consistent
requirements for the evaluation of the impacts of the proposed interconnection of Large Load
Projects in a manner that accounts for the unique operational characteristic of Large Loads,
including identifying any Attachment Facilities or Network Upgrades required for the reliable
interconnection of the Large Load and determining the type and amount of Withdrawal Service
for the Large Load Project.
In particular, the NYISO proposes an Initial Study Phase as described in this Part II.H in
which the NYISO and Transmission Owners will perform certain initial analyses of the proposed
interconnection and a System Impact Study. These collectively will provide a Large Load
Project with a preliminary assessment of the feasibility of its proposed interconnection and
potential Attachment Facilities and Network Upgrades, including preliminary estimates of the
costs and time to construct such facilities. If an Eligible Customer elects to proceed with its
Large Load Project, the NYISO will then perform an Assessment of Load Integration as
described in Part II.I.i in parallel with the Transmission Owner’s performance of a Facilities
Study as described in Part II.I.ii to identify both the required Attachment Facilities and Network
Upgrades and to establish the final determination of Withdrawal Service that the project is
eligible to obtain.
228 Show Cause Order at PP 66, 69.
229 Id. at P 66. The Show Cause Order recognized the Transmission Owners may be partially responsible
for conducting the studies that evaluate whether a large load may be interconnected to the transmission system and
served by the Eligible Customer and that determine whether Network Upgrades are necessary to provide
transmission service. Id. at 58.
230 OATT §§ 3.9.1, 3.9.2; NYISO Manual 23, Transmission Expansion and Interconnection Manual § 3.5
(Issued: February 2025).
PDF page 51
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 51
The NYISO proposes to perform the Large Load Integration Study Process on a clustered
basis for a Group of Large Load Projects that have satisfied the application requirements
described in Part II.F to enter the next available Group, rather than performing such study
through serial, individual studies.231 As with the NYISO’s Cluster Study Process in its Standard
Interconnection Procedures, which evaluates a cluster of Cluster Study Projects, it is just and
reasonable for the NYISO to perform the Large Load Integration Study Process on a clustered
basis. As the Commission found in Order No. 2023 in adopting a cluster study process for
generator interconnection requests, a group study increases efficiencies as the transmission
provider can perform larger interconnection studies encompassing many proposed facilities,
rather than individual studies for each customer.232 As described in the Nguyen Affidavit, a
grouped study permits the NYISO and the Transmission Owners to evaluate the collective
reliability effects of Large Load additions and to identify coordinated upgrades, rather than
conducting overlapping serial studies that could produce duplicative or inconsistent solutions.233
Although the addition of multiple projects and larger aggregate MW quantities increases the
technical complexity of the study, the grouped approach provides a more comprehensive basis
for assigning responsibility for shared impacts and allocating the costs of common Network
Upgrades.
The NYISO proposes that the study work in the Large Load Integration Study Process
will be allocated between the NYISO and the Transmission Owners as detailed in this filing
letter and as described in the Nguyen Affidavit.234 This approach reasonably allocates the study
work to the entity with the relevant system knowledge, planning responsibility, and access to the
underlying criteria and data. The parallel division of work will also allow the NYISO and the
Transmission Owners, working in parallel, to meet the proposed study timeframes and minimize
inefficient and duplicative analyses. The NYISO will perform the evaluation of the impacts of
the proposed interconnections of Large Load Projects on the Bulk Electric System portion of the
New York State Transmission System and identify any violations and adverse impacts on the
Bulk Electric System caused by the project. In particular, the NYISO will evaluate impacts on
the Bulk Electric System to provide a consistent statewide assessment of bulk-system reliability
and interregional effects. If more than one project contributes to the violation, then the NYISO
will provide the Transmission Owners with the projects’ respective contributions to the identified
violations to facilitate the allocation of upgrade costs.
The applicable Transmission Owners will perform parallel evaluations for the impacts of
the Large Load Projects to the non-Bulk Electric System. Transmission Owners will evaluate
impacts on their non-Bulk Electric System and distribution facilities because they maintain the
detailed models, equipment information, local planning criteria, operating procedures, and design
standards needed to identify localized impacts and develop practicable upgrades. Each
Transmission Owner will be responsible for identifying: (i) violations on the non-Bulk Electric
231 See proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.1 (definition of Group). The NYISO also proposes to provide that
the Transmission Owner may perform a Facility Study on a grouped basis. Id. § 44.12.1.3.
232 Improvements to Generator Interconnection Procs. & Agreements, Order No. 2023, 184 FERC ¶ 61,054
at P 177 (“Order No. 2023”), order on reh’g, 185 FERC ¶ 61,063 (2023), order on reh’g, 186 FERC ¶ 61,199,
errata notice, 188 FERC ¶ 61,134 (2024).
233 Nguyen Affidavit at P 7.
234 Id. at PP 8-10.
PDF page 52
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 52
System, including local transmission and distribution systems, (ii) the Network Upgrades to
address violations on both the Bulk Electric System and non-Bulk Electric System (subject to
consultation with the NYISO), (iii) cost estimates and time to construct the Network Upgrades,
(iv) the allocation of costs among the Large Load Projects participating in the study process,
based on the NYISO’s and Transmission Owner’s determinations of each project’s respective
contribution to the identified violations, (v) Attachment Facilities, and (vi) estimates of the costs
and time to construct the Attachment Facilities.
ii.
Initial Study Phase Overview
The NYISO proposes to commence the Large Load Integration Study Process with an
Initial Study Phase.235 This phase will consist of (i) the Resource Adequacy and Modeling
Period as described in Part II.H.iii and (ii) the System Impact Study as described in Part
II.H.vii.236 The NYISO proposes to perform up to two successive, independent rounds of the
Initial Study Phase for each Large Load Integration Study Process cycle, which rounds will be
referred to as Initial Study Round 1 and Initial Study Round 2.237 Performing two rounds will
increase the number of Large Load Projects that may proceed to be evaluated in the Assessment
of Load Integration for a given study cycle once that assessment is completed for the prior cycle.
For Initial Study Round 1, the Resource Adequacy and Modeling Period and the System Impact
Study will be performed for the Large Load Projects in Group 1, and for Initial Study Round 2,
the Resource Adequacy and Modeling Period and the System Impact Study will be performed for
the Large Load Projects in Group 2.238 The NYISO proposes to commence the Initial Study
Phase and the Initial Study Round 1 on the Large Load Integration Study Process Start Date,
which is described in Part II.E.i.239 Following the completion of the draft System Impact Study
Report for Group 1 in the Initial Study Round 1, the NYISO will commence the Initial Study
Round 2.240
Notwithstanding the above, for the Transition Large Load Integration Study Process, the
NYISO proposes that the Initial Study Phase be performed in a single round for the Group of
entities in Transition Group B that satisfied the requirements to enter the transition study. The
Initial Study Phase for the transition process will only include certain elements of the Resource
Adequacy and Modeling Period as the participants in the transition process were already
evaluated in a system impact study and will not be subject to a new System Impact Study under
the Attachment LL rules. The Resource Adequacy and Modeling Period for the Transition Large
Load Integration Study Process will commence on the Transition Large Load Integration Study
Process Start Date, which is described in Part II.E.i above.241
iii.
Resource Adequacy and Modeling Period
235 See proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.1 (definition of Initial Study Phase).
236 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.9.1.1.
237 Id. §§ 44.1 (definitions of Initial Study Round 1 and Initial Study Round 2), 44.9.1.1.
238 Id. §§ 44.1 (definitions of Group 1 and Group 2), 44.9.1.2. 44.9.1.3.
239 Id. §§ 44.9.1.2, 44.9.2.1.
240 Id. §§ 44.9.1.3, 44.9.2.1.
241 Id. § 44.9.2.1.
PDF page 53
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 53
The NYISO proposes that the Resource Adequacy and Modeling Period consist of the
following three components: (i) the RAMP Part 1 Process as described in Part II.H.iv, (ii) the
SIS Entry Decision Period as described in Part II.H.v, and (iii) the RAMP Part 2 Process as
described in Part II.H.vi.242 The NYISO proposes that the scheduled duration of the Resource
Adequacy and Modeling Period for each round in the Large Load Integration Study Process be a
90 Calendar Day period between the start date and the NYISO’s presentation of the scope of the
System Impact Study to stakeholders.243 For the Transition Large Load Integration Study
Process for which there is no System Impact Study related work, the NYISO proposes a shorter
period of 60 Calendar Day between the start date and the ALI Entry Decision Period.244
iv.
RAMP Part 1 Process
The NYISO proposes that the RAMP Part 1 Process include the following elements to
develop information for the System Impact Study and provide the Eligible Customer with initial
information concerning its proposed interconnection.245 In particular, the NYISO will develop
the base case for the System Impact Study and will perform a Resource Adequacy Evaluation for
each Large Load Project. In addition, the Connecting Transmission Owner will determine
preliminary Attachment Facilities for each Large Load Project, and the Connecting Transmission
Owner and any Affected Transmission Owners will perform a Physical Infeasibility
Screening.246 The NYISO proposes that the RAMP Part 1 Process have a scheduled duration of
60 Calendar Days.247
a)
Transmission Owner Responsibilities in the RAMP Part 1 Process
The NYISO proposes to establish a Physical Infeasibility Screening in the Large Load
Integration Study Process by which the Connecting Transmission Owner and any Affected
Transmission Owner will review the proposed interconnection of each Large Load Project to
assess whether the proposed Point of Interconnection is Physically Infeasible.248 This process
step is consistent with the Physical Infeasibility Screening requirements for the Cluster Study
Process in the NYISO’s Standard Interconnection Procedures. It serves to catch early in the
study process, when possible, those projects that will not be able to interconnect due to physical
infeasibility, so that such projects can withdraw without incurring or causing significant costs,
time, and resources. The NYISO and Transmission Owners have successfully applied this
process in the NYISO’s Cluster Study Process to facilitate either the modification of Points of
Interconnection, where permitted, or the withdrawal of projects that would not otherwise have
been able to interconnect at their requested Point of Interconnection.249
242 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.1 (definition of Resource Adequacy and Modeling Period).
243 Id. § 44.9.2.2.
244 Id. § 44.9.2.3.
245 Id. § 44.1 (definition of RAMP Part 1 Process).
246 Id. § 44.9.3.
247 Id. § 44.9.2.
248 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.9.3.4.
249 As described above, the NYISO is proposing to include a Pre-Application Report process to assist
Eligible Customers in obtaining information about potential Points of Interconnection prior to submitting Large
Load Integration Requests.
PDF page 54
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 54
The NYISO proposes to define Physically Infeasible in Attachment LL consistent with its
definition in the Standard Interconnection Procedures in Attachment HH.250 In particular, a
Large Load Integration Request will be Physically Infeasible if:
(1) the substation for the selected Point of Interconnection (i) does not have any
available bus positions and (ii) (a) is not expandable electrically or within the
existing substation footprint, and (b) the Transmission Owner has determined that
adjacent usable vacant land is not available, or
(2) proposals by Eligible Customer are inconsistent with Good Utility Practice or
Applicable Reliability Requirements; or
(3) a viable tie line cable route(s) cannot be established from either the Point of
Change of Ownership to the Point of Interconnection or, where these points are
the same, a viable route cannot be established within or from the fence line; or
(4) the project capacity exceeds the ratings of equipment at the substation selected
for the Point of Interconnection, replacement equipment that would be adequately
rated for the project capacity is not commercially available from an approved
supplier and within applicable specifications set by the Transmission Owner, and
an alternative upgrade is not physically feasible (e.g., higher voltage Point of
Interconnection substation);251 or
(5) an Attachment Facility or Local Network Upgrade required for the Large Load
Project to reliably interconnect is Physically Infeasible.252
Within 45 Calendar Days of the commencement of the RAMP Part 1 Process, the Connecting
Transmission Owner or Affected Transmission Owner will provide the NYISO with its written
assessment of the results of the Physical Infeasibility Screening.253 If, as a result of the Physical
Infeasibility Screening or at any time in the Large Load Integration Study Process, the NYISO
determines, in consultation with the Connecting Transmission Owner or Affected Transmission
Owner, that the proposed interconnection of a Large Load Project is Physically Infeasible, then
the NYISO will notify the Eligible Customer that the proposed interconnection of its Large Load
Project is Physically Infeasible and will withdraw the Large Load Integration Request for the
Large Load Project.254 However, in such circumstances, the Eligible Customer may modify its
250 OATT Attach. HH § 40.7.3.2.
251 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.9.3.4.2. For purposes of this definition, “commercially available”
equipment shall mean equipment manufactured by an approved supplier of a particular Connecting Transmission
Owner and/or Affected Transmission Owner(s) and conforming with engineering specifications and procedures of
the Connecting Transmission Owner and/or Affected Transmission Owner(s). Id.
252 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.9.3.4.2.
253 Id. §§ 44.9.3, 44.9.3.4.1. The Physical Infeasibility requirements: (i) do not establish on behalf of the
Large Load Project any rights or title to a Transmission Owner’s real property and (ii) do not create an obligation on
a Transmission Owner to transfer, convey or use its real property rights on behalf of the Large Load Project or to
acquire on behalf of the Large Load Project through eminent domain or otherwise any real property. Id. § 44.9.3.4.2.
254 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.9.3.4.3, 44.10.4.2. If: (i) more than one Large Load Integration
Request in a Group proposes to interconnect at the same Point of Interconnection on the New York State
PDF page 55
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 55
Large Load Integration Request in the SIS Entry Decision Period or ALI Entry Decision Period
to indicate a new Point of Interconnection if such modification is agreed upon by the Connecting
Transmission Owner and does not modify the electrical characteristics of the Large Load
Project.255
Within the same 45 Calendar Day period, the Connecting Transmission Owner will also
be responsible for developing a one-line diagram with a preliminarily determination of
Attachment Facilities for each Large Load Project in the Group, unless the Large Load Project is
determined to be Physically Infeasible.256
b)
NYISO Responsibilities in RAMP Part 1 Process
The NYISO proposes as part of the RAMP Part 1 Process to establish the Pre-Project
Base Case for purposes of the short-circuit/fault duty, steady state (thermal and voltage) and
stability analyses for the System Impact Study.257 For this base case, the NYISO will use the
most recent quarterly Short-Term Assessment of Reliability in its Short-Term Reliability Process
established in Attachment FF of the NYISO OATT.258 As it is updated quarterly, the STAR base
case represents an up-to-date set of planning cases for assessing reliability impacts. The NYISO
will then update the base case in the RAMP Part 2 Process to account for those Large Load
Projects that elect in the SIS Entry Decision Period to enter the System Impact Study as
described in Part II.H.vi.
The NYISO will also conduct a Resource Adequacy Evaluation of each Large Load
Project to evaluate the adverse impact of the interconnection of the Large Load Project and any
Associated Resource identified in the Large Load Integration Request for the project on the
resource adequacy of the New York Control Area.259 For this evaluation, the NYISO will apply
the Resource Adequacy Impact Standard as described in Part II.G.ii to determine the preliminary
amount of Firm Withdrawal Service and Non-Firm Withdrawal Service for the Large Load
Project.
Within 15 Calendar Days from the NYISO’s receipt of the results of the Physical
Infeasibility Screening from all of the identified Connecting Transmission Owners and Affected
Transmission Owners, the NYISO will issue a summary report with the results of the Resource
Transmission System and (ii) all of the Large Load Integration Requests proposing to interconnect at that location
are not able in the aggregate to interconnect due to a Physical Infeasibility, then a Large Load Integration Request
with a Load Queue Position with a higher designated priority shall have priority over a Large Load Integration
Request with a Load Queue Position with a lower designated priority (including as between Large Load Integration
Requests within the same Group) for access to that Point of Interconnection for purposes of Physical Infeasibility
determinations. Id. § 44.9.3.4.4.
255 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.9.3.4.3, 44.9.4.4.
256 Id. §§ 44.9.3, 44.9.3.3.
257 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Pre-Project Base Case), 44.9.3.1. The NYISO will also commence the
development of the Post-Project Base Case for purpose of short-circuit/fault duty, steady state (thermal and voltage)
and stability analyses for the System Impact Study, which will be updated in the RAMP Part 2 Process. Id.
258 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.9.3.1.
259 Id. § 44.9.3.2.
PDF page 56
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 56
Adequacy Evaluation of each Large Load Project and the results of the Physical Infeasibility
Screening.260
v.
SIS Entry Decision Period
The NYISO proposes to establish an SIS Entry Decision Period in which an Eligible
Customer may assess the information determined in the RAMP Part 1 Process and elect whether
its Large Load Project will proceed to be evaluated in a System Impact Study or be withdrawn
from the Load Queue.261 The SIS Entry Decision Period will be a seven Calendar Day period,
which period will commence 61 Calendar Days after the commencement of the RAMP Part 1
Process.262
For a Large Load Project to be included in the System Impact Study, the Eligible
Customer must notify the NYISO of its election for the project to proceed to the study during the
SIS Entry Decision Period.263 If the Eligible Customer does not make such election, then the
NYISO will withdraw the project from the Load Queue without an opportunity to cure.264
During the SIS Entry Decision Period, the Eligible Customer may propose two types of
modifications to its proposed Large Load Project to account for input obtained in the RAMP Part
1 Process. First, the Eligible Customer may reduce the size (i.e., MW) of its Large Load Project
from the size included in the Large Load Integration Request provided that the project with the
reduced size continues to satisfy the definition of a Large Load Project.265 Second, the Eligible
Customer may modify the Point of Interconnection included in its Large Load Integration
Request to address Physical Infeasibility if such modification is agreed upon by the Connecting
Transmission Owner and does not modify the electrical characteristics of the Large Load
Project.266
vi.
RAMP Part 2 Process
The NYISO proposes to establish a RAMP Part 2 Process prior to the System Impact
Study to update materials based on the results of the SIS Entry Decision Period and to meet with
the projects that elected to proceed to the System Impact Study.267 The scheduled duration of the
Ramp Part 2 Process will be 23 Calendar Days.268
260 Id. § 44.9.3.
261 Id. § 44.1 (definition of SIS Entry Decision Period).
262 Id. § 44.9.4.1.
263 Id. § 44.9.4.2.
264 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.9.4.5.
265 Id. § 44.9.4.3.
266 Id. § 44.9.4.4. To implement the modification, the Eligible Customer must submit the change to the
Point of Interconnection using the Load Modification Form. A change in the Point of Interconnection will result in
a change to the priority designation of the Load Queue Position assigned to the Large Load Integration Request
based on the date and time of the NYISO’s receipt of the Eligible Customer’s submission of the completed Load
Modification Request form. Id. This is consistent with the NYISO’s treatment of changes to Points of
Interconnection in its Standard Interconnection Procedures. See OATT Attach. HH § 40.7.2.3.
267 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.1 (definition of RAMP Part 2 Process).
268 Id. § 44.9.2.2.
PDF page 57
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 57
First, the NYISO proposes to update the Post-Project Base Case for the power flow,
stability, short-circuit, and transfer studies for the System Impact Study by adding the Large
Load Projects that satisfied the requirements to proceed to the System Impact Study.269 The
NYISO may also update the assumptions in the base cases used in the System Impact Study in
accordance with its procedures. The NYISO will also develop the scope of the System Impact
Study, provide the scope to the impacted Connecting Transmission Owner(s) and any identified
Affected Transmission Owner(s) and Affected System Operator(s) for their review, and then
finalize the study scope.270 The NYISO will submit the draft scope of the System Impact Study
to its stakeholder Transmission Planning Advisory Subcommittee (“TPAS”) for review and
comment.271
Second, the NYISO proposes to hold a group Scoping Meeting for all Eligible Customers
included in the Group which Large Load Projects satisfied the requirements to proceed to the
System Impact Study, along with the Connecting Transmission Owners and any Affected
Transmission Owner(s).272 The purpose of the Scoping Meeting will be to reinforce the roles
and responsibilities of all parties in the System Impact Study and to discuss the study scope for
the System Impact Study, the schedule, and the work plan.273 The NYISO, Connecting
Transmission Owner, Affected Transmission Owner(s), and Eligible Customer will bring to the
meeting personnel and other resources as may be reasonably required to accomplish the purpose
of the meeting in the time allocated for the meeting.274 The duration of the meeting will be
sufficient to accomplish its purpose.275
vii.
System Impact Study
The NYISO proposes to perform, in coordination with Connecting Transmission
Owner(s) and Affected Transmission Owner(s), a System Impact Study for the Group of Large
Load Projects for that Large Load Integration Study Process that satisfied the requirements in the
SIS Entry Decision Period to participate in the study.276 As described below, the study will
evaluate any potential transmission security issues for the proposed interconnection of a Large
269 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Post Project Base Case), 44.9.5.1.
270 Id. § 44.9.5.1.
271 Id. § 44.9.5.3.
272 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Scoping Meeting), 44.9.5.2. The Scoping Meeting will take place no later than
15 Business Days following the close of the SIS Entry Decision Period. In setting the date, the NYISO will consult
with the Connecting Transmission Owners and Affected Transmission Owners on the review of the draft scope, with
the Scoping Meeting to take place no later than 15 Business Days. The NYISO will provide notice of the Scoping
Meeting to the contact list of the Large Load Projects that satisfied the requirements in the SIS Entry Decision
Period to proceed to the System Impact Study and to the applicable Connecting Transmission Owners, Affected
Transmission Owners, and Affected System Operators. Id. Before holding a Scoping Meeting with an Affiliate of a
Connecting Transmission Owner and that Connecting Transmission Owner, the NYISO will post on its OASIS an
advance notice of its intent to do so. Id.
273 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.9.5.2.
274 Id. § 44.9.5.2. If the Scoping Meeting consists of more than one Eligible Customer, the Eligible
Customer must provide an executed non-disclosure agreement to the NYISO that provides for confidentiality of
commercially sensitive information identified in the Scoping Meeting pertaining to any other Eligible Customers
prior to the start of the Scoping Meeting to participate. Id.
275 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.9.5.2.
276 Id. § 41.1 (definition of System Impact Study).
PDF page 58
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 58
Load Project, will preliminarily identify and cost estimate any required Network Upgrades, and
will preliminarily determine the Withdrawal Service for which the project is eligible. There will
not, however, be a System Impact Study for the Transition Large Load Integration Study
Process, as the NYISO already performed a system impact study for the projects participating in
the transition process pursuant to its existing load interconnection rules in Section 3.9 of the
OATT.277 The System Impact Study will be performed over a 90-Calendar Day period between
the start of the study and the NYISO and Transmission Owners’ provision of the draft System
Impact Study report to Eligible Customers for their review.278
a)
Performance of System Impact Study
The NYISO proposes that the System Impact Study be performed on a combined basis
for the Group of Large Load Projects that satisfied the requirements to proceed to the study.279
The performance of the System Impact Study will be divided between the NYISO and the
applicable Transmission Owner(s), with the NYISO performing analyses for the Bulk Electric
System, and the applicable Transmission Owner performing analyses on the non-Bulk Electric
System.
In particular, the NYISO will perform short-circuit/fault duty, steady state (thermal and
voltage) and stability analyses for the Bulk Electric System pursuant to the scope of the System
Impact Study and the Transmission Security Standard.280 The NYISO will provide the study
results to the applicable Transmission Owner(s) within 45 Calendar Days from the
commencement of the System Impact Study.281 The applicable Transmission Owner(s) will
perform these analyses for the non-Bulk Electric System and may perform bus flow analysis on
the Bulk Electric System and non-Bulk Electric System.282 The applicable Transmission
Owner(s) will provide the results of its analyses to the NYISO within 30 Calendar Days from the
NYISO’s provision of the Bulk Electric System results.283
Within the same 30-Calendar Day period the impacted Connecting Transmission
Owner(s) and Affected Transmission Owner(s) will preliminarily identify Network Upgrades
required to mitigate any transmission security impacts resulting from the proposed
interconnection of the Large Load Project(s).284 The applicable Transmission Owner will
provide preliminary, non-binding estimates of the costs and the time to construct the Network
Upgrades.285 In addition, the applicable Transmission Owner will provide any updates to the
277 Id. § 44.10.1.1.3.
278 Id. § 44.10.1.1.1. The NYISO will notify stakeholders within 5 Business Days of the start date of the
study the scope of the study and the list of Large Load Projects participating in the study. Id. § 44.10.1.1.2.
279 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.10.2.1.
280 Id. § 44.10.2.2.
281 Id. § 44.10.2.2.
282 Id. § 44.10.2.2. Certain Transmission Owners may perform bus flow and certain other analyses for both
the Bulk Electric System and the non-Bulk Electric System for purposes of evaluating the capabilities of the
Attachment Facilities.
283 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.10.2.2.
284 Id. §§ 44.10.2.3, 44.10.2.5.
285 Id. § 44.10.2.3.
PDF page 59
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 59
Attachment Facilities preliminarily identified in the RAMP Part 1 Process and a preliminary,
non-binding estimate of the costs and time to construct the Attachment Facilities.286
Finally, the NYISO will determine preliminary amounts of Firm Withdrawal Service and
Non-Firm Withdrawal Service for each Large Load Project and, if requested, whether any
portion of a Large Load Project is eligible to be classified as a Zero Withdrawal Service Load.287
b)
Review of System Impact Study Report
The NYISO proposes that it will provide, in coordination with the Connecting
Transmission Owner(s) and Affected Transmission Owner(s), the draft System Impact Study
Report to the Eligible Customer(s) which Large Load Project(s) are in the Group studied in the
System Impact Study within 90 Calendar Days of the commencement of the study.288 The
NYISO and applicable Transmission Owner(s) may then meet with the Eligible Customer(s) to
discuss the study results.289 The Eligible Customers may provide comments for the NYISO’s
and Transmission Owners’ consideration on the draft report.290 The NYISO will then submit the
final System Impact Study Report to the TPAS for review and comment and to the stakeholder
Operating Committee (“OC”) for its approval.291 Following this approval, the NYISO will post
the final System Impact Study Report on its password-protected website.292
viii.
ALI Entry Decision Period
The NYISO proposes to establish an ALI Entry Decision Period in which an Eligible
Customer may assess the information determined in the Initial Study Process and elect whether
its Large Load Project will proceed to be evaluated in the Assessment of Load Integration and
Facilities Study or be withdrawn from the Load Queue.293 The ALI Entry Decision Period will
apply to all Large Load Projects that were included in either Group 1 or Group 2 in the Initial
Study Phase of that Large Load Integration Study Process cycle (or in the Group for the
Transition Large Load Integration Study Process) and were not determined to be Physically
Infeasible.294
The ALI Entry Decision Period will commence for the Transition Large Load Integration
Study Process following the conclusion of the Resource Adequacy and Modeling Period.295 For
subsequent Large Load Integration Study Processes, the ALI Entry Decision Period will
commence following the Operating Committee’s approval of the System Impact Study Report
286 Id. § 44.10.2.4.
287 Id. § 44.10.2.2.
288 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of System Impact Study Report), 44.10.3.1.
289 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.10.3.1.
290 Id. § 44.10.3.1.
291 Id. § 44.10.3.2.
292 Id. § 44.10.3.2.
293 Id. § 44.1 (definition of ALI Entry Decision Period),
294 Id. § 44.10.4.1.
295 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.10.4.1.
PDF page 60
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 60
for Group 2 at the conclusion of the Initial Study Round 2 for the Initial Study Phase of that
study cycle.296 The ALI Entry Decision Period will be a seven Calendar Day period.297
The NYISO proposes that the Eligible Customer must satisfy the following requirements
during the ALI Entry Decision Period for its Large Load Project to be included in the
Assessment of Load Integration and Facilities Study.298 If the Eligible Customer does not satisfy
these requirements, then the NYISO will withdraw the project from the Load Queue without an
opportunity to cure.299
First, the NYISO proposes that the Eligible Customer must notify the NYISO of its
election for its Large Load Project to proceed to the Assessment of Load Integration.300 Second,
the NYISO proposes that the Eligible Customer must also satisfy a readiness requirement to
proceed. In particular, the Eligible Customer must submit a Readiness Deposit for its Large
Load Project, which will evidence its commercial readiness to proceed.301 The NYISO proposes
to calculate the Readiness Deposit as $4,000 per MW based on the Large Load Project’s peak
MW amount.302 As described in the Nguyen Affidavit, this is consistent with the per MW
amount for the Readiness Deposit 1 required in the NYISO’s Standard Interconnection
Procedures previously accepted by the Commission.303
Third, except for participants in the Transition Large Load Integration Study Process, the
Eligible Customer must submit to the NYISO the Study Deposit 2 to account for the additional
study work for the Assessment of Load Integration.304 The Study Deposit 2 will be the
incremental difference between the Study Deposit 1 amount that the Eligible Customer
previously submitted for the Large Load Project and the following amount based on the size of
the Large Load Project: (i) $200,000 for a Large Load Project less than 200 MW, (ii) $250,000
for a Large Load Project that is both less than 500 MW and greater than or equal to 200 MW,
and (iii) $300,000 for a Large Load Project that is 500 MW or greater.305 The Study Deposit 1
amount for the Large Load Project and the incremental difference submitted by the Eligible
Customer for the ALI Entry Decision Period will, in total, constitute the Study Deposit 2 for the
296 Id. § 44.10.4.1. The ALI Entry Decision Period for Group 1 may commence as soon as practicable but
no sooner than the completion of the Facilities Study conducted by the Transmission Owner(s) for the previous
cycle (i) if there are no validated Large Load Integration Requests seeking to participate in Group 2 following the
deadline to enter Group 2, or (ii) after the withdrawal of the last validated Large Load Integration Request in Group
2 if all validated Large Load Integration Requests in Group 2 have withdrawn prior to completion of the System
Impact Study for Group 2. Id.
297 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.10.4.1.
298 Id. § 44.10.4.2. The Eligible Customer’s participation in a Facilities Study is also subject to it satisfying
the Transmission Owner’s requirements for such study. Id.
299 Id. § 44.10.4.4.
300 Id. § 44.10.4.2.
301 Id. § 44.10.4.2.
302 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.1 (definition of Readiness Deposit), 44.10.4.2.
303 Nguyen Affidavit at P 26; see also OATT Attach. HH § 40.7.5.3.
304 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.1 (definition of Study Deposit 2), 44.10.4.2. As described above, an
Eligible Customer for a Large Load Project in the Transition Large Load Integration Study Process will be required
to submit this higher deposit amount with its Large Load Integration Request.
305 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.10.4.2.
PDF page 61
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 61
Large Load Project and replace the Study Deposit 1 for the project.306 The NYISO will hold the
Study Deposit 2 amount for the duration of Eligible Customer’s participation in the Large Load
Integration Study Process, subject to the deposit requirements described in Part III.B.i.c.307
Finally, the Eligible Customer may indicate, if it did not do so with its Large Load
Integration Request, whether its Large Load Project is eligible to be a State Exempt Large Load
Project.308 In such case, the Eligible Customer must also submit a State Exempt Large Load
Project Verification.
During the ALI Entry Decision Period, the Eligible Customer may propose three types of
modifications to its proposed Large Load Project to account for input obtained in the Initial
Study Phase. First, the Eligible Customer may reduce the size (i.e., MW) of its Large Load
Project from the size included in the Large Load Integration Request or from a previous
reduction of the project size during the SIS Entry Decision Period.309 Second, the Eligible
Customer may modify the Point of Interconnection included in its Large Load Integration
Request for its Large Load Project to address Physical Infeasibility if such modification is agreed
upon by the Connecting Transmission Owner and does not modify the electrical characteristics
of the Large Load Project.310 Finally, the Eligible Customer may include or change the
Associated Resources, including Partner Resources and Co-Located Resources, that satisfy the
tariff requirements for an Associated Resource.311
I.
Assessment of Load Integration (“ALI”) and Facilities Study
i.
Assessment of Load Integration
The NYISO proposes to perform an Assessment of Load Integration by which it will
update its analyses of the remaining Group of Large Load Projects in the Large Load Integration
Study Process that satisfied the requirements to proceed in the ALI Entry Decision Period.312
The Assessment of Load Integration will consist of two parts – the ALI Part 1 Study and the ALI
Part 2 Study as described below.313 The NYISO will perform the Assessment of Load
Integration in parallel and in coordination with the Transmission Owners’ performance of
Facilities Studies for these projects.314 As described below, the NYISO will provide the
Transmission Owners with updated information from the Assessment of Load Integration of the
306 Id. § 44.10.4.2.
307 Id. § 44.10.4.2.
308 Id. § 44.10.4.2.
309 Id. § 44.10.4.3.
310 Id. § 44.10.4.3. The Eligible Customer must submit to the NYISO any requested change to the Point of
Interconnection through a Load Modification Request. In such case, the NYISO will modify the priority designation
for the Load Queue Position assigned to the Large Load Integration Request based on the date and time of the
NYISO’s receipt of the completed Load Modification Request form. The NYISO will notify the Connecting
Transmission Owner and Affected Transmission Owner of this change when notifying the Eligible Customer of its
modified Load Queue Position. Id.
311 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.10.4.3.
312 See proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.1 (definition of Assessment of Load Integration).
313 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.1 (definitions of ALI Part 1 Study and ALI Part 2 Study), 44.11.1.4.
314 Id. § 44.11.1.3.
PDF page 62
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 62
Large Load Project’s proposed interconnection to facilitate the Transmission Owners’
identification and cost allocation of Network Upgrades in the Facilities Study.
The Assessment of Load Integration will have a scheduled duration of one year. It will
commence following the latter of: (i) the completion of the ALI Entry Decision Period or (ii) the
completion of the Assessment of Load Integration and Facilities Study for the previous
Transition Large Load Integration Study Process or Large Load Integration Study Process.315
a)
Base Case for Assessment of Load Integration
The NYISO proposes to use for the base cases of the Assessment of Load Integration, as
applicable, the base cases described in Parts II.G.ii and II.G.iii above for the performance of the
Resource Adequacy Impact Standard and Transmission Security Standard.316 The NYISO
proposes that it may update the assumptions in these base cases, including any updates received
from Connecting Transmission Owners and Affected Transmission Owners on the Large Load
Projects and associated Network Upgrades that have been studied in a previous cycle of the
Large Load Integration Study Process, in accordance with the NYISO’s procedures.317 Within 5
Business Days following the completion of the ALI Entry Decision Period, the Connecting
Transmission Owners and Affected Transmission Owners will provide any updates for the
NYISO to review and incorporate in the assumptions in the base cases.318 In addition, the
NYISO will develop the scope of the ALI Part 1 Study, which it will provide to the impacted
Connecting Transmission Owners and Affected Transmission Owners for their review.319 The
NYISO will also provide the base cases that it will use for the Assessment of Load Integration to
the impacted Connecting Transmission Owners and Affected Transmission Owners.320
b)
ALI Part 1 Study
The NYISO proposes for the ALI Part 1 Study that it will evaluate the impact on the Bulk
Electric System of the proposed interconnection of the Large Load Projects that satisfied the
requirements to enter the Assessment of Load Integration.321 For this evaluation, the NYISO
will use: (i) the Resource Adequacy Impact Standard, as applicable, for the individual Large
Load Projects (except for State Exempt Large Load Projects) and for the collective group of any
State Exempt Large Load Projects and (ii) the Transmission Security Standard for the Group of
Large Load Projects, including confirming each Large Load Project’s contribution to any
observed transmission security violations.322
Within 150 Calendar Days from the end of the ALI Entry Decision Period, the NYISO
will provide the applicable Transmission Owners with any transmission security violations
identified in the ALI Part 1 Study for use by the Transmission Owner in the Facilities Study to
315 Id. §§ 44.11.1.1, 44.11.1.2.
316 Id. § 44.11.1.5.
317 Id. § 44.11.1.5.
318 Id. § 44.11.1.5.
319 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.11.1.5.
320 Id. § 44.11.1.5.
321 Id. § 44.11.2.1.
322 Id. § 44.11.2.1.
PDF page 63
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 63
design Network Upgrades to mitigate the violations.323 The NYISO will also provide the
applicable Transmission Owners with each Large Load Project’s contribution to the identified
violations for use by the Transmission Owner in the Facilities Study to allocate the costs of
Network Upgrades among the Large Load Projects.324
Based on the evaluations in the ALI Part 1 Study, the NYISO will update the amount of
Firm Withdrawal Service and Non-Firm Withdrawal Service for each Large Load Project and, if
requested, whether any portion of a Large Load Project is eligible to be classified as a Zero
Withdrawal Service Load.325 The NYISO will provide the draft study results to Eligible
Customers and Transmission Owners for their review.326 This will include: (i) the violations
identified in the ALI Part 1 Study, (ii) the Large Load Project’s contribution percentages to the
identified violations, (iii) the amount of Firm Withdrawal Service and Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service for each Large Load Project; and (iv) if requested, whether any portion of the Large
Load Project is eligible to be classified as a Zero Withdrawal Service Load.327
The NYISO will also perform sensitivities based on its engineering judgment to identify
how the violations and contribution percentages determined in ALI Part 1 could change if one or
more Large Load Projects withdraw, elect to obtain Non-Firm Withdrawal Service in lieu of
Network Upgrades, or fail to accept its cost allocation and post security in accordance with the
Facilities Study requirements.328 The NYISO will provide the Transmission Owners with the
results of any sensitivities performed by the NYISO in ALI Part 1 for use by the Transmission
Owner in the Facilities Study.329
c)
ALI Part 2 Study
For the ALI Part 2 Study, the NYISO will review and confirm that the Non-Local
Network Upgrades designed by Transmission Owners in the Facilities Studies resolve the
violation(s) identified in the ALI Part 1 Study and do not result in new violations.330 If a
Transmission Owner in a Facilities Study identifies the need for an additional Non-Local
Network Upgrade or a Local Network Upgrade that the Transmission Owner believes impacts
the Bulk Electric System, the NYISO will review and confirm that such Network Upgrade does
not result in new violations on the Bulk Electric System. The NYISO will notify the applicable
Transmission Owner of the NYISO’s review within 30 Calendar Days of the NYISO’s receipt of
the upgrade identified by the Transmission Owner.331
ii.
Facilities Study
323 Id. § 44.11.2.2.
324 Id. § 44.11.2.2.
325 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.11.2.3.
326 Id. § 44.11.2.4.
327 Id. § 44.11.2.4.
328 Id. § 44.11.2.5.
329 Id. § 44.11.2.5.
330 Id. § 44.11.3.1.
331 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.11.3.1.
PDF page 64
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 64
The NYISO proposes that the Facilities Studies for a Large Load Project be performed,
as applicable, by the Connecting Transmission Owner to which system the project proposes to
interconnect and any Affected Transmission Owner which system is impacted by the project.332
Consistent with the NYISO’s existing load interconnection process and the NYISO’s other
interconnection procedures, the Transmission Owner is responsible for determining the required
Attachment Facilities and Network Upgrades for its system and estimating the costs and
schedule for constructing such facilities.333 As described below, in the Facilities Study, the
Transmission Owner will further determine the Attachment Facilities and Network Upgrades
required for the reliable interconnection of the Large Load Project, identify the estimated costs
and schedule to construct these facilities, and allocate the cost of the facilities among the
applicable Large Load Projects. The Transmission Owner will commence the Facilities Study
for a Large Load Project no later than the NYISO’s commencement of the Assessment of Load
Integration for the project.334
The Transmission Owner will tender the Eligible Customer a Facilities Study
agreement.335 In the agreement, the Eligible Customer must agree to reimburse the Transmission
Owner(s) for performing the required Facilities Study and provide the study deposit required by
the Transmission Owner.336 The Eligible Customer must execute a Facilities Study agreement,
comply with any requirements of the Transmission Owner(s), and return the agreement to the
Transmission Owner(s).337 The Transmission Owners will include the pro forma Facilities Study
agreement in their separate Section 205 filing(s).
a)
Performance of Facilities Study
The Connecting Transmission Owner will coordinate with any Affected Transmission
Owners and Affected System Operators concerning the performance of the Facilities Studies.338
The applicable Transmission Owner may group Large Load Projects as appropriate for the
performance of the Facility Study.339
The Connecting Transmission Owner and Affected Transmission Owner will design the
Attachment Facilities and Local Network Upgrades required to reliably interconnect the Large
Load Project with the New York State Transmission System in accordance with Applicable
Reliability Requirements, Applicable Laws and Regulations, and Good Utility Practice.340 The
332 See proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.1 (definition of Facilities Study).
333 For the NYISO’s Cluster Study Process and Transmission Interconnection Procedures, the NYISO
coordinates with the Transmission Owner concerning the identification of non-local upgrades and the Transmission
Owner designs the upgrades and determines the estimate of the costs and the schedule for constructing such
upgrades.
334 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.12.1.1.
335 Id. § 44.12.1.2.
336 Id. § 44.12.1.2.
337 Id. § 44.12.1.2.
338 Id. § 44.12.1.3.
339 Id. § 44.12.1.3.
340 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.12.1.4. Local Network Upgrades include Network Upgrades
necessary to physically interconnect a proposed Large Load Project to the Connecting Transmission Owner’s
transmission system, consistent with applicable interconnection and system protection design. Id. § 44.1 (definition
PDF page 65
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 65
Connecting Transmission Owner and Affected Transmission Owner will provide an estimate of
the cost of the Attachment Facilities and Local Network Upgrades, along with a schedule
showing the estimated time required to complete the engineering and design, procurement,
construction, installation, and commissioning phases for the required Attachment Facilities and
Local Network Upgrades.341
Each Connecting Transmission Owner and Affected Transmission Owner will also assess
the impact of the proposed interconnection of the Large Load Project on the non-Bulk Electric
System and the distribution system using the Transmission Security Standard.342 As necessary,
the Connecting Transmission Owner and Affected Transmission Owner may perform additional
analyses, including, but not limited to, bus flow analysis for the Bulk Electric System and the
non-Bulk Electric System affected by the proposed interconnection of the Large Load Project.
The Connecting Transmission Owner and Affected Transmission Owner will design Non-Local
Network Upgrades to resolve violations on the non-Bulk Electric System or distribution system
or violations related to bus flow analysis on the Bulk Electric System and will provide a good
faith cost estimate for such upgrades, along with a preliminary schedule showing the estimated
time required to complete the engineering and design, procurement, construction, installation,
and commissioning phases for the required Non-Local Network Upgrades for their respective
facilities.343
Finally, following the NYISO’s completion of the ALI Part 1 Study, the Connecting
Transmission Owner and Affected Transmission Owner will design Non-Local Network
Upgrades required to address violations on the Bulk Electric System identified in the ALI Part 1
Study.344 The Connecting Transmission Owner and Affected Transmission Owner will provide a
good faith cost estimate for such upgrades, along with a preliminary schedule showing the
estimated time required to complete the engineering and design, procurement, construction,
installation, and commissioning phases for the required Non-Local Network Upgrades.345 The
Transmission Owner will provide the Non-Local Network Upgrades to the NYISO for its review
in the ALI Part 2 Study within 120 Calendar Days of the NYISO providing any transmission
security violations identified in the ALI Part 1 Study.346 The NYISO and Transmission Owner
will coordinate to confirm: (i) whether the Non-Local Network Upgrades fully resolve the
of Local Network Upgrades). They include any electrical facilities required to make the physical connection (e.g., a
new ring bus for a line connection or facilities required to create a new bay for a substation connection). Id. They
also include any system protection or communication facilities that may be required for protection of the Connecting
Transmission Owner’s and/or Affected Transmission Owner’s transmission facility (line or substation) involved in
the interconnection. Id.
341 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.12.1.4.
342 Id. § 44.12.1.5.
343 Id. § 44.12.1.5.
344 Id. § 44.12.1.6. Non-Local Network Upgrades include Network Upgrades required to mitigate any
adverse reliability impact(s) of the Large Load Project(s) identified through analysis such as power flow, short
circuit, or stability (e.g., replacement of a circuit breaker at a nearby substation that becomes overdutied as a result
of the Large Load Project(s)). Id. § 44.1 (definition of Non-Local Network Upgrades).
345 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.12.1.6.
346 Id. § 44.12.1.6.
PDF page 66
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 66
identified violations on the Bulk Electric System or create additional violations and (ii) whether
further refinement in the determination of any Non-Local Network Upgrades is required.347
b)
Consideration of Alternative Transmission Technologies
In the Show Cause Order, the Commission directed the NYISO to propose tariff revisions
to require (1) the evaluation of alternative transmission technologies as potential solutions to
accommodate an Eligible Customer’s request for transmission service on behalf of a large load,
and (2) if alternative transmission technologies are not identified, to include in the study report a
sufficiently clear demonstration of why alternative transmission technologies are not feasible or
would not result in lower costs or a faster timeline for accommodating the transmission service
request.348
The NYISO proposes that the Transmission Owner consider in identifying the Network
Upgrades in the Facilities Study the use of static synchronous compensators, static VAR
compensators, advanced power flow control devices, transmission switching, synchronous
condensers, voltage source converters, advanced conductors, and tower lifting.349 The
Transmission Owner will consider each alternative transmission technology that could
reasonably be implemented to address the identified violation or constraint and determine
whether the above technologies should be used, consistent with Good Utility Practice,
Applicable Reliability Requirements, and Applicable Laws and Regulations.350 The
Transmission Owner will provide an explanation of the results for each technology.351
c)
Completion of Facilities Study
At the conclusion of the Facilities Study, the Connecting Transmission Owner and
Affected Transmission Owner will require the Large Load Project to accept the cost allocation of
any required Attachment Facilities and Network Upgrades and to post security to cover the
allocated cost, consistent with the terms of the Transmission Owner’s cost recovery agreement
and security agreement.352 If the Large Load Project does not satisfy a milestone demonstrating
its acceptance of its cost responsibility for Network Upgrades and Attachment Facilities in
accordance with the requirements established by the applicable Transmission Owner within 14
Calendar Days of the completion of the Facilities Study, the applicable Transmission Owner will
notify the NYISO, and the NYISO will withdraw the Large Load Project from the Load
Queue.353
The Connecting Transmission Owner and Affected Transmission Owner will inform the
NYISO of the results of the Facilities Study, including: (i) any Network Upgrades identified for
each Large Load Project and their estimated cost and time to construct and enter service, and (ii)
347 Id. § 44.12.1.6.
348 Show Cause Order at PP 67-68. Alternatively, the Show Cause Order permitted the NYISO to explain
whether its tariffs remained just and reasonable without these revisions.
349 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.12.1.7.
350 Id. § 44.12.1.7.
351 Id. § 44.12.1.7.
352 Id. § 44.12.1.8.
353 Id. § 44.12.1.8.
PDF page 67
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 67
whether the Eligible Customer for the Large Load Project accepted its cost allocation for any
Network Upgrades and posted the related security.354
iii.
Conclusion of Large Load Integration Study Process
In the Show Cause Order, the Commission indicated that the NYISO’s current tariff
appears unjust and unreasonable because it does not require the provision of data on NYISO’s
website in a single location and in an easily accessible format that is searchable and allows users
to filter the data that identifies the Network Upgrades that are needed to accommodate requests
for transmission service by Eligible Customers on behalf of large loads, and the costs of those
Network Upgrades.355
The NYISO proposes to provide details on its website concerning the results of the Large
Load Integration Study Process following its completion of the Assessment of Load Integration
and the Transmission Owners’ provision to the NYISO of the final results of the Facilities
Studies. In particular, the NYISO will notify stakeholders of the completion of the Large Load
Integration Study Process for the Group of Large Load Projects. The NYISO will post on its
website a summary in an easily accessible format that is searchable and allows users to filter the
data that provides: (i) each Large Load Project’s final amount of Firm Withdrawal Service and
Non-Firm Withdrawal Service and, if requested, its eligibility to be classified as a Zero
Withdrawal Service Load, (ii) the Network Upgrades identified for each Large Load Project as
provided by the Connecting Transmission Owner and/or Affected Transmission Owner, and (iii)
the cost of the Network Upgrades.356
The NYISO proposes that after its final reconciliation of the Eligible Customer’s costs
incurred in the Large Load Integration Study Process and Eligible Customer’s payment of all
invoices, the NYISO will proceed with the return and cancellation process for the Study Deposit
and Readiness Deposit as described in Part III.B.i.c.357
J.
Affected Systems
The NYISO proposes tariff revisions in Attachment LL to address how Affected System
impacts of load interconnections will be assessed within the New York Control Area and how
the NYISO will coordinate with neighboring regions – External Affected Systems – concerning
the impacts of load interconnections.
i.
Coordination with Affected Systems within the New York Control Area
The NYISO proposes to coordinate the conduct of any studies required to determine the
impact of the Large Load Integration Request on Affected Systems within the New York Control
354 Id. § 44.12.1.9.
355 Show Cause Order at P 82.
356 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.11.4.1.
357 Id. § 44.11.4.1.
PDF page 68
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 68
Area with Affected System Operators, as soon as they are identified.358 The NYISO will include
those results on Affected System Operators’ and Affected Transmission Owners’ systems in the
Large Load Integration Study Process within the time frame specified in the Large Load
Integration Procedures.359 The NYISO will invite such Affected System Operators to all
meetings held with the Eligible Customer as required by the Large Load Integration
Procedures.360 The Eligible Customer must cooperate with the NYISO in all matters related to
the conduct of studies and the determination of modifications to Affected Systems.361 An
Affected System Operator, the NYISO, and Connecting Transmission Owner with whom
interconnection has been requested will cooperate with each other in all matters related to the
type and/or conduct of studies and the determination of modifications to Affected Systems.362
ii.
Coordination with External Affected Systems
The NYISO proposes to establish requirements concerning how it will coordinate with its
neighboring regions – External Affected Systems – concerning the coordination and study of the
impacts of load projects proposing to interconnect in New York or in a neighboring region.363
The NYISO’s proposal to establish separate requirements for coordination with External
Affected Systems is consistent with its approach in its Standard Interconnection Procedures.
For Large Load Projects proposing to interconnect in the NYISO’s region, the NYISO
proposes to identify potential impacts on External Affected Systems during the Resource
Adequacy and Modeling Period once the Large Load Projects participating in the Group for the
Large Load Integration Study Process have been confirmed.364 At the time of initial notification,
the NYISO will provide an impacted Eligible Customer with a list of potential Affected Systems,
along with relevant contact information for such systems.365 The NYISO will coordinate the
conduct of any studies required to determine the impact of the Large Load Integration Request
on External Affected Systems with External Affected System Operators.366 Eligible Customer
will cooperate with the NYISO and External Affected System Operator in all matters related to
358 Id. § 44.13.1.1. The Affected System Operator can be identified by its own accord, by the Connecting
Transmission Owner, by the NYISO, or by members of the NYISO’s Operating Committee or Transmission
Planning Advisory Subcommittee of the NYISO’s Operating Committee. Id.
359 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.13.1.2. For identified Affected Transmission Owner(s) of facilities
that are electrically adjacent to the Point of Interconnection and that have design criteria, operational criteria, or
other local planning criteria applicable to either (1) the substation to which the Eligible Customer proposes to
interconnect; or (2) the substation that will be required to be built to accommodate the interconnection, the NYISO
will provide such Affected Transmission Owner(s) with the opportunity to review and provide comments on all
study scopes, study reports and drafts thereof for the project, and will be included on communications regarding the
project and meetings discussing the project or any of its studies, where such communications or meetings involve
the NYISO, Eligible Customer, and Connecting Transmission Owner. Id. § 44.13.1.3.
360 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.13.1.2.
361 Id. § 44.13.1.2.
362 Id. § 44.13.1.2.
363 Id. § 44.1 (definitions of External Affected System and External Affected System Operator).
364 Id. § 44.13.2.1. If the NYISO subsequently identifies additional or changes to potential impacts on an
External Affected System during the performance of the Large Load Integration Study Process, the NYISO will
notify the External Affected System Operator of the impacts. Id.
365 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.13.2.2.
366 Id. § 44.13.2.3.
PDF page 69
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 69
the conduct of studies and the determination of modifications to the External Affected
Systems.367 Any work on or impacting the External Affected System that is required for the
reliable interconnection of the Large Load Project must be completed prior to the Large Load
Project entering service.368 However, the Eligible Customer may coordinate with the NYISO,
applicable Transmission Owner(s), and External Affected System Operator concerning any
limited operation, including any related studies, prior to the required work on the External
Affected System being completed.369
iii.
Study of Impacts to New York State Transmission System of an Affected
System Eligible Customer’s Proposed Interconnection to Another Region’s
Transmission System
The NYISO proposes to establish its responsibilities when it receives notification that a
customer in another region – an Affected System Eligible Customer – is proposing to
interconnect a load project to another region’s transmission system that may impact the New
York State Transmission System.370 In such case, the NYISO will cooperate with the other
region in all matters related to the conduct of studies and the determination of modifications to
the New York State Transmission System.371
a)
Response to Notification
When the NYISO receives initial notification based on the applicable interconnection
study or restudy in another region that an Affected System Eligible Customer’s proposed
interconnection of a load project to another region’s transmission system may impact the New
York State Transmission System, the NYISO must respond in writing within 20 Business Days
whether it intends to conduct an Affected System Load Study.372 By 15 Business Days after the
NYISO responds with its affirmative intent to conduct an Affected System Load Study, the
NYISO will share with Affected System Eligible Customer(s) and its host region a non-binding
good faith estimate of the cost and the schedule to complete the Affected System Load Study.373
b)
Affected System Load Queue Position
367 Id. § 44.13.2.3.
368 Id. § 44.13.2.3.
369 Id. § 44.13.2.3.
370 Id. § 44.1 (definition of Affected System Eligible Customer).
371 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.13.3.1.
372 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.13.3.1.1.1. Within 5 Business Days of receipt of notification of a
restudy of the applicable interconnection study in another region, the NYISO will send written notification to
Affected System Eligible Customer(s) involved in the restudy and the host transmission provider that the NYISO
intends to delay a planned or in-progress Affected System Load Study until after completion of the restudy. If the
NYISO decides to delay the Affected System Load Study, it is not required to meet its obligations concerning the
Affected System Load Study until the time that it receives notification from the host transmission provider that the
restudy is complete. If the NYISO decides to move forward with its Affected System Load Study despite the
restudy, then it must meet all of the tariff requirements for the study. Id. § 44.13.3.1.1.2.
373 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.13.3.1.1.1.
PDF page 70
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 70
The NYISO proposes to assign an Affected System Load Queue Position to Affected
System Eligible Customer(s) that require(s) an Affected System Load Study.374 The Affected
System Load Queue Position will be assigned based upon the date of execution of the Affected
System Load Study Agreement.375 The NYISO will study the Affected System Eligible
Customer(s) that are all interconnecting in a particular region in a consolidated Group, and all
Affected System Eligible Customers studied in the same Group will be equally queued.376 For
Affected System Eligible Customers that are equally queued, the Affected System Load Queue
Position will have no bearing on the assignment of Affected System Network Upgrades
identified in the applicable Affected System Load Study.377 The NYISO proposes that the costs
of the Affected System Network Upgrades be allocated among the Affected System Eligible
Customers in accordance with the requirements in Attachment P to the ISO OATT as described
below.378
c)
Affected System Load Study Agreement
The NYISO proposes to provide to Affected System Eligible Customer(s) an Affected
System Load Study Agreement or a Multiparty Affected System Load Study Agreement, as
applicable, within 10 Business Days of the NYISO sharing the schedule for the Affected System
Load Study, unless otherwise agreed upon.379 The NYISO proposes to establish these form study
agreements in Appendices 4 and 5 of Attachment LL. The study agreements are consistent with
the agreements used in the NYISO’s Standard Interconnection Procedures. The NYISO will
invoice the Affected System Eligible Customer(s) for the actual cost of the Affected System
Load Study, and the NYISO will notify Affected System Eligible Customer’s host region of any
failure to pay.380
The Affected System Eligible Customer(s) must execute, as applicable, the Affected
System Load Study Agreement or Multiparty Affected System Load Study Agreement, deliver
the executed agreement to the NYISO, and provide the study deposit in the amount of $100,000
within 10 Business Days of receipt.381 If the Affected System Eligible Customer does not
provide all required technical data when it delivers the study agreement, the NYISO will notify
the deficient Affected System Eligible Customer, as well as its host region, of the technical data
deficiency within 10 Business Days of the receipt of the executed study agreement.382 The
deficient Affected System Eligible Customer must cure the technical data deficiency within 10
374 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Affected System Load Queue Position), 44.13.3.1.2.
375 Id. § 44.13.3.1.2.
376 Id. § 44.13.3.1.2.
377 Id. § 44.13.3.1.2.
378 Id. § 44.13.3.1.2.
379 Proposed OATT Attach. LL §§ 44.1 (definitions of Affected System Load Study Agreement and
Multiparty Affected System Load Study Agreement), 44.13.3.1.3.
380 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.13.3.1.3.
381 Id. § 44.13.3.1.4. If the NYISO notifies Affected System Eligible Customer(s) that it will delay the
Affected System Load Study due to a re-study in the host region, Affected System Eligible Customer(s) are neither
required to execute and return the previously tendered study agreement, nor provide the Affected System Load
Study deposit for the previously tendered study agreement. Id.
382 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.13.3.1.4.
PDF page 71
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 71
Business Days of receipt of the notice.383 This deficiency does not include failure to deliver the
executed study agreement or the deposit for study agreement.384 If Affected System Eligible
Customer does not cure the technical data deficiency within the cure period or fails to execute
the study agreement or provide the deposit, the Affected System Eligible Customer will lose its
Affected System Load Queue Position.385
d)
Scope of Affected System Load Study
For the Affected System Load Study, the NYISO proposes to use the most recent of the
base case of the latest in time Assessment of Load Integration or Short-Term Reliability Process
that is available at the time of the commencement of the Affected System Load Study.386 The
NYISO will coordinate with the Affected System Eligible Customer(s)’ host region as necessary
to align to the extent possible the network system modeling between the regions for purposes of
the Affected System Load Study.387
The NYISO will identify and notify any Transmission Owners whose systems are
potentially impacted by the Affected System Eligible Customer’s load project.388 The NYISO
and the identified Transmission Owners will develop the scope of the Affected System Load
Study.389 The NYISO will hold a scoping meeting among the NYISO, the Affected System
Eligible Customer(s) with load projects participating in the Group for the Affected System Load
Study, and the impacted Transmission Owner(s).390 The NYISO will conduct the Affected
System Load Study for a group of load projects and shall use existing studies to the extent
practicable, when multiple Affected System Eligible Customers that are part of a single group
may cause the need for Affected System Network Upgrades.391 The Affected System Load
Study will commence upon agreement between the NYISO and Transmission Owner(s)
concerning the scope of the study.392
The NYISO will evaluate the impact that Affected System Eligible Customer’s proposed
interconnection of a load project to another region’s transmission system will have on the
reliability of the Bulk Electric System portion of the New York State Transmission System using
the Transmission Security Standard.393 The Transmission Owner(s) will evaluate the impact of
the interconnection of the Affected System Eligible Customer’s load project on the non-Bulk
Electric System using the Transmission Security Standard.394 If adverse impacts to reliability are
identified, the NYISO, in coordination with the Transmission Owner, will identify potential
Affected System Network Upgrades, to the extent not Physically Infeasible, and the
383 Id. § 44.13.3.1.4.
384 Id. § 44.13.3.1.4.
385 Id. § 44.13.3.1.4.
386 Id. § 44.13.3.1.5.1.
387 Id. § 44.13.3.1.5.1.
388 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.13.3.1.5.2.
389 Id. § 44.13.3.1.5.2.
390 Id. § 44.13.3.1.5.2.
391 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Affected System Load Study), 44.13.3.1.5.2.
392 Id. § 44.13.3.1.5.2.
393 Id. § 44.13.3.1.5.3.
394 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.13.3.1.5.3.
PDF page 72
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 72
Transmission Owner will provide a preliminary indication of the cost and length of time required
or the Affected System Network Upgrades.395 The NYISO, in coordination with the
Transmission Owner(s), will develop an Affected System Load Study Report summarizing the
results of the Affected System Load Study and will provide the report to the Affected System
Eligible Customer(s) and its host region.396 Within 10 Business Days of providing the Affected
System Load Study Report to Affected System Eligible Customer(s), the NYISO, Affected
System Eligible Customer(s), and Affected Transmission Owner or Affected System Operator
will meet as permitted by schedule or availability of the parties to discuss the results of the
Affected System Load Study.397 Upon request, the NYISO will provide Affected System
Eligible Customer(s) with all supporting documentation, workpapers and relevant power flow,
short circuit and stability databases for the Affected System Load Study, subject to
confidentiality arrangements.398
e)
Evaluation of Affected System Network Upgrades
The NYISO proposes to establish requirements for the circumstance in which an Affected
System Load Study identifies that Affected System Network Upgrades are required to mitigate
adverse impacts to reliability of an Affected System Eligible Customer’s load project. In such
case, the NYISO proposes that the Affected System Eligible Customer must submit a
Transmission Interconnection Application in accordance with the requirements in the NYISO’s
Transmission Interconnection Procedures in Attachment P to the OATT for the evaluation of the
identified Affected System Network Upgrades.399 This is consistent with the NYISO’s current
practice for addressing impacts in New York of load projects proposing to interconnect in
neighboring regions.
The Affected System Network Upgrades may proceed directly to be evaluated in the
Facilities Study in the Transmission Interconnection Procedures.400 The Affected System
Eligible Customer must satisfy the requirements in Attachment P of the ISO OATT concerning
the Affected System Network Upgrades, including accepting the Affected System Eligible
Customer’s cost allocation identified in Attachment P and paying cash or posting Security for the
allocated amount.401 The Affected Transmission Owner or Affected System Operator must enter
into a construction agreement with the Affected System Eligible Customer for the construction
of the Affected System Network Upgrades.402
III.
POST-STUDY REQUIREMENTS
i.
Post-Study Agreements
395 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Affected System Network Upgrade), 44.13.3.1.5.3.
396 Id. §§ 44.1 (definition of Affected System Load Study Report), 44.13.3.1.5.3. The NYISO will not have
an obligation to study impacts of Affected System Eligible Customers of which it is not notified. Id.
397 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.13.3.1.5.3.
398 Id. § 44.13.3.1.5.3.
399 Id. § 44.13.3.1.5.4.
400 Id. § 44.13.3.1.5.4.
401 Id. § 44.13.3.1.5.4.
402 Id. § 44.13.3.1.5.4.
PDF page 73
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 73
The NYISO proposes that following the completion of the Facilities Study the Eligible
Customer for the Large Load Project may elect to continue with the proposed interconnection of
its Large Load Project by (i) entering into an interconnection agreement with the Transmission
Owner for which system the Eligible Customer proposed to interconnect its Large Load Project
and (ii), as applicable, entering into construction agreement(s) for Network Upgrades with any
Transmission Owner(s) or Affected System Operator(s) for which system a Network Upgrade is
required in connection with the Large Load Project.403 The agreements must identify any
required Attachment Facilities and Network Upgrades and specify the Large Load Project’s cost
responsibility for such facilities consistent with the terms of the applicable Transmission
Owner’s cost recovery agreement and security agreement.404 The NYISO proposes that these
agreements remain two-party agreements between the Transmission Owner and the Large Load
Project consistent with the longstanding practice under its existing load interconnection
requirements. The Transmission Owner is responsible for determining the Attachment Facilities
and Network Upgrades required for the safe and reliable interconnection of the Large Load
Project, estimating and allocating the costs of these facilities, and owns and/or operates the
system impacted by the interconnection, while the Large Load Project is responsible for paying
for the expense of the required facilities and for coordinating with the Transmission Owner
concerning the construction of the facilities. As discussed in Part VI below, the NYISO
anticipates that the Transmission Owners will include two-party security, cost recovery, and
interconnection agreements in their concurrent FPA Section 205 filing.
ii.
Transmission Service Agreement for Firm and Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service for Large Loads
In the Show Cause Order, the Commission preliminarily found the NYISO’s tariff to be
unjust and unreasonable because it lacks pro forma provisions in a transmission service
agreement between NYISO and the transmission customer taking transmission service on behalf
of a large load to memorialize operational requirements for transmission customers taking
transmission service on behalf of large loads (e.g., equipment requirements, data requirements,
remote disconnect capability).405
The NYISO proposes to establish in its OATT requirements for entering into a
Transmission Service Agreement and the proposed pro forma Transmission Service Agreement.
a)
Process for Entering into Transmission Service Agreement
The NYISO proposes to require the Eligible Customer and the Large Load (if the Large
Load is not its own Eligible Customer or Load Serving Entity) to enter into a Transmission
Service Agreement with the NYISO.406 The NYISO will offer the standard form Transmission
Service Agreement to an Eligible Customer when it submits a Completed Application, and the
403 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.14.1.
404 Id. § 44.14.1.
405 Show Cause Order at PP 63, 71.
406 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.14.2.
PDF page 74
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 74
Eligible Customer and, if applicable, the Large Load will be required to enter into the
Transmission Service Agreement in order to receive Withdrawal Service.407
b)
Pro Forma Transmission Service Agreement
The NYISO proposes to establish a new, pro forma Transmission Service Agreement for
Large Loads obtaining Firm Withdrawal Service or Non-Firm Withdrawal Service. The new
agreement will be located in Attachment B to the OATT.408
The NYISO proposes to establish certain general requirements in the Transmission
Service Agreement.409 In particular, the Transmission Service Agreement establishes that the
NYISO agrees to provide, and the Transmission Customer agrees to pay, for Firm Withdrawal
Service and/or Non-Firm Withdrawal Service in accordance with the Withdrawal Service
requirements in the OATT, other Transmission Owner rate schedules, and the terms of the
Transmission Service Agreement.410 The agreement specifies that the Transmission Customer’s
eligibility to take such service on behalf of Large Load will be determined in accordance with the
Large Load Integration Procedures in Attachment LL and other applicable requirements in the
OATT and Services Tariff.411 The agreement provides that such Withdrawal Service is subject
to adjustment in accordance with the Large Load Integration Procedures in Attachment LL, the
requirements in the Services Tariff, and the NYISO’s procedures.412
The agreement provides that the Withdrawal Service provided under the agreement will
commence on the latest of: (1) the requested service commencement date, (2) the date
construction of any Attachment Facilities and/or Network Upgrades are completed, (3) the date
that all of the applicable preconditions for obtaining the requested Withdrawal Service set forth
in the tariffs are satisfied, or (4) any such date the Withdrawal Service is permitted to commence
by the Commission.413
The NYISO also proposes to include additional requirements in the Transmission Service
Agreement that are specific to the Firm Withdrawal Service and/or the Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service for the Large Load.
For purposes of Firm Withdrawal Service, the NYISO proposes to require that the
Transmission Customer and Large Load comply with all applicable requirements in the OATT
407 Proposed OATT § 3A.4. An executed Transmission Service Agreement that contains the information
required under the tariff will be filed with the Commission, if required, in compliance with the applicable
Commission regulations. Id.
408 The new form replaces the existing service agreement placeholder form in Attachment B (OATT
Section 8), which was for Non-Firm Point to Point Transmission Service, which service, as indicated in that
placeholder form, is not available in the NYISO-administered markets.
409 Proposed Transmission Service Agreement §§ 1.0 – 8.0. The terms of the OATT and Services Tariff are
incorporated into the Transmission Service Agreement. Id. § 7.0.
410 Proposed Transmission Service Agreement § 3.0.
411 Id. § 4.0.
412 Id. § 4.0.
413 Id. § 5.0.
PDF page 75
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 75
and Services Tariff concerning Firm Withdrawal Service.414 This includes the Transmission
Customer’s compliance with the requirements in the Services Tariff concerning Co-Located and
Limited Load Configurations, Partner Resource Arrangements, and Co-Located Arrangements.
This also includes the Large Load’s compliance with the requirements for load modifications and
increases and the requirements concerning the performance, protection and control, and
monitoring requirements set forth in Attachment LL of the OATT.
For purposes of Non-Firm Withdrawal Service, the NYISO proposes to require that the
Transmission Customer and Large Load comply with all applicable requirements in the OATT
and Services Tariff concerning Non-Firm Withdrawal Service.415 This includes the
Transmission Customer’s compliance with the requirement in the Service Tariff concerning Co-
Located and Limited Load Configurations and the bid cap and other bid restrictions. This also
includes the Large Load’s compliance with the requirements for load modifications and increases
and the requirements concerning the performance, protection and control, and monitoring
requirements set forth in Attachment LL of the OATT. In addition, the agreement provides for
the Large Load’s agreement to be subject to the Non-Firm Withdrawal Service Bid Cap,
applicable bidding requirements, and all other related requirements set forth in the NYISO’s
tariffs. Finally, the agreement provides for the Large Load’s agreement to be subject to and to
comply with additional curtailment requirements and any other requirements specifically
applicable to Large Loads as set forth in the NYISO’s tariffs.
iii.
Large Load Performance, Protection and Control, and Monitoring
Requirements
In the Show Cause Order, the Commission preliminarily found the NYISO’s tariff to be
unjust and unreasonable because it lacks provisions that address ongoing operational
requirements for transmission customers serving large loads necessary to ensure reliable
operation of the transmission system.416 The NYISO proposes to establish operational
requirements for Large Load in its tariffs as described below and in the Nguyen Affidavit.417 In
particular, the NYISO proposes that a Large Load that was subject to the Large Load Integration
Procedures must comply with Applicable Reliability Standards, including providing to the
NYISO and applicable Transmission Owner(s) all information that they may reasonably require
to comply with Applicable Laws and Regulations and Applicable Reliability Standards.418 In
addition, the NYISO proposes that the Large Load must satisfy performance, protection and
control, and monitoring requirements described below that will be included in the OATT and
further detailed in the NYISO’s procedures, unless the NYISO agrees to an exemption to a
requirement.419 The NYISO proposes to explicitly require in the Transmission Service
414 Id. §§ 9.0 - 10.0.
415 Id. §§ 11.0 – 14.0.
416 Show Cause Order at P 63.
417 Nguyen Affidavit at PP 38-41.
418 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.14.3. The NYISO proposes to define Applicable Reliability Standards
for Attachment LL as “the requirements and guidelines of the Applicable Reliability Councils, and the Transmission
District to which the Large Load is directly interconnected, as those requirements and guidelines are amended and
modified and in effect from time to time.” Id. § 44.1 (definition of Applicable Reliability Standards).
419 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.14.3.
PDF page 76
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 76
Agreement that the Large Load must comply with these performance, protection and control, and
monitoring requirements.420
The NYISO proposes performance, protection and control, and operating requirements as
detailed below that address the Commission’s findings in the Show Cause Order (which
requirements identified with an asterisk are eligible for an exemption as described below).
First, the Commission found that the NYISO’s existing tariff does not specify the ramp
rate or ride-through requirements with which the transmission customer taking transmission
service on behalf of the large load must comply.421 The NYISO proposes to include in
Attachment LL that a Large Load must satisfy the following categories of performance
requirements, which will be detailed in the NYISO’s procedures: (i) active power ramp rate*, (ii)
active power recovery*, (iii) high and low voltage ride through*, (iv) high and low frequency
ride through*, (v) multi-disturbance ride through*, (vi) stable operation, (vii) torsional and
controller interaction, (viii) cycling, (ix) reactive power capability requirement*, and (x) voltage
phase jump*.422
Second, the Commission found that the NYISO’s existing tariff does not: (i) specify that
transmission customer enable the NYISO to remotely disconnect large loads when necessary to
maintain reliability of the transmission system, with the costs of such equipment directly
assigned to the transmission customer, as well as the terms and conditions under which NYISO
may remotely disconnect the large load (e.g., emergency conditions, so that transmission
equipment is not harmed) or (ii) require necessary control technologies and/or protection systems
that may be necessary to limit a transmission customer’s withdrawals from the transmission
system as appropriate.423 The NYISO proposes to include in Attachment LL that a Large Load
must satisfy the following protection and control requirements: (i) remote disconnect ability by
the Connecting Transmission Owner, (ii) active-power variation monitoring relays,* and (iii)
injection and withdrawal limits for co-located facilities implemented with appropriate
controls.424
Finally, the Commission identified that the NYISO’s existing tariff does not specify that:
(i) transmission customer provide hourly forecasts, telemetry data, and other data to ensure
sufficient visibility or specify requirements for maintaining communication channels between
NYISO and the transmission customer on behalf of the large load, or (ii) that the transmission
owner install, and transmission customer pay for, equipment to enable the NYISO to monitor
large loads for impacts of, for example, fast-ramping load that may impact the transmission
system too quickly to be captured by conventional data acquisition systems (e.g., the need for
phasor measurement units or similar equipment).425 The NYISO proposes to include in
Attachment LL that a Large Load must possess the following minimum telemetry requirements
to ensure sufficient visibility concerning the Large Load: (i) phase 1 analog metering, (ii)
420 Proposed OATT Attach. B §§ 10.0, 12.0.
421 Show Cause Order at P 63.
422 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.14.3.1.
423 Show Cause Order at P 63.
424 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.14.3.2.
425 Show Cause Order at P 70.
PDF page 77
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 77
revenue grade metering, (iii) SCADA MW/MVAR metering, (iv) digital fault recorder (“DFR”),
(v) phasor measurement unit (“PMU”) installations, (vi) sequence of event recorder (“SER”),
and (vii) dynamic disturbance recorder (“DDR”).426 The communications equipment will
facilitate the provision of the data to the NYISO identified in the Show Cause Order, with the
exception of load forecast data, which reporting requirements will be addressed in accordance
with updated NYISO procedures.
The NYISO proposes that an Eligible Customer for a Large Load that is a Non-
Computational Large Load may request that the NYISO grant an exemption from a performance
or a protection and control requirement that is eligible for exemption.427 The operational
characteristics of Non-Computational Large Loads, such as traditional manufacturing facilities,
are driven by the physical attributes of the load and may not be able to meet certain of the
performance or protection and control requirements (e.g., ramp rates that do not align with a
reasonable operation of the facility).
The Eligible Customer for a Non-Computational Large Load may request the exemption
as part of its Large Load Integration Request or through a modification request.428 To request an
exemption, the Eligible Customer must identify the requirement for which it is requesting an
exemption, provide justification for why the requirement cannot be met, and propose an
alternative to the requirement.429 If the request is part of a modification request, the Eligible
Customer must also provide technical rationale to support that the proposed alternative would
not adversely impact the reliability of the New York State Transmission System.430 The NYISO
or the applicable Transmission Owner may perform studies, at Eligible Customer’s expense, to
determine if the proposed alternative is permissible. The NYISO will not grant an exemption if it
is determined to create reliability concerns or a reliability violation.431
iv.
Status of Large Load Project and Associated Network Upgrades
The NYISO proposes to establish monitoring requirements for Large Load Projects and
associated Network Upgrades that are consistent with the monitoring rules in its Standard
Interconnection Procedures.432 In particular, at: (i) the completion of the first calendar quarter
after the NYISO’s posting of the final results of the Assessment of Load Integration and (ii) the
conclusion of each subsequent calendar quarter, the Eligible Customer or Transmission
Customer, as applicable, for the Large Load Project and its respective Connecting Transmission
Owner(s) and any Affected Transmission Owner(s) must report on the status of the Large Load
426 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.14.3.3.
427 Id. § 44.14.3.4. A Non-Computational Large Load is a Large Load Project that does not meet the
definition of a Computational Large Load. The NYISO proposes to define Computational Large Load as “a Large
Load Project that primarily consists of information technology infrastructure used for: (i) creating, executing, and
delivering software applications and services, (ii) artificial intelligence training, development, and delivery, (iii)
cryptocurrency mining, or (iv) other computational activities at a data center.” Id. § 44.1 (definitions of
Computational Large Load and Non-Computational Large Load).
428 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.14.3.4.
429 Id. § 44.14.3.4.
430 Id. § 44.14.3.4.
431 Id. § 44.14.3.4.
432 See OATT Attach. HH § 40.11.6.
PDF page 78
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 78
Project and any associated Network Upgrades, including the progress of the milestones in the
applicable interconnection or construction agreement(s) in a format consistent with, and
including the content required by, the NYISO’s procedures.433
B.
Additional Requirements
i.
Study Cost Allocation, Invoicing, and Deposit Requirements
The NYISO proposes to establish tariff requirements that describe the Eligible
Customer’s cost responsibilities for the study work in the Large Load Integration Procedures, the
invoicing and payment requirements for these study costs, and the rules for the use and refund of
deposits provided under these procedures.434 These requirements are based on the similar
requirements in the NYISO’s Standard Interconnection Procedures.435
a)
Study Cost Responsibility and Allocation of Study Costs
The NYISO proposes that it will charge, and the Eligible Customer will pay, the actual
costs of the study work incurred by the NYISO and Transmission Owner for the Large Load
Integration Study Process, after the Eligible Customer has submitted its Large Load Integration
Request.436 The NYISO proposes to allocate the costs of the Large Load Integration Study
Process among the Eligible Customers for their projects participating in the process so that the
Eligible Customer is only responsible for the costs associated with the study of its particular
project. In particular, each Eligible Customer must pay an equal share of the Large Load
Integration Study Process costs except for the study of Attachment Facilities, which are specific
to each project.437 For Attachment Facilities, the Eligible Customer must pay the actual costs of
studying the Attachment Facilities for its own project(s).438 If more than one Large Load Project
contributes to the need for particular Attachment Facilities, those Large Load Projects will share
equally in the cost to study those Attachment Facilities.439
For an Affected System Load Study, the NYISO proposes that it will charge, and the
Affected System Eligible Customer will pay, the actual costs of the study work of that study.440
The NYISO proposes to allocate such costs among Affected System Eligible Customers
participating in the Affected System Load Study, so that each project participating in the study
must pay an equal share of the study costs required for the identification of the need for any
Affected System Network Upgrades.441 If more than one project contributes to the need for
433 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.14.4.
434 Id. § 44.15.4.
435 See OATT Attach. HH § 40.24.3
436 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.15.4.1.1. For purposes of the Facilities Study that is conducted by a
Transmission Owner, the applicable Transmission Owner will charge and the Eligible Customer will pay the actual
costs of the study work incurred by the Transmission Owner for that study. Id. § 44.15.4.1.2.
437 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.15.4.2.1.
438 Id. § 44.15.4.2.1.
439 Id. § 44.15.4.2.1.
440 Id. § 44.15.4.1.1.
441 Id. § 44.15.4.2.3.
PDF page 79
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 79
particular Affected System Network Upgrades, those projects will share equally in the cost to
study the Affected System Network Upgrades.442
Finally, for requested modifications to load facilities and projects, the NYISO proposes
that it will charge, and the entity that submitted a Load Modification Request will pay, the actual
costs of the NYISO’s review and any required studies for the Load Modification Request.
The NYISO’s proposed approach allocates study costs in accordance with cost causation
principles to the particular entities responsible for such costs in place of a more general
allocation of costs.
b)
Invoicing and Payment Requirements
The NYISO proposes to invoice an Eligible Customer on a monthly basis for study
costs.443 A monthly invoicing approach is consistent with how the NYISO invoices customers in
its other interconnection process and provides transparency to customers of their study costs
throughout the study process and timely reimbursement of costs incurred by the NYISO.
The Eligible Customer must pay the invoiced amount to the NYISO within thirty 30
Calendar Days of the NYISO’s issuance of the invoice.444 Except as otherwise provided in the
billing dispute rules, if the Eligible Customer does not pay its invoice within this period, it will
be subject to withdrawal and will be assessed interest on any unpaid invoiced amounts calculated
in accordance with section 35.19a(a)(2) of FERC’s regulations.445 To dispute an invoiced
amount, an Eligible Customer must (i) timely pay any undisputed amounts to the NYISO and (ii)
pay into an independent escrow account the portion of the invoice in dispute, pending resolution
of such dispute.446 If the Eligible Customer fails to meet these two requirements, then neither the
NYISO nor Transmission Owner is obligated to perform or continue to perform any study work
on behalf of the Eligible Customer’s Large Load Integration Request, Load Modification
Request, or Affected System Load Study.447 A billing dispute will be addressed through the
dispute resolution procedures set forth for the Large Load Integration Procedures as described in
Part III.B.i.b.448 Within thirty 30 Calendar Days after resolution of the dispute, the Eligible
Customer will pay the NYISO any amounts due with interest actually earned on such amounts.449
Any invoices for the Transition Large Load Integration Study Process, the Large Load
Integration Study Process, any study resulting from a Load Modification Request, or an Affected
System Load Study must be submitted to the NYISO within 60 days of completion of the subject
study and must include a detailed and itemized accounting of the incurred cost of the applicable
442 Id. § 44.15.4.2.3.
443 Id § 44.15.4.3.1. For purposes of the invoicing and payment provisions requirements, the Eligible
Customer includes: (i) the Eligible Customer that submits a Large Load Integration Request, (ii) the entity that
submits a Large Load Modification Request, or (iii) an Affected System Eligible Customer. Id.
444 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.15.4.3.2.
445 Id § 44.15.4.3.2.
446 Id § 44.15.4.3.5.
447 Id §§ 44.15.4.3.5, 44.15.4.3.6.
448 Id § 44.15.4.3.5.
449 Id § 44.15.4.3.5.
PDF page 80
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 80
study work.450 After the conclusion of the applicable study or if, prior to the conclusion of the
process, the Eligible Customer withdraws its applicable request or the request is withdrawn by
the NYISO from the Load Queue, the NYISO will issue a final invoice to Eligible Customer,
which Eligible Customer must pay within the 30 Calendar Day period.451
c)
Requirements Applicable to Fees and Deposits
The NYISO proposes to permit entities to provide their required deposits (e.g., Study
Deposits, Readiness Deposits) for the Large Load Integration Study Process in the form of cash,
a letter of credit, or a surety bond, while they must satisfy any fees using cash (e.g., the
application fee).452
The NYISO proposes to clarify in Attachment LL its requirements for accepting cash,
letters of credit, or surety bonds for deposits.453 These requirements are consistent with the
NYISO’s existing credit requirements under its tariffs applicable to Market Participants and its
requirements for fees and deposits in its Standard Interconnection Procedures.454
The NYISO also proposes to specify how it will hold and apply such deposits, refund any
cash deposits, and/or provide authorization to the entity that provided the deposit to request that
the issuing entity cancel a letter of credit or surety bond.455 In particular, the NYISO will hold
deposits provided by an Eligible Customer until settlement of the final invoices. If an Eligible
Customer has not paid all invoices, the NYISO will recover any unpaid costs from Eligible
Customer’s deposits. After the NYISO has recovered all unpaid costs, if any, from Eligible
Customer’s deposits, the NYISO will (i) refund to the Eligible Customer any remaining
refundable cash portion of its deposits, and (ii) provide written authorization for Eligible
Customer to request that the bank cancel any remaining letter of credit or surety bond provided
as a deposit.
These invoicing, payment, and deposit rules do not apply to the Facilities Study or to the
requirements under the Facilities Study agreement, security agreement, cost recovery agreement,
or interconnection agreement that the Transmission Owners will submit in their separate Section
205 filing(s).
ii.
Confidentiality Requirements
The NYISO proposes to include in its Large Load Integration Procedures requirements
concerning the treatment of Confidential Information exchanged by the parties during the
administration of the procedures.456 In particular, the NYISO proposes to use the same
450 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.15.4.3.4.
451 Id § 44.15.4.3.4.
452 The forms of deposits are for deposits submitted to the NYISO and do not apply to any deposits or
security provided to a Transmission Owner in connection with the Facilities Study, which deposit or security is held
by the Transmission Owner.
453 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.15.3.
454 See Services Tariff Attach. K §§ 26.6.1.1, 26.6.1.2; OATT Attach. HH § 40.2.4.
455 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.15.4.3.3.
456 Id. § 44.15.1.
PDF page 81
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 81
confidentiality approach that is included in its Standard Interconnection Procedures in
Attachment HH of the OATT.457
iii.
Dispute Resolution Requirements
The NYISO proposes to establish that a party may address a dispute that arises out of or
in connection with the Large Load Integration Procedures or their performance in accordance
with its standard dispute resolution procedures set forth in Article 11 of the NYISO’s Services
Tariff.458 Pursuant to these procedures, parties first attempt to resolve a dispute through informal
discussions.459 If the dispute is not resolved, the parties may agree to proceed with non-binding
mediation or arbitration as further detailed in Article 11, or may commence legal proceedings
before the Commission or a court of competent jurisdiction.460
iv.
Third Party Conducting Studies
The NYISO proposes to establish requirements for the use of third parties to conduct
study work under the Large Load Integration Procedures that is generally consistent with the
similar requirements for its Standard Interconnection Procedures.461 In particular, the NYISO
proposes that the NYISO, a Transmission Owner, or an Affected System Operator may use a
Transmission Owner or other third party to perform its respective obligations under the Large
Load Integration Procedures.462 The NYISO proposes that the use of a third party be limited to
situations where the NYISO determines that doing so will help maintain or accelerate the study
process.463 Such third-party consultants must comply with the relevant NYISO OATT,
procedures, and protocols as would apply if the NYISO were to conduct the study process and
must use the information provided to it solely for purposes of performing such services and for
no other purposes.464
v.
Additional Requirements
The NYISO proposes to include in the Large Load Integration Procedures certain process
requirements concerning data requirements, limitations of liability, and reserved rights that are
based on related requirements in its Standard Interconnection Procedures in Attachment HH of
the OATT, which requirements the Commission has previously accepted as just and reasonable.
457 See OATT Attach. HH § 40.24.1. The confidentiality requirements in the Standard Interconnection
Procedures were based on the requirements in the Commission’s pro forma Large Generator Interconnection
Procedures.
458 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.15.6.
459 Services Tariff § 11.3.
460 Id. § 11.4.
461 See OATT Attach. HH § 40.24.4. The NYISO’s proposed requirements align with these requirements,
except that it does not include the reference from Section 40.24.4 to the subcontractors provision in the Standard
Interconnection Agreement.
462 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.15.5.
463 Id. § 44.15.5.
464 Id. § 44.15.5.
PDF page 82
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 82
First, the NYISO proposes to establish that Eligible Customers must provide the NYISO
with all data necessary to make the determinations contemplated by the rules in the Large Load
Integration Procedures and the NYISO’s procedures.465 In addition, the NYISO proposes to
require that the NYISO or Transmission Owner, as applicable, provide power flow, short circuit,
and stability databases, including all underlying assumptions and contingency lists, to the
Eligible Customer upon request.466
Second, the NYISO proposes to clarify that all obligations of the NYISO or a
Transmission Owner pursuant to the Large Load Integration Procedures in Attachment LL of the
OATT are services or associated with services under the NYISO’s OATT and subject to the
limitation of liability requirements contained in the body of the OATT.467
Third, the NYISO proposes to clarify that nothing in the Large Load Integration
Procedures restricts the rights of any person under the NYISO’s OATT or the right of any person
to file a complaint with the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission under the relevant
provisions of the Federal Power Act or under the Independent System Operator Agreement,
Independent System Operator/Transmission Owner Agreement, or an Operating Agreement with
the NYISO.468
Finally, the NYISO proposes to clarify that any Connecting Transmission Owner’s or
Affected Transmission Owner’s implementation and construction of Network Upgrades will be
in accordance with the NYISO’s OATT, Commission-approved ISO Related Agreements, the
Federal Power Act and Commission precedent, and, therefore, will be subject to the Connecting
Transmission Owner’s or Affected Transmission Owner’s right to recover, pursuant to
appropriate financial arrangements contained in agreements or Commission-approved tariffs, all
reasonably incurred costs, plus a reasonable return on investment.469
IV.
THE NYISO’S PROPOSED TARIFF REVISIONS TO ESTABLISH NEW
MARKET PARTICIPATION PROVISIONS APPLICABLE TO LARGE LOADS
A.
Overview of Key Market Design Elements
The NYISO proposes market participation rules for (1) Large Loads eligible to take Firm
Withdrawal Service (referred to herein as “Full Withdrawal Service Loads”); (2) Large Loads or
465 Id. § 44.3.3; cf. OATT Attach. HH § 40.2.9.
466 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.3.2; cf. OATT Attach. HH § 40.2.6. The parties must treat
Confidential Information in accordance with the confidentiality requirements for the Large Load Integration
Procedures, and the NYISO and Connecting Transmission Owner may require that Eligible Customers and
password-protected website users sign a non-disclosure agreement before the release of Confidential Information or
Critical Energy Infrastructure Information in the base case data. Id.
467 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.3.4; cf. OATT Attach. HH § 40.2.10.
468 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.3.5; cf. OATT Attach. HH § 40.2.11.
469 Proposed OATT Attach. LL § 44.3.6; cf. OATT Attach. HH § 40.9.8.7. ISO Related Agreements is
defined as “[c]ollectively, the ISO Agreement, the NYSRC Agreement, the ISO/NYSRC Agreement, the ISO/TO
Agreement, and Operating Agreements.” OATT § 1.9.
PDF page 83
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 83
portions thereof and an Associated Resource(s)470 that enter into a Co-Located Arrangement471 or
Partner Resource Arrangement472 in order to allow the Large Load to take some amount of Firm
Withdrawal Service; (3) Large Loads or portions thereof taking Non-Firm Withdrawal Service
and/or are designated Zero Withdrawal Service Loads, which are known collectively as “Limited
Withdrawal Service Loads”; and (4) the co-location of Large Loads with generation.473
Full Withdrawal Service Loads are Large Loads that do not adversely impact resource
adequacy and/or transmission security or have appropriately mitigated such impacts and are
deemed eligible for full Firm Withdrawal Service, as determined in the LLIP. Such a Large
Load may use the NYS Transmission System and participate in the markets in the same way as
other existing Firm service Load that currently participates in the ISO Administered Markets.
Consistent with existing Load bidding rules, a Transmission Customer serving a Large Load
taking only Firm Withdrawal Service shall not be required to, but may, submit Day-Ahead Bids
for the Large Load.474
A Large Load that is seeking Firm Withdrawal Service and has been identified in the
LLIP as causing impermissible adverse impacts on resource adequacy may pair with a new
Installed Capacity Supplier through a (1) a Co-Located Arrangement with an Associated
470 An “Associated Resource” shall be defined as “[a] Co-Located Resource or Partner Resource that may
mitigate some or all of a Large Load’s adverse impacts to resource adequacy and/or transmission security identified
in the LLIP set forth in Attachment LL of the ISO OATT, which allows the respective Co-Located Load or Large
Load to take some amount of Firm Withdrawal Service.” See Services Tariff § 2.1. An Associated Resource must
be (a) a proposed project that does not yet meet the inclusion rules for the Reliability Planning Process at the time
the Large Load Integration Request is validated in accordance with Section 44.6.5 of Attachment LL of the ISO
OATT; (b) a new Installed Capacity Supplier; and (c) otherwise satisfy the applicable requirements set forth in
Section 44.6.4 of Attachment LL of the ISO OATT. See id.
471 A “Co-Located Arrangement” shall be defined as “[a]n agreement between a Co-Located Load and a
Co-Located Resource(s) for the purpose of enabling the Co-Located Load to take some amount of Firm Withdrawal
Service, consistent with Section 4.1.12 of the ISO Services Tariff and Attachment B of the ISO OATT. The Co-
Located Resource(s) and the associated Co-Located Load must be behind the same Point of Interconnection and
must jointly submit an attestation in accordance with Section 44.6.3.5 of Attachment LL of the ISO OATT. A Co-
Located Arrangement may be between: (1) a Co-Located Load taking solely Firm Withdrawal Service and a Co-
Located Resource or (2) a Co-Located Load and Co-Located Resource in a CLLC. The Co-Located Arrangement
shall have a required minimum duration of fifteen (15) years, starting the first day of the Obligation Procurement
Period for which the UCAP equivalent of ICAP documented in the Large Load Bilateral Transaction is initially
certified, in accordance with ISO Services Tariff Sections 5.11.2 and 5.13.1 and ISO Procedures.” See Services
Tariff § 2.3.
472 A “Partner Resource Arrangement” shall be defined as “[a]n agreement between Partner Resource(s)
and a Large Load that are electrically located in the same Capacity Region for the purpose of enabling the Large
Load to take Firm Withdrawal Service, consistent with Section 4.1.12 of the ISO Services Tariff and Attachment B
of the ISO OATT. The Partner Resource(s) and the Large Load must jointly submit an attestation in accordance with
Section 44.6.3.5 of Attachment LL of the ISO OATT. The Partner Resource Arrangement shall have a required
minimum duration of fifteen (15) years, starting the first day of the Obligation Procurement Period for which the
UCAP equivalent of ICAP documented in the applicable Large Load Bilateral Transaction is initially certified, in
accordance with Sections 5.11.2 and 5.13.1 of the ISO Services Tariff and ISO Procedures.” See Services Tarif §
2.16.
473 A “Limited Withdrawal Service Load” is a “Large Load taking any amount of Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service and/or is a Zero Withdrawal Service Load in a CLLC. A Zero Withdrawal Service Load in a CLGC is not a
Limited Withdrawal Service Load.” See Services Tariff § 2.12
474 See proposed Services Tariff § 4.2.1.9.
PDF page 84
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 84
Resource(s) or (2) a Partner Resource Arrangement with an Associated Resource(s) in order to
be eligible to receive some amount of Firm Withdrawal Service. A Co-Located Arrangement is
an agreement between a Co-Located Load475 and a Co-Located Resource(s)476 that are connected
behind the same Point of Interconnection for the purpose of enabling the Load to take some
amount of Firm Withdrawal Service.477 A Partner Resource Arrangement is an agreement
between Partner Resource(s) 478 and a Large Load that are electrically located in the same
Capacity Region for the purpose of enabling the Large Load to take Firm Withdrawal Service.479
Among other requirements, an Associated Resource must be a new Installed Capacity
Supplier.480 Note that, if an existing Installed Capacity Supplier that has retired, its Capacity
Resource Interconnection Service (“CRIS”) rights have expired, and chooses to re-enter the ISO
Administered Markets by proceeding back through the Standard Interconnection Procedures
through which it must obtain new CRIS rights, it shall be considered a new Installed Capacity
Supplier481 that may participate as an Associated Resource, with caveats for Aggregations and
Demand Side Resources.482 These arrangements shall have a required duration of a fifteen (15)
year term, as further discussed below in Part IV.F.483
Limited Withdrawal Service Loads, whether participating as standalone Non-Firm
Withdrawal Service Load or in a co-located configuration or is partially a Zero Withdrawal
Service Load, will be required to utilize the NYISO’s newly proposed Co-Located and Limited
Load Configuration (“CLLC”) participation model. A CLLC shall participate in the NYISO-
administered Energy markets as a single Resource and must follow the ISO’s dispatch
475 A “Co-Located Load” shall be defined as “[a] Large Load connected behind the same Point of
Interconnection as a Co-Located Resource.” See Services Tariff § 2.3.
476 A “Co-Located Resource” shall be “[a] Resource connected behind the same Point of Interconnection as
a Co-Located Load.” See Services Tariff § 2.3. A Co-Located Resource may include an Energy Limited Resource;
an Energy Storage Resource; a Generator without a PURPA contract(s); a Hybrid Storage Resource; an Intermittent
Power Resource; a Limited Control Run of River Hydro Resource; and a Demand Side Resource that is participating
as a standalone Distributed Energy Resource. See id. An Aggregation is not a Co-Located Resource. A Co-
Located Local Generator is not a Co-Located Resource.
477 See proposed Services Tariff § 4.1.12; proposed OATT Attach. B.
478 A “Partner Resource” shall be “[a] Resource that has been identified by an Eligible Customer, and
confirmed by the Resource developer, to be associated with a Large Load, which is electrically located in the same
Capacity Region, that may mitigate some or all of its adverse impacts to resource adequacy and/or transmission
security identified in the LLIP set forth in Attachment LL of the ISO OATT and is not connected to the same Point
of Interconnection as the Large Load in the applicable Partner Resource Arrangement.” See Services Tariff § 2.16.
Partner Resources may include an Aggregation, or an Energy Limited Resource, Energy Storage Resource,
Generator without a PURPA contract(s), Hybrid Storage Resource, Special Case Resource, Intermittent Power
Resource, Limited Control Run of River Hydro Resource, System Resource, or a standalone Demand Side Resource.
See id. Partner Resources must comply with all applicable market rules contained in Section 5.12 of the Services
Tariff for their respective Resource type. See id. § 5.12.1.
479 See proposed Services Tariff § 4.1.12; proposed OATT Attach. B.
480 See supra note 470.
481 See Services Tariff § 5.18.6; see OATT § 40.2.3.6.
482 Note, however, that the retired Installed Capacity Supplier would be required to complete the generator
interconnection process in order to enter into an Associated Resource arrangement with a Large Load. See Part
II.G.i.a.
483 See proposed Services Tarif § 4.1.12.
PDF page 85
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 85
instructions.484 A CLLC shall be required to submit Energy Bids consistent with the Withdrawal
Service(s) being taken by its composite Limited Withdrawal Service Load.485 Any portion of a
Limited Withdrawal Service Load participating in a CLLC that is taking Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service shall be subject to a nodal $200/MWh maximum Bid Price, which is the main
mechanism by which NYISO will enforce the mandatory curtailment of these Limited
Withdrawal Service Loads when doing so is necessary to avoid adverse impacts to resource
adequacy and/or transmission security.486
The NYISO proposes assessing fees and charges to all Large Loads, regardless of
Withdrawal Service classification, on a Gross Load 487 basis, consistent with the Commission’s
preliminary finding that the NYISO’s Tariff may be “unjust and unreasonable because it allows
load with behind the meter generation to net its behind the meter generation against its load for
purposes of calculating Transmission Service Charges”488 and expressed concern that the
NYISO’s Tariff does not appear to include a “mechanism by which an Eligible Customer []
would be charged for ancillary services commensurate with its usage of such services,
particularly if such customer did not withdraw energy from the transmission system.”489 In
addition, a System Reliability Benefit Fee shall be assessed to the LSE taking service on behalf
of a Large Load associated with the MW of (1) the portion of a Limited Withdrawal Service
Load(s) that is not taking Firm Withdrawal Service and/or (2) a Co-Located Local Load(s).
Lastly, the NYISO proposes revisions to the settlement rules to ensure that Large Loads are
assessed the appropriate charges and fees in a manner that is at least roughly commensurate with
the benefits that entity receives and to incorporate the new Gross Load basis construct in
accordance with the cost causation principle.490
Finally, the NYISO proposes to include Associated Resources that have satisfied the
applicable Partner Resource Arrangement or Co-Located Arrangement requirements under the
definition of “Excluded Facilities” with respect to conduct warranting mitigation and thus, such
Associated Resources would be excluded from examination under the NYISO’s buyer-side
capacity market power mitigation measures as discussed below in Part IV.J and in the Newton
Affidavit.491
B.
Market Rules Applicable to Full Withdrawal Service and Limited Withdrawal
Service Loads
484 See Services Tariff § 2.3.
485 See proposed Services Tariff § 4.2.1.9.1; see also id. §§ 4.4.1.1, 4.4.1.2, 4.4.2.1.
486 See proposed Services Tariff § 21.4.7.
487 “Gross Load” shall be defined at the actual Energy consumption value of a Large Load. See proposed
revision to Services Tariff Section 2.7. Gross Load shall be measured by separate and direct real-time telemetry and
a revenue quality real-time meter at the Load, not the Point of Interconnection and irrespective of whether or not this
consumption was met by withdrawals at the Point of Interconnection, consistent with Section 13 of the ISO Services
Tariff. See id.
488 Show Cause Order at P 110.
489 Id. at P 106.
490 See proposed revisions to Services Tariff § 7.4.
491 See proposed revision to Services Tariff § 23.2.1; see also Jonathan Newton Affidavit.
PDF page 86
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 86
i.
Firm Withdrawal Service Loads
Large Loads that are eligible to receive Firm Withdrawal Service for their full amount of
Load are fully represented in the Load forecasts that inform the IRM, LCRs, and ultimately
ICAP auction outcomes, and submit traditional Load bids according to existing Load bidding
rules, may register as Demand Side Resources (with limitations), and are not eligible to
participate in the NYISO’s proposed CLLC model.
As discussed in the attached affidavit of Zachary T. Smith, the NYISO’s Director of
Market Solutions (“Smith Affidavit”), it is reasonable for Large Loads or the portions thereof
that are receiving Firm Withdrawal Service to be included in the load forecast for the IRM and
LCRs.492 This inclusion is the foundation of the NYISO’s obligation to provide Firm
Withdrawal Service continuously and regardless of price, consistent with the way that firm
transmission service is provided to existing load resources in the NYISO today.
It is also reasonable for Full Withdrawal Service Large Loads to engage with the markets
using the NYISO’s established Load bidding rules. The Large Load’s LSE may submit Fixed or
Price Capped Load bids in the Day-Ahead Market on the Large Load’s behalf or voluntarily
choose to be served in real-time at the Real-Time LBMP.
The NYISO is proposing to settle Large Loads with Firm Withdrawal Service for Energy
in substantially the same manner as existing Loads receiving firm transmission service are settled
for Energy today.
ii.
Limited Withdrawal Service Loads
“Limited Withdrawal Service Loads” are Large Loads that are taking some amount of
Non-Firm Withdrawal Service and/or are, in part or in full, a Zero Withdrawal Service Load.
This includes Large Loads that are taking, in part but not in full, some amount of Firm
Withdrawal Service. Limited Withdrawal Service Loads are: (i) completely or partially excluded
from the Load forecasts used to establish the IRM and LCRs; (ii) therefore subject to some
amount of the System Reliability Benefits Fee; (iii) submit (negative) Energy withdrawal bids to
consume Energy from the grid or, when co-located with supply, a single net Energy bid; (iv) are
ineligible to register as Demand Side Resources; and (v) are required to participate in the
proposed CLLC participation model. The CLLC participation model is a single unified result that
can simultaneously support both the standalone and co-located participation of Limited
Withdrawal Service Loads. Though the CLLC ruleset is singular, there are specific stipulations
for Zero Withdrawal Service Load and NFWS Load contained therein. To the extent that a
Limited Withdrawal Service Load is also a Co-Located Local Load, it will be modeled as
belonging to a Co-Located Local Generator Configuration (“CLGC”) that neither withdraws
from nor injects onto the system.
a)
Exclusion of Limited Withdrawal Service Large Loads from
Capacity Forecasts and Capacity Markets
492 Zachary T. Smith Affidavit at P 16 (“Smith Affidavit”).
PDF page 87
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 87
Large Loads taking Non-Firm Withdrawal Service will be excluded from the Load
Forecasts used in establishing the Installed Reserve Margin and Locational Minimum Installed
Capacity Requirement.493 Accordingly, the NYISO will not be obligated to serve Large Loads
taking Non-Firm Withdrawal Service during peak hours, and such Large Loads will have no right
to consume Energy during times of peak demand. Unlike Firm Withdrawal Service, Large
Loads taking Non-Firm Withdrawal Service will not be eligible to participate in NYISO Demand
Side Resource programs.494
It is appropriate to exclude Large Loads or the portion thereof that are receiving Non-
Firm Withdrawal Service or are ZWS Load from capacity-related Load Forecasts because they
do not contribute to their LSEs’ minimum ICAP market obligations, and their demand does not
clear in the ICAP market auctions. No entity will procure ICAP on behalf of these
aforementioned types of Load through the ICAP market auctions, or through other means, like a
Capacity market bilateral. As a result, these Large Loads are excluded from traditional ICAP
charges. However, these Large Loads still benefit from the stability provided by Capacity
Resources in hours in which the Large Load is eligible to withdraw Energy from the
transmission system, despite these Large Loads having not cleared in the ICAP market auction.
Therefore, the NYISO will require Large Loads or the portions thereof that are taking Non-Firm
Withdrawal Service or are ZWS Load to pay a System Reliability Benefit Fee as discussed
below in Part IV.B.ii.g. These requirements help to protect customers by incentivizing these
Large Loads to voluntarily take the measures necessary to obtain Full Withdrawal Rights.
Because Large Loads receiving Non-Firm Withdrawal Service are non-firm customers, it
is appropriate that the NYISO is not obliged to redispatch to continue service to them until the
curtailment threshold described in Part IV.B.ii.b below is reached. It is likewise reasonable that
such Large Loads have no right to consume Energy during such times.
b)
The Non-Firm Bid Cap and Out-of-Merit Requirements for Limited
Withdrawal Service Loads
The NYISO proposes to add new language to Section 21 (Attachment F) of the Services
Tariff which governs bidding restrictions. Proposed new Section 21.4.7, “Large Loads
Participating in a CLLC” would establish that “[t]he portion of a Large Load participating in a
CLLC that is taking Non-Firm Withdrawal Service shall be subject to a $200/MWh maximum
Bid Price . . . .” The proposed tariff provision notes that this “is the mechanism by which these
Large Loads are interruptible/curtailed to avoid adverse impacts to the grid.” By contrast, Large
Loads with Firm Withdrawal Service will not be subject to the proposed bid cap. They will be
curtailed on the same basis and with the same priority as firm transmission service loads that
exist in the NYISO today, i.e., only for reliability emergencies per NYISO’s existing emergency
procedures.
The NYISO is also proposing to include language in new OATT Section 3A.1.2 to
establish that Large Loads taking Non-Firm Withdrawal Service “shall timely respond to ISO or
493 Proposed Services Tariff § 5.11.1.
494 Proposed OATT § 3A.1.2.
PDF page 88
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 88
Transmission Owner Out-of-Merit instructions, including instructions to reduce withdrawals or
disconnect when necessary to maintain system reliability, consistent with ISO Procedures.”
Explanation of the NYISO’s Proposal
NYISO currently uses Constraint Specific Shortage Pricing (“CSSP”) to represent the
price impact that transmission shortages have on LBMPs. The CSSP is supported by a six-step
Transmission Demand Curve representing transmission shortage prices that increase in tandem
with further utilization of a transmission facility’s Constraint Reliability Margin (“CRM”). The
CRM is a portion of transmission facility transmission capacity that the NYISO has reserved
between a predetermined market limit and the facility’s hard limit, i.e. its line rating, which
serves to insulate the NYCA transmission system from severe overload risk by allowing
transmission scarcity to be reflected in market prices. In times of severe transmission scarcity,
i.e. when a transmission facility reaches 100% CRM utilization, flows across a transmission
facility will near or meet the facility’s line rating and the facility’s Transmission Demand Curve
will produce a transmission constraint price of $4,000/MWh.
The NERC Transmission Loading Relief (“TLR”) process is used to filter/sort external
transactions for curtailment, based on a transaction’s ability to affect flows across a given
flowgate. This process uses an individual transaction quantity-share de minimis threshold of 5%
when determining whether the curtailment of an individual transaction will materially impact
flows across a given flowgate. The NYISO applied similar materiality logic to the CSSP
construct, specifically to the Transmission Demand Curve, in determining the $200/MWh bid
price cap for NFWS Loads.
The NYISO will use the 5% materiality threshold used in the NERC TLR process in
determining which NFWS Loads have material impact on flows across a binding transmission
constraint, i.e. an NFWS Load that has a minimum Shift Factor of 5% on a transmission
constraint will be considered to have material impact on flows across that constraint. As
discussed, when the Transmission Demand Curve binds at 100% CRM utilization, it produces a
price of $4,000/MWh on the associated transmission constraint. NYISO believes this is the point
at which it becomes most appropriate to ensure NFWS Loads that exacerbate this constraint are
curtailed. An NFWS Load whose Shift Factor meets the 5% materiality threshold described
above would, except in rare cases, receive a nodal price of $200/MWh when the correlated
transmission constraint produces a $4,000/MWh price. By aligning the NFWS Load bid cap with
this $200/MWh nodal LBMP, NYISO ensures that NFWS Loads that meet the 5% materiality
threshold are curtailed automatically by the market optimization when the CRM of a relevant
transmission facility is fully utilized, preventing the Large Load from exacerbating the constraint
further and avoiding manual intervention by NYISO Grid Operators.
The proposed bid cap ensures that Non-Firm Withdrawal Service Large Loads will be
curtailed in advance of significant transmission security or resource adequacy shortage events. It
also increases the probability that Non-Firm Withdrawal Service Loads that most aggravate a
given transmission constraint, i.e. those with higher Shift Factors on a given constraint, will be
curtailed in advance of those that do not. This results in a natural precipitation of NFWS Load
curtailment priority that is grounded directly in reliability and automated by NYISO’s
PDF page 89
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 89
optimization. It will benefit customers by helping to prevent Large Loads from driving up
LBMPs and will also help to reduce the likelihood of reliability issues.
Some stakeholders have suggested that a single $200/MWh bid cap would be
insufficiently flexible and could be too low of a dollar figure especially in times of high winter
fuel costs. However as the Smith Affidavit explains, it will not be feasible for the NYISO to
adopt fuel indexing for the bid cap, or for other potentially relevant market parameters, in the
near-term, especially in the expedited timeframe that the Commission has allowed for responses
to the Show Cause Order.495 Additionally, during the course of the stakeholder sessions, the
argument has also been made that the $200/MWh Bid cap may be set below the non-firm Large
Load's true cost of curtailment and therefore could lead to inefficient pricing signals. However,
this is not a persuasive reason to opt for a different non-firm Bid price cap level for several
reasons, including the fact that the Large Load has voluntarily elected non-firm service, which is
a lower level of service compared to firm service.
Use of a bid cap to effectuate the necessary curtailment of non-firm service is an
effective, fair, and efficient implementing mechanism. Moreover, the claim, that the threshold
may be set below the non-firm Load’s true cost of curtailment could be true of all bid cap levels,
including alternative bid caps of $1000/MWh or $2000/MWh. It is possible that many Limited
Withdrawal Service Loads would be willing to consume above the $200/MWh threshold.
However, allowing Large Loads to offer in at any level under an alternative Bid cap of
$1000/MWh or $2000/MWh would lead to distorted outcomes and market signals. First, any
curtailments that the NYISO would need to effectuate in order to properly ensure reliability
would be required to be handled outside the market software, in an “ad hoc” manner, and could
result in there being schedules that are inconsistent with prices. Second, it is possible that many
of these non-firm loads would remain willing to consume above even $2000/MWh As such, the
NYISO contends that the $200/MWh Bid Cap proposal is necessary to protect reliability, and is
just and reasonable.
In order to effectuate this price cap, and to ensure that Large Loads taking NFWS are
responding to the $200/MWh nodal LBMP curtailment threshold in Real-Time as mandated by
the terms of their Withdrawal Service, NYISO proposes to model these Loads as negative
generation, akin to the way it models the Energy Withdrawal portion of an Energy Storage
Resource (“ESR”). This modeling approach extends to all types of Limited Withdrawal Service
Loads, i.e. all Loads that participate using the CLLC participation model. This means that, like a
Generator, the Market Participant representing a Limited Withdrawal Service Load will need to
submit an 11-point incremental Energy Withdrawal bid to the NYISO’s market optimization in
each interval in which the Load seeks to consume Energy from the grid. Like an ESR that
submits an Energy Withdrawal Bid, the Large Load’s bids will be evaluated by the optimization,
and the Load will subsequently be dispatched for discrete amounts of Energy Withdrawals
according to the economics of their bids and the physical characteristics of the Load. The Market
Participant may, but is not required to, specify multiple $/MWh price points in its Energy
Withdrawal Bid that represent the NFWS Load’s willingness to pay for Energy at different price
495 See Smith Affidavit at P 25.
PDF page 90
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 90
points below the $200/MWh NFWS nodal LBMP bid cap. Doing so effectively expands the
price sensitivity of the NFWS Load.
The Smith Affidavit emphasizes that the NYISO’s proposed rules and requirements for
Non-Firm Withdrawal Service Large Loads reflect a “a reasonable, market-based approach that
is consistent with the NYISO’s broader market design proposal and existing rules and
frameworks.”496 The newly proposed Non-Firm Withdrawal Service should be found to be just
and reasonable, as it provides Large Loads with an option to connect to the grid faster and
without the potential delays required to mitigate adverse impacts to resource adequacy and/or
transmission security.
The Harvey Affidavit provides additional support for the market design, operational, and
reliability advantages of the curtailment proposal.497 Dr. Harvey explains that the NYISO’s
proposal functions very similarly to the Commission-approved Southwest Power Pool (“SPP”)
non-firm service curtailment rules and also appears to be consistent with proposals made in the
PJM Co-Location Order proceedings.498 At the same time, the NYISO’s proposal is “more
concrete and amenable to modeling in unit commitment and interchange scheduling software, as
well as real-time dispatch software than the general hierarchy of load shedding articulated by
PJM or the general criteria in the SPP tariff.”499 In addition, “the NYISO price-based curtailment
threshold is also forward looking and could identify the need to reduce non-firm load not just
immediately before shedding of firm load is necessary, but identify the need to reduce non-firm
load in order to help assure that shedding of firm load will not become necessary in future hours
because of the impact of meeting that non-firm load on gas availability or battery state of
charge.”500
Dr. Harvey also contends that the NYISO’s proposed use of a price based curtailment
trigger would provide greater transparency to Large Loads served via Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service501 and be more consistent with the overall evolution of organized markets away from
reliance on operator judgment and towards the use of sophisticated modeling tools.502 He
maintains that relying on a price-based curtailment rule will reinforce reliability, help to
maximize the utilization of the transmission system, and be practically administrable by the
NYISO.
Moreover, Dr. Harvey supports the NYISO’s selection of a $200/MWh bid price cap
level as “reasonable and appropriate from a number of perspectives” including market pricing
considerations, compatibility with market initiatives that the NYISO may pursue in the future,
and suitability for the evolving resource mix.503
496 Smith Affidavit at P 24.
497 See Harvey Affidavit at Section III.
498 Id. at PP 53-57.
499 Id. at P 56.
500 Id.
501 Id. at P 58.
502 Id. at P 59.
503 Id. at PP 63-70.
PDF page 91
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 91
The Curtailment Proposal Is Commission-Jurisdictional
The NYISO is mindful that there questions may be raised regarding the jurisdictional
status of its curtailment proposal. In particular, the Commission recently rejected substantial
portions of PJM’s proposal to introduce an “Interim Resource Adequacy Service” (“IRAS”) and
Bring Your Own New Capacity framework in its region.504 PJM defined IRAS as “a load
reduction service through which New Large Loads reduce load as directed by the applicable
Electric Distributor[.]”505 Among other determinations, the Commission found that PJM’s
proposed tariff language appeared to be setting a retail rate because it would have established a
“compensation rate for IRAS payable to the Eligible New Large Load.”506 Notably, the
Commission stated that “a non-firm transmission service similar to Non-Firm Contract Demand
transmission service, with appropriate adjustments, might be considered as a potential avenue to
achieve some of the aims of PJM’s proposed IRAS framework.”507
By contrast, the NYISO neither proposes to mandate any load reduction service of the
kind presented IRAS or otherwise, nor proposes any form of compensation for such a service.
Rather, the NYISO is proposing to provide Transmission Customers taking service on behalf of
Large Loads and Large Loads acting as their own LSEs with a new Commission-jurisdictional
non-firm transmission service option with attributes similar to Non-Firm Contract Demand
service, with appropriate adjustments,508 which aligns with the Commission’s guidance set forth
in the IRAS Order.
Unlike PJM under IRAS, the NYISO would not curtail NITS, or any other form of firm
transmission service, to similarly situated firm loads. Instead, the NYISO is proposing a new
category of service to differently situated loads (i.e., loads voluntarily choosing to be served via
Non-Firm Withdrawal Service instead of Firm Withdrawal Service.) The possibility of
curtailment is a necessary component of Non-Firm Withdrawal Service because it ensures the
reliability of the NYISO’s wholesale markets and transmission system during elevated demand
conditions.509 A Large Load receiving Non-Firm Withdrawal Service will have been studied and
found to have adverse impacts resource adequacy impacts that it has chosen not to mitigate. The
NYISO would not simply be relegating the Large Load to inferior service based on
characteristics that touch on retail jurisdictional domains.
Additionally, a CLLC is not entitled to compensation when it is curtailed under Non-Firm
Withdrawal Service. Mandatory curtailment of Limited Withdrawal Service Loads when
capacity exceeds the nodal $200/MWh price threshold is required to avoid adverse impacts to
resource adequacy and/or transmission security. The NYISO’s proposed bid cap is a condition to
504 PJM Interconnection, L.L.C., 197 FERC ¶ 61,019 (2026) (“PJM IRAS Order”).
505 Id. at P 81.
506 Id. at P 82.
507 Id. at P 111.
508 As is discussed in Part V, below, the NYISO is not proposing to adopt the Non-Firm Contract Demand
Service in the form specified in the PJM Co-Location Order.
509 Cf. id. P 91 (“Data Center Coalition and Vistra also argue that PJM misread the SPP CHILLS precedent,
which they argue supports offering different services to differently situated loads but not reducing NITS for Electric
Distributors serving materially identical loads.”)
PDF page 92
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 92
the receipt of Commission-jurisdictional non-firm transmission service and is a wholesale market
design mechanism that exists in the wholesale energy space. The proposed NYISO tariff
obligation runs to the CLLC (or a Transmission Customer taking service on its behalf) as a
wholesale market participant, the wholesale market dictates whether the Large Load will be
curtailed, and the NYISO does not impose any charge on a retail customer. The NYISO’s
proposal falls within the bounds of the Commission’s jurisdiction. And the NYISO’s proposal
does not impermissibly intrude on state authority 510
The NYISO’s curtailment proposal is much closer to SPP’s Conditional High Impact
Large Load Service (“CHILLS”), which the Commission accepted earlier this year,511 than it is
to IRAS. SPP proposed CHILLS as a new, non-firm transmission service that would enable high
impact large loads to take transmission service prior to having the sufficient designated resources
or network upgrades in place that are required for long-term, firm service.512 CHILLS is subject
to curtailment and interruption on a non-discriminatory basis when the transmission system is
constrained.513 CHILLS has equal curtailment priority to SPP’s monthly non-firm point-to-point
transmission service.514 As noted in Part V, the NYISO does not currently offer any form of
non-firm transmission service but Non-Firm Withdrawal Service, like CHILLS and pro forma
OATT non-firm service, would be curtailed before firm transmission service in NYISO.
The NYISO’s proposal shares many features that the Commission found significant in
accepting CHILLS. As with CHILLS, the NYISO’s Non-Firm Withdrawal Service is a new non-
firm service and curtailment is an integral part of that service priority level. The curtailment
obligation also is implemented through an objective standard that would be part of the NYISO’s
Commission-jurisdictional wholesale market framework as opposed to curtailment via a
discretionary directive to a retail customer. There is also no retail compensation mechanism for
curtailment. The CHILLS Order is thus precedent for the NYISO’s Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service curtailment rule being subject to the Commission’s jurisdiction.
Finally, as the NYISO noted with respect to the State Exempt Large Load Project
proposal, courts have found that the intent underlying a regulatory requirement is an important
part of drawing jurisdictional lines under the FPA’s cooperative federalism framework. Here
again, the NYISO has no intention of interfering with or intruding into New York State
jurisdiction. The NYISO is instead adapting well-established Commission-jurisdictional rules
allowing transmission providers to curtail Commission-jurisdictional non-firm services to fit the
NYISO’s Large Load market participation model.
510 See Tri-State Generation & Transmission Ass’n, 196 FERC ¶ 61,127, at PP 66–68 (2026) (finding that
Tri-State’s proposal did not intrude upon retail rate regulation where, among other things, it did not establish terms
or conditions of retail service).
511 See Sw. Power Pool, Inc., 195 FERC ¶ 61,196 (2026) (“SPP CHILLS Order”). The Commission found
that SPP demonstrated that the terms and conditions for its proposed CHILLS are just and reasonable, specifically
noting that the terms and conditions were “substantially similar to those of existing transmission services” and that
the differences from those existing transmission services were “narrowly tailored to reflect” the nature and
characteristics of the CHILLS. Id. at P 84.
512 Id. PP 6–7.
513 Id. P 10.
514 Id. P 86.
PDF page 93
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 93
c)
Excluding Limited Withdrawal Service Loads from Participation as
Demand Side Resources
The NYISO is proposing to exclude Limited Withdrawal Service Loads, i.e., Loads that
are not fully served via Firm Withdrawal Service, from participation in the ISO Administered
Markets as a Demand Side Resource (e.g., Special Case Resource (“SCR”), Emergency Demand
Response Program (“EDRP”), Distributed Energy Resource (“DER”) and Aggregations).515 It is
reasonable to make Large Loads taking NFWS ineligible to receive compensation for demand
reductions because Large Loads taking this service have voluntarily elected to take a lower level
of transmission service in order to either avoid paying for Network Upgrades or to avoid
bringing new ICAP supply to market to mitigate any resource adequacy and/or transmission
security impacts they may cause, as determined in the LLIP. Non-Firm Withdrawal Service
Large Loads, by definition, are not entitled to consume Energy from the system at any time.
Accordingly, NFWS Large Loads are not in a position to voluntarily reduce their consumption of
Energy from the grid at all, let alone do so during the specific hours in which there would be a
net benefit to the system and/or other customers by virtue of their voluntary demand reduction.516
It follows that Large Loads taking NFWS are excluded from the Load forecasts that
inform the Installed Reserve Margin (“IRM”) and Locational Minimum Installed Capacity
Requirements (“LCRs”), do not create an ICAP obligation for their LSE and therefore Capacity
Resources are not procured on their behalf through the ICAP auctions. Large Loads with NFWS
are not similarly situated to those with Firm Withdrawal Service.
When a Large Load with Firm Withdrawal Service voluntarily registers to participate in
the ISO Administered Markets as a Demand Side Resource, it is agreeing to forego its Firm
Withdrawal Service Rights, i.e. agreeing to voluntarily curtail its Load, in exchange for payment
when the requisite net benefit threshold is met. This payment is justified because the absence of a
Large Load making its typical withdrawals from the system via its Firm Withdrawal Service
during peak hours reduces NYISO’s net on-peak Capacity obligations and when the net benefits
test is met and hence, the overall benefit of the reduced LBMP that results from dispatching such
FWS Large Loads to reduce their consumption exceeds the cost of dispatching the more
expensive generation resources.517 In other words, by qualifying as an ICAP Supplier and
offering ICAP at auction, a Firm Withdrawal Service Load is reducing the net impact that its
Load has on the outcomes of the ICAP market auctions, and reduces its LSE’s net ICAP
obligations as a result.
In sum, Large Loads with Firm Withdrawal Service may elect to participate as a Demand
Side Resource in the NYISO markets and thus receive compensation for voluntary demand
reductions during hours in which there is a net benefit to other customers and the system for
515 See, e.g., proposed Services Tariff § 2.4.
516 See Demand Response Compensation in Organized Wholesale Energy Markets, Order No. 745, 76 Fed.
Reg. 16,658 (Mar. 24, 2011), FERC Stats. & Regs. ¶ 31,322 (2011) (“Order 745”). “Rather than requiring
compensation at LMP in all hours, the Commission requires the use of the net benefits test described herein to
ensure that the overall benefit of the reduced LMP that results from dispatching demand response resources exceeds
the cost of dispatching those resources.” Id. at P 150 (emphasis added).
517 See Order 745 at P 150.
PDF page 94
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 94
them to do so. Whereas Large Loads with Non-Firm Withdrawal Service have elected to receive
a lower level of transmission service and are not entitled to withdraw, or refrain from
withdrawing, in exchange for demand reduction compensation. This justification extends to
ZWS Loads as well, which are Large Loads that lack any right to withdraw from the system, or
voluntarily refrain from withdrawing, altogether. Non-firm Large Loads are far from being
similarly situated to Large Loads with Firm service.
d)
Market Participation Provisions Applicable to Limited Withdrawal
Service Loads that Receive “Partial” Firm Withdrawal Service
As previously stated, Large Loads taking some amount of Firm Withdrawal Service
along with some amount of Non-Firm Withdrawal Service and/or that are partially Zero
Withdrawal Service Loads, will be classified as Limited Withdrawal Service Load and must
participate under the CLLC participation model. Like with other CLLCs, these “partial” Firm
Withdrawal Service Large Loads will still be required to submit Energy Bids in the Day-Ahead
Market whenever they seek to withdraw from the grid and will need to be dispatchable. It will be
possible for Market Participants to “preserve” their Firm Withdrawal rights when participating
under the CLLC participation model through the structuring of their bids, such that CLLC
scheduling outcomes honor the Large Load’s right to in part consume Energy from the grid
regardless of price.518
e)
Market Rules Applicable to Zero Withdrawal Service Loads
(“ZWSL”)
The NYISO is proposing to add new language to the Services Tariff to address the
treatment of ZWSLs. The introduction of a defined ZWSL voluntary option and related market
rules is responsive to the Show Cause Order’s observation that the NYISO’s tariffs did “not
appear to include a mechanism by which an Eligible Customer, on behalf of Eligible Load,
would be charged for ancillary services commensurate with its usage of such services,
particularly if such customer did not withdraw energy from the transmission system.”519 The
ZWSL proposal is also compatible and practically implementable within the framework of the
NYISO’s market design and financial reservation transmission model.
The new ZWSL designation applies to a Large Load or portion thereof that is not
permitted to physically withdraw Energy from the NYS Transmission System or has requested
not to withdraw Energy from the NYS Transmission System and is served exclusively by a Co-
Located Resource(s) or Co-Located Local Generator. The ZWSL designation is only relevant to
co-located configurations, i.e., Large Load that cannot be served by front-of-the-meter
generation or that a Market Participant has requested not be served by front-of-the-meter
generation. ZWSL are not studied for and do not receive eligibility to receive any Withdrawal
Services through the LLIP, i.e., do not have a right to withdraw from the grid to serve their Load.
ZWSL status is similar to the BTM:NG Host Load concept under NYISO’s existing
design, in that ZWSL is Load that exists behind-the-meter and is served exclusively by behind-
518 See Smith Affidavit at P 68.
519 Show Cause Order at P 106.
PDF page 95
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 95
the-meter generation, which may or may not offer excess generator capability to the system via
participation in the CLLC participation model. BTM:NG Host Loads effectively function and
participate in the NYISO markets under this construct today.
Co-Located Local Generators are providing service behind the meter to ZWSL and are
not requesting, or permitted to inject any Energy onto the system. They are therefore not
required to obtain Energy Resource Interconnection Service (“ERIS”) or CRIS. These Co-
Located Local Generators may still request ERIS and/or CRIS rights if they are able and willing
to offer excess operating capacity supply into the market that is not needed to support the ZWSL.
A Large Load that is a full ZWSL that is supplied solely by a co-located Generator(s) that
lacks ERIS/CRIS and exists solely to serve the Zero Withdrawal Service Load are respectively
referred to as a Co-Located Local Load and a Co-Located Local Generator. If the resulting co-
located configuration is interconnected and synchronized to the NYS Transmission System, the
configuration will be classified as a Co-Located Local Generator Configuration (“CLGC”). Such
a configuration does not interface with the NYISO markets but, consistent with the general rule
for ZWSL, would be subject to the Gross Load cost allocation methodology described in Part
IV.B.ii.f and to the System Reliability Benefit Fee described in Part IV.B.ii.g.
The ZWSL option may be attractive if it aligns with potential market participant’s
business objectives or use cases, e.g., if the value of a faster development timeline makes it
worthwhile for a Large Load to elect to take this option.520 For example, if a Co-Located
Facility’s Point of Withdrawal is undersized relative to the amount of Load that is seeking to
interconnect behind-the-meter, some or all of that Load may choose to classify as ZWSL and be
served exclusively by behind-the-meter generation.
ZWS Load is subject to the Gross Load cost allocation methodology described in Part
IV.B.ii.f as it is, by definition, interconnected and synchronized to the NYS Transmission
System and therefore benefits from the stability provided by Ancillary and Transmission
Services. ZWS Load is additionally subject to the SRBF discussed in Part IV.B.ii.g. This is
consistent with the Show Cause Order’s expressed concern that the NYISO’s Tariff does not
appear to include a “mechanism by which an Eligible Customer [] would be charged for ancillary
services commensurate with its usage of such services, particularly if such customer did not
withdraw energy from the transmission system.”521
As such, the NYISO’s proposal to provide a participation framework for Zero
Withdrawal Service Loads appropriately accommodates the unique operating characteristics of
this type of Large Load and is just and reasonable.
f)
Allocating Costs to Large Loads on a Gross Load Basis
The Show Cause Order preliminarily found that the NYISO’s tariff appears to be unjust
and unreasonable because it does not address whether or how Eligible Customers taking
transmission services on behalf of Eligible Loads will be charged for their use of regulation and
520 Smith Affidavit at P 40.
521 Show Cause Order at PP 106-107.
PDF page 96
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 96
black start services, creating a risk that Eligible Load may benefit from these services without
contributing to cost recovery for such services.522 In response to the Commission’s concern, and
to ensure that Eligible Customers taking transmission service on behalf of Eligible Load pay for
wholesale transmission services that they receive, consistent with the cost causation principle,523
the NYISO proposes to assess fees and charges to all Large Loads on a gross Load basis.524 This
treatment will include, but is not limited to, assessment on a Gross Load Basis of Operating
Reserves Charges, Black Start Charges, Voltage Support Service Charges, and Regulation
Service Charges.525 The NYISO would implement this change via proposed amendments to
OATT Sections 6.2, 6.3, and 6.5.
Applying these charges to all Large Loads on a Gross Load basis, regardless of
Withdrawal Rights, rather than on a Net Load basis, will help to prevent unreasonable cost
shifting to existing Loads and thus to protect customers.
g)
The System Reliability Benefit Fee
The NYISO proposes to assess a System Reliability Benefit Fee (“SRBF”) under new
OATT Section 6.24. The SRBF would be “assessed to an LSE associated with the MW of (a)
the portion of a Limited Withdrawal Service Load(s) that is not taking Firm Withdrawal Service
and/or (b) a Co-Located Local Load(s) that is not included in the applicable LSE’s portion of
Unforced Capacity Obligation the NYCA Minimum Unforced Capacity Requirement, in
accordance with Section 5.11.1 of the Services Tariff.”
The purpose of the SRBF is to allocate ICAP market costs Limited Withdrawal Service
Loads, or portions thereof, not taking Firm Withdrawal Service in an amount roughly
commensurate to the benefits they receive from ICAP Resources and the value of the reliability
service that they provide during periods of low demand. The SRBF will serve as a cost allocator
for these Large Loads, which will benefit from reliable service despite not being required to pay
ICAP market costs.
As discussed in the Smith Affidavit,526 the SRBF will be assessed to the LSE taking
service on behalf of a Limited Withdrawal Large Service Load.527 It is not a volumetric charge
based on actual Large Load energy withdrawals, Instead, it will be based on the amount of Non-
Firm Withdrawal Service or Zero Withdrawal Service MW studied and authorized through the
LLIP. By tying the SRBF to authorized MW rather than actual MWh, the NYISO will charge
these Large Loads for the reliability benefits they receive from the NYISO capacity market.
Without the SRBF, these Large Loads would benefit from stable and reliable system operations
without contributing correspondingly to the costs incurred to maintain those operations. The
522 Id. at P 107.
523 Id. at P 103.
524 The fact that the NYISO is proposing to adopt a gross load basis assessment under FPA section 205
should not be construed as a concession that the NYISO’s existing tariffs are unjust, unreasonable, or unduly
discriminatory or preferential
525 See Proposed OATT §§ 6.2, 6.3, and 6.5.
526 See Smith Affidavit at PP 46-51.
527 Proposed OATT § 6.24.
PDF page 97
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 97
SRBF will also create an incentive for Large Loads taking any amount of Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service or Zero Withdrawal Service to acquire full Firm Withdrawal Service rights.
Under OATT Section 6.24, the SRBF will be calculated as follows.
SRBFCm = (NFWS LoadCm + ZWS LoadCm ) * ((NYCA IRMm ) * (NYCA Capacity Translation
Factorm)) + NYCA excess %m) * Spot Market Auction Clearing PriceCm
Where:
𝑆𝑅𝐵𝐹𝐶𝑚 = the System Reliability Benefit Fee assessed to the LSE responsible for
the kW associated with the portion of Limited Withdrawal Service Load C that is
not taking Firm Withdrawal Service or Co-Located Local Load C for month m;
𝑁𝐹𝑊𝑆 𝐿𝑜𝑎𝑑𝐶𝑚 = the amount of kW associated with the portion of a Limited
Withdrawal Service Load or Co-Located Local Load C taking Non-Firm
Withdrawal Service supplied by the LSE for month m;
𝑍𝑊𝑆 𝐿𝑜𝑎𝑑𝐶𝑚 = the amount of kW associated with the portion of a Limited
Withdrawal Service Load or Co-Located Local Load C classified as a Zero
Withdrawal Service Load for month m;
𝑁𝑌𝐶𝐴 𝐼𝑅𝑀𝑚 = the NYCA Installed Reserve Margin or the NYCA Winter
Installed Reserve Margin that is in effect for the NYCA for month m;
NYCA Capacity Translation Factorm = the ratio of (i) NYCA Minimum Unforced
Capacity Requirement for month m; and (ii) NYCA Minimum Installed Capacity
Requirements in effect for month m;
NYCA excess %m = the ratio of (i) the additional UCAP procured in excess of the
NYCA Minimum Unforced Capacity Requirement as reported in the ICAP Spot
Market Auction results for NYCA for month m; and (ii) NYCA Minimum
Unforced Capacity Requirement as reported in the ICAP Spot Market Auction
results for NYCA for month m;
Spot Market Auction Clearing PriceCm = the applicable ICAP Spot Market
Auction Clearing Price for month m for the Capacity Region in which that
Limited Withdrawal Service Load or Co-Located Local Load C is electrically
located.
Assessing the SRBF on these Large Loads will generate residual rents because these
Loads do not clear in the ICAP auction and the charges collected from them are not allocated
through any existing process. The NYISO is proposing a new allocation methodology that will
assign these residuals to such LSEs based on LSEs’ share of the total NYCA-wide ICAP
PDF page 98
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 98
obligation.528 This methodology will mitigate LSEs’ Capacity costs as well as, potentially, costs
to customers.
The SRBF proposal is responsive to the Show Cause Order’s preliminary finding that the
NYISO’s Tariff appears to be unjust and unreasonable because it “lacks adequate mechanisms to
mitigate the risk of cost shifting among transmission customers, which may result in unjust and
unreasonable rates for transmission service.”529
C.
Proposed Large Load Operating Requirements
The NYISO proposes to revise Sections 3.5.2 and 13 of the Services Tariff to require
Transmission Customers taking service on behalf of Large Loads to submit the following
information to the NYISO: (i) six-second Real-Time telemetry; (ii) hourly revenue-grade meter
data; (iii) Day-Ahead and hourly real-time load forecasts; (iv) PMU data and Phase 1 metering,
as applicable; (v) separate and direct metering of Load at co-located facilities; and (vi) other
information and data in accordance with ISO Procedures. Transmission Customers will also be
required to submit all data, telemetry, operating information, and control documentation for
Large Loads on a facility-specific basis.530 These requirements ensure that the NYISO has
necessary operational visibility into and control over Large Loads, which will result in more
accurate and reliable market solutions and operator decisions. Having clear operational
requirements in place also protects customer interests by minimizing the need for costly out-of-
market actions to account for changes in Large Load behavior.
As discussed in the Smith Affidavit, the NYISO’s proposal will expressly preserve
Connecting Transmission Owners’ (“CTOs”) authority to remotely disconnect Large Loads
when necessary to maintain reliability of the transmission system.531 It would also allow the
NYISO to request that a CTO remotely disconnect a Large Load for reliability reasons. In
addition, the NYISO and/or CTO may request disconnection of a CLLC or a CLGC to avoid
impermissible injections and/or withdrawals. These actions are expected to be consistent with
existing operating and communication procedures that exist today with transmission owners. 532
This proposal is responsive to the Show Cause Order’s directive that the NYISO’s Tariff
should include provisions addressing ongoing operational requirements for transmission
customers taking transmission service on behalf of large load.533 The Commission specifically
highlighted the absence of provisions requiring transmission customers to provide the NYISO
hourly forecasts, telemetry data, and other data necessary to ensure sufficient visibility, as well
as requirements for maintaining communication channels between the NYISO and the
Transmission Customers on behalf of the large load.534
528 See proposed Services Tariff § 6.24 (“Residuals created by the System Reliability Benefit Fee shall be
allocated to LSEs based on their share of the applicable NYCA Minimum Unforced Capacity Requirement.”).
529 Show Cause Order at P 72.
530 See Proposed Services Tariff Section 3.5.2.
531 Smith Affidavit at P 52.
532 Smith Affidavit at P 52.
533 Show Cause Order at P 70.
534 Id.
PDF page 99
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 99
D.
Additional CLLC Rules
i.
Overview and Eligibility
As noted above, the NYISO is proposing to establish and describe a new market
participation model in the Services Tariff for Co-Located Arrangements535—the Co-Located and
Limited Load Configuration (“CLLC”) framework.
ii.
CLLC-Specific Definitions
The NYISO proposes several definitions related to co-location. In particular, the NYISO
proposes to define CLLC as:
A configuration that consists of (a) a Co-Located Load that is a
Limited Withdrawal Service Load participating with one or more
Co-Located Resources, in accordance with Section 4.1.12 of the
ISO Services Tariff, or (b) a stand-alone Limited Withdrawal
Service Load. All components of the CLLC must be located
behind a single Point of Interconnection. A Large Load taking only
Firm Withdrawal Service may not participate in a CLLC.
A Co-Located Resource(s) participating in a CLLC may not
participate in the ISO Administered Markets through any other
participation model. A Co-Located Resource that is a Hybrid
Storage Resource cannot participate in a CLLC.
The CLLC shall participate in the ISO-administered Energy and
Ancillary Services markets as a single Resource that is capable of
following the ISO’s dispatch instructions. In order to qualify for
wholesale market participation, a CLLC must be able to inject or
withdraw at least 1 MW of Energy to/from the transmission
system. A CLLC will be required to submit Energy Bids consistent
with the Withdrawal Service(s) being taken by the Co-Located
Load and the manner in which the Market Participant seeks to
exercise those Withdrawal Service rights within a given real-time
market interval. The Co-Located Resource(s) in a CLLC shall
participate in the ISO-administered Installed Capacity market as a
single ICAP Supplier referred to as a Composite Co-Located
Resource.536
535 A Co-Located Arrangement is an agreement between a Co-Located Load and a Co-Located Resource(s)
that are connected behind the same Point of Interconnection, which is entered into for the purpose of enabling the
Co-Located Load to take some amount of Firm Withdrawal Service.
536 Proposed Services Tariff Section 2.3.
PDF page 100
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 100
The NYISO also proposes the following CLLC-related definitions:537
Co-Located Load: A Large Load connected behind the same
Point of Interconnection as a Co-Located Resource. A Co-Located
Load may include an ESR in a CLLC in which all withdrawals of
the ESR are settled as Load, in accordance with Section 4.1.12.1 of
the ISO Services Tariff.
Co-Located Resource: A Resource connected behind the same
Point of Interconnection as a Co-Located Load. A Co-Located
Resource may include an Energy Limited Resource; an Energy
Storage Resource; a Generator without a PURPA contract(s); a
Hybrid Storage Resource; an Intermittent Power Resource; a
Limited Control Run of River Hydro Resource; and a Demand
Side Resource that is participating as a standalone Distributed
Energy Resource. A Co-Located Local Generator is not a Co-
Located Resource.
Composite Co-Located Resource: One or more Co-Located
Resource(s) within a CLLC that participates in the ISO-
administered Installed Capacity market as a single Installed
Capacity Supplier.
Withdrawal Scheduling Limit: The maximum amount of MW
associated with a CLLC that is registered as eligible for withdrawal
scheduling by the NYISO.
Zero Withdrawal Service Load: A Large Load or portion thereof
that is not authorized under the ISO OATT to withdraw Energy
from the NYS Transmission System. A Zero Withdrawal Service
Load is either (a) a Limited Withdrawal Service Load in a CLLC
or (b) a Co-Located Local Load in a CLGC. Energy consumption
by Zero Withdrawal Service Loads shall be metered and included
in Gross Load.
The NYISO proposes to clarify that an ESR, as defined in Services Tariff Section 2.5,
that participates in a CLLC shall follow the rules set forth in Section 4.1.12.1 of the Services
Tariff.”538 The NYISO also proposes conforming revisions to the definitions of Resource,
Supplier, Installed Capacity Supplier, Lower Operating Limit, Minimum Generation Bid and
Minimum Generation Level, and Station Power to integrate the CLLC.
The NYISO’s definition of Co-Located Resource is broad, encompassing Resource types
such as HSR, CSR, and others. This is intentional – the Co-Located Resource definition is
intended to be applied broadly to contexts external to the CLLC participation model, such as the
537 Id.
538 Id.
PDF page 101
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 101
Co-Located Arrangement construct. A subset of Co-Located Resources, i.e. Generators that do
not utilize other participation models, will be eligible to participate in a CLLC. For example,
storage is a CLLC-eligible technology type, but storage participating in a CLLC will not be able
to utilize the NYISO’s Energy Storage Resource participation model rules. This is to prevent
Market Participants from creating nested Aggregations, such as locating an HSR within a CLLC,
and to maintain a distinct participation model that can support the integration of Load and
Generation into a single co-located facility.
Demand Side Resources are ineligible to participate in the CLLC participation model by
default. In order to participate in a CLLC, any composite Load would have to be classified as
Limited Withdrawal Service Load, which disqualifies the Load from qualifying for Demand
Response compensation. However, Load flexibility can still be reflected in the CLLC’s net
Energy bid, and may be reflected in other aspects of CLLC performance such as DMNC tests.
This enables the CLLC Market Participant to utilize Load flexibility in effectuating greater net
injections onto the grid, in the event that the CLLC contains enough Generation to effectuate
such an outcome.
iii.
CLLC-Specific Metering and Telemetry Requirements
The NYISO proposes to revise Services Tariff Sections 13.1 (General Requirements) and
13.2 (Requirements Pertaining to Customers) to extend the metering and six-second real-time
telemetry requirements to (1) CLLCs and (2) Large Loads, including those in a CLLC or a
CLGC.539
The NYISO proposes a new Section 13.2.7 (Metering Requirements for Co-Located and
Limited Load Configurations). This section would provide that a CLLC shall be metered by the
Transmission Owner it is interconnected to or in whose Load Zone it is located, and Energy
injections and withdrawals at the Point of Interconnection shall be metered separately and
directly and be submitted to the ISO by the Transmission Owner Meter Authority in separate
fields such that the ISO is able to separately determine the total Energy injections and
withdrawals in each interval.540 The Co-Located Load shall provide real-time telemetry at the
Point of Interconnection and the Gross Load at the Large Load nominally every six seconds, in
accordance with the specifications set forth in ISO Procedures.541
iv.
CLLC-Specific Energy Market Rules
The NYISO proposes several changes to its Day-Ahead and Real-Time Market rules to
schedule and dispatch a CLLC as a single Resource and limit its withdrawals to levels consistent
with its Withdrawal Service rights.
The NYISO proposes to revise Services Tariff Section 4.2.1.1 (General Customer
Forecasting and Bidding Requirements) by adding “Bids to purchase Energy and Bids to supply
539 Services Tariff §§ 13.1, 13.2.
540 Id. § 13.2.7.
541 Id.
PDF page 102
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 102
Energy by CLLCs” to the list of bids required by LSEs and Customers and Transmission
Customers submitting Bids in the Day-Ahead Market.542
The NYISO proposes to add a new Section 4.2.1.9 (Large Loads) providing that all Large
Loads, regardless of Withdrawal Service classification, are subject to a maximum ramp rate limit
of 20 MW/min, and that the ISO may instruct a Large Load to deviate from this ramp rate limit
in order to protect reliability.
The NYISO proposes to add a new Section 4.2.1.9.1 (Co-Located and Limited Load
Configurations) requiring a CLLC to submit Day-Ahead Market Bids using the ISO-Committed
Flexible, Self-Committed Flexible, or ISO-Committed Fixed Bid modes. A Supplier’s Day-
Ahead Market Bids for a CLLC to withdraw and to inject Energy must be submitted as a single,
continuous bid curve representing the net capability available for scheduling for each hour of the
Dispatch Day.543 Any portion of a Co-Located Load that is taking Non-Firm Withdrawal Service
must be included in the net bid curve as an Energy withdrawal and is subject to the $200/MWh
Non-Firm Withdrawal Service bid cap.544 A CLLC is not required to submit Day-Ahead Market
Bids to withdraw for any hour in which it does not intend to withdraw.545 A CLLC’s Day-Ahead
Market Bid must reflect the CLLC’s applicable operating limits.546 The maximum physical Point
of Injection and Point of Withdrawal limits shall represent the Bid bounds of the CLLC.547 The
Lower Operating Limit shall represent the maximum desired net withdrawal MW and the Upper
Operating Limit shall reflect the maximum desired net injection MW for which the CLLC may
receive a schedule.548 The CLLC may nominate up to three response rates; provided, however,
that the Large Load component of a CLLC’s Day-Ahead Market Bids shall be subject to the
Large Load ramp rate limit of 20 MW/min. CLLCs are not eligible to provide Operating
Reserves or Regulation Service.549
The NYISO proposes to revise Section 4.2.3 (Security Constrained Unit Commitment) to
provide that SCUC will treat CLLCs, like Hybrid Storage Resources, Energy Storage Resources,
and Aggregations as already committed and available to be scheduled, and proposes conforming
edits throughout the section.550
The NYISO proposes to revise Section 4.2.6 (Day-Ahead LBMP Market Settlements) to
provide that a CLLC scheduled in SCUC to sell Energy will be settled at the product of the Day-
Ahead hourly LBMP at the applicable Generator bus and the hourly Energy schedule.551 The
revisions also provide that a CLLC scheduled to purchase Energy will pay the product of the
542 Services Tariff § 4.2.1.1.
543 Id. § 4.2.1.9.1.
544 Id.
545 Id.
546 Id.
547 Id.
548 Id.
549 Id.
550 Id. § 4.2.3.
551 Id. § 4.2.6.
PDF page 103
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 103
Day-Ahead hourly Zonal LBMP for the Load Zone associated with the CLLC and the hourly
Energy schedule.552
The NYISO proposes to revise Section 4.4.1.2 (Bids and Other Requests) to require a
CLLC to submit Real-Time Market Bids using the ISO-Committed Flexible, Self-Committed
Flexible, or ISO-Committed Fixed Bid modes.553 A Supplier’s Real-Time Bids for CLLCs to
withdraw and to inject Energy must be submitted as a single, continuous bid curve representing
the net capability available for scheduling in the Real-Time Market for each hour of the Dispatch
Day, and any portion Co-Located Load that is taking Non-Firm Withdrawal Service shall be
included in the net bid curve as an Energy withdrawal and shall be subject to the $200/MWh
Non-Firm Withdrawal Service bid cap.554 A CLLC’s Real-Time Bid must reflect the CLLC’s
applicable operating limits, including upper and lower operating limits and other parameters as
required by ISO Procedures.555
The NYISO proposes to revise Section 4.4.3.1.2 (Maximum Generation Pickup) to
provide that RTD-CAM must produce schedules directing all CLLCs taking a portion of Non-
Firm Withdrawal Service located in a targeted area to fully decrease any withdrawals associated
with Non-Firm Withdrawal Service at their emergency response rate.556
The NYISO proposes a new Section 4.1.12.1 in the Services Tariff providing that a
Limited Withdrawal Service Load participating with one or more Co-Located Resources or a
stand-alone Limited Withdrawal Service Load must participate in NYISO markets as a CLLC.557
Under this configuration, Large Loads taking solely Firm Withdrawal Service are ineligible to
participate in a CLLC, withdrawals by participating Energy Storage Resources are settled as
Load, and any changes to a CLLC’s composition require a material modification evaluation
under OATT Attachment LL.558
The NYISO proposes to revise Rate Schedule 3 (Payments for Regulation Service) to
include CLLCs among the Resources that are not eligible to provide Regulation Service.559
v.
CLLC-Specific Capacity Market Rules
The NYISO proposes various tariff changes related to CLLC participation in its capacity
market. The NYISO proposes to revise Services Tariff Section 5.12.1 (Installed Capacity
Supplier Qualification Requirements) by adding Composite Co-Located Resources to the
Resources that may qualify as Installed Capacity Suppliers,560 and would require such Resources
552 Id.
553 Id. § 4.4.1.2.
554 Id.
555 Id.
556 Id. § 4.4.3.1.2.
557 Services Tariff § 4.1.12.1.
558 Id.
559 Id. § 15.3.
560 Services Tariff § 5.12.1.
PDF page 104
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 104
to submit Operating Data in the same manner other Installed Capacity Suppliers per a revision to
Section 5.12.5.1.561
The NYISO proposes a new Section 5.12.6.1.3 (Composite Co-Located Resources) under
which a Composite Co-Located Resource may, consistent with the deliverability requirements in
Attachment HH of the OATT, qualify for ICAP up to the lesser of the aggregate CRIS of its
individual Co-Located Resource(s) and the aggregate DMNC of the Composite Co-Located
Resource, and must comply with Section 5.12.1 and the outage notification requirements of
Section 5.12.7.562
The NYISO proposes to revise Section 5.12.6.2 (UCAP Calculations), by providing that
the Unforced Capacity that a Composite Co-Located Resource is authorized to supply in the
NYCA will be based on its availability in the Real-Time Market, excluding the hours in any
month that the applicable Composite Co-Located Resource was in an outage state that precluded
its eligibility to participate in the Installed Capacity market.563
The NYISO proposes a new Section 5.12.7.4 requiring each Composite Co-Located
Resource, on a daily basis and for each hour of the Day-Ahead Market Day, to (i) schedule a
Bilateral Transaction; (ii) Bid the ICAP sold by that Composite Co-Located Resource minus the
larger of zero and the minimum of (a) the ICAP MW of Firm Withdrawal Service associated
with the given CLLC and (b) the absolute value of the LOL of the given hour; or (iii) notify the
ISO of any outages.564
vi.
CLLC-Specific Settlement Rules
The NYISO proposes to revise Services Tariff Section 4.5.2.1 (General Rules for
Suppliers) to provide that CLLCs are subject to the balancing market settlement rules when
scheduled to provide or withdraw Energy or when actually providing or withdrawing Energy in
real-time.565 A CLLC will pay or be paid for Energy imbalance based on Actual Energy
Injections and Scheduled Energy Injections at the Generator bus LBMP, and based on Actual
Energy Withdrawals and Scheduled Energy Withdrawals at the Zonal LBMP.566 Actual Energy
Withdrawals for a CLLC will be determined from real-time revenue grade meters and
telemetry.567 Energy imbalance will be determined in two parts, with a breakpoint at zero MW of
injection or withdrawal, so that all injections are settled at the Generator bus LBMP and all
withdrawals are settled at the Zonal LBMP.568 The NYISO proposes conforming revisions to
Section 4.5.3.1 to provide that a Customer’s Actual Energy Withdrawals for a Large Load will
562 Id. § 5.12.6.1.3.
563 Id. § 5.12.6.2.
564 Id. § 5.12.7.4.
565 Services Tariff § 4.5.2.1.
566 Id.
567 Id.
568 Id.
PDF page 105
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 105
be determined from real-time revenue grade meters and telemetry, and that CLLCs are subject to
the withdrawal balancing rules subject to the zero MW breakpoint.569
The NYISO proposes to revise Sections 18.2.1.2 (Attachment C) and 25.2.28
(Attachment J) to the Services Tariff to clarify that a CLLC shall not be eligible to receive Day-
Ahead Bid Production Cost Guarantee or Day-Ahead Margin Assurance Payments.570 This is
reasonable because CLLCs are unique Resources, treated as Load when net withdrawing and as
wholesale supply when net injecting. The NYISO does not currently have any other Resources
with such characteristics. It is therefore reasonable for NYISO to wait to gain practical working
experience with the new CLLC model before it determines whether CLLCs require make whole
payments and what form such payments might take.571
E.
Deviation Charges for CLLCs that Fail to Follow NYISO’s Dispatch
Instructions
The NYISO is proposing to add a new Section 15.3B (“Rate Schedule 3-B”) to the
Services Tariff to assess new deviation charges to CLLCs that do not follow the NYISO’s
dispatch instructions/basepoints when net withdrawing from the system.
Under Section 15.3B.1 (Overwithdrawal Charges), a CLLC whose Actual Energy
Withdrawals exceed its scheduled Energy withdrawals over a Real-Time Dispatch interval would
pay an overwithdrawal charge calculated as follows:
i.
Overwithdrawal MW x Max (MPRCDAM, MPRCRT) x Length of Interval in
seconds 3600 seconds572
Under Section 15.3B.2 (Underwithdrawal Charges), a CLLC that withdraws less than its
scheduled Energy withdrawals minus the tolerance will pay a corresponding underwithdrawal
charge calculated as follows:
ii.
Underwithdrawal MW x Max (MPRCDAM, MPRCRT) x Length of Interval in
seconds 3600 seconds573
These charges are a necessary incentive mechanism because CLLCs are dispatchable,
even when net withdrawing from the system. When a Generator today deviates from its
basepoints, such deviations must be corrected for through the dispatch of additional Regulation
capacity, which incurs a systemwide cost. Under the existing rules, the additional cost of
dispatching such Regulation capacity is allocated to the Generators that caused the discrepancy
via Generator Overgeneration/Undergeneration charges. A CLLC that deviates from its dispatch
while net withdrawing yields the same end result – NYISO must dispatch additional Regulation
to compensate for those deviations. NYISO therefore believes that it is reasonable to assess
569 Id. § 4.5.3.1.
570 Id. §§ 18.2.1.2, 18.4.2.
571 See Smith Affidavit at P 79.
572 Id. § 15.3B.1.
573 Id.
PDF page 106
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 106
similar, but distinct, Overwithdrawal and Underwithdrawal charges to CLLCs in intervals where
they are dispatched to withdraw yet fail to follow their withdrawal basepoints.
The CLLC deviation charge that is applied when the CLLC is net withdrawing will have
a tolerance threshold of 5% of the Large Load’s maximum registered withdrawal limit, i.e. the
total amount of Withdrawal Service that the Load was studied for and awarded in the LLIP. The
charge will be assessed using the Regulation clearing price, consistent with existing
Under/Overgeneration penalties for Generators. The 5% tolerance applied to the CLLC
withdrawal deviation charge is more generous than the 3% tolerance applied to Generator
Overgeneration/Undergeneration charges, and accommodates stakeholder feedback that some
Loads, though dispatchable, may not be able to modulate Load as precisely as a Generator can
modulate supply.
CLLCs will be subject to the existing DER Aggregation Overgeneration/Undergeneration
charges in market intervals where they are dispatched to net inject onto the system. The Smith
Affidavit further addresses the reasonableness of these charges.574
The Commission should accept the NYISO’s proposed deviation charges as within the
scope of the Commission’s jurisdiction for the same reasons as the NYISO’s proposed
curtailment rules for Limited Withdrawal Service Loads, discussed above in Part IV.B.ii.b are
Commission-jurisdictional. Namely, the deviation charges are conditions to the receipt of
jurisdictional non-firm transmission service and are wholesale market design mechanisms that
exist in the wholesale energy space. They are intended to incentivize CLLCs’ adherence to
NYISO dispatch/basepoint instructions under NYISO’s Commission-jurisdictional tariffs. The
NYISO has no intention to intrude on state jurisdiction.
In addition, the SPP CHILLS Order also supports NYISO’s proposed deviation charges.
CHILLS customers taking transmission service in excess of their CHILLS reserved capacity are
subject to SPP-imposed penalties.575 The Commission found this arrangement to be just and
reasonable because it ensures that CHILLS customers pay for unreserved use of SPP’s
transmission system based on the amount and duration of such unreserved use.576 The
Commission also found that escalating penalties will help deter CHILLS Customers from
repeatedly failing to adhere to reserved capacity amounts.577 So too with the NYISO’s proposed
deviation charge, which is structured to ensure that customers being served via Non-Firm
Withdrawal Service adhere to the NYISO’s dispatch instructions and basepoints when net
withdrawing.
F.
The Associated Resource Arrangements and the Capacity Region Construct
As discussed above in Part II.G.ii, a Large Load that is seeking Firm Withdrawal Service
but has been identified in the LLIP as causing impermissible adverse resource adequacy impacts
may mitigate those impacts, and thus be eligible to receive some or a full amount of Firm
574 See Smith Affidavit at PP 80-82.
575 SPP CHILLS Order at P 98.
576 Id.
577 Id.
PDF page 107
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 107
Withdrawal Service by entering into an Associated Resource arrangement(s). The NYISO
would revise Section 2.1 of the Services Tariff to define an “Associated Resource” as follows:
[a] Co-Located Resource or Partner Resource that may mitigate some or all of a
Large Load’s adverse impacts to resource adequacy and/or transmission security
identified in the LLIP set forth in Attachment LL of the ISO OATT, which allows
the respective Co-Located Load or Large Load to take some amount of Firm
Withdrawal Service.” An Associated Resource must be (a) a proposed project
that does not yet meet the inclusion rules for the Reliability Planning Process at
the time the Large Load Integration Request is validated in accordance with
Section 44.6.5 of Attachment LL of the ISO OATT; (b) a new Installed Capacity
Supplier; and (c) otherwise satisfy the applicable requirements set forth in Section
44.6.4 of Attachment LL of the ISO OATT.
Services Tariff Section 2.3 would be revised to define a “Co-Located Arrangement” as:
An agreement between a Co-Located Load and a Co-Located Resource(s) for the
purpose of enabling the Co-Located Load to take some amount of Firm
Withdrawal Service, consistent with Section 4.1.12 of the ISO Services Tariff and
Attachment B of the ISO OATT. The Co-Located Resource(s) and the associated
Co-Located Load must be behind the same Point of Interconnection and must
jointly submit an attestation in accordance with Section 44.6.3.5 of Attachment
LL of the ISO OATT. A Co-Located Arrangement may be between: (1) a Co-
Located Load taking solely Firm Withdrawal Service and a Co-Located Resource
or (2) a Co-Located Load and Co-Located Resource in a CLLC. The Co-Located
Arrangement shall have a required minimum duration of fifteen (15) years,
starting the first day of the Obligation Procurement Period for which the UCAP
equivalent of ICAP documented in the Large Load Bilateral Transaction is
initially certified, in accordance with ISO Services Tariff Sections 5.11.2 and
5.13.1 and ISO Procedures
And Services Tariff Section 2.16 would define a “Partnered Resource Arrangement” as:
An agreement between Partner Resource(s) and a Large Load that are electrically
located in the same Capacity Region for the purpose of enabling the Large Load
to take Firm Withdrawal Service, consistent with Section 4.1.12 of the ISO
Services Tariff and Attachment B of the ISO OATT. The Partner Resource(s) and
the Large Load must jointly submit an attestation in accordance with Section
44.6.3.5 of Attachment LL of the ISO OATT. The Partner Resource Arrangement
shall have a required minimum duration of fifteen (15) years, starting the first day
of the Obligation Procurement Period for which the UCAP equivalent of ICAP
documented in the applicable Large Load Bilateral Transaction is initially
certified, in accordance with Sections 5.11.2 and 5.13.1 of the ISO Services Tariff
and ISO Procedures.
PDF page 108
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 108
Once a Large Load enters into a Co-Located or Partner Resource Arrangement with an
Associated Resource(s), that Large Load’s eligibility to take the amount of Firm Withdrawal
Service dependent on such arrangement with an Associated Resource becomes contingent on the
continued ICAP market participation of the Associated Resource(s). If the Associated
Resource(s) that is party to a given Large Load’s Co-Located or Partner Resource Arrangement
enters into an ICAP Ineligible Forced Outage, Mothball, or Retired status, or otherwise exit the
ICAP markets, the corresponding Large Load will be required to reclassify, in part or in full, as a
NFWS Load.
If the Large Load’s Associated Resource(s) later exit from one of the aforementioned
statuses and resumes ICAP market participation, then the Large Load’s Firm Withdrawal Service
Rights may be restored.
The NYISO proposes to require that all Co-Located and Partner Resource Arrangements
remain in place for a term of 15 years.578 After the 15-year term expires, the Large Load’s Firm
Withdrawal Service shall no longer be contingent on the continued ICAP market participation of
its Associated Resource(s).
NYISO’s proposed rules ensure that the ICAP associated with an Associated Resource(s)
in an arrangement with a Large Load is being made available to the ICAP market by requiring
that a Large Load Bilateral Transaction be in place, which is a capacity bilateral, between
Associated Resources and the Large Load to whose arrangement they belong. This Large Load
Bilateral Transaction must be in place for each Obligation Procurement Period following the
effective date of the Large Load’s Co-Located or Partner Resource Arrangement.
This requirement ensures that the ICAP of the Associated Resource(s), which was caused
to enter the ICAP market as a result of the Large Load’s need to mitigate its adverse impacts to
resource adequacy, continues to do so for the required term of the Co-Located or Partner
Resource Arrangement, as further discussed below. Further, as the Smith Affidavit explains, the
NYISO’s proposed rules will also ensure that Associated Resource(s) are not transient, and
remain in the ICAP markets for a predetermined, minimum period of time.
The NYISO’s Associated Resource arrangement construct and related rules are
responsive to the Commission’s concern expressed in the Show Cause Order that “[w]ithout such
a common and consistent understanding of entities’ responsibilities relevant to co-location
arrangements [] we are concerned that these arrangements may be developed in a manner that is
itself unjust and unreasonable or that may result in unjust and unreasonable rates for other
customers[,]579 and encouragement for the NYISO to consider “what type of transmission service
an Eligible Customer will need to take on behalf of the electrically proximate large load or large
co-located load.”580
The Show Cause Order’s suggested defined terminology of Large Load associating with
“electrically proximate” supply. i.e., less than two substations away, is not well suited for
578 See Proposed Services Tariff § 4.1.10.3.
579 Show Cause Order at P 102.
580 Show Cause Order at P 127 (emphasis added).
PDF page 109
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 109
implementation in the NYISO. Requiring an Associated Resource to be in the same Capacity
Region as its associated Large Load is appropriate in light of the NYISO’s specific frameworks.
This is because, during the interconnection process, when the deliverability of a new resource to
be eligible to supply capacity is evaluated (i.e., the deliverability test is applied to projects
seeking CRIS), the NYISO looks at the deliverability of the new Resource within the Capacity
Region where that Resource is located. Given that the Associate Resource is addressing the
resource adequacy impact of the Large Load, it is appropriate to require that the Associated
Resource be within the same Capacity Region as the Large Load in the NYISO .
As such, the NYISO is proposing to allow Large Loads to partner or co-locate with
Associated Resource(s) that are electrically located in the same Capacity Region as the Large
Load. This construct is more conducive to the way the NYISO’s resource adequacy
requirements and ICAP market are structured. And, as discussed in the Smith Affidavit, utilizing
a Capacity Region construct in place of an electrical proximity approach is better suited to the
NYISO’s markets and the configuration and topology of the NYS Transmission System.581
The NYISO’s proposed Capacity Region requirement achieves the same objectives as the
electrically proximate generation specifications discussed in the Show Cause Order, including
its expressed concern that “[i] the absence of Tariff provisions accounting for these operational
dynamics when an interconnection customer’s generating facility is serving electrically
proximate large loads or large co-located loads, new shovel-ready generating facilities may face
unnecessary delays in reaching commercial operation under current generator interconnection
processes and will be unable to serve the immediate demand of new large loads or large co-
located loads.”582 Allowing Large Loads to enter into arrangement with an Associated
Resource(s) in the same Capacity Region, may avoid or lessen unnecessary delays in Large
Loads properly reaching commercial operation. Also, of note, in the Show Cause Order the
Commission stated that it would consider “proposed revisions to this definition that ensure it is
appropriately tailored to NYISO transmission system.”583
G.
DSR/Aggregation Rules
Under proposed OATT Part 3A, Section 3.A.1.1, a Large Load taking Firm Withdrawal
Service is eligible to participate in the NYISO markets via its various Demand Side Resource
programs, and is treated the same as other firm Transmission Service customers, including being
subject to the same curtailment priority and the NYISO’s emergency operating procedures.584 By
contrast, Section 3.A.1.2 and the revised “Demand Side Resource”585 definition in Services
581 Smith Affidavit at P 86.
582 Show Cause Order at P 121. “Where a generating facility’s output is matched to the demand of the
electrically proximate large load or large co-located load or if the generating facility’s output is limited to ensure no
new injection, the impacts to the transmission system of interconnecting the generating facility to serve that
electrically proximate large load or large co-located load may be limited, thereby potentially reducing the need for
Network Upgrades, which can accelerate the generator interconnection process.” Id.
583 Show Cause Order at P 120.
584 Proposed OATT Part 3A § 3.A.1.1.
585 The NYISO proposes to define “Demand Side Resource” as “A Resource located in the NYCA that: (i)
is capable of controlling demand by either curtailing its Load or by operating a Local Generator to reduce Load from
the NYS Transmission System and/or the distribution system at the direction of the ISO, in a responsive, measurable
PDF page 110
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 110
Tariff Section 2.3 provide that a Large Load taking any amount of Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service, including a Large Load taking a combination of Firm and Non-Firm Withdrawal
Service, is not eligible to participate in NYISO Demand Side Resource programs.586
The NYISO is proposing to allow a Large Load to enter a Partner Resource Arrangement
or Co-Located Arrangement with an Associated Resource(s)587 to obtain, in part or in full, Firm
Withdrawal Service, as determined by the Large Load Integration Procedures set forth in
proposed Attachment LL to the OATT.588 Both arrangements would be subject to a minimum
duration of fifteen years, starting the first day of the Obligation Procurement Period for which
the UCAP equivalent of ICAP documented in the applicable Large Load Bilateral Transaction is
initially certified.589 Large Load taking Firm Withdrawal Service that is a party to a Partner
Resource Arrangement and is a Demand Side Resource that is not participating in an
Aggregation cannot serve as the Partner Resource to another Large Load.590 A Large Load taking
Firm Withdrawal Service that is a party to a Co-Located Arrangement and is a Demand Side
Resource that is participating as a standalone Distributed Energy Resource cannot serve as the
Associated Resource to another Large Load.591 Under this framework, the Large Load must
partner with a “new” DSR; that is, the DSR must have never participated in a NYISO Demand
Response Program, and facilities included in DER Aggregations must never have participated in
a NYISO market.
Because the NYISO’s proposed Large Load market rules would allow a Demand Side
Resource to become an Associated Resource and engage with a Partner or Co-Located Resource
Arrangement as well, the NYISO sees a need to prohibit a Large Load that is receiving Full
Withdrawal Rights through a Co-Located or Partner Resource Arrangement and which registers
as a DSR from itself serving as the Associated Resource to a second Large Load seeking FWS in
a second Co-Located or Partner Resource Arrangement. NYISO is concerned that the first Large
Load’s Associated Resource could exit the ICAP market, causing the first Large Load to
reclassify as NFWS Load and causing it to lose its ability to participate in the markets as a
Demand Side Resource. This, in turn, would cause the second Large Load to lose access to its
Associated Resource, which was the first Large Load when it was operating as a Demand Side
and verifiable manner within time limits, and (ii) is qualified to participate in competitive Energy, Capacity,
Operating Reserves or Regulation Service markets, or in the Emergency Demand Response Program pursuant to this
ISO Services Tariff and the ISO Procedures. A Large Load is not eligible to participate in the ISO Administered
Markets as a Demand Side Resource if it is a Limited Withdrawal Service Load.” Proposed Services Tariff Section
2.4.
586 Proposed OATT Part 3A § 3.A.1.2.
587 The NYISO proposes to define “Associated Resource” as “a Co-Located Resource or Partner Resource
that may mitigate some or all of a Large Load’s adverse impacts to resource adequacy and/or transmission security
identified in the LLIP set forth in Attachment LL of the ISO OATT, which allows the respective Co-Located Load
or Large Load to take some amount of Firm Withdrawal Service. An Associated Resource must be (a) a proposed
project that does not yet meet the inclusion rules for the Reliability Planning Process at the time the Large Load
Integration Request is validated in accordance with Section 44.6.5 of Attachment LL of the ISO OATT; (b) a new
Installed Capacity Supplier; and (c) otherwise satisfy the applicable requirements set forth in Section 44.6.4 of
Attachment LL of the ISO OATT.” Proposed Services Tariff Section 2.1; Proposed OATT Section 44.1.
588 Proposed Services Tariff § 4.1.12.
589 Id.
590 Id.
591 Id.
PDF page 111
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 111
Resource. Then, the second Large Load must also reclassify as NFWS Load. Such a mass
reclassification of Large Loads from FWS to NFWS would also result in these Large Loads
losing DSR eligibility, requiring them to withdraw their Demand Response capability from the
ICAP, Energy, and Ancillary Services markets. Without such a prohibition in place, markets may
inadvertently incentivize the creation of an interdependent web of Large Load FWS eligibilities
(i.e., “daisy-chaining”) that could pose a risk to reliability and/or market stability.
This proposal responds to the Commission’s directive that the NYISO’s Tariff should
provide for transmission services for Eligible Load and flexible large loads that are willing and
able to limit their withdrawals.592
H.
DER Modeling Improvements and Baseline Enhancements
The maximum physical injection capability for a Resource participating in an
Aggregation is 20 MW, but Resources above 20 MW may participate in an Aggregation if the
NYISO determines sufficient physical protection and control schemes exist to limit the injection
capability of the Resource to 20 MW or less.593
The NYISO proposes to prohibit Demand Side Resources whose Demand Response
capability exceeds 20 MW from aggregating with other DER Facilities.594 Rather, Demand Side
Resources exceeding 20 MW shall only be permitted to form an Aggregation of one (i.e., they
shall not be permitted to form an Aggregation with other Distributed Energy Resources).595
These revisions will provide necessary access and transparency into large DSR activity and will
support safe and reliable real-time grid operations. This responds to the Commission’s directive
in the Show Cause Order that the NYISO should address the lack of provisions addressing
ongoing operational requirements for Transmission Customers taking Transmission Service on
behalf of Large Loads in its tariffs.596
These changes are grounded in working experience that NYISO has gained with the
participation model over the past several years. The NYISO has found that, without such
restrictions in place, the impacts of large Demand Side Resource dispatch on the transmission
system becomes difficult to model and anticipate, and true impacts become difficult to deduce.
The NYISO is concerned that the participation of Large Loads in the DER and Aggregation
participation model as Demand Side Resources will exacerbate these modeling issues. The
NYISO’s proposed enhancements will give the NYISO grid operators direct insight into the
activity of individual, large, Demand Side Resources, making it easier to understand the impacts
they are having on the transmission system and how the Demand Side Resource is currently
operating.
These rules have precedent within the DER and Aggregation participation model itself –
other types of DER Facilities, such as small ESRs, may only participate in the DER and
592 Show Cause Order at P 66.
593 Services Tariff § 4.1.10.1.
594 Proposed Services Tariff § 4.1.10.1.
595 Id.
596 Show Cause Order at P 70.
PDF page 112
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 112
Aggregation participation model if they are less than 20MW in size. The NYISO’s DER and
Aggregation participation model rules made an exception for Demand Side Resources because,
with the sunsetting of NYISO’s Demand Side Ancillary Services and Day Ahead Demand
Response Programs, dispatchable Demand Side Resources had no other method of participation
in the NYISO markets. Hence the DER and Aggregation participation model needed to support
both standalone and aggregated Demand Side Resource participation use cases. These proposed
revisions to the DER and Aggregation participation model do not restrict the model’s ability to
handle both use cases. Rather, the revised rules more clearly define boundaries describing which
Demand Side Resources should participate and therefore be modeled as individual Resources, vs
those that may aggregate with other DER Facilities.
The NYISO also proposes to require Demand Side Resources participating in the DER
Participation Model to use “Meter Before/Meter After” baselining methodology to measure the
amount of Demand Reduction provided in the first hour of Demand Side Resource dispatch.597
The use of Meter Before/Meter After baselining will enhance the accuracy of the actual load
reduction measurement. Following that initial hour, Aggregators will calculate a new baseline
using the current Economic Customer Baseline Load (“ECBL”) methodology, and the ECBL
methodology calculation will be used to measure DSR Demand Response for all subsequent
intervals in the dispatch. This proposal responds to the Commission’s directive in the Show
Cause Order that the NYISO should address the lack of provisions requiring the data necessary
to ensure sufficient operational visibility nor establishes requirements for maintaining
communication channels between the NYISO and Transmission Customers taking service on
behalf of Large Loads.598
I.
Sunsetting the NYISO’s BTM:NG Resource Program
The Show Cause Order made a preliminary finding that the NYISO’s Tariffs were unjust
and unreasonable because “they allowed load with behind the meter generation to net its behind
the meter generation against its load for purposes of calculating Transmission Service Charges
for Host Loads configured in a BTM:NG Resource arrangement.”599 The NYISO acknowledges
that its existing BTM:NG Resource program allows for such netting. The NYISO takes no
position at this time on whether this fact renders the existing program unjust and unreasonable.
But the NYISO is nevertheless proposing to address the Commission’s concern here.
The “netting” mechanism is an integral component of the BTM:NG Resource program.
As such, the NYISO proposes to sunset the program, and transition its existing participants to
another participation model. Because the BTM:NG Resource program has relatively few
participants and no recent enrollees600 it would be unreasonable to commit substantial resources
to overhauling it in its current form at this time. This is especially true given the need to
prioritize work on many other large load reforms, including various others presented in this
filing, that are more consequential. It would therefore be preferable to replace the BTM:NG
597 Proposed OATT § 24.2.
598 Show Cause Order at P 70.
599 Id. at P 110
600 Specifically, as of the date of this filing, there are only six active BTM:NG Resources. No new
BTM:NG Resources have enrolled in recent years.
PDF page 113
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 113
Resource program in the near future with an entirely new model that would address the
Commission’s netting concern while also providing greater functionality and compatibility with
the NYISO’s other Large Load enhancements.
Accordingly, the NYISO seeks to sunset its existing BTM:NG program and to develop a
replacement framework under which ancillary service, transmission, and other charges would be
assessed on a Gross Load basis. The NYISO would implement sunsetting by revising the
definition of Behind-the-Meter Net Generation Resource in Section 2 of the Services Tariff to
indicate that it will no longer be effective after May 1, 2029. The NYISO would also end
enrollment for new BTM:NG Resources as of February 1, 2027 which coincides with the
proposed effective date of the LLIP and related tariff revisions.601
The NYISO intends to work with the handful of current BTM:NG Resources to create
individual transition plans that are suited for them in light of their operational characteristics and
business models for continued participation in the ISO-administered markets. As the Smith
Affidavit notes, it will take time to develop individualized transition plans because the variability
in BTM:NG Resource characteristics and capabilities makes a one-size fits all approach
impractical.602 The NYISO will seek to complete the transition process before the existing
BTM:NG program sunsets on May 1, 2029.
J.
Proposed Revisions to the NYISO’s Market Power Mitigation Measures
i.
Revisions to the “Buyer-Side” Capacity Market Power Mitigation
Measures
The NYISO is proposing to revise the definition of “Excluded Facility” in Section 23.2.1
(Attachment H) to create two new exclusions from its existing buyer-side capacity market power
mitigation measures.
The BSM Rules apply to new capacity resources entering the ICAP Auctions in New
York City and the Lower Hudson Valley, i.e., the NYISO’s “Mitigated Capacity Zones.”
Traditionally, any such resource that did not qualify for an exemption was required to offer its
capacity into the Spot Market Auctions at a price at or above the applicable offer floor and to
then continue to offer at or above that price until its capacity clears twelve, not necessarily
consecutive, monthly Spot Market Auction.
In 2022, the Commission accepted a substantial new exclusion from the BSM Rules.603
New capacity resources that were deemed to serve the objectives of New York State’s Climate
Leadership and Community Protection Act (“CLCPA”) were no longer subject to the BSM Rules
partly in consideration of New York State’s reserved authority under the F PA to determine its
resource mix. The NYISO demonstrated that the CLCPA exclusion was consistent with
601 See Proposed Services Tariff Section 4.2.
602 Smith Affidavit at P 103.
603 N.Y. Indep. Sys. Operator, Inc., 179 FERC ¶ 61,102 (2022) (“CLCPA Exclusion Order”).
PDF page 114
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 114
Commission precedent that market power mitigation rules must balance investor and consumer
interests by avoiding both over-mitigation and artificial price suppression.604
The two exclusions that the NYISO is proposing now are considerably narrower in scope
than the CLCPA exclusion. Both are necessary to update and clarify the BSM Rules to account
for issues presented by the influx of new types of Large Loads. And both will reasonably guard
against the risks of over- and under-mitigation.
The NYISO seeks to establish an exclusion for new generation that is co-located with
Large Loads or that enters a partnership with Large Loads so that the Large Loads may receive
Firm Withdrawal Service. Such generation must also obtain CRI S through the NYISO’s
interconnection processes. The exclusion would recognize that the NYISO has proposed to
require arrangements with generation to address a given Large Loads’ resource adequacy
impacts as determined through the LLIP.
As is discussed in the Altman Affidavit, the NYISO currently faces unprecedented near-
term resource adequacy challenges. The purpose of requiring Co-Located/Partnered
Arrangements is to offset the substantial resource adequacy impacts created by new Large Loads.
This is an important policy objective that I believe justifies a new exclusion from the BSM
Rules. Today’s resource adequacy challenges certainly did not exist and were not accounted for
when the BSM Rules were first devised or as they evolved over time.
In addition, it is highly unlikely that Large Load projects and Associated Resources
would be jointly developed as part of capacity market price suppression schemes. Development
times are much shorter for Large Loads than for generation. The risk of Large Load projects
being effectively used to cause artificial price suppression is certainly lower than it was for the
kinds of subsidized generation investments that the BSM Rules, and comparable measures in
other regions, were originally devised to prevent. Creating an exclusion for Co-
Located/Partnered Generation should therefore not reasonably be expected to result in under-
mitigation.
During the NYISO stakeholder process that preceded this filing, some stakeholders
suggested that the new exclusion should be modified to include a “right-sizing” limitation, i.e.,
that it should not apply to the extent that Co-Located/Partnered Generation was materially larger
than the associated Large Load. The Newton Affidavit explains that these hypothetical scenarios
presented as justifications for right-sizing do not appear to represent realistic mechanisms for the
exercise of buyer-side market power under current market conditions.
Furthermore, many of the resource technology types referenced by stakeholders are
already Excluded Facilities on other grounds and thus are not subject to the BSM Rules under the
currently effective tariff. The NYISO is not proposing to change any of the existing exclusion
rules in this proceeding. For the limited resource types that remain subject to the BSM Rules,
604 Id. at P 39.
PDF page 115
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 115
there does not appear to be a credible near-term market power concern that would necessitate
adding a right-sizing rule or other restrictions.
The NYISO also seeks to introduce an exclusion for any proposed supply-side solution
responding to a reliability need identified by the NYISO in a STAR or RNA that is found to be a
viable and sufficient response to that need.
In the past the Commission sometimes rejected reliability-based exceptions to capacity
market power mitigation rules. But circumstances have changed greatly in recent years. This
includes rapid growth across new types of loads that was not anticipated at the time of the
Commission’s earlier rulings. Reliability conditions may not yet be as severe in New York as
they are becoming in certain other regions. But the challenges facing the NYISO are serious and
must be addressed.
The NYISO is proposing that once a capacity resource in a Mitigated Capacity Zone
obtains one of the two new exclusions that the exclusion would not be rescinded. This is
consistent with how the existing CLCPA exclusion is implemented.
Although it is proposing to add a new exclusion to its tariff, the NYISO would not turn a
blind eye toward potential buyer-side market power abuses. As the NYISO stated when it
proposed the existing exclusion for CLCPA resources, the NYISO “will continue to monitor and
identify any relevant market behaviors or developments that could constitute abuses of buyer-
side market power. If the NYISO were to identify any such exercise of buyer-side market power,
it would take all appropriate and timely actions to address such abuse and protect against
unreasonable capacity market outcomes.”605 This could include proposing prospectively
effective tariff changes that would prevent an inappropriate exclusion from being granted before
final investment decisions are made.
Similarly, with respect to the new exclusion(s) that the NYISO is proposing now, the
NYISO’s Market Mitigation and Analysis Department (“MMA”) would continue to monitor the
capacity market for potential exercises of buyer-side market power. MMA will monitor new
capacity entry, market outcomes, and other information that could indicate the exercise of buyer-
side market power.
The interconnection process, stakeholder process, and public visibility associated with
large load infrastructure projects provide significant additional transparency – and time to act if
required. Projects with the attributes that have concerned some stakeholders, e.g., , an
Associated Resource far larger than its associated load, would likely be identified and reviewed
well in advance of entering service. This would give the NYISO, its independent Market
Monitoring Unit, and stakeholders sufficient time to assess potential concerns and responses,
including potential tariff changes if needed to close loopholes and prevent abuses in individual
cases.
605 New York Independent System Operator, Inc., Excluding Certain Resources from the “Buyer-Side”
Capacity Market Power Mitigation Measures, Adopting a Marginal Capacity Accreditation Market Design, and
Enhancing Capacity Reference Point Price Translation, Docket No. ER22-772-000 (January 5, 2022) at 25.
PDF page 116
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 116
ii.
Additional Market Power Mitigation Measures Changes for CLLCs
The NYISO also proposes to revise Section 23 of the Services Tariff (Attachment H) to
clarify the applicability of existing market power mitigation rules to CLLCs. Revised Section
23.2.1 (Definitions) provides that, for purposes of Sections 23.2 through 23.4.4, a CLLC that
includes a Co-Located Resource or Co-Located Supply will be evaluated as an Electric Facility
and/or a Generator to identify physical withholding, economic withholding, or uneconomic
production that may warrant mitigation.606 Revised Section 23.3.1.3.2 adds CLLCs to the
resources for which the NYISO may impose a mitigation measure based on uneconomic
withdrawals.607 Revised Section 23.3.1.4.1 provides that a reference level for a CLLC’s Bid to
provide or withdraw Energy will be calculated consistent with Sections 23.3.1.4.1.3 or
23.3.1.4.2.608 Revised Section 23.3.1.4.3 excludes CLLCs from the reference level provision for
New Capacity.609
The NYISO’s proposed changes to its market power mitigation measures are not a direct
response to any finding in the Show Cause Order. But they are just and reasonable revisions to
account for the attributes and impacts of Large Loads.
V.
THE NYISO’S PROPOSALS BUILD ON THE NYISO’S ESTABLISHED
TRANSMISISON MODEL AND MARKET STRUCTURES AND DO NOT NEED
TO INCORPORATE THE PJM CO-LOCATION ORDER’S TRANSMISSION
SERVICES
The Commission has repeatedly determined, the NYISO’s financial reservation based
transmission service (“Financial Transmission Service”) rules are consistent with or superior to
the Order No. 888 pro forma service offerings.610 For the reasons explained below, the NYISO’s
existing Financial Transmission Service model represents the best, the most practically
implementable, and the most flexible way for the NYISO to serve Large Loads, including co-
located Large Loads and flexible Large Loads. In this Part, the NYISO explains why its
Financial Transmission Service continues to produce more efficient solutions than the Order No.
888 pro forma physical transmission service options, and why it should serve as the foundation
for the new withdrawal services proposed in this filing. The NYISO also explains the reasons
606 Services Tariff § 23.2.1.
607 Id. § 23.3.1.3.2.
608 Id. § 23.3.1.4.
609 Id. § 23.3.1.4.3.
610 See, e.g., N.Y. Indep. Sys. Operator, Inc., 125 FERC ¶ 61,274, at P 13 (2008) (recognizing “that
NYISO’s proposed deviations from the pro forma OATT reflect the actual market design used by NYISO, and find
the deviations to be consistent with or superior to the pro forma OATT” in connection with NYISO’s Order No.
890-A compliance filing); N.Y. Indep. Sys. Operator, Inc., 123 FERC ¶ 61,134, at P 37 (2008) (same with respect to
NYISO’s Order No. 890 compliance filing); see also Cent. Hudson Gas & Elec. Corp., 88 FERC ¶ 61,138, 61,382
(1999) (concluding that “the Member Systems have complied with the requirement to provide long-term service”
and finding “that the service offered by the ISO is consistent with or superior to that offered under the pro forma
tariff.”)
PDF page 117
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 117
why it is not proposing to adopt the PJM Co-Location Order’s611 forms of transmission service in
response to the Show Cause Order.
A.
The NYISO’s Financial Transmission Service Model Enables the NYISO to
Maximize the Use of the Transmission System Efficiently and to Support
Flexible Service for Large Loads
The NYISO does not accept or facilitate reservations of physical transmission service
within the NYCA. Instead, the NYISO offers “financial reservation” based transmission service
where LBMP energy markets are used to manage congestion and operate bid-based markets.612
In 1999,613 the Commission accepted the NYISO’s proposed Point-to-Point (“PTP”) and
Network Integration Transmission Service (“NITS”) provisions in the OATT, which are
substantially different from the physical based pro forma transmission services, finding the
NYISO’s variations to be consistent with or superior to the pro forma OATT.614 The
Commission has repeatedly found the NYISO’s financial reservation model to be just and
reasonable in various contexts.615
Physical transmission rights are different from the NYISO’s Commission-accepted
“financial” reservation regime that (a) bundles transmission service with Energy purchases and
deliveries, and (b) does not provide for Market Participants to reserve and hold transfer
capability, but rather makes access to, beneficial use of and the capability of its transmission
system available through scheduling each day in its Day-Ahead and Real-Time Markets.616
Transmission service within the NYCA is scheduled “implicitly” when Resources and External
611 PJM Interconnection, L.L.C., 193 FERC ¶ 61,217 (2025).
612The original 1998 proposal to establish the NYISO provided for a single form of financial reservation-
based transmission service. However, in 1999, the Commission required the NYISO’s sponsors to file an OATT
that included two kinds of transmission service but allowed them to propose changes from the pro forma OATT to
reflect how the financial nature of the NYISO’s model differs from the physical reservation-based transmission
service. See Cent. Hudson Gas & Elec. Corp., 88 FERC ¶ 61,138, 61,382 (1999) (accepting the revised financial
transmission reservation model for the NYISO.) For the reasons explained below, the NYISO’s financial
reservation system bridges the gap between the traditional “point-to-point” and “network” transmission service
offerings. As further detailed herein, the NYISO’s financial transmission service method provides greater flexibility
to customers than traditional point-to-point and traditional network service do and, consistent with the proposed
modifications to accommodate “non-firm” service to Large Loads that are described in this filing, the NYISO’s
financial reservation transmission model can accommodate Large Loads that are not eligible to receive firm
transmission service at times when the transmission system is significantly congested or available Energy is limited.
613 See Cent. Hudson Gas & Elec. Corp., 88 FERC ¶ 61,138, 61,382 (1999).
614 See N.Y. Indep. Sys. Operator, Inc., 125 FERC ¶ 61,274 (2008) (confirming that NYISO's financial
reservation model was consistent with or superior to the physical reservation requirements of Order No. 890's pro
forma OATT.); New York Independent System Operator, Inc., 123 FERC ¶ 61,134 (2008) (stating the same); Cent.
Hudson Gas & Elec. Corp., 88 FERC ¶ 61,138, 61,382 (1999) (concluding that “the Member Systems have
complied with the requirement to provide long-term service” and finding “that the service offered by the ISO is
consistent with or superior to that offered under the pro forma tariff”).
615 See N.Y. Indep. Sys. Operator, Inc., 125 FERC ¶ 61,274 (2008) (confirming that NYISO's financial
reservation model was consistent with or superior to the physical reservation requirements of Order No. 890's pro
forma OATT); N.Y. Indep. Sys. Operator, Inc., 123 FERC ¶ 61,134 (2008) (stating the same).
616 See Sections 3.1.5 and 3.1.8 of the OATT for information about how transmission service is scheduled
in the NYCA.
PDF page 118
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 118
Transactions receive Energy schedules from the NYISO, and NYCA Loads are served without
the need to formally schedule transmission service.
The Financial Transmission Service that customers select and the NYISO has provided
since its inception in 2000 most closely resembles an improved, more flexible version of pro
forma NITS which effectively designates all NYCA Resources to serve all NYCA Loads with
administrative efficiency. The NYISO commits and dispatches all NYCA Resources based on
their economic offers, accounting for congestion on its transmission network, to serve all NYCA
Loads (plus scheduled Export Transactions) at the least production cost. The transmission
service that customers select, and the NYISO provides, is referred to as Firm Point-to-Point
Transmission Service.617 As the Commission noted in the Show Cause Order,618 in the twenty-
six years since the NYISO commenced operations, it has never “received a formal request from a
transmission customer for NITS.”
An internal Bilateral Transaction provides a financial method for a NYCA Generator to
contractually serve a NYCA Load. The Point of Injection (“POI”) for an internal Bilateral
Transaction is the Generator Bus where the Energy the Generator produces is made available to
the NYISO. The Point of Withdrawal (“POW”) is the Zonal Load Bus for the Load Zone to
which the Generator’s Energy is being financially “delivered.”619 To the extent the participating
Generator is producing Energy, the “cost” of obtaining transmission service is limited to paying
for transmission congestion and losses between the POI and the POW. If the MWh scheduled in
the Bilateral Transaction exceed the source Generator’s output, the additional MWh required to
serve the scheduled Bilateral Transaction are purchased by the Generator from the LBMP market
based on the LBMP at the source Generator’s location.620 Compared to “physical” transmission
service, market efficiency is improved by providing “financial” transmission service using
Bilateral Transactions because the scheduling of a Bilateral Transaction does not disrupt the
NYISO’s economic, least production cost commitment of Resources to serve all NYCA Load
(plus Export Transactions). Unlike a physical transmission service option, the NYISO’s financial
scheduling of Bilateral Transactions does not force the commitment of a “source” Generator to
serve the Load if that Generator is not an efficient source of economic Energy based on the Bid it
submitted.
617 OATT Sections 16.3.1 through 16.3.4.2 address Bilateral Transactions and Wheels Through the NYCA.
Possibly, customers have only ever requested Firm PTP Service by default given that, under the NYISO’s model,
PTP service offers all of the benefits of NITS in an administratively efficient manner and thus the two services are
largely equivalent; however, it is also possible that customers only select PTP because the limited set of transactions
that need Transmission Service to support them (i.e., Bilateral Transactions and Wheel-Through Transactions) are
readily scheduled on a point-to-point basis. In any case, for over twenty-six years NITS has never been formally
requested or provided in the NYCA.
618 See N.Y. Indep. Sys. Operator, Inc., 195 FERC ¶ 61,216 at P 20 fn. 69 (2026) (“[The NYISO] has never
provided or received a formal request from a transmission customer for NITS.”).
619 NYCA Generators are paid for the Energy they produce based on the LBMP at their Generator Bus.
NYCA Loads pay for the Energy they consume based on the Zonal LBMP calculated for the Load Zone in which
the Load is located.
620 Energy Imbalance Service for Generators serving Bilateral Transactions is addressed in Rate Schedule 4
(Section 6.4) of the OATT. At times when the “source” Generator for a Bilateral Transaction is not the least cost
producer of Energy based on its economic Bids, the LBMP Market will provide the Energy at a lower cost from
other sources, improving efficiency for all involved.
PDF page 119
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 119
In the two and a half decades since the NYISO commenced operations, Transmission
Customers have only ever used the NYISO’s financial based PTP Transmission Service. The
NITS provided for under the NYISO OATT has never been used. As OATT Section 4.2.3
indicates, the NYISO would need to develop substantial new software functionality in order to
implement NITS. One characteristic of the pro forma version of NITS is the ability of a
Transmission Customer to schedule service from one or more designated Generators to one or
more designated Loads. The universe of Resources available for economic commitment and
dispatch by the NYISO is larger and more diverse than an individual Transmission Customer’s
set of designated network resources under the pro forma OATT. The financial transmission
service that NYISO provides is superior to pro forma NITS because the NYISO dispatches all
available Resources based on their economic offers and accounting for the capability of the
transmission system, to serve NYCA Load at least production cost.
Currently, under the NYISO’s model, non-firm transmission service is not available
because it is not needed within the framework of the NYISO’s Financial Transmission Service
Model. Initially, the NYISO offered Non-Firm PTP service for internal Transactions, which was
described as being service for which a Transmission Customer is not willing to pay Congestion
and was made available on a stand-alone basis for one hour periods.621 The NYISO has not
offered Non-Firm PTP service for internal Transactions since March 2011.622 Additionally, Non-
Firm Point-To-Point Transmission Service for External Transactions was eliminated in August
2014.623 As the Harvey Affidavit notes, the non-firm transmission service option that previously
existed under the NYISO OATT was hardly ever used.624 The NYISO’s transmission model
lends itself to providing Loads with the flexibility to structure its service in a manner that
reasonably aligns with its operational dynamics, and is made available to Loads on a relatively
short timeline.
B.
The NYISO’s Financial Reservation Model Promotes Economic Efficiency in
the Use of the Transmission System and Resources
Under the NYISO’s model, the most economically efficient use of the transmission
system and generation resources is achieved within the context of the LBMP energy markets.625
The NYISO’s congestion management framework promotes efficient use of the transmission
grid through the Security Constrained Unit Commitment (“SCUC”) mechanism conducted in the
621 The NYISO’s original Non-Firm Point-to-Point Transmission Services rules were previously found in
Section 3.2 of the NYISO OATT.
622 New York Independent System Operator, Inc., Letter Order, Docket No. ER11-2459-000 (Feb. 10,
2011); see also NYISO’s Proposed Tariff Clarifications Regarding the Bidding for and Scheduling of Energy in New
York’s LBMP Market and the Scheduling of Transmission Service in the New York Control Area, Docket No. ER11-
2459-000 at p. 15 (December 21, 2010) (“the NYISO proposes to affirmatively indicate that Non-Firm Transmission
Service is unavailable for internal Transactions”).
623 New York Independent System Operator, Inc., Letter Order, Docket No. ER14-2623-000 (Oct. 8, 2014)
624 See Harvey Affidavit at P 23.
625 As discussed supra, under the NYISO’s approach, the Transmission Customer bears the financial
responsibility for the marginal congestion cost associated with its own transactions.
PDF page 120
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 120
Day-Ahead Market (“DAM”) and the Real-Time Commitment (“RTC”) and Real-Time Dispatch
(“RTD”) conducted in the Real-Time Market (“RTM”).
While PJM also administers co-optimized day-ahead and real-time energy and ancillary
services markets and its transmission model involves Financial Transmission Rights somewhat
akin to the NYISO’s TCCs, the NYISO’s transmission model is materially different from PJM’s
because the NYISO’s financial reservation-based model does not involve any physical
reservations for transmission service.
Through the NYISO’s DAM and RTM software, internal New York generation resources
compete, including with External Transactions, to be economically awarded an Energy schedule,
which includes the necessary transmission service and ramp schedule. Additionally, the NYISO
continuously redispatches the grid on a security-constrained, least-cost basis in order to
maximize the efficient use of the system. As such, the total production cost to serve Load is
minimized by the NYISO’s SCUC, RTC and RTD, which provides significant savings to Loads
compared to a dispatch that matches Generator output to the demand of a specific sub-set of
Loads.
NYISO’s market constructs, specifically the Transmission Congestion Contract market,
also provides a pathway to manage congestion cost (i.e., the Transmission Usage Charge
associated with firm transmission) for instances where ex-ante price certainty is valuable. TCCs
provide a voluntary financial hedge against Day-Ahead congestion costs without conferring a
physical scheduling priority or altering the NYISO’s security-constrained dispatch. This
separation permits customers to obtain greater cost certainty while preserving efficient,
nondiscriminatory access to transmission capability for all market participants.
The financial reservation model also accommodates materially different Large Load
operating characteristics without creating administratively defined transmission priorities. A
Large Load that can reduce withdrawals during constrained conditions may express that
flexibility through its scheduling parameters and applicable operational requirements, while a
Large Load that requires uninterrupted withdrawals (and whose interconnection supports such
un-interrupted withdrawals) remains exposed to the costs associated with that service. The model
therefore preserves a direct relationship between the service a customer values, the flexibility it
provides, and the congestion costs it causes, rather than socializing those costs or embedding
them in a new class of physical transmission rights. This supports efficient customer decisions
regarding location, consumption, onsite supply, contractual hedging, and willingness to curtail.
The model is also adaptable as system conditions and Large Load consumption change
over time. Financial schedules and locational settlements can reflect the actual hourly—and, in
real time, interval-specific—effects of a Large Load’s withdrawals, avoiding the need to
establish a static physical reservation based on forecasts that may prove inaccurate or operating
assumptions that may later change. That adaptability is especially valuable for Large Loads
whose development timelines, utilization levels, and operating profiles may be uncertain. It
reduces the risk that scarce transmission capability will be stranded or inefficiently reserved,
protects other customers from subsidizing uneconomic uses of the system, and permits Large
PDF page 121
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 121
Loads to obtain service commensurate with their demonstrated needs and willingness to bear the
resulting costs.
Importantly, the financial reservation model does not substitute congestion pricing for the
recovery of Large Load-specific interconnection or upgrade costs. Rather, it preserves efficient
system operations while allowing separate, targeted tariff provisions to address cost
responsibility, readiness, and reliability concerns without converting those protections into
physical scheduling preferences that could distort dispatch or strand transmission capability.
As such, the NYISO’s financial reservation system is beneficial because it enables the
NYISO to efficiently use the full capability of the transmission system to arrive at a least
production cost solution to serve NYCA Load using available Resources.626 All desired uses of
the transmission system are scheduled to the extent that customers are willing to pay congestion
charges.
C.
There Is No Need for the NYISO to Adopt the Transmission Services
Established by the PJM Co-Location Order
The Show Cause Order made a preliminary finding that:
NYISO’s Tariff appears to be unjust and unreasonable because it does not include
transmission services that reflect Eligible Customers taking transmission service
on behalf of Eligible Load that are willing and able to limit their use of the
transmission system under certain conditions. NYISO should explain whether the
Tariff remains just and reasonable without the transmission services described by
the Commission in the PJM Co-Location Order, with regional variation as
appropriate, being available to Eligible Customers taking transmission service on
behalf of Eligible Load, or propose appropriate Tariff revisions. Specifically,
NYISO should explain whether the Tariff remains just and reasonable without (1)
an interim non-firm network transmission service while Network Upgrades are
being constructed (i.e., interim NITS) and (2) permanent firm and non-firm
contract demand transmission services (transmission service up to a specified
MW quantity, i.e., the contract level, on a firm or non-firm basis).627
The NYISO is not proposing to adopt the three transmission services described in the
PJM Co-Location Order (the “PJM Co-Location Order Services”).
The NYISO notes that the Commission issued a Show Cause Order for the California
Independent System Operator Corporation (“CAISO Show Cause Order”) at the same time as the
626 See Regional Transmission Organizations, Order No. 2000, 65 Fed. Reg. 809 (Jan. 6, 2000), FERC
Stats. & Regs. ¶ 31,089 at pg. 31,126 (2000) (holding that systems based on locational prices and financial rights
“provide a sound framework for efficient congestion management”), order on reh'g, Order No. 2000-A, 65 Fed.
Reg. 12,088 (Feb. 25, 2000), FERC Stats. & Regs. ¶ 31,092 (2000), aff'd, Public Utility District No. 1 of Snohomish
County, Washington v. FERC, 272 F.3d 607 (D.C. Cir. 2001).
627 Show Cause Order at P 109.
PDF page 122
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 122
it did for the NYISO.628 The CAISO Show Cause Order recognized that the “CAISO does not
offer traditional Order No. 888 network and point-to-point transmission services.”629 It invited
CAISO to “explain whether, given that CAISO does not offer the transmission services required
by Order No. 888, CAISO’s existing transmission service framework addresses the concerns
described herein, or explain what specific changes to its existing transmission service framework
would effectively provide the same range of transmission service options for flexible large loads
as in the PJM Co-Location Order.”630
The Show Cause Order acknowledges in passing that the NYISO also provides non-
traditional transmission services.631 But the Commission did not expressly invite the NYISO to
justify its “existing transmission service framework” as it did the CAISO. Nevertheless, the
Commission should recognize that the NYISO’s financial transmission model is functionally the
same the CAISO’s. As discussed above and in the Harvey Affidavit, the NYISO, like the
CAISO, does not offer “traditional Order No. 888 network and point-to-point transmission
services,” does not make physical long-term transmission capacity reservations available, and
“does not provide a formal application process for transmission service.”632 The Commission
should therefore be every bit as open to the NYISO’s transmission service proposals in this filing
as it has indicated it will be to alternatives offered by the CAISO.633
Dr. Scott Harvey, a leading expert on the NYISO’s and CAISO’s transmission models,
market designs, and market software confirms the close similarities between the NYISO’s and
CAISO’s transmission regimes.634 Dr. Harvey emphasizes that, “NYISO’s existing firm service
and proposed new firm and non-firm withdrawal services address the need for tariff provisions
covering large loads that are able to curtail use of the transmission system when needed to avoid
adverse reliability and market impacts.”635 Dr. Harvey also states that “the NYISO’s proposed
Firm Withdrawal Service/Non-Firm Withdrawal Service framework is a reasonable and efficient
approach to serving large loads able to curtail load in real-time based on system conditions that is
compatible with and an effective application of the established NYISO financial reservation
model based on financial transmission rights and economic bids and security constrained
economic dispatch.”636 Dr. Harvey sees, “no need for the NYISO to adopt interim non-firm
NITS or contract demand services that were designed with a different region and different tariff
design in mind. NYISO’s proposed Firm and Non-Firm withdrawal services will bring
628 Cal. Indep. Sys. Operator Corp., 195 FERC ¶ 61,214 (2026)(“CAISO Show Cause Order”).
629 CAISO Show Cause Order at P 101.
630Id.
631 See, e.g., Show Cause Order at n. 68 (noting that no form of non-firm transmission service is currently
available within the NYISO) and n. 69 (recognizing that no customer has ever requested NITS from the NYISO.).
632 CAISO Show Cause Order at P 19.
633 The NYISO understands that the CAISO will likewise propose not to adopt the three PJM Co-Location
Order Services and will instead offer comparable alternatives that better fit its transmission and market model. See
CAISO Press Release, CAISO Board Advances New Procedures for Connecting Large Loads Quickly and Reliably,
https://www.caiso.com/about/news/news-releases/caiso-board-advances-new-procedures-for-connecting-large-
loads-quickly-and-reliably (Oct. 28, 2026).
634 See Harvey Affidavit at Section II.
635 Harvey Affidavit at P 52.
636 Id. at P 27.
PDF page 123
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 123
comparable (or greater) benefits and are more compatible with the NYISO’s financial
transmission reservation model and existing transmission cost allocation design.”637
In addition, Dr. Harvey demonstrates that there are various transmission cost recovery
and cost allocation differences between the NYISO’s transmission model and those used in other
regions that would further complicate any effort to implement the PJM Co-Location Order
Services in the NYISO. Dr. Harvey emphasizes that the NYISO’s decision not to adopt the PJM
Co-Location Order Services is “superior to a large load tariff based on interim non-firm NITS
and firm and non-firm contract demand service because the NYISO approach avoids the need for
a completely unnecessary change in the NYISO’s wholesale transmission cost recovery design
from one based on megawatt hours of withdrawals to one based on megawatt reservations . . .
.”638 The Harvey Affidavit provides a detailed review of the relevant distinctions that support his
conclusion.639
As explained above, the NYISO’s currently offers a single form of firm financial
reservation transmission service that operates as an improved, more flexible version of pro forma
NITS that does not subject customers to various restrictions that exist under the physical
reservation version of NITS. Moreover, the NITS procedures under the NYISO OATT have
never actually been used, even though they are theoretically available. There is thus no reason to
introduce a non-firm interim version of NITS that the Commission envisioned as a bridge to firm
NITS service when firm NITS service is not actually used in the NYISO.
Similarly, the NYISO proposes to offer its new Non-Firm Withdrawal Service as an
option to allow new Large Loads to connect to the grid faster and without the potential delays
required to mitigate adverse impacts to resource adequacy and/or transmission security. It is a
voluntary Transmission Service option that new Large Loads are permitted to choose provided
however that they comply with the applicable terms and conditions described in Part IV.B.ii
above. Reintroducing a new form of non-firm service, i.e., Non-Firm Withdrawal Service, to the
options available in the NYISO is a more than sufficient substitute for interim non-firm NITS
and the two contract demand services.
Furthermore, the NYISO is concerned that attempting to add the PJM Co-Located Order
Services to the NYISO’s model would be detrimental to the economic efficiencies achieved by
the NYISO’s existing market constructs. The result could be reducing the efficiency of the
NYISO’s least production cost commitment and dispatch system and to increase the overall cost
of serving Load in New York, as further explained below. The NYISO does not believe that this
would be a just and reasonable outcome given the lack of a rationale for adopting the PJM Co-
Location Order Services in NYISO.
During the extensive stakeholder process that culminated in this filing, no stakeholder
argued that the NYISO should adopt any of the three PJM Co-Location Order Services in lieu of
NYISO’s proposed Withdrawal Services. The NYISO believes that this fact is further evidence
637 Id.at P 52.
638 Harvey Affidavit at P 28.
639 See Harvey Affidavit at PP 28, 33-49.
PDF page 124
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 124
that the PJM Co-Location Order Service would serve no useful purpose in the NYISO, no matter
their potential benefits in PJM or other regions.640
Finally, the NYISO understands that PJM has indicated it could take several years to
implement the PJM Co-Location Order Services. PJM initially proposed a June 1, 2029
implementation date even though the services are native to PJM and were designed to
complement PJM’s established rules and procedures. By contrast, the NYISO would effectively
be starting from scratch and would have to make many more software and tariff changes if it
were required to integrate the PJM Co-Location Order Services into its model. Adopting the
PJM services would also very likely require the NYISO to take extensive measures to comply
with numerous North American Energy Standards Board requirements that do not currently
apply to it. In short, adapting the PJM Co-Location Order Services to fit the NYISO would all
but certainly be more expensive and time-consuming for the NYISO than for PJM. By contrast,
NYISO’s proposed Withdrawal Services would provide comparable or greater benefits and do so
more quickly, i.e., by the NYISO’s proposed June 1, 2028 effective date for its Large Load
market participation tariff revisions.
VI.
THE NYTOS AND THE NTOS ARE ADDRESSING CERTAIN SHOW CAUSE
ORDER ISSUES IN SEPARATE FPA SECTION 205 FILINGS
The Show Cause Order recognized that certain large load issues involve matters over
which New York’s transmission-owning jurisdictional utilities retain unilateral Section 205 filing
rights.641 The Commission gave the transmission owners an opportunity to address those issues
in their own FPA Section 205 filings. Subsequently, the Abeyance Order granted both the
NYTOs and the NTOs additional time to make such filings.
The NYISO understands that the NYTOs will make a concurrent filing to address several
Show Cause Order issues that they assert are subject to their reserved filing rights under the
ISO/TO Agreement. This will involve a number of revisions to NYISO OATT Section 5
(Special Provisions for Retail Access) to address large load-related rate issues that were not
contemplated when Section 5 was written. The NYISO also expects that the NYTOs will
propose some modifications to proposed Attachment LL and OATT Section 1. The NYTOs may
make additional Section 205 filings to address rate and cost recovery matters after the NYPSC
provides guidance on state-jurisdictional issues in its ongoing large load proceedings, i.e., Case
No. 26-E-0045.
The NYTOs will also propose four new two-party pro forma agreements that would be
added to the NYISO OATT. Specifically: (i) a Network Upgrade Cost Recovery Agreement; (ii)
a Security Agreement; (iii) a Facilities Study Agreement; and (iv) a Large Load Interconnection
Agreement. The NYISO would not be a party to any of these arrangements.
640 For the avoidance of doubt, the NYISO emphasizes that its arguments against implementing the PJM
Co-Location Order Services in NYISO should not be interpreted as questioning the adoption of those services in
PJM or other regions that choose to implement them. The NYISO’s arguments here are only applicable to the
NYISO region.
641 Show Cause Order at P 41.
PDF page 125
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 125
Similarly, the NYISO understands that the LS Power NY intends to make a Section 205
filing to address its rate and cost recovery issues. Because LS Power NY is an NTO without
retail customers the NYISO understands that its filing will principally involve proposed revisions
to NYISO OATT Schedule 10 (Rate Mechanism for the Recovery of the Regulated Transmission
Facilities Charge) instead of OATT Section 5
The NYISO is not a signatory to the NYTOs’ or NTOs’ FPA Section 205 filings. It will
play a ministerial role in electronically submitting their filings because they implicate NYISO
tariffs as the NYISO has done for prior transmission owner rate filings made under their reserved
rights. The NYISO reserves the right to comment on the NYTOs’ and NTOs’ proposals before
the Commission. In particular, the NYISO recognizes that the draft pro forma agreements will
be important to resolving the cost-shifting questions raised by the Show Cause Order. And while
the Show Cause Order envisioned the NYISO joining a three-party cost recovery agreement it
did not foreclose reasonable alternatives.642
VII.
THE FPA SECTION 205 STANDARD OF REVIEW AND SEVERABILITY
The Commission has explained that “[u]nder FPA section 205, the Commission is limited
to considering the filing before it, . . . .”643 Federal courts have similarly noted that “[w]hen
acting on a public utility’s rate filing under section 205, the Commission undertakes ‘an
essentially passive and reactive role’ and restricts itself to evaluating the confined proposal.”644
Courts have further acknowledged that “FERC has interpreted its authority to review rates under
[the FPA] as limited to an inquiry into whether the rates proposed by a utility are reasonable—
and not to extend to determining whether a proposed rate schedule is more or less reasonable
than alternative rate designs.”645 The Commission “is not required to choose the best solution,
only a reasonable one.”646
Adhering to these precedents and principles is especially appropriate in this proceeding.
The NYISO’s proposal addresses a large number of operationally and legally complex questions
in the context of the resource adequacy challenges facing New York. This included considering
jurisdictional issues, particularly the NYPSC’s views as a state regulator in the process of
devising its own large load interconnection policies. The NYISO’s proposal also had to be
developed exceptionally quickly while balancing the interests of many parties in order to obtain
super-majority stakeholder support. The proposal should therefore be judged on whether it
produces just, reasonable, not unduly discriminatory, and lawful rules – not on whether it will
result in the best imaginable solution in every instance.
The Commission should also assess the NYISO’s proposals in light of the NYISO-
specific conditions and circumstances that shaped it. As Chairman Swett noted in her
concurrence to the Show Cause Order, the Commission “has long allowed different regional
642 See Show Cause Order at PP 87-88.
643 Midcontinent Indep. Sys. Operator, Inc., 164 FERC ¶ 61,069, at P 48 (2018).
644 Advanced Energy Mgmt. All. v. FERC, 860 F.3d 656, 662 (D.C. Cir. 2017) (quoting City of Winnfield v.
FERC, 744 F.2d 871, 875-76 (D.C. Cir. 1984)).
645 Cities of Bethany v. FERC, 727 F.2d 1131, 1136 (D.C. Cir. 1984).
646 Petal Gas Storage, L.L.C. v. FERC, 496 F.3d 695, 703 (D.C. Cir. 2007).
PDF page 126
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 126
transmission organizations to follow different rules, in recognition of regional variations . . . .”647
The NYISO is starting from a different place, with different market, transmission, and
interconnection rules that several other ISOs and RTOs. It should not be a surprise, and is
entirely reasonable, that NYISO would develop distinctive proposals to address the Show Cause
Order’s concerns. What matters is that the NYISO’s proposals are just, reasonable, and not
unduly discriminatory on their own merits.
Each element of this proposal is just and reasonable. Nevertheless, in the event the
Commission deems it necessary, and to help facilitate the Commission’s acceptance of this filing
without delay, NYISO provides notice that it consents to the Commission’s exercise of authority
to modify and/or sever any element of the proposed OATT and Services Tariff language to the
extent necessary and permitted under FPA section 205 and NRG Power Marketing, LLC v.
FERC,648 where such modification and/or severance is consistent with the NYISO’s overarching
objectives in this filing. While the each of the reforms proposed in this filing is just and
reasonable and act together to advance important objectives, they may also be considered
separately. In particular, the NYISO consents to making any clarifications to its proposed tariff
revisions that the Commission considers necessary to confirm that Firm and Non-Firm
Withdrawal Services are Commission-jurisdictional transmission services.
VIII. STAKEHOLDER APPROVAL
The NYISO used the additional time provided by the Abeyance Order to conduct an
expedited, extensive, and ultimately successful stakeholder process. The NYISO held numerous
stakeholder meetings and made presentations describing its evolving proposals on July 23,
August 13, August 20, September 1, September 8, September 14, September 22, October 1,
October 7, and October 14. As the Smith Affidavit notes, this was not a straightforward effort
but an iterative, intense, and thorough process. The NYISO’s proposals are the product of
countless hours of internal coordination amongst NYISO business units and stakeholder
deliberations under significant time pressure. The proposals have evolved and matured
substantially since they were first proposed as a direct result of stakeholder feedback.
A near-final version of the NYISO’s proposal was discussed at a joint meeting of the
NYISO’s Business Issues Committee and Operating Committee on October 21. Several
changes, most notably the addition of the State Exempt Large Load Projects rules, were made in
response to comments presented at joint meeting. Subsequently, the NYISO’s final proposal was
approved by the stakeholder Management Committee on October 28 by a 100% vote with
abstentions.649 The proposal was then approved for filing by the NYISO’s independent Board of
Directors on November 16.
647 Show Cause Order (Swett, Chairman, concurring at n. 6 citing , Cent. Hudson Gas & Elec. Corp. v.
FERC, 138 F.4th 531, 539 (D.C. Cir. 2025) (internal citations omitted).
648 NRG Power Marketing, LLC v. FERC, 862 F.3d 108 (D.C. Cir. 2017).
649 The Management Committee authorized the NYISO to make incremental tariff revisions after the vote
subject to approval by the Management Committee, Business Issues Committee, and Operating Committee chairs.
A number of such incremental changes have been incorporated into this filing.
PDF page 127
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 127
The NYISO notes that the NYTOs’ and NTOs’ reserved filing rights are not subject to
the NYISO’s shared governance procedures. Their expected Section 205 filings therefore did
not require stakeholder approval. The NYTOs made an informational presentation describing
their planned filing at the October 22 meeting of the NYISO’s stakeholder Transmission
Planning Advisory Subcommittee.
IX.
REQUESTED EFFECTIVE DATES
The NYISO respectfully requests a February 1, 2027 effective date for proposed OATT
Attachment LL, i.e., the new LLIP, all new defined terms referenced in Attachment LL, Section
3A of the OATT, all other OATT and Services Tariff revisions directly related to Attachment LL
that are discussed in Parts II and III of this transmittal letter, and the BTM:NG sunsetting-related
revisions referenced in Part IV.I above. Because February 1 is less than 120 days after the date
of this filing there is no need for a demonstration of good cause to support these proposed
effective dates under Section 35.3 of the Commission’s regulations. The NYISO expects to be
ready to commence the optional pre-application process described proposed Attachment LL
Section 44.5 on February 1.
The requested February 1 effective date for the new Large Load Integration Procedures
also means that the NYISO’s currently effective large load interconnection procedures in OATT
Sections 3.9 and 4.5 will continue to be in effect for the entirety of the comment period. This is
more than eight months after the issuance of the Show Cause Order which will accommodate
existing commercial arrangements.
The NYISO is proposing to make its proposed tariff revisions related to its new market
participation provisions for Large Loads, i.e., the revisions described in Part IV (other than Part
IV.I) of this transmittal letter, effective on June 1, 2028. There is good cause for allowing these
provisions to become effective more than 120 days after this filing. No Large Loads are
expected to have completed the new LLIP, and thus to be able to utilize the new market
participation provisions, until June 1, 2028 at the earliest.
Finally, the NYISO’s is proposing to make its revision to Section 2 of the Services Tariff,
which would effectuate the sunsetting of the existing BTM:NG program, effective on May 1,
2029. There is good cause for an effective date more than 120 days in the future because it will
allow time for the handful of existing BTM:NG market participants to transition to alternative
participation models.
X.
REQUEST TO CONTINUE ABEYANCE OF SHOW CAUSE PROCEEDINGS
The Abeyance Order stated that, “[i]f NYISO or Transmission Owners submit an FPA
section 205 filing addressing the Commission’s preliminary findings in the Show Cause Order
on or before November 16, 2026, then the obligation of the respondent(s) who have made such
an FPA section 205 filing to file a response to the Show Cause Order will be suspended, and this
proceeding will continue to be held in abeyance pending further Commission directive in this
PDF page 128
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 128
proceeding.”650 The NYISO therefore requests that the Commission continue to hold the
proceedings in Docket No. EL26-69-000, and the NYISO’s obligation to submit an answer to the
Show Cause Order, in abeyance, pending Commission action on this filing.
In addition, the NYISO requests that if the Commission were to require the NYISO to
make additional tariff revisions before accepting the NYISO’s proposals under FPA Section 205
that it hold the Show Cause proceedings in further abeyance for a reasonable time to give the
NYISO an opportunity to prepare the necessary filing.
XI.
REQUEST FOR EXTENDED COMMENT PERIOD
The NYISO respectfully requests that the Commission extend the standard 21-day
comment period for FPA section 205 filings by one week. The Commission has often granted
extended comment periods for major filings that encompass numerous complex issues and tariff
revisions that are likely to have substantial economic and reliability implications. At the same
time, the NYISO recognizes the importance of the issues addressed by this filing and
understands the Commission’s desire to address large load issues rapidly. The NYISO is
mindful that the Commission has denied extension requests in certain recent involving large load
matters.651 Accordingly, the NYISO submits that a brief one-week extension to the standard
period so that comments would be due on December 14 instead of December 7 is reasonable
given the number, complexity, and importance of the proposals included in this filing. Such an
extension would also make a reasonable allowance for the comment period encompassing the
Thanksgiving holiday. Because the earliest effective date requested in this filing is February 1,
2027, i.e., two weeks beyond the default sixty-day period, a one-week extension would leave the
Commission with slightly more time to review this filing than if the standard comment and
notice periods applied.
650 Abeyance Order at P 11.
651 See, e.g., Notice Denying Extension of Time, Docket No. ER26-3515-000 (Sept. 2, 2026).
PDF page 129
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 129
XII.
COMMUNICATIONS AND CORRESPONDENCE
All communications and service with regard to this filing should be directed to:
Robert E. Fernandez, Executive Vice President,
Chief Compliance Officer & General Counsel
Karen Georgenson Gach, Deputy General
Counsel
Brian R. Hodgdon, Senior Attorney
Kimberly Loan Osborne, Senior Attorney I
Raquel M. Parks, Attorney II
New York Independent System Operator, Inc.
10 Krey Boulevard
Rensselaer, NY 12144
Tel: (518) 356-6000
Fax: (518) 356-4702
rfernandez@nyiso.com
kgach@nyiso,com
bhodgdon@nyiso.com
kosborne@nyiso.com
rparks@nyiso.com
*Ted J. Murphy
Nathan R. Menard
Hunton Andrews Kurth LLP
2200 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
Washington, D.C. 20037
Tel: (202) 955-1500
Fax: (202) 778-2201
tmurphy@hunton.com
nmenard@hunton.com
*Michael J. Messonnier Jr.
Hunton Andrews Kurth LLP
951 East Byrd Street
Richmond, VA 23219
Tel: (804) 788-8200
Fax: (804) 344-7999
mmessonnier@hunton.com
Mackinlee Rogers
Hunton Andrews Kurth LLP
1445 Ross Avenue
Dallas, TX 75202
Tel: (214) 979-3000
Fax: (214) 880-0011
rogersm@hunton.com
XIII. SERVICE
The NYISO will send an electronic link to this filing to the official representative of each
of its customers, to each participant on its stakeholder committees, to the New York Public
Service Commission, and to the New Jersey Board of Public Utilities. In addition, a complete
copy of the documents included with this filing will be posted on the NYISO’s website at
www.nyiso.com.
PDF page 130
Hon. Debbie-Anne A. Reese
November 16, 2026
Page 130
XIV. CONCLUSION
Wherefore, the NYISO respectfully requests that the Commission accept the revisions
proposed in this filing as just, reasonable, and not unduly discriminatory without requiring any
modifications or initiating additional procedures. The Commission should continue to hold the
proceedings initiated by the Show Cause Order in abeyance while it reviews this filing and
should ultimately determine that that this filing satisfies all Show Cause Order directives that fall
within the scope of the NYISO’s responsibilities and FPA Section 205 filing rights.
Respectfully submitted,
/s/ Kimberly Loan Osborne
Kimberly Loan Osborne
Brian R. Hodgdon
Raquel M. Parks
/s/ Ted J. Murphy
Ted J. Murphy
Michael J. Messonnier, Jr.
Hunton Andrews Kurth LLP
Counsel for the New York Independent System
Operator, Inc.
cc:
Janel Burdick
James Dawson
Jignasa Gadani
Leanne Khammal
Jaime Knepper
Travis LaHue
David Morenoff
Jason Rhee
Douglas Roe