ER27-25-000 · 2026-11-12 · Citizens Utility Board of Michigan and five other consumer advocates

Six MISO-state consumer advocates answer in support of the Organization of MISO States

Consumer advocates from Wisconsin, Minnesota, Michigan, Illinois and Iowa answer in MISO's ER27-25 docket. They agree coordinated study of mature, proximate loads may bring efficiencies. They ask FERC to condition acceptance of the large load study tariff on cost protections and a strict proximity test.

Asks FERC to: Condition acceptance of LARS on cost responsibility, an approved cost-recovery framework, an engineering-based proximity test, a materiality review after changes, tracking, and a five-year sunset.

Answers the order. Filed in MISO's section 205 LARS docket, ER27-25, and cites the E-8 show cause order's preliminary finding on cost shifts. It argues LARS only partly answers that order.

E-8 MISO: Show cause or propose tariff changes in 60 days (p. 5) E-8 MISO: Cost-recovery agreement (P 6(b), p. 6) E-8 MISO: Proximate-generation service (P 6(e), p. 7)

Key points

  1. The advocates agree with the Organization of MISO States that coordinated study of mature, proximate loads and generation may bring efficiencies if well designed.
    the Consumer Advocates agree with OMS that coordinated study of sufficiently mature, electrically proximate Large Loads and associated generation may provide meaningful efficiencies if appropriately designed. PDF p. 2
  2. They say FERC opened the show cause proceeding on a preliminary finding that MISO's tariff may not protect transmission customers from large load cost shifts.
    The Commission instituted the related show-cause proceeding because it preliminarily found that MISO’s existing Tariff may be unjust and unreasonable insofar as it does not adequately protect transmission customers against cost shifts resulting from Large Load integration. PDF p. 3
  3. They ask FERC to condition acceptance of LARS on cost causation, a prior cost-recovery framework, real proximity and review of material changes.
    The Commission should condition acceptance of LARS on protections that preserve cost causation, prevent construction of a project before the associated cost-recovery framework is approved, require an actual electrically-proximate relationship between associated generation and load, and provide appropriate review when material changes undermine the assumptions supporting identified transmission investments. PDF p. 3
  4. They say cost responsibility should start from cost causation and not from the planning label given to a facility.
    For ratepayer-protection purposes, the inquiry should begin with cost causation, not the planning label subsequently assigned to the facility. PDF p. 4
  5. They say FERC should not approve faster transmission investment decisions before it can evaluate the mechanism protecting customers from the resulting exposure.
    The Commission should not approve the mechanism that accelerates transmission investment decisions before it can evaluate the mechanism intended to protect customers from the resulting financial exposure. PDF p. 5
  6. They say being in the same local resource zone should not count as proximity or alone establish eligibility.
    Same-LRZ membership should not be considered “proximity” and should not alone establish eligibility. PDF p. 8
  7. They ask for a materiality review after a withdrawal, material downsizing or other significant change.
    It should instead require a materiality review following a withdrawal, material downsizing, or other significant change. PDF p. 8
  8. They support the OMS recommendations on public reporting and a five-year sunset.
    support OMS’s recommendations concerning public reporting and a five-year sunset. PDF p. 9

Read topic-matched comments in ER27-25

Topics in the text: Connecting load and generation · Cost allocation · Registry access

Source sections

Printed headings where available; page ranges otherwise. Excerpts below are selected from the text by keyword.

Opening text

opening text · Topic match: Registry access

ER27-25-000 MOTION FOR LEAVE TO ANSWER AND ANSWER OF MISO CONSUMER ADVOCATES Pursuant to the Rules of Practice and Procedure of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (Commission or FERC), the Citizens Utility Board of Wisconsin, the Citizens Utility Board of Minnesota, the Citizens Utility Board…
Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access

I. MOTION FOR LEAVE TO ANSWER

printed heading · Topic match: Registry access

We accept the answers filed in this proceeding because they have provided information that assisted us in our decision-making process.”) (citing 18 C.F.R. § 385.213(a)(2)); Great Basin Transmission, LLC, 190 FERC ¶ 61,110 at P 26 (2025) (“We accept Great Basin’s answer because it has provided…
Read this passage Filed comments: Registry access

II. INTRODUCTION

PDF bookmark

II.
Read this passage

INTRODUCTION

printed heading · Topic match: Cost allocation

INTRODUCTION The MISO Consumer Advocates represent residential and other ratepaying customers that ultimately bear substantial portions of the costs of the generation and transmission systems serving the MISO region.
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

III. LARS SHOULD PRESERVE COST CAUSATION THROUGH SUBSEQUENT PLANNING AND CLASSIFICATION PROCESSES

PDF bookmark · Topic match: Cost allocation

This does not mean every facility identified in connection with LARS must automatically be directly assigned to a Large Load.
Read this passage Filed comments: Cost allocation

IV. LARS SHOULD NOT BECOME OPERATIONAL BEFORE THE ASSOCIATED COST-RECOVERY PROTECTIONS ARE APPROVED

PDF bookmark · Topic match: Connecting load and generation

LARS SHOULD NOT BECOME OPERATIONAL BEFORE THE ASSOCIATED COST-RECOVERY PROTECTIONS ARE APPROVED MISO acknowledges that the LARS process ultimately will require a pro forma cost- shifting agreement and additional transmission-service provisions for Large Loads.
Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation

V. MISO’S READINESS AND WITHDRAWAL PROVISIONS DO NOT RESOLVE THE COST-CAUSATION ISSUE

PDF bookmark · Topic match: Connecting load and generation

Among other measures, MISO proposes a $250,000 nonrefundable application deposit, a $30,000/MW generator milestone, 100 percent site control, binding generation-load arrangements, service deadlines, financial-security requirements, and continuing responsibility for certain Network Upgrade costs…
Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation

VI. SAME-LRZ MEMBERSHIP DOES NOT ESTABLISH THE ELECTRICAL PROXIMITY NECESSARY FOR SPECIALIZED TREATMENT

PDF bookmark · Topic match: Connecting load and generation

SAME-LRZ MEMBERSHIP DOES NOT ESTABLISH THE ELECTRICAL PROXIMITY NECESSARY FOR SPECIALIZED TREATMENT OMS also correctly questions MISO’s use of LRZ boundaries to establish proximity between a LARS Associated Load and associated generation.
Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation

VII. MATERIAL CHANGES SHOULD TRIGGER REVIEW OF CONTINUING NEED AND COST RESPONSIBILITY

PDF bookmark · Topic match: Connecting load and generation

MATERIAL CHANGES SHOULD TRIGGER REVIEW OF CONTINUING NEED AND COST RESPONSIBILITY MISO proposes that there will be no LARS restudy when an Associated Load withdraws.
Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation

VIII. TRANSPARENCY AND PERIODIC REVIEW ARE NECESSARY TO PROTECT RATEPAYERS

PDF bookmark · Topic match: Connecting load and generation

A five-year sunset and formal review are also appropriate because MISO proposes LARS as a permanent process from its inception.20 Before continuing LARS, MISO should report at least: • LARS applications, completed projects, and withdrawals; • forecast and actual Large Load additions; • transmission…
Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation

IX. CONCLUSION

PDF bookmark

IX.
Read this passage

CONCLUSION

printed heading · Topic match: Connecting load and generation

But MISO’s filing confirms that LARS can produce cost shifts under existing Tariff mechanisms, proposes implementation before the associated cost-recovery agreement is before the Commission, relies on an LRZ construct that does not necessarily demonstrate electrical proximity, and categorically…
Read this passage Filed comments: Connecting load and generation

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

printed heading

Dated at this 11th day of November 2026 /s/ Daniel Narvey Daniel Narvey General Counsel Citizens Utility Board of Wisconsin 625 N.
Read this passage