Key issues in permitting reform

What S. 5653 would change, the bill sections behind each provision, and how supporters and critics read them.

Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026 · Updated 2026-11-18 · Open interactive view

Jump to: Data centers · Project delays · Communities · Debate · Senate votes · Published estimates

What would the bill change?

Review deadlines

Sets 2-year EIS and 1-year assessment deadlines, followed by deadlines for agency decisions. Bill p. 46, line 15 to p. 46, line 18

Extensions and enforcement conditions apply; the travel sanction limits official trips beyond 25 miles after a qualifying deadline is 60 days overdue. Bill p. 54, line 17 to p. 54, line 20

Court challenges

Generally allows 150 days for NEPA challenges in a court of appeals, with direct-harm and conditional comment requirements. Bill p. 67, line 24 to p. 68, line 2

Limits remedies to remand, with a fix due within 180 days; preliminary injunctions remain available under specified conditions involving other law. Bill p. 69, line 24 to p. 70, line 1

Issued permits

Restricts interference with permits in effect on or after September 16, 2026, subject to listed exceptions including the holder’s request. Bill p. 159, line 12 to p. 159, line 15

If the agency fails to meet its burden in court, the sponsor is entitled to specified relief, including a court-determined 25 to 50 percent of incurred project costs not otherwise recovered. Bill p. 164, line 3 to p. 164, line 6

Data center costs

Newly connected data-center loads of 20 megawatts or more must cover their incremental electricity costs. Bill p. 235, line 12 to p. 235, line 13

Previously approved service arrangements remain in effect. Bill p. 240, line 5 to p. 240, line 8

The bill recognizes state authority to require new generation. Bill p. 237, line 14 to p. 237, line 17

Transmission siting

FERC can permit interstate lines of 230 kilovolts and up that states have not approved, after making required findings, and planning regions must plan lines with their neighbors. Bill p. 189, line 17 to p. 189, line 19

Actions outside NEPA

Excludes specified loan-only actions, qualifying work in existing grid and pipeline corridors, and listed oil, gas and geothermal activities from NEPA. Bill p. 204, line 17 to p. 204, line 21

Each exclusion has its own scope and conditions. Bill p. 204, line 19 to p. 204, line 21

Clean Water Act

Narrows state water-quality certification review and generally limits it to one year; extensions require written agreement. Bill p. 114, line 20 to p. 114, line 22

Extends nationwide permits to 10 years. Bill p. 125, line 2 to p. 125, line 3

Endangered Species Act

Cuts the standard formal consultation period from 90 days to 60, with extension rules. Bill p. 134, line 16 to p. 134, line 17

Lets approved state programs assume specified consultation responsibilities; applicants can opt for federal consultation. Bill p. 148, line 7 to p. 148, line 10

Historic preservation and tribal consultation

Narrows the effects covered by historic-preservation review and sets deadlines. Bill p. 380, line 13 to p. 380, line 16

Adds a 150-day challenge window and limits remedies, with separate rules for missed deadlines. Bill p. 408, line 23 to p. 408, line 25

Digital permitting

Requires a public tracker of defined transparency projects, and targets December 1, 2028 for an interagency ePermit system, to the maximum extent practicable. Bill p. 98, line 1 to p. 98, line 3

Data centers

What the bill would change for data centers, AI computing facilities and grid interconnection: study automation, transmission rates, grid-enhancing technologies, behind-the-meter resources and cost allocation.

Interconnection study automation and AI evaluation

Directs FERC to initiate a rulemaking within 1 year requiring public utility transmission providers to share and employ queue management practices using artificial intelligence, machine learning, and automation to evaluate and process interconnection requests faster, revisited every 4 years. Sec. 2110

15-day default deadline for grid study data

Adds Federal Power Act section 232. Bulk-power system users, owners, and operators must provide requested grid data within 15 days (unless FERC sets an alternative timeline for a data category) in a format the requester can use or convert. Confidentiality rules cannot be used to withhold data; violations by public utilities are subject to FPA section 316A reliability enforcement penalties, with other entities subject to FERC compliance orders. Sec. 2111

Standardized reference spec for fully automated studies

Requires FERC and the Department of Energy to publish, within 1 year, a joint reference specification for fully automated interconnection studies, including system impact studies, without supplemental data requests during the study process. Sec. 2111

Standardized cost-reduction options in upgrade studies

Requires FERC rules for a standardized analysis to identify upgrades for computational load sites and cost-reduction options. Sec. 2107

Mandatory transmission rate discount for non-firm computational load

Directs FERC to revise its 1994 pricing policy statement within 270 days to provide a lower cost of transmission service for computational loads that elect non-firm transmission service, followed by a proposed rule within 270 days and a final rule within 1 year. Sec. 2107

Standard firm transmission pricing baseline ('and' pricing)

Declares it unjust and unreasonable under FPA sections 205 and 206 to charge computational loads less than embedded costs plus incremental expansion costs ('and' pricing). Directs that incremental revenues be credited to the utility's annual transmission revenue requirement to prevent double recovery from other customers. Sec. 2107

Codification of flexible and interim transmission service

Statutorily defines transmission service categories under FPA section 228, explicitly including network integration, point-to-point, and any interim, non-firm, or contract demand service that limits the quantity of energy withdrawn or operating conditions. Sec. 2107

Mandatory deployment of advanced transmission technologies

Requires public utilities to use advanced transmission technologies in covered projects whenever benefits exceed costs, backed by a presumption of prudence and return-on-equity reduction penalties for non-compliance. Sec. 2109

NEPA and historic preservation categorical exclusion for reconductoring

Adds Federal Power Act section 216A: work that maintains or increases grid capacity in an existing right-of-way or necessary adjacent area (reconductoring, higher voltage, advanced conductors, added circuits) is designated as categorically excluded from NEPA and exempt from NHPA section 106 undertakings. Sec. 2102

Statutory wholesale market access for behind-the-meter power

Effective 18 months after enactment, declares it unjust and unreasonable under FPA sections 205 and 206 for any grid operator to prevent participation of qualifying behind-the-meter aggregations (100 kW minimum aggregation, 5 kW per unit, 15-minute response) in wholesale energy, capacity, or ancillary service markets. Sec. 2108

Device-level metering and inverter telemetry

Rules cannot require equipment owned or installed by the distribution utility; wholesale market participation may use device-level equipment and smart inverters for metering and telemetry. Sec. 2108

No allocation of incremental cost to other customers

Adds Federal Power Act section 228. For data centers and high-density computing loads of 20 MW or more that interconnect on or after enactment, no portion of the incremental generation, storage, transmission, or distribution cost may be allocated to or recovered in rates of any other customer. Existing approved arrangements remain grandfathered. Sec. 2107

Exit liability and up-front financial assurance

For loads connecting on or after enactment, utilities must collect financial assurance or upfront contributions before constructing facilities or upgrades. Cost recovery continues even if the data center terminates its contract or ceases electric purchases; existing arrangements are grandfathered. Sec. 2107

State authority to auction grid access and require new generation

For loads connecting on or after enactment, States may hold competitive solicitations or open seasons to allocate retail service among covered loads, charge more than incremental cost to rebate other customers, require bring-your-own new generation, and prioritize non-firm loads. Pre-enactment approved arrangements remain in effect. Sec. 2107

Mandatory EIA reporting on data center electricity load

Directs the Energy Information Administration to revise Form 861 to include electricity load from data center entities (AI, cloud, cryptocurrency) no later than 90 days before the first April 1 after enactment. Sec. 2114

Project delays

Studies of how long energy projects take and why, grouped by cause, with the bill text on each cause and named analysts' readings of it. Disagreements between studies are noted on the cause they concern.

Environmental impact statement timelines

CEQ reported a median of 2.2 years from notice of intent to final EIS for EISs finished in 2024; the 2017-2020 median was 3.1 years and 2021-2024 was 2.4 years. Council on Environmental Quality

CGO found clean-energy EISs averaged about three years from notice of intent to record of decision, with solar fastest (just under two years to final EIS) and hydroelectric slowest (5.1 years). Center for Growth and Opportunity (Utah State University)

RFF found solar and wind EISs averaged 26 and 43 months against 54 months across all project types, and most wind, solar and geothermal projects took over five years to become operational. Resources for the Future

CGEP, citing CEQ, put the 2019-2024 median EIS at 2.8 years, and noted agencies reported two EISs and 153 assessments missing the 2023 statutory deadlines between June 2023 and June 2025. Columbia University Center on Global Energy Policy

Lawsuits under NEPA

Ruple and Race found about one in 450 NEPA decisions (all decisions, including categorical exclusions) was litigated, and the challenge rate fell over the study period. University of Utah Wallace Stegner Center

Bennon and Wilson found 28% of projects requiring an EIS saw pre-development litigation, with the highest rates for solar (nearly two-thirds), pipelines (50%), wind (38%) and transmission (31%). Stanford University

RFF found nearly a third of solar and half of wind projects that completed EISs were sued, and agencies mostly won. Resources for the Future

Breakthrough found NEPA appeals averaged 4.2 years from the EIS or EA to the end of the appeal, with agencies winning about 80%. Breakthrough Institute

Interconnection queues

LBNL found the median time from interconnection request to commercial operation doubled from under 2 years (built 2000-2007) to over 4 years (built 2018-2024). Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

LBNL found 13% of capacity requested 2000-2019 reached operation, 77% was withdrawn and 10% was still active. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory

Reporting LBNL's July 2026 update, APPA says request-to-agreement took well over 3 years in 2025 and request-to-operation exceeded 5 years in regions with data. LBNL's own page was not fetchable. American Public Power Association (reporting LBNL's next Queued Up edition)

Hausfather finds data centers that skip the grid for on-site gas generators have 60 to 80% higher emissions. He gives no figure for queue times. The Climate Brink

High-voltage transmission construction

Grid Strategies found only 322 miles of 345 kV+ lines were completed in 2024, versus nearly 4,000 in 2013. Grid Strategies and Americans for a Clean Energy Grid

Gas pipelines averaged 534 miles a year over five years against 345 miles for high-voltage lines; the report links the gap to FERC's siting authority over pipelines. Grid Strategies and Americans for a Clean Energy Grid

The report cites DOE's study as calling for doubling regional and quadrupling interregional capacity by 2050, about 5,000 miles a year of regional lines. Grid Strategies and Americans for a Clean Energy Grid

Local and state siting

Sabin counted at least 459 counties and municipalities in 44 states with severe local restrictions on renewables, up 16% in a year. Columbia University Sabin Center for Climate Change Law

The sixth Sabin report counts 567 contested projects since 2004, with about 40% cancelled; it says cancellations cannot all be attributed to local opposition. Columbia University Sabin Center (reported by pv magazine USA)

LBNL's developer survey ranked community opposition and local ordinances alongside grid interconnection as leading causes of delay and cancellation. Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory (reported by Latitude Media)

Third Way's survey found organized resistance affects a minority of projects, federal reviews caused the longest delays, and state and local permitting also slowed projects. Third Way (survey by ERM)

Adelman and co-authors conclude the empirical record shows environmental review and permitting rarely delay or block utility-scale renewables, citing the LBNL survey result that environmental regulations caused under 15% of delays or cancellations. Environmental Law Reporter

A Crux survey of 50 developers says federal permitting contributed to delays or cancellations in 94% of surveyed projects. Crux

Federal action on approved projects

The largest 2025 cancellation in Sabin's data, 6.2 GW Esmeralda 7 in Nevada, was cancelled by BLM. pv magazine USA (reporting Sabin Center)

AP reports the administration suspended five offshore wind projects in December and they later moved forward after federal judges intervened. Associated Press via PBS NewsHour

Historic preservation review (Section 106)

ACHP says over 120,000 undertakings go through Section 106 each year and over 95% resolve without ACHP involvement. Advisory Council on Historic Preservation

IFP says few undertakings are found to adversely affect historic properties, but those that do are disproportionately large energy and infrastructure projects. Institute for Progress

Adelman and co-authors note that there are almost no data or studies on how long Section 106 consultation takes. Environmental Law Reporter

Endangered species consultations

Li reported median consultation times of 13 days (informal) and 62 days (formal) from when FWS had enough information to start. Defenders of Wildlife

Li reported 1,381 formal consultations, 20%, exceeded the 135-day limit, many with agreed extensions. Defenders of Wildlife

Clean Water Act permits and state certification

EPA's inspector general found more than a third of the Corps individual permits in its sample took a year or longer. The sample is from 2011 and covers coal mining only. EPA Office of Inspector General

Agency staffing

A former Permitting Council director warned staff losses and expected funding cuts could undermine the federal permitting modernization plan. No headcount is given. Nextgov/FCW (quoting Eric Beightel, former Federal Permitting Council director)

IFP reports Utah's digital SHPO finishes about 98% of reviews within seven days. Institute for Progress

Adelman and co-authors argue that agency funding, staffing and training speed permitting for every kind of project. Environmental Law Reporter

Clean energy and fossil projects in federal review

RFF found solar, wind and geothermal reviews were historically shorter than other infrastructure, though other steps may take as long. Resources for the Future

Communities

How the bill changes who can comment, be consulted, take part in planning or go to court.

Section 106 and tribes

Historic preservation review, tribal land and the lawsuits that follow from them.

Environmental review of tribal rights-of-way

A tribe could grant rights-of-way over its own land without Interior's approval if it follows a tribal regulation Interior has approved. The regulation must provide an environmental review that informs the public, gives a reasonable opportunity to comment and requires the tribe to answer each relevant and substantive comment before approval. Interior's approval of a tribal regulation is not subject to NEPA, section 106 or the Endangered Species Act. Sec. 2212

Who is consulted under section 106

The new consultation steps name state and tribal historic preservation officers, Indian tribes, Native Hawaiian organizations, local governments and the applicant. They do not name other consulting parties or the public. The agency 'may' consult the named parties on the area of effects and on historic properties, and must seek and, as applicable, incorporate their information if received within 30 days of a request. The agency's duty is limited to the area of potential effects it identifies. Sec. 2301

What counts as an effect or an undertaking under section 106

An adverse effect must be reasonably foreseeable and directly alter a property's characteristics. Visual, atmospheric or audible elements count only if they directly and significantly diminish the property's eligible characteristics. An undertaking would exclude work where the only federal involvement is a loan, loan guarantee or grant not made for historic preservation, and the area of potential effects would exclude areas affected only by a non-federal part of a project. Sec. 2301

Deadlines in section 106 consultation

The agency has 30 days to decide whether a proposal is an undertaking and 60 days after that to send a report when there are adverse effects. It then has 90 days to find the effects acceptable or reach an agreement, followed by 60 days of consultation, 45 days for formal Advisory Council comments and 30 days for a final determination. Consultation must end by the date the environmental document is due, unless the Secretary approves an extension for extraordinary circumstances. Sec. 2301

Silence and objections in section 106 consultation

If a preservation officer, tribe, Native Hawaiian organization or local government does not respond within 30 days of a request to review a report or finding, the agency proceeds. If a party raises substantive objections within 30 days, the agency has 30 days to explain how it considered them, and its duty to consult on that report is then fulfilled. The agency may decide, in its sole discretion, that other considerations outweigh historic preservation. Sec. 2301

Funding and oversight of state and tribal preservation offices

The bill authorizes $200,000,000 a year for the Fund for fiscal years 2027 to 2036 and makes deposits available from fiscal year 2028 without further appropriation. It adds $20,000,000 a year for fiscal years 2027 to 2030 in competitive grants for tribal preservation officers' online databases. Programs would be evaluated at least every 2 years, and a program that does not regularly meet consultation timelines is not consistent, which can lead to suspended grants and the Secretary taking over the officer's functions. Sec. 2302 · Sec. 2301

Tribal consent to rights-of-way across tribal land

The bill strikes the references to the 1934 and 1936 Acts from that sentence, which as amended reads as covering lands of any tribe. A tribe could also grant rights-of-way itself under an approved regulation and set compensation and terms by negotiation or regulation. An approved regulation does not stop a tribe from consenting to a grant by Interior. Sec. 2212

NEPA challenges to actions on tribal trust land

For an action authorizing use of land, minerals or other resources held in trust for a tribe, there would be no administrative or judicial review based on a failure to comply with NEPA. The exceptions are a claim by the tribe whose trust resources are used and a claim about reasonably foreseeable effects outside those resources. For tribe-initiated actions, the lead agency must presume the no-action alternative has negative effects. Sec. 1110 · Sec. 1106

Time, comment and court rules for section 106 claims

A claim would be barred unless filed within 150 days after the later of the final agency action being made public and the preservation officer being notified. The plaintiff must have suffered or imminently will suffer direct harm and, where there was a comment period, filed a substantive and unique comment by the noticed deadline on the same subject. Claims go to the courts of appeals, with substantial deference to the agency. Sec. 2301

Governments that raise issues in consultation keep their right to sue

The direct-harm and comment requirements would not apply where a state or tribal preservation officer, tribe, Native Hawaiian organization or local government gave detailed written notice during consultation that identified the issues. The exemption does not name other consulting parties or the public. Sec. 2301

Remedy when a court finds a section 106 violation

The only remedy would be a remand without vacatur or injunction, with a deadline of no more than 180 days. A preliminary injunction is allowed only if the action likely violates a federal law other than the historic preservation division of title 54 or NEPA, and the usual tests are met. Sec. 2301

Challenges to section 106 programmatic agreements

Only signatories could sue over how a programmatic agreement is implemented; no court would have jurisdiction over a suit by anyone else. Federal agencies must develop programmatic agreements for routine and repetitive categories, and a state or tribal officer's agreement for the same category would apply. Sec. 2301

Objecting to a tribe's handling of a right-of-way

An interested party that has exhausted tribal remedies could petition Interior to review a tribe's compliance with its approved regulation. If Interior finds a violation it may act, including rescinding approval of the regulation, after the tribe gets a formal hearing and a chance to cure. Sec. 2212

Species and water

Endangered Species Act consultation and Clean Water Act permits and certifications, with their court rules.

Public comment on federal water quality criteria

EPA would have to use rulemaking under 5 U.S.C. 553 when it develops any section 304(a) criterion. Final criteria, and a definition of waters of the United States, would be added to the actions reviewed first in the courts of appeals under section 509(b)(1). Sec. 1201

Time for Endangered Species Act section 7 consultation

The 90-day period becomes 60 days and the 150-day mark becomes 100 days. An applicant becomes eligible for relief under 5 U.S.C. 706(1) if an extended consultation passes 145 days without the required statement or consent. When an environmental document is required, consultation must finish by the date that document is due, unless the Secretary approves an extension for extraordinary circumstances. Sec. 1302

State-run Endangered Species Act consultation

Interior could assign its consultation duties to a state by written agreement of up to 10 years, for projects within that state. The state must publish its complete application at least 60 days before filing, take public comment for at least 30 days and respond to comments. Audits for the first 4 years go out for public comment and Interior must respond within 60 days. District courts would hear suits against a state that fails to carry out its duties, under the same standards as against Interior. A permit applicant may still choose to consult Interior. Sec. 1304

What a state can deny or condition under Clean Water Act section 401

Scope would be limited to 'water quality requirements', meaning sections 301, 302, 303, 306 and 307 and the federal, state and tribal laws implementing them. A certifying authority could deny only on clear and convincing evidence that no modification or reasonable condition would allow certification. Each condition needs clear and convincing evidence that it is necessary, the least burdensome and consistent with the federal permit. Sec. 1202

Time for a state to act on a section 401 certification

The federal agency sets a reasonable period of up to 1 year that must account for time needed under state or tribal law for public notice and comment. An extension needs the applicant's written request and the state's written concurrence. Certifying authorities must keep procedures for public notice of all applications and, as they see fit, hearings. For interstate gas pipelines and interstate transmission lines the period is up to 9 months and certification covers only direct point-source discharges. Sec. 1202

Reissuing nationwide Clean Water Act permits

Reissuing a nationwide permit would need no state consultation under ESA section 6(a), no federal consultation under ESA section 7(a)(2) and no section 106 consultation, and NEPA would be met by a programmatic assessment, if the permit does not narrow or raise the threshold for preconstruction requirements. The Corps would consider only effects on water quality requirements and treat a discharge into less than 2 acres as minimal. General permits would last 10 years. Sec. 1204 · Sec. 1203

Challenges to Clean Water Act section 404 permits

Suits over individual and general permits, verifications under a general permit, and EPA approval of a state permit program would be barred unless filed within 150 days. Where a draft was published in the Federal Register with at least 30 days of comment, the plaintiff must have filed a detailed comment and the claim must relate to it. A court must remand and may not vacate or enjoin a permit unless activities would present an imminent and substantial danger to human health or the environment for which no other equitable remedy is available. Sec. 1205

Time and court for challenges to biological opinions

Any person could seek review of a biological opinion only in the D.C. Circuit, by a petition filed within 150 days after the opinion is made public on the agency's website. Sec. 1305

Court review of state certification decisions

A court reviewing a denial must put the burden on the certifying authority to show by clear and convincing evidence that no reasonable modification or condition would allow certification. For a challenged condition, the authority must show by clear and convincing evidence that it is necessary, least burdensome and consistent with the federal permit. A waiver of certification would not be subject to judicial review. Sec. 1202

Siting and transmission

Federal siting of transmission lines, landowners, payments to places a line crosses and where challenges go.

FERC siting of a line over a state's objection

The corridor requirement is dropped. FERC 'shall' issue a permit for lines of 230 kilovolts or more that meet the findings, including one of the state-related triggers. The state's clock would start when the application is filed with the state. Developers of lines of 345 kilovolts or more could file at FERC at the same time as at the state, but FERC may not issue a permit until it makes one of the state-related findings. Sec. 2101

Views before FERC in a siting case

FERC must hold a public comment period of at least 45 days and must take landowner input into account. Affected landowners include owners of land crossed, used as a facility site or abutting the right-of-way, owners of a residence within 500 feet of the right-of-way, and federal, state and local governments. A state may file any part of its state record, and FERC must consider it. Sec. 2101

Eminent domain and compensation for a FERC-permitted line

Federal court procedure would follow Rule 71.1 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Section 2101(e) also strikes subsection (f) of section 216 and replaces it with a cost allocation subsection. As written, the statutory fair market value language would no longer appear in section 216. The text does not change the Fifth Amendment's just-compensation requirement. Sec. 2101

Payments to places a transmission line crosses

The list would add all prudently incurred costs of payments to jurisdictions impacted by lines developed under section 216 or 225. The text does not require any payment or set an amount. Sec. 2101

States referring a utility's local transmission planning to FERC

Within 1 year FERC must set procedures for states to refer a public utility for investigation of its local transmission planning. FERC must notice the investigation for public comment and certify a team that includes up to 3 state-appointed members, then notice the team's report for comment. Remedies include changed processes, a lower return on equity, loss of the prudence presumption and a fine of up to $5,000,000 per facility paid to the referring state. Sec. 2104

Selected regional projects and FERC siting findings

A project selected in a regional or joint interregional plan would be considered to satisfy the findings in paragraphs (2) through (5) and, if applicable, (6) of section 216(b). The planning section lists required process elements, and none addresses state or public participation. Approval of a planning process is not a major Federal action under NEPA. Sec. 2103

Courts for challenges to transmission authorizations

Any order of a federal agency, or of a state agency acting under federal law, to issue, condition or deny a federal authorization for a transmission facility would be reviewed in the courts that review FERC orders under Federal Power Act section 313. 'Federal authorization' would include a Clean Water Act section 401 certification and other state approvals required under federal law, except under the Coastal Zone Management Act. Sec. 2101

Court rules and public comment

Environmental review: comment periods, who can sue, how long they have and which court hears them.

Comment period on a notice of intent for an EIS

Each notice of intent would be published in the Federal Register with a request for comment. The lead agency would set a comment period of 45 to 60 days after publication, or up to 75 days if the lead agency and the project sponsor agree. Sec. 1106

Combining categorical exclusions

A lead agency could rely on one exclusion or a combination of several. Repeated use of the same or similar exclusions based on size, acreage or dollar thresholds would not count as a combination. An exclusion established by Congress would also qualify. The text adds no notice or comment step for relying on an exclusion. Sec. 1105

Actions defined as not a major Federal action

The list would grow to fourteen. New entries include projects whose only federal involvement is a loan or loan guarantee, and routine agency actions costing up to $10,000,000. Others cover lifeline infrastructure repair that adds no more than 20 percent capacity, geothermal observation tests, transmission activities described in a new section 216A(b) of the Federal Power Act and covered activities under Natural Gas Act section 7(i)(1). Actions another agency already evaluated under NEPA, and some Corps projects with a federal share of up to $50,000,000, also qualify. These actions fall outside the Act's review requirements. Sec. 1102

State or tribal review standing in for NEPA

An agency would not need an environmental document if the action was reviewed under a state or tribal environmental review law or policy and the lead agency finds the review serves a similar function. The same applies where another federal law serves a similar function. On a sponsor's request the lead agency must also consider, and as appropriate adopt, state or tribal analysis. The text does not say what notice or comment the earlier review must have had. Sec. 1105 · Sec. 1106

New science that arrives after a notice of intent

No federal agency would have to consider research that becomes public after the notice of intent or the decision to prepare an environmental document, and an agency could not delay past a deadline to wait for it. A savings clause leaves in place Administrative Procedure Act review of information in comments received during a comment period. Sec. 1106

Alternatives the public can ask an agency to study

The lead agency must eliminate any alternative, except no-action, that does not fulfill the purpose and need or meet the goals of an applicable non-federal sponsor. Cooperating agencies must consider only the alternatives the lead agency found reasonable. The statement of purpose and need would include the sponsor's goals. Sec. 1106 · Sec. 1102

Public tracker and portal for large reviews

CEQ would keep a public tracker with an entry for every project needing an EIS, and for any EA still open 13 months after its deadline. Entries show location, purpose and need, contacts for the sponsor and lead agency, schedule changes and litigation status. A common authorization portal, targeted for December 1, 2028, must include a way to tell local communities about notices of intent, public meetings and project status. Sec. 1132 · Sec. 1121

Record of the sponsor's outreach before applying

A sponsor would file, with its application, a record of stakeholder engagement of up to 20 pages. It lists pre-application contacts with state, local and tribal officials and community entities, the meeting dates, a brief summary of feedback and how feedback shaped the proposal. The bill requires the record, not any particular outreach. Sec. 1109 · Sec. 1102

Corridor work and routine drilling placed outside NEPA

Grid capacity work in or next to an existing right-of-way, and interstate gas pipeline repair, looping and compression in covered areas, would be outside NEPA and would not be a section 106 undertaking. Routine oil, gas and geothermal drilling activities on public and national forest land would not be a major Federal action and would carry no NEPA requirements. Clean Water Act and Clean Air Act duties remain for pipelines. Sec. 2102 · Sec. 2229

State, tribal and local governments as cooperating agencies

The designation test names jurisdiction by law over an environmental effect. It does not mention special expertise. The lead agency must identify and invite likely agencies within 30 days of the notice of intent or EA decision, and each has 7 days to accept or decline. A cooperating agency's comments are limited to matters within its jurisdiction by law, and designation gives it no authority over the action. Sec. 1106

Time to sue over a NEPA decision

A claim that an environmental review was not properly conducted under NEPA would be barred unless filed within 150 days after the authorization is published in the Federal Register (where an EIS was prepared) or made public (any other case), unless a shorter deadline applies. A supplemental document required by court order starts a new 150-day clock, and the claim is limited to information not in the earlier document. Sec. 1110

Who can bring a NEPA claim

Where an opportunity for comment was provided, the plaintiff must have submitted a substantive comment, detailed enough to put the agency on notice of the issue, during a public comment period. The plaintiff, or one of its members, must allege an actual or imminent injury in fact amounting to a direct harm. The section says it does not create a cause of action. Sec. 1110

Which court hears a NEPA claim

The court of appeals for the circuit where the project will be built or operated would have original and exclusive jurisdiction, with supplemental jurisdiction over related claims on the authorization's validity. Judges are to be randomly assigned to the maximum extent practicable. Courts must give substantial deference to the agency on the scope and contents of the document and must rule 'as expeditiously as possible', with no fixed deadline. Sec. 1110

Remedy when a court finds a NEPA violation

The only remedy would be a remand without vacatur or injunction, with instructions and a deadline of no more than 180 days. The authorization stays in effect and the project may proceed during the remand. A preliminary injunction is allowed only if the authorization is likely to violate a federal law other than NEPA and the National Historic Preservation Act, and the usual harm, equity and public interest tests are met. Sec. 1110

Claims over gaps in the sponsor's outreach record

There would be no claim or judicial review of whether a final agency action complies with NEPA for any omission from the list described in section 3(22)(B). In the bill's definitions that list is the sponsor's pre-application engagement with state, local and tribal officials and community entities. Sec. 1110 · Sec. 1102

Time to sue over energy and mineral permits under any federal law

A civil action under federal law seeking review of a final agency action granting or denying an authorization for an energy, carbon capture or mineral project would be barred unless filed within 150 days after the action is made public, which must happen within 3 days of the action. Courts must expedite, and a remand deadline is up to 180 days unless a longer time is needed to comply with law. Sec. 2201

Asking an agency to revoke or change an issued permit

For projects with non-federal sponsors, a federal agency could not take new action to revoke, suspend, amend or alter an authorization in effect on or after September 16, 2026, except in five cases. These include a court order, a material breach or violation of law, fraud, a need to prevent specific, urgent, substantial and proximate harm based on new information, or a request from the holder. The agency carries the burden by clear and convincing evidence. Sec. 1401

Where do supporters and critics disagree?

Can a later administration revoke a permit it says was issued unlawfully?

Bill section 1401: “the Federal agency is required to take such action by order of a court of competent jurisdiction”

Critics · Earthjustice (2026-10-26): “none cover a situation in which a future administration concludes that a prior administration violated federal law in issuing a given permit or authorization.”

Critics · The Wilderness Society (2026-10-15): “This section bans future administrations from taking any action on permitted projects on public lands, even when permits were approved unlawfully, except under extremely limited circumstances.”

Critics · Aaron Weiss (2026-10-22): “Challengers also get just 150 days to sue.”

Critics · Center for Western Priorities (2026-10-23): “Trump’s wind and solar cancellations would stand, while the data centers, drilling, and nuclear projects Interior Secretary Doug Burgum approves over the next two years would be nearly impossible for a future administration to undo.”

Supporters: no reading recorded for this question.

When can a developer sue over how agencies treat a project type?

Bill section 1402: “an empirically demonstrated statistical pattern that”

Critics · Rep. Jared Huffman (2026-09-30): “the provisions that seek to guarantee fair treatment for wind, solar, and battery storage are novel, untested, and don't really end the war on clean energy”

Critics · Oil Change International (2026-10-26): “This doesn’t just apply to projects permitted after the bill passes, but all projects with any kind of federal permit.”

Supporters · Jane Flegal (2026-10-21): “The old approval rate is *not a quota,* but can be used as evidence of targeting.”

Supporters · Senate ENR Committee (Chair Lee's office) (2026-10-03): “Section 1402 provides recourse if a future administration tries to use the same playbook”

Must data centers pay the embedded and incremental cost of transmission service?

Bill section 2107: “to require public utilities and transmitting utilities to charge eligible customers seeking transmission service on behalf of computational load owners and computational load operators the embedded cost and the incremental cost of transmission service”

Critics · Bisnow (2026-10-18): “Any upfront cost that you have to spend before you even know the answer if something is viable will wipe everyone out”

Supporters · Institute for Progress (2026-10-12): “Utilities may not shift a data center's "incremental cost" to other customers.”

Supporters · Bipartisan Policy Center (2026-10-02): “ensuring that data centers keep paying even if they leave early and must provide financial guarantees before utilities build to serve them”

Must an agency still consult Tribes?

Bill section 2301: “may consult with any applicable State Historic Preservation Officers, Tribal Historic Preservation Officers, Indian tribes”

Bill section 2301: “shall seek, discuss, as appropriate, and incorporate, as applicable, information from each applicable State Historic Preservation Officer, Tribal Historic Preservation Officer, Indian tribe”

Critics · NATHPO, NCAI, NARF, AAIA and Cultural Heritage Partners (2026-10-16): “BAAJA turns that mandate into a “may”: an agency “may consult” Tribes when it identifies historic properties.”

Critics · NCAI, NARF, NATHPO and six other Tribal organizations (2026-10-09): “Tribal Nations need not be consulted as federal agencies designate an area of potential effect, identify historic properties, and assess potential effects”

Critics · NATHPO (2026-10-20): “Agencies are already legally required to consult Tribes. BAAJA makes that optional.”

Critics · NRDC (2026-10-19): “The bill limits Tribal participation in decisions concerning federally connected projects and what Tribal interests are protected”

Supporters · Institute for Progress (2026-10-13): “NHPA’s Tribal consultation requirement, THPO authority, or other sources of duties to Tribes (treaties, the trust responsibility, NAGPRA, and the consultation executive orders) are unchanged in BAAJA.”

Supporters · Thomas Hochman (2026-10-19): “BAAJA keeps Sec. 101’s "shall consult" language *and* adds explicit Tribal consultation requirements to Section 106.”

Supporters · Searchlight Institute (2026-10-07): “It writes tribes' role in historic preservation reviews into law, guaranteeing them a seat from the start of consultation through every major decision.”

Which projects still get a 106 review?

Bill section 2301: “substantial Federal control and responsibility”

Critics · Preservation coalition (13 groups) (2026-10-20): “Projects funded by federal grants or loans would mostly fall outside the Section 106 process unless the funding is for historic preservation itself.”

Supporters · Institute for Progress (2026-10-12): “Section 2301 comprehensively reforms NHPA § 106, codifying much of ACHP's existing regulatory process to protect consultation rights while also streamlining review”

What counts as harm to a historic place?

Bill section 2301: “directly alters the characteristics of a historic property”

Critics · Preservation coalition (13 groups) (2026-10-20): “A new statutory definition of "adverse effect" would exclude most visual, atmospheric, and audible effects, temporary effects, and effects on parts of a property beyond its character-defining features.”

Supporters · Institute for Progress (2026-10-12): “This new definition raises the bar for demonstrating that an effect harms a historic property, requiring parties to identify how the effect directly alters a core element that made the property eligible for the Register.”

Which sacred places count?

Bill section 2301: “means an identifiable geographic location or feature at which an event of continuing religious or cultural significance to a living community occurred”

Critics · NATHPO, NCAI, NARF, AAIA and Cultural Heritage Partners (2026-10-16): “the definition’s own examples are a “district, site, building, structure, or object” and “artifacts or material remains,” not a mountain, spring, or river”

Supporters · Institute for Progress (2026-10-13): “would ensure natural features important to Tribes can be treated as historic properties under NHPA”

Supporters · Thomas Hochman (2026-10-19): “It also codifies definitions for Tribal sacred places”

What if a Tribe misses the 30 days?

Bill section 2301: “fails to respond within 30 days of receipt of a request for review of any report or finding by the applicable Federal official, the applicable Federal official shall proceed”

Critics · NCAI, NARF, NATHPO and six other Tribal organizations (2026-10-09): “forces a Tribal Nation to assert substantive objections to a federal agency’s Section 106 report within a mere 30 days of receipt”

Critics · NATHPO, NCAI, NARF, AAIA and Cultural Heritage Partners (2026-10-16): “BAAJA halves the time, with the same consequence.”

Critics · National Trust for Historic Preservation (2026-10-01): “Consultation could effectively end when a consulting party does not respond within prescribed deadlines”

Critics · National Conference of State Historic Preservation Officers (2026-10-02): “If a SHPO, THPO, Tribe, Native Hawaiian organization, or local government fails to respond to an agreement, the Federal official could enter into the agreement with ACHP instead.”

Critics · Preservation coalition (13 groups) (2026-10-20): “Consulting parties would generally have 30 days to provide information or object, after which the agency may proceed without them.”

Supporters: no reading recorded for this question.

Can Interior take over a THPO?

Bill section 2301: “the Secretary shall assume all or part of the functions of the Tribal Historic Preservation Officer”

Critics · NCAI, NARF, NATHPO and six other Tribal organizations (2026-10-09): “missed review deadlines will result in the loss of THPO status and funding, as well as the deeply paternalistic assumption of THPO functions by the Department of the Interior”

Critics · NATHPO, NCAI, NARF, AAIA and Cultural Heritage Partners (2026-10-16): “Far from protecting Tribes or leaving their preservation offices “unchanged,” BAAJA penalizes Tribes that miss its deadlines”

Critics · Preservation coalition (13 groups) (2026-10-20): “For the first time, the Secretary of the Interior could assume a THPO's functions and suspend its funding.”

Supporters · Institute for Progress (2026-10-08): “THPO programs already operate within a federal approval and oversight framework.”

Can an agency set aside harm to a sacred place?

Bill section 2301: “in the sole discretion of the Federal official and as otherwise allowed by law, other considerations outweigh”

Critics · NCAI, NARF, NATHPO and six other Tribal organizations (2026-10-09): “the bill would give federal agencies the authority to determine that “other considerations” outweigh adverse effects on our sacred places”

Critics · National Trust for Historic Preservation (2026-10-01): “the proposal would give federal agencies significant authority to end the Section 106 process based on their own unilateral determination that other considerations outweigh historic preservation”

Supporters · Aidan Mackenzie (2026-10-19): “NHPA 106 is an information gathering and consultation process. That's true now and BAAJA doesn't change it”

Can a court stop a project that skipped the review?

Bill section 2301: “the only remedy the court may order is to remand, without vacatur or issuance of an injunction”

Critics · NATHPO, NCAI, NARF, AAIA and Cultural Heritage Partners (2026-10-16): “Courts cannot stop a project that violates Section 106; the only remedy is to reinitiate the review while construction continues.”

Critics · NCAI, NARF, NATHPO and six other Tribal organizations (2026-10-09): “nearly eliminates any real remedies available to Tribal Nations by stipulating remand without vacatur as a baseline”

Critics · Preservation coalition (13 groups) (2026-10-20): “Claims would have to be filed within 150 days, courts would owe agencies substantial deference, and the usual remedy would be remand without vacatur or injunction.”

Supporters · Searchlight Institute (2026-10-07): “What changes is that a paperwork mistake in a procedural review can't kill a project on its own.”

Is the Tribal funding authorized or appropriated?

Bill section 2302: “There is authorized to be appropriated to the Secretary to carry out this subsection $20,000,000 for each of fiscal years 2027 through 2030”

Critics · NATHPO, NCAI, NARF, AAIA and Cultural Heritage Partners (2026-10-16): “Tribes get a promise, not funding: the $200 million is only “authorized,” and the Tribal grants are worth less per office than THPOs receive today.”

Supporters · Thomas Hochman (2026-10-19): “the new $20 million authorization is a new program – it adds to, not replaces, the existing THPO operating grants.”

Supporters · Searchlight Institute (2026-10-07): “it creates a $20 million-a-year grant program to help tribes document cultural and sacred sites without having to disclose where they are”

How does the bill compare with the administration's draft rule for Tribes?

No single passage: this is about what happens if the bill fails and the Advisory Council finishes its draft rule.

Critics · NATHPO, NCAI, NARF, AAIA and Cultural Heritage Partners (2026-10-16): “Trading a reversible bad rule for an irreversible bad statute is not protection.”

Supporters · Institute for Progress (2026-10-13): “Without BAAJA, Tribes face the narrowed ACHP rule now — ACHP has already voted in favor of it — then years of litigation and a new administration’s rulemaking process to attempt to reverse it.”

Can a Tribe still sue?

Bill section 2301: “the claim is filed by a party that has suffered or imminently will suffer direct harm from the agency action”

Bill section 2301: “has provided detailed notice in writing during the consultation process”

Critics · NCAI, NARF, NATHPO and six other Tribal organizations (2026-10-09): “This bill also institutes a 150-day statute of limitations, attempts to limit standing”

Supporters · Institute for Progress (2026-09-30): “Section 2301(c) exempts Tribes from the new standing requirements, ensuring that Tribes who raised a concern in writing during consultation can bring a lawsuit after the decision.”

What happens to the best-available-science rule?

Bill section 1301: “impartially gathered and objectively applied without presumptions or policy prescriptions that bias the application”

Critics · Center for Biological Diversity and 214 other groups (2026-10-06): “would significantly raise the evidentiary burden for protecting imperiled animals and plants by limiting the Services’ ability to account for uncertainty and reasonably foreseeable risks”

Supporters · Institute for Progress (2026-09-30): “Under the new language, the Services could no longer default to using the worst-case scenarios when making a jeopardy or critical habitat determination”

Can a state run consultations?

Bill section 1304: “the Secretary may assign, and the State may assume, the consultation responsibilities of the Secretary within the boundary of the State”

Bill section 1304: “authorize the State to take the actions necessary to carry out the responsibilities being assumed”

Critics · Center for Biological Diversity and 214 other groups (2026-10-06): “More than half of the states — including Texas, Utah, and Idaho — lack the statutory authority to protect the full range of plants and animals covered by the federal Endangered Species Act”

Critics · Earthjustice (2026-10-20): “the bill does not specify federal backstop authority to override state decisions that would jeopardize a species' survival”

Supporters · Institute for Progress (2026-09-30): “State authority would be limited to projects within the state, and applicants would have the option to opt out and request review from FWS instead.”

Where can a consultation be challenged?

Bill section 1305: “of any opinion issued by the Secretary under subsection (b) in the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit”

Bill section 1304: “The district courts of the United States shall have exclusive jurisdiction over any civil action against a State”

Critics · Center for Biological Diversity and 214 other groups (2026-10-06): “The legislation would direct every Section 7 challenge to the D.C. Circuit”

Critics · Earthjustice (2026-10-20): “By contrast, challenges to consultations by states would be brought in district court, creating a balkanized system for judicial review”

Supporters: no reading recorded for this question.

Senate votes

All three votes were on procedure. None was a vote on passing the bill.

Ending debate on the motion to proceed to H.R. 2347

· 73 yea, 25 nay, 2 not voting · needed three-fifths of all senators (60 votes) · Cloture on the Motion to Proceed Agreed to · Senate roll call 257

Republicans: 51 yea, 1 nay, 1 not voting; Democrats: 21 yea, 23 nay, 1 not voting; Independents: 1 yea, 1 nay, 0 not voting

Yea (73): Alan Armstrong (R-OK), Jim Banks (R-IN), John Barrasso (R-WY), Marsha Blackburn (R-TN), Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), John Boozman (R-AR), Katie Britt (R-AL), Ted Budd (R-NC), Shelley Capito (R-WV), Bill Cassidy (R-LA), Susan Collins (R-ME), Christopher Coons (D-DE), John Cornyn (R-TX), Tom Cotton (R-AR), Kevin Cramer (R-ND), Mike Crapo (R-ID), Ted Cruz (R-TX), John Curtis (R-UT), Steve Daines (R-MT), Joni Ernst (R-IA), John Fetterman (D-PA), Deb Fischer (R-NE), Ruben Gallego (D-AZ), Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY), Darline Graham (R-SC), Chuck Grassley (R-IA), Bill Hagerty (R-TN), Josh Hawley (R-MO), Martin Heinrich (D-NM), John Hickenlooper (D-CO), John Hoeven (R-ND), Jon Husted (R-OH), Cindy Hyde-Smith (R-MS), Ron Johnson (R-WI), James Justice (R-WV), John Kennedy (R-LA), Andy Kim (D-NJ), Angus King (I-ME), Amy Klobuchar (D-MN), James Lankford (R-OK), Mike Lee (R-UT), Cynthia Lummis (R-WY), Roger Marshall (R-KS), Catherine Cortez Masto (D-NV), Mitch McConnell (R-KY), David McCormick (R-PA), Ashley Moody (R-FL), Jerry Moran (R-KS), Bernie Moreno (R-OH), Lisa Murkowski (R-AK), Jon Ossoff (D-GA), Rand Paul (R-KY), Gary Peters (D-MI), John Reed (D-RI), Pete Ricketts (R-NE), James Risch (R-ID), Jacky Rosen (D-NV), Brian Schatz (D-HI), Eric Schmitt (R-MO), Charles Schumer (D-NY), Rick Scott (R-FL), Tim Scott (R-SC), Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH), Elissa Slotkin (D-MI), Dan Sullivan (R-AK), John Thune (R-SD), Thomas Tillis (R-NC), Tommy Tuberville (R-AL), Mark Warner (D-VA), Raphael Warnock (D-GA), Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI), Roger Wicker (R-MS), Todd Young (R-IN)

Nay (25): Angela Alsobrooks (D-MD), Tammy Baldwin (D-WI), Michael Bennet (D-CO), Cory Booker (D-NJ), Maria Cantwell (D-WA), Tammy Duckworth (D-IL), Richard Durbin (D-IL), Maggie Hassan (D-NH), Mazie Hirono (D-HI), Chris Van Hollen (D-MD), Timothy Kaine (D-VA), Mark Kelly (D-AZ), Ben Lujan (D-NM), Edward Markey (D-MA), Jeff Merkley (D-OR), Patty Murray (D-WA), Alex Padilla (D-CA), Lisa Blunt Rochester (D-DE), Mike Rounds (R-SD), Bernie Sanders (I-VT), Adam Schiff (D-CA), Tina Smith (D-MN), Elizabeth Warren (D-MA), Peter Welch (D-VT), Ron Wyden (D-OR)

Not Voting (2): Christopher Murphy (D-CT), Tim Sheehy (R-MT)

The motion to proceed to H.R. 2347

· 62 yea, 21 nay, 17 not voting · needed a majority of senators voting · Motion to Proceed Agreed to · Senate roll call 258

Republicans: 46 yea, 1 nay, 6 not voting; Democrats: 15 yea, 19 nay, 11 not voting; Independents: 1 yea, 1 nay, 0 not voting

Yea (62): Alan Armstrong (R-OK), Jim Banks (R-IN), John Barrasso (R-WY), Marsha Blackburn (R-TN), Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), John Boozman (R-AR), Katie Britt (R-AL), Ted Budd (R-NC), Shelley Capito (R-WV), Bill Cassidy (R-LA), Susan Collins (R-ME), Christopher Coons (D-DE), Tom Cotton (R-AR), Kevin Cramer (R-ND), Mike Crapo (R-ID), Ted Cruz (R-TX), John Curtis (R-UT), Steve Daines (R-MT), John Fetterman (D-PA), Deb Fischer (R-NE), Ruben Gallego (D-AZ), Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY), Darline Graham (R-SC), Chuck Grassley (R-IA), Bill Hagerty (R-TN), Martin Heinrich (D-NM), John Hoeven (R-ND), Jon Husted (R-OH), Cindy Hyde-Smith (R-MS), Ron Johnson (R-WI), John Kennedy (R-LA), Andy Kim (D-NJ), Angus King (I-ME), Amy Klobuchar (D-MN), James Lankford (R-OK), Mike Lee (R-UT), Cynthia Lummis (R-WY), Roger Marshall (R-KS), David McCormick (R-PA), Ashley Moody (R-FL), Jerry Moran (R-KS), Bernie Moreno (R-OH), Lisa Murkowski (R-AK), Jon Ossoff (D-GA), Rand Paul (R-KY), John Reed (D-RI), Pete Ricketts (R-NE), James Risch (R-ID), Brian Schatz (D-HI), Eric Schmitt (R-MO), Charles Schumer (D-NY), Rick Scott (R-FL), Tim Scott (R-SC), Tim Sheehy (R-MT), Elissa Slotkin (D-MI), Dan Sullivan (R-AK), John Thune (R-SD), Thomas Tillis (R-NC), Raphael Warnock (D-GA), Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI), Roger Wicker (R-MS), Todd Young (R-IN)

Nay (21): Angela Alsobrooks (D-MD), Tammy Baldwin (D-WI), Michael Bennet (D-CO), Cory Booker (D-NJ), Maria Cantwell (D-WA), Tammy Duckworth (D-IL), Richard Durbin (D-IL), Maggie Hassan (D-NH), Mazie Hirono (D-HI), Chris Van Hollen (D-MD), Timothy Kaine (D-VA), Ben Lujan (D-NM), Edward Markey (D-MA), Jeff Merkley (D-OR), Patty Murray (D-WA), Alex Padilla (D-CA), Lisa Blunt Rochester (D-DE), Mike Rounds (R-SD), Bernie Sanders (I-VT), Peter Welch (D-VT), Ron Wyden (D-OR)

Not Voting (17): John Cornyn (R-TX), Joni Ernst (R-IA), Josh Hawley (R-MO), John Hickenlooper (D-CO), James Justice (R-WV), Mark Kelly (D-AZ), Catherine Cortez Masto (D-NV), Mitch McConnell (R-KY), Christopher Murphy (D-CT), Gary Peters (D-MI), Jacky Rosen (D-NV), Adam Schiff (D-CA), Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH), Tina Smith (D-MN), Tommy Tuberville (R-AL), Mark Warner (D-VA), Elizabeth Warren (D-MA)

Ending debate on the substitute, SA 6883

· 70 yea, 27 nay, 3 not voting · needed three-fifths of all senators (60 votes) · Cloture Motion Agreed to · Senate roll call 264

Republicans: 49 yea, 2 nay, 2 not voting; Democrats: 20 yea, 24 nay, 1 not voting; Independents: 1 yea, 1 nay, 0 not voting

Yea (70): Alan Armstrong (R-OK), Jim Banks (R-IN), John Barrasso (R-WY), Marsha Blackburn (R-TN), Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), John Boozman (R-AR), Katie Britt (R-AL), Ted Budd (R-NC), Shelley Capito (R-WV), Bill Cassidy (R-LA), Susan Collins (R-ME), Christopher Coons (D-DE), John Cornyn (R-TX), Tom Cotton (R-AR), Kevin Cramer (R-ND), Mike Crapo (R-ID), Ted Cruz (R-TX), John Curtis (R-UT), Steve Daines (R-MT), Joni Ernst (R-IA), John Fetterman (D-PA), Deb Fischer (R-NE), Ruben Gallego (D-AZ), Kirsten Gillibrand (D-NY), Darline Graham (R-SC), Chuck Grassley (R-IA), Bill Hagerty (R-TN), Martin Heinrich (D-NM), John Hickenlooper (D-CO), John Hoeven (R-ND), Jon Husted (R-OH), Cindy Hyde-Smith (R-MS), Ron Johnson (R-WI), James Justice (R-WV), John Kennedy (R-LA), Andy Kim (D-NJ), Angus King (I-ME), Amy Klobuchar (D-MN), James Lankford (R-OK), Mike Lee (R-UT), Cynthia Lummis (R-WY), Roger Marshall (R-KS), Mitch McConnell (R-KY), David McCormick (R-PA), Jerry Moran (R-KS), Bernie Moreno (R-OH), Lisa Murkowski (R-AK), Jon Ossoff (D-GA), Rand Paul (R-KY), Gary Peters (D-MI), John Reed (D-RI), Pete Ricketts (R-NE), Jacky Rosen (D-NV), Brian Schatz (D-HI), Eric Schmitt (R-MO), Charles Schumer (D-NY), Rick Scott (R-FL), Tim Scott (R-SC), Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH), Tim Sheehy (R-MT), Elissa Slotkin (D-MI), Dan Sullivan (R-AK), John Thune (R-SD), Thomas Tillis (R-NC), Tommy Tuberville (R-AL), Mark Warner (D-VA), Raphael Warnock (D-GA), Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI), Roger Wicker (R-MS), Todd Young (R-IN)

Nay (27): Angela Alsobrooks (D-MD), Tammy Baldwin (D-WI), Michael Bennet (D-CO), Lisa Blunt Rochester (D-DE), Cory Booker (D-NJ), Maria Cantwell (D-WA), Catherine Cortez Masto (D-NV), Tammy Duckworth (D-IL), Richard Durbin (D-IL), Maggie Hassan (D-NH), Josh Hawley (R-MO), Mazie Hirono (D-HI), Timothy Kaine (D-VA), Mark Kelly (D-AZ), Ben Lujan (D-NM), Edward Markey (D-MA), Jeff Merkley (D-OR), Patty Murray (D-WA), Alex Padilla (D-CA), Mike Rounds (R-SD), Bernie Sanders (I-VT), Adam Schiff (D-CA), Tina Smith (D-MN), Chris Van Hollen (D-MD), Elizabeth Warren (D-MA), Peter Welch (D-VT), Ron Wyden (D-OR)

Not Voting (3): Ashley Moody (R-FL), Christopher Murphy (D-CT), James Risch (R-ID)

Published estimates

Each figure is the publisher's own, with its scenario and source sentence. Most model the September 30 text or part of it. The tracker has not checked the models.

No Congressional Budget Office estimate of the bill was found through November 15.

Emissions

Rhodium Group (research firm; no stated position on the bill), 2026-11-02: Rhodium projects economy-wide greenhouse gas emissions 5 to 148 million metric tons a year lower in 2040, and as much as 1.5 gigatons lower in total. Measured against: Compared with current policy without the bill. Covers: The transmission, gas pipeline and data center cost provisions of the September 30 text. “Taken together, these provisions uniformly reduce economywide greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 5-148 million metric tons annually in 2040 and as much as 1.5 gigatons cumulatively, compared to without BAAJA.” Source · Method

Center for Climate and Energy Solutions, with Greenline Insights (research group; supports the bill), 2026-11-06: C2ES reports annual power-sector carbon dioxide 173 million metric tons lower in 2035, a 13 percent cut. Measured against: Compared with business as usual, in modeling by Greenline Insights. Covers: The interconnection and transmission planning provisions. The release does not say which text was modeled. “And in 2035 alone, reform would: ... Reduce annual power sector carbon dioxide emissions by 173 million metric tons, a 13 percent reduction relative to business as usual.” Source · Method

Center for Climate and Energy Solutions, with Greenline Insights (research group; supports the bill), 2026-11-06: C2ES reports that putting the changes off until 2030 would give up about 800 million metric tons of emissions cuts and about $55 billion in electricity system savings through 2040. Measured against: The same modeled changes, starting in 2030. Covers: The interconnection and transmission planning provisions. The release does not say which text was modeled. “a delay until 2030 would mean achieving only about 40 percent of the modeled benefits by 2035 ... Through 2040, this delay would forgo roughly $55 billion in electricity system savings and 800 million metric tons of emissions reductions.” Source · Method

Resources for the Future (research institute; no stated position on the bill), 2026-10-29: RFF projects power-sector carbon dioxide about 200 million tonnes lower in the near term and about 1.8 gigatonnes lower in total through 2041. Measured against: Compared with a baseline without the bill, in the ReEDS power-sector model. Covers: The power-sector provisions of the September 30 text. “We project near-term emissions reductions from the power sector of roughly 200 million tonnes (Mt) of carbon dioxide, with cumulative carbon dioxide emissions from the power sector declining by about 1.8 gigatonnes (Gt) through 2041 as compared to the baseline.” Source

Solar Energy Industries Association (trade association; supports the bill), 2026-11-09: SEIA says its analysis finds cumulative power-sector carbon dioxide about 20 percent lower and $54 billion in public health damages avoided. Measured against: SEIA's own analysis, announced in its November 9 statement. The statement gives no baseline in this sentence. Covers: The bill as SEIA modeled it. The statement does not say which text. “The analysis finds that the bill’s reforms could reduce cumulative power sector CO2 emissions by approximately 20% and avoid $54 billion in public health damages.” Source · Method

American Clean Power Association (trade association; supports the bill), 2026-10-09: ACP says the bill would avoid 290 million metric tons of carbon dioxide a year. Measured against: The page states no scenario, baseline or year. It points to an ACP fact sheet. Covers: The September 30 text; the page predates the substitute. “290 million metric tons of avoided CO₂ emissions annually — equivalent to the emissions of 63 million cars.” Source

Electricity costs

Rhodium Group (research firm; no stated position on the bill), 2026-11-02: Rhodium projects household electricity bills $50 to $78 a year lower in 2040. Measured against: Compared with current policy without the bill. Covers: The transmission, gas pipeline and data center cost provisions of the September 30 text. “We project that the combined impact of these provisions would reduce household electricity bills by $50-78 per year in 2040 compared to without BAAJA” Source · Method

Resources for the Future (research institute; no stated position on the bill), 2026-10-29: RFF projects savings of more than $350 billion through 2050 in net present value, with lower national electricity prices. Measured against: Compared with a baseline without the bill, in the ReEDS power-sector model. Covers: The power-sector provisions of the September 30 text. “BAAJA is projected to save more than $350 billion through 2050 in net-present-value terms, decreasing national electricity prices.” Source

Resources for the Future (research institute; no stated position on the bill), 2026-10-29: RFF projects the average yearly cost of the electricity system 3.5 to 7.0 percent lower over the modeled period. Measured against: Compared with a baseline without the bill, in the ReEDS power-sector model. Covers: The power-sector provisions of the September 30 text. “Reduce the costs of providing electricity, decreasing the average annual costs of the electricity system by 3.5–7.0 percent over the modeled period.” Source

Generation and transmission built

Rhodium Group (research firm; no stated position on the bill), 2026-11-02: Rhodium projects 17 to 249 gigawatts more clean generation built through 2040, and interregional transmission built at nearly three times the pace of the past decade. Measured against: Compared with current policy without the bill. Covers: The transmission provisions of the September 30 text. “The transmission provisions of the bill enable accelerated average interregional transmission build rates nearly triple that of the last decade or more and drive an additional 17-249 GW of clean resources to be built through 2040.” Source · Method

Center for Climate and Energy Solutions, with Greenline Insights (research group; supports the bill), 2026-11-06: C2ES reports 170 gigawatts more wind, solar and battery storage capacity by 2035. Measured against: Compared with business as usual, in modeling by Greenline Insights. Covers: The interconnection and transmission planning provisions. The release does not say which text was modeled. “by 2035 the modeled reforms would enable 170 GW of additional wind, solar, and battery storage capacity” Source · Method

Resources for the Future (research institute; no stated position on the bill), 2026-10-29: RFF projects total transmission capacity 30 percent higher by 2041, with interregional capacity more than doubling. Measured against: Compared with a baseline without the bill, in the ReEDS power-sector model. Covers: The power-sector provisions of the September 30 text. “By 2041, we project overall transmission capacity to increase by 30 percent over the baseline; interregional transmission capacity more than doubles.” Source

Solar Energy Industries Association (trade association; supports the bill), 2026-11-09: SEIA says its analysis shows 167 gigawatts more solar capacity between 2028 and 2035, bringing solar to over 18 percent of U.S. generation by 2035. Measured against: SEIA's own analysis, announced in its November 9 statement. The statement gives no baseline in this sentence. Covers: The bill as SEIA modeled it. The statement does not say which text. “shows that BAAJA could unlock 167 gigawatts of additional solar capacity between 2028 and 2035, bringing solar to over 18% of U.S. electricity generation by 2035.” Source · Method

American Clean Power Association (trade association; supports the bill), 2026-10-09: ACP says the bill can bring more than 350 gigawatts of new clean energy and over $800 billion in new transmission and clean power infrastructure. Measured against: The page states no scenario, baseline or year. It points to an ACP fact sheet. Covers: The September 30 text; the page predates the substitute. “By creating a more predictable path to build, BAAJA can unleash: Over $800 billion in new transmission and clean power infrastructure; 350+ GW of new clean energy;” Source

LNG exports

Rhodium Group (research firm; no stated position on the bill), 2026-11-02: Rhodium projects LNG exports 8 to 15 percent higher with the bill, on top of a 76 to 145 percent rise it expects under current policy. Measured against: Compared with current policy without the bill. The sentence gives no year. Covers: The bill as a whole, as Rhodium modeled the September 30 text. “The bill as a whole increases liquefied natural gas (LNG) export levels by 8-15% beyond a 76-145% increase already happening under current policy.” Source · Method

Public Citizen (advocacy group; opposes the bill), 2026-11-08: Public Citizen says Title IV would keep the Energy Department from changing export approvals that cover 39 billion cubic feet a day of capacity already authorized. Measured against: A count of existing approvals under current law. It is not a model result. Covers: Title IV. The page does not say which text. “Title IV of BAAJA directly impedes this Natural Gas Act authority, and will lock in this already-authorized 39 bcf/d of LNG export capacity.” Source

Economic output

White House Council of Economic Advisers (White House office; supports the bill), 2026-10-28: The Council of Economic Advisers estimates long-run GDP 0.28 to 0.56 percent higher, or $82 billion to $164 billion more output a year, if federal reviews are shortened to the deadlines the bill sets. Measured against: Compared with current federal review times. Covers: The review deadlines. The page does not say which text. “We find that reducing review times down to the levels required by the BAAJA would: Increase long-run GDP by between 0.28 percent and 0.56 percent (i.e., $82 billion to $164 billion in additional output each year).” Source

Review time

Columbia Center on Global Energy Policy (university research center; no stated position on the bill), 2026-10-21: Columbia's tool replays past projects under the bill's deadlines. Its composite transmission project reaches the federal decision 64 months sooner. Measured against: Compared with the dates those projects recorded under current law. The count stops at the federal decision and leaves out state siting and the FERC backstop permit. Covers: The deadlines in the September 30 text. “which account for most of the projected time savings for the transmission archetype. Up to the federal decision, that archetype saves 64 months.” Source · Method